Project Manager Workbench and Cost Forecasting Solutions in SAP ERP
Business Challenges You have implemented SAP Project System, Or You are planning to implement SAP Project System… However, you ...
• • • • •
Struggle creating project plan or initial cost estimate Cannot manage monthly forecasts Cannot manage project variations in seamless integration with budgeting, revenue and cost forecasts Cannot find one single place where project manager can monitor, update and report on their projects. Cannot produce comprehensive reports out of SAP standard Project System
Business Challenges As a result …
• •
High use of excel spread sheets Use of third-party planning tools integrated with PS
• • • • •
Project System becomes a cost collector No information transparency and consistency Lack of standardization of project delivery Poor project governance Undermined Benefits of integrated system
Business Challenges • PS (Project System) is one of
Human Resources (HR) Time Sheets (CATS) Sales and customer billing (SD)
Accounting (FI) and Controlling (CO)
SAP PS + Noveco ePM Plant Maintenance, Customer Service (PM/CS)
Materials Management and Procurement (MM)
Production Planning (PP)
the most integrated modules in SAP ERP
• Noveco ePM enhances SAP Capacity and Resource Planning
Project System enabling integrated project management directly in SAP ECC
• You will not need any other
tools like excel, BI, BO etc. to manage your project lifecycle in SAP.
Why Noveco ePM Noveco ePM is a family of seamlessly integrated software components designed to complement and enhance SAP's standard Project System (PS) functionality, with a focus on easy project planning, forecasting, variation management and reporting directly in SAP ECC Noveco ePM enables management of your project lifecycle directly inside your ERP system (no other tools needed) Execution
l Estimating l Planning l Budgeting
Efficient Project Management
.
.
Forecasting
.
.
Monitoring
l Reporting l Analysis l Settlement
Project Management Lifecycle Run by Noveco Run by SAP or other software
Project Initiation
• Estimating: Costs and Revenues (under development ) • Project Structure & Planning • Budget Approval • Start/Finish Dates Scheduling • Plan Cost Distribution
Efficient Project Management
• Purchase Orders / Contracts • Time Sheets • Invoicing & Billing • Variations Execution
• Final Settlement • Project Close
Monitoring & Forecasting
Project Close Out
• Settlement • Result Analysis/Profit Take • Period Close
Period Closing
• KPIs Review • Cost / Margin Forecast • Resource Planning • Progress Analysis • Materials and Procurement forecast
Reporting
• Operational • Dash Board • Programs/Portfolio • Analytical
Integrated Project Management in SAP * Project Reporting
Profit Take (Result Analysis)
* Noveco Applications Dashboard reporting
Portfolio Planning
Reporting and Analysis
Monitoring Forecasting Progress Tracking
* Project Manager Workbench
Planning and Execution Project Builder
Cost & Revenue Planning
Project Dates Scheduling
Procurement, Time Sheets Invoicing, Billing
* Project Variation Management
Project Manager Workbench: Integrated Financial Information
Noveco Project Manager Workbench provides simple and clear environment to review (and manage) your project KPIs directly in your SAP ERP system
Project Manager Workbench: Integrated Financial Information Automa)cally Recalculate Es)mate Cost at Comple)on, Costs to Complete and Project Progress
Workbench provides new user experience in PS: • Combines several transactions in one screen • •
User friendly UI and Intuitive navigation Display, Change, Refresh and drill down into details
•
Automatic recalculation of Cost To Complete
• •
Review and update project progress Instant and Real-time integration with ERP (no interfaces, no extractors…)
If required, manually change Cost (and Work) to complete, Actual Progress Manually Distribute Cost To Complete and Commitments Automa)cally record changes in a change log
Automa)cally record forecast history
Save Changes directly in ERP
Noveco ePM Project Management Workbench Project Management Workbench key functions: • Management of Project Cost To Complete (automatic recalculation and manual adjustment)
– Cost To Complete is project remaining costs spread over project remaining duration – Estimated Cost At Completion ( or Final Forecast Cost ) is calculated as Actual Cost + Commitments + Cost To Complete
– Cost To Complete is always distributed in the future
• Variations and Issues management in seamless integration with Budgeting and Forecasting • Built-in Easy Project Progress and Earned Value Analysis
• One central place to review and manage your project with drill down reports • Graphs to represent project KPIs • Project forecast history tracking (automatic function)
Project Manager Workbench Overview Interface and Navigation Functionality Reports Integration
Project Manager Workbench: Integrated Financial Information
Aggregated view of Key Performance Indicators for entire project or selected project element
Project Manager Workbench: Integrated Financial Information Es)mated Cost at Comple)on = Actual Costs + Commitments + Cost To Complete
Current Budget including Varia)ons
Cost To Complete
Original Cost Es)mate
Budget Deficit = Current Budget – Es)mated at Comple)on If “+” it is under the budget If “-‐” it is over the budget
Project Manager Workbench: Integrated Financial Information
Current Revenue Plan including Rev. Varia)ons
Original Profit Margin. %
Original Revenue Plan
Forecast Profit Margin. %
Project Manager Workbench: List view
Detailed cost breakdown
You can review and change Forecast Costs in a list view without having to navigate to project element in the tree
Project Manager Workbench
Aggregate all values by Cost Element, Resource and Value category to the selected WBS or entire project
Project Manager Workbench
Detailed cost breakdown
Financial information is grouped by:
Value Category
Resource Type
Cost Element
Cost Element Grouping – Presented by Workbench Value Categories
Resource Type
Cost Elements
Engineering & Design Designer Structural Designer System Designer
Engineer Civil Engineer
Labour
Structural Engineer
Fitter Constr. Labour Materials
Value Categories in SAP are assigned to Cost Elements or Cost Element groups. Noveco ePM introduced “Resource” that allows you to split Value Category into smaller sub-groups For example, Value Category “LABOUR” can be broken down into resources: - Construction Labour - Electricians - Fitters - Testers - etc. Each Resource can be assigned to multiple cost elements.
Project Manager Workbench
Financial information is grouped by:
Value Category
Resource Type
You can turn off Cost Elements in Noveco configuration. All financial information is grouped by Value Categories and Resource Names
Project Manager Workbench: Exception indicators
Exception icons indicate where Estimated Cost at Completion (EAC) is over or under Current Budget
Project Manager Workbench: Plan by Period
Plan by Period (view and change): • Current Budget • Cost To Complete • Actuals • Commitments • Revenue
Project Manager Workbench: Detailed line items by period
Period breakdown view as line items
Display by Value Category by Period
Cost breakdown view by Value Category and Resource by Period
View all key figures by period:
Display by Value Category by Period
Cost breakdown view by Value Category and Resource by Period
View Cost To Complete by Value Category by period:
Display Cumulative Values
Display cumulative values and s-curves of KPI for entire project or selected project element
Display cumulative values and S-curves of the KPI for selected project element In this example, the top WBS is selected, so aggregated information from all sub-elements is presented
Project Manager Workbench: Cost Element View
View open purchasing commitments for selected project element and its subelements. You can drill down to purchase order details by double-clicking on the order line item
Project Variations
Display Project variations
Project Manager Workbench Overview Interface and Navigation Functionality Supported Project Structures Period Specific Forecasting Cost To Complete management Progress Analysis Variation Management Forecast History Reports Integration
Option 1: WBS for Cost Planning, Execution and Forecasting Construction project
Engineering & Design Drafting Structural Engineering
Construction Construction worker Materials Sub-contracted services
• WBS Hierarchy only (w/o Network Activities) • WBS used for cost planning, budgeting, cost forecasting • Actual costs, time confirmation and Purchasing Commitments posted to WBS elements • Cost To Complete are calculated and manually updated on WBS elements - WBS element - Costing line item
Option 2: WBS as Planning Element for Cost Planning and Forecasting Construction project Drafting Structural Engineering Construction worker Materials Sub-contracted services
Engineering
Construction
• WBS marked as Planning element used for cost planning, budgeting, cost forecasting. • Actual costs, time confirmation and Purchasing Commitments posted to sub-WBS • You can also post actual costs to NWA, PM/CS orders as well if they are part of the structure (see options 3, 5 and 6 ) • Actuals and commitments are rolled up to Planning WBS element. Cost To Complete are calculated on Planning WBS • Using this structure you can plan and execute work packages w/o need to plan each sub-package
- WBS element - Costing line item
Option 3: WBS for Cost Planning and Forecasting; NWA for Execution Construction project
Engineering & Design Drafting Structural Engineering
Design Drafting Engineering
• WBS and Network structure • WBS used for cost planning, budgeting, cost forecasting • Network Activities used for scheduling, resource planning, collecting actual costs, procurement • Actuals and commitments are rolled up to Planning WBS element. Cost To Complete are calculated on Planning WBS
- WBS element - Network activity - Costing line item
Option 4: NWA for Planning, Execution and Forecasting Construction project
Engineering & Design
Drafting
Engineering
Construction Earth moving Construction
• WBS and Network structure • Network Activities used for cost planning, budgeting, cost forecasting • Network Activities used for scheduling, resource planning, collecting actual costs, procurement, time confirmation • Cost To Complete are calculated and manually updated on Network Activities
- WBS element - Network activity - Costing line item
Option 5: NWA for Cost Planning and Forecasting, Orders for Execution Construction project
Engineering & Design
Drafting
Engineering
Construction Earth moving Construction
• WBS, Network and PM/CS Order structure • Network Activities used for scheduling, cost planning, budgeting, cost forecasting • Network Activities and PM/CS orders resource planning, collecting actual costs, procurement, time confirmation • Cost To Complete are calculated and manually updated on Network Activities
- WBS element - Network activity - Work Order - Costing line item
Option 6: WBS for Cost Planning and Forecasting, Orders for Execution Maintenance Project
Pump Maintenance Engineering
Electrical
Engineering
Electrical works
Mechanical works
• WBS and PM/CS Order structure • WBS used for cost planning, budgeting, cost forecasting • PM/CS orders resource planning, collecting actual costs, procurement, time confirmation • Cost To Complete are calculated and manually updated on WBS
- WBS element - Work Order - Costing line item
Project Manager Workbench Overview Interface and Navigation Functionality Supported Project Structures Period Specific Forecasting Cost To Complete management Progress Analysis Variation Management Forecast History Reports Integration
Period Sensitive Cost Forecasts
Planning Period: • Project planning period enables periodic cost forecasting, where automatic changes to cost to complete can be protected from actual cost life to date, thus keeping forecast costs fixed for specific planning period. • This allows project managers to complete their forecasts for a specified month end while being in the first week of a next month, with no impact to project cost to complete from actual costs and purchasing commitments made in the new (next) month • Once cost to complete are manually adjusted project can be rolled over to the next month, so project forecasts can be recalculated taking latest values
Periodic (Monthly) Cost Forecasting • Actual CostME – actual costs at Month End December 2013 • Actual Cost TD – actual costs life To Date Cost Forecasts are usually prepared in a first week of a new month. However Actual Costs and Purchasing Commitments might change within first few days of a new month
$, Actual Cost
Noveco Workbench cumulates Actual Costs and Commitments from project start date to the current month end planning period (e.g. December 2013) and recalculates Cost To Complete
Costs to Complete = EAC – Actual Costs ME – Commitments ME
Actual Cost TD Actual Cost ME
This way you can “freeze” forecast from actual costs posted in the new period
December
Today
January
Time
Period Roll Over $, Actual Cost
December
T
January
Today
Forecast History – can’t change
January
CTC
Commit
Actual TD
CTC
Today
• Actual Cost TD – actual costs life To Date Once forecast is completed and all reports are produced you can roll project over to the next month Latest Actual costs and Purchasing commitments will be taken into recalculation of project CTC
EAC
December
Commit
Actual ME
EAC
$, Actual Cost
Actual TD
CTC
Commit
Actual ME
EAC
• Actual CostME – actual costs at Month End December 2013
T
Project Manager Workbench Overview Interface and Navigation Functionality Supported Project Structures Period Specific Forecasting Cost To Complete management Progress Analysis Variation Management Forecast History Reports Integration
EAC
CTC
Initial step: Copy Estimates to Project Cost To Complete This step is done once only
Estimate
Project Forecasting: Cost To Complete Lifecycle Initially Cost To Complete are generated from Estimates Since at the beginning Actual Cost and Commitments equal 0, EAC = CTC according to the formula:
Copy Estimate to Cost To Complete
EAC CTC
On-going: Automatically reduce Cost To Complete from Actual Costs and Purchasing Commitments
Estimate
EAC = CTC + Actuals + Commitments
As Project progresses Actual Costs and Purchase Commitment increase CTC is automatically reduced by the Workbench, using formula:
On-going: Manually Change CTC, recalculate EAC and save new EAC for monthly snapshot for history reporting
EAC CTC
Estimate
CTC = EAC – ( Actuals + Commitments)
User can manually change CTC after it was recalculated by the Workbench EAC is automatically recalculated using formula:
EAC = CTC + Actuals + Commitments
Cost To Complete Management: Initial Step Initial step: Copy Estimates to Project Cost To Complete This step is done once only
On-going: Automatically reduce Cost To Complete from Actual Costs and Purchasing Commitments
On-going: Manually Change CTC, recalculate EAC and save new EAC for monthly snapshot for history reporting
In this example, Estimates were copied to Cost To Complete No Actual costs or Purchasing Commitments were posted Note: Current Budget is calculated as Estimate + Variations
Cost To Complete Management: Auto-recalculation of CTC Initial step: Copy Estimates to Project Cost To Complete This step is done once only
On-going: Automatically reduce Cost To Complete from Actual Costs and Purchasing Commitments
On-going: Manually Change CTC, recalculate EAC and save new EAC for monthly snapshot for history reporting
In this example, Actual Costs and Purchasing Commitment were posted Project Manager Workbench re-calculated Cost To Complete automatically using formula CTC = EAC – ( Actual Costs + Commitments) On large projects automatic reduction of Cost To Complete saves Project Manager’s time!!
Cost To Complete Management: Manual adjustment of CTC Initial step: Copy Estimates to Project Cost To Complete This step is done once only
On-going: Automatically reduce Cost To Complete from Actual Costs and Purchasing Commitments
On-going: Manually Change CTC, recalculate EAC and save new EAC for monthly snapshot for history reporting
When small variations occur you need to manually adjust Cost and Work To Complete In this example, we increased Work To Complete for Construction Labour and the value of Concrete Mix required. This change pushed Cost To Complete up. All manual changes are recorded in a change log Project Manager Workbench re-calculated Estimated at Completion using formula EAC = CTC + Actual Costs + Commitments
Cost Planning: Actual Costs and Forecasts
Costs To Complete are always distributed forward from today’s date into the future CTC values cannot be saved in the past periods This makes Cost To Complete management different from Cost Planning
Past
$
Today Date
Actual Costs Feb-12
Mar-12
Apr-12
May-12
Mar-12
Apr-12
May-12
T
Apr-12
May-12
T
Future
$
Cost To Complete Feb-12
Mar-12
Apr-12
May-12
Mar-12
Cost To Complete: manual distribution Manually Distribute - Cost to Complete - Current Budget - PO Commitments You can choose Value Category or Resource Type or even individual Cost Element. This way you can distribute different type of costs using different patterns
Graphs and values in the table are updated immediately as you type
Cost To Complete: Manual Distribution In this example we distribute Labour Budget and Cost To Complete different to other cost You can type percentage (%) or Values ($) to distribute
Purchasing Commitments: Manual Distribution You can distribute Purchasing commitments according to material or service delivery schedule
Display Cumulative Values as S-Curve Report
Display cumulative values as s-curves for selected Network Activity , WBS or entire project
Project Manager Workbench Overview Interface and Navigation Functionality Supported Project Structures Period Specific Forecasting Cost To Complete management Progress Analysis Variation Management Forecast History Reports Integration
Progress Analysis You can track Plan POC, Calculated POC and adjust Actual POC. Earned Values are calculated automatically.
Plan POC calculated by the system from distributed plan values Actual POC initially copied from calculated POC and changed manually Calculated POC calculated by the system from actual values
Project Manager Workbench Overview Interface and Navigation Functionality Supported Project Structures Period Specific Forecasting Cost To Complete management Progress Analysis Variation Management Forecast History Reports Integration
Project Variations
You can see project variation history
See List of all Variations and drill down to variation document
Project Variations You can create different types of Variations: Budget Variations, Adjustments and Contingency Variations Variation can have Revenue and Costing items and can be assigned to several project elements (WBS or network activities) Upon approval it automatically update budget, revenue and forecasts
Project Manager Workbench Overview Interface and Navigation Functionality Supported Project Structures Period Specific Forecasting Cost To Complete management Progress Analysis Variation Management Forecast History Reports Integration
Project Financials Monthly Snapshot Forecast history tracking is fully automatic it does not require version copy
Noveco: Project Forecast History Tracking
Project Forecast History is recorded for each financial period This is done automatically and does not require additional steps (e.g. copy into a special version to keep snapshot for forecast history reports) In this example, both Project Budget and Estimated Cost Completion changed in August 2013. You can view the change and see what project elements (WBS or Network Activities) have changed and why
Project Manager Workbench Overview Interface and Navigation Functionality Reports Integration
Project Report: Example
SAP Project Hierarchy reports can be tailored to view project financial information produced by Noveco ePM. In this example, you can compare current Estimated Cost At Completion (EAC) vs. EAC from any other months in a past. Noveco ePM delivers comprehensive reports (see next slide)…
Project Manager Workbench: Problem Focused Navigation
You can run context dependent reports by selecting project element from the tree and clicking these buttons
Project Manager Portal Inside SAP ERP Noveco ePM Portal presents all projects assigned to a project manager –
Personalized project selection is created, saved and “remembered” by the system
Projects exceptions and Key Performance Indicators are displayed against each project Graphical representation of project KPIs – –
For all project portfolio Selected project(s), WBS or network activity
Drill down to key business transactions: – Project Builder, Project Manager Workbench, reports, line items
Did you know? :
• •
That you don’t need BW/BI system to run comprehensive reports like this one above? PS info-system has been designed to hold all related project information. BW cubes simply mirror PS info-system inside BI
Project Manager Portal Inside ECC Displays cumulative values of: - Budget, Estimated costs
at Completion (EAC), Cost To Complete (CTC), Revenues, Actual costs, Commitments
Values are presented By entire portfolio (group of projects) or by selected project or WBS
Project Manager Portal Inside ECC Displays historical trends from the beginning of the portfolio (or project)
–
Budget, Estimated costs at Completion (EAC), Cost To Complete (CTC), Revenues, Profit Margin
You can see how your portfolio or a project evolved over time Values are presented by entire portfolio (group of projects) or by selected project or WBS
Project Manager Portal Inside ECC Review your Budget, Cost To Complete and Estimated Cost at Completion by Value Categories by Period
Project Manager Workbench Overview Interface and Navigation Functionality Reports Integration
Noveco System Architecture
¤
No middleware (BI, BO etc.)
¤
No interfaces
¤
No custom tables
¤
Always real-time
¤
Rich functionality
¤
Automatic forecasting
¤
Simple and intuitive interface
¤
Minimum training
¤
Quick implementation
Integrated Project Management in SAP * Project Reporting
Profit Take (Result Analysis)
* Noveco Applications Dashboard reporting
Portfolio Planning
Reporting and Analysis
Monitoring Forecasting Progress Tracking
* Project Manager Workbench
Planning and Execution Project Builder
Cost & Revenue Planning
Project Dates Scheduling
Procurement, Time Sheets Invoicing, Billing
* Project Variation Management
Result Analysis
Monitoring, Forecasting, Variations, Progress
Execution
Company Strategy Planning
Program Portfolio Planning
Analysis, Resourcing Reports
Strategic Planning
System Landscape including Noveco
Noveco
Estimation Budget values
Time Sheets, Invoices Actual Costs
Resource Planning
PS Information System
Sales Orders Revenue
Transactional System
● ● ● ● ● ● ●
Business Intelligence
Project Manager Workbench Automatic Forecasting Manual adjustment of CTC or Work TC Progress Analysis Exception and drill down reporting Integrated variations into cost forecast Forecast history
Purchase Orders, Commitments
Variations
ePM Project Cost Forecasting, Progress and Variation Management ●
Project Manager Workbench provides one central place to review KPIs, update forecasts, track and update progress, execute analytical and drill down reports
●
Complete Cost and Work To Complete management: Automatic reduction and Manual adjustment
●
Instant Integration with ECC transactions: PO, time sheets, invoices etc.
●
Forecasting results are immediately available for Result Analysis, Progress Analysis, PS Reports and BI (no custom interfaces needed to native SAP reports)
●
Period Sensitive Forecasts: designed for month end forecasts in live transactional system
●
Saves project forecast history w/o need to perform version copy by the user
●
Project Costs Forecasts integrated with PM/CS and PP orders
●
Integrates Project Variations into cost forecasting and budgeting
●
No modifications to SAP standard core applications. No “z-tables” to keep forecasts costs, all data read/written from/to SAP standard database.
Business Value of Integrated Project Forecasting in SAP ●
Connects upstream (estimating, procurement, timesheets) and downstream (monitoring, resource allocation, analytical reports) activities of project management lifecycle
●
Closes the loop between execution and analysis processes providing 360 degree flow of information
●
Replaces spreadsheets and other third party tools with centralized SAP database
●
Reduces amount of effort required to produce project forecasts and analytical reports
●
Reduces number of interdependent systems and interfaces needed; reduce costs of maintenance and support of systems other then SAP
●
Decreases potential for errors of data entry and manipulation
●
Improves quality, transparency and accuracy of data
●
Allows potential savings and process efficiency by relieving Project Managers from performing routine transactional and administrative activities.
●
Integrates Resource (personnel) Planning into project planning and forecasting
●
Determine realistic project progress
●
Unleashes the true power of integrated SAP system
Integrated Project Management
MM HR PM
PS
SD
FI
Costs Forecasting
Progress Analysis
CO
Integrated Project Management in SAP
Variation Management
Project Manager Workbench
SAP Customers running Noveco ePM Rawson Group – rawsonhomes.net.au – Industry: Residential construction Powercor/CityPower – powercor.com.au – Industry: Utility, Construction Sedgman – sedgman.com – Industry: Mining Construction TRILITY – trility.com.au – Industry: Utility, Construction Hydro Tasmania – www.hydro.com.au – Industry: Utility, Construction
For more information visit Noveco Systems on www.novecosystems.com