Ministry of Agriculture and Land Reclamation, Ministry of State for Environmental Affairs

Ministry of Agriculture and Land Reclamation, Ministry of State for Environmental Affairs Dear decision makers, We, the undersigned, are hereby procla...
Author: Melissa Brown
264 downloads 0 Views 1MB Size
Ministry of Agriculture and Land Reclamation, Ministry of State for Environmental Affairs Dear decision makers, We, the undersigned, are hereby proclaiming our disapproval of keeping dolphins in captivity within the borders of Egypt.  The existence of dolphinaria is detrimental to the welfare of dolphins and causes harm and death to them through capture, transportation, and confinement in captivity. This is true for both wild-captured and captive-born animals. Our request is based on scientific and factual evidence that keeping dolphins in captivity only benefits humans who profit from them, but has no conservation, educational or scientific value whatsoever. Governments need to be firmer in their response to these important threats to these animals and prevent dolphinaria from establishing, while also helping to educate the public, many of whom flock to dolphinaria to watch the dolphins cavorting, blissfully unaware of the suffering and death toll that such shows entail. We hereby respectfully petition you to: - PREVENT the opening of a new dolphinarium in Makadi Bay (south of Hurghada) which is supposed to open its gates soon. - DO NOT grant any further permits for the establishment of dolphinaria in the Red Sea Governorate - PASS required legislation to prohibit commercial captive display of dolphins and other marine mammals in Egypt, as another Party to ACCOBAMS, Croatia, has done. We will lobby vigorously, for the passing of new laws to make Egypt and especially the Red Sea Governorate free from this heartbreaking, inhumane business. Name

From

Comments

1.

Urte Fiek

Bordesholm, Germany

2.

Amina Cesario

Milano, Italy

3.

Grandin Corinne

Hurghada, Egypt

4.

Meltem Weiland

vienna, Austria

5.

Maha Khalil

Cairo, Egypt

6.

Georgina Cole

El Gouna, Egypt

7.

Dana Kaiser

Ontario, CA

8.

Bishoy Kamel

Cairo, Egypt

Dolphinariums are prisons for innocent creatures. They should not exist. This is absolutely UNACCEPTABLE! They have to be taken out of that water before they die or have permanent damage. :( Page 1

-

Signatures 1 - 8

Name

From

Comments

9.

Janina Witt

Wanderup, Germany

10.

mostafa hussein

cairo, Egypt

11.

Tracey Siepser

Claremont, CA

12.

davide bortolin

torino, Italy

13.

Katherine Lapuz

Placentia, CA

14.

Jessica Allen

Upland, CA

15.

S Guyver

Southwick, United Kingdom

16.

denis mermet

port arthur, Australia

17.

Jenny Bennett

Haslemere, United Kingdom

18.

Cosima Doerfel Hill

Wallasey, United Kingdom

To the Ministry of Agriculture & Land Reclamation, I am an Egyptologist and have professional links with Egypt, but this case of intolerable cruelty makes me consider boykotting Egypt and cutting all my ties with this otherwise beautiful country. This case is particularily shocking because the dolphins are kept in this utterly inadequate pool, where they are left to swim in their own faeces and which came to light because passers-by could HEAR THEIR CRIES OF ANGUISH (!!!), due to the authorities' demand for quarantine, even though in 2005 the same autorities had promised not to allow any further imports of marine mammals! This is a disgrace of epic proportions, even more so in the country who can boast the world's oldest university and is the mother of medicine!

19.

Marion Madau

San vero Milis, Italy

We are living in 2010 this situation is unacceptable and we are coming to enjoy your nature, but this is a crime and we will not coming back to egypt!

20.

Christopher Barrett

boca raton, FL

21.

anita gogolla

Kaprun, Austria

22.

afroditi katsikis

Rio Vista, CA

23.

Marcello Cazzola

Glasgow, United Kingdom

24.

Frédérique Mahaud

Saint-genis-laval, France

25.

Mathias Hohl

Berlin, Germany

26.

Mary Vasquez

Ontario, CA

27.

Norbert Michutta

schönefeld, Germany

28.

Angela Ziltener

Gossau, Switzerland

29.

Lawrence Sartore

Thousand Oaks, CA

30.

kelly ann welch

Fife, United Kingdom Page 2

THIS NEEDS TO STOP! Where is the compassion? This is unnecessary there are plenty in the sea off the coast in egypt, without capturing and caging them.

SAVE THESE DOLPHINS NOW

this is so sad....and disgusting... -

Signatures 9 - 30

Name

From

Comments

31.

Sarah Rifaat

Cairo, Egypt

This is completely unacceptable!

32.

Pia Mendiburu

pucon, Chile

33.

NinA BUDINI

Wollongong, Australia

34.

davide gatti

rovigo, Italy

35.

Nouran Mahfouz

Alexandria, Egypt

36.

JaNine Erickson

Douglass, KS

37.

Amina Abaza

Cairo, Egypt

38.

Kathy Schramm

Encino, CA

39.

Aleksandar Nicic

Gaithersburg, MD

40.

Alessia Beltrame

Milan, Italy

41.

eliette cofflard

hurghada, Egypt

42.

Holly Smith

Bunbury, Australia

43.

Areej Alsheikh

Thuwal, Saudi Arabia

44.

Daria Cantù

new york, NY

45.

Simon Allen

Perth, Australia

46.

Donia Badrakhan

Giza, Egypt

47.

Helen Colby

Miami, FL

48.

salma omar

cairo, Egypt

49.

jaki song

Montreal, Canada

This is a disgrace to all living things on earth! They cannot speak out but we can and we will! Until you RELEASE these poor creatures. I am not alone on this, there are hundreds and thousands of people who loves and care about these mammals and I know that some of us will not stop until there is justice! Set them FREE!

50.

Margarita Fierro

Bogotá, Colombia

It doesn´t matter where are we from: Nature around the world is our responsability and we must take actions for it benefit.. it is impossible that, when in Egypt and other many countries, hotels and big condominiums certify that "they follow environmental rules", this kind of acts are still happening, and, the most derisory, Egyptian national authorities doesn´t do anything, unless people (from other countries mainly) inform against it, to the world. I really hope it isn´t too late for the dolphins at the moment they will take it out from those pools, and this signatures will stop more japanese dolphins importation. Unbelievable.

Page 3

Egypt...STOP ABUSING ANIMALS EGYPT REMEMBER YOUR GLORIOUS HISTORY . RESPECT YOUR ANIMALS, RESPECT THE FEELINGS OF EGYPTIAN ANIMAL LOVERS AND ALSO TRY TO ATTRACT THE TOURISTS INSTEAD OF HURTING THEIR FEELINGS. REMOVE THE DOLPHINS NOW FROM THIS FILTHY POOL !!!!! stop Please we have to respect the nature and the freedom of all wild animals and if human being don't stop being selfish he will destroy the planet thank to which he is surveying!!!

-

Signatures 31 - 50

Name

From

Comments

51.

Mercedes De Windt

Philipsburg, Netherlands Antilles

The dolphin hype and dolphinariums should be killed not the dolphins. Please watch the movie The Cove. People who love dolphins don't swim with them but protect, defend and think with them. Thanks for this petition, thanks for the dolphins ♥

52.

John Grinins

Brooklyn, NY

53.

Nicolaas Koekoek singapore, Singapore

54.

Santiago Jaime

Bogotá, Colombia

55.

Ilga Sokolova

Sverdlovsk Region, Severouralsk, Russian Federation

56.

Morris Greer

Jacksonville, FL

57.

barbara owens

West Palm Beach, FL let these beauitful creatures out they need to be free, not lock up like a jail. let them go. so our children can enjoy them and learn. i am a voice for the animals.this is 2010 not the middle ages people.

58.

Masami Mizuguchi

New York, NY

59.

Mohie El Din Sherif

Cairo, Egypt

60.

Gaye Gamble

La Quinta, CA

61.

Nicole Baudisch

Ho Chi Minh City, Viet Nam

62.

Karrie Dennis

Edmond, OK

63.

Rebecca McKenney

Lancaster, VA

64.

STACY REYES

Sacramento, CA

65.

Alexandra El Nomeir

Hurghada, Egypt

66.

Debra Sousa-Oliveira

Kearny, NJ

"Stop the Dolphin Slavery". They belong in the Sea. They were not created to be put in big tanks, of water for human entertainment and amusement. If humans want to be amused and entertained, go watch humans on television.

67.

denise edgar

St Louis, MO

stop this now

68.

Joy Askew

Brooklyn, NY

69.

Anne Pulm

Nettetal, Germany

70.

Jochen Krebs

Haibach, Germany

71.

brigitte lehmann

hurghada, Egypt

put these stupid persons in prison!!!!

72.

Michael Haas

Sanur - Denpasar Bali, Indonesia

Dolphins should not be held in captivity. They are intelligent animals, sensitive and they need to be free.

Page 4

Please stop this cruelty!

Is $$$$$ so much more important than doing the right thing? These Dolphins did nothing to deserve a life of cruel captivity! Please release these beautiful creatures!

-

Signatures 51 - 72

Name

From

Comments

73.

Maren Thorwarth

Mörfelden-Walldorf, Germany

74.

Nina Gajor

Gelsenkirchen, Germany

75.

Thomas Stommel

Hagen, Germany

76.

meredith fuller

west falmouth, MA

77.

Sami Shlimon

Chicago, IL

78.

Natalia Semko

Moscow, Russian Federation

79.

Anja Hag

Dubai, United Arab Emirates

80.

Thomas Bordiehn

Hurghada, Egypt

81.

Katja Mueller

Dortmund, Germany

82.

M. Reimer

Garden Grove, CA

83.

Maike Belz

Battenberg, Germany

84.

Gwinny Zeeuwen

Lanaken, Belgium

85.

Bianca Rennecke

Hurghada, Egypt

86.

Wendy Ryan

Lucan, Canada

87.

cathy bogenberger

hurghada, Egypt

88.

Edwin Cruz-Rivera

New Cairo, Egypt

89.

Nadine Thesing

Poing, Germany

90.

marco grigolo

milan, Italy

91.

Stefan Dormayer

Gã¼nzburg, Germany

92.

Martina Miertsch

Berlin, Germany

These amazing animals belong to the vastness of the seas. Make people come to Egypt to see them swimming free in the sea instead of in captivity. Stop this cruelty immediately!!!

93.

Peter Fairweather

El Gouna, Egypt

This is appalling and must be acted against quickly.

94.

Tanja Weiler

Oldenburg, Germany

95.

tanja klang

iserlohn, Germany

96.

Larisa Reif

Dortmund, Germany

97.

Lisa Demirgil

Alanya, Turkey

98.

Somaya Abbas

hurghada, Egypt

99.

Madelene Richardsson

Väröbacka, Sweden Page 5

Please halt cruel treatment of dolphins. Thank you.

stop this now!!!

Ich hoffe das wir etwas bewirken können! Es ist nicht unsere welt, sie gehört uns allen....

its a shame that there is no other way for the animals to give them the freedom, which them right !!!!! open ur eyes !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

-

Signatures 73 - 99

Name

From

Comments

100.

Katrin Kueker

Berlin, Germany

101.

Stephen Bird

Sharm el Sheikh, Egypt

102.

Stéphane VERSAUT

El Gouna, Egypt

103.

Michael Finger

Westhofen, Germany

104.

Nicole Banda

Gibraltar, Gibraltar

105.

Nic Wuerz

Rheinstetten, Germany

106.

A. Liefke

Haselbachtal, Germany

107.

Valerie Cook

Swindon, United Kingdom

108.

stelvio baffetti

Abbadia S S, Italy

109.

Claudio Fedeli

milan, Italy

110.

MAUFROY CHRISTINE

MONTIER EN DER, France

111.

stina gemmel

hurghada, Egypt

112.

Jocellyn David

Craigieburn, Australia

Families belong with families. Wild life belongs in the wild. how many are being killed because you didnt choose them, but you create the market for them to be killed

113.

Mandy Hewett

Worthing, United Kingdom

Please sign this petition to help the Dolphins, they should be kept in the wild not in a contained pool!

114.

Canoë Segeren

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

115.

Tessa McLean

Hurghada, Egypt

116.

Mary Ghabrial

Cairo, Egypt

117.

Katrin Lauterborn

Dortmund, Germany

118.

Rene van Rossen

Poortugaal, Netherlands

119.

Frank Leienbach

Safaga, Egypt

120.

Rana Nessim

Cairo, Egypt

121.

Susanne Geissler

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

122.

Valentina Cucchiara

Rome, Italy

Page 6

set the dolphins free!!!

The conditions these animals are being kept in are appalling - there are so many wild and free dolphins here we dont need or want captive dolphins in Egypt.

The Red Sea has a unique environment by free living species of dolphins and whales. There is absolutly no need at all to hold these creatures in an unhumanely dolphinarium, dosn't matter where it would be located. Extra Divers Worldwide, Madinat Makadi

-

Signatures 100 - 122

Name

From

Comments

123.

Rob Keersmaekers

Breda, Netherlands

124.

Saad Ouf

hurghada, Egypt

125.

Amr Ali

cairo, Egypt

126.

Gayle Bell

pEACEHAVEN, United Kingdom

127.

Sigrid Lueber

Waedenswil, Switzerland

128.

Tina Gauer

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

129.

Elli Maria Laura

Milano, Italy

130.

Elena Marianna Bianchi

Milano, Italy

131.

Elsa Oliveira

Lisboa, Portugal

132.

Francesco Iarz

Brussels, Belgium

133.

Rich Husband

Nuremberg, Germany

134.

Kirsi Koponen

Helsinki, Finland

135.

Christina Hörterer

Bremen, Germany

136.

ritch cheval

sharm, Egypt

137.

Sven Stegmüller

Mühlheim, Germany

138.

Uwe Schmolke

Ruesselsheim, Germany

139.

Vanessa Buila

hurghada, Egypt

140.

Marcus Dengel

Helsingborg, Sweden

Stop this madness.

141.

Christian Krzywicki

Baldham, Germany

Dolphins in the Red Sea - this is great. Dolphins in a Pool or Dolphinarium - this is bad!

142.

Katarina Kollarova Prague 7, Czech Republic

143.

Andre Billion

Linden, Germany

144.

karen long

hurghada, Egypt

145.

Ali Ghaleb

Cairo, Egypt

146.

Wolfgang Kreft

Erlangen, Germany

147.

Jo Warner

Scharbeutz, Germany Serious diving instructors always teach proteting the marine environment. Thanks to HEPCA for your engagement - free the dolphins!

148.

Benjamin Bena

Hamburg, Germany

149.

christoph donati

Hurghada, Egypt

150.

Pascal Thill

Prettingen, Luxembourg Page 7

Stop this Horror! NOW!!!! No more Holidays in this Country!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

indefensible....let them free....now!

-

Signatures 123 - 150

Name

From

Comments

151.

Tina Göthner

Kempen, Germany

152.

Mai Sirry

Heliopolis, Cairo, Egypt

153.

Linda Pareschi

Milano, Italy

154.

Kevin Miller

Leatherhead, United Kingdom

155.

Jim Pickup

Macau, Macao

If you visit the places where marine mammals are kept in captivity then you are guilty,

156.

Hatem Tallima

Giza, Egypt

Stop this brutality at once! Stop dolphin captivity in Egypt!

157.

anne crowther

Brisbane, Australia

shame on you egypt

158.

Torsten Villnow

Jettingen, Germany

159.

Elke Würth

Freiberg, Germany

160.

Thomas Segers

Cologne, Germany

161.

Mai ElZeiny

Cairo, Egypt

162.

Gudrun Wiesflecker

Absam, Austria

163.

Ksenia Chernysheva

hurghada, Egypt

164.

Sylvia Hirst

Sheffield, United Kingdom

165.

silvia knips

Leipzig, Germany

166.

Michele Balconi

milano, Italy

167.

Terri Mc

White City, OR

168.

Cathy Cliff

Kidlington, United Kingdom

169.

Felipe Villa

thwal, Saudi Arabia

170.

Shantel Seoane

Chula Vista, CA

171.

Matthias Andenmatten

Bern, Switzerland

172.

Claudia Peters

Lethbridge, Canada

173.

Marianne Hanna

Cairo, Egypt

For whoever is captioning the dolphins: Imagine you are trapped in one room you can move in & you cannot get out with the worst oxygen to breathe! This is what you are doing to the animals! Free the dolphins! They are not gold fish in an aquarium! They need a good habitat like you do!

174.

Fadi Rezq

Sanad, Bahrain

Sick sick sick.

175.

Kim Cooper

Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom Page 8

All creatures of God deserve freedom and to flourish in their own natural habitat. Captivity is an ugly word and an ugly idea.

Resue them and put them out! Put the owner in to the jail... Poor, poor Taiji dolphins,it's a shame!!!!

Pleases release the dolphins.

-

Signatures 151 - 175

Name

From

Comments

176.

Chantal Buslot

Hasselt, Belgium

177.

David Taylor

Farnham, United Kingdom

178.

Heiner Endemann Cologne, Germany

179.

Menna Maassarani

Cairo, Egypt

180.

Losa Emanuele

Milan, Italy

181.

Treva Fleischmann

Houston, TX

182.

Yaseen Kafafi

Giza, Egypt

183.

Peta Peggs

Mudgee, Australia

184.

Kerstin Ehlert

Marsa Alam, Egypt

185.

Markus Frei

Eglisau, Switzerland

186.

Kerstin Huf

Ingelheim, Germany

187.

Dovile Kucinskyte

Kelme, Lithuania

188.

Elisabeth Ehmann Vienna, Austria

189.

Maddalena Fumagalli

190.

Rafik El Shaarawy Cairo, Egypt

191.

Tina Smith

Harbord, Australia

Absolutly disgusting...how can any country sanction such inhumane cruelty? FREE THEM!!

192.

Hans-Christoph Deeken

Neckargemünd, Germany

Imagine yourself in solitary confinement with polluted air and without waste disposal facilities and then ask yourself, whether you would want to inflict that on any other being.

193.

sherry el kilany

cairo, Egypt

This is disgusting, this country is already disappointing enough!

194.

Andreas Reppien

Berlin, Germany

195.

Sigge Lundqvist

U-Vasby, Sweden

196.

Monika Neff

Klang, Malaysia

197.

Peter Arend

Hann. Münden, Germany

198.

filippo zelman

milan, Italy

199.

Priya Knolbruins

Alkmaar, Netherlands

200.

Lyndsay Mairs

Hurghada, Egypt

STOP dolphin captivity in Egypt

that should never happen, why we need a dolphinatrium right beside the see, where they can be see in their natural environment ???

Dolphins are mammals. They are warm-blooded, suckle their young, and breathe air.. Stop capturing and displaying dolphins for our amusement. These intelligent, social animals should not lose their freedom just so that we can watch them perform silly tricks. mish munkin

Inzago, Italy

Page 9

-

Signatures 176 - 200

Name

From

Comments

201.

Simon Taylor

bentham, United Kingdom

This will discourage more tourists then encourage.

202.

Milie Roberts

Horsham, United Kingdom

203.

Alexander Volkmar

Bad Steben, Germany

204.

Daniel Schoeberl

Durban, South Africa

205.

Gernot Conrad

Holzkirchen, Germany

206.

Klaus Delling

Dortmund, Germany

207.

Manuela Gargiulo

Sant, Italy

208.

Rachel Bailey

Chippenham, United Kingdom

209.

Michaela Muick

Heidenheim, Germany

210.

Nina Milton

Dahab, Egypt

211.

Marko Klink

Bergkamen, Germany

212.

Markus Peters

Herzogenrath, Germany

213.

Peter Schmidt

Kiltimagh, Ireland

214.

Britta Steiner

Dahab, Egypt

215.

Marina Costa

Glasgow, United Kingdom

216.

Simone Reich

Erlangen, Germany

217.

Brigitte Bard

Santa Monica, CA

218.

dina maghawry

cairo, Egypt

219.

Linda Clark

Cairo, Egypt

220.

Ahmed Emad

Cairo, Egypt

221.

Izabela Ziomek

Hurghada, Egypt

222.

karim el motayam

red sea, Egypt

223.

Sinisa Adamovic

Podgorica, Montenegro, Serbia And Montenegro

224.

Martyn Dormer

Bath, United Kingdom These beautiful and intelligent creature should NEVER be incarcerated in any circumstances. This is an OUTRAGE.

225.

Chiara C.

Ancona, Italy

226.

Robert Burgers

El Gouna, Egypt

227.

Conny Schmidt

Berlin, Germany

228.

Ahmed Rashad

Cairo, Egypt

229.

Sven Jahnke

Appen, Germany Page 10

STOP!!!!

it is a shame!

-

Signatures 201 - 229

Name

From

Comments

230.

Michelle Heimgartner

Bergdietikon, Switzerland

231.

Sherine Omar

Cairo, Egypt

232.

Birte Schrader

Hurghada, Egypt

233.

amina ghali

cairo, Egypt

234.

Nicole Fuchs

Hof, Germany

235.

Michalis Tsirponouris

Vienna, Austria

236.

Ines Maerz

HRG, Egypt

237.

Melanie Koch

Bremen, Germany

238.

Rene Lipmann

Mijdrecht, Netherlands

239.

Jo Gough

Southampton, United Kingdom

240.

KLaus gaar

Holzkirchen, Germany

241.

Lan Nguyen Tran

HCM, Viet Nam

242.

Robin Pritchard

Doha, Qatar

243.

Mo Hammoud

beirut, Lebanon

244.

Daniel Binham

Thuwal, Jeddah, Saudi Arabia

245.

Yuliya Bidyuk

Hurghada, Egypt

It is so inhuman

246.

Susanne Dominkovits

Hurghada, Egypt

This is absolutely unacceptable. Its nothing dirty enough that people wouldnt do it for money. Makadi Bay is a good example for raping the nature. Broken corals for building hotels, rubbish that is buried in the desert beside the hotels filled in blue bags, guest walking on the reefs and now the plan of a Dolphinarium!

247.

Birgit Oevermann

Kippenheim, Germany

248.

raffaella malevolti

sambuca pistoiese, Italy

249.

Petra Ziehm

Haltern, Germany

No Jail for dolphins

250.

suzi ghezawi

amman, Jordan

we can never be at our best until we free all ..

251.

Anja Buchloh

Hurghada, Egypt

252.

tina weiß

waldenbuch, Germany

253.

Sven Meyer

Berlin, Germany

254.

kevin van der beeuren

Ranst, Belgium

Page 11

i´ve no wirds left for this, just sham.... Stop this now!

STOP THIS!

-

Signatures 230 - 254

Name

From

Comments

255.

Nino Del Duca

Sharm el Sheikh, Egypt

256.

Tori Sugden

Clifton Beach, Australia

257.

Markus Greissl

Munich, Germany

258.

Anna Miserocchi

milano, Italy

259.

Hesham El-Sharawy

Cairo, Egypt

All humans need to learn compassion if we are to advance as a race.

260.

sarah konopelska

10247, Germany

money shall never be gained by making others (any living creature!) suffer!

261.

Sandra Bögli

Ortschwaben, Switzerland

262.

Corinne Ackermann

Suhr, Switzerland

263.

Seham Eloraby

Cairo, Egypt

264.

mandy buckley

crewe, United Kingdom

I love Egypt, and am saddened by this... Put a stop to it

265.

Peter Siegenthaler

Doettingen, Switzerland

Typical Egypt, no respect for animals at all

266.

Sebastian Gaissert

Berlin, Germany

267.

Sarah Moir

Stevenage, United Kingdom

268.

rossella paterno

GOSSOLENGO, Italy

269.

marie perthuisot

La Garde, France

270.

Dina Zulfikar

Cairo, Egypt

Please those dolphins ought to be placed in a comploying facility which meets species specific needs. Please no more dolphinariums or cruel entertaining facilities. Please save the species

271.

Peter Hoffmann

Marktoberdorf, Germany

Dolphins in a small pool! That is horrible and a crime for a country where diving tourism is a important economic value.

272.

Suheil Elbaseer

Hurghada, Egypt

273.

Stella Hansen

Kiel^, Germany

274.

Thomas Happel

El Gona, Egypt

275.

CARLOS SARRA

madryn, Argentina

276.

Friso Jankowsky

Vienna, Austria

278.

Wotke Carmen

Munic, Germany

I am ashamed to be human. Please stop it!

279.

Linda Dean

Leeds, United Kingdom

please please please don't, dolphins belong in the wild where they can choose to interact. If humans want interaction then they should do it in the dolphins natural

no more captivity

(continues on next page)

Page 12

-

Signatures 255 - 279

Name

From

Comments

279.

Linda Dean

Leeds, United Kingdom

(continued from previous page)

280.

Veerle Roelandt

Berlare, Belgium

281.

Mary Cyr

Hampton, Canada

282.

nicolette lusolphi

Bremen, Germany

283.

Jörg Verhoeven

Münster, Germany

284.

manal Eissa

Cairo, Egypt

285.

Evelina Trinkler

Gretzenbach, Switzerland

286.

Gerd Geertz

Hamburg, Germany

287.

Denise Fletcher

Hurghada, Egypt

288.

Bruno Pin

Samarate (Va), Italy

289.

Paul Newing

Reading, United Kingdom

290.

Sandra Pasqual Cucco

Torino, Italy

291.

Petra Taeuber

Oerlinghausen, Germany

292.

ugin zhoglo

hurghada, Egypt

293.

Amr Bassiouny

cairo, Egypt

294.

Ahmed Tarek

Cairo, Egypt

295.

Patrick Suter

Ecublens, Switzerland

296.

Ute Renung

Hurghada, Egypt

297.

fernanda trinkler

gretzenbach, Switzerland

298.

gabriella rusticali

forli, Italy

299.

silvia fantini

canonica d'adda, Italy

300.

Eva Voegler

Berlin, Germany

301.

KERRY MCKENZIE

WEYMOUTH, United Kingdom

302.

Irena Andreasen

Haarby, Denmark

303.

dina radwan

Cairo, Egypt

304.

tania rebourg

Lyon, France

305.

vandemeulebrouck neuilly sur marne, leslie France

environment not some where cruel & false like a prison which is captivity. CRUEL.

you the most beautiful richness in nature and history. show the western world that you care for our oceans and life. Give a great example and forbid the misery of captive marine mamals. Now! Is your chance. thanks for your kindness

Page 13

-

Signatures 279 - 305

Name

From

Comments

306.

christine chamoun malmoe, Sweden

307.

Hans Lange

Dahab, Egypt

308.

yassmin atieh

Cairo, Egypt

309.

Claudia Jung

Bayreuth, Germany

310.

Christoph Meier

Wasserburg, Germany

311.

Keira Beattie

Arbroath, United Kingdom

312.

Melania Mols

Amsterdam, Netherlands

313.

Melanie Schroeder

Grevenbroich, Germany

314.

Tatjana Romanenkow

Hurghada, Egypt

315.

Judith Studer

Oberentfelden, Switzerland

316.

dalia ragab

Gizza, Egypt

317.

darren jones

abercarn, United Kingdom

318.

Joris Prangsma

drachten, Netherlands

319.

claire roberts

london, United Kingdom

320.

Reem Alfutaih

Cairo, Egypt

321.

Marcus Gisi

Bettlach, Switzerland

322.

Katrien Vandevelde

Nieuwrode, Belgium

323.

Hamza Besaiso

Cairo, Egypt

324.

Mark Bamberry

Seven Lakes, NC

325.

Youssef Labib

giza, Egypt

326.

Iman Zoulfikar

Cairo, Egypt

327.

Jussi-Pekka Kurtti helsinki, Finland

328.

Jaki Teo

Strathmore, Australia

329.

Giuseppe Notarbartolo di Sciara

Milano, Italy

Page 14

This is continuous torture for these poor dolphins. They might not even survive the 105 quarantine days. STOP THIS IMMEDIATELY!!!

It's a shame!!!!! Such situations need to stop!

ive seen dolphins in the wild in hurgahada and its was amazing. these animals should be free to roam the the seas and oceans. so no to the keeping of wild dolphins in eygpt.

are you criminals insane?? the whole dolphinarium industry is disgusting. these fellows r so unique and important to our nature and ecosystem that its pure insanity to capture them! see also my blog: www.disciara.net

-

Signatures 306 - 329

Name

From

Comments

330.

Anine Hell

Innsbruck, Austria

331.

Fabio Volpe

Villar Dora, Italy

332.

Aimee Billington

Brighton, United Kingdom

333.

Carol Tuskey

Hillsborough, NC

334.

Tundi Agardy

Colrain, MA

335.

Alessia Scuderi

reggio Calabria, Italy

336.

Steven Surina

Hurghada, Egypt

337.

Jasmine Moreillon Sierre, Switzerland

338.

Andrew Butt

Port Glasgow, United Kingdom

339.

Ann V

R, Belgium

340.

Samir Bendali Braham

Úri, Hungary

341.

Georg Radl

Kümmersbruck, Germany

342.

Marie James

Doha, Qatar

343.

treilles gwen

Saint Paul, Reunion

344.

Mario Essinger

Stavanger, Norway

Keep them free, do not capture and torture these fantastic animals!!!

345.

Barbara Ceschi

Vicenza, Italy

Stop it NOW!!!

346.

Angy Refaat

Cairo, Egypt

347.

marie castelli

amtidad 15 mayo, Egypt

STOP DOLPHIN CAPTIVITY IN EGYPT

348.

marya verschoor

Vianen, Netherlands

the world is sick, so also the rich people. Egypt let the dolphins free, this is so cruel and sick, they belong to live in freedom.

349.

Kristina Scheidt

Neunkirchen, Germany

350.

dee manning

sharm, Egypt

351.

Karin van Capelle

Hurghada, Egypt

352.

Christine Muehlematter

Hurghada, Egypt

353.

Claude Valérie Hermann

Biel, Switzerland

354.

Blue Paradise Red Sea

Hurghada, Egypt

355.

Sarah-Jane Aziz

Marsa Alam, Egypt

356.

sandre lovergne

Conflans, France Page 15

So cruel

that's a sham!!!!

This should not be allowed to happen. Dolphins cannot survive in such an environment. Something should be done and punitive measures put in place for such horrible acts.

please stop this type of captivity. -

Signatures 330 - 356

Name

From

Comments

357.

Jacqueline Meessen

wijlre, Netherlands

this has to stop!!!!!!

358.

Carole Kuehl

Chanute, KS

359.

Kjetil Astrup

Perth, Australia

360.

Penny Noble

Brisbane, Australia

361.

Karina Kaiser

Gänserndorf, Austria

362.

Andy Michelberger

Karlsruhe, Germany

363.

Teresa Birmingham

Ft. Carson, CO

364.

J Teo

Singapore, Singapore Dolphins belong in the wild! Free them please!

365.

nora seoudi

Cairo, Egypt

366.

Miranda Daniel

Sharjah, Egypt

367.

Andrea Cavanaugh

Columbia, SC

368.

john timoney

Gorey, Ireland

369.

Carol Matthews

Hurghada, Egypt

370.

Claire Despins

Ottawa, Canada

371.

Murray Tensing

Termeil, Australia

372.

AnaLiza Festen

Den Bosch, Netherlands

373.

Ian Mielke

kingsley, MI

374.

L. McGannon

Mitchell, SD

375.

Michele Nevola

copiague, NY

376.

Sonja Bruce

San Antonio, TX

377.

Cristina Stroescu

Bucharest, Romania

378.

Andreas Kohlhofer

Weilheim, Germany

379.

Marjatta Jokinen

Orivesi, Finland

380.

Ellen Powell

South Burlington, VT

381.

Johannes Friedrich

Nürnberg, Germany

382.

Manuel Krämer

Zürich, Switzerland

383.

Claudia Buschke

Hamburg, Germany

384.

Kristin Molnar

Jacksonville, NC

385.

Serena Harris

Surprise, AZ

386.

Nora Sinkankas

Bethany, OK

387.

Elaine Despins

Montreal, Canada

388.

Jasmin Hussein

El Gouna, Egypt Page 16

We all need to help that such crimes can be avoided

free the Dolphins!!

Have a HEART.

-

Signatures 357 - 388

Name

From

Comments

389.

Deborah Pritchard Menai Bridge, United Kingdom

390.

nora hendriks

wuustwezel, Belgium

391.

nathan wilkins

hahira, GA

392.

Dirk Merkel

Berlin, Germany

393.

Marion Kriegesmann

Paderborn, Germany

394.

Monique van Montfoort

Hurghada, Egypt

395.

Claudine Thill

prettingen, Luxembourg

396.

Denise Darnstaedt

Tacoma, WA

397.

jan jansen

rotterdam, Netherlands

398.

jennifer nichols

DeLeon, TX

I love dolphins. they are ment to be free not like this!!! please do something!!!!

399.

Paulgun Sulur

University City, MO

This is horrible!

400.

adel heine

amsterdam, Netherlands

401.

Sarah Nader

Maadi, Egypt

402.

karin smith

vancouver, WA

404.

noortje van vlasselaer

Haacht, Belgium

405.

rebecca verschoor

maasdijk, Netherlands

406.

Re Steinman

Ann Arbor, MI

407.

Melissa Cavanaugh

Corpus Christie, TX

408.

Ann Van Den Bossche

Geraadsbergen, Belgium

Stop this cruelty now.

409.

Nour Edin Saleh

Cairo, Egypt

stop the stupidity

410.

vanessa wasik

hurghada, Egypt

411.

GRUMIAUX Thierry

GARGENVILLE, France Page 17

This completely unacceptable,shame on you.

Something has to be done, this is cruel and selfish

Despite zoos' and aquariums' claims that they are promoting conservation, they actually reduce populations of even endangered species in the wild. Send a message to the world of your commitment to the environment, animal welfare, and the delicate balance of the ocean's ecosystems. Well-publicized compassion will do much better for public relations and potential tourist trade than an exploitative "dolphinaria."

This is totally unacceptable as the place for dolphins is in the deep sea and certainly not in swiming pools to enjoy a few irresponsible persons! -

Signatures 389 - 411

Name

From

Comments

412.

Huberschwiller Franck

Altorf, France

413.

Holger Breite

Wendlingen, Germany

414.

Pemba Dive & Bush Camp

Pemba - Quirimbas, Mozambique

415.

Rawan Khalil

Cairo, Egypt

416.

Wayne Cowley

Boksburg, South Africa

417.

jane gorman

Manchester, United Kingdom

418.

Esther Gugger

Epalinges, Switzerland

419.

Laura Poepleu

Verden, Germany

420.

Rolland Thierry

Gueberschwir, France

421.

Werner Gaßner

München, Germany

422.

Leif Stenbom

Norrköping, Sweden

423.

ulysse de hesselle alphen a/d Rijn, Netherlands

424.

Jean-Philippe Borges

Toulouse, France

425.

Cara Pepper

Kinmel Bay, United Kingdom

426.

dominique colletti

La Valette Du Var, France

427.

Kelly Cleveland

Denver, CO

428.

Emanuela Tacci

Parma, Italy

429.

Clémence P

Montpellier, France

430.

Nora Baltzer

Kiel, Germany

431.

Stephan Mesik-Nehrkorn

Leck, Germany

432.

Annabell Zeiter Elsaka

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

433.

Christine Schmidt

Freiburg, Germany

Are you crazy??? Free the dolphins!

434.

Paolo Poli

barcelona, Spain

basta con questa mattanza!!!!!! se vi ci metto io in una gabbia "senza aver fatto nulla" a vita? stronzi!!!!!

Page 18

Under no circumstances does Japan qualify for any activity of this type, especially killing of so much marine life for so called “research”. It is a rape to conservation and principles. Their damaging, dishonesty is only for commercial use.

Don't eat fish and don't eat meat for un best future four our children. Let the fish in the ocean and the birds in the air. No capture, no cage. Love

Stop it - this is cruel!

Please stop dolphin captivity...don't support the supporters of dolphin captivity...do not visit the attractions...don't feed into the cruelty that goes on all around the world!

Stop that!

-

Signatures 412 - 434

Name

From

Comments

435.

Marie-France Anagnostopoulos

Newmarket, Canada

As the world is in crisis, it is so vital to conserve and protect all the species possible. This action is contrary to that and must be stopped. Humans must realize the duty we have to fight for the creatures that exist on this planet or else they will be extinct!! Enough is enough!

436.

hassan gomaa

safaga, Egypt

look guy's rich people here in egypt they like to do what they want and they don't care about anything else

437.

Alexander Wunderer

Vienna, Austria

438.

Sonja Kruess

Ruhsto, Germany

439.

Lucia Plavcova

Newcastle, United Kingdom

440.

Mona Sabri

cairo, Egypt

441.

Emanuela Rebecchi

Hurghada, Egypt

442.

cristian toledo

Madrid, Spain

443.

Doris Driggs

Frankfurt, Germany

444.

Dani Link

Gräfenberg, Georgia

445.

Amanda Darnstaedt

glendale, AZ

446.

Shona El Sayed

Hurghada, Egypt

447.

Mike Beazer

Lancashire, United Kingdom

448.

mandy cutsforth

Hull, United Kingdom

449.

Ralf Rohn

Essen, Germany

450.

LEROY JEAN LUC

St Martin Des Champs, France

451.

pauline Beazer

Chorley, United Kingdom

452.

Belinda Shams

Soest, Germany

453.

Francesca Zardin

Bergamo, Italy

454.

Oswald Maggy

Zeihen, Switzerland

455.

Gerd Neubauer

Erkelenz, Germany

456.

Vanessa Visita

Trieste, Italy

457.

Susanne Finke

Minden, Germany

458.

Ruth Stephens

Wiesbaden, Germany I did see the pool. It is not 9 x 9 m. It is darkgreen and about 6 x 5 m.

459.

Renate Harb

Bonn, Germany Page 19

Hey. This is totally unfair to the environment as well as those sweet lovely animals. Only 401 votes its a shame. Lets all do something

It's a scandal. It's inhuman. I have no words for this.

I am likewise appalled at this disgraceful self-indulgent abuse - indeed, a crime against nature!!

This is a retro step, totally unacceptable in a modern society, please put them back in their natural environment, where they belong.

Wo leben wir in der Seinzeit? So etwas darf es im Jahre 2010 nicht mehr geben

-

Signatures 435 - 459

Name

From

Comments

460.

Roula Tsirponouri

limassol, Cyprus

This has to be stopped

461.

sandrine courpet

montauban, France

462.

Andrea Schubert

Groß-umstadt, Germany

463.

Michele Welter

Hove, United Kingdom

464.

habiba el derini

cairo, Egypt

465.

Dominika Steeger

rösrath, Germany

466.

Margot Wehrli

Oberägeri, Switzerland

467.

alyssa warren

Pensacola, FL

468.

NEWHAVEN SCUBA CENTRE

NEWHAVEN, United Kingdom

469.

Jacqueline Norrish

London, United Kingdom

From the wild to a life of sensory deprivation - what hell!

470.

Bob Cantwell

Dursley, United Kingdom

Sick bastards....if this goes ahead lets stop diving out of Sharm????

471.

Gege Hägele

Stuttgart, Germany

472.

Stefan Seeger

Muenster, Germany

473.

Stefan Wastl

Erding, Germany

474.

Amina Bouiri-Hafez

Frankfurt, Germany

475.

Jose Arevalo

PArla, Spain

476.

Klaus Heyser

Oberursel, Germany

477.

damien mauric

Asnières Sur Seine, France

478.

Sabine Neumann

Petershagen, Germany

479.

piet bierhaalder

Winterswijk, Netherlands

480.

Niels Berschneider

23, Germany

481.

Elena Gatti

Casalborgone, Italy

482.

Sandra Caramelle munich, Germany

483.

Kerstin Schwarzbich

STOP THIS FOREVER

I urgently ask you to help the 4 dolphins in 2 steps: First please help to bring the dolphins to a much bigger pool with an adequate filtration system; second please help to bring them back to their natural environment. And beyond these points please help to avoid that any other dolphins are imported to Egypt. Yours sincerely, Klaus Heyser

Hurghada, Egypt Page 20

-

Signatures 460 - 483

Name

From

Comments

484.

ulrich schindler

krefeld, Germany

485.

Martha Rengifo

Bogotá, Colombia

486.

Lucy Wingate

Atlanta, GA

487.

Dana Inter

Oranienburg, Germany

488.

Serhat Cinar

Cologne, Germany

489.

CHRISTINE LOCK

Manchester, United Kingdom

490.

Beate Quinn

Erlangen, Germany

491.

Walter Ziltener

Rorschacherberg, Switzerland

492.

Amy Hernandez

Upland, CA

493.

Holger Massmann Bottrop, Germany

494.

Joan Marindin

Hurghada, Egypt

495.

Sarah Parsons

Al Khuwair, Oman

496.

Joerg Scheffler

Hannover, Germany

497.

Geoff Morris

Ripon, United Kingdom

498.

camilla ottina

milano, Italy

499.

kryssie francis

Tewkesbury, United Kingdom

500.

Karen Kirk

Galashiels, United Kingdom

501.

Anna Spiller

Burglengenfeld, Germany

502.

Michael Böhm

Murnau, Germany

503.

dirk jan bijmholt

kralendijk, Netherlands Antilles

504.

C Andrews

Soton, United Kingdom

505.

Barbora Petrikovicova

Bratislava, Slovakia

506.

Olga Zaric

Montreal, Canada

507.

Natascha Fawzy

Hurghada, Egypt Page 21

Please stop threating dolphins as things. They're living and sensitive beeings like you and me. You wouldn't like to be caged on 9x9m your whole life, althou you may deserve it.

I'd only love to see dolphins in freedom in the environment they come from and belong to. Nobody has the right to keep them in captivity in such cruel tiny pools.

Whats the point when you can see dolphins in their natural habitat the RED SEA. How stupid or lazy can you get!!!!

Dolphins are known to be highly intelligent and to need the company of other Dolphins, this is a death sentence for them, pls keep Egypt a beautiful place, kind to Animals and attractive for tourists who will NOT like this at all. Please enforce your laws to free them and save their lives.

This really has to stop.. Humans can be so cruel it is unforgivable

-

Signatures 484 - 507

Name

From

Comments

508.

Slavoljub Zaric

Montreal, Canada

509.

Cornelia Stegemann

Duisburg, Germany

510.

Gordon Davies

Carlsbad, CA

511.

Lisa Lange

Müllheim, Germany

512.

sharon collette

Athens, GA

513.

carmen vasile

Triuggio, Italy

514.

Lucas Künnecke

Hamburg, Germany

515.

caitlin mckissick

Ellenton, FL

Can't we just leave the creatures alone? ??

516.

M Lotaief

Naser city, Egypt

That's just stupid... Dolphins should be free to roam not stuck in a tiny pool where they will get depressed and die.

517.

Danny Aslan

Swanborough, United Kingdom

518.

noor diab

giza, Egypt

519.

Yuka Azuma

Brooklyn, NY

520.

Debbi Scheun

Pretoria, South Africa

521.

Nancy Hambach

Odenthal, Germany

522.

robert hii

Scarborough, Canada Dear Minister, I strongly urge you to look into this dolphinarium and shut it down. Kind regards from Canada

523.

Giovanna Carrascosa

huntersville, NC

524.

deborah drammeh Providence, RI

525.

Vivienne Ben-Shir London, United Kingdom

526.

Lisa charrett

Southampton, United Kingdom

527.

carrateo david

remilly, France

528.

thomas florence

vélizy, France

529.

Kristie Lyon

St. Louis, MO

530.

Laus Jacques

Braine-le-comte, Belgium

531.

kelly mc corry

Belfast, United Kingdom

532.

catherine insomby seynod, France

533.

Sophia Papadochatzaki

Athens, Greece

534.

Stijn Bruers

Herentals, Belgium

535.

Evangelos Aragiannis

Ermoupolis - Syros, Greece

536.

Tamar Citak

Vienna, Austria Page 22

stop it now !!!

We must Stop this delay!

Release the dolphins they are not yours.

-

Signatures 508 - 536

Name

From

Comments

537.

Ana Maria Olivo

Caracas, Venezuela

538.

Nathalie Bron

Hurghada, Egypt

539.

Myrto Mavropoulou

Thessaloniki, Greece

540.

lucy Fedoriwskyj

Nottingham, United Kingdom

541.

RAHUL SHARMA

DELHI, India

542.

Amal Haouet

Tunis, Tunisia

543.

roberta bocca

roma, Italy

544.

Heidi Niggemeyer

Pacific Grove, CA

545.

Lina Kuijl

Stockholm, Sweden

546.

Karolien Coppens

kortenberg, Belgium

547.

Daniel Kachelriess

Nürnberg, Germany

548.

Raluca Schutte

Zoetermeer, Netherlands

549.

Eric HENRY

Nancy, France

550.

Jane Stanley

Toronto, Canada

551.

vaes sylvain

mol, Belgium

552.

Connie Hoffmann

Cottage Grove, WI

553.

Nadezhda Peneva

Alicante, Spain

554.

Haylee Angles

Pompano Beach, FL

555.

Leigh Sleight

johannesburg, South Africa

556.

Axel Muench

Haar b. Muenchen, Germany

557.

Axelle Tramaloni

Marseille, France

558.

Carina Mueller

Bayreuth, Germany

559.

Sean Kelly

newbridge, Ireland

560.

Cindy Poulin

Thetford Mines, Canada

561.

Jana Hoffmann

Leipzig, Germany

562.

Jasmin Simon

Mönchaltorf, Switzerland

563.

Keem Fares

San Diego, CA

564.

Aleksandra Koper

Warsaw, Poland Page 23

save life!! save dolphins!!! Dolphins are extremely intelligent, playful, and social creatures that do not belong in a tank or a "play pool".

These creatures are far too intelligent for us too simply be taking advantage of them for entertainment!

Every voice counts...

As a regular visitor to the Red Sea I beg you to take responsible action as soon as possible.

-

Signatures 537 - 564

Name

From

Comments

565.

david stokes

manchester, United Kingdom

this is barbaric leave the dolphins in the wild !!! Egypt is better than this

566.

Christopher Garcia

Oakland, CA

567.

Michelle Morton

Derby, United Kingdom

568.

Lisa Yohon

Allegany, NY

569.

Colleen Brown

Rochester Hills, MI

570.

sarah stjohn

Odem, TX

571.

Sarah Vis

Amsterdam, Netherlands

572.

Lenny Botter

Dordrecht, Netherlands

573.

Jean Loughlin

Granada, Spain

574.

Cathrine Plath

Nordborg, Denmark

575.

jake bourgraf

key west, FL

576.

Suze Harrison

London, United Kingdom

577.

kimberly woodruff

canton, NY

578.

Vera Mornatta

Cadorago (Como), Italy

579.

Melanie Bayle

Hurghada, Egypt

580.

Naomi White

Whangarei, New Zealand

582.

Jack Colwell

San Francisco, CA

583.

Camilla Hedegaard Andersen

Viby J, Denmark

584.

susana navajas

Miami, FL

585.

karin kurz

rum, Austria

586.

Alberto Turri

Trequanda, Italy

587.

Steffi Finnerty

Hernando, FL

588.

Emily Aldridge

New York, NY

589.

shyam fareed

hurghada, Egypt

590.

Marcel Ludwig

Waldshut, Germany

591.

Lenka Praizlerova Pilsen, Czech Republic

592.

mary foley

Cork, Ireland

593.

Bryan Marley

Sand Springs, OK

594.

agnese mancini

jesi, Italy Page 24

Is better that I don't speak about this people and what I think about it ... Dolphins are more intelligent than humans! leave them ALONE

-

Signatures 565 - 594

Name

From

Comments

595.

Heather Reser

Bristol, IN

596.

Lisa Bowyer

Grand Cayman, Cayman Islands

597.

Alfred Martinez

Coachella, CA

598.

CHRISTOS GEORGALLIS

Kos, Greece

599.

Bernd Oltmanns

Lichtenberg, Germany

600.

pamir saracoglu

bodrum, Turkey

601.

Marta Zamora

Barcelona, Spain

602.

Jacobus Johannes Boomsma

Almere, Netherlands

603.

tina mann

sutton in ashfield, United Kingdom

604.

Céline Meyer

hoenheim, France

605.

claudio cifarelli

Brescia, Italy

606.

Evgeniy Gordinskiy

Moscow, Russian Federation

607.

maurizia burlando

Genova, Italy

608.

Mary Dolgorukova Moscow, Russian Federation

609.

Laura Grippia

milano, Italy

610.

N.C.W. Abdallah

Boise, ID

611.

Jean Bruneau

Montreal, Canada

612.

Jennifer Boose

Winston Salem, NC

613.

Debbie Pritchard

Menai Bridge, United Kingdom

614.

JEAN BOURREL

VIGNY, France

615.

Wayne Adey

Hereford, United Kingdom

616.

Sian Foch-Gatrell

Norwich, United Kingdom

617.

Laura Ashmore

Monrovia, CA

618.

Cher Clarke

London, Canada

619.

Sarah O"Gorman

Tonbridge, United Kingdom

620.

Hassan Adly

Balaclava, Vic, Australia

621.

Jennifer Wade

Vestavia Hills, AL

Wild animals belong in the WILD!!! LET THEM GO!!!

Page 25

-

Signatures 595 - 621

Name

From

Comments

622.

Steven De Greveleer

1, Belgium

623.

Jeannie Wright

Temecul, CA

624.

Norma Jean Garza Kabirpour

San Antonio, TX

625.

Judith Wouters

Duffel, Belgium

626.

Jacqueline Jewula Cumbria, United Kingdom

627.

Beatriz Fündling

Bad Homburg, Germany

628.

Jo-lene Funk

White City, OR

629.

myra gordon

Mastic Beach, NY

630.

berny dupre

Gagny, France

631.

Tumeria Langlois

Maynard, MA

632.

Daniel Albicker

Zürich, Switzerland

633.

Kathryn Dalenberg

Valley Head, AL

634.

Debby Bradford

Dania Beach, FL

635.

lia adams

Tacoma, WA

636.

Lucy Bradford

Stroud, United Kingdom

637.

ENRIQUETA GIL GELOSO

Mendoza, Argentina

638.

Cara Wilson

Sooke, Canada

639.

Wendy Phillips

Phoenix, AZ

640.

Marcel Hoogeveen

Lelystad, Netherlands Are you crazy? These creatures belong to the sea!!!!!! Please eliminate this kind of animal torture! As a frequent visitior of egypt and the red sea, I expect that the government of this country will prosecute these criminals who have the dolphins in their pool. Crazy!!!!

641.

Jo Jo

Bristol, United Kingdom

642.

maria eugenia harraca

Jackson Heights, NY

643.

Maja Greminger

Gockhausen, Switzerland

644.

irena digangi

hanover park, IL

645.

Glaucia Lolli

Northford, CT

646.

Sarah Corrigan

London, United Kingdom

647.

Daniela Gatti

Assago, Italy Page 26

Let them go back to the ocean! Please!

This is so VERY wrong! Save the dolphins and imprison the exploiters.

PARAR LA CAPTURA SE DELFINES EN EGIPTO.

Stop this cruelty!

-

Signatures 622 - 647

Name

From

Comments

648.

Diane McNally

Victoria, Canada

Please act on HEPCA's recommendations to end dolphin captivity in Egypt. I work with others to put an end to cetacean captivity in North America and other locations as well.Put Egypt at the forefront of growing worldwide awareness that cetacean captivity is deeply wrong.

649.

R Tillier

London, United Kingdom

650.

derek lally

carshalton, United Kingdom

651.

Maureen Hurly

Calgary, Canada

652.

Mireille Slokker Lodewijks

Zaandijk, Netherlands

654.

Rosemary Lachance

West Haven, CT

655.

Garrett Spencer

Jacksonville, FL

As having my Master's in Marine Biology, traditions, or whatever the reason, these and all sea life are a treasure and a gift. So much is out there, that is still undiscovered. Let's protect our oceans, and what lives in them.

656.

sANDRA SEGOVIA

Mexico City, Mexico

STOP ANIMAL CRUELTY!

657.

chiara ferrarini

Modena, Italy

658.

Jean-Sebastien Fessier

Toulon, France

659.

Portia Saucedo

West Sacramento, CA

660.

Caroline Stuart

Folkestone, United Kingdom

661.

carrie grant

Oakland Park, FL

662.

Andreas Gazis

oslo, Norway

663.

Wind Harps

Yonkers, NY

664.

Julie Clarke

Cairo, Egypt

665.

andrea morandi

Genova, Italy

666.

Jo Daniels

Bristol, United Kingdom

667.

Christina Kemp

Chesterfield, MI

668.

Joel de Lieme

Wettingen, Switzerland

669.

Virginie Lavisse

Saint Doulchard, France

Please free the dolphins! Captivity is cruel.

This is a sick practice! Please stop the inhumane treatment of our oceanic friends!

Être enfermé, c’est ne plus pouvoir vivre une vie décente. La captivité est incompatible avec la satisfaction des besoins naturels du dauphin. Dans l’océan, il chasse et peut parcourir des centaines de kilomètres par jour. Dans les delphinariums, il mange du poisson mort et tourne en (continues on next page)

Page 27

-

Signatures 648 - 669

Name

From

Comments

669.

Virginie Lavisse

Saint Doulchard, France

(continued from previous page)

670.

Mohamed EL-Shafei Mohamed

6 octobre`, Egypt

671.

Alice Denford

London, United Kingdom

672.

Michelle Devlin

New York, NY

673.

Dawn Wheeler

Wheeling, IL

674.

Lisa Koehl

Brooklyn, CT

675.

Maria Rosaria Ciano

Bari, Italy

676.

Barbara Mindermann

Marseille, France

677.

Debbie Prodger

Eastbourne, United Kingdom

678.

Danielle Hawley

South River, NJ

679.

Kim Jett

Los Angeles, CA

680.

Linda Reese

Fremont, CA

681.

Hanna Mai

München, Germany

682.

George Rix

London, United Kingdom

683.

bary olivier

vandoeuvre, France

684.

Burghild Wiget

Wädenswil, Switzerland

685.

Nicola O'Brien

Nottingham, United Kingdom

686.

Kate Marler

Coulsdon, United Kingdom

Its a shame in a country doing so much to conserve its coastal enviroment, it allows such a backwards step of a dolphinarium.

687.

ANNIE SIMMONDS

essex, United Kingdom

all of us have a duty of care for our planet and all creatures who live on it, and more than anything else we need to protect our oceans and the sealife that dwells there, so come on people time to wake up and save our planet.

688.

Terri Jones

Baltlimore, MD

Page 28

rond dans son bassin. Son dressage et ses conditions de vie finissent par le détruire ; le dauphin captif devient fou

Please, there is no need to be so cruel.

These creatures are far too intelligent for us too simply be taking advantage of them for entertainment!

une seule chose à dire: "horrible " c'est impensable de voir ca meme de le pensée, j'en ai vu un dauphin dans l'eau (dans la rade de BREST FRANCE en liberté ) que du bonheur pour moi. le fait de vivre quelques minutes avec un dauphin. Et lui, libre de partir ou de rester rien de mieux.

-

Signatures 669 - 688

Name

From

Comments

689.

enisty fahmy

winnipeg, Canada

appalling that people would treat such beautiful and gentle creatures this way

690.

Bella Rose

Brooklyn, NY

691.

jesi hokit

tempe, AZ

692.

renee washburn

Los Angeles, CA

693.

Liva Kjærulff

kbh v, Denmark

694.

Antonio Dominguez

Phoenix, AZ

695.

Rosa Doblas

Málaga, Spain

696.

Irene Nashed

Cairo, Egypt

697.

caroline raward

Georges Hall, Australia

698.

Kena Longabaugh Bellingham, WA

699.

Roxanne Coryell

Mishawaka, IN

700.

Cris Botao

Porto Alegre, Brazil

701.

Miranda van der Linde

Kaikoura, New Zealand

702.

Courtney Rivera

Tacoma, WA

703.

David DJD

Lockport, NY

704.

Malvina Berguglian

Montreuil, France

705.

Anna Carla Perrone

Hurghada, Egypt

706.

Susan Taylor

FARNHAM, United Kingdom

707.

pozzer rossella

rovereto (tn), Italy

708.

MANDY RADZANOWSKI

hurghada, Egypt

709.

jeanette underwood

bedford, United Kingdom

710.

Sonia Silva

Almada, Portugal

711.

Lynn Johanson

New Port Richey, FL

712.

wendy allyn

Oxnard, CA

713.

Jennifer Jake

Cheshire, United Kingdom Page 29

Enough with the money lust people! wake up & listen to your consciences! you're killing the smartest, gentlest, most amazing of God's creatures :-( They belong to the wild & nothing else.

It is ashamed to act in this way with the doplphins that are friends of humain being from alot of centuryes ago. They are so clever and we make them soffer in prison to let children see a very bad lesson of life . This is not educational for a civil population.

-

Signatures 689 - 713

Name

From

Comments

714.

Marlene Lochkrin

Delta, Canada

715.

holly crawford

perry hall, MD

716.

Jeanice Barcelo

Kihei, HI

717.

MANTOVANI Frederic

NICE, France

718.

james donney

Eastlake, CA

719.

Ty Robbins

Santa Barbara, CA

720.

Calista Harrison

Buckeye, AZ

721.

grisard sophie

menetou salon, France

722.

Kadyan Naresh

Delhi - India, India

723.

Mona Khalil

Giza, Egypt

724.

Erika Câmara

Chesapeake, VA

725.

Sameh Salama

Cairo, Egypt

726.

Lesley Myburgh

Cusco, Peru

727.

Ahmad Elbadry

cairo, Egypt

728.

Marc Ayres

Hornchurch, United Kingdom

729.

Cristina Galan

West Hempstead, NY

730.

Steve Scarff

Bozeman, MT

731.

Joel Sarver

Coconut Creek, FL

732.

nigel stephens

london, United Kingdom

733.

Debra Rose

Birchington, United Kingdom

734.

sally okail

cairo, Egypt

735.

tim bain

Penzance, Saint Helena

736.

Karen Truitt

Seattle, WA

737.

Watter Al Bahry

Port Said, Egypt

738.

Kim Greene

Preston, GA

739.

linda miller

Mclaren Vale, Australia

Page 30

I don't like this !!! STOP please

This has to end now and immediately, it is not about proper papers and licenses it is about what is appropriate and acceptable and in compliance with animal welfare.

WHEN are humans going to learn? free these beautiful creatures before its too late for them. AND if there IS karma, I hope the captives find themselves in a similar prison.

Please listen to the voices of the people and let these beautiful creatures go free from captivity, show the world how much you really care, we are all watching and waiting.

-

Signatures 714 - 739

Name

From

Comments

740.

Tierschutzverei Straßentiere in Not

Oberhausen, Germany

741.

diana irizarry

lake worth, FL

742.

Gohary Zeyad

Cairo, Egypt

743.

Barbrara Penley

San Ramon, CA

Please do not have these dolphins live in captivity. Have some compassion and set them free as nature intends.

744.

ghida hammoud

beirut, Lebanon

none

745.

Mirella Burgess

Bridgetown, Australia

746.

Jodi Coutu

Olds, Canada

747.

Grace Peters

Edison, NJ

748.

caroline macPherson

Dartmouth, Canada

I have always wanted to visit Eygpt,not to see captive dolphins!. I guess I'll wait to visit your country until you stop the captive dolphin trade.

749.

ronda carter

San Francixco, CA

Captivity is cruel !

750.

joey racano

Los Osos, CA

751.

david watson

Melbourne, Australia

752.

Kelley Wear

Superior, CO

753.

Marion Nolte

Frankfurt, Germany

754.

Juliana Klein

New York, NY

755.

Michael Beasley

Leongatha, Australia

756.

j barnaby

Gilmour, Canada

757.

Olivier Van den Broeck

Brasschaat, Belgium

758.

Jacqueline Borsje

Christchurch, New Zealand

759.

Meagan Morrison

Key West, FL

760.

Georgie Dicks

City Beach, Australia

761.

sebastien vigne

Triuggio, Italy

762.

Lydia Schepers

Zolder, Belgium

763.

Andrea Vanderhoek

Kau, HI

764.

gillian morrison

Edinburgh, United Kingdom

Ridiculous from any nation considering itself progressive. Set standards, rather than lower them.

765.

Rasha Moussa

Cairo, Egypt

stop those unhumane so called ppl

766.

Anita Ritt

Walldorf, Germany

Nobody needs a dolphinarium next to the Red Sea!

Page 31

Free and Save the Dolphins!!!!! It's so disgusting keeping them trapped in a little pool. God Bless The Dolphins!

This is terrible to hold dolphons captive for someones own private pleasure! very disturbing!!

The dolphin drive hunt and the cptivity of these creatures is cruel. Marine Parks must be Stopped! Animals are not Entertainment unless they are human animals!

Dolphins should never be in captivity.. NEVER!!

-

Signatures 740 - 766

Name

From

Comments

767.

nathalie soler

toulon, France

STOP, STOP AND STOP

768.

Beth Milton

Olympia, WA

769.

Soler Stef

Toulon, France

770.

Janet Donovan

Kent, United Kingdom Unbelievable ! I wouldn't want to keep a gold fish in this filthy pool. And dolphins should be in the ocean not in this tiny confinement, this is so cruel, get them out before they die !

771.

Thomas Kaether

Phang Nga, Thailand

772.

mirjana dzuver

Novi Sad, Serbia And Montenegro

773.

Rick Pearson

Austin, TX

774.

angela fazzari

Tucson, AZ

775.

richard wimmer

Kraiburg, Germany

776.

Margo Lenweaver Oneida, NY

777.

eszter dosa

budapest, Hungary

778.

Jessica McGarty

Hurghada, Egypt

Human cruelty and stupidity knows no boundaries.

779.

Konstantina Kanellopoulou

Filiatra, Greece

This is an act of cruelty with no regard for these animals but only to fill the pockets of those involved in these despisable acts. These acts are illegal and justice must be upheld. Law are made to protect those who can not protect themselves.

780.

Betty Habash

Amman, Jordan

781.

Darja tjioe

5019, Netherlands

782.

angela scibetta

montreal, Canada

783.

Holly Allen

Boise, ID

784.

Lina Radzevičiūtė

Vilnius, Lithuania

785.

Martha Siahaan

Jakarta, Indonesia

786.

Maria Cristina Tittaferrante

Buenos Aires, Argentina

787.

Holly Drouillard

Pleasanton, CA

788.

JOSEPH BARNETT

Pensacola, FL

789.

Christopher White wigan, United Kingdom

dolphins shouldnt be in captivity let alone a pool this small

790.

Bärbel Klefenz

Dielheim, Germany

This is very terible!!!I hope they can help them.

791.

PELLISSON CAROLE

YERRES, France

It is a shame to keep dolphins in a swimming pool !!!

Page 32

this is not human, please set them free.

This is TERRIBLE!!!!! I feel so sad...and feel so impotent hearing they do it over and over again!!! They dont have hart!! they have money instead of hart, so they are not able to feel nothing, no love, no compasion. PLEASE STOP CAPTURING DOLPHINS!!!! CLOSE ALL DOLPHINARIOUMS!!!! IT NEEDS AN END!!!

-

Signatures 767 - 791

Name

From

Comments

792.

Maisa Weber

Mainburg, Germany

793.

Celia atkinson

Perth, Australia

794.

Selma Zaghow

cairo, Egypt

795.

Rahul Muralidharan

Chennai, India

796.

Luis Mesquita

Aruba, Aruba

797.

Michel Darnstaedt Peoria, AZ

798.

Jaana Nystrom

799.

Melinda Shepherd Cottonwood, AZ

800.

noel luine

Barcelona, Spain

801.

Angela Heck

Horgen, Switzerland

802.

Sharon O'Dell

Lincoln, United Kingdom

803.

Catherine Xaria Tay

Singapore, Singapore Please Stop facilitating the dolphin trade, so that the cruel dolphins drive will end! Dolphins should not be kept in captivity!

804.

Jessica Neumann

Chandler, AZ

805.

Helmut Halm

Heidelberg, Germany

806.

Matthias Breit

Hurghada, Egypt

807.

Titian Lu

Hsinchu, Taiwan

808.

Fefe morisod

Hurghada, Egypt

809.

Pascale Schampaert

Schelle, Belgium

810.

Starla Cross

Oklahoma City, OK

This is SICK!

811.

Mona Khoury

Beirut, Lebanon

This is horrible. I don't understand how people can enjoy cruelty

812.

Heather Nagy

Hurghada, Egypt

813.

Steve Wallemme

Erquelinnes, Belgium

814.

SL VSL

Sofia, Bulgaria

815.

Christy-belle Smith

Beaverton, OR

816.

Natascha Sedlacek

44, Germany

817.

Jennifer Miles

Milton Keynes, United I feel that if god would have wanted the beautiful animals Kingdom that he so loving created put into captivity he would have never let them be free first. Everyone has the right to

THIS IS A HORROR MOVIE,PLEASE STOP DOLPHIN CAPTIVITY.

Jyvaskyla, Finland

It makes me very said knowing that just a view cilometers away from this aweful pool the perfect place for them would be, please react as humans

Laissez les dans leur milieu naturel et laissez leur le choix de venir nager avec nous si ils en ont envie !!!

STOP IT!!! Let the Dolphins free! Think about somebody do the same with you!

(continues on next page)

Page 33

-

Signatures 792 - 817

Name

From

Comments

817.

Jennifer Miles

Milton Keynes, United (continued from previous page) Kingdom freedom. As human we scream for our rights all the time, then why is it that if we want freedom do we then take it away from other loving animals? This is something I will never understand. If it was born in the wild then it belongs in the wild to live and grow and enjoy life. Please this is wrong. They are not being taken care of properly why would you want them to suffer?

818.

Elcin Tamolcen

Mugla, Turkey

819.

lea valori

Rome, Italy

820.

Alexandra Bulham dongen, Netherlands

821.

mona barakat

822.

Joanne Akiskalian Encinitas, CA

I firmly object to keeping dolphins in captivity, have you not yet seen The Cove?

823.

Volkmar Goeldner Hilterfingen, Switzerland

This is a Shame for the egyptian Government!

824.

Alex Chang'a

Dar es Salaam, Tanzania, United Republic Of

825.

Tracey munro

North shore, New Zealand

826.

Didier Rossi

Waterloo, Belgium

827.

Anne Holmberg

Glumso, Denmark

828.

Sandra Arnoldi

El Gouna, Egypt

829.

Julia Voigt

Erlangen, Germany

830.

Francisco Figueiredo

Labruge, Portugal

831.

Andrea H

Bayreuth, Germany

832.

Sandra VIRGILI

TOULOUSE, France

833.

Burcu Mahmutoğlu

TRNC, Cyprus

834.

Dijana Knezevic

Sarajevo, Bosnia And Herzegovina

835.

Donna-Louise Coggins

Bristol, United Kingdom

836.

pascal gasser

Biel, Switzerland

837.

Lee Hutchison

Cupar, United Kingdom

838.

Nahla hanna

beirut, Lebanon

839.

Gillles Chardon

Geneva, Switzerland

It's so amazing what money are used for! It's alwasy the same old story: enslaving and limiting other living and sentient beings just to show off! Shame on you all!

amman, Jordan

Page 34

Please stop playing with wild life....

-

Signatures 817 - 839

Name

From

Comments

840.

Ria Brantjes

Rotterdam, Netherlands

This is to crasy for words and must stop. This way you don't respect this beautiful animals.

841.

Carine Vandenabeele

Menen, Belgium

842.

Monica Ackermann

Erlinsbach, Switzerland

843.

Valerie LABADENS

TOULOUSE, France

844.

violetta prager

munich, Germany

845.

Carsten Müller

Kürten, Germany

846.

patrizia olivieri

HURGHADA, Egypt

847.

Gwenaëlle LE MENEDEU

YERRES, France

848.

Ronald Blom

Kortgene, Netherlands

849.

fabrice leroy

malancourt la montagne, France

850.

Miriam de Vries

Zürich, Switzerland

851.

MONICA PERONI hurghada, Egypt

This is the world we want to deliver to our kids!!!!!! A mother!

852.

Peter Rijcken

Brasschaat, Belgium

Stop het uitmoorden van dolfijnen

853.

Isabel Rodrigues

Lisbon, Portugal

STOP THESE SADISTIC MONSTERS!!!!!

854.

agata sarci

hurghada, Egypt

855.

Luca Maritan

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

856.

Vo Bu

Bonaire, Netherlands Antilles

857.

valentine drevet-benatti

poitiers, France

858.

Hajo Roozendaal

Farnborough, United Kingdom

859.

Justyna Budych

Owinska, Poland

860.

Heike Taffertshofer

Hurghada, Egypt

Let the dolphins in their natural environment. You have a right to it.

861.

Debra Fear

London, United Kingdom

another example of treating animals as things with no thought of welfare

862.

Karel Bernard

Tallinn, Estonia

863.

Tino Da Silva

somewhere nice, United Kingdom

864.

Milla Erkkilä

Bromma, Sweden Page 35

J'ai simplement été scandalisée de lire cet article ! Il est pour moi hors de question de laisser faire de telles horreurs et je m'engage à mon petit niveau à contribuer à ce que ce projet n'aboutisse pas !

-

Signatures 840 - 864

Name

From

Comments

865.

Jasmin Ebner

Leonberg, Germany

Please stop playing with wild life!!!!

866.

ilona vd heuvel

Helmond, Netherlands

867.

Karym Moustafa

Cairo, Egypt

868.

Michelle Hibberd

London, United Kingdom

869.

Pam Ludgate

Crowborough, United Kingdom

870.

ilonka de molennaar

zierikzee, Netherlands

871.

Chibi Vanwijnsberghe

Gent, Belgium

872.

shereen bashi

Hurghada, Egypt

873.

erwin vermeulen

Veldhoven, Netherlands

874.

Luca Poggesi

Milano, Italy

875.

Linda Bacher

Sebring, FL

876.

Maureen Campbell

Margaret River, Australia

877.

ROUDAIRE fabienne

Lyon, France

878.

Martin Höller

Garsten, Austria

879.

Maria Jaeger

Karlsruhe, Germany

880.

Katja Pittelkau

Emmendingen, Germany

881.

Inge V

Hurghada, Belgium

882.

Toto Freedomdiver

Safaga, Egypt

www.freedom-divers.de

883.

Helene Bouveret

St Christol, France

des dauphins dans une piscine !! les hommes ne savent plus quoi inventer sans se soucier du bien être de l'animal .

884.

Freek Wallaard

Noordeloos, Netherlands

These animals are lovely, and even showing them in captivity wouldn't be the greatest problem for me. But these circumstances are just horrible, STOP THIS!

885.

decaudin caoline

pontoise, France

I desagree about daulphin's captivity because i think it's not a kind of life for them !!!!

886.

Marleen Geudens

Westerlo, Belgium

887.

louis rouaze

el gouna, Egypt

888.

Anika Schupraß

Hamburg, Germany Page 36

Awfull how people can do this to such beautifull animals!!!! They need to be in their own enveirement : THE RED SEA!!!!!!! So stop doing it!!!! Think about the dolfins not for yourself!!!!!

Stop these monsters now!!!

I am STRONGLY AGAISNT dolphinarium development,

-

Signatures 865 - 888

Name

From

Comments

889.

Julia Hohoff

Braunschweig, Germany

890.

Corcodel Anca

El ejido, Spain

891.

Linda Zenou

Paris, France

892.

samy mustafa

Hurghada, Egypt

893.

Robert Pohle

Hameln, Germany

894.

Susanne Abdel Hadi

HERNE, Germany

895.

Manuel Lindenblatt

Münster, Germany

896.

isabel Barros

San Fernando, Argentina

897.

monique lugo

Lafayette, LA

898.

Stefan Pokorny

Munich, Germany

899.

Tony Couto

windsor, Canada

900.

Kamilla Ghars el DIn

Hoogezand, Netherlands

901.

Verena Fischer

Vienna, Austria

902.

veerle van poucke bietigheim, Germany

903.

Pamela Leigh Richards

Sedona, AZ

904.

Ilona Molenaar

Purmerend, Netherlands

905.

Ahmed elazab

hurghada, Egypt

906.

Bertil Saukkoriipi

Kiruna, Sweden

907.

Silke Schild

London, United Kingdom

908.

hushang abadian

tübingen, Germany

909.

Katharina Ehlers

Bremerhaven, Germany

910.

oliver schäfer

kipfenberg, Germany

911.

Tina Blondia

Knesselare, Belgium

912.

Martyn Falkous

Lagos, Portugal

Should you let this scheme go ahead then you should be forever ashamed of yourselves

913.

Daniela Selinski

Berlin, Germany

Stop this!!!!

914.

Thorsten Langhanke

Sachsenheim, Germany

915.

Prinz Lilo

Au, Switzerland

916.

Tarek Khalil

Cairo, Egypt Page 37

Please stop doing it immediately!

I think deserts in Egypt need also water...

Are there no legal measures that could be taken?

OUTRAGEOUS!!! The time for talk and half measures are over. No answers nor questions necessary, simply release these magnificent mammals back into the Ocean where they belong please.

how bad is this :-(

All animals should only live in thier normal habitat -

Signatures 889 - 916

Name

From

Comments

917.

Annette Becker

Stuttgart, Germany

918.

natacha apavou

épinay sur seine, France

919.

Silke Petersen

Mülheim / Ruhr, Germany

920.

Melanie Braun

El Gouna, Egypt

921.

Lia Tseki

London, United Kingdom

922.

Peter Scheibel

Næstved, Denmark

Sick

923.

linda mahmutoglu

girne, Cyprus

shame on such evil human beings !!!

924.

Karen Knowles

Essex, United Kingdom

Let them into the wild

925.

Andrej Vudler

Stuttgart, Germany

926.

Tom Baumann

80999, Germany

927.

zappa naita

toulouse, France

928.

Hannah Hamilton Dutoit

Odense C, Denmark

929.

annamaria cozzi

monza, Italy

930.

Julien MANIGOT

Perrusson, France

931.

Yvonne Kilgour

Auckland, New Zealand

932.

Torsten Flegel

Gotha, Germany

933.

Kristofer Ling

vallakra, Sweden

934.

Helene van der Kogt

Raamsdonksveer, Netherlands

935.

OUAI Dalila

Paris, France

936.

Sylvia Boettger

Idstein, Germany

937.

catherine bovenrade

el Gouna, Egypt

938.

Vicki Dorey

London, United Kingdom

939.

materre julie

Cahors, France

940.

Michelle Hinte

Mesa, AZ

941.

isa spirlet

Huy, Belgium

942.

Hans-Curd Welsch

Barcelona, Spain

Stop this cruelty now!!! This is against the law and against God will for free wild animals!!!

Please stop this! In a country like egypt, which claims to really care about nature and see wildlife, something like this should not be allowed to happen!

this is outrageaous! This is insane....what is mankind coming too.

Dolphins are not born to make shows. Let them free

By allowing this, you are approving a slow death for these poor animals. The area is much too small, and the water quality has already begun to cause harm to them.

Page 38

-

Signatures 917 - 942

Name

From

Comments

943.

Roberta Bown

Colchester Essex, United Kingdom

944.

KAREN COBB

Lancing, United Kingdom

945.

Gabriele Martinec

Dã¼rnkrut, Austria

946.

Karin Kaalverink-Baas

Enschede, Netherlands

947.

Stéphanie Omnes Villeréal, France

948.

marine desprez

bressolles, France

949.

oliver mally

Wagna, Austria

950.

Diana Gil Ochoa

New York, NY

951.

christine pardoe

clacton on sea, United Kingdom

952.

r hart

london, United Kingdom

953.

Doniscia VEYSSIERE

Labourse, France

954.

Edgardo Coronel

Buenos Aires, Argentina

955.

GAULIN Arnaud

CAPBRETON, France

956.

Christoph Nagel

Einhausen, Germany

957.

Tatiana Toelen

Arezzo, Italy

958.

petra DUIVENS

hurghada, Egypt

959.

j kersten

den haag, Netherlands

960.

Melanie Morof

Zurich, Switzerland

961.

Henrike Brandstoetter

Vienna, Austria

962.

Boyan Dimitrov

Burgas, Bulgaria

963.

Nicole Winter

Oberviehbach, Germany

964.

Radostina Dubarova

Burgas, Bulgaria

965.

Carette Plettinck

Tongeren, Belgium

966.

D M Piercey

kent, United Kingdom

967.

Maria Fongaro

Verona, Italy

968.

Norman Sieler

Berlin, Germany

969.

Szilard Kerekes

Budapest, Hungary

Page 39

Absoloute cruelty, let him the so called owner swin in his excrement. Release them NOW

Dolphins = Make friends = Of Happiness = Liberate!!!!!!!!!!! This way they must live.

-

sort it plz

Signatures 943 - 969

Name

From

Comments

970.

Hind Samy

Cairo, Egypt

Please do not allow this to continue, these animals are intelligent and social and cannot be kept successfully in aquariums, it is cruel and unnecessary.Egypt has an appalling public record on animal rights, let's clean this image up now and drag ourselves into the 21st century.

971.

Annette Barsby

Dymchurch, United Kingdom

I have holidayed in Hurghada in 2007. I am strongly against these dolphins being in captivitiy at all, let alone in such bad conditions. Release them back ino the Wild where they belong. They will surely die if left in this tiny dirty pool you have offered in place of a wondeful ocean of pureness.

972.

Karin Zulauf

Münsingen, Switzerland

973.

Dagmar Reger

Saint Hippolyte Du Fort, France

974.

stephanie muller

chatou, France

975.

Birgit Smak

Wismar, Germany

976.

Michael Grail

Abertillery, United Kingdom

977.

Julita Wozny

Sieradz, Poland

978.

sara navarro

Zaragoza, Spain

979.

colin blyth

rainham, United Kingdom

980.

Anna Kozenko

London, United Kingdom

981.

Linda Tew

Chesterfield, VA

982.

Ali Buzzelli

Los Angeles, CA

983.

bounhouret catherine

st orens, France

984.

mariette larsson

Nol, Sweden

985.

Andy Wainwright

Tokyo, Japan

986.

hay olivier

cappel, France

987.

sandy broenimann

hurghada, Egypt

988.

Petra Gad

Hurghada, Egypt

989.

Elke Bojanowski

Hurghada, Egypt

990.

Georg Heiss

Berlin, Germany

991.

marjon phur

Perth, Australia Page 40

Please stop this inhumane process of bringing dolphins from Japan and putting them in pools that are too small and too dirty for them to survive. Let them live their lives untouched by human hands and on their own environments.

-

Signatures 970 - 991

Name

From

Comments

992.

Regula Rieser

Zürich, Switzerland

993.

Julia Ertl

Kirchheim, Germany

994.

Sylvie Guibert

Binningen, Switzerland

995.

PETRA FRIES

EITELBORN, Germany

996.

Christoph Lomberg

Taunusstein, Germany

997.

john Hinton

yarm, United Kingdom

Please stop this cruelty

998.

Alain GRECK

Riviere Pilote, Martinique

Des sanctions sévères doivent être prises à l'encontre de ceux qui se permettent de telles cruautés.

999.

nat Camar

canet en roussillon, France

Ich werde Ägypten erst mal den Rücken kehren.

1,000. Pamela Brossard

Chester, United Kingdom

1,001. jacquet sylvie

Marne, France

1,002. Joerg Werth

Essen, Germany

1,003. Yves TOSCANO

Nice, France

1,004. Irene cooper

Dandenong, Australia

1,005. Mermier Christian

St Julien en Genevois, France

1,006. Beatriz Perez

Alicante, Spain

1,007. marc-etienne despland

Pampigny, Switzerland

1,008. Sven Wippis

Tosterglope, Germany

1,009. Nilden Liljegren

Istanbul, Turkey

1,010. oyku yagci

istanbul, Turkey

1,011. Dawne Buyukkoca

Fethiye, Turkey

1,012. dorothy pipe

atlanta, GA

1,013. Susanne Weber

Worthing, United Kingdom

1,014. Roger Michel

Münsingen, Switzerland

1,015. Tiina Wall

Hurghada, Egypt

1,016. Biggi Ortiz

Wiesbaden, Germany Page 41

Stop wild animals captivity and torture (ultrasound in concrete hurt, all the time)

stop captivity and massacre

Delfine kann man ausreichend im roten Meer sehen. Da braucht man nicht so ein schwachsinniges Delfinarium. WE SHALL FREE ALL CAPIVE DOLPHINS ALL AROUND THE WORLD and raise full awareness to grow bigger, so that the ones who use them for money will economically go down and pay for their cruel acts! LET THEM LIVE WHERE THEY BELONG, IN THE OCEANS!

Stop it now

-

Signatures 992 - 1,016

Name

From

Comments

1,017. Carsten Bues

Bielefeld, Germany

1,018. Mark Dinkel

Salina, KS

These are terrible conditions to keep such intelligent creatures with brains larger thant their captors.

1,019. Elena Izyumskaya Hurghada, Egypt 1,020. Iris Hochstaetter

Erlenbach Zh, Switzerland

1,021. Fiona Robson

Uzumlu, Turkey

1,022. atif hariz

Beirut, Lebanon

How can people enjoy the capture and captivity of glorious creatures and partake in their torture, be it physical or mental. They belong in the wild.

1,023. françoise follain

Paris, France

contre la captivité des dauphins

1,024. Barbara Silvia Calamai

pisa, Italy

1,025. Kate Redman

New Quay, United Kingdom

1,026. Kaat Broecke

Gent, Belgium

1,027. sylvie lemaitre-sidane

Paris, France

1,028. Sean OBrien

stoughton, WI

1,029. Ramy Wafaa

Alexandria, Egypt

1,030. Heiko Braun

Bamberg, Germany

1,031. tony boulton

cradley heath, United Kingdom

This is outrageous, should be criminal!

1,032. mandy clark

Northants, United Kingdom

this is cruelty in a big way ! free them !!!!

1,033. Walt Stearns

Palm Beach Gardens, FL

1,034. Tommy Smillie

Kilwinning, United Kingdom

1,035. Cintia Loewenstein

South Plainfield, NJ

1,036. Greet Eerens

Brussels, Belgium

Let the dolphins live their own life in freedom, stop using them as "things", and for big big money !!!

1,037. Leah Mae Macrohon

Zamboanga, Philippines

Stop using them for selfish entertainment..set them free..

1,038. Hana Vratislavska Popovice, Czech Republic 1,039. Rosie Simpson

Ormskirk, United Kingdom

1,040. Kev Prince

Weymouth, United Kingdom

1,041. Orsolya Levai

Budapest, Hungary Page 42

-

Signatures 1,017 - 1,041

Name

From

Comments

1,042. Amina El Baroudi

Cairo, Egypt

1,043. Clifford Hritz

Philadelphia, PA

1,044. Angela Painter

Chippenham, United Kingdom

1,045. rossana artioli

Gorizia, Italy

1,046. Dee Day

Sunshine Coast, Australia

These are intelligent, social creatures who belong in the wild, not confined in captivity - especially in such poor conditions.

1,047. Daniele Tranchant Castelsarrasin, France 1,048. Marten van Suylekom

oosterhout, Netherlands

1,049. Lanis Loveday Chidel

Tampa, FL

1,050. Valentina Mazzeo

hurghada, Egypt

1,051. Aladin Thaler

Vienna, Austria

1,052. roberta rocco

Pisa, Italy

1,053. ATZ Céline

Montpellier, France

1,054. Julie Menkin

Oslo, Norway

1,055. Randa Mourad

cairo, Egypt

1,056. florence Bourgineau

Montreal, Canada

1,057. Sue Henderson

Manchester, United Kingdom

1,058. John Palmieri

Blounts Creek, NC

1,059. Robert Archell

Leigh on Sea, United Kingdom

1,060. henry anabel

Bayeux, France

1,061. Marie-Eve Glandon

Montreal, Canada

1,062. Renee Lenhard

Milwaukee, WI

1,063. Thomas Stockhammer

Braunau, Austria

1,064. Susan Helke

Amman, Jordan

1,065. Ulrike Verhoeven

Meinerzhagen, Germany Page 43

Please end this madness, and treat these beautiful animals like, well, beautiful animals, and not some property. I hope you will make a compassionate choice. Best Regards, Ali

this is cruel and must be stopped.

I do a lot of business in Egypt associated with the recreational dive trade there, and this situation on these captive dolphins puts Egypt in a bad environmental light. i hope the Egyptian Govenment takes action to return these animals to the wild.

Leave the nature as it is... natural!!!

-

Signatures 1,042 - 1,065

Name

From

Comments

1,066. Sabrina LEVASSEUR

LE HAVRE, France

1,067. Diana Dantas

cascais, Portugal

1,068. Manuela Schneider

München, Germany

1,069. Nicole Graziano

Howard Beach, NY

1,070. Andrey Yanchevsky

Minsk, Belarus

1,071. Christine Cullen

Iver, United Kingdom

1,072. Martina Medeková

Prague, Czech Republic

1,073. Attila Terjéki

tata, Hungary

1,074. jessica fabris

bergkamen, Germany

1,075. Saada Magdy

Cairo, Egypt

1,076. Anna Sherwood

Meshoppen, PA

1,077. Maria Quintas

Esmoriz, Portugal

1,078. Camille FRANCOIS

WITTISHEIM, France

1,079. mike broom

brighton, United Kingdom

1,080. Sheri Gray

Grantham, United Kingdom

1,081. Claudia Waha

Zirndorf, Germany

1,082. Michiel Hoekstra

Haarlem, Netherlands STOP THIS PLEASE!!!!!

1,083. Nicole Möller

q, Germany

1,084. Barbara Graham

Clementsvale, Canada

1,085. vieillard vanessa

villerupt, France

1,086. tracey sparrow

birmingham, United Kingdom

1,087. Sonia Fey

Deroche, Canada

1,088. Laura Hanley

2 Peveril Ave, United Kingdom

Instead direct resources to Marine Potected Areas aiming to conserve and protect high use areas used by Egypts dolphins and limit underwater noise from underwater precussive works during construction.

1,089. Janet Goldie

Port Elizabeth, South Africa

This is outrageous.

Page 44

This is silly and completely unacceptable,we are a country that respects the agreements and regulations. Please release these dolphins right away

Those lovely innocents deserve to live free and safe from their greatest enemy, which would be mankind. Shame on your country for allowing this to happen, please release these beautiful innocents and please do not ever allow this to happen again. The world is watching.

-

Signatures 1,066 - 1,089

Name

From

Comments

1,090. Bourguignon Josiane

Ans, Belgium

1,091. kimberley gibbs

Northampton, United Kingdom

1,092. Bonhomme Lydia

Stembert, Belgium

1,093. tawha barboza

gibsons, Canada

1,094. Hussain Khalafallah

Cairo, Egypt

1,095. Richard Soos

Hemel Hempstead, United Kingdom

1,096. Anja Eckardt

Bremen, Germany

1,097. Janett Kuschmierz

magdeburg, Germany

1,098. faucon-biguet géraldine

Bron, France

1,099. Jennifer Wiegand

Wuppertal, Germany

1,100. Nelly Abgarian

Hurghada, Egypt

1,101. Ashley Mack

Central, SC

1,102. Tanya Chappuis

Gland, Switzerland

1,103. Günter Kleinschmidt

Zwettl, Austria

1,104. christelle lafalize

kain, Belgium

1,105. Abigail Bradley

Meadville, PA

1,106. Joanna Bee

Toronto, Canada

1,107. Natalia Bragina

Fiumicino, Italy

1,108. феевф фвефврефр

сдцс, Bulgaria

1,109. Carole Sarcinello

Mosheim, TN

1,110. Sven Kleibrink

Düsseldorf, Germany

1,111. paulina huguet

frances, Spain

1,112. Dominika Senkowska

Toruń, Poland

1,113. eric robson

mugla, Turkey

1,114. sabrina schmidt

Krummbek, Germany

1,115. carol harary

Tel-aviv, Israel Page 45

Cruel irony that people go to dolphin parks out of love for them. Here we can see the motives of those who create them. What are local authorities doing to stop this? Get them out!

Please set the dolphins free, that are kept in pool in Hurghada, Mobarak region. This is a shame for Red |Sea !!! Thx.

Günter Kleinschmidt

Free the dolphins! Dont bring new dolphins into the captivity!!! They are not home pets, their place is in open ocean!!!!

Stop this cruelty!!!

-

Signatures 1,090 - 1,115

Name

From

Comments

1,116. laura partel

Hurghada, Egypt

1,117. alessandro bonamici

Pisa, AE

1,118. George Martin

Loule, Portugal

1,119. Lauren Browning

Cincinnati, OH

1,120. harlet alexandra

Thouars, France

1,121. vanessa allen

Orpington Kent, United Kingdom

1,122. Magdalena Mazurek

Mississauga, Canada

1,123. Thorsten Fricke

Linden, Germany

1,124. Laetitia Nunny

La Garriga, Spain

1,125. Anna Raciti

milano, Italy

1,126. Melba Weaver

Los Lunas, NM

1,127. chrissy schulz

meerbusch, Germany

1,128. Janette Martindale

Nottingham, United Kingdom

1,129. Klaus Pfurtscheller

Innsbruck, Austria

1,130. Alex Bracey

Bournemouth, United Kingdom

1,131. Frank Bongartz

Solingen, Germany

1,132. carette francoise

st denis, Belgium

1,133. cinzia giannella

Milano, Italy

1,134. momen elmasry

marsa alam, Egypt

1,135. sarah flaten

cambridge, OH

1,136. Angie Tipler

Woodland Park, CO

1,137. stacey emiliou

birmingham, United Kingdom

1,138. Francesca Novello

Pisa, Italy

1,139. Janet Stafford

Readfield, ME

Page 46

Dolphins are intelligent creatures that need to live freely in the open oceans. They do not thrive in captivity. Please rehabilitate these animals to be returned to the ocean where they belong.

Free them

I have gone to a dolphin park to swim with dolphins. I really had no idea of the torture these animals endure. I am trying to really think like these animals and what it would be like to be locked up in a prison, because that's what it is. This is the worst case of marine mammal cruelty i have ever witnessed!

Dolphins around the world should be treasured, not kept in small capitivity. We know from research that they do not do well and get sick and sometimes die in that environment. We need to protect them! -

Signatures 1,116 - 1,139

Name

From

Comments

1,140. Yauheniya Kozlova

Minsk, Belarus

1,141. Caroline Diels

Bornem, Belgium

1,142. Immanuel Stadermann

Zürich, Switzerland

1,143. Colleen Gorman

St. Pete Beach, FL

1,144. denise linden

Cairo, Egypt

1,145. Andrew Petrushenko

Moscow, Russian Federation

1,146. David Gallardo

Provo, Turkmenistan

1,147. james darby

swindon, United Kingdom

Stop this now. It is wrong.

1,148. Dimitris Politis

Athens, Greece

Egypt is one of the favorites holiday and especially diving, destinations for all European people, but such unacceptable actions will force me (and I thing there will allot of people with the same opinion) to refuse to visit again Egypt in the future and prefer other alternative destinations.

1,149. Peter Salzmann

Walperswil, Switzerland

Since years I came to Egypt for Holidays especially for Scuba Diving. As long as Egypt allows any Dolphinariums and keep those and other dolphins in captivity I will not come to Egypt again. As a Dive Instructor I have a big influence to dive tourist, and I will not longer recommend Egypt as a place to go but as a place not to go!!!

1,150. Anatoly Nezhdanov

Khimky, Russian Federation

1,151. stephanie sanchez

nice, France

1,152. Stefan Bachmann

dsfsdfgdsf, Germany

1,153. sabine weissmann

willich, Germany

1,154. Kaspar Spoerri

Zurich, Switzerland

1,155. Gigon Louise

Oupeye, Belgium

1,156. Sandra Mertn

Erftstadt, Germany

1,157. angela caputo

santa croce sull'arno, Italy

1,158. Alicia Tan

Petaling Jaya, Malaysia

1,159. Annie PEYSSON

Pusignan, France

1,160. Reinhard Gaby

Völklingen, Germany Page 47

Please get them out of this hell hole. After having been to Egypt many times in my life, I can assure you - this is the last place on earth they deserve to be.

STOP THIS -- PLEASE

Dolphins will not live longer than when they're in the ocean, that means whoever capture them indirectly killing them.

-

Signatures 1,140 - 1,160

Name

From

Comments

1,161. peneau cedric

la saline, Reunion

1,162. Linda Coman

Berlin Center, OH

1,163. Bridget Gard

Scotch Plains, NJ

1,164. Amanda Fraser

Barrie, Canada

1,165. Berrand Parry

Southwell, United Kingdom

1,166. viviane vanbuggenhout

Brussels, Belgium

1,167. Damien Wallace

Grapevine, TX

1,168. Weronika Łukowicz

Wrocław, Poland

1,169. Ashley Hartley

Brandon, FL

1,170. Ripoll Cécile

Starsbourg, France

1,171. Christine Duts

San Jose Del Cabo, Mexico

1,172. ABADIE FABRICE

GUEUGNON, France

1,173. Per Lundin

Falun, Sweden

1,174. Mary Coon

Alta Loma, CA

1,175. Mohammed Abdullah

Hurghada, Egypt

not fear

1,176. J Potter

Memphis, TN

These creatures share intelligence with us. PLEASE cease your inhumane treatment of them.

1,177. debra fusillo

girard, OH

I can't believe that with all the scientific confirmation on how smart and kind these animals are, that idiots still treat them as they do! Dolphins should be protected in every area of the world!!!

1,178. Angelica Hagen

El Gouna, Egypt

1,179. valery masselot

eyragues, France

1,180. annick maitre

19, France

1,181. cinzia l'innocente

Alba Adriatica Te, Italy

1,182. Pia Ackermann

Walperswil, Switzerland

1,183. vagnoux marie

Sales, France

1,184. Francoise Phipps

Ronchamp, France

1,185. Levente Márton

Szeged, Hungary

1,186. Zuzanna Falkowska

Łódź, Poland Page 48

JOIN THE 21 CENTURY and free this DOLPHINS!!!! TAIJI DOLPHIN SLAUGTHER GOES ON BECAUSE OF HUMANS LIKE YOU!!!!

Insanity

Please stop this cruelty!

S.O.S. DAUPHINS EN DANGER !

shame on japan !

-

Pitiful project - stick with the pyramids!

Signatures 1,161 - 1,186

Name

From

Comments

1,187. Andrea De Windt

Philipsburg, Netherlands Antilles

1,188. Maria Do Carmo Burnay Lencastre

Lisbon, Portugal

1,189. Norbert Köchel

33106, Germany

1,190. martina rofi

Cascina (Pi), Italy

1,191. beche laurent

les avirons, France

1,192. Alexander Vienna, Austria Stromberger-Wissiak

STOP IT! I come to Egypt about 3 times a year for eco diving - having those prisons is a reason not to visit Egypt. STOP IT!

1,193. Tina Garcia

Las Vegas, NV

why are you letting certain people blatantly break the laws that you set forth in your country? please think about the victims...the dolphins that have to live in filth and get diseases so that somebody can watch him do back flips. Please stop contributing to the suffering of dolphins and whales around the world. There is blood on your hands if you do not uphold your laws about dolphin captivity

1,194. Soula Christos

Johannesburg, South Africa

1,195. annamaria vaccari milan, Italy 1,196. Anna d'Albertis

Genova, Italy

Shame and infamy for everyone who allows or supports captive dolphins, including dolphinarium fans.

1,197. Kaitlin Carlson

Papillion, NE

1,198. Ines Vasquez

Caracas, Venezuela

1,199. Susanne Heine

Oberneukirchen, Germany

1,200. lucile angier

Chalons En Champagne, France

1,201. Ann Cawley

Saint Joseph, MO

1,202. Greg Hall

Justin, TX

1,203. Willem Mazerant

Ann, Netherlands

1,204. Lynne Clark

South Uist, United Kingdom

1,205. Marna Bennett

San jose, CA

1,206. anze petric

krsko, Slovenia

1,207. claudia van loosen

Schweinfurt, Germany

1,208. Marion Fromm

Köln, Germany

1,209. Stephi Bodden

Aachen, Germany

1,210. Mohamed Ibrahim Vienna, Austria 1,211. Susanne Rossbach

Dahab, Egypt Page 49

Incredible, how people disturb nature! -

Signatures 1,187 - 1,211

Name

From

Comments

1,212. Jane Southorn-Elliott

Glossop, United Kingdom

1,213. moody elemam

Cairo, Egypt

1,214. Agnieszka Modrzejewska

Warsaw, Poland

1,215. Judy Penna

Holiday, FL

1,216. Natalya Antonova

Manama, Bahrain

1,217. Karisa Bigelow

Thornton, CO

1,218. Nina Ceccarelli

Lyon, France

1,219. lisa mcgill

leicester, United Kingdom

1,220. Anna Somla

Siedlce, Poland

1,221. Attila Szekeres

Budapest, Hungary

1,222. Mana AlMana

Dammam, Saudi Arabia

1,223. Arjan Looij

nieuwe tonge, Netherlands

1,224. Vladimir Arkhipov

Pushchino, Russian Federation

1,225. Ursula NIGMATULINA

Stone Town, Tanzania, United Republic Of

1,226. pasquale RAPILLY

caen, France

1,227. Fani Katrana

Thessaloniki, Greece

1,228. Susan Leacy

Blackburn, United Kingdom

1,229. linda barton

hurghada, Egypt

1,230. Peter Bühl

Hurghada, Egypt

1,231. Marwa Slaeh

cairo, Egypt

1,232. Annick Gerard

Hove, Belgium

1,233. Yasmin O'Dell

Lincoln, United Kingdom

1,234. kim dossche

Tielt, Belgium

1,235. debbie baker

Birmingham, United Kingdom

1,236. Kathleen Engels

München, Germany

1,237. Jacqui Lyons

Chattanooga, TN

1,238. Emma nicholls

UK, United Kingdom Page 50

Dolphins are sentient, intelligent beings. they love humans. harming them in any way is a vicious crime.

STOP dolphin captivity in Egypt!!!

disgusting to treat dolphins this way they should be free to swim the sea

dolphins also have the right to live

-

Signatures 1,212 - 1,238

Name

From

Comments

1,239. Licario Zepeda

Roatan, Honduras

1,240. Becky Bain

Owatonna, MN

1,241. Johan Lisra

Malung, Sweden

1,242. Maria Serrano

seattle, WA

What is wrong with some humans who don't care about animal life and they like to see animals suffer just to get money in exchange. Money will run out eventually but sea life and nature in general will end forever and there be no place for their kids to grow up happy, healthy and they would never get to see how beautiful nature is. Is so fustrating not to be able to stop it.

1,243. Silvana van Engelen

mosta, Malta

We have to stop this illegal cruelty just for our pleasures, this is so traumatic for the mammal let alone being kept in such a small pool, please please stop this and let these creatures enjoy their freedom what they know best to feel alive.

1,244. Susanne Mecke

Sharpsburg, GA

1,245. Michelle Buzas

West Newton, PA

1,246. alina soto

Miami, FL

1,247. Christina Brill

Safaga, Red Sea, Egypt

1,248. Tara Andow

Garfield Heights, OH

1,249. yannis deslandes

St-bruno, Canada

1,250. Roulin Patrick

Châtel-St-Denis, Switzerland

1,251. Steven Rohde

Ostfildern, Germany

1,252. Rebecca Baird

Sanford, FL

1,253. Anders Jarmyr

Motala, Sweden

1,254. Pasquale De Vivo

Quarto (Napoli), Italy

1,255. rita olivieri

olbia, Italy

1,256. Marlene Timm

Hamburg, Germany

1,257. tainguy stéphanie

romilly sur seine, France

1,258. Delliana of the Sea

Manitou Springs, CO

1,259. Kochhan Norbert

Leverkusen, Germany

1,260. Sheila Bynum

Willis, TX

1,261. Heike Fischer

Hasselroth, Germany

Page 51

This is outrageous! These are creatures not money makers! Enough of all of this already!

These wonderful and intelligent mammals belong wild and free in the big blue ocean!

-

Stop this immediately! Let the animals in their natural environment! Do not destroy this world!

Signatures 1,239 - 1,261

Name

From

Comments

1,262. LYNE JULIETTE

SAINT TROPEZ, France

1,263. Manuela Rodrigues

Alpharetta, GA

1,264. Sarah Shashe

Berlin, Germany

1,265. Pellé-Hyvon Gabrielle

Crest, France

1,266. kaja finne

Tofte, Norway

1,267. jill lee

Corvallis, OR

1,268. marisa vandeneynde

antwerp, Belgium

1,269. Anastasia Karagiannidis

Jhb, South Africa

1,270. Erik Brush

Sarasota, FL

1,271. Maretta Malferrari

Milano, Italy

1,272. Susan Goldberg

Chatsworth, CA

1,273. SARA ASHOUR

Cairo, Egypt

1,274. Eszter Kovats

Budapest, Hungary

1,275. Bex Vaughan

Weston, United Kingdom

1,276. Petra Jovy

Troisdorf, Germany

1,277. Andrzej Wilman

Lodz, Poland

1,278. Karin Pesse

Bellach, Switzerland

1,279. flament evelyne

Renescure, France

1,280. Jos Poell

Chignolo D'Isola, Italy

1,281. Raven Bigwood

Charing, United Kingdom

1,282. Nadja Böthin

Baeretswil, Switzerland

1,283. Monique Eban

Berkshire, United Kingdom

1,284. Lawrence Belleni

Glasgow, United Kingdom

1,285. Maria Urrutia

Lapworth, United Kingdom

1,286. Jutta Klein

Karben, Germany

1,287. Julia Serrago

Staten Island, NY

1,288. Gijs Roozendaal

Hurghada, Egypt

1,289. Jerry Cook

Kill Devil Hills, NC

Page 52

Please let these dolphins go free back to where they belong...the open sea...

-

Signatures 1,262 - 1,289

Name

From

Comments

1,290. Bruno Van Gansen

Hurghada, Egypt

let the dolphins free

1,291. Annabella Laws

Torquay, United Kingdom

This barbaric practice has got to stop GLOBALLY! No more taken from the wild and those in captivity should be sent for rehab! not kept in ponds for HUMAN entertainment! May Allah/God visit vengeance on ALL who treat the worlds animals like this!

1,292. Grace Keast

South Perth, Australia You cannot allow the wealthy to think that they can do as the please with no regard for animal welfare. Please use the law to show them they cannot and prosecute those responsible, or should I say irresponsible!?

1,293. Helen King

Zakynthos, Greece

1,294. Christine Melanson Hill

Oshawa, Canada

1,295. Joke de Bruin

Hurghada, Egypt

1,296. jennifer akomo

bruxelles, Belgium

1,297. Aileen O'Brien

River Ridge, LA

1,298. Robert Balcombe

Ely, United Kingdom

1,299. Rosemary Howard

Fairfax, VA

1,300. Marissa Abramovic

Edenton, NC

1,301. sally eldars

elgouna, Egypt

1,302. susana duarte

lisboa, Portugal

1,303. drouel murielle

ste marie aux mines, France

1,304. Phyllis Pipkin

Marietta, GA

1,305. Patrick Kaufman

Portland, OR

Show some compassion for sentient beings...

1,306. Gigi Ridgeway

Private, CA

Free these creatures NOW! The world is watching. Turkey just did it. You can too.

1,307. Kristine von Denffer

Puolanka, Finland

1,308. sylvia gatefield

chelmsford, United Kingdom

1,309. Suzanne Pugh

Hurghada, Egypt

1,310. Roland Ganser

dahab, Egypt

1,311. prodhomme patrick

orgères, France

Wild animals should be appreciated in the wild!

1,312. evalien van't Veen utrecht, Netherlands 1,313. Lilli Lanér

Helsinki, Finland

1,314. R Lopez

Phoenix, AZ Page 53

-

Signatures 1,290 - 1,314

Name

From

Comments

1,315. Constanze Conrad

Marsa Alam, Egypt

1,316. Simon van der Hoek

Harlingen, Netherlands

1,317. Nelson Maureen

uzes, France

1,318. Rose Marie

Kelantan, Malaysia

1,319. Juliane Hollenberg

Hurghada, Egypt

1,320. Itala Wollinjack

Kempten, Germany

1,321. Ann Adams

Hertford, United Kingdom

I was in Hurghada, Egypt in July, and I was so privileged to swim in the Red Sea with free dolphins. It was one of the most amazing experiences of my life. It would be a shame if these dolphins were held captive in any way. It would cause me to never to return to Egypt. The reason I come to Egypt is to experience the life there--not the captivity of the wildlife. I don't stay in the European resorts when I stay there. I stay amongst the Egyptians. Likewise, I want to swim with the native wildlife--that includes the dolphins.

1,322. burger stef

wittenheim, France

honteux

1,323. ALEX PARSONS

seaford, United Kingdom

1,324. Haggag Hassan

Hurghada, Egypt

1,325. Tanja Staudigl

Kleinostheim, Germany

1,326. Nicola Vidovich

London, United Kingdom

1,327. FABIEN TOUBOUL

NICE, France

1,328. Anne Ammerstorfer

Neustrelitz, Germany

1,329. Nicole Valdez

Orange, CA

1,330. Brenda Humbert

Johnson City, NY

1,331. chris van der draai

vlissingen, Netherlands

1,332. Ann Lawlor

Purley, United Kingdom

1,333. Robert Anderson

Ipswich, United Kingdom

1,334. Astrid Bürgers

Hurghada, Egypt

1,335. Ram Man

Chapel Hill, NC

Page 54

unacceptable - i don't know how people can have these kind of ideas... Stop dolphin & whale captivity & slaughter period!!!!!

These dolphins should be returned to the wild where they came from not kept in improper conditions that contravene Egyptian law. Bad news.. don't be bad boys!!!

-

Signatures 1,315 - 1,335

Name

From

Comments

1,336. MARIA EUGENIA GONZALEZ CASTELLANOS

Tlalnepantla Estado De Mexico, Mexico

1,337. lydia tzigane

sharjah, United Arab Emirates

1,338. Nivaldo Petry Filho

Brighton, United Kingdom

1,339. stuart andrews

norwich, United Kingdom

Dolphins are sentient beings, they must be left alone free in the oceans, dolphins like to interact with humans but they need to be free to do so at will in open water

1,340. Kristine Daniels

Ipswich, United Kingdom

Please release these dolphins - they should be swimming free not kept in a swimming pool

1,341. Aurora Johannesson

London, United Kingdom

1,342. ira mushkella

hurghada, Egypt

1,343. Attila Visontao

Weisendorf, Germany

1,344. Joanne Garbutt

North walsham, United Kingdom

1,345. Timo Müller

Bassum, Germany

1,346. Julie Jones

DENBIGHSHIRE, United Kingdom

1,347. Laurel Simms

Port Orange, FL

1,348. sven lebeuf

kontich, Belgium

1,349. tina lynch

merseyside, United Kingdom

disgusting conditions!!

1,350. Patricia Komoroski

StrawPlains, TN

OMG, this is simply atrocious!!!!! SUch horrid conditions, the animals are dying and the humans that put them there have NO shame:(

1,351. Jane Widdison

Sheffield, United Kingdom

please stop ....its just crule......

What an appaling way to treat such intelligent animals. Please let these dolphins go back to where they belong in the wild, and not held in captivity.

1,352. Yannis Karaouzas Athens, Greece 1,353. Sara Shanahan

Littleton, CO

1,354. Corinne MOUNOU

METZ, France

1,355. greetje stevens

kontich, Belgium

1,356. lacourt loic

Amfreville La Mivoie, France

1,357. Lisa Matye

Sheboygan, WI

1,358. Karen Akiskalian

Goleta, CA

1,359. paula kenny

Dublin, Ireland

1,360. jonathan wan

tullinge, Sweden Page 55

Du respect et de l'humanité pour les dauphins!!! Laissez-les en liberté...!!!!

Shut them down forever!!!

-

Signatures 1,336 - 1,360

Name

From

Comments

1,361. L Kooistra

Amersfoort, Netherlands

1,362. Diann Turpin

Nottingham, United Kingdom

1,363. Dirk Krüßmann

Voerde, Germany

1,364. suppin nathalie

St Maime, France

1,365. christel devos

Lichtervelde, Belgium

1,366. Nora Shilo

Richmond Hill, Canada

This is disgusting! How can these 'people' live with themselves. They have no conscience, no love, no concept of who God is, nothing...

STOP DOLPHIN CAPTIVITY AND DOLPHIN SLAUGHTER AROUND THE WORLD!

1,367. Stephanie Wacker Lage, Germany

Dolphins belong free in the red sea, not behind stupid glass !!!!!!!

1,368. Colin Penny

Gyongyos, Hungary

Dear Minister, I'm hoping that you will take note of public opinion and the damaging effect that the ill treatment of dolphins will have on the Egyptian tourism industry and Egypt's status as an animal-caring nation and immediately outlaw such practices. Thank you for your time.

1,369. Amanda Engle

Orlano, FL

As someone who is normally supportive of aquariums, this is disgusting. It is facilities like this which give aquariums and zoos as a whole a bad name. These animals deserve a better life. This is shameful to Egypt as a whole. Please end it before it's too late to save these beautiful creatures.

1,370. Stefanie Tolski

Darmstadt, Germany

1,371. Susan Knowles

Coulsdon, United Kingdom

1,372. Birte Kühnholz

Dallgow-Döberitz, Germany

1,373. lisa fox

lancing, United Kingdom

1,374. charlie f

london, United Kingdom

1,375. Kariam Badawi

Cairo, Egypt

1,376. Gemma Boden

Liverpool, United Kingdom

1,377. Holly Ward

-, United Kingdom

1,378. Kathrin Wohlrab

Dogern, Germany

please set the four dolphins back to the wild where they belong. this is disgusting get it sorted!!!!

1,379. Thompson Marron Denver, CO 1,380. Birgit Fischer

Leipzig, Germany

1,381. beugin jerome

paris, France

1,382. sabine pankau

Braunschweig, Germany

1,383. Monica Kaiser

Edlibach, Switzerland Page 56

-

Signatures 1,361 - 1,383

Name

From

Comments

1,384. Amanda Overton

Sullivan, IN

Quit making money off these mammals and let them live free

1,385. Stefan Matuszynski

Cologne, Germany

1,386. Emily Bliss

Timonium, MD

1,387. klara benes

Kautzen, Austria

1,388. Sabine Giefing

Berndorf, Austria

1,389. Jane Soyturk

fethiye, Turkey

1,390. Orsolya Haas

Budapest, Hungary

1,391. Heidi Schroeder

Bielefeld, Germany

1,392. Jakob leeonoer

detroit, CO

1,393. bruno marchesin

arco di trento, Italy

1,394. Miglena Bozhikova

Plovdiv, Bulgaria

1,395. priya knolbruins

Alkmaar, Netherlands

1,396. Dorota Czerny

Hurghada, Egypt

1,397. kirsty knowles

Worcs, United Kingdom

1,398. Kerri Dobson

Norwich, United Kingdom

1,399. Lesley Allen

Nottingham, United Kingdom

I could not believe what I had read...it is sad how selfish some people are! Just because we are humans does not give us the right to do whatever we want with other animals.

1,400. girot marie-claude lessay, France 1,401. Mireille Müller

Schongau, Switzerland

1,402. Abela Marie

Nice, France

1,403. Stuart Moss

Sherborne, United Kingdom

1,404. Nancy Murawski

Fã¼rstenfeldbruck, Germany

1,405. manuela nusser

Sterzing, Italy

1,406. Yvonne Egan

Blackburn, United Kingdom

1,407. Adrian von Arx

Egerkingen, Switzerland

1,408. Patricia Ho

Los Angeles, CA

Dolphins deserve better

These magnificent animals are not meant to be kept in captivity. The buyer of these dolphins must not be also allowed to buy his way out of punishment. It is completely unnecessary to have to IMPORT dolphins (continues on next page)

Page 57

-

Signatures 1,384 - 1,408

Name

From

Comments

1,408. Patricia Ho

Los Angeles, CA

(continued from previous page)

1,409. Chrissy Sepulveda

Anaheim, CA

1,410. Brigid Cooling

6th October City, Egypt

1,411. Barry Seth

Deerfield, IL

1,412. Alexandra Zinnecker

Hollenbach, Germany

1,413. Raquel Costa

Porto, Portugal

and view them in an oversized aquarium when the Red Sea is full of dolphins that you can view in their natural surroundings! Get those dolphins out of there! Allow them to rejoin nature! People view the Egyptian government badly as it is; letting something like this happen just proves the absolute corruption of money and power here in Egypt. FREE THE DOLPHINS!

1,414. Couthier A-France Bruxelles, Belgium 1,415. toni wales

gateshead/newcastle, these poor things should be in the ocean were they belong United Kingdom not suffering in small pools its a disgrace something needs to be done x

1,416. Jorjan Felder

palestine, TX

1,417. Thomas Zinnecker

Hollenbach, Germany

1,418. Maria Lowe

Hindley, Wigan, United Kingdom

1,419. Maarten van Rouveroy

Amsterdam, Netherlands

1,420. Anja Schroeder

Berlin, Germany

1,421. Waltraud Grassegger

Salzburg, Austria

1,422. Yevgeniy Pakhomov

Dnipropetrovsk, Ukraine

1,423. Tiest van Woerkom

Amsterdam, Netherlands

1,424. Lydia Köhler

Kiel, Germany

1,425. DIANE Symons

Perkasie, PA

1,426. Nastassia Gumuchdjian

New York, NY

1,427. Dietgard Kühnholz

Dallgow-Döberitz, Germany

1,428. monty christiane

La Louviere, Belgium Page 58

"It seems odd that we call our home planet Earth when it is clearly Ocean." - Arthur C. Clarke

Stop this inanimal behaviour NOW...they should swim in the ocean!!!

There is no excuse to tread this wonderful animals like this!

-

Signatures 1,408 - 1,428

Name

From

Comments

1,429. cassandra gann

san diego, CA

1,430. marius hammerich

krefeld, Germany

1,431. Danièle Dolleans

St-fargeau-ponthierry, France

1,432. Ingrid Preuss-Polzin

Geilenkirchen, Germany

1,433. Baumann Eva

Flawil, Switzerland

1,434. nicola kinney

hurghada, Egypt

1,435. Sandra Holliger

Roggenhouse, France

1,436. Leszek Wilk

Lund, Sweden

1,437. Shelley Tresidder

bangor, United Kingdom

1,438. Sara Serras

Lisbon, Portugal

1,439. myriam callot

west vancouver, Canada

1,440. Manuela Kellner

Wettstetten, Germany Be proud of your nature, not of dolphins in prison!Nobody wants to see dolphins suffering. Tourist will not come to Egypt any longer if dolphins are treated so bad.

1,441. Myle Marie

tourcoing, France

laissez les dauphins dans leurs milieu naturel

1,442. Denise Ferguson

Eden, NC

Dolphins are more than just mammals. They are intelligent, loving and joyful beings. To capture and confine them away from their oceanic home is a slow and saddening death. Imagine if you were confined in a jail for a lifetime.

1,443. Gavin Parfitt

Norwich, United Kingdom

1,444. de brabanter michele

mornimont, Belgium

1,445. Epp Bos

Groningen, Netherlands

1,446. Muireann Quigley

Manchester, United Kingdom

1,447. melissa everet

anderson, IN

1,448. Surya Vadde

St.Gallen, Switzerland

it needs to stop

Seeing this image breaks my heart- they need freed!

save the dolphin!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

1,449. christine EMBLAD Nottingham, United Kingdom 1,450. Monika Förster

Rabensburg, Austria

1,451. jane eveland

Solingen, Germany

1,452. joelle coudriou

Paris, France Page 59

-

Signatures 1,429 - 1,452

Name

From

Comments

1,453. Jenni Wyrsta

Lobethal, Sa, Australia

Please stop dolphin captivity. These are intelligent and social creastures and deserve to be free - just like humans.

1,454. Anne Kinkelaar

Simi Valley, CA

1,455. maria montgomery

London, United Kingdom

1,456. angela flandorfer

deruta, Italy

1,457. Danielle Roche

Berkley, MI

They are kept in horrific conditions and they have to be realeased.

1,458. Marina Dornbusch Erkelenz, KY

Stoppen Sie diese tierunwürdige Haltung. Es muss nicht sein dass Delfine in Pools oder Delfinarien gehalten werden

1,459. Brandy Orr

Rockledge, FL

1,460. Catja Sander

22767, Germany

1,461. Natalia Infusino

£óDŸ, Poland

1,462. rachel haddad

pittsburg, PA

1,463. Amber Humphreys

Bath, United Kingdom It is unforgivably cruel to keep creatures who can swim huge distances in a tiny unhygienic pool. Please, do something to release these dolphins before they are permanently blinded or get sick and die.

1,464. Florence Nagel

Saginaw, MI

1,465. Bruno LAVISSE

SAINT DOULCHARD, France

1,466. francoise deleuze

jauche, Belgium

1,467. Susan Wood

Hurghada, Egypt

1,468. Danielle Curtis

Beccles, United Kingdom

What gives humans the right to treat animals the way they do? It is sickening having seen 'The Cove' that this has been allowed to happen in Egypt.

1,469. Paula Santos

Vila Nova de Gaia, Portugal

ANIMALS HAVE FEELINGS AND RIGHTS TOO! PLEASE HELP

1,470. Martine Polain

Hamoir, Belgium

1,471. steve bongo

durham, United Kingdom

1,472. Larry Cato

Wells, ME

1,473. Brigitta Straub

Egg, Switzerland

1,474. Ulla Saure

Hennef, Germany

1,475. beverley watterson

nottingham, United Kingdom

1,476. joao morais

Porto, Portugal

1,477. Bruni Staiger

Sydney, Australia

1,478. Danielle Crosbie

Dublin, Ireland

1,479. kellie payne

Rasmussen, Australia Page 60

please let these creatures swim free in the sea, where they belong

this is so wrong this majestic creatre shoud be free

This is disgraceful. Something must be done! -

Signatures 1,453 - 1,479

Name

From

Comments

1,480. Debby Dobbins

Charlotte, NC

1,481. farge vincent

le chastang, France

1,482. Chelsea Lewis

Holyhead, United Kingdom

1,483. benoit LAURIOZ

Montpellier, France

1,484. Buisseret Françoise

Mons, Belgium

1,485. Elise Triniol

Hericy, France

1,486. Frank Veit

Berlin, Germany

1,487. Nigel Jarvis

Greenhead, United Kingdom

1,488. angelique hermann

fierville bray, France

1,489. Andy Mutter

Neuenkirch, Switzerland

1,490. Liliana Santos

., Portugal

1,491. Reem Mansour

Cairo, Egypt

1,492. Evelyn Rohrbach

Villingen-schwenningen, Germany

1,493. Renee Sheeran

Everett, WA

1,494. Susan Smith

San Jose, CA

1,495. Linda Tomkins

Co Tipperary, Ireland

1,496. vicky roberts

caergeiliog, United Kingdom

1,497. Weber Coryn Ⓥ

Gingen, Germany

This is sickening! These beautiful creatures should be in the wild,there they belong, not in a discraceful captive area like this. Something needs to be done. If a human was kept in thees conditions,it would be a big deal an action would take place immediantly....the dolphins and any other animal should have the same rights.

This is a crime, I firmly object to dolphin captivity!

ARRETEZ L'ESCLAVAGE et L'EXPLOITATION DES ANIMAUX !!!

1,498. Maha AlKhazindar Cairo, Egypt 1,499. Marisa Muskett

Manukau City, New Zealand

1,500. Joelle Petrakian

Beirut, Lebanon

1,501. Manuel Gelsen

Paris, France

1,502. Odette Hernández Guanacaste, Costa Rica 1,503. Youri Van Leynseele

kortrijk, Belgium

Page 61

How would you like to be a prisoner for life ?

-

Signatures 1,480 - 1,503

Name

From

Comments

1,504. Lana Porter

cairo, Egypt

Just sickening. What human beings will not stoop to for a quick buck. You guys really need to go back and read the Koran because this is truly HARAM !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

1,505. David Sharp

Paderborn, Germany

1,506. vanessa Nini

aix en provence, France

1,507. Brittany Royal

Upper Ferntree Gully, Australia

1,508. Andrea Johnson

Scunthorpe, United Kingdom

1,509. Margaret Ross

Oakdale, NY

1,510. renee codsi

San Clemente, CA

1,511. Courtney Schwartz

Puyallup, WA

1,512. barbara clement

Edmonton, Canada

For God's sake pleas act like a HUMAN being.

1,513. Nathan Roche

Bologna, Italy

Dolphin captivity is completely unacceptable, there is no justification, dolphins should not be imprisoned in small tanks, deprived of their freedom and their lives to be exploited, and this is also supporting the Japanese dolphin hunt.

1,514. Omnia Abbas

Cairo, Egypt

1,515. marcia mcphail

Kapaa, HI

YOU WILL SUFFER ...LIKE THESE DOLPHINS ..ONE A MILLION TIMES WORSE !!!!!! AMEN

1,516. Caroline Jacobson

Rolle, Switzerland

How can something like this exist???? i am disgusted totally.............i wish i could have magic and undo and make all those dolphins, whales, sharks etc etc happy forever and ever!!!!!!!!......i hate humans......bad ones.........

1,517. karin leonrd

Westfield, MA

1,518. Kathy Shoemaker

Georgetown, SC

1,519. nancy lepe

guadalajara, Mexico

1,520. Renee Paternoster

Schwenksville, PA

1,521. Joanne Garbato

Webster, NY

1,522. Paula Silva

São Paulo, Brazil

1,523. Lisa Godfroy

Waltham, MA

1,524. Julie Feltner

Dayton, OH

Shame on you for letting this happen! How would you like to live in these conditions?

1,525. Gale Bolduc

Graham, WA

IT IS NOT HUMANA WE ARE HUMAN,

1,526. niya lee

Albuquerque, NM

1,527. Wilfried Niedermayr

Unterengstringen, Switzerland Page 62

-

Signatures 1,504 - 1,527

Name

From

Comments

1,528. magda jichova

usti nad labem, Czech Republic

1,529. Judy Whetton

Higham, United Kingdom

I really cannot understand why the Egyptian government has not already made the keeping of wild dolphins unlawful! It cannot be too difficult can it?

1,530. Ian Clement

Sharm el Sheikh, Egypt

Both the people doing this and the people that then encourgage it by visiting the shows in Sharm and Hurghada should be ashamed of themselves

1,531. Nan Bongiovanni

Carlsbad, CA

1,532. Fabrice CONTI

GAN, France

1,533. Barbara Ginsberg

Santa Cruz, CA

1,534. Verena Vifian

Hurghada, Egypt

1,535. Daisy Penzo

Coconut Creek, FL

1,536. Diana Spencer

Giza, Egypt

no one , and i repeat no one had ever a right to capture a spirit was initially created free.

1,537. Mary Megalli

Highland Park, NJ

Speaking as a resident of Egypt, and worker in nature protection, I find this contravention of Egypt's laws totally unacceptable, and commend HEPCA for taking action.

1,538. Amr ELsawi

Cairo, Egypt

1,539. Peter Schinck

91207, Germany

1,540. Rose Evans

Hurghada, Egypt

1,541. ANDY MOFFAT

STRATHPEFFER, United Kingdom

This is shocking. I expect better of the Egyptians who have one of the oldest civilizations in the world.

1,542. william churcher

exeter, United Kingdom

i AM NOT INTERESTED IN DIVING OFF EGYPT NOW...

1,543. ibrahim ward

hurghada, Egypt

1,544. YASSER SAID

HURGHADA, Egypt

1,545. Rehab El Gindy

Red Sea, Egypt

1,546. Andrea Kriwonosow

Airlie Beach, Australia Stop the dolpinariums keeping these intelligent mammals in captivity..this is outdated,cruel and unnecessary.The world is watching ..stop now.

1,547. Roger Tabet

El Gouna, Egypt

1,548. Laurenz Geihsler

Safaga, Egypt

1,549. Alexander Just

Kehmstedt, Germany

1,550. Dawn Harcom

Bristol, United Kingdom

1,551. dawn zegledi

Deltona, FL

1,552. Puente Laurence

Epagny, France

1,553. Koen Spierings

Morschach, Switzerland Page 63

IT'S AN INCIENT UNCIVILISED BEHAVIOUR STILL EXIST IN THE MODERN WORLD,,

Natural Enviroment is the Sea and not a tank or pool Born free, are we going to let them die in hell?...GET THEM OUT!!!

-

Signatures 1,528 - 1,553

Name

From

Comments

1,554. Laurent Lavoye

Gili Air - Lombok Utara, Indonesia

1,555. regine botrel

Gommenec'h, France

1,556. Tarl gillings

Sittingbourne, United Kingdom

1,557. Moya Rowland

bradford, United Kingdom

1,558. Petra Gramberg

Leer, Germany

1,559. Sylvie Hamon

Chamonix, France

1,560. Isabelle Lacroix

Nanteuil, France

1,561. mike nunya

Auxvasse, MO

1,562. Christian Fritz

El Gouna, Egypt

1,563. Eric BELLOIN

Hurghada, Egypt

1,564. B Barton-Carroll

Else, United Kingdom

Who has the right to subject a creature to such cruelty? Please stop.

1,565. Ingrid Rapson

Sharm El sheikh, Egypt

Free the dolphins they should be in the sea

1,566. Keren Grant

El Gouna, Egypt

1,567. Jan Walsh

Mugla, Turkey

1,568. marc klainer

baisy, Belgium

1,569. Els Waterschoot

Vilvoorde, Belgium

1,570. Ángel Marina Miguel

Palma De Mallorca, Spain

1,571. Ines Hoffmann

Lage, Germany

1,572. adriana poppe

Vlissingen, Netherlands

1,573. rachel lambrech

Audun Le Tiche, France

1,574. steffen mrosek

hurghada, Egypt

1,575. Sarah Sewell

Nottingham, United Kingdom

1,576. marina durante

milano, Italy

1,577. lorraine lewis

northumberland, United Kingdom

1,578. anne edwards

lossiemouth, United Kingdom

Page 64

I am a diver going to Egypt soon. I want my daughter to grow up discovering wildlife, not dolphins in a swimming pool!

Please stop this cruel torture of the dolphins! They should be free in the ocean where they belong!

-

Outrageous that these beautiful creatures are kept in these conditions!

Signatures 1,554 - 1,578

Name

From

Comments

1,579. jan pauwels

Mol, Belgium

I hope this stop I 20 time to Egypte for my holiday Stop paese come never to Egypte This is craesy Gr J.P

1,580. Geoffroy Rivat

Noisy le Grand, France

1,581. amr elfar

port said, Egypt

1,582. lae laethitia

Wetteren, Belgium

1,583. Graeme Irwin

Lisburn, United Kingdom

1,584. xenia gazi

bratislava, Slovakia

1,585. Peter Riesen

Bruetten, Switzerland

1,586. Dominic Hodges

Evesham, United Kingdom

1,587. Julie Leitch

Galashiels, United Kingdom

1,588. Michaela Apfelthaler

Hallein, Austria

1,589. Pamela Piombino

El Ma'adi, Egypt

The laws need to be strengthened to preclude the import of any dolphins and the penalties need to reflect the ugliness and greed of the uncaring people trying to make money from these intelligent animals. How about confiscating the private villa in which the dolphins were kept in such horrible conditions? Take their cars as well. This will continue to happen until there in no monetary incentive to do so or the risks for significant fines and personal property loss do not make it worth doing. I do not need to, "swim with the dolphins" to appreciate their beauty and place in the environment. The Japanese are dreadful when it comes to dolphins and whales. "Scientific" whaling: absolute lies.

1,590. Brian Green

Sheffield, United Kingdom

Horrendous! We must help HEPCA to help these poor creatures and stop this cruelty.

1,591. james mosley

nottingham, United Kingdom

it's illegal so let's stop it now! they have Dolphins in the red sea so why have them in captivity?

1,592. Gabriele F.-Keuerleber

Kohlberg, Germany

dolphins have to be free in the sea

1,593. tinne smits

mechelen, Belgium

this MUST STOP!!!!!

1,594. Rob Davies

Sudbury, United Kingdom

I and 7 of my dive buddies have all agreed not to go to Egypt until this is type of thing doesn't happen again, we used to go 2 or 3 times a year.

Page 65

i don't agree for this pls give us the address to try to help mob 0020122189634

-

Please, please let them go! Why can humans be so cruel to animals? What legitimation do they have? Would anyone of us spend the rest of our life in a cabinet measuring 2x3x6ft?

Signatures 1,579 - 1,594

Name

From

Comments

1,595. Iain Whyte

Kingston Upon Thames, United Kingdom

Disgraceful

1,596. Jens-Peter Wedlich

Rutesheim, Germany

1,597. Andrea Martins

Valencia, Spain

1,598. Eva Lundgren

Norrköping, Sweden

1,599. Ian House

Bicester, United Kingdom

1,600. Ludwig Adorf

Heiligenhau, Germany

1,601. Stefanie Theimer

Hurghada, Egypt

How would you like it!!

1,602. S.I. Petrozavodsk, Schmidhamer-Petrova Russian Federation

As member of GreenPeace and IFAW we advice keep that people in prison.

1,603. Wael Rashad

Hurghada, Egypt

1,604. Anna-Layla Amer

Langenfeld, Germany

1,605. cristiano cesario

milano, Italy

1,606. MARIE-HELENE LE POLES

PLOUHA, France

1,607. Carolina Kuipers

zoeterwoude, Netherlands

1,608. Jo McHugh

Leeds, United Kingdom

1,609. Michael Dürmann

Weinbach, Germany

1,610. Suzy Fraser

New Orleans, LA

1,611. Angelo Dentis

Corbola, Italy

so that this no longer happens

1,612. Johanna Rediers

Lummen, Belgium

Respect animal rights , especially the right of freedom

1,613. Stefan Schwarz

Weissenfels, Germany

1,614. Vitaliy Sokol

Moscow, Russian Federation

freedom for all

1,615. VALERIE MOFFAT

STRATHPEFFER, United Kingdom

Please stop this cruel imprisonment of dolphins

1,616. jan mosley

nottingham, United Kingdom

Having been privileged to swim in the red sea with these magnificent animals i find it disgusting in this day and age that "man" should want to put these highly intelligent creatures in captivity in a criminally small pool. they should be allowed to swim free and interact with "man" WHEN and IF they want to.

1,617. Sven Adamski

boptown, Germany

Page 66

-

Stop the dolphin captivity in Egypt !!! www.Hurghada-Holiday.de

Signatures 1,595 - 1,617

Name

From

Comments

1,618. Ahmed Sherif

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

Keeping animals in captivity under inhuman conditions and in suffering is not acceptable. We should learn to be more civilized and not allow such activities to take place in Egypt. The rest of the world is heading in this direction and so must we (Egyptians). I urge government officials to stop giving permits to such activities. It gives a bad name to Egypt and is bad for responsible tourism. I would also like to point out that Islam is against the torture of animals. Imprisoning animals under such conditions is a form of torture and is against the teachings of Islam. Thank you for listening.

1,619. valerie Masse

Morlaix, France

1,620. Lynzi Leroy

Edinburgh, United Kingdom

1,621. John Sauren

Ittervoort, Netherlands

1,622. michele archbold

Failsworth Manchester, United Kingdom

1,623. Urban Karlsson

Västra Frölunda, Sweden

1,624. DESNOS ANNIE

Bruxelles, Belgium

1,625. Alain Sobol

Brussels, Belgium

1,626. Evgeny Novikov

St-Petersburg, Russian Federation

1,627. Bernd Jauch

Gippf-Oberfrick, Switzerland

1,628. Kurt Amsler

Bandol, France

Be proud of your nature, and not of dolphins in prison!Nobody wants to see dolphins suffering. You'll loose many tourist, expecially divers, because theire are sensible in that matter!!

1,629. Bryce Watson

Melbourne, Australia

to support the inhumane capture and slaughter of these beautiful earthlings is to support the destruction of planet earth as we know it.

1,630. Petra Luthardt

Blankenheim, Germany

1,631. Peter Grønborg

Århus, Denmark

1,632. Sonja Schwaiger

Mürzzuschlag, Austria

1,633. Michelle Sketchley

Plymouth, United Kingdom

1,634. Serge Balev

Krasnodar, Russian Federation

1,635. Peter Overeem

Hurghada, Egypt Page 67

-

Signatures 1,618 - 1,635

Name

From

Comments

1,636. Birgit Derpoorter

Bruges, Belgium

1,637. Luisa Cortellino

Saronno, Italy

1,638. Andrew Kirkland

Sutton Coldfield, United Kingdom

1,639. J White

Tattenhoe, United Kingdom

1,640. jane ayres

ross on Wye, United Kingdom

1,641. Stephen Lewis

St Albans, United Kingdom

Egypt has done wonderful work in conserving the life in the Red Sea, but this tarnishes that image. Dolphinariums are a cruel way of keeping these wonderful creatures, and are a shame on us. I've regularly visited Sharm (and other areas of the Red Sea) to dive and have seen native, free dolphin.

1,642. Katerina Sherman Moscow, Russian Federation

I working on film about Dolphins.Everyone can see it from this evening at www.youtube.com " Dolphins are ouer Famely"

1,643. Philip Medcalf

Manchester, United Kingdom

As someone who regularly holidays in Egypt and loves the country and people very much I feel that allowing dolphinaria to continue to exist brings shame on the country. I am very glad that such places no longer exist in the UK.

1,644. Ulrike Pilz

Kilb, Austria

1,645. Tomoko Nakamura

Kobe, Japan

1,646. Katie Skassis

Bexleyheath, United Kingdom

1,647. Daniela Abdelbar

Cairo, Egypt

1,648. sharon cook

teesside, United Kingdom

1,649. Christiane Nedwed

Hurghada, Egypt

1,650. marlen el khatib

hurghada, Egypt

1,651. Julia Djelia

Hurghada, Egypt

1,652. Dmitry Lanchikhin

Moscow, Russian Federation

1,653. Peter Kennedy

Liverpool, United Kingdom

Born Free, Live Free

Thanks to Hepca for the great work. But the next step: Stop the new dolphinarium, before it starts to work. We saw already, how the owners are acting with the animals. 2. Step, stop the dolphinarium in Sharm. Since 2005 there are reports and everybody can read: What ever could be done wrong, they do it !!

Stop the needless cruelty

1,654. Andrey Bashtanov Donetck, Ukraine 1,655. antonio canales

balsicas, Spain Page 68

-

Signatures 1,636 - 1,655

Name

From

Comments

1,656. Barbara Buchholz

Valensole, France

1,657. Angela Widmer

Herisau, Switzerland

1,658. Nadezda Kuznetsova

Moscow, Russian Federation

1,659. Debbie Sargent

seaford, United Kingdom

1,660. Lydia Wilde

Chester, United Kingdom

1,661. gail dair

Perth, Australia

Stop it !!!!

This is barbarick and they should be put into prison theirselves

1,662. Alexander Zhukov Tula, Russian Federation 1,663. Thomas Ackermann

Zürich, Switzerland

1,664. DAWN BACON

SHARM EL SHEIKH, Egypt

1,665. lance jones

South Ctroydon, United Kingdom

1,666. Andy Johnson

FLEET, United Kingdom

There is absolutely no reason to keep these graceful creatures in captivity, you can go out on a boat and see them in the wild in Egypt & swim witht them.

1,667. clare wilders

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

So sad.. not another Dolphinella.. there are plenty of dolphins wild in the Red Sea, why capture them?

1,668. kelvin knight

london, United Kingdom

Savage display of selfishness . wwwthemagicsnorkel.com

1,669. kast carole

riedseltz, France

1,670. paquet cédric

Nice, France

1,671. Ewelina Pyrek

Crawley, United Kingdom

1,672. Anja Backhaus

31a, Germany

1,673. grosjean audrey

wolfisheim, France

1,674. Janne Diepvens

lommel, Belgium

1,675. Sebastian Schlund

Nuremberg, Germany

1,676. Michaela Marquardt

Huegelsheim, Germany

1,677. Olga Oleynikowa

Moscow, Russian Federation

1,678. James Cardno

edinburgh, United Kingdom

1,679. Nathalie Lecat

Tournai, Belgium

1,680. amir khalil

hurghada, Egypt Page 69

please protect this wonderful animals that we will be able to show them to our grandkids too.

-

Signatures 1,656 - 1,680

Name

From

Comments

1,681. Emma Lloyd

Ramsgate, United Kingdom

1,682. Ola Rashed

Cairo, Egypt

1,683. Kathrin Förstl

Gangkofen, Germany

1,684. Isabella Jewelle Pangini

Macao, Macao

1,685. Michael Dinges

Frechen, Germany

1,686. Antonio Stacca

Munich, Germany

1,687. Hartmut Schwieters

Essen, Germany

1,688. Kerstin Schulz

Swisttal, Germany

1,689. Elke Weisse

Hurghada, Egypt

1,690. Andreas Worsch

ahorn, Germany

1,691. stavroula nika

patrai, Greece

1,692. Walter Zeug

Bietigheim, Germany

1,693. percy mak

hong kong, Hong Kong

1,694. christine Andersson

malmö, Sweden

1,695. Anke Geutjes

Emden, Germany

1,696. ulrich michael dangelmeyer

Ueberlingen, Germany

1,697. Viktoria Belikova

Moscow, Russian Federation

1,698. Zuzana Uzakova

Hurghada, Egypt

1,699. francesco gigliotti

catanzaro, Italy

1,700. patricia swalwell

billingham, United Kingdom

Hope you are successful in putting a stop to having dolphins kept in captivity.

1,701. debbie wright

hopeman, United Kingdom

how can it be legal to keep any creature against its will in a unnatural environment? where are the morals of the people involved, they should really rethink thier actions and try to put themselves in the dolphins place.

1,702. Michael Hellwig

hamburg, Germany

1,704. Rüdiger forster

Bad Salzuflen, Germany

1,705. Laura Storm

Esher, United Kingdom

1,706. Larissa Lehnert

Hannover, Germany

Page 70

I hope we can do samething,im open for everything,if you need help

-

Hören Sie endlich auf Ihre Resourcen zu vernichten! Sie leben von einer intakten Fauna und Flora!!!!!!

Signatures 1,681 - 1,706

Name

From

Comments

1,707. barbara petty

telford, United Kingdom

1,708. Alessia Crociani

Bern, Switzerland

1,709. marek rusinski

toms river, NJ

1,710. Klaudia Pasch

Sonsbeck, Germany

1,711. Mark Hunt

Liss, United Kingdom

1,712. Victoria Cox

London, United Kingdom

1,713. Joanna Smallridge

Horsham, United Kingdom

1,714. Paula Lauper

Lyss, Switzerland

1,715. yann faure

birkirkara, Malta

This is discusting and should be stopped immediately

1,716. Yegana Sattarova dubai, United Arab Emirates 1,717. Edith schmid

Wil, Switzerland

1,718. Sybille Thommen

Arisdorf, Switzerland

1,719. Shawn Santorufo

Sharm, Egypt

The ones who are responsible for this,, just need to look in the mirror, and they will know that this is wrong, and they will know what they need to do. Set the Dolphins Free, so the can live in Peace,,, both, the Dolphins and them.

1,720. sandie stone

Bristol, United Kingdom

You are the worst of all animals!!!

1,721. Rainer Hopf

Feuchtwangen, Germany

1,722. Catherine Bates

Rowlands Castle, United Kingdom

1,723. Susan Nestibo

Melita, Canada

1,724. Claudia Howald

Bertschikon, Switzerland

1,725. L O

Foster City, CA

1,726. Karim Noor

Marsa Alam, Egypt

1,727. Horus Fawzy

Hurghada, Egypt

STOP!!! Wild animals are just that...wild! This is absolutely sickening ....and it is a cruel existence to keep these animals confined! I challenge those who are doing this to lock themselves in a small room for the rest of their lives and see how they feel about that!

Enough madness against wild life

1,728. caroline dehu saiz marsa alam, Egypt 1,729. Helene Bragg

Crete, Greece

1,730. Simon East

Leeds, United Kingdom

1,731. Winfried Rolapp

Eldingen, Germany Page 71

-

Signatures 1,707 - 1,731

Name

From

Comments

1,732. Stephen Tassell

Poole, United Kingdom

1,733. ellie haynes

cornwall, United Kingdom

1,734. Ahmed El Droubi

Hurghada, Egypt

1,735. Jutta Herzog

Stockstadt, Germany

1,736. Bram Bredero

Hurghada, Egypt

1,737. Claire Newman

ross on wye, United Kingdom

1,738. bollen jean

Peer, Belgium

1,739. Faye Wilde

Croydon, United Kingdom

Leave dolphins in the sea where they belong please!

1,740. David McElhoney

Northallerton, United Kingdom

Each year I am responsible for bringing a large amount of tourist income to Egypt. This now stops until these dolphins go free.

1,741. Gunnar Gauert

Österskär, Sweden

1,742. Richy Nevins

hurghada, Egypt

1,743. michaela könig

Ammersbek, Germany

1,744. George Kinias

Scottsdale, AZ

1,745. Andre Kuhn

Berlin, Germany

1,746. Olga Dolgova

Riga, Latvia

1,747. Pamela Day

Evanvsville, IN

1,748. Victoria Morton

Leeds, United Kingdom

1,749. Donna Hughes

Story City, IA

How can you allow this? It is intolerable!

1,750. Linda Phillips

London, United Kingdom

Disgraceful, these people need to be charged with animal cruelty and placed in a proportional cell based on the space all 4 dolpins need to survive in a healthy environment.

1,751. Jane Ritchie

Portlethen, United Kingdom

1,752. Christian Köhler

Büren, Germany

Wir Touristen bringen sehr viel Geld in dieses Land. Touristen und vor allen die Taucher unterstützen keine Tierquälereien! Wenn wir weiterhin ihr Land unterstützen sollen, dann stoppen sie die Delfinarien!!! Es wird sonst der letzte Urlaub bei ihnen sein!!!!

1,753. Roland Mattis

Hurghada, Egypt

STOP dolphin captivity ALL AROUND THE WORLD!!!!

1,754. karen aydin

leicester, United Kingdom Page 72

stop dolphin captivity in Egypt now

i moved to egypt 3 years ago from wales [UK],so i could dive with these amazing mamals,and not to see them in the middle of the desert!!! GOOD WORK,RICHY.

let us free

-

Signatures 1,732 - 1,754

Name

From

Comments

1,755. Elke Kloos

Staig, Germany

1,756. Angela Scholl

Ü-P, Germany

1,757. Louis Perron

Adlikon, Switzerland

1,758. Manfred Schweizer

Bad Wildbad, Germany

1,759. Barbara HOTZ

Vienna, Austria

1,760. michael sieber

remscheid, Germany

1,761. Sarie Roels

assebroek, Belgium

1,762. jacques audrey

hurghada, France

1,763. Victor Spano

München, Germany

1,764. heike hamdane

hurghada, Egypt

i hope we can stop this fast and many people will sign with us

1,765. linda boland

essex, United Kingdom

these beautifull creature should be where they belong , having the freedom they so deserve xx

1,766. Karina Smit

Emden, Egypt

1,767. teresa carver

Plymouth, United Kingdom

please,, this is so not right,, people arent intereted in this anymore,, its cruel..

1,768. Helen Cooke

Northampton, United Kingdom

These creatures are wild animals and should never live in a pool! If you want to see dolphins go and see them out at sea in their own environment.

1,769. dave nail

Croydon, United Kingdom

I'm so glad some thing is being done to save these fine mammals being confined like this

1,770. Yvan Gesquière

hechtel, Belgium

1,771. Sandy MacDonald Kemptville, Canada

Egypt was high on my list of foreign places to visit. But after hearing about this, not anymore!

1,772. Julie oakley

Bristol, United Kingdom

1,773. Noora Assem

garden city, Egypt

1,774. M. dunbar

Leimbach, Switzerland

a painful disgrace. Bar Egypt from having wild animals. e.g. Zoo; Acquarium etc.

1,775. rita paceroni

rome, Italy

the dolphins are of the Seaaaa!!!

1,776. sabine reichelt

Castrop-rauxel, Germany

Unglaublich und nicht zu unterstützen. Bitte helft den Delfinen!

1,777. Juergen Diessner

Ziethen, Germany

1,778. Sharon Reijnders

posterholt, Netherlands

1,779. jochen van lysebettens

sharm el sheikh, Egypt

1,780. Hanne Emmert

96465 Neustadt B. Coburg, Germany

1,781. reynald vercoutre

marck, France Page 73

-

Signatures 1,755 - 1,781

Name

From

Comments

1,782. ghada Ali

Cairo, Egypt

1,783. Milan Nikolić

Kovin, Serbia And Montenegro

1,784. Sabine schleicher

Laaber, Germany

1,785. Sarah Cornelis

Sharm, Egypt

1,786. Faye Macdougall

Anapolis Royal, Canada

1,787. Becki Frost

Bexleyheath, United Kingdom

1,788. Ramy Adel

Hurghada, Egypt

1,789. Tony Menechella

Frankfort, KY

1,790. Pascale Leese

Blankenberge, Belgium

1,791. Luke Pickett

Blacksburg, VA

1,792. Kornelia Schweikart

Lossburg, Germany

1,793. Claudia Weber

Naurath, Germany

1,794. Karen Varndell

Neiafu, Tonga

1,795. Julia Zhidkova

Moscow, Russian Federation

1,796. jocelyn goncalves

Phuket, Thailand

1,797. Walter Ritz

Andernach, Germany

1,798. Thomas Weber

Herford, Germany

1,799. Ruth Rollow

Bastrop, TX

1,800. Holly Smith

London, United Kingdom

1,801. Manfred Zimmermann

Bad Rappenau, Germany

1,802. Helga Hackenbroich

Nörvenich, Germany

1,803. Henrik From

Copenhagen, Denmark

1,804. samantha argent

west sussex, United Kingdom

1,805. Corinne NAON

Grenoble, France

1,806. Stefan Schössel

Weidenberg, Germany

1,807. tasha obrycki

Sandwich, IL

1,808. Andreas Margreiter

Holzkirchen, Germany Page 74

please make this stop,,,its not right

Please stop dolphin captivity!

This animals need to be free!!!

I hate dolphinariums. Keep the dolphins free. You can see a lot of dolphins in the red sea when you like.

-

Signatures 1,782 - 1,808

Name

From

Comments

1,809. Stuart Dunn

Guernsey, United Kingdom

This is abhorrent !!

1,810. Veronica Kneeshaw

Paphos, Cyprus

These beautiful gentle creatures need to be in the open sea not in a tiny swimming pool. It is inhumane.

1,811. Alex Wasef

Croydon, United Kingdom

Keeping animals in captivity for human entertainment should be banned everywhere

1,812. Jean Taylor

Manchester, United Kingdom

What right has any human being for whatever reason to keep beautiful wold creatures as prisoners

1,813. Anna Panteleeva

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

1,814. Thorsten Rauch

Georgenhausen, Germany

1,815. Anastasia Lyakhova

Moscow, Russian Federation

1,816. Andrea Eckert

Saarlouis, Germany

1,817. susan patton

New Bern, NC

1,818. Philipp Kurucz

Chemnitz, Germany

1,819. karine sauvageot

Aillon Le Jeune, France

1,820. Thomas Roie

Langenselbold, Germany

1,821. Uwe Mewes

Hurghada Red sea, Egypt

1,822. Daniel Fritz

Kevelaer, Germany

1,823. Joachim Bahr

Torgau, Germany

1,824. Morag McCall

ILFORD, United Kingdom

1,825. Deb Cannon

Milton Keynes, United Dolphins are WILD, they should STAY that way, not be Kingdom trained to do silly tricks.

1,826. Luke James Donnelly

Thunder Bay, Canada

1,827. Stefan Quero

Buchholz, Germany

1,828. Lord Barber

Bristol, United Kingdom

1,829. paul andrews

harlow, United Kingdom

1,831. Carola Borchert

Hurghada, Egypt

1,832. Henrike Freibüter

Karlsruhe, Germany

1,833. Pia Kissling

Hinterkappelen, Switzerland

1,834. Helga Kaiser

Hurghada, Egypt Page 75

Do the right thing and release the dolphins

-

If this were Humans....

Signatures 1,809 - 1,834

Name

From

Comments

1,835. Martin Bojé

Wuppertal, Germany

1,836. Reem Wassif

Cairo, Egypt

1,837. Joerg Rust

Bad Oeynhausen, Germany

1,838. colin salisbury

flint, United Kingdom

1,839. Jan Richter

Berlin, Germany

1,840. Frank Brindle

Auckland, New Zealand

1,841. tina cuyvers

balen, Belgium

1,842. Chris Gooda

Hurghada, Egypt

1,843. Streit Cornelia

Münsingen, Switzerland

1,844. carole azzam

liege, Belgium

1,845. Lisa Jackson

Essex, United Kingdom

1,846. Ina P. Al Soqauer

Vienna, Austria

1,847. Amr Sharara

Cairo, Egypt

1,848. Artyom Shein

Kempa, Ecuador

1,849. Sophia Jenner

London, United Kingdom

1,850. Graciela Patron Mederos

Leã³n, Spain

1,851. laurence jungers

LUXEMBOURG, Luxembourg

STOP DOLPHINARIUM

1,852. Jeff Walker

Blackpool, United Kingdom

Dolphions belong FREE in the ~~~ SEA~~~

1,853. Barbara Nistler

Vienna, Austria

1,854. Antje Meyer-Giumelli

Suedergellersen, Germany

1,855. Sandra Milic

Nis, Serbia And Montenegro

1,856. Olivia Senninha

Oostende, Belgium

1,857. Susanne Lindström

Hillared, Sweden

1,858. Brian Richards

Gosport, United Kingdom

1,859. Schlicinski Charlotte

Hurghada, Egypt

Page 76

I could see dolphins in the red sea in wildlife. That is where they should live!

Dolphins have not been created to live in captivity! Animal cruelty should be stopped.

I (and my friends and family) visit Egypt regularly. I have property there. I love the country and want it to be a place that many more people will want to visit.

-

Signatures 1,835 - 1,859

Name

From

Comments

1,860. ilona steel

bradford, United Kingdom

1,861. Kai Schnoor

Munich, Germany

1,862. mireille abiad

dekwaneh, Lebanon

1,863. Angela Rudderham

Lower Sackville, Canada

1,864. Tracey Keetley

Nottingham, United Kingdom

1,865. Tonja Fjell

Maryville, TN

1,866. tarek omar

dahab, Egypt

1,867. Petra Jaerling

Cologne, Germany

1,868. Lobna Kabbage

Cairo, Egypt

free the dolphins

1,869. Allison Stewart

Brighton, United Kingdom

Absolutely disgraceful!!!

To allow humans to profit from the suffering of animals, humans or nature should be unacceptable.

1,870. Stefan Habermehl Frankfurt/main, Germany 1,871. Nicola Keenan

hurghada, Egypt

I have been devistated by the horrendous predicament of these poor animals if I had not witnessed it with my own eyes I would have never believed that this wicked and unbelievably stupid thing could have been done by a fellow human being....... You are EVIL and God will not forgive you.Your Greed will be your your downfall on your final day of Judgement at your Gods Call.

1,872. Nonny Mouse

Hertford, United Kingdom

1,873. Ahmed Maher

South Sinai, Egypt

1,874. june hesayne

metn, Lebanon

1,875. eva schneiders

emsdetten, Germany

1,876. Nikos Leventakis

Glasgow, United Kingdom

1,877. Katinka Leiner

oslo, Norway

These beautiful and intelligent animals must be treated with respect and competence, not kept in private pools like this!

1,878. Jose Ramon Fisher Rodriguez

Panorama Thessalonikis, Greece

This is a serious abuse of the dolphins. The owner of this villa should be prosecuted. Dolphins are not to be abused for amusement.

1,879. Mariana Platte

Hannover, Germany

1,880. andrea LARCHER leoben, Austria

bitte helft den wahnsinn zu stoppen

1,881. SARAH YASSIN

HOW CRUEL AND UNHUMANE CAN THIS BE?! FIRST OFF, WHY ON EARTH WOULD ANYONE WANT TO IMPRISON BEAUTIFUL CREATURES LIKE THESE IN WHAT YOU CALL A "DOLPHINARIUM"? NO MATTER

Cairo, Egypt

(continues on next page)

Page 77

-

Signatures 1,860 - 1,881

Name

From

Comments

1,881. SARAH YASSIN

Cairo, Egypt

(continued from previous page)

1,882. elisabeth dimitras

Athens, Greece

1,883. Brigitte Zerbst

Oberlunkhofen, Switzerland

1,884. ella kogel

Dania, FL

1,885. Lesley Hufnagel

Chelmsford, United Kingdom

1,886. Anne Gliemann

Oberasbach, Germany

1,887. kerstin kup

New York, NY

1,888. Siobian Baker

Bham, United Kingdom

1,889. Toni Mitchell

Knoxville, TN

1,890. Rene Galster

Allschwil, Switzerland

1,891. Sandra Platte

Wuppertal, Germany

1,892. Mohamed Abd El Aal

Heliopolis-Cairo, Egypt

WHAT YOUR ANSWERS ARE, THERE WILL BE NO VALID REASONS TO TAKE SUCH ACTIONS. SECOND, THE LEAST YOU CAN DO IS TREAT THEM RIGHT, ATLEAST SPEND SOME MONEY TO PUT THESE TORTURED ANIMALS IN A SUITABLE ENVIRONMENT-NOT A 9MX9M SWIMMING POOL!! WE HAVE DAMAGED ENOUGH IN OUR ENVIRONMENT TO CAUSE DISASTERS IN OUR ENVIRONEMT, DO NOT MAKE IT WORSE!! DOLPHINES ARE NOT MEANT TO BE PUT IN AN AQUARIUM TO BE OBSERVED BY PEOPLE WHILE SUFFERING.

Dolphins are highly intelligent animals. Please consider protecting them.

Stop this tragedie! if you were one of them , would you like to spend you life like this ? or free in the sea ?

1,893. Alona Hurghada, Egypt Voronova-Stutzinger 1,894. Judith Siebenborn the hague, Netherlands

Dolphins belong in the sea and nowhere else!

1,895. Ulrike Rittirsch

Munic, Germany

Stop this buisness with the Dolfins, don`t put them into prison, they need their place for leaving in their natural habitat

1,896. Heinz Plate

Bremen, Germany

1,897. Pat Morin

New Britain, CT

1,898. pavlina miltiadou

Thessaloniki, Greece

1,899. Alicia Sangineti

Alejandro Korn, Buenos Aires, Argentina

1,900. lina el fadel

Caracas, Venezuela Page 78

-

Signatures 1,881 - 1,900

Name

From

Comments

1,901. günter schwellenbach

augustin, Germany

1,902. Jason Bellifemini

Jackson, NJ

1,903. Olga Filonova

Adigea. Enem, Russian Federation

1,904. Helene Hammarberg

Ludvika, Sweden

1,905. QUENIART Brigitte

Ste Anastasie Sur Issole, France

1,906. Beatriz Tur

São Paulo, Brazil

1,907. Arnaud Renard

CINEY, Belgium

1,908. Sandra Eckstein

Heilbronn, Germany

1,909. Sophie Bertrand

Villeurbanne, France

thanks for them (dolphins)

1,910. Jochen Hofmann

V'heim, Germany

stop it !

1,911. Lia Rodriguez

Buenos Aires, Argentina

1,912. Rebecca Noonan

Elgin, IL

1,913. dave zaffiro

bristol, United Kingdom

1,914. Christine Cibula

Tulsa, OK

1,915. elena tripatzi

Rafina Attiki, Greece

1,916. Charissa Allan

Moura, Australia

1,917. ORTMANN MICHEL

EL GOUNA, Egypt

1,918. Lutz Schreckenbach

ansbach, Germany

1,919. Rachel Ivey

Sharm el Sheikh, Egypt

1,920. Matthias Kressin

Dresden, Germany

1,921. kristel van de voorde

borgerhout, Belgium

1,922. Massimo Bidetti

Sharm el Sheikh, Italy

1,923. Jani Klemi

Lahti, Finland

1,924. Paul Krattiger

Baulkham Hills, Australia

1,925. Klaudija Janzelj

Horjul, Slovenia

1,926. reem qahtan

abu dhabi., United Arab Emirates

1,927. Kari Viitanen

Fuengirola, Spain Page 79

Dolphin captivity should be banned worldwide and the killing of dolphins and whales should be banned worldwide. This is absolutely appauling.

Dolphins belong in the sea not in pools

STOP dolphin captivity in Egypt.

-

Signatures 1,901 - 1,927

Name

From

Comments

1,928. Markus Laub

Karlsruhe, Germany

1,929. Helen McGoldrick

Edinburgh, United Kingdom

1,930. THEODORE SPACHIDAKIS

Piraeus, Greece

1,931. Rose Nguyen

Houston, TX

1,932. Holger Ahrens

Mülheim, Germany

1,933. Oana R

Hurghada, Egypt

1,934. kathy sinnaeve

Fentange, Luxembourg

1,935. christopher skrodolies

wremen, Germany

1,936. Marco Ravelli

San Donato Milanese, Italy

1,937. Marc Koch

Fentange, Luxembourg

1,938. phil meyer

Ostwald, France

Live them in peace

1,939. Cherifa Sirry

Cairo, Egypt

What a Shame!!!

1,940. Istvan mOLDOVAN

Targu Mures, Romania

I would like to expres my whole disagreement with the keeping of the dolphins in captivity. High evolved mammals, which can be much superior to humans (understanding the human language, but we do NOT understand their communication form), can not be held in captivity. Inteligent mammals should have the right to live free.

Cetaceans are more intelligent than humans. They don't keep us in captivity for entertainment or slaughter thousands of us for food - leave them in the ocean where they belong!

I live in Egypt, Hurghada and everyday I see the general disregard for animal rights. I have seen the dolphinarium that is under construction, with a capacity of 1500 seats. The travel industry in Hurghada also has to take a stand and not to sign contracts with the dolphinarium for the shows.

just watch the movie THE COVE !!!!!!!!!!!!!

1,941. clement issaevitch SEAFORD (vic), Australia 1,942. jeffrey george

ST, Thailand

1,943. Lilla Tagai

Szeged, Hungary

1,944. roy smeets

6301px, Netherlands

1,945. Elisabeth Bechmann

St. P�lten, Austria

1,946. Sandra Ehm

Marl, Germany

1,947. sabine watel

angoulème, France Page 80

These dont belong a bloody pool ,the ocean is the only finally frontier for these amazing creatures

-

laisser les libres, gardont les paradis intacts Signatures 1,928 - 1,947

Name

From

Comments

1,948. Manuela Cadilek

Zürich, Switzerland

1,949. Sonja Grote

Lünen, Germany

1,950. Uwe Helm

Pulheim, Germany

1,951. Essam H

Cairo, Egypt

1,952. Katrin Lenz

Hohenlockstedt, Germany

1,953. jose martins

johannesburg, South Africa

1,954. Kathrin Treml

Regensburg, Germany

1,955. Jana Koopmann

berlin, Germany

1,956. Federica Angelosante

Avezzano, Italy

1,957. Jay Way

Faro, Portugal

1,958. Jan Vermij

Lopik, Netherlands

1,959. patrizia aruti

rimini, Italy

1,960. Sonja Stiegen

Siegburg, Germany

1,961. Anne Gillardin

Bxl, Belgium

1,962. herman raters

44137 Dortmund, Germany

1,963. Beate Kalllmeyer

Hannover, Germany

1,964. Anna Clavero

Barcelona, Spain

1,965. eva uloth

bad kreuznach, Germany

1,966. Sian Green

Hjhhj, Egypt

1,967. Jamiel Dabbas

Koeln, Germany

1,968. Ralph Van Loo

Maastricht, Netherlands

1,969. froidevaux mary-jose

hurghada, Switzerland

1,970. Richard Hoath

Cairo, Egypt

1,971. Christian Egerer

Wiesbaden, Germany

1,972. William Moodie

Millport, United Kingdom

Stop cruelty to animals

gail the basterds

This is a public disgrace for Egypt.

Get them back where they belong...

The keeping of dolphins in captivity is cruel and unnessesary.

1,973. Veronique Paquet El Gouna, Egypt 1,974. Karin Stocker

Hasselroth, Germany

1,975. karen fox

Penrith, United Kingdom

1,976. Britt Mattsson

Alafors, Sweden Page 81

-

Signatures 1,948 - 1,976

Name

From

Comments

1,977. ferran colubi

barcelona, Spain

1,978. Andre Wolfs

Mönchengladbach, Germany

1,979. Ursula Halbeisen

Palmanova, Spain

1,980. Alfred Baur

rehlingen, Germany

1,981. Dan Mehlqvist

Hurghada, Egypt

1,982. Anne Druppel

Holsbeek, Belgium

1,983. Walter Floth

Klosterneuburg, Austria

1,984. francesca pasotti

Ghent, Belgium

1,985. Jessica Geiger

Frankenthal, Germany

1,986. Linda Magnusson

Copenhagen, Denmark

1,987. Petra Aschauer

Traisen, Austria

STOP!!!!!

1,988. POIGNON Aurelie Nancy, France 1,989. Jens Kipping

Berlin, Germany

1,990. David France

Wrexham, United Kingdom

1,991. Laura Barcroft

Near Fochabers, United Kingdom

1,992. Oberson Esther

Genève, Switzerland

1,993. sandra kaiss

Redlham, Austria

1,994. Anja Mueller

Bern, Switzerland

1,995. Guido Kuckuck

Konstanz, Germany

Beendet endlich diese Quälerei ! ! ! !

1,996. Ralf Hülsmann

Kempen, Germany

To me, it's unbelievable in a Tourist Country

1,997. Ulrike van Koll

Kempen, Germany

1,998. Olaf Dräger

Rathenow, Germany

1,999. Claudia Kafka

Vienna, Austria

2,000. julia bähre

berlin, Germany

2,001. Fadi Greiss

Cairo, Egypt

2,002. Bernd Klien

Altach, Austria

2,003. Pee-Wee Amer

London, United Kingdom

All creatures on this earth should be free. NOT exoplioted for money.

I can't believe that this sort of madness has reached even in Egypt! Why?! And to what extent can displaying dolphins in Hurghada be of interest to visitors or the public?! VERY LITTLE! A pathetic attempt at turning the resort into an American-style Florida-like copy! This has to be stopped! We must get as much support for this cause as possible. These beautiful sea creatures are meant to be free, in their NATURAL HABITAT ONLY! I urge people to support the (continues on next page)

Page 82

-

Signatures 1,977 - 2,003

Name

From

Comments

2,003. Pee-Wee Amer

London, United Kingdom

(continued from previous page)

2,004. Angela Leberfinger

82065, Germany

cause and sign the petition as quickly as possible in order for it to be effective!

2,005. Amanda Croucher Hongkong, Hong Buckingham Kong

This has really got to be stopped ..NOW ...

2,006. Dustin Genter

Essen, Germany

2,007. Sabine Gaertner

Ochtrup, Germany

2,008. Oliver Martens

Hannover, Germany

2,009. mohamed ahmed

giza, Egypt

2,010. Evine Naga

paris, France

2,011. Doreen Hartmann

Zurich, Switzerland

2,012. Frans Eikelboom

Roemerberg, Germany

2,013. Markus Rettinger

Kempten, Germany

2,014. Christian Albers

Bremerhaven, Germany

2,015. Martin Grajcarek

Rosa, Germany

2,016. edwin dolpin

20, Belgium

free all wildlife in prissond by people

2,017. Margit Herb

reichenbach, Germany

stop it now!

2,018. Joonas Oksanen

Lahti, Finland

2,019. Natalie Baker

Dubai, United Arab Emirates

2,020. Sebastian Pilling

Sonneberg, Germany

2,021. Angela Kuepper

Munich, Germany

2,022. Christian O'Connor

grove, United Kingdom

2,023. Angela Gabbert

CLEARWATER, FL

2,024. Johanna Kramer

Gütersloh, Germany

2,025. Michael Adam

Sheffield, United Kingdom

2,026. Sven Schmeisser

Hamburg, Germany

2,027. Daniel Bleher

Hamburg, Germany

2,028. Christoph Franke

Stockach, Germany

2,029. Svetlana Savranskaya

Tomilino, Russian Federation

2,030. Christiane Hummel

Fürstenfeldbruck, Germany Page 83

we have to stop that .

-

stop this immediately please!

Signatures 2,003 - 2,030

Name

From

Comments

2,031. stefanie paulsen

viöl, Germany

2,032. Thomas Römling

Pfaffenhofen, Germany

2,033. tine peter

münchen, Germany

2,034. Brian Weidmann

Freiberg am Neckar, Germany

2,035. Daniela Lehmler

Beckingen, Germany

2,036. Sonja Graesslin

Baldingen, Switzerland

2,037. Asmaa Al Zohairy

Cairo, Egypt

2,038. Stephan Reitz

Köln, Germany

2,039. Frank Hermann

Mechernich, Germany

2,040. Brigitte Garnschroeder

Verl, Germany

STOP MISTREATING THE DOLPHINS!!!!NOW!!!!!!

Not only are the imported dolphins dying a slow death. You should also know that the dolphin hunt in Taiji has started again 4 weeks ago AND not only are 'new' dolphins caught, ALSO dolphins are being slaughtered. We are in Taiji now. We know this for a FACT! I would much like you to come to Taiji and see this for yourself, I think it would make you think twice about giving out permissings to import dolphins. Thank you for your consideration.

In ein Land das soetwas zuläst kann man sicher nicht mit ruhigem Gewissen einen Urlaub verbringen.

2,041. Jasmin Beermann Bevern, Germany 2,042. Joachim Schmidt

Hannover, Germany

2,044. Tanwi Sandelwood

Onbekend, Belgium

2,045. Kris Ysebaert

Antwerpen, Belgium

2,046. Manuel Woehrle

Newington, CT

2,047. Kalin Petrov

Varna, Bulgaria

2,048. soha kabbani

Beirut, Lebanon

2,049. Jason Claus

Hamburg, Germany

2,050. Marcus Sänger

Taucha, Germany

2,051. Michael Mentsches

Leverkusen, Germany

2,052. ROUMIEU VANESSA

TOULOUSE, France

2,053. Georgios Kakomanolis

Berlin, Germany

2,054. silvia gori

/, Italy

2,055. Nils Domrose

Bergisch Gladbach, Germany Page 84

-

Shame on you!

Stop it!

Signatures 2,031 - 2,055

Name

From

Comments

2,056. Andreas Beckmann

Bremen, Germany

2,057. Monika Kunz

Herisau, Switzerland

2,058. Tilo Fissl-Krumteich

Bruchsal, Germany

2,059. Benno Panzenböck

Breitenbach am Inn, Austria

2,060. Steffen Vey

Würzburg, Germany

2,061. Wolfgang Roellin

Steinhausen, Switzerland

2,062. Detlef Plöger

Bochum, Germany

2,063. Pontone Ylenia

acerra( Napoli), Italy

2,064. fiora nielsen

santiago, Chile

2,065. Thomas Kwella

Soltau, Germany

2,066. Ilka Domrose

Bergisch Gladbach, Germany

2,067. Felix Lorenz

Buseck, Germany

2,068. elizabeth catling

sheffeild, United Kingdom

2,069. karin müller

korschenbroich, Germany

2,070. NADIA RIFAAT

Cairo, Egypt

2,071. Simone Palecek

Neuburg, Germany

2,072. Darko Bandur

Vaihingen Riet, Germany

2,073. Maria Pichlmaier

Handenberg, Austria

2,074. hanifa sadek

Cairo, Egypt

2,075. Thomas Pichlmaier

Tamariu, Spain

2,076. Dietmar Rueder

Flensburg, Germany

2,077. günter suttka

wallerfangen, Germany

2,078. A Khan

Münster, Germany

2,079. Anja Bettinger

Schwalbach, Germany Page 85

Stop it!

vorrei vedere 4 persone bloccate in un ascensore per lungo tempo... e poi osservare i loro comportamenti,.. come starebbero?

you f... bastards!

There is the beautiful Red Sea in front of Hurghada, there is the beauty of seeing a dolphin in his freeness swimming among with Diving or Snorcheling Ships, don't allow such a cruelty of dolphins beeing held in this environment, stay to your words of protecting the red sea for all turist and natives, animals and peoples!

Just stop this nonsens !

Es ist immer wieder entsetzlich zu sehen, wie Menschen handeln. Es liegt am Einzelnen dies zu verhindern,KEINER darf wegsehen -

Signatures 2,056 - 2,079

Name

From

Comments

2,080. S. G.

cologne, Germany

2,081. Heike Giese

Köln, Germany

2,082. Steve Mueller

Zuerich, Switzerland

2,083. Oliver Joerg

Coventry, United Kingdom

2,084. Helene Malek

Beirut, Lebanon

What a shame ! Please act the sooner possible

2,085. Katrin Trautwein

Uster, Switzerland

Who is responsible for such inhumane behavior?

2,086. C. Sörgel

Nürnberg, Germany

2,087. Daniela Winter

Mülheim, Germany

2,088. ISABEL GONZALEZ

barcelona, Spain

2,089. Popi Gkikopoulou

St Andrews, United Kingdom

2,090. Roman Züllig

Wetzikon, Switzerland

2,092. Piet Spin

Kerkrade, Netherlands

2,093. Katrin Beck

Dresden, Germany

2,094. Hisham Youssif

Cairo, Egypt

2,095. Nils Wischmeyer

Köln, Germany

2,096. Fiammetta lucchetta

Belo Horizonte, MG, Brazil

2,097. Matthias Weber

Saarbrücken, Germany

2,098. Jana Kratsch

Buseck, Germany

2,099. Elena Schirrmann

Berlin, Germany

2,100. Sarah Raich

Berlin, Germany

2,101. Ulrich Becker

Windeck, Germany

2,102. Josef Lubina

Stadtsteinach, Germany

2,103. kay meurer

wuppertal, Germany

2,104. Lars Kauth

Lahnstein, Germany

2,105. Leonie Stoehr

Mainz, Germany

2,106. Peter Schunk

Polch, Germany

2,107. Alexander Zumdieck

berlin, Germany

Freedom for the dolphins !!!

the earth don't belong to us, we belong to earth

Please sign and share with all your friends

As a diver and biologist and after having a great time snorkeling with wild dolphins in Hurghada, I claim the responsible AND the authorities to stop this animal abuse NOW!!!

2,108. Annekatrin Freese Berlin, Germany Page 86

-

Signatures 2,080 - 2,108

Name

From

Comments

2,109. amy wethington

grapevine, TX

2,110. Jörg Fred Raschbacher

Magdeburg, Germany Das ist so schlecht, dass mir die Worte fehlen. Zeigt diesen Menschen das es Grenzen gibt !!!

2,111. Manfred Matthäi

Zella-Mehlis, Germany

2,112. Ulf Boehnke

Brugg, Switzerland

2,113. Burkhard Döbbelin

Geesthacht, Germany

2,114. Matthias Krammich

Oberursel, Germany

2,115. Eva Prantl

traiskirchen, Austria

stop this now!

Schweinerei!!!

2,116. Angelika Döbbelin Geesthacht, Germany 2,117. Ben Toms

Bristol, United Kingdom

2,118. O. Dürrschmidt

Stuttgart, Germany

2,119. Lagala Antonio

gorgonzola, Italy

2,120. keith bramley

nottingham, United Kingdom

2,121. Mauro Colla

Lentate sul Seveso, Italy

2,122. eugen hellmuth

lampertheim, Germany

2,123. Karina Wiczkowski

Lotte, Germany

2,124. Lisa Provident

Belle Vernon, PA

2,125. Sophie Sigouin

Mont-Tremblant, Canada

2,126. Uwe Blenk

Bamberg, Germany

2,127. johnny krüger

Schemmerhofen, Germany

2,128. Roman Svoboda

MUNICH, Germany

2,129. Cristina Seica

Anadia, Portugal

2,130. Günther Gogol

Cologne, Germany

2,131. Anja Militzer

Hamburg, Germany

2,132. Guido Witt

Elsdorf, Germany

2,133. Claudia Heinemann

Hamburg, Germany

2,134. Sabine Spindler

Regensburg, Germany

2,135. Josef Fuerstauer

Heinsberg, Germany Page 87

get them out

this is unbelievable.. I have been 11x in Egypt and I know the Egyptian People would noct support sucha cruelty! Please stop this right away!

-

that´s a scandal Signatures 2,109 - 2,135

Name

From

Comments

2,136. Michael Laeuppi

Adlikon, Switzerland

Stop This Urgent!!

2,137. Hellmut Ebbert

Gießen, Germany

2,138. Marieke Gelies

Erftstadt, Germany

2,139. Niels Gelies

Erftstadt, Germany

2,140. Dominique ALLARY

Rosselange, France

2,141. Dirk Orth

Kirchheim, Germany

2,142. Sandra Kleinert

Adlikon b. Regensdorf, Switzerland

2,143. Diane Davies

London, United Kingdom

These dolphins are suffering and should be released to their natural environment immediately.

2,144. dulot josiane

Salon De Provence, France

laissez les dauphins tranquille... ce sont des êtres vivant qui méritent de vivre au même tittre que les humains.....

2,145. DAWN DAVIES

Wilmslow, United Kingdom

The inhumanity of people unfortunately never surprises me. We are the most selfish species on the planet, believing everything on earth is here for our convenience. It makes me sick. Stop this cruelty NOW!

2,146. J Williams

Staffordshire, United Kingdom

2,147. Ali El Breashy

Cairo, Egypt

2,148. Andreas Weitz

63814, Germany

2,149. anna zaynard

oooooooo, Austria

2,150. KATHLEEN WISSENZ

Warminster, PA

2,151. Robert Illek

Starnberg, Germany

2,152. Josef Astlinger

St. Johann in Tirol, Austria

2,153. Jan Schütze

Mannheim, Germany

2,154. Sabine Ortner

bruckneudorf, Austria

2,155. Dirk Kalle

Dortmund, Germany

2,156. porez anne

cambrai, France

2,157. miles whetton

matlock, United Kingdom

2,158. Marko Lichtenfels

Zittau, Germany

Stop this now!

2,159. Cathy Clements

Liverpool, United Kingdom

Dolphins are not equipped to deal with life in captivity and their lives are shortened as a result. We must not pay for a half hour of being near them, as when we walk away, their suffering goes on while others make money from their suffering. NO MORE!!

2,160. Efthimios Papadimitriou

Athens, Greece Page 88

-

Stop this torture!

Signatures 2,136 - 2,160

Name

From

Comments

2,161. Joerg G.

Berlin, Germany

2,162. Manfred Pink

Ulmen, Germany

2,164. henry celia

maisons alfort, France

2,165. marica parisini

pordenone, Italy

2,166. Matthias Hertel

Chemnitz, Germany

2,167. Bernd Neeser

Albertshofen, Germany

stop this.!

2,168. Laurence Lejeune Dreux, France 2,169. Joern Schierbaum Hanau, Germany 2,170. Jutta Schäfer

Ebersburg, Germany

2,171. Erwin Sachs

Marl, Germany

2,172. Stephanie Weide

Long Beach, CA

2,173. Liz Mueller

Kronach, Germany

2,174. Abdessalam Diab

Giza, Egypt

2,175. STEPHAN Pascale

charmes sur rhone, France

2,176. Shyheim NEMICHE

LIEVIN, France

It's a shame!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

2,177. Joachim Loeffel

Magstadt, Germany

Stop 'caging' these great creatures, now and world wide. They belong to the sea and not in bath tubs, no matter how big they are. Keeping them in captivity is barbarism.

2,178. Michael Kretschmann

Mittelhof, Germany

2,179. Nicola Selka

,, Germany

2,180. Jürgen Sperr

Kernen, Germany

2,181. Ina Behnken

Lilienthal, Germany

2,182. kelly govan

bexhill on sea, United Kingdom

2,183. Andre Frattino

Gainesville, FL

Cruel and disgusting treatment...this needs to be stopped starting HERE!

2,184. Nicolette Macve

Veliko Turnovo, Bulgaria

I'm continually outraged and shocked at what people do to animals. I am disgusted by this selfishness.

2,185. Andreas Baehr

Erkrath, Germany

2,186. heinrich rau

bad vilbel, Germany

unbelieveable how rotten human beeings can be.

2,187. Robert Scharf

Graz, Austria

Hear your inner Voice and you take the right decision not to do harm on any living species just for Profit !

Page 89

Why you don't improve your eco tourism... you have the most amazing water right in front of you ... THE RED SEA !!! Make promotion about saving the nature not to ruin it.... PLEASE don't let that happen

-

Signatures 2,161 - 2,187

Name

From

Comments

2,188. Angelika Trenkwalder

Garmisch-Partenkirchen, Germany

2,189. Harald Kimmel

Baudenbach, Germany

2,190. Daniela Brzobohata

Ujezd U Brna, Czech Republic

2,191. Marc Witte

Osnabrück, Germany

2,192. Ralf Lauterbach

Neuss, Germany

2,193. joel malraison

SAINT JURE, France

2,195. Stephan Löbbe

Hamm, Germany

2,197. Alexander Ivanov

Moscow, Russian Federation

2,198. mahmoud raouf

cairo, Egypt

2,199. Michael Duss

Hurghada, Egypt

2,200. Elisabeth Cichon

Regelsbrunn, Austria

2,201. Stephan Fröhlich

Eisenstadt, Austria

2,202. Stefan Enders

Schöneck, Germany

2,203. Paolo Riva

inzago, Italy

2,204. Philip Jones

Northwich, United Kingdom

Put those dolphins back! Grrrr.

2,205. Ralle H

Tübingen, Germany

‫اﻠدﻠاﻔﻴﻦ ﻣﺠاﻨﺎ! ﻳﺤﻤﻴﻬﻢ وﻐﻴرﻬﻢ ﻣﻦ اﻠﻤﻘﻴﻤﻴﻦ ﻓﻲ اﻠﺒﺤﺮ‬ ‫اﻠأﺤﻤﺮ! ﻋﻠﻰ ﺧﻠاﻒ ذﻠﻚ وﻨﺤﻦ ﻟﻦ ﻧﻌوﺪ إﻠﻴﻚ‬

2,206. Michael Wischmeyer

Cologne, Germany

2,207. Tilo Wünderlich

Dresden, Germany

2,208. Alexandra Wissel

Brandenburg, Germany

2,209. Stefanie Stern

Berlin, Germany

2,210. Dmitry Melnikov

Rostov on Don, Russian Federation

STOP dolphin captivity in Egypt

2,211. karen williamson

portsmouth, United Kingdom

This is just awful these poor dolphins must be realesed

2,212. Christian Saboth

Moosinning, Germany Eine Sauerrei

2,213. Johann Kleiner

Ihrlerstein, Germany

2,214. ALBERTO SILVA

ALCOBAÇA, Portugal

2,215. anni schnau

stuttgart, Germany

2,216. Bastian Nebenführ

Göteborg, Sweden

2,217. Patrick van Beek

Windeck, Germany

2,218. Anke Dierckx

Lundh, Sweden Page 90

free for dolphin

Stop this dolphin captivity in Egypt !!!

help the Dolphin, give she free and back to the sea !!

-

Incredible

Signatures 2,188 - 2,218

Name

From

Comments

2,219. Paul Osselmann

Falkensee, Germany

2,220. Stefan Zornmüller

Ratingen, Germany

2,221. Tarek Ayad

München, Germany

2,222. Johann Prem

Hurghada, Egypt

2,223. Achim Schunk

Düsseldorf, Germany

2,224. Ulrich Ratsch

Heidelberg, Germany

2,225. Ireen Heinemann

Erfurt, Germany

2,226. Franz Rodler

Passau, Germany

2,227. Uwe Haberkorn

Radebeul, Germany

2,228. Holger Janke

Cologne, Germany

2,229. Phillip Kanonit

Moscow, Russian Federation

2,230. Pascal Kilian

Kaufering, Germany

2,231. Astrid Hummel

DSSiuhdsf, Germany

2,232. Ralf Schifferer

Duesseldorrf, Germany

its a NOT GO

2,233. Ernesto Fumagalli Inzago, Italy 2,234. Claudia Ruch

Strengelbach, Switzerland

2,235. Manfred Biedermann

Memmingen, Germany

2,236. Rudolf Kotnik

Oberwaltersdorf, Austria

2,237. Christian Milbrandt

Weyhausen, Germany

2,238. Meike Gefke

Flensburg, Germany

2,239. Arne Riedel

Fehmarn, Germany

2,240. Tobias Baust

Mannheim, Germany

2,241. Peter Fiechter

Gelterkinden, Switzerland

2,242. Kazuko T. Kjeldsen

Virum, Denmark

2,243. Cindy Weber

16, Germany

2,244. marina colombo

Inzago (MI), Italy

2,245. Udo Bielek

Olbernhau, Germany

2,246. Jelica Roland

Buzet, Croatia

2,247. Sven Gebhard

Chemnitz, Germany

2,248. Rubina K.

Wilhelmshaven, Germany Page 91

-

Stop dolphin captivity in egypt!

dolphins or also other animals in captivity, this is very, very  bad

Signatures 2,219 - 2,248

Name

From

Comments

2,249. chris Saurer

Mäder, Austria

2,250. Tanja Fullin

Flüelen, Switzerland

2,251. Felix Diemerling

Bad Vilbel, Germany

2,252. Alexandra Radtke

Remscheid, Germany

2,253. Kersten Wegner

Aachen, Germany

2,254. Nicole Schmidt

07745, Germany

2,255. Michaela Biedermann

Memmingen, Germany

2,256. Barbara Wolf-Gröninger

Mainz, Germany

2,257. REGINE DENAEGEL

Brussels, Belgium

2,258. Florian Bruhns

Wörrstadt, Germany

2,259. Lara Hill

Brussels, Belgium

Such cruelty disgusts me.

2,260. Ralph Gehrke

Blankenburg/Harz, Germany

Was soll das? Wir kommen um Delphine im Wasser und nicht im Pool zu erleben- STOP DIESE SAUEREI!! Wie krank muß man(n) sein um sowas zu tun!

2,261. Hannah Hh

Happy, TX

2,262. Thomas Frank

Nuremberg, Germany

2,263. Alex Pople

York, United Kingdom

2,264. Bettina Winert

Vienna, Austria

2,265. Sergey Sarychev

Astrakhan, Russian Federation

The torturer of these dolphins needs to be prosecuted!

2,266. Thomas Mersmeyer

Muenster, Germany

Please stop this torture immediately!

2,267. Sabrina Di Renzo

Pisa, Italy

2,268. Hartmut Schmidt

Pullach, Germany

2,269. Manfred Stahlbauer

Bernau, Germany

2,270. Solveig Herzog

Berlin, Germany

2,271. Markus Grduszak

Herne, Germany

2,272. Rainer Eberlberger

Zell An Der Pram, Austria

2,273. Silke Dallmann

Drymen, United Kingdom

2,274. Björn Mayr

Dusseldorf, Germany

2,275. Amir Poorvash

Hamburg, Germany

2,276. bernd seibert

Jever, Germany Page 92

Incredible!!!

Keine Delphine in gefangenschaft

This case should be stopped and a solution is really importent for the animals and for you image in all touristic matters lasst sie frei!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

-

Signatures 2,249 - 2,276

Name

From

Comments

2,277. Carsten Seer

Wittingen, Germany

2,278. Andre Gellert

Duisburg, Germany

2,279. Gergely Terjéki

Tata, Hungary

2,280. Astrid MORDELT

Düsseldiorf, Germany dolphins are proposed to live in freedom/the nature. everyody who wants to see a happy and healthy dolphin should get the chance to do so in the open sea. not in a much to small and furthermore not sufficent surrounding! dolphins are LIVING species! What would you think and how would you behave, if somebody would put you in a cage the rest of your live? In our terms it´s a penalty and called prison!

2,281. Markus Albert

Nürnberg, Germany

2,282. Ismene Dontas

Athens, Greece

2,283. Pension Tiare

Taravao - Tahiti, French Polynesia

2,284. Nana Alyagas

Sankt-Peterburg, Russian Federation

2,285. Walter Tacha

Gmünd, Austria

2,286. Jasmin van de Sand

Darmstadt, Germany

2,287. Jessie Durnin

calgary, Canada

2,288. Crystal Corbin

sioux falls, SD

2,289. Kerstin Milbradt

Rendsburg, Germany

2,290. Katia Beck

Dortmund, Germany

2,291. Martina Spornberger

Munich, Germany

2,292. Karsten Schilke

Sudwalde, Germany

2,293. Klaus Beckers

Braunschweig, Germany

More than horrible!!

2,294. viviane les animaux du monde

Six Fours, France

Ces animaux ont un énorme besoin d'espace, c'est criminel de les enfermer ! LIBEREZ LES !!!!

2,295. Rene Frisch

Schneisingen, Switzerland

2,296. giulia fumagalli

inzago, Italy

2,297. Stefan Beckmann

Muenchen, Germany

2,298. Ralf Albus

sure, Germany

This is absolutely awful!

2,299. Ruslan Tarasenko Düsseldorf, Germany 2,300. Viona Hausmann

Wuppertal, Germany

2,301. Sabine Ostermeier

Munich, Germany

Page 93

No fun people do not justify violence. Look at us our children

This is unbelievable! It should be STOPPED! This is absolutely UNACCEPTABLE!

-

Signatures 2,277 - 2,301

Name

From

Comments

2,302. Odette Hausmann Wuppertal, Germany 2,303. Alina Lahmann

Edemissen, Germany

2,304. Simone Leidig

Offenburg, Germany

2,305. Ingrid Fuerstenau

Duisburg, Germany

2,306. Donna Piland

Boulder Creek, CA

2,307. Moustafa Ezz

Cairo, Egypt

2,308. Chris Kuehr

Krefeld, Germany

2,309. Marc Schaible

Nagold, Germany

2,310. Harald Kummerfeldt

Neu-Ulm, Germany

2,312. Karin Treutlein

Nuernberg, Germany

2,313. Jo Bessems

Spijkenisse, Netherlands

das is so grauenvoll...wie kann man das einem tier nur antun?

Please have pity on these dolphins. Be as kind to them as you can possibly be. they have lost their freedom and the life they have always known. They are very intelligent and caring animals and so please be kind to them. I beg of you. Stop this madness and put the dolphins back to where they belong, the ocean!! I would prefer to see dolphins only when diving in the red sea !!! Please release them immediately !!!! This is torture!

2,314. stéphanie rossenu St Maurice, France 2,315. Tamara Cristalli

Frankfurt/M, Germany

2,316. Harald Meininger

Bremen, Germany

2,317. Sabina Rakusa

Selnica Ob Dravi, Slovenia

2,318. Bernd Schmitt

Oberhaid, Germany

2,319. Barbara Meierhöfer

Neu-Anspach, Germany

2,320. sonia sempere

Tarragona, Spain

2,321. Beate Bauer

Burgthann, Germany

2,322. Jan Timms

Varsity Lakes, Australia

2,323. Michael Heinikel

Schwarzenbruck, Germany

2,324. Thomas Flory

Cologne, Germany

2,325. andy allin

eppelheim, Germany

2,326. Marc De Sutter

Erpe-Mere, Belgium

2,327. Heiko Bielstein

Norderstedt, Germany

2,328. Juliette Roux

La chapelle des marais, France

2,329. Gasser El.Ganayni

Hurghada, Egypt Page 94

Free the dolphins!!!

please stopppp this

Have a HEART -

Signatures 2,302 - 2,329

Name

From

Comments

2,330. Soenke Schulz

Hamburg, Germany

2,331. Andrea Friedrich

70806, Germany

2,332. Christian Sitterlee

Recklinghausen, Germany

2,333. chris meisen

ellijay, GA

2,334. mohamed ezzo

6th of october, Egypt

2,335. Konstantinos Blatzonis

Stuttgart, Germany

2,336. Vanditta Diwakar

Suva, Fiji

2,337. M. Berti

Montreal, Canada

2,338. Francesca Zavanaiu

Norwich, United Kingdom

2,339. Sven Parczany

Rumohr, Germany

2,340. Donna Schlaufman

Chapel Hill, NC

2,341. Anthony Montapert

Ventura, CA

2,342. Lucy Lee Evans

New Canaan, CT

2,343. wendy wimer

Fullerton, CA

2,344. lisa mayfield

oak harbor, WA

2,345. Anja Hauenstein

Ottobrunn, Germany

Don't you people have a soul? That's just brutal and ignorant. Shame on you!

2,346. Sven Seifert

Hamburg, Germany

Time to show people, that you are interested in more, as only in the money, that tourist bring to Egypt.

2,347. Armin Graewe

Muenster, Germany

I always thought Egypts have a sense for the nature. Some don't !!!

2,348. Matthias Ambrosi

Oetz, Austria

2,349. Robert Eggleston

Melbourne, Australia

2,350. Clare Crowhurst

Bedford Park, Australia

2,351. Ralf Grywnow

Capellen, Luxembourg

2,352. Jennifer Lee

Sg, Singapore

2,353. Jürgen Cremer

Troisdorf, Germany

2,354. Sabine Kleine

Blieskastel, Germany

2,355. Sven Heinstein

Mannheim, Germany

2,356. Hans-Ulrich Sickert

Grimma, Germany

Page 95

the owner should live in a guest bathroom..maybe he knows then how they feel

Decandence has no limit anymore.... very sadly...

The world is going to run out of marine wildlife and these countries don't care.

Strong protest, that’s a shame

-

Signatures 2,330 - 2,356

Name 2,357. Norbert Lerchner

From

Comments

Mönchengladbach, Germany

2,358. waleed deep diver horgahda, Egypt

we will fight to the end

2,359. Jutta von Tiedemann

Mönchengladbach, Germany

2,360. Jens Schachtler

berka werra, Germany

2,361. Morena Beckmann

Obertshausen, Germany

2,362. Michael Buber

Mank, Austria

2,363. Richard Groegel

Roth, Germany

2,364. Beate pfau

ketsch, Germany

2,365. Johnny Braun

Luxembourg, Luxembourg

2,366. Stefan Fendt

Memmingen, Germany

2,367. Sven Bretthauer

Langgöns, Germany

2,368. Sandra Mathieu

merzig, Germany

2,369. Dirk Siegmund

Gelsenkirchen, Germany

2,370. Gabi Zwahlen

Bassersdorf, Switzerland

2,371. Milada Mockova

Zlin, Czech Republic

2,372. Till Nordmeyer

Wels, Austria

2,373. Hana Elhattab

potomac, MD

2,374. Thomas Teusch

Munich, Germany

2,375. Bernd Dittmar

Nürnberg, Germany

2,376. DICKON SMITH

london, United Kingdom

2,377. kosmos traveller

Athens, Greece

2,378. Michael Schnipe

Rheine, Germany

Change this ! I will avoid traveling to Egypt until you change this ! Save the dolphins !

2,379. Sandra Kühn

Morsum, Germany

So etwas sollte es heute auf der Welt nicht mehr geben. Es ist traurig das es Menschen gibt die so etwas mit Delphinen noch machen.

2,380. Julia Antonietta Hübner

Rülzheim, Germany

I have no comments for this! It´s a shame!!!!

2,381. Karin Ottmann

Weißenburg, Germany Page 96

Ich kann mir nicht vorstellen, dass es Menschen gibt, denen diese Anblick gefällt. Kein Lebewesen ist gerne eingesperrt.

Pfui.

NO TO DOLPHINS IN CAPTIVITY IN EGYPT! DOLPHINS DESERVE TO LIVE IN THE WILD AND NOT IN A TINY POOL

-

Signatures 2,357 - 2,381

Name

From

Comments

2,382. Mandy O'Neil

Apache Junction, AZ

2,383. melli gassmann

speyer, Germany

2,384. Francisco Ruiz Serrano

murcia, Spain

2,385. Jens Paschke

Potsdam, Germany

2,386. john ruggles

dagenham, United Kingdom

2,387. Ursula Guggenberger

Kritzendorf, Austria

2,388. Sabrina Winistoerfer

Safenwil, Switzerland

2,389. kim lawley

Huthwaite, United Kingdom

2,390. Michael Noske

Raunheim, Germany

2,391. Patrick Kogerer

Blieskastel, Germany

2,392. Ger Kraaijpoel

Wassenaar, Netherlands

2,393. Andreas Lippelt

Berlin, Germany

unglaublich!!!

2,394. Kai Dathe

Berlin, Germany

So etwas ist einfach untragbar! Warum muss Ägypten immer wieder negative Schlagzeilen machen? Auch in Deutschland sind Sie Ägytper negativ aufgefallen mit Ihrem ersten Platz bei Verkehrsverstössen mit Ihren Diplomaten Fahrzeugen. Ich werde meine zukünftigen Urlaube lieber in anderen Ländern unserer Erde verbringen! Kai Dathe

2,395. Garnet Bendig

Wuerzburg, Germany

2,396. Gina Röder

Offenbach am Main, Germany

2,397. Pamela Sodaro

Niederönz, Switzerland

2,398. Cristina Cristache

Bucharest, Romania

2,399. Oliver Geiger

Griesheim, Germany

2,400. Jochen Zander

Weste, Germany

2,401. Ilona Gachot

Eschborn, Germany

2,402. Nina Degelmann

11a, Germany

Please stop this horrible project! It`s so wonderful to see dolphins underwater in their natural environment. We don`t want to look at tortured and ill dolphins in small pools. Pleas stop this madness!!!

2,403. Eugen Blattmann

Niederhasli, Switzerland

STOPT dies Disaster!!!!!!

Page 97

this is just so wrong let these creature roam free

no dolphins should be in captivity

STOP-IT - PLEASE! WE DONT NEED DOLPHINS IN HURGHADA IN POOLS OR DELFINARIUM - WE LOVE DOLPHINS IN THE NATURE - THE RED SEA

-

Signatures 2,382 - 2,403

Name

From

Comments

2,404. Holger Seifert

Essen, Germany

2,405. Sonja Mori

Fichtenau, Germany

2,406. Heiko Wolf

Buchholz, Germany

2,407. Marco Zeizinger

Hainburg, Germany

Please let these Dolphins back to the red sea. This is horrible. Dolphins live in a social community which is not given in this "pool" ! PUT THEM BACK !

2,408. Simone Kotthaus

Solingen, Germany

Free the dolphins

2,409. Michael Timm

Oberhofen, Switzerland

2,410. Gerd Reinprecht

Eisenstadt, Austria

2,411. Sandra Ihmig

Münster, Germany

2,412. Jochen Hohnrath

Solingen, Germany

2,413. Nadia Birkhoff

Kaarst, Germany

2,414. muriel POZZALLO

TOULOUSE, France

2,415. Simone Staak

Groß-Gerau, Germany

2,416. ahmed kamel

Hurghada, Egypt

2,417. Maria Kyriakaki

Nea Smyrni, Greece

2,418. Isabell Cantrell

Bühlertal, Germany

2,419. Jacqueline Waldenberger

Neusäß, Germany

2,420. Ernst-Günter Böhmfeld

Wahrenberg, Germany

2,421. Carsten Schulz

Delbrück, Germany

2,422. janique latty

grandvillard, Switzerland

2,423. Jörg Harperath

Pulheim, Germany

2,424. Marcel Nibbia

Wangen, Switzerland

2,425. giulia gionchetta

milano, Italy

2,426. Marion Dommel

Heilsbronn, Germany

2,427. Holger Kuczinski

Norderstedt, Germany

2,428. sandra eichinger

heilsbronn, Germany Page 98

Stop, at once!! Let the dolphins free!!

So etwas ist einfach untragbar! Warum muss Egypten negative Schlagzeilen machen? Wir kamen nicht nur weil Ihr viel Sand habt! Wir lieben das Land, das Meer und die Menschen, die wir dort kennen gelernt haben bei vielen Urlauben. Wir werden unsere zukuenftigen Urlaube aber lieber in anderen Laendern unserer Erde verbringen in denen man die Mitbewohner auf unserem Planeten – die Tiere mehr schätzt als in Eurem Land!! Ernst-Günter

I will Dolphins only be free!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

-

Signatures 2,404 - 2,428

Name

From

Comments

2,429. Klavdiya Bolkunova

Moscow, Russian Federation

We must help to pure dolphins

2,430. bruna governi

siena, Italy

2,431. Roger Hahn

Neu-anspach, Germany

2,432. Klaus Martin

Lienen, Germany

2,433. Dieter Slawik

Muehlheim, Germany

2,434. Lisa Martin

Lienen, Germany

2,435. YASIN KARAYEL

berlin, Germany

2,436. Dominik Hoffmann

18, Germany

2,437. Lars Thelen

Havixbeck, Germany

2,438. Hanko Spitznas

Winnweiler, Germany

2,439. Anja Demeulenaere

Wetteren, Belgium

2,440. Katja Kalfas

Riegelsberg, Germany

2,441. Line Overdeput

Gent, Belgium

2,442. Nikolas Orelly

Limburgerhof, Germany

2,443. Nikolaus Ettmayr

Röhrmoos, Germany

2,444. Sandra Bos

Krefeld, AE

2,445. Raul Martinez

Liederbach, Germany

2,446. Emma Buck

Norwich, United Kingdom

2,447. Sven Meier

Hannover, Germany

2,448. Katja Zimmermann

Ostfildern, Germany

2,449. Katharina Keiser

Bludenz, Austria

2,450. leen hendrickx

cairo, Belgium Page 99

This is another black day in the hystorie of the Hurghada turism. The 'good' reputation of Hurghada will get hurt a bit more. And if the Egyptian or local coverment in Hurghada will not change the situation I will recommend to all of my diving studends not to visit Egypt at all. this project should stop dolphins belong in the freedom to know, just so, and we love them, they belong to the ocean, where they are at home, not in a pool basin.

Delphine in Freiheit zu erleben ist einfach unbeschreibbar, in Gefangenschaft - egal ob Aquarium oder Minipool - wird den Tieren Ihre Lebenslustige Art entzogen und man sieht nur eine Hülle. Wie würden wir es finden tagein tagaus hinter Glas in einem kleinen Raum zu leben?????

Stop this dispicable, hanous and criminal activity. From now on, all those who participate at this also confined in a house with no toys and distraction!!!!

-

FREE THE DOLPHINS NOW!!!

Signatures 2,429 - 2,450

Name

From

Comments

2,451. Steffen Beyer

Den Haag, Netherlands

If this outrageous situation is not remedied immediately, I will not return to Egypt for vacation, ever, as I had planned.

2,452. Schasa Schmidt

Warendorf, Germany

Unbelievable.

2,453. Igor Baggio

Dettum, Germany

2,454. Marcel Machiels

Echt, Netherlands

2,455. André Kobler

Hergiswil, Switzerland

2,456. Wolf Andreas

dresden, Germany

2,457. Georg D. Strbac

Vienna, Austria

It´s a shame ! ! !

2,458. Philipp Niedermair Hallbergmoos, Germany 2,459. Sven Klosowski

cologne, Germany

2,460. Thomas Hierl

Aschaffenburg, Germany

2,461. Nicole Moy

Biel, Switzerland

2,462. Chris Cyr

Hurghada, Egypt

2,463. Uwe breiting

Buchen, Germany

2,464. Maria Kagelind

Sweden, Sweden

Unbeliviable Crulety......

2,465. Mario Burgemeister

13, Germany

ohne Worte!!!!!

2,466. Katharina Aeckerle

München, Germany

2,467. Roland Aulbach

Hausen, Germany

2,468. Franz Pörtner

Dortmund, Germany

2,469. Niels Reker

Loerzweiler, Germany From a country rich of beautiful sea life and publicly pretending to defend and protect it, I would have expected more responsibility. I'll definitely think twice before going back to Egypt for scuba diving.

2,470. Danny Jost

Leinfelden-Echterdingen, Germany

2,471. martinez olivia

marsa alam, Egypt

2,472. kelly o'donnell

herne bay, United Kingdom

2,473. George Kyriakakis Athens, Greece 2,474. Juergen Sabah

Geiselwind, Germany

2,475. Angie Fritsch

Offenburg, Germany

2,476. Ileana Kempter

Mainz, Germany

2,477. Stephanie Efinger

Frittlingen, Germany Page 100

-

That is unbelievable and should be forbidden. Regards Juergen

Do you want to live in this pool? Signatures 2,451 - 2,477

Name

From

Comments

2,478. Ronny Förster

Horburg-Maßlau, Germany

2,479. Gloria Giacomelli

Pisa, Italy

2,480. Petra Schiller

Düsseldorf, Germany

2,481. Tina Tack

Hamburg, Germany

2,482. Heike Mazzola

Wardenburg, Germany

2,483. M.S. Rotar

Stuttgart, Germany

This must stop!

2,484. Samir Soliman

Frankfurt, Germany

Just imagine you as a human being where locked down in a box where you just can turn from side to side but cut not stand up !! FOR > 3 months!!!! And you dont know why! You would be frighendtry and driving crazy and at one point in time might try to kill yourself! THIS IS WHAT YOU DO TO THIS BEAUTIFUL PLAYFUL creations of GOD!!!

2,485. Mario Neßler

Madrid, Spain

2,486. Katharina Westenberger

Düsseldorf, Germany

2,487. Detlef Raulf

Landshut, Germany

2,488. Sergey Kuznetsov Zarya, Russian Federation

Это безобразие! Дельфины должны быть свободны!

2,489. Jennifer Salbego

Helbra, Germany

2,490. Frank Gregor

Lindlar, AE

2,491. Emma Mackenzie

Farnborough, United Kingdom

2,492. Ingo Scholz

Braunshorn, Germany

2,493. Udo Pfanzelt

Ergolding, Germany

2,494. Yvette Jacob

Dusseldorf, Germany

2,495. Jessica Gasser

Cairo, Egypt

2,496. Hendrik Hustert

Dortmund, Germany

2,497. Thomas Zimmermann

Asslar, Germany

2,498. Bente Kloth

Amsterdam, Netherlands

2,499. Jürg Gysel

Männedorf, Switzerland

2,500. Matthias Lamka

Feuchtwangen, Germany

2,501. Konstantin Korochkin

Tallinn, Estonia Page 101

Please think on you self, will you live in a Prison

Let them free! I travel to Egypt to see animals in their natural habitat. I planned to travel to Hurghada in this autum. I stop this planning until the dolphins get free. Stop dolphin captivity in Egypt!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

This is terrible!!!

-

Signatures 2,478 - 2,501

Name

From

Comments

2,502. Hans Henrich

Bingen, Germany

Give the owners 2 options. Keep the dolphins - and employ two marine biologist and build a big enough aquarium, within the shortest period of time OR in thel likely case that this exceeds their owners financial posibillities, take the dolphins, give them the neccessary medical treatment and release them into a) a professionally controled enviroment or b) back where they belong. The question still remaining: HOW THE HELL DID THEY GET THOSE ANIMALS? IS THERE A CHANCE TO ERASE THIS CHAIN OF SUPPLY TO AVOID THIS TO HAPPEN OVER AND OVER AGAIN?

2,503. J Maes

Oostrozebeke, Belgium

Set these dolphins free, it is stupid to keep them in this pool

2,504. Sven Dreyer

Duisburg, Germany

2,505. Stefan Lüdecke

Berlin, Germany

2,506. victoria gazzard

bristol, United Kingdom

Please stop the cruel practice of keeping dolphins in captivity. They belong free in the sea. Victoria

2,507. Klaus Gerhard

Berlin, Germany

Unverschämtheit, unglaulich

2,508. Ute Bader

Essen, Germany

2,509. Bernhard Fusseder

Fuerstenzell, Germany

2,510. Margit Teske

Berlin, Germany

2,511. Stefan Kneller

Cologne, Germany

2,512. Karin Hadn

Amstetten, Austria

2,513. Sebastian Seip

Karben, Germany

2,514. Nathalie Depuydt

Gent, Belgium

2,515. Fabiana Saporiti

Barcelona, Spain

2,516. Joerg Luedemann Rellingen, Germany 2,517. Brenda Gabriel

Hurghada, Egypt

2,518. Rudolf Steiner

Vienna, Austria

It is a shame and barbaric. The owner of the dolphins schould be kept with them in the same pool. He would change his mind soon.

2,519. Remco Verspaget Amsterdam, Netherlands 2,520. Trudpert Schweikart

3, Germany

2,521. Peter Papadopoulos

Athens, Greece

2,522. Helmut Trappe

Hildesheim, Germany

2,523. Falk Keiner

Dresden, Germany

2,524. Frauke Herbst

Düsseldorf, Germany Page 102

-

Signatures 2,502 - 2,524

Name

From

Comments

2,525. Britta Genz

Arendsee, Germany

2,526. Claus Terjung

Wuppertal, Germany

2,527. Oscar Berkenbosch

London, United Kingdom

2,528. Susann Schumann

Borsdorf, Germany

2,529. Calvin Lee

Singapore, Singapore

2,530. claudia paeck

Berlin, Germany

2,531. gabriele trivellini

palma, Spain

2,532. Carolyn Palmer

Brighton And Hove, United Kingdom

2,533. isabell käser

saarbrücken, Germany

2,534. Dean Wengenroth Groningen, Netherlands 2,535. Stefanie Gellert

Duisburg, Germany

2,536. Björn von Bredow

Nürnberg, Germany

2,537. Peter Hasler

fürstenfeld, Austria

2,538. maha brence

Cairo, Egypt

2,539. Yvonne Quack

Saarbrücken, Germany

2,540. werner rittirsch

nennslingen, Germany

2,541. An De Vijlder

Gent, Belgium

2,542. Cornelia Schulze

Friolzheim, Germany

2,543. Christina Bißdorf

Mannheim, Germany

2,544. Andreas Unnold

St. Ingbert, Germany

2,545. Silke Sanewytsch

Alzenau, Germany

2,546. jona schwarz

Cologne, Germany

2,547. Sabine Lang

Passau, Germany

2,548. samantha hurley

St Leonards On Sea, United Kingdom

2,549. binder tanja

zürich, Switzerland

2,550. Klaus Dieter

Gerlach, Germany

2,551. Nadia A

Cx, France

2,552. Heiko Spieweg

10, Germany

2,553. christine hey

cramlington, United Kingdom

2,554. klaus maucher

augsburg, Germany Page 103

der bauträger soll so lange in einen container gesperrt werden bis sein haus fertig ist! This has to stop - please!

no dolphins in private pools!

STOP IT !!!

-

Signatures 2,525 - 2,554

Name

From

Comments

2,555. Michael Schmidt

Gröditz, Germany

2,556. Manfred Oppermann

Bad Salzdetfurth, Germany

2,557. Irina Trey

Wien, Austria

2,558. Lea Pittomvils

Herent, Belgium

2,559. dive team hamburg

Hamburg, Germany

Unbelievable!!! Stop them immediately!!!

2,560. Silke Voecks

Hamburg, Germany

please stop keeping dolphins in swimming pools!! that's torture!!!!

2,561. Mirco Levermannn

Pinneberg, Germany

2,562. Verena von Olberg

Detmold, Germany

2,563. Esther Röhling

Waf, Germany

2,564. Cornelius Heggli

Luzern, Switzerland

2,565. Frauke Dinjus

offenbach, Germany

2,566. Erhard Streng

Munich, Germany

2,567. Victor Vaessen

Heerlen, Netherlands

2,568. MJ Janssen

Gemert, Netherlands

My husband and I like diving in the Red Sea, we've been to Egypt often. Sorry, but we want no torture of animals, humans, dolphins - whereever, whenever. We Will stop our holidays in your beautiful country until we hear that things are improving. Many regards, Verena

2,569. Claudia von Hacht Hamburg, Germany 2,570. Silke Wiegand

Berlin, Germany

2,571. Reham Yehia

Cairo, Egypt

2,572. Nadine Hilmer

Munich, Germany

Yes, there is people who don't care about things like that as long as they get their profit!!! Unbelievable something like this is actually happening in a country that is somehow depending on marine life... THIS NEEDS TO BE STOPPED!!!!!!

This is pure cruelty.

2,573. Michael Wernerus Bad Zwischenahn, Germany 2,574. Trixy Banik

Langerwehe, Germany

2,575. croise aurelie

marseille, France

2,576. Udo Kahlbrock

Norheim, Germany

Delfine gehören ins Meer und nicht in Zwangskäfige. Es sind freie Lebewesen wie wir.

2,577. Christian Scholz

Gross Wittensee, Germany

STOP ASAP!!!!

2,578. wim fierens

averbode, Belgium Page 104

-

Signatures 2,555 - 2,578

Name

From

Comments

2,579. Heddo Knieper

Castrop-Rauxel, Germany

2,580. Anette Reichwagen

Rostock, Germany

2,581. Stefan Preisinger

Oberhaching, Germany

2,582. Andre Quast

Berlin, Germany

2,583. Ulrike Jaeger

Schwäbisch Hall, Germany

2,584. Herbert Hartung

Detmold, Germany

2,585. Andrea Stark

Dürnau, Germany

2,586. chris heider

Trumau, Austria

2,587. Verena Weiden

Hamburg, Germany

2,588. Boris Althammer

Ludwigsburg, Germany

2,589. Daniel Hacker

Berching, Germany

2,590. Amy Q

Cairo, Egypt

2,591. Corrado Bortolin

Volvera (TO), Italy

2,592. Willy Rama

Köln, Germany

2,593. Fabian Maschke

Lehrte, Germany

2,594. Heinz Wolber

Speyer, Germany

2,595. alexa becker

heidelberg, Germany

2,596. nicole brandt

Franschhoek, South Africa

2,597. Krekels Christoph

/, Germany

2,598. Sophie Castex

Saint Clément de Rivière, France

2,599. Brater Bob

Hamburg, Germany

2,600. Carmen Mosca

Basel, Switzerland

2,601. Cornelia Gottschalk

Holzwickede, Germany

2,602. Felix Hettig

Cologne, Germany

2,603. Andreas Zabe

Irndorf, Germany

2,604. Qais Yousef

Amman, Jordan

2,605. Yamonpat Pattarakup

Nonthaburi, Thailand

Page 105

What a shame!!! Sometimes I feel sorry to be a human..... It´s so sad how we treat our "home"

Please STOP dolphin captivity in Egypt (Hurghada)

stop this!

This is Unbelievable...

Egypt has a beautiful underwater world with wild living dolphins. You can even snorkel with them. Why this unnecessary insanity, which no human needs. Stop this terrible madness! Respects nature and the earth. We have only one.

-

Stop it please.

Signatures 2,579 - 2,605

Name

From

Comments

2,606. Frank Krupinski

Fuerth, Germany

2,607. Robert Murray

Preston, United Kingdom

2,608. Christina Budden

Moers, Germany

2,609. Andrea Seresova

Bratislava, Slovakia

2,610. Sigrid Hecker

Düsseldorf, Germany

2,611. peter janssen

heerlen, Netherlands

2,612. Arkadius Zielinski

Marl, Germany

2,613. Jens Adams

Gondershausen, Germany

2,614. Ronald Staeps

Howth, Ireland

2,615. Dominique Albert

Bristol, United Kingdom

2,616. Christine Drax

Rechtmehring, Germany

2,617. Karin Morris

Cheltenham, United Kingdom

2,618. Randolf Krings

Wiesbaden, Germany I am a scuba diver and like to visit Egypt to see the wonderful underwater world you have, like thousands every year. If tourists want to see dolphins in Egypt there are a lot of possibilities to do so, with boats from nearly every city at the red sea. So it isn't necessary at all to do such a cruelty to those wild animals. Please do your best to make the owner of that pool leaving those dolphins free.

2,619. trisha addey

allestree, United Kingdom

2,620. Sabine Voß

Velbert, Germany

2,621. france fayet

bagnolet, France

Any responsible person should be appalled at the introduction of dolphinarium in Egypt, of any description. As a family of keen divers, we have been fortunate to see dolphins on several occasions in the only place you should see them, OPEN SEA. Shame on the Egyptian government for allowing the venture to get off the ground! Will we who visit Egypt twice a year and the thousands of other divers continue to visit Egypt and spend our money, that is what the Egyptian Government should consider, should they be unable to see the welfare issue for our fellow mammals.

Stop it. Now!

Dolphins do not belong in captivity.

2,622. Henriette Hummel D.f, Mexico 2,623. Ricardo Pato

Lisbon, Portugal

Those bandids should be arrested and brought to a trial. Simply ashamed...

2,624. andrea trebaticka

barcelona, Spain

they should be stopped all over the world!!!

2,625. Paolo Carnevali

Mantova, Italy

2,626. Nicole Kiehn

Erkrath, Germany Page 106

-

Signatures 2,606 - 2,626

Name

From

Comments

2,627. Michaela Schuppe

Tübingen, Germany

2,628. Katrina King

Gravesend, United Kingdom

2,629. Marina Seidel

München, Germany

2,630. ioana zaiu

Cluj, Romania

2,631. Ester Perez

Alicante, Spain

2,632. Mirja Pollesche

Stuttgart, Germany

2,633. Hans-Joachim Stemper

Frankfurt am Main, Germany

STOP!

2,634. David M

E, Germany

This is disgusting and needs to be stopped imidiatly!!

2,635. Lesleigh Harnwell

Johannesburgb, South Africa

2,636. Ralf Lieder

Dresden, Germany

2,637. Emma Wall

Hurghada, Egypt

2,638. marie whiston

newcastle under I do not understand how we claim/believe we are 'higher lyme, United Kingdom intelligence/evolved', when as a species, we behave like this towards other animals – it’s disgraceful, shocking and sickening. And, why does it take so long for the (all) authorities to pick up the baton and take the right action to defend & protect, how many creatures to suffer before lessons learnt and humanity comes before greed.

2,639. Leah Clooney Gainey

Newbridge, Ireland

2,640. Andrea Mason

Kempten, Germany

2,641. Hermann Jeannine

Vence, France

2,642. Baudinet Kelly

Pleure, France

2,643. Matthias Rettl

Vienna, Austria

2,644. Johannes Hübner

Brandenburg, Germany

2,645. Kurt Sparer

Brixen, Italy

2,646. Uli Erfurth

Weimar, Germany

2,647. Matthias Domke

Dortmund, Germany

2,648. Thomas Schmidlin

Buchs, Switzerland

Page 107

This is a disgusting display of human cruelty! These animals belong in the wild where they can act naturally and choose to interact with humans if they want!

Mais comment peut on être aussi con!!!! comment peut on priver les animaux de vivre dans leur lieu naturel c'est vraiment inhumain de faire ça!!!!! les propriétaire de cette piscine doivent être sévèrement punis en étant enfermé à VIE dans une prison !!!!!!

-

Signatures 2,627 - 2,648

Name

From

Comments

2,649. elisa rosa

novara, Italy

stop it!!!!!! bring your kids to the sea to watch them freeee!!!!!

2,650. Phil Rosa-Leeke

Almada,, Portugal

Dolphins should not be used for profit.

2,651. Lukas Feuerherdt

Brandenburg an der Havel, Germany

2,652. Tricia Boutwell

Orlando, FL

2,653. Monique Seitzer

Beilstein, Germany

2,654. Berndt Sandtner

Heilsbronn, Germany

2,655. ulli ehler

hildesheim, Germany

2,656. Jörg Fünfstück

Heidenau, Germany

Stopt diese Quälerei!!!

2,657. Franziska Skopp

Berlin, Germany

Es ist eine Unverschämtheit und eine Schande so wunderbare Tiere, die ich letztes Jahr in Hurghada in freier Natur erleben durfte, so zu halten und auf so eine abschäuliche Art und Weise zu quälen!!!!!

2,658. Heidi Tallat

Cairo, Egypt

2,659. Susanne Bergauer

Nürnberg, Germany

2,660. mosele eric

queven, France

2,661. kathleen giblin

stoke on trent, United Kingdom

2,662. Montassar Riahi

menzah 4, Tunisia

2,663. Andrew Wheeler

Stone, United Kingdom

2,664. René Michalski

Stockstadt Am Main, Germany

2,665. Urs Gmünder

München, Germany

2,666. Christof Hennenkämper

Schönau, Germany

2,667. Carrie Burns

Clearwater, FL

stop it!

disgusted

I am shocked and don't know what to say to such a discovery.... I hope the freaks which had this idea will be send to a prison-cell 1*1 meter for the rest of their lifes to see what they did to this beautifull and lovely animals! I realy hope something like that will not happen again!

2,668. Vincent el-Hawary cairo, Egypt 2,669. Julia Katz

Essen, Germany

2,670. Elin Jenna Monsen

Lillehammer, Norway, Norway

2,671. Gabriele Witter

Hamburg, Germany

2,672. Frank Wachsmann

Bochum, Germany

2,673. GRAZIOTIN MURIEL

MONTBAZON, France Page 108

Stop it ! All over the World !!

-

Signatures 2,649 - 2,673

Name

From

Comments

2,674. Kelli Stanko

Naples, FL

thats where they come to live after they are violently torn away from they're families and freedom! the worst!! they need to be free ASAP

2,675. Jasmin Rauch

Wolfsburg, Germany

2,676. Joanna Lampard

London, United Kingdom

2,677. Katharina Messerschmidt

Frankfurt, Germany

2,678. Stefanie Branscheid

Potsdam, Germany

2,679. Laith Arif

Nyon, Switzerland

2,680. Andreas Eberhardt

Wolfertschwenden, Germany

2,681. Sofie Kempeneer

Dilbeek, Belgium

2,682. Jordan Karadakov Thessaloniki, Greece 2,683. Stefanie Wolter

Berlin, Germany

2,684. Peter Meister

Nussbaumen, Switzerland

2,685. Andrea Reiner

Sachsenheim, Germany

2,686. Yvonne Clemente

Neufahrn, Germany

2,687. Cas Renooij

Bussum, Netherlands

2,688. herbert goller

marktbergel, Germany

how hutmans can be like this, the proof for biggest pretator on earth.

2,689. Shorouk Genena

Cairo, Egypt

I think we have enough animal rights issue to deal with here in Egypt, so please don't aggravate the pain of animal rights activists by granting permissions to dolphinariums in Egypt. Our goal is to save each end every living creature from cruelty, suffering and pain. Please assist us in achieving our goal. Thank you!

2,690. peter lustiger

Hamburg, Germany

2,691. Rebecca Tinyow

Sydney, Australia

2,692. Marianne Gasteiger

Thierachern, Switzerland

2,693. Michael Weber

Bad Ems, Germany

2,694. Susan Pektas

Benfleet, United Kingdom

2,695. Bianca Kuhlmann

Hamburg, Germany

2,696. lothar gossmann

brühl, Germany

2,697. Eszter Laura Toth

Szeged, Hungary

2,698. Frank Gabei

Thale, Germany Page 109

This should be stopped now

please try to solve this problem and try to avoid things like this in the future

-

Signatures 2,674 - 2,698

Name

From

Comments

2,699. karen widdicks

mngoiuahgkj.\v, United Kingdom

2,700. Alex Scott

Southport, United Kingdom

2,701. Jeannette Leichenich

Köln, Germany

2,702. Stefanie Langhammer

Hattersheim, Germany

2,703. Frank Waldenberger

Augsburg, Germany

2,704. Federica Cionci

Pisa, Italy

2,705. Merlin Schindlbeck

Nürnberg, Germany

Tiere sind NICHT zur Unterhaltung des Menschen da, schon gar nicht, wenn sie unter so unwürdigen Bedingungen gehalten

2,706. Kathryn Henzler

Perrysburg, OH

To allow this kind of sick maltreatment of dolphins to continue would be a violation of both reasonable conscience and moral decency. Please set them free!

2,707. Giorgia Zambianchi

Treviso, Italy

2,708. Karolina Stacevic

Visaginas, Lithuania

2,709. paula warren

derby, United Kingdom

2,710. Daniel de Wolff

Cairo, Egypt

2,711. Sabine Weidel

ostfildern, Germany

2,712. Christian Scholl

Ubstadt-Weiher, Germany

2,713. simon delay

bayonne, France

2,714. molteni monica

como, Italy

2,715. Annika Liese

Cologne, Germany

2,716. Alainna Bailey

Hallsboro, NC

2,717. Gregor-Sascha Cremosnik

Watt, Switzerland

2,718. Shahir Boshra

Cairo, Egypt

2,719. Marco Valenti

Dachau, Germany Page 110

UNBELIEVABLE!!!!!!! Please stop this Bullshit immediately!!!!

The captivity of dolphins is now proved to be barbaric and although we were hoping to visit Egypt for a holiday, have decided that until these poor creatures have been released. There is no way we would consider visiting a place where the inhabitants actually allow this to happen within their country! Please interveen and put an end to their misery now before this becomes public knowledge and creates a lot of bad publicity for your country and its people.

Your tourism industry lives of healthy underwater fauna and flora. Please stop to destroy it!

-

Signatures 2,699 - 2,719

Name

From

Comments

2,720. Djazz Weijers

Hillegom, Netherlands

2,721. Peter Mynarik

Oxnard, CA

2,722. Stefano Budoia

Brugherio, Italy

2,723. alexander nowikow

waldaschaff, Germany

2,724. Karina Soerensen Slagelse, Denmark 2,725. Kerstin Buhmann

Hergensweiler, Germany

2,726. Lucia Frangione

Pisa, Italy

2,727. Edina Rostás

budapest, Hungary

2,728. nadine salama

Hurghada, Egypt

2,729. Klaus Worm

Aachen, Germany

2,730. Gabriela Fuchs

Singen, Germany

2,731. Sabrina Wald

Vienna, Austria

2,732. bettina fehr

dornbirn, Austria

2,733. Sarah Panullo

Waymart, PA

2,734. Tonny van Eck

Biddinghuizen, Netherlands

2,735. Nico Kinzel

Lahr, Germany

2,736. babette sindram

Apeldoorn, Netherlands

2,737. Lauren Dingwall

Glasgow, United Kingdom

2,738. Rolf Rietzler

Triesen, Liechtenstein

2,739. tina hamann-Russow

hamburg, Germany

2,740. karen lyons kalmenson

Allenwood, NY

2,741. Peter Siegel

Frickingen, Germany

2,742. michael peter

bern, Switzerland

please stop dolphin captivity in egypt. there is more money in tourists meeting dolphins in the free ocean!

2,743. Liz Musil

Overland Park, KS

This is cruel and needs to stop!!!

2,744. Bruno Richli

Goldau, Switzerland

Stopt diese Tierquälerei sofort, ansonst Aegypten als Taucherparadies nicht mehr 1. Wahl sein wird !

2,745. Enno Stiller

63739, Germany

2,747. Fernando Pineda

Buena Park, CA

2,748. Shellie Baker

Lakewood, CO

Page 111

No Dolphins in swimming-pool But they must be free! the people dont have to close them eyes infront of it they have to do something.

eine Sauerrei, die sollten sich zu tode schämen......

-

Signatures 2,720 - 2,748

Name

From

Comments

2,749. Christopher Forth

Antalya, Turkey

We are a civilised socıety.Please let us treat our wıldlıfe with the respect they deserve and leave them where they belong. İn thier natural environment

2,750. thomas gregory

new york, NY

2,751. Wolfgang Mählen

Gelsenkirchen, Germany

2,752. Emily Kapellusch

Oak Creek, WI

2,753. grit engelmann

Hildesheim, Germany

2,754. Rebecca McClain

Morristown, TN

2,755. Daniel Schabert

10785, Germany

Pfui!!!!!!!

sending gay people to prison, allowing sick bastards to keep dolphins in a tiny pool. cool! egypt can suck it.

2,756. Christiane Reimer Münster, Germany

This is just appalling and barbaric. Set those poor creatures free.

2,757. Joachim Schneider-Reigl

Runkel, Germany

2,758. Reynaldo Alcantara

Orange Park, FL

2,759. Birgit Neumeier

München, Germany

2,760. Mathias Weidel

ostfildern, Germany

2,761. mili vanili

cz, Czech Republic

2,762. Annette Listl

Bad Iburg, Germany

2,763. József Molnár

Szeghalom, Hungary

2,764. Janine Amin

Velten, Germany

2,765. Iris Patzer

Lüdenscheid, Germany

2,767. abbie mclean

falkirk, United Kingdom

2,768. Bettina Rohr

Schaffhausen, Switzerland

2,769. Fergus Sullivan

london, United Kingdom

2,770. Linda Psillakis

Chania, Greece

2,771. Michael Dieterle

Böblingen, Germany

2,772. Tove Eleni Ask

Volos, Greece

It is too cruel....must stop!

2,773. Mary Miller

Columbia, MD

This is horrible! As a US citizen living in Egypt I am embarrassed to think that this is going on here. Come on people - is this the way that a country that call itself religious should treat animals!!!???

2,774. martin philipkowski

hamburg, Germany

STOP dolphin captivity in Egypt

Page 112

Pls release the dolphins from captivity, It's inhumane and serves no purpose

Shame on you for this animal abuse !!!!!!!

The dolphins dont only suffer from the narrow pool and the dirty water, they also burn themselves in the sun, I can't bear to see that!!

-

Signatures 2,749 - 2,774

Name

From

Comments

2,775. Sebastian Hartlieb altlandsberg, Germany 2,776. Michael Plagmann

Neustadt a. Rbge., Germany

2,777. Elicia Poluck

Sault Ste. Marie, Canada

2,778. Fernando Guida

Spreitenbach, Switzerland

2,779. Leentje De Vos

Ghent, Belgium

2,780. Markus Steiner

Zofingen, Switzerland

2,781. Tessa Meyer

Berlin, Germany

2,782. Robert Jones

Velserbroek, Netherlands

Please do what you can to stop other dolphins being treated in this way.

2,783. Susanne Makufke Castrop-Rauxel, Germany 2,784. German Bluvstein

Dortmund, Germany

This is just disgusting. Poor little dolphins

2,785. Donna Kermode

Isle of Man, United Kingdom

this is disgusting.. these animals have the right to remain free!

2,786. Stefan Scholz

Koeln, Germany

2,787. Yvonne Vogt

40699, Germany

2,788. Beth Sanders

Sharm el Sheikh, Egypt

2,789. Oliver Zuchowski

Stuttgart, Germany

2,790. Karin Biallass

Regensburg, Germany

2,791. Christina Werkmeister

Staten Island, NY

2,792. Hugo Loop

Luzern, Switzerland

2,793. Bernhard Merk

Ellhofen, Germany

2,794. Ann-Christin Wissenbach

Oerbke, Germany

2,795. Julie Zito

Lake Worth, FL

2,796. Heather White

Charlotte, NC

2,797. Caroline Peach

Lincoln, United Kingdom

I'm appalled that this is happening, especially in a country that relies on tourism and its Red Sea ecology so heavily for its income - shame

2,798. Arnaud RICHARD ANSTAING, France 2,799. Klaus Sawatzki

Stuttgart, Germany

Page 113

-

Signatures 2,775 - 2,799

Name

From

Comments

2,800. Marko Backer

Berlin, Germany

Ich selbst war 2010 in Ägypten/Hurghada und durfte mehrfach Delfine sehen. In freier Natur! Sie haben entschieden uns zu kreuzen oder weiter zu schwimmen. Es war einfach nur schön. Unverschämt, dass sieser privaten Haltung nicht gnadenlos ein Riegel vorgeschoben wird. Egal wer das ist. Ich schone die Natur. Tun sie das auch. Geben SIe den Delfinen die Freiheit wieder. Nur dort sind sie so schön, wie sie sind. BITTE!

2,801. Traci Koon

Port VUe, PA

2,802. Harald Mathae

Puchenau, Austria

2,803. Iman Saleh

nasr city, Egypt

2,804. Amy Angelo

Jenks, OK

2,805. Renee Wright

Pretoria, South Africa

2,806. Traci Hunt

Emeryville, CA

2,807. sabrina dussuyer

Vallauris, France

2,808. Carolin Hawwas

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

2,809. Carolin Inkmann

Buenos Aires, Argentina

2,810. Bettina Burchard

Hemmingen, Germany

2,811. May Kafafy

Cairo, Egypt

Please let them live in peace & dont ruin the nature echo of this life.

2,812. Christopher Molter

Dreisen, Germany

I loved to be in Egypt for diving but seeing this I doubt that I will ever come back to Hurghada being afraid that my spend money will support such animal crime!

2,813. Anja Nicolaus

Immenstadt, Germany

2,814. Inge Hellings

Cairo, Egypt

2,815. Matthias Gröschl

Bad Soden, Germany

2,816. Donna washer

Birchington, United Kingdom

2,817. Christoph Grill

Traiskichen, Austria

2,818. Monika Frank-Zierer

Landshut, Germany

2,819. Anja S.

Hamburg, Germany

2,820. Stefan Eisold

Bautzen, Germany

2,821. Gerrit Danner

Münster, Germany

2,822. Leonard Pauletto

Mertert, Luxembourg

Page 114

d'une cruaute sans pareille!

-

Stop this!

Signatures 2,800 - 2,822

Name

From

Comments

2,823. Elissa Stankiewicz

Hacienda Heights, CA

2,824. jo yılmaz

Fethiye, Turkey

2,825. Geraint Owens

Uk, United Kingdom

2,826. S. Bentler

181, Germany

2,827. Arne Hossinger

Neu Anspach, Germany

Solche Tiere gehoeren nicht in gefangenschaft und schon garnicht so!!! Es ist schlimm genug das mit der Fischerrei die Meere leer gefischt werden, aber das geht garnicht.

2,828. Peter Conradi

Felsberg, Germany

STOPP THIS! There's no sense in it!

2,829. Sam Ponsford

Melksham, United Kingdom

2,830. Melli ...

.., Germany

2,831. Cornelia Wunder

Kiel, Germany

2,832. anna fisher

berlin, Germany

2,833. Sharon Fischer

Granville, NY

2,834. Andreas Diethelm

Pfullendorf, Germany

2,835. Tabitha Friebel

Landshut, Germany

2,836. tina rago

Quakertown, PA

2,837. Natalia Burch

London, United Kingdom

2,838. natalie miller

stockport, United Kingdom

2,839. Annette Rehbein

Rostock, Germany

2,840. Cristiana Agliardi

Milan, Italy

2,841. Sandra Hohenstein

Hamburg, Germany

STOP

2,842. sandra baierl

vienna, Austria

stopp this cruelty!

2,843. miguel castaner

madrid, Spain

Es una vergüenza que empaña la buena voluntad de la gente que asiste a estos expectaculos, pensando que los delfines y el hombre,son amigos un termino que solo funciona en nuestra especie

2,844. Bart Rauwoens

Dendermonde, Belgium

2,845. Ashley Erving

Allegan, MI

2,846. Isabella Donner

Biberbach, Austria

2,847. Faith Campbell

Hamilton, Canada

2,848. Kali Elenoa

Abbotsford, Canada Page 115

Absolutely discusting this is criminal and the owner of the villa should be prosecuted

i´m shockt, i can´t imagine how bad it is for this dophins. people how do somthing like this are monsters =( hope this dolphins can be saved

-

simply put, this is shameful. Signatures 2,823 - 2,848

Name

From

Comments

2,849. Brigitte Mirling

Gerlingen, Germany

2,850. Peter Pegoraro

Pfeffingen, Switzerland

2,851. Anna Davidyuk

St.-Petersburg, Russian Federation

2,852. Melanie Wrightson

Reigate, United Kingdom

2,853. Jean Lord

Cliffwood Bch, NJ

2,854. Marcel Gierth

Munich, Germany

2,855. john morrow

Brooklyn, NY

2,856. Sonja Hitz

Zürich, Switzerland

2,857. Karin Siebert

Remchingen, Germany

2,858. Karin Oswald

3654 Gutnen, Switzerland

2,859. jerry goldstein

athens, Greece

2,860. David Stahmer

Bargteheide, Germany

2,861. Linda Post

Hamilton, OH

2,862. Karsten Köster

Berlin, Germany

2,863. Silke Scholz

Bergisch Gladbach, Germany

2,864. Marina Sequeira

Lisboa, Portugal

STOP dolphin captivity in Egypt!!

Free the dolphins immediately!

Ich kenne als Taucherin Hurghada sehr gut. Ich bin bestürzt, dass in diesem schönen Land mit super Tauchgebieten so eine massive Tierquälerei stattfindet! Warum benötigt es an diesem Ort ein Delphinarium, wo doch die Delphine in der Freiheit betrachtet werden können? Set them free!!!

2,865. Matteo De Lorenzi merano, Italy 2,866. Nicole Carolus

Ahrensburg, Germany

2,867. Sarah Vuylsteke

Linkhout, Belgium

2,868. Corinna Koch

Wiesbaden, Austria

2,869. Chloe Yzoard

Santa Cruz De Tenerife, Spain

2,870. Elena Politi

Venice, Italy

2,871. Michael Goebel

Schöllkrippen, Germany

Help and save the dolphins! You can make a difference!

2,872. mark laskowski

los angeles, CA

this needs to be stopped NOW!!

Page 116

Absolutely shocking. I cannot believe that this actually managed to happen and that someone was able to import these poor animals. I hope the guilty are punished accordingly and that measures will be taken to stop this from happening again.

-

Signatures 2,849 - 2,872

Name

From

Comments

2,873. Graff Beatrix

Fällanden, Switzerland

2,874. Yasmine Tarek

Hurghada, Egypt

2,875. Martin Punz

Scheibbs, Austria

2,876. Wolfgang Jocham Mattsee, Austria 2,877. CROUSAZ Isabelle

Geneva, Switzerland

2,878. Karsten Wegener

Auhagen, Germany

2,879. Stefanie Kollschegg

Hamburg, Germany

2,880. ariane ABDEL NABI

PARIS, French Guiana

2,881. Amgad Ibrahim

Cairo, Egypt

2,882. Isabella Büllesbach

Berlin, Germany

2,883. Maike Grosselfinger

Hurghada, Egypt

2,884. Castreuil Sophie

Bruxelles, Belgium

2,885. Ann-Kristin Grosselfinger

Karlsruhe, Germany

2,886. Katharina Schoder

Vienna, Austria

2,887. Martina Elfert

Frankfurt, Germany

2,888. maria bernardes

Cascais, Portugal

2,889. Jens Haak

Burgdorf, Germany

2,890. Jenny Steidl

Untermeitingen, Germany

2,891. Silvia Puhl

Karlsruhe, Germany

Page 117

Imagine you are a prisoner in a bath tub. Would you bath in your own excrements for 105 days because someone has given the order for it? Please treat the dolphins fairly and let them free and give them much more free space. That will honour you.

Je pense que ces dauphins serait mieux a dolphina a sharm el sheikh

Shocking! Please help the dolphins. In previous years I enjoyed diving in egypt and I hope now the ministry stops this cruelty for the animals.

-

This is absolutely shocking and incredible how men treat animals. this has nothing to do with animal love and makes me sad how egypt behaves itself.this is criminal behaviour and should be punished. i loved to come to egypt lots of times but seeing this makes me thinking to stop it and not to spend any money over there - money which probably supports this kind of animal crime. i hope that this will be stopped immediately and the dolphins could be solved!

Signatures 2,873 - 2,891

Name

From

Comments

2,892. Rosario Rodriguez Leon

Tazacorte, Spain

Keeping acuatic wild animals in tanks is just abusive!!! They need hunting... They need flows from ocean and swimming but 40 miles a day, and having their family and socialize!!! They need all this and even more than this I'm saying just to be psychologically balanced!!! And ONLY THE OPEN SEA, THE OCEAN, CAN BRING IT TO THE DOLPHINS!!! God told us TO CARE FOR HIS CREATION. Please, because you are able to make a big big and beauty difference for dolphins if you decide it to make, help no more dolphins are treated in this cruel and criminal way!!! DOLPHINS SHOULD TO REMAIN FREE IN THE NAME OF THEIR NATURE!!!

2,893. Joachim Hirth

Karlsruhe, Germany

2,894. thomas edom

butjadingen, Germany

2,895. Mary Challenger

Stuart, FL

2,896. Frank Deiler

Lichtenfels, Germany

2,897. Daniel Gahler

Regensburg, Germany

2,898. Sven Hollmichel

Zwenkau, Germany

2,899. stephanie möllmann

Dorsten, Germany

2,900. Barbara Bünter

Steinen, Switzerland

2,901. Denise Reinagl

Geras, Austria

2,902. Sylvia Kurz

Stuttgart, Germany

Stop this NOW !

2,903. Peter Pan

Berlin, Germany

Stop this!!!

2,904. Deena Pagano

Arlington Heights, IL

this is ABSOLUTELY APPAULING Im so SIck and TIRED of hearing these stories... and everybody is getting away with treating these precious intelligant mammals this way discusting!

2,905. somicha bouzitoun

amsterdam, Netherlands

captivation of dolphins for recreational purposes is no good at all...

2,906. Christine Peat

N orwich, United Kingdom

Please free the dolphins they should be in the ocean not in Captivity. It would be like putting you in prison to see how you like it. It must stop now.

2,907. Markus F. Heuer

Hamburg, Germany

2,908. Harry Armbruster

Winterthur, Switzerland

2,909. Patrick Dekkers

Maren kessel, Netherlands

2,910. karen page

Cheshunt, United Kingdom

help for the 4 Dolphins in hurghada. Also we need no dolphinarium in egypt..... we only want to look dolphins in the red sea!!!!!

not tolerable

Please do not keep buying dolphins - these animals should be free not a small pool

2,911. Jan Wuennenberg Bochum, Germany Page 118

-

Signatures 2,892 - 2,911

Name

From

Comments

2,912. amanda doelle

Canberra, Australia

there are some cruel and disgusting people in this world...i wish the animal cruelty penalties were more severe....id like to see the people responsible locked in a small pool for the rest of their lives!

2,913. Jennifer Geele

Phoenix, AZ

2,914. fux Manuela

Brig, Switzerland

2,915. Borsik József

Budapest, Hungary

2,916. andrew james

london, United Kingdom

these beautiful smart creatures must be set free. they have done nothing to warrent this prison sentances.

2,917. Marcus Hoeber

Offenbach, Germany

unbelievable.... what the f... these animals are suffering only for money, to get a few rich, and another few cursed when going there to watch the dolphins.

2,918. Michael Silver

Lorton, VA

These conditions are appalling and these poor animals must be set free. 4 more dolphins are expected to be imported from Japan and assigned to a brand new dolphinarium in Makadi Bay and this too must be stopped and all future dolphin exports must be averted and prohibited.

2,919. Sarina Catto

Dietlikon, Switzerland

2,920. Christel Gerber

Idar-Oberstein, Germany

2,921. kathrin ringel

berlin, Germany

2,922. Claudia Green

Mesa, AZ

2,923. Breeze Azrael

hurghada, Egypt

2,924. Carrie DeBord

Plano, TX

2,925. L.C. Burns

northumberland, United Kingdom

Everybody who takes these intelligent beautiful animals out of their naturell enviroment should be put to prison into a very small room and not to go out for a walk. not to breath fresh air and not to see trees and flowers, green gras and the beauty of nature and Live for the Rest of their selfish Lives!!!!!! Please release these dolphins from their deplorable condictions and cease to continue such orafices in the future!

Animal exploitation and cruelty is not acceptable in todays society, nor should it ever have been..put a stop to it now and make your country a country to be proud of ...Linda

2,926. Noushin Yadollahi London, United - Farsani Kingdom 2,927. stew smith

southampton, United Kingdom

2,928. Yolanda Lopez

Valencia, Spain

Page 119

-

stop this now. dolphins are wild animals and deserve to be left in the wild. do you know how much suffering has been caused by the japanese who sell these dolphins.

Signatures 2,912 - 2,928

Name

From

Comments

2,929. Abdallah Tolba

Cairo, Egypt

Have a Heart People !! Its very disappointing that people actually pay money for things like these to happen. Educate the people around you about ecosystems and about underwater creatures. Educated people will start to have an understanding of the picture without which its useless trying to get a point through !

2,930. Michelle Matthews

Toronto, Canada

2,931. Margarete Salem

Oooooo, Germany

2,932. Danielle Marie

Moreno Valley, CA

2,933. Jessica Gallagher

Matawan, NJ

2,934. Pam Johnson

Lake Village, IN

2,935. Luise Wagner

Vancouver, Canada

HOW DARE YOU DEPRIVE THESE CREATURES OF THEIR NATURAL HABITAT AND KEEP THEM PRISONER IN AN AQUARIUM FROM HELL!!!!!!!!

2,936. Michelle Ferguson Salt Lake City, UT

This is cruel and wrong! Let these animals swim freely! No one has the right to keep something captive for their own entertainment or financial gain!!

2,937. Olga Vinogradova Borok, Russian Federation 2,938. JOANNE BRIGGS

Milton, WI

2,939. Leigh Goodin

Durham, NC

2,940. Giuliana Pirozzi

sumter, SC

2,941. Bethany Pinegar

xxx, CA

2,942. ashley stanitsas

Rossmoor, CA

2,943. charlene kaput

Schaumburg, IL

2,944. Brett Hobbs

Suffolk Park, Australia

2,945. Jürgen Kolpe

Brühl, Germany

2,946. Astrid Stelzer

Pfaffenhofen, Germany

2,947. Janine Clark

Tustin, CA

Stop abusing these gentle creatures

2,948. MARY JOHNSON Oregon City, OR 2,949. Thorsten Drescher

Neuss, Germany

Free the dolphins!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

2,950. Steffi Wiesner

Neuss, Germany

Free the dolphins!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

2,951. Mieke Piket

Hurghada, Egypt

2,952. Ann McLeod

Dahab, Egypt

2,953. Heinz Dieter Panzer

Bedburg, Germany

Page 120

-

Signatures 2,929 - 2,953

Name

From

Comments

2,954. Stanka Miklovicova

Partizanske, Slovakia

2,955. Gysele van Santen

Washington, DC

2,956. Angelika Brunner

Obertrum, Austria

2,957. Terry Johnson

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

2,958. Kathleen Flemig

Hurghada, Egypt

2,959. Gabriele Lechelmayr

Kutzenhausen, Germany

2,960. Dagmar Fritz

El Gouna, Egypt

2,961. Diana Schulz

Dresden, Germany

2,962. Jörgen Müller

Elz, Germany

Why they people do this?

2,963. Thomas Gallas

Berlin, Germany

Ich als ehemaliger Hochseefischer und Sporttaucher finde es eine Sauerei das es überhaupt möglich ist eine derartige demonstration von Tierquelerei zuzulassen. Hier ist nicht nur der Tierqueler in verantwortung sondern ebenso der Staat.

2,964. Bettina Barritt

Hille, Germany

We have got a divingschool and I`m the owner of a travelagency, If Egypt ore any inhabitant of Egypt keeps on importing Dolphins ore any other whales, I will think about it, not to to suggest Egypt as a holidayland for my customers.

2,965. Maria Kirchisner

Sharm el Sheikh, Germany

2,966. Ken Bordig

Rodovre, Denmark

2,967. Janet Nelson

Mack, CO

2,968. Sylvia Mauch

Jestetten, Germany

2,969. Thomas Schelter

Nürnberg, Germany

2,970. Anita Papassarandis

Athens, Greece

2,971. Ute Werner

Binnen, Germany

2,972. Petra Lackmaier

Dauchingen, Germany

2,973. anke helene geissler

alheim, Germany

2,974. sinje weber

Kiel, Germany

2,975. Julia Schneider

Jena, Germany

2,976. Andrea Resio

Hurghada, Egypt

2,977. Marjan Zabeau

70, Belgium

2,978. cornelia Spieweg

Lübbenau, Germany Page 121

Hard to believe, how stupid humans are !!!

The people do this thing should be in prison!!!

-

Signatures 2,954 - 2,978

Name

From

Comments

2,979. Kaufmann Irina

Zuerich, Switzerland

2,980. Holger Poppeck

Renningen, Germany

2,981. Uwe Lohrke

Hamm, Germany

2,982. Mohamed Kamel

Giza, Egypt

2,983. Robert Schukoff

graz, Austria

2,984. Franz Burgstaller

Siebenhirten, Austria

2,985. Holger Wagner

Schwerin, Germany

2,986. Benjamin Burkhart

Y, New Zealand

2,987. guenther peters

gråsten, Denmark

2,988. Chris McCabe

Cambridge, United Kingdom

2,989. Jana Woltering

Heddesheim, Germany

2,990. Patrick Plasberg

Hamburg, Germany

Please, let them free!!!

2,991. Alexander Driess

Speyer, Germany

Please stop this cruelty to animals now and forever! Leave the dolphins where they are supposed to be - in their natuaral habitat, the Red Sea! Regards, AD

2,992. Tim Harder

Hamburg, Germany

Please stop this cruelty and prevent these intelligent creatures from dying slowly in a small chamber filled with excrements! Regards, Tim Harder

2,993. Barbara Brost

Hannover, Germany

2,994. Martina Aziz

Hurghada, Egypt

2,995. steve burke

gairo, Egypt

2,996. Shant Hamamciyan

Hurghada, Egypt

2,997. Heide Schroeder

Widensolen, France

2,998. Eve Radmacher

Hamburg, Germany

STOP THAT NONSENS!

2,999. Mario Eilers

Südbrookmerland, Germany

Stop this Dolphin Terror - NOW

3,000. Jörg Hüttmann

Hamburg, Germany

3,001. Andreas Schulz

Lentföhrden, Germany

3,002. Nikki Strike

stoke on trent, United Kingdom

3,003. Daria Grozovskaya

Moscow, Russian Federation

3,004. Dorit Pasinelli

Düsseldorf, Germany

3,005. Jens Kellermann

Pattensen, Germany Page 122

Der Kapitalismus hat noch nicht gesiegt.

-

Disgusting, keep them correctly or set them free! YOU are the dumb animals!

wie können Menschen nur so grausam und dumm sein? Signatures 2,979 - 3,005

Name

From

Comments

3,006. Peter Winter

Ottobrunn, Germany

3,007. Simona Puettner

Duesseldorf, Germany

3,008. Eva Schächter

Pottendorf, Austria

3,009. Maria Vass

Kornwestheim, Germany

3,010. Ulrike Schiener

Kemnath, Germany

3,011. Alexey Pryanishnikov

Moscow, Russian Federation

3,012. Mike Dooley

West Malling, United Kingdom

3,014. Sabrina Holste

Nersingen, Germany

3,015. Mohamed Youssef

Cairo, Egypt

3,016. Tim St.Clair

Lüneburg, Germany

3,017. Christian Matzat

Hamburg, Germany

3,018. Klara Bruemmer

Geldern, Germany

3,019. sandra guyomard

Montrouge, France

3,020. Antonio Amador

Setubal, Portugal

3,021. Rachell Lucas

Manchester, United Kingdom

3,022. Michael Zaugg

Schaffhausen, Switzerland

3,023. Susanna Pucher

Wien, Austria

Please let them free!!!!!

3,024. dawn turner

London, United Kingdom

Please give these Dolphins the freedom they deserve, your country has it's own Dolphin Island that allows visitors to swim with wild Dolphins and make your Country a great Tourist attaction, please allow these beautiful creatures the freedom they deserve.

3,025. Lin Marston-Weston

Fethiye, Turkey

3,026. Boris Schaefer

Meckenheim, Germany

Freiheit für die Tiere!

As a regular visitor to Egypt over the past 10 years, I am appalled that this cruelty has been officially sanctioned. An inadequate response to this campaign by the Egyptain authorities will greatly diminish any desire on my part to revisit your country in the next 10 years.

I find it both shocking and disgusting that these beautiful creatures are left to rot in such vile conditions, free these Dolphins and return them back to the wild where they belong!

3,027. Frank Theilen von Cologne, Germany Wrochem 3,028. Peter Gade

There is simply no justification for trapping and keeping wild dolphins in confined areas. They are open water creatures, and should be left in the wild.

Free them now!!

Aachen, Germany Page 123

-

Signatures 3,006 - 3,028

Name

From

Comments

3,029. Julia Heid

trierweiler, Germany

3,030. desban alain

savigné sur lathan, France

3,031. joanna cope

ipswich, United Kingdom

3,032. Karim Strougo

Cairo, Egypt

3,033. m edwards

Elizabeth Vale, Australia

3,034. Scho Doe

Hannover, Germany

3,035. polly pagan

London, United Kingdom

3,036. jodie nobbs

Lauw, France

3,037. Marco Gazzola

Cucciago (Como), Italy

3,038. Delia Sch

Hamburg, Germany

3,039. Paulina Hoppel

Poznan, Poland

3,040. dorothy Zein

Athens, Greece

3,041. Coroiu Catalina

Bucuresti, Romania

3,042. tangki pisangg

Singapore, Singapore

3,043. dagmar miatke

Moers, Germany

3,044. Alexa Herschel

Ludwigshafen, Germany

3,045. Tatja Gantert

Laufenburg, Germany Please Please Please. Stopp it!!!!!!!

3,046. Monika Pfeifer

Wartenberg, Germany

das sind keine Menschen,die so was machen,nur Profit-Geier,,,,:-( :-( :-(.....FREIHEIT FUER DIE TIERE

3,047. Steven Angell

London, United Kingdom

Typical Japanese attitude to sea life

3,048. Rudy Rallis

Athens, Greece

3,049. Jeanett Fak

Hildesheim, Germany

3,050. yvonne weitzel

hessen, Germany

3,051. Frank Weber

Backleben, Germany

3,052. Sylvie Weyland

Soleuvre, Luxembourg

3,053. Stephan Dittrich

Hagen a.T.W., Germany

3,054. Uwe Gasser

M-Gladbach, Germany

3,055. Rosalind Holder

Clavering, United Kingdom Page 124

je soutien et lutte pour la fermeture définitive des delphinariums dans le monde et surtout en FRANCE DESBAN ALAIN

Dolphins are not pets !! They are beautiful wild creatures that are meant to live freely out in the open!

Good luck.

it´s a shame

Stop that profit minded sacrileg against our nature. These Dolphins are not property of anybody.

-

Signatures 3,029 - 3,055

Name

From

Comments

3,056. Kay Joest

7, Germany

Act FOR nature and FOR Freedom and FOR respect and FOR the future of nature, animal kingdoms and humanity!

3,057. Ged Kelly

Oldham, United Kingdom

3,058. Nicole Winter

o, Germany

3,059. debra claessens

Antwerp, Belgium

3,060. Birgit Erben

neufahrn, Germany

3,061. Ingo Buehring

Hachenburg, Germany

3,062. rike beckmann

berlin, Germany

3,063. mecklenburg werner

pullach, Germany

3,064. Peter Dreyer

Hamburg, Germany

3,065. Stefanie Belina

Nüdlingen, Germany

3,066. Ulrike Schönherr

Lage, Germany

3,067. Verena Parl

Remchingen, Germany

3,068. holger martin

westerstede, Germany

3,069. elena moskvina

Moscow, Russian Federation

3,070. Wibke Schmitz

Düsseldorf, Germany

3,071. M Marks

Leeds, United Kingdom

Stop this disgraceful captivity. These animals should be treated with care. Release is the only answer.

3,072. M Knappe

Buxtehude, Germany

never, never

3,073. Evelyn Linden

Langenfeld, Germany

3,074. Corinna Brückner

Oberwölbling, Austria

3,075. Zoe Stevenson

Swansea, United Kingdom

3,076. Werner Stachowiak

Hamburg, Germany

3,077. Eric Mehud

Oberursel, Germany

3,078. karolien d'hondt

kalmthout, Belgium

3,079. Alexandra Kofler

Anzing, Germany

3,080. Sebastian Petersen

Hamburg, Germany

3,081. Magdi Shalash

Cairo, Egypt

3,082. Durga Sandmann

Titz, Germany

Page 125

that's absolutely horrible and cruel,what happens to the dolphins,

Stop prisoning dolphins in Egypt, Let them live in the ocean where they should be!

This story makes me feel sick. It's disgusting how such beautiful animals can be held in such appalling conditions.

animals should be treated like humans, with respect!

LAW...a Law is missing

-

Signatures 3,056 - 3,082

Name

From

Comments

3,083. Marija Pokramovich

Liepaja, Latvia

3,084. Thomas Schmidt

Oldenburg, Germany

3,085. anita palmer

Sutton Coldfield, United Kingdom

3,086. Kai Aumüller

Rehlingen, Germany

3,087. Kurosch Borhanian

Vienna, Austria

3,088. beden erika

riberac, France

3,089. imogen wise

batley, United Kingdom

3,090. Marcel Lobstedt

Norderstedt, Germany

3,091. Hilary Tavukcu

Mugla, Turkey

3,092. shakira miles

hampshire, United Kingdom

3,093. Monika Schmid

Wien, Austria

3,094. John Nightingale

Dartmouth, United Kingdom

3,095. Petra Rupp

Schnaittach, Germany

3,096. Raabia Hawa

Nairobi, Kenya

3,097. Janusz Charytonowicz

Poznan, Poland

3,098. Simon Gardener

newport, United Kingdom

3,099. LINCOLN O'BARRY

Marina Del Rey, CA

3,100. bethan griffiths

newark, United Kingdom

3,101. Naomi Stribley

liverpool, United Kingdom

3,102. Leah Blasi

Bristol, United Kingdom

3,103. Robina Lindner

Hamburg, Germany

3,104. Aime Readman

Andover, United Kingdom

3,105. corinna caplain

Avigliana, Italy

3,106. Manuela Ruppert

Heidesheim, Germany Page 126

It is time to end this cruel practice

i think it's time we let sanity prevail, the truth is out now! we know how you got these guys here! and you need to let them go! they are NOT your toys!

This is a very sad situation - please act to protect these poor animals

-

Signatures 3,083 - 3,106

Name

From

Comments

3,107. sanitha kurian

Kottayam, India

3,108. David Kennedy

NY, NY

3,109. Abby Perry

Richmond, KY

3,110. Gerlinde Drescher Neuss, Germany

Save all the dolphins

3,111. Nathan DeMontigny

South Yarmotuh, MA

3,112. Jenny Diez

Burlington, NC

3,113. Larissa Drescher

Neuss, Germany

Save all the dolphins

3,114. Marissa Valeri

Rockville, MD

Dolphins belong in the ocean, not in too-small pool in a private villa or in dolphinariums.

3,115. Frances Connell

Maidstone, United Kingdom

3,116. Mario Habeck

Schkopau, Germany

3,117. Till Glauner

Berlin, Germany

3,118. Dirk Lehmler

Beckingen, Germany

3,119. Sandra Paweronschitz

Vienna, Austria

3,120. Sam Daniels

Gent, Belgium

3,121. OLIVERA ISABELLE

Ivry Sur Seine, France

3,122. Lauren Winn-Dallmer

Centennial, CO

3,123. Ewa Romanowska

Warsaw, Poland

3,124. Mandie Gray

Chippenham, United Kingdom

3,125. Katheryn Rankin

Keyser, WV

3,126. Lara Perski

Leverkusen, Germany

3,127. elena costa

hurghada, Italy

If you love dolphins, give them freedom!

3,128. Michael Paramore Tampa, FL 3,129. Natasha Nanji

Nairobi, Kenya

3,130. tom hiermer

regen, Germany

3,131. Natalie Staller

Hurghada, Egypt

Page 127

I always hoped that this kind of brutal business would never reach Egypt. I found out I was wrong. I hope that we can stop this all together. For the sake of all the Dolphins in captivity all around the World, let us take the first step to bring an end to this!

-

Signatures 3,107 - 3,131

Name

From

Comments

3,132. Ellie Chalmers

Bedford, United Kingdom

As a previous resident of this area for 5 years, I am absolutely disgusted that these precious dolphins are being kept in such inhuman conditions. The question really needs to be asked as to how these dolphins were allowed to be imported into Egypt in the first place anf then transported to Hurghada! Good work Amr Ali!

3,133. James Glandon

Twin Falls, ID

3,134. liz collins

winchester, VA

3,135. Michael Dontas

Lancaster, PA

3,136. vickie williams

salem, NH

3,137. Michael McDaniel

Halifax, Canada

3,138. Ellen Sauer

Bischofsheim, Germany

3,139. franck Grünenberger

clamart, France

3,140. Ana María Quesada

Valencia, Spain

3,141. Annika Hinrichs

Hamburg, Germany

3,142. Aimee Humberstone

Manchester, United Kingdom

3,143. Tree House

Singapore, Singapore

3,144. TRAVAGLINI Cyrielle

Cannes, France

3,145. PAUL CHARD

Celebration, FL

Please, stop dolphin captivity!

Please sort out this situation with immediate effect

3,146. Mahmoud Medhat Cairo, Egypt 3,147. kathryn livesley

Crewe, United Kingdom

3,148. anthony Woodridge, IL giampaoli-martinez

A captive dolphin is not a real dolphin. If you want to see real dolphins go to the ocean.

3,149. Laura Grote

Amherst, NY

WILD ANIMALS NEED TO BE WILD! they are not here for the pleasure / profit / food of humans!

3,150. Beat Kernen

Heimberg, Switzerland

3,151. Amr Abbas

Cairo, Egypt

3,152. Andy Orr

Glasgow, United Kingdom

3,153. Jenna Corbin

winchester, United Kingdom

3,154. Ruth Khan

Manchester, United Kingdom

3,155. Antonio Kulhanek

Schaffhausen, Switzerland Page 128

these people should be ashamed of themselves!

-

Signatures 3,132 - 3,155

Name

From

Comments

3,156. anne spike

manchester, United Kingdom

i think whats happening here is barbaric ,uncalled for and should be illegal and anyone found doing so should be inprinsoned

3,157. Michael Kuch

Bendestorf, Germany

...incredible unexaptable situation! Do these irresponsible Animalkeeper wants to live in their own excrements??? ...kann ja wohl gar nicht angehen, oder???

3,158. billie alexander

akron, OH

Outrageous! Dolphins are majestic not pets

3,159. Lyn Shea

Altrincham, United Kingdom

The welfare of species who can't fight for themselves is everyone's concern.

3,160. Ashley Santone

Prospect park, PA

3,161. Björn Nardten

Gorinchem, Netherlands

3,162. Cindy Osborne

Bowling Green, KY

3,163. Danny Osborne

Bowling Green, KY

3,164. Leigh Jamieson

North Shields, United Kingdom

3,165. zena sallam

Cairo, Egypt

3,166. Johannes Felixberger

Hebertsfelden, Germany

3,167. Angie Moore

Richardson, TX

3,168. Bonnie Ann King

PG, UT

3,169. Aleksandra zak

london, United Kingdom

3,170. Heike Loos

Barbengo, Switzerland

3,171. Wouter van Gent

El Gouna, Egypt

3,172. Ryan Adams

Aberdeen, United Kingdom

3,173. Judith Brandenstein

Cottbus, Germany

3,174. Stefanie Schussler

Savage, MN

3,175. Manja Below

Lübz, Germany

3,176. Daniela Roell

Jena, Germany

3,177. Karim Naguib

Allston, MA

3,178. Mathias Körner

Pfaffenhofen, Germany

Dolphins deserve freedom just like humans do! Treat them how you would treat your family. You wouldn't keep your mom trapped in a tiny pool in your back yard when she could be swimming the oceans!

Page 129

...ohne Worte... Das geht ja wohl überhaupt nicht!!!

It is a disgrace - immediately stop now!!!

-

Signatures 3,156 - 3,178

Name 3,179. Suzanne Russell

From

Comments

Dromore, United Kingdom

3,180. Bianca Wittkowski Neukirchen-vluyn, Germany 3,181. Krisztian Pavuk

Kürnach, Germany

3,182. Terri Heeter

Hurghada, Egypt

3,183. Myriam Backer

Mörfelden, Germany

3,184. Nadine El Sayed

cairo, Egypt

3,185. Fritz Schaedler

Munich, Germany

3,186. Lisa Renner

Conroe, TX

3,187. BOURDEAU Michael

Ingy, France

3,188. tara green

Devine, TX

3,189. Heidi Schaffer

Laguna Hills, CA

3,190. Ina Croissier

Hamburg, Germany

3,191. Sourma Khoury

Evanston, IL

3,192. Laura Giacomel

Toronto, Canada

3,193. Brian Clark

Huntington Beach, CA

3,194. Amanda Sesely

matawan, NJ

3,195. boucher hugues

95290, France

3,196. Lindsay Bramble

Towson, MD

3,197. Rolf Egger

Nürensdorf, Switzerland

3,198. Andy Maidlow

Brighton, United Kingdom

3,199. Alexandros Frantzis

Vouliagmeni, Greece

3,200. Sophie THIEVENT

VILLARS LES DOMBES, France

There should be no question about the issue - dolphins should never be touched or imposed by any human actions.

Stopp em' ! Stop a l'esclavagisme de l'homme sur les animaux.

This is sick! I hope this cruelty is stopped immediately!

Scientific director Pelagos Cetacean Research Institute Terpsichoris 21 16671 Vouliagmeni, GREECE Tel.: +30-210-8960108 website: http://www.pelagosinstitute.gr

3,201. lacassagne carine toulouse, France 3,202. Natalie Orr

Craigavon, United Kingdom

3,203. Alodie Duante

Riverside, CA Page 130

Have some respect. The pool isn't huge, the water is nasty, just have respect and let them go! -

Signatures 3,179 - 3,203

Name

From

Comments

3,204. Alaa Sharshar

cairo, Egypt

A cruel world full of ignorance....

3,205. Marina Apitzsch

Dubllin, Ireland

3,206. Dario Cuccia

Velletri, Italy

3,207. Nadine Schulz

Dublin, Ireland

3,208. adrian boyle

Broome, Australia

3,209. kelly brohan

Philadelphia, PA

3,210. John Hertlein

Lexington Park, MD

3,211. Jaimie Reichert

Bakersfield, CA

3,212. Magda Sultan

Dahab, Egypt

3,213. Marcus Buchwald

Algermissen, Germany

3,214. Rochelle Bray

Swansea, United Kingdom

3,215. Rosemarie Gutzmer

Düsseldorf, Germany

3,216. Mircea Hirlea

Narbonne, France

3,217. Brigitte SIMON

REIMs, France

3,218. Saki Hashimoto

San Diego, CA

3,219. Leonhard Schwägerl

Egmating, Germany

3,220. maomi neko

North Point, Hong Kong

3,221. Lino Dos Santos

Vila Nova de Gaia, Portugal

3,222. Uwe Grasemann

Thale, Germany

3,223. Mathea Rubin

New York, NY

3,224. Dusko Maric

Belgrade, Serbia And Montenegro

The people doing this, to make a living, are bad enough, the Governments allowing it should think about what it means to live with Mother Earth and not just living on it. Seeing a video of Dolphins in the wild is far greater than seeing them in a dolphinarium. Stop this NOW!!!

If I could save these dolphins, I'd make my possible. 'til this day, I've saved 21 horses about euthanasy, or death. I'm sorry for this bad action, If i could, I'll be ready for save them. Wie kann mann nur ? Bei diesen Leuten fehlts echt vorn und hinten.

Stop this atrocity.

3,225. breanna rondilone riverside, CA 3,226. Anna Maria Voltatzi

Rhodes, Greece

3,227. Kai Altair

Brooklyn, NY

3,228. kristen carson

Duluth, GA Page 131

Please release these poor creatures back to the sea. Show the world that Egypt cares for animal welfare!

-

Signatures 3,204 - 3,228

Name

From

Comments

3,229. vanessa glover

poway, CA

Let the dolphins be free!!!!

3,230. Marie-Theres Hallepape

Essen, Germany

3,231. Ursula Diefert

Diez, Germany

3,232. Christina Gruber

xxx, Germany

3,233. Selin Geyik

İstanbul, Turkey

What can I say... they are out of their f...ing mind!!!!

3,234. Marysia Nieciecka Brooklyn, NY

Please stop all dolphinaria in Egypt! It is definite, these dolphins are a direct result of the annual Taiji dolphin hunt and were transported to Egypt from Japan in the month of August. Egypt do the right thing and stop the building of dolphinaria which just fuel man's greed! This is a prime example. To take these sentient creatures from their ocean home and keep them in a backyard pool is devoid of any humanity. Shame on that individual!

3,235. Heide Gabler

Hurghada, Egypt

3,236. Valeria D'Alterio

Florence, Italy

3,237. alfredo valle

chicago, IL

3,238. Rebecca McKeown

Newry, United Kingdom

3,239. cheryl smart

Brynmawr, United Kingdom

3,240. Kerstin Dietholm

Glattbach, Germany

3,241. Heiko Dobrinski

Bremen, Germany

3,242. Roswitha Labes

Ratingen, Germany

3,243. Edmund Klett

Weiler-Simmerberg, Germany

3,244. Johnetta Hatfield

Wichita, KS

3,245. Alexander Indermark

Frankfurt am Main, Germany

3,246. Christian Bötttcher

Dolgesheim, Germany

3,247. Shannon Dean

La Habra, CA

3,248. Stefanie Pnter

Hurghada, Egypt Page 132

After I read the story I became aware of the fact that dolphins are kept captive and have to be trained and are displayed as a show against their will. I have experienced what it is like to see free dolphins out in the ocean, and there is nothing more thrilling. Hope the petition works. Dolphins are smart animals, they have a bigger brain then homo sapiens !! evidently we humans, don't know how to use ours!!

dolphinsa are beautiful intelligent creatures and what is done to them is appalling, the WHOLE WORLD IS WATCHING i am ashamed to be called human

Bitte geben diese armen Kreaturen zurück ins Meer . Zeigen Sie der Welt , dass Ägypten für den Tierschutz kümmert!

-

Signatures 3,229 - 3,248

Name

From

Comments

3,249. Katja Schubert

Fuerth, Germany

3,250. Elysa Graci

Toronto, Canada

3,251. Romana Gruber

Innsbruck, Austria

3,252. Andreas Wolf

Duesseldorf, Germany

3,253. Ludger Wilp

Bottrop, Germany

3,254. Rosi Zang

Alzenau, Germany

Save the dolphins!! I looked a free-living dolphin in the eye - the don't belong to dolphinariums, they belong to the ocean - let them free!!!

3,255. Markus von Hacht Hamburg, Germany 3,256. Steger Marion

Gais, Italy

3,257. Frieder Rottmann

Nürtingen, Germany

3,258. Michele Boskovich

Westlake village, CA

3,259. Jessica Kennedy

Valencia, CA

3,260. Cristina Garcia

Miami, FL

3,261. Valerie Vilvoorde, Belgium DERBAUDRENGHIEN

Dolphins belong in the sea, no where else, ghallas!

3,262. sue fogli

Ibiza, Spain

3,263. Kelsy Cowles

Marquette, MI

What, what, what?! This blows my mind. Why would anyone do this?

3,264. MALCOLM BARRADELL

NEWPORT, United Kingdom

WHEN WILL THIS SORT OF MADNESS END IN WHAT IS SUPPOSED TO BE A CIVILISED WORLD???

3,265. Nariman mobdy

Antioch, CA

FREE the dolphins!! NO dolphins should be held captive. Have a heart & stop thinking about money

3,266. Susana Ortiz

Guadalupe, Mexico

3,267. holger ohde

Schwarzenbek, Germany

3,268. Belinda Sun

Fresh Meadows, NY

3,269. Anja Schuck

Burgdorf, Germany

3,270. romina rossi

riccione, Italy

3,271. Regina Dasch

Nbg, Germany

3,272. Cécile Niederer

Uster, Switzerland

3,273. Horst Wegele

Memmingen, Germany

3,274. Angela Sudholt

Starnberg, Germany

3,275. Ahmed El Basosy

Giza, Egypt

3,276. joanne m

San Antonio, TX

3,277. Uwe Colditz

Pfaffenhofen, Germany Page 133

-

Signatures 3,249 - 3,277

Name

From

Comments

3,278. lauran woodhead

Hamilton, Bermuda

DOLPHINS ARE NOT FOR ENTERTAINMENT. IF PEOPLE WANT TO SEE THESE CREATURE THEY CAN FIND THEM ALL OVER THE WORLD IN BEAUTIFUL LOCATIONS. PLEASE RECONSIDER THIS CAPTURE AND RELEASE THEM BACK TO THEIR HOME!!!!

3,279. Lars Burghardt

Muenster, Germany

3,281. ana zinger

Rj, Brazil

3,282. lelievre nathalie

hyeres, France

3,283. Matthias Schuster lLuebeck, Germany 3,284. Sophie Bizot

Los Angeles, CA

3,285. Annelie Moeller

Kiel, Germany

3,286. Stephanie Blackburn

Somerville, MA

3,287. G Franke

Neuss, Germany

Stop toture

3,288. Jasmin Raap

Oberursel, Germany

Absolutely unacceptable !!! Hopefully the world is watching... Let the dolphins free !!!

3,289. JUNIA MACHADO D M

Sao Paulo, Brazil

3,290. Eline Stoop

Dahab, Egypt

3,291. Sophie Gerring

Banbridge, Ireland

3,292. Sylvia Hesse

Chemnitz, Germany

3,293. Marisa Baumanns Aachen, Germany

3,294. Rudolf Althaller

Wels, Austria

3,295. Daniel Crook

Swansea, United Kingdom

3,296. Diaber Julie

Paris 12e, France

3,297. Sebastian Schmädicke

20a, Germany

3,298. Nicole Haas

Uster, Switzerland

Page 134

We call ourselves human, but what we do is the opposite. This animals are known for saving us "humans" from a lot of critical situations like drowning and we reward them by destroying their (and our!) environment and the animals themselves. If I was a dolphin, I would push all humans on my way down under water. But we are lucky, dolphins are not mean and evil like us humans. Everybody who still has the gifts of empathy and compassion cannot enjoy watching depressed animals in a dolphinarium or any other facility like that.We have to change and start to respect the nature and every creature on this planet, because without them, we are nothing. Stop the humans inhumanity!

-

Signatures 3,278 - 3,298

Name

From

Comments

3,299. Linda Glenn

Centralia, IL

DOLPHINS ARE NOT FOR ENTERTAINMENT. IF PEOPLE WANT TO SEE THESE CREATURE THEY CAN FIND THEM ALL OVER THE WORLD IN BEAUTIFUL LOCATIONS. PLEASE RECONSIDER THIS CAPTURE AND RELEASE THEM BACK TO THEIR HOME!!!!

3,300. Katarzyna Halani

salford, United Kingdom

3,301. Ulrike Richling

Ludwigsburg, Germany

3,302. Simone Luedtke

Borna, Germany

3,303. Stephanie Spors

Almere, Netherlands

3,304. Andirabel Padilla

Espoo, Finland

3,305. Susanne Horst

Münster, Germany

3,306. Ana Maria Carvalho

Guaratingueta, Brazil

3,307. Douglas Ljungkvist

Brooklyn, NY

3,308. Jackie Sidwell

Runcorn, United Kingdom

3,309. Barbara Vera

Ghent, Belgium

3,310. Alfred Kirchmann

Kronburg, Germany

3,311. johnny luciano

st. cloud, FL

3,312. Fatima Mobdy

Antioch, CA

3,313. Gozde Ogmen

Istanbul, Turkey

3,314. kevin connelly

Berkeley, CA

3,315. Rey Palmero

Key west, FM

3,316. Frank Poggemann

Hersbruck, Germany

3,317. BOURGUIGNON CAROLE

BACCARAT, France

3,318. Gina Bolaño

London, United Kingdom

3,319. Vidya Sims

Orick, CA

3,320. Sébastien ONNIS

ITTENHEIM, France

3,321. R. Zierikzee

San Francisco, CA

3,322. virginie derbaudrenghien

jette, Belgium

3,323. Bonnie Lindsay

Newport Coast, CA

3,324. Peter Förster

Fuerth, Germany

3,325. Justyna Gubala

ŁóDåº, Poland Page 135

Stop it

Stop it now!

No comment...

I am very concerned about the welfare of these dolphins.

-

Signatures 3,299 - 3,325

Name

From

Comments

3,326. Madonna DePalo

Baltimore, MD

These beautiful creatures are meant to be free! Perhaps Moses is needed to lead them out of Egypt too. I hope we don't need that kind of miracle....surely you can do it.

3,327. Django Paige

Edinburgh, United Kingdom

Egypt has the Red Sea, an amazing NATURAL attraction for tourism, let`s see the imprisonment of dolphins in Egypt come to an end?

3,328. Sandra Fabian

St. Stefan, Austria

3,329. Angelika Burgard

Saarbruecken, Germany

3,330. Sebastian Selg

Riedlingen, Germany

3,331. Sascha Ginter

Kadelburg, Germany

3,332. Nina LeDuc

Key West, FL

3,333. Johann Ruider

Bad Aibling, Germany

3,334. Miriam Spieth

Schlieren, Switzerland

3,335. Werner Brömme

Zeuthen, Germany

3,336. Yee Ping Fruehwein

Wiesloch, Germany

3,337. Steffi Wahl

Schönberg, Germany

3,338. Rob Petley-Jones

Kendal, United Kingdom

3,339. Tamara El Bezi

Korb, Germany

3,340. Pat Watt

Calgary, Canada

3,341. Kim Thompson

Burlington, Canada

3,342. Alexander Efonoff

Surrey, Canada

3,343. Damian Brook

totton, United Kingdom

3,344. Ashlee Dotson

Fresno, CA

3,345. Anna Markula

Brisbane, Australia

3,346. Dawn Seyedoff

Chickasha, OK

3,347. Margaret Forbes

Cairo, Egypt

3,348. Kathy Eaton

Holly, MI

3,349. Heiderose Scheerer

Vaihingen an der Enz, Germany

3,350. Chris Peternell

Carson City, NV

Page 136

Please stop this cruelty!!! They are living creatures and we should appreciate, respect and care about them as much as we can.

The dolphins deserve to have the ability to travel and use their senses and brains in their natural habitat, not some artificial pool. Something needs to be done to save and protect them!

FREE, FREE, SET THEM FREE

-

Signatures 3,326 - 3,350

Name

From

Comments

3,351. Andrew Harris

Portadown, United Kingdom

I would sign this petition a thousand times if I could.

3,352. Mira Iordanescu

Toronto, Canada

3,353. Debbie Oseguera

Oakley, CA

3,354. Alexandra Decu

Bucharest, Romania

3,355. Janine Hauck

Perth, Australia

3,356. river godwin

clayton, NM

3,357. Mandy Bailey

Selkirk, NY

3,358. James Sabo

Key West, FL

3,359. Elizabeth Ryback

Portsmouth, RI

3,360. Archana Shenoy

columbus, OH

3,361. Vanessa Pallares

brampton, Canada

3,362. Esther Koutnik

Tallahassee, FL

3,363. Rodney Pallister

Mindarie, Australia

3,364. tanya robles

Newark, NJ

3,365. Menna Awad

Cairo, Egypt

3,366. nina schläpfer

uster, Switzerland

3,367. anita janssen

amsterdam, Netherlands

3,368. Jennifer Iskalieva

Euclid, OH

3,369. Andrea Mow

Pleasantville, NY

3,370. Amanda Latham

Islip Terrace, NY

3,371. Deborah Adler

Whitehall, OH

3,372. Tahlia Haeuser

saint paul, MN

3,373. Miki Duchsinger

Ho Chi Minh City, Viet Nam

3,374. Aubrey McCormick

Arlington, VA

3,375. Fabienne Maradan

Givisiez, Switzerland

3,376. Jonathan Lee

San Diego, CA

3,377. june porter

W Ossipee, NH Page 137

My goal by signing this petition is to stop the cruelty and inhumane care of dolphins. They belong in the ocean and able to swim freely as they were put on God's green earth to do. This must stop now! have you drowned your heart in wealth? this is cruel, be a human being and don't be afraid to show and admit to yourself how wrong this is

In history Egyptians have been known to worship animals such as dogs and cats, why damage that image by being cruel to dolphins?

STOP DOLPHIN CAPTURING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Go Greenpeace!! -

Signatures 3,351 - 3,377

Name

From

Comments

3,378. John Wynn

Newburgh, IN

3,379. Christoph Wüest

Pfungen, Switzerland

3,380. Ulrich Heck

Eschenz, Switzerland

3,381. Benedikt Schoeffmann

St Veit, Austria

3,382. negro noemie

beauvais, France

3,383. kelly keane

garden grove, CA

3,384. Marion Abels

Potsdam, Germany

3,385. Gilles Denizot

Hamburg, Germany

3,386. anna saunders

Victoria, Canada

3,387. Sabine Fath

Abtsgmünd, Germany

3,388. Ricarda Raths

Berlin, Germany

3,389. Ennio Caminada

Rhäzüns, Switzerland

3,390. Ashley Rehnblom

Scottsdale, AZ

3,391. norbert pesendorfer

salzburg, Austria

3,392. Doreen Briggs

Cairo, Egypt

3,393. ashley stewart

Vista, CA

3,394. Jessica Lattmann

Hurghada, Egypt

3,395. Gabriel Giese

Unterfoehring, Germany

3,396. Dirk Eitzeroth

Munich, Germany

3,397. Sarah Mcevoy

Chesapeake, VA

3,398. Stefanie Janisch

Wien, Austria

3,399. Annelies Verelst

Hurghada, Egypt

3,400. Klaudio Negric

Rijeka, Croatia

3,401. christel dubois

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

3,402. VICTOR CAVIN

Hong Kong, Hong Kong

3,403. Erica Bastow

Altamonte Springs, FL

3,404. Karina Mihm

Merkers, Germany

3,405. ildiko egeto

eger, Hungary Page 138

We now know that dolphin captivity industry in the cause of the mass dolphin slaughter in Taiji, Japan. It is for our entertainment, that these highly intelligent, social creatures live in agony. Captivity creates a world of stress, pain, and sorrow. Why must we selfishly continue this evil trade?

Why is this person so cruel. How would he like to be caged up in an unpleasant atmosphere living in his faeces and pee. Lock him up and free the dolphins.

How can this be allowed in one of the oldest civilisations in the world?

-

Signatures 3,378 - 3,405

Name

From

Comments

3,406. Petra Thumm

Berlin, Germany

3,407. Sylvia Prietzsch

Hannover, Germany

3,408. philippe queriaud

suez, Egypt

3,409. Christiane Eichbaum

hägendorf, Switzerland

3,410. Andrea Leonhardt Frankfurt, Germany 3,411. Maximilian Margraf

Westerstede, Germany

3,412. Benjamin Ketels

13, Germany

3,413. JanWillem van der Kogt

Raamsdonksveer, Netherlands

3,414. Anna Meer

seattle, WA

3,415. Jayne Dunn

South Godstone, United Kingdom

3,416. Kurt Bötsch

Hannover, Germany

3,417. Bea Wenz

Stuttgart, Germany

3,418. Rolf Arendt

Brühl, Germany

3,419. Andreas Schildmann

Krefeld, Germany

3,420. Thomas Hartinger Blankensee, Germany 3,421. Jennifer Williams

Edinburgh, United Kingdom

3,422. Paola Reynaud

torino, Italy

3,423. Svenja Hahn

Dahab, Egypt

3,424. Lisa Miller

Knittlingen, Germany

3,425. Nicole de Schepper

Hamburg, Germany

3,426. Helen Nash

London, United Kingdom

3,427. Norman Gies

Aschaffenburg, Germany

3,428. Eleonora Merlini

sharm el sheikh, Egypt

3,429. Irmgard Macher

Rust, Austria

3,430. Janmalte Schui

Muenster, Germany

3,431. Claudia Alraun

Ebreichsdorf, Austria

3,432. Robin Rader

Klosterneuburg, Austria

Page 139

Disgusting. Free these poor creature and jail the person who is imprisoning them. Let him see how it feels!

-

Stop

Signatures 3,406 - 3,432

Name

From

Comments

3,433. Michaela Ashton-Braun

Hamburg, Germany

Dolphins do not belong into captivity, let alone a bigger bathtub! You can judge a civilization by the way they treat their animals!

3,434. Karen St. Clair

Lüneburg, Germany

3,435. Martina Reischmann

Stuttgart, Germany

3,436. Susanne Pusch

Munich, Germany

3,437. Michael Krichbaum

Wittlich, Germany

3,438. Nicole Umbreit

Hirschbach, Germany

3,439. Eva Gatz

Stuttgart, Germany

3,440. Andre Gatz

Stuttgart, Germany

3,441. Nicola Müller

Hamburg, Germany

3,442. Katie Flowers

Geary, Canada

3,443. Olaf Liepelt

Barsinghausen, Germany

3,444. Laszlo Kovacs

Budapest, Hungary

3,445. Carina Eriksson

Billesholm, Sweden

3,446. Christine Mahler

Göttingen, Germany

3,447. Dimitri Rutter

Leipzig, Germany

3,448. Peggy Muehlmann

Leipzig, Germany

3,449. Daniela D.

Vienna, Austria

3,450. Angela Franke

Berlin, Germany

3,451. christine tonge

coventry, United Kingdom

3,452. Verena Tams

Kiel, Germany

3,453. albiez maggi

Chiang Mai, Thailand

3,454. Baudry Anais

La Baule, France

3,455. Rolf Peter Sloet

Woerth, Germany

3,456. Heinz Borgas

Wennigsen, Germany

3,457. Patrizia Birtolo

Giussano, Italy

3,458. Mohamed El Maghraby

Cairo, Egypt

3,459. Claus Frech

München, Germany

Page 140

Totally not acceptable to ceep the dolphins in such a prison !

Human stupidity is obviously endless.

VDST IN/TL**** (Course Director) What a SHAME!!! FREE the dolphins NOW !!!!!

-

We definitely don't need these dolphinariums. There are many whale watching places. Or go to the Shark Bay World Heritage, with Monkey Mia where you can experience Dolphins and hand-feed them from the shore and they are living in FREEDOM: Signatures 3,433 - 3,459

Name

From

Comments

3,460. Sandra Tyralla

Germany

3,461. Isabel Morgenstern

Basel, Switzerland

3,462. Hans Juergen Mueller

Kaiserslautern, Germany

3,463. James Brueckner

Munich, Germany

3,464. neil george

los belones, Spain

3,465. Lucia Gerharz

Offenbach am Main, Germany

3,466. Claudia Bunzel

Berlin, Germany

3,467. Ahmed Abaza

Hurghada, Egypt

3,468. Christa Oppenauer

Wien, Austria

3,469. Anja Sloet

Woerth, Germany

It is incredible, how cruel humans can be - please, stop it!

3,470. Suzzanne Cromwell

Lowell, MA

We implore you to please think of the health and lives of these wonderful animals above our own enjoyment. Please WORK WITH US on ceasing this brutality.

3,471. yvonne gohrband

Berlin, Germany

3,472. Michael Werthmann

Geesthacht, Germany

3,473. Lisa Schembri

San Gwann, Malta

3,474. Natalie Barnes-Hore

Mount Hawthorn, Perth Western Australia, Australia

3,475. Christina Truog

Ostermundigen, Switzerland

3,476. Susi Keck

Wien, Austria

3,477. Jasmine Shaw

Perth, Australia

3,478. Claudia Jennel

Eisenstadt, Austria

3,479. Silvia Logez

Cayenne, French Guiana

3,480. Federica Rota

Milano, Italy

3,481. Stefanie Glasser

Gold Coast, Australia

3,482. Megan Moncure

Florissant, MO

Page 141

Is there not enough captivated animals in the world!!we have learned this is not the way to interact with creatures, we have to learn by our mistakes not continue to make more! its all about money and feeding peoples greedyness while using animals to make selfish people money! SELFISH, GREEDY PEOPLE WILL BE THE END OF THIS WORLD!! WE ALL NEED TO CHANGE!!

Disgusting. Wild animals should not be kept in captivity especially as these conditions are truly appalling!

-

Signatures 3,460 - 3,482

Name

From

Comments

3,483. MANDANA HADJIDAI

Brasov, Romania

3,484. Shirin Bunting

Manchester, United Kingdom

3,485. Willi Epp

Elsau, Switzerland

3,486. Karin Metzger

Heidenheim, Germany

3,487. Alexandra Kiehl

Seligenstadt, Germany

3,488. Steffen Boettger

Idstein, Germany

3,489. Anna Stukart

Landau, Germany

3,490. Hans-P. Fehrenz

Ottobrunn, Germany

3,491. Gabrielle Lees

Sheffield, United Kingdom

3,492. Wolfgang Zang

Alzenau, Germany

3,493. Helga Beste

Berlin, Germany

3,494. Martin Huber

Lienz, Switzerland

3,495. dhersin patrick

couiza, France

3,496. Björn Lars Oberndorf M.A.

Wokrent, Germany

3,497. Caralu Martin

Chattanooga, TN

3,498. Karine ZUK

Villerupt, France

3,499. Daniela Luz

Lisboa, Portugal

3,500. Irene Suitela

IJsselstein, Netherlands

please let these poor animals go! They don't belong in a pool!

3,501. D Gaidemak

Monsey, NY

We have to PROTECT the dolphins.

3,502. Barbara Krinner

neudorf, Austria

3,503. Dirk Fansel

Sörgenloch, Germany

3,504. Jürgen Elz

Rheinbach, Germany

3,505. Cordelia Stollberg

Port Elizabeth, South Africa

3,506. james gallant

woolwich, ME

3,507. Ingo Ide

12109, Germany

3,508. DEBORAH SULLIVAN

Dyfed, United Kingdom

3,509. marco mugnaini

colle val d'elsa, Italy

3,510. Christiane Bratfisch

Erfurt, Germany

3,511. Irene Brosseit

Herford, Germany

3,512. Michael Gruettner

Berlin, Germany Page 142

dolphin captivity is extremely cruel and should not be aloud to continue

-

Signatures 3,483 - 3,512

Name

From

Comments

3,513. Dirk Hormann

Lübeck, Germany

As a diver how loves to dive in the Red Sea I never will come back to Agypt when you don't STOP it!

3,514. JOANNE ROWE

liverpool, United Kingdom

3,515. franziska gerhardt D-79115 Freiburg, Germany 3,516. Roger Theisen

Sank Sebastian, Germany

3,517. Raimund Schied

Hamburg, Germany

3,518. saskia gall

euskirchen, Germany

3,519. Julia Sommer

Düsseldorf, Germany

3,520. Klaus Rieck

Köln, Germany

3,521. Betul Al-Bassam

Mitcham, United Kingdom

3,522. Mitsumi Mobdy

Antioch, CA

3,523. Emily Armstrong

Banbridge, United Kingdom

3,524. Christin Meier

Bielefeld, Germany

3,525. Bonnie Brown

Ny, NY

Dolphins swimming in their own excrement...and people want to actually pay to see this? We are a sick species and need help. Please let these dolphins go.

3,526. Ted Jones

Arnsberg, Germany

Humans will never learn

3,527. Boris Weber

Berlin, Germany

Everyone who wants to see captured dolphins, should be forced to see The Cove before.

3,528. Mariko Satow

Bellevue, WA

3,529. Lillian Meetz

Ratingen, Germany

3,530. Romy Gerring

Banbridge, United Kingdom

3,531. Humblet Samantha

Maisons Alfort, France

3,532. Viri Jim

Brussels, Belgium

3,533. Nadine Khalil

Bremen, Germany

3,534. wim otten

gulpen, Netherlands

3,535. Gunnar Redeker

Bremen, Germany

3,536. Ralph Ellwanger

Backnang, Germany

3,537. Carlo van Haren

Bingelrade, Netherlands

3,538. walter benedik

vienna, Austria

3,539. Birgit Schneider

Eschweiler, Germany

3,540. Kathryn Hull

Orange, CA Page 143

Dolphins are way too intelligent to be treated like that! Imagine putting a toddler in a dog cage.

Protect all Dolphins

Let them free!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Walgelijk !!!!

-

Signatures 3,513 - 3,540

Name

From

Comments

3,541. Séverine Crettenand

Isérables, Switzerland

3,542. maik Burgemeister

Stendal, Germany

3,543. Sofia van Moorsel Zürich, Switzerland 3,544. Beate Weller

Monheim, Germany

3,545. Anna Predonzan

Crespano, Italy

3,546. Nadine Barna

Wien, Austria

3,547. Jennifer Baker

London, United Kingdom

3,548. Florin Kunz

Siebnen, Switzerland

3,549. Elisabeth Spieth

Weil, Germany

3,550. Brigitte Carstensen

Wanderup, Germany

3,551. Frithjof Bührig

Calw, Germany

3,552. nada soliman

cairo, Egypt

3,553. amanda williams

Birmingham, United Kingdom

3,554. Maria Schulz

Timisoara, Romania

3,555. nina rothe

southampton, United Kingdom

3,556. Jackie Loose

Hamburg, Germany

How sick can Human get because of money, thats just disgusting!!! help quick !

Why????

3,557. Roman Kreimeyer Rathjensdorf, Germany 3,558. judith leon de arayaes

San Diego, CA

3,559. Roos Kampen

Roggel, Netherlands

3,560. Annette Bader

Meerbusch, Germany

3,561. Clare Newman

Sandown, United Kingdom

3,562. Ahmed Gadou

Chelmsford, United Kingdom

3,563. Dominik H

Newport, United Kingdom

3,564. Amanda Gadou

Chelmsford, United Kingdom

3,565. Selina Puckett

Briton Ferry, United Kingdom

3,566. Daniel Kroell

Brixlegg, Austria Page 144

I was horrified to see this, how could someone be so cruel!! I swam with dolphins in the wild, where they should be, and it was magical.

...und wenn's nur für's bessere karma is ;] -

Signatures 3,541 - 3,566

Name

From

Comments

3,567. Brittany McCambridge

Brookfield, WI

3,568. peyton Mills

Midlothian, VA

3,569. Thomas Riede

Günthersleben-Wechmar, Germany

3,570. Malte Bruemmer

Stuttgart, Germany

3,571. Dirk Mittweg

München, Germany

3,572. Dirk J Rombach

Aachen, Germany

3,573. Heribert Kuepper

Duesseldorf, Germany

3,574. Cabiria Tomat

Barcelona, Spain

3,575. Ileana Carmen Carare

Tromso, Norway

3,576. a k

Buenos Aires, Argentina

3,577. lucie louca

cairo, Egypt

3,578. Bartek Rainski

New York, NY

3,579. Genevieve Bock-Caron

Edmonton, Canada

3,580. MARIA CHORATTA

Nicosia, Cyprus

3,581. Rachael Pahl

Lake Villa, IL

3,582. Liz Robles de Medina

Rotterdam, Netherlands

3,583. sonia de marco

Dragoni- Caserta, Italy

3,584. GABRIELLA MARCONI

Mendicino, Italy

3,585. Rosemarie Sardinas Herrera

Salzburg, Austria

this is disgusting! im soo glad they are being moved and hopefully they will be able to be rehabiltiated and released!

Leave nature natural ...

Please release those dolphins - their condition is terrible!

3,586. Richard Overtoom Frauenfeld, Switzerland 3,587. Wahrmut Sobainsky

bad Homburg, Germany

3,588. Shanon Wise

Thornville, OH

3,589. Mary Farmer

Bradenton, FL

3,590. Spela Magana

San Miguel, Mexico

3,591. gigi gaulin

Santa Fe, NM

3,592. Angela Brock

Fort Myers, FL Page 145

When are humans going to realize that ALL living things have a right to live free in their natural environment. shame on you!

-

Signatures 3,567 - 3,592

Name

From

Comments

3,593. Mirja Davidovska

Skopje, Macedonia, The Former Yugoslav Republic Of

3,594. Nadya shanab

cairo, Egypt

3,595. Yara Shawa

Giza, Egypt

3,596. Bitch slut Whore

Vancouver, Canada

3,597. Hillary Gay

Lubbock, TX

3,598. Pierre Guirguis

Cairo, Egypt

FUCKE YOU DOLPHEEEN

3,599. Sarah Brozdowski Bromley, United Kingdom 3,600. Michelle Mizrahi

11700, Mexico

3,601. Rachel Aviles

portland, OR

3,602. lucia bogdanov

cordoba, Argentina

3,603. Karen McCullough

Swansea, United Kingdom

3,604. Kolby Duhon

Groves, TX

3,605. Lillian Gargiulo

Juiz De Fora, Brazil

3,606. Nabih Berzi

Cairo, Egypt

3,607. Luca Frattini

novara, Italy

3,608. Gaby altermann

Palmerston, New Zealand

3,609. Hannah Dietrich

Graz, Austria

3,610. Nina Schabert

Augsburg, Germany

3,611. Stephanie Kemna

Sarzana, Italy

3,612. Uran Saiti

Skopje, Macedonia, The Former Yugoslav Republic Of

3,613. Lynet Taunus

Hamburg, Germany

3,614. khalid abdulhak

cairo, Egypt

3,615. Louise Maltas

Leeds, United Kingdom

3,616. Kate Williams

London, United Kingdom

3,617. David Hirst

Sheffield, United Kingdom

3,618. Andreas Kneip

Telgte, Germany

3,619. WEGMULLER JASMINA

lausanne, Switzerland

3,620. claudia hoellhuber Bad Hall, Austria 3,621. Brian Barnes

Tampa, FL Page 146

-

Signatures 3,593 - 3,621

Name

From

Comments

3,622. amor busa

Quezon City, Philippines

3,623. Alan Winstanley

Redcliffe, Australia

3,624. Tom Harvie

Saanich, Canada

3,625. Jacob Wodzynski

Halmstad, Sweden

3,626. kaisa kangasniemi

Tampere, Finland

3,627. Raimo Kangasniemi

Juupajoki, Finland

3,628. Olli Radke

Berlin, Germany

3,629. Lee Richmond

Christchurch, New Zealand

3,630. Naomi Mitchell

Lincoln, United Kingdom

3,631. Amira Jehia

Berlin, Germany

3,632. Lorali Llewellyn

Nice, CA

3,633. Kerry O'Brien

Auckland, New Zealand

3,634. Harry Kemna

Eibergen, Netherlands

3,635. Ruby Eaches

Newport, RI

3,636. Mariusz Wojdyna

Piaseczno, Poland

3,637. Fred Castillo

Bakersfield, CA

3,638. suzanne charles

Godalming, United Kingdom

3,639. Michael Carter

Chippenham, United Kingdom

3,640. Vikki Mead

Heathmont, Australia

3,641. Veronique Glauser

Wolfhalden, Switzerland

3,642. Julia Zeitlinger

Bad Hall, Austria

3,643. Estella Sumangil

San Diego, CA

3,644. Markus Witt

Teltow, Germany

Egypt? No way...

STOP dolphin captivity in Egypt This is crazy, I am disgusted. I will not set foot in Egypt whilst this continues.

I was 9 times in Egypt, I like the Country, the Red Sea an the Peolple, but the Tourism for Egypt seams to be more important the environment. Next year i want to have my 10. holiday in Egypt - not under these circumstances ... maybe in some years, if Egypt came back behind the (russian) tourism.

3,645. Michelle Robinson Cornwall, United Kingdom 3,646. Dalibor Jaksic

Milan, Italy Page 147

-

Signatures 3,622 - 3,646

Name

From

Comments

3,647. Christian Kuhlmann

Hurghada, Egypt

Just stop it, you have the biggest aquarium right in front of your shores!!!!

3,648. Renate Niedermair

Linz, Austria

3,649. Marjolein Kemna

enschede, Netherlands

3,650. M Nicholas

Herts, United Kingdom

3,651. Yasamin Nadeem

Munich, Germany

3,652. Puck Bosch

Amsterdam, Netherlands

3,653. Judith Hannak

Vienna, Austria

Dolphins in captivity have nothing to do with nature based tourism.

3,654. Marinda Grobler

Durban, South Africa

Inhumane doesn't even begin to describe the thought of these poor animals being kept in a convined space like this!!!! It's like shoving grown up's in a kiddies play pen for the rest of their life!!! Come on, free them and let them live where they belong.....

3,655. Soenke Lorenzen

Hamburg, Germany

3,656. Vicky Rose

London, United Kingdom

3,657. malak ezzat

cairo, Egypt

3,658. Amira Haroun

Kuwait, Kuwait

3,659. Tiziana Gabello

Inzago, Italy

3,660. SHELLEY CONNOR

Toowoomba, Australia

3,661. mt kemna

eibergen, Netherlands

3,662. Heike Lewe

Hürth, Germany

I´m really shocked.Stop this horror for the dolphins and let them free.

3,663. natacha tratzi

toulon, France

il faudrait les enfermer eux dans des cages!!!!!!

3,664. Veronika Olivier

Egg Harbor Township, NJ

3,665. erika mock

Mannersdorf, Austria

3,666. Isabella Moreschi

Roma, Italy

3,667. Varina Paone

Bedminster, NJ

3,668. Maria Brosch

Düsseldorf, Germany

3,669. Christine Sullivan

Cambridge, VT

3,670. Erika Horváth

Hurghada, Egypt

3,671. Sabine Voß

München, Germany

3,672. Paola Ghidotti

Milano, Italy Page 148

-

Signatures 3,647 - 3,672

Name

From

Comments

3,673. Frank Olivier

Egg Harbor Twp, NJ

3,674. Maria Ferraria

Porto, Portugal

3,675. Ahmed Rashad

Cairo, Egypt

3,676. Mary D

Morphett Vale, Australia

3,677. Lorri Kazandjian

cairo, Egypt

3,678. Paul Critcher

Surrey, United Kingdom

3,679. Martina Bruder

Filderstadt, Germany

It's horrible what ist happening with dolphins. They need Freedom for Life!!!!!!

3,680. Cathy Law

Lisburn, United Kingdom

This is rediculous!! I'd like to cage the assholes doing this!!

3,681. masia licia

bregnano, Italy

3,682. Anita Gagel

Jonesboro, AR

3,683. Angelika Schui-Lindthaler

Hoexter, Germany

3,684. Dirk Semmler

Dortmund, Germany

3,685. Robin Bischler

Heppenheim, Germany

3,686. ute biederer

duisburg, Germany

3,687. karine abate

Pisa, Italy

3,688. Jochen Fincke

Rerik, Germany

3,689. Lisa Berberich

Veitshöchheim, Germany

3,690. Summer Campbell-kelsch

Salt Lake City, UT

3,691. Petra Bieck

Modautal, Germany

3,692. nick finlay

edinburgh, United Kingdom

3,693. Jens Möller

Brakel, Germany

3,694. Kris Altmann

Rosenberg, Germany

3,695. Daniel Broggel

Kirkland, WA

Dolphins are among the most intelligent life on earth. It is only a step to what the Dolphins are suffering to what humans will suffer.

3,696. Terry Ridge

Lakeview, OR

Barbaric and inhumane. STOP the wholesale slaughter of sharks NOW!!! Malama aina 'a malama kai. Aloha

3,697. Andreas Bentrup

Am Mellensee, Germany

3,698. Peter Wündisch

plauen, Germany

3,699. Mike Masley

Manville, NJ Page 149

Let's hope our voices are heard

just stop it, let them free

ute biederer

-

Signatures 3,673 - 3,699

Name

From

Comments

3,700. Piotr Jaworski

Jastków, Poland

3,701. Elke De Boysere-Engel

Hattersheim, Germany

3,702. Renate Müller

Witten, Germany

3,703. Charlotte Heaton

Manchester, United Kingdom

3,704. Caroline Peters

Regensburg, Germany

3,705. Phillippine Sensmeier

Göttingen, Germany

3,706. Ralf Seidel

Borken, Germany

STOP IT !!!!!!!!!!!!!

3,707. Bouassida Soraya Martigues, France 3,708. Tatiana Torres

Bogota, Colombia

3,709. Ometh Layton

Bogota, Colombia

3,710. Nelly Lopez

Bogota, Colombia

3,711. Rocio Salazar

Bogota, Colombia

3,713. Susan Gundlach

Tigard, OR

3,714. Elizabeth Palumbo

Westfield, NY

3,715. Viv Flegg

Calgary, Canada

3,716. Michael Kissing

Sehnde, Germany

3,717. Heather David

Des Plaines, IL

3,718. yoshiko wada

Ishikawakenn Japan, Japan

3,719. Farida Sultan

Frauenfeld, Switzerland

3,720. Margarida Oliveira Matosinhos, Portugal 3,721. Andrew Starr

Roselle, IL

Unless you are willing to be enslaved without question, you should not enslave the dolphins. They are beautiful creatures from the marine world, and as such, they deserve to live peacefully and humanely in their natural habitat. This is outrageous--exploiting the dolphins for the selfish entertainment of mankind. PLEASE: FREE THEM NOW!!!

3,722. Laura Christenson Arlington, WA 3,723. rachel blankenship

clifton, CO

3,724. Sarah Pikarski

Herts, Egypt

3,725. Zoe Wengenroth

Corby, United Kingdom Page 150

PLEASE set these beautiful and intelligent animals FREE! They don't deserve this horrible treatment!

-

Signatures 3,700 - 3,725

Name

From

Comments

3,726. Patricia Comrie

Spokane, WA

3,727. Jessica Boardman

Clermont, FL

3,728. S Barnes

Fethiye, Turkey

3,729. Kathleen Hobson

Greene, IA

3,730. Klaus Braunert

Kropp, Germany

3,731. Robert Sanders

Temple, GA

3,732. Mohamed Ghanem

Cairo, Egypt

3,733. Kathy Hoar

So.glastonbury, CT

3,734. ashemi Shahram

8, Germany

3,735. Susanne Baldus

Heppenheim, Germany

3,736. Sandra Soller

Sinking Spring, PA

3,737. Karina Oakes

Austin, TX

3,738. steve viner

Shaftesbury, United Kingdom

3,739. chris maguire

Bristol, United Kingdom

3,740. Kathrin Wiegand

Hamburg, Germany

3,741. Suzanne Warren

Grass Valley, CA

3,742. Boudewijn Dominicus

Guildford, United Kingdom

3,743. Kristian Nybergh

Espoo, Finland

3,744. marieke van otterloo

amsterdam, Netherlands

3,745. Brittany Mercer

Woodstock, GA

3,746. Tony Bieri

Zurich, Switzerland

3,747. Eugenia Dudec

Carabobo, Venezuela

3,748. Margaret Guenena

Hurghada, Egypt

3,749. gina assem

waxahachie, TX Page 151

Barbaric cruelty with a death sentence at the end unless we can help!!!!!!!!!!

It`s a shame.

No animal should be kept in captivty, especially in such horrible conditions. No person imagines if they were locked in a tiny room with mold and unimaginable odors, or something disgusting enough to put your health at risk, causing you to loose some vision. Put yourself in their shoes, and imagine how you would feel. They don't know whats going on and were taken from their own home. This is appalling and anyone who has a heart shouldn't allow this. Human beings should NOT allow this.

-

Signatures 3,726 - 3,749

Name

From

Comments

3,750. Jeff Birgbauer

Grosse Pointe Woods, MI

3,751. Gill Sinclair

Hull, United Kingdom

3,752. Henrietta Smith

Auckland, New Zealand

For God's sake what is the matter with these people that do these things.

3,753. Anika Munshi

Toronto, Canada

I hope we reach 10,000 signatures. This needs to stop immediately.

3,754. natalie sirkedjian

cairo, Egypt

stop dolphin captivity nowww

3,755. Shanta Rambharose

toronto, Canada

3,756. stefan eckstein

umkirch, Germany

3,757. Angel Alaris

Newtown, United Kingdom

3,758. Clara Farahat

cairo, Egypt

please stoooppp what you are doing!! you wouldnt like to be locked in a small room for the rest of ur life!!!!!!

3,759. siobhain gaughan

Galway, Ireland

These poor creatures, we need to speak up for them! dolphins are intelligent creatures and are no doubt cramped, bored, and not in their natural habitat.

3,760. Andy Taylor

Colchester, United Kingdom

3,761. Nick Kail

One Mile, Australia

3,762. Nathalie Atalla

Cairo, Egypt

3,763. Lissa Newbould-Ortiz

Hastings, MN

3,764. Stephanie Kosak

Edmonton, Canada

3,765. Sheena Perry

Hunt, WV

3,766. Annie Dillon

Scotland, United Kingdom

3,767. ramy samy

cairo, Egypt

3,768. Ceizun Schwartz

Knoxville, TN

Please release these beautiful animals to their natural habitat. This is not humane!

3,769. Jill Oleszko

Essex, United Kingdom

Disgusted at Egypt for obtaining these dolphins which are taken from the wild! I do know 'Sea Shepherd are keeping a close eye down at the 'Cove' in Japan. Boycott Japan and all they stand for!!

3,770. Patricia Myers

Ancramdale, NY

3,771. Olivia Schlosser

Mansfield Center, CT

3,772. Charlotte Mead

Amersham, United Kingdom

Page 152

Please know that this is not the way an animal that is used to a vast home should be treated. To confine an animal to such conditions is not right.

-

Signatures 3,750 - 3,772

Name

From

Comments

3,773. yann roger

bouaye, France

Comment peut on enfermer de tels voyageurs ? L'homme est vraiment la pire des énigmes !

3,774. gabrielle de bruijn

Eindhoven, Netherlands

DOLPHINS BELONG IN THE SEA, NOT IN A POOL CREATED BY CRAZY PEOPLE. DEEP SHAME

3,775. Patricia Chiorello

Delanco, NJ

3,776. Sandra El Manesterly

Cairo, Egypt

3,777. Rodney Peasley

Truro, United Kingdom

3,778. Véronique DUBOURG

Lagoa, Portugal

3,779. Dirk Zapf

Kassel, Germany

3,780. Nicole Dotzler

Kiel, WI

3,781. Lindsey Martens

williams lake, Cambodia

3,782. Pamir Kiciman

Hollywood, FL

3,783. Oleg Morozov

Moscow, Russian Federation

3,784. Niz Khan

London, United Kingdom

3,785. Bryan Walston

Waikoloa, HI

3,786. Cynthia Ford

Bexley, OH

3,787. Mowaffak Saad

Alexandria, Egypt

3,788. Alex Dillon

Scotland, United Kingdom

3,789. Doreya Karim

montreal, Canada

3,790. Osama Abdel Aal

Caorp, Egypt

3,791. Leticia Frutos

Asunciã³n, Paraguay

3,792. Judith Pecho

Corrales, NM

3,793. Katrina Ocampo

Markham, Canada

3,794. Omar Shash

montreal, Canada

3,795. Chris Vaughn

Weimar, CA

3,796. Kelli Higgins

Marlboro, NJ

3,797. lana el shanty

santa monica, CA Page 153

This is disgusting, what is wrong with the human race that we want to bestow such cruelty on other species, God forgive us.

Every time news came with such inhuman and insane, I feel my heart aching. Please continue your efforts HEPCA.

This is absolute cruelty. Return these dolphins back to the sea where they belong. You have woefully inadequate place for them while in quarantine and they are suffering. You have no right to cause them pain because you want to make money from exhibiting them. Please return them to the sea.

-

Signatures 3,773 - 3,797

Name

From

Comments

3,798. Allison Kleine

Pasadena, CA

3,799. philip yost

Ellwood City, PA

3,800. Carina Schaffenrath

Schwaz, Austria

3,801. mohamed hossam

cairo, Egypt

3,802. jeanette argentin

San Pedro, CA

3,803. Diane Berings

Deurne, Belgium

3,804. Guido Eckhardt

Oranienburg, Germany

3,805. Denise LaChance

Los Angeles, CA

3,806. Michaela Mergenthaler

Oftersheim, Germany

3,807. werner kiesewetter

feldkirchen, Austria

3,808. lisa stein

heidelberg, Germany

3,809. Savina Parolini

Muggiò, Italy

3,810. Nadine Roder

Brackenheim, Germany

Please stopp, stopp,stopp

3,811. Sylvia Kiesewetter Berlin, Germany 3,812. Ana Bello Castillo

Belgrade, Serbia And Montenegro

3,813. Richard Gorissen

Rotterdam, Netherlands

3,814. Remo Vifian

Rothrist, Switzerland

3,815. Penni Norman

Des Moines, IA

3,816. Manuela Oliveira

Porto, Portugal

3,817. Sandra Büchi

Zürich, Switzerland

Stop it!!!!

3,818. David Grimsell

Lampeter, United Kingdom

Capture of dolphins tears them from their families, involves killing of others, and results in a short, miserable life in captivity. This is uncivilised, cruel and unnecessary and Egypt needs to prevent it.

3,819. Uwe Beyer

Wedel, Germany

3,820. aly taha

cairo, Egypt

3,821. Joanna Frusher

Brighton, United Kingdom

3,822. Daniela Taschwer Villach, Austria 3,823. Karin Schiedeck

DO NOT KEEP DOLPHINS in any artificial surroundings. The Sea (and we divers) need them in the sea and not in some pools or in some ridiculous aquariums.

Erkelenz, Germany Page 154

-

Signatures 3,798 - 3,823

Name

From

Comments

3,824. julie selby

london, United Kingdom

3,825. Edda Hosiner

Vienna, Austria

Why do you need to get dolphins from Japan ?! There are enough dolphins at the Red Sea already !!!

3,826. Martin Teichmann Potsdam, Germany

Its unbelievable how humans treat thier environment. Dolphins aren`t our ownership!

3,827. Renate Baumann

Kelkheim, Germany

3,828. Anita van der Wal

Amersfoort, Netherlands

3,829. Alia Ammar

Cairo, Egypt

3,830. P COLLIER

Whalley, United Kingdom

3,831. Iwona Janeczko

Warsaw, Poland

3,832. Susan Hoskam

Ammerzoden, Netherlands

3,833. Lara Meuli

Cairo, Egypt

3,834. Susan Graham

Bournemouth, United Kingdom

Please, please stop this terrible cruelty.

3,835. Jason Clarke

Southampton, United Kingdom

Dolphins belong in the sea not captivity. Please put a stop to this practice immediately

3,836. joanne wright

Oldham, United Kingdom

STOP THIS NOW.

3,837. Daniela Wanner

Wohlen, Switzerland

3,838. Christiane Flechtner

Berlin, Germany

3,839. Linda Burr

Southampton, United Kingdom

Dolphins and whales belong in the ocean not in a pool where they lead boring sterile lives. Let them be free.

3,840. Ernest Condillac

cairo, Egypt

This is inhumane and a grave atrocity!

3,841. sharon gates

Independance, MO

3,842. Marco Glauser

1043, Switzerland

Shame on them!

3,843. Sanja Belgrade, Serbia And Radovinovic-Tasic Montenegro 3,844. Claudia Sopp

Ostheim, Germany

3,845. Virgilio Morichi

Panania Nsw, Australia

3,846. Miriam Nierwitzki

Bönen, Germany

3,847. Dennis Hutton

Reading, United Kingdom

3,848. Pensee Afifi

Cairo, Egypt

Let the nature in peace

3,849. Wolfgang Schmidt Neustadt, Germany Page 155

-

Signatures 3,824 - 3,849

Name

From

Comments

3,850. kay Bichener

Bedford, United Kingdom

3,851. Ellen Gutfleisch

Lisbon, WI

3,852. Olivia GERARD

Pto Del Carmen, Lanzarote, Spain

3,853. Adrienne Young

Denver, CO

3,854. Adam Ackermann

Hallerndorf, Germany

3,855. Caroline Gillings

Dover, United Kingdom

3,856. Dalia Ghanem

San Diego, CA

3,857. Husain Salah

New york, NY

3,858. Andreas Heck

Gau-Odernheim, Germany

3,859. hesham gabr

Sharm, Egypt

this is the result of ignorance , corruption and greed

3,860. Nick Bruton

Bristol, United Kingdom

Dolphins should be free to roam not kept in tanks that are far too small for them

3,861. TRACEY ONEILL

Rathmines, Ireland

its shocking fireworks only be sold to people over 21 young people abuse them and torture cats and dogs its horrible

3,862. Justine Ephgrave

Leighton buzzard, United Kingdom

3,863. Idalia Rauchfleisz

Gdynia, Poland

3,864. shirene roberts

ditchingham, United Kingdom

3,865. Isabel Spring

Northwich, United Kingdom

3,866. Theresa Beasley

Cambridgeshire, United Kingdom

3,867. Christine Kita

Glastonbury, United Kingdom

3,868. Amy Cartwright

Norwich, United Kingdom

3,869. Gersende ATTIA

SAFAGA, Egypt

Their place is the sea not a pool. WOuld you be happy you as human that someone stuck you in the sea with no point of return.... Think about those poor dolphins closed in a dirty pool without enought space to move and get develop on proper way....

3,870. Yvonne Clarke

Greenwood, Canada

Unbelievable cruelty all over the world...let us respect these creatures so that they can be amongst us for years to come..let them roam free as the Gods intended.

Page 156

Delphins were born to live free in oceans and seas, not to be slaves in aquarium to entairtain mindless people while more mindless people make money on their back. Shame on you.

These beautiful creatures belong in the sea where nature intended, not in a private pool so small it is cruelty at its worse, I hope and pray they are rescued in time :( :( :( :(

Disgraceful. Shameful. Cruel. Sadly though I am not surprised by it. It must stop immediately :-/

-

Until one animal will be held captive on the planet Mother Earth will still be in pain . In service of the 7 generations to come and all life on the Earth Mother and beyond, Kita.

Signatures 3,850 - 3,870

Name

From

Comments

3,871. Wilfried Jakob

Ettlingen, Germany

3,872. Willem Kop

Sharm el Sheikh, Egypt

3,873. Matthias Breit

Hurghada, Egypt

3,874. hossam helmy

marsa alam, Egypt

3,875. botros youssef

marsa alam, Egypt

3,876. Suzanne Nichols

HULL, United Kingdom

3,877. shokry selim

sharm elsheikh, Egypt

dolphin should be free ‫دوﻠﻒ ﻟازﻢ أﻦ ﻳﻜوﻦ ﺣﺮ‬

3,878. Jennifer Murphy

Owen Sound, Canada

It's time to take a stand. We have to stop this, and teach future generations that the exploitation of animals will not be accepeted. Lets put these horrific acts of cruelty as a lesson, in our history....

3,879. Paolo Gioberti

Hurghada, Egypt

Good Job ! I Love you all

3,880. clive wilsom

manchester, United Kingdom

Disgraceful, As a diver who travels to egypt I find it disgusting that these creatures are kept this way. set them free and make money by taking tourists on boat trips to see them.

3,881. sylvie caron

dahab, Egypt

3,882. Helene Kalamian

Hurghada, Egypt

3,883. maria cristina boella

sharm el sheikh, Egypt

3,884. Jessica Krüger

Düsseldorf, Germany

3,885. Hans Weiland

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

3,886. Martin Kessler

Krefeld, Germany

3,887. Kerstin Ehlert

Goettingen, Germany

3,888. Joëlle Roger

Bouaye, France

3,889. Rene Jass

Berlin, Germany

3,890. Magdalena Szymanska

El Gouna, Egypt

3,891. maurer serge

Mittelhausen, France

3,892. Zeinab Kamal

Giza, Egypt

3,893. Christiane Sturm

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

3,894. Hazem Metwally

Doha, Egypt

These people have no idea what they are doing to tourism in Egypt!

There is no need to write a comment, it is clear that animals belong in their natural habitat and not in small pools and cages just to satisfy human pleasure. Not only in Egypt! Its a shame!!!!!!!!!!

mais à quoi pense ces gens,il faut tout faire pour arreter ça

pls stop this right now!!!!!

3,895. Laila Popper-Harb Werne, Germany Page 157

-

Signatures 3,871 - 3,895

Name

From

Comments

3,896. peter kraft

mainz, Germany

3,897. suzanne reemers

weesp, Netherlands

3,898. Wadi Lahami

cairo, Egypt

3,899. Matthew Lafontaine

dahab, Egypt

3,900. Sanne Bos

Ziets, Netherlands

I am going to Egypt to spot some (free) dolphins,but now that I am reading this..it breaks my heart.I never knew that Egypt kept dolphins in such terrible condition.

3,901. Dorothy Charles

Aberdare, United Kingdom

This horrible abuse of living creatues must be stopped. What right do people have to do this?

3,902. Aurora Goodall

National City, CA

3,903. Alicy Lima

Silvolde, Netherlands

3,904. monka blanke

Hasselt, Belgium

3,905. Salomon Morales

National City, CA

3,906. Louise Bennett

So Portland, ME

3,907. Claire Smith

paignton, United Kingdom

3,908. Mercy Hehuat

Dahab, Egypt

this is for Egypt,a country that supports a lot of divers/marine life enthousiasts, an awful thing to allow. please think about it to take the right actions. many thanks Mercy

3,909. renee watt-hayes

beaverton, OR

why?

3,910. Cas Willemsen

Doetinchem, Netherlands

This is shocking and the shame of humankind,it makes me sick to see such beautiful animals in a dirty,stinking pool!

3,911. Benz Gabriela

Frankfurt am Main, Germany

3,912. rossana massone

sharm el sheikh, Egypt

3,913. Emese Liliom

Budapest, Hungary

3,914. Penny Orford

Sharm el Sheikh, Egypt

3,915. mourad mikhail

Dahab, Egypt

3,916. sherifa el mofty

cairo, Egypt

3,917. Solveig Bach

Hurghada, Egypt

3,918. joseph h.abdallah

hurghada, Egypt

Page 158

That is not a pool,it is an open sewer,look at the dirty water,unbelievable that Egypt allow this I would never visit Egypt when these conditions for the poor dolphins don't change.I love the ancient history that Egypt has to offer,but I can read books about it,but to see this horror of the poor dolphins I will never forget.

This is just horrendous! How cruel!

...no comment!!! Where is respect to living beeings gone?????

-

Signatures 3,896 - 3,918

Name

From

Comments

3,919. Patrycja Piskorska

gdynia, Poland

3,920. Ramadan Diver

Hurghada, Egypt

3,921. Jennifer Kehr

Eagan, MN

3,922. max mustang

amsterdam, Netherlands

3,923. Sharon Sim

Congleton, United Kingdom

3,924. Rene Suchan

Vienna, Austria

3,925. Verena Köhler

Gablitz, Austria

3,926. John Diver

Hurghada, Egypt

3,927. moumen nabata

safaga, Egypt

3,928. SYLVIE MONTAGNON

Huningue, France

3,929. Claire Mortimer

Mansfield Woodhouse, United Kingdom

3,930. estelle cornio

villedieu, France

please...

3,931. Hossam Osman

sharm el sheikh, Egypt

if they calculate how much money the government will make keeping the dolphins free compared to the money they will make selling them.. i guess it is clear.. be smart let the dolphin free

3,932. James Saunders

Henlow, United Kingdom

3,933. Tina Gosenson

Landgraaf, Netherlands

3,934. Adolfo Maciocco

07026, Italy

3,935. Donna Farr

San Antonio, TX

3,936. Jindra Cechova

Praha, Czech Republic

3,937. MARIA LUZ WILHELM

Santiago, Chile

3,938. riham tarek

cairo, Egypt

3,939. Laona Jones

Perth, Australia

Page 159

Most of us live in spaces bigger than clothes closets and dolphins do not belong in swimming pools or oceanariums to serve as entertainment. Let us be merciful, responsible stewards and allow them to live as intended.

Please stop that immediately, let them free!

Dolphin should be left in the ocean where they belong. Stop captureing them!!

just get them out of there, what is wrong with ppl dont they see there wrongs??...i bet they do and they dont care, you all disgust me...

-

Signatures 3,919 - 3,939

Name

From

Comments

3,940. Susan Nieto-Butterman

Winton, CA

This is inhumane practice, please stop this selling of dolphins and sending them to areas they are not normally use to and the survival is slimmer for them, why would these places in Europe purchase them to begin with????

3,941. Matthias Kropp

Fronreute-staig, Germany

3,942. le tirilly tiphaine

Quimper, France

3,943. Cordula Johnson

Tracy, CA

3,944. Christian Schoettler

Safaga, Egypt

3,945. Annick Maurer

Leinefelde, Germany

3,946. Anna Seppala

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

3,947. Sterckx Martine

Florée, Belgium

3,948. Albert Wim

Elgouna, Egypt

3,949. Amr Ibrahim

Hurghada, Egypt

3,950. Csilla Páll

Hosszúpályi, Hungary

STOP ALL CRUELTY TO ANIMALS! HAVE COMPASSION TO ANIMAL! ANIMALS NEED OUR HELP, NOT PAIN!

3,951. Phillip Alun Evans Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt 3,952. Vifian Johann

Hurghada, Egypt

3,953. Tom Buik

Marsa Alam, Egypt

3,954. Mauro Barocci

Sharm el Sheikh, Egypt

3,955. adel labib

hurghada, Egypt

3,956. Silvia Martin

Dahab, Egypt

3,957. Marcus Zander

14621, Germany

3,958. jc behra

Aubagne, France

3,959. Marta Prusisz-Hassan

El Gouna, Egypt

3,960. Salma Khalil

Cairo, Egypt

3,961. Patricia Perret

Dahab, Egypt

A am sad that Egyptian authorities do agreement with Japan in this way, Japan respecting NO any marine life. If the objective is to attract more tourists in Egypt, better to invest in cleaning programs which will be more efficient in long term.

3,962. roberta santucci

Condove (Torino), Italy

Stop dolphin captivity in Egypt!

3,963. Patrick Fuerst

Sigmaringen, Germany Page 160

Definitely unacceptable!

-

Signatures 3,940 - 3,963

Name

From

Comments

3,964. Tarek Elkhayat

Sharm Elsheikh, Egypt

they need our help

3,965. khaled ramadan

sharm el sheikh, Egypt

show some mercey to these beutifull poor animals

3,966. Aline Depétris Macedo

Itararé, Brazil

3,967. Esther Hesselink

Scharnegoutum, Netherlands

3,968. Natasha Farag

Hurghada, Egypt

3,969. New Waves Sharm el Sheikh

Sharm el Sheikh, Egypt

3,970. Christophe Koehren

Entzheim, France

3,971. Sabrina Vossen

Safaga, Egypt

3,972. RONALD SHARM EL SHEIKH, GARBACCIO GILI Egypt

PLEASE , stop the captivity of dolphins in Egypt.

3,973. Maged Mostafa

hurghada, Egypt

FREE the dolphins NOW pleas....

3,974. Adham Taweela

Cairo, Egypt

3,975. szilvia szollosi

Budapest, Hungary

3,976. Tanis Newman

Dahab, Egypt

3,977. monique van aanholt

raamsdonksveer, Netherlands

3,978. Anna Maria Alexi

Göteborg, Sweden

3,979. Brit Sopora

Hamburg, Germany

3,980. Cono oops

Xx, France

3,981. Anna Emich

Lelystad, Netherlands

3,982. Veronika Strelskaya

Perth, Australia

3,983. Kata Mészáros

Budapest, Hungary

3,984. Roy Sharma

Lydney, United Kingdom

3,985. moreau vanessa

Chemire, France

3,986. Marika Laghi

Hurghada, Egypt

3,987. Jean-Pierre Vandergooten

Zaventem, Belgium

3,988. Steen Paul

Meerbeke, Belgium Page 161

I hope i could help.

I feel for dolphins and it´s abbusing to make such a criminal use of them I sned my Love to the dolphins. Be brave.

These are truly wild mammals - not fair to imprison them. At least they survived without getting eaten. However - I fear they may never be fit to go back in to the wild now - so may have to be kept somewhere? What do the experts say?

Interdiction totale des dauphins en captivité

-

Signatures 3,964 - 3,988

Name

From

Comments

3,989. Niamh Moran

Meath, Ireland

3,990. Sper Karolien

Geraardsbergen, Belgium

3,991. Agnes Hall

Langwarrin Victoria, Australia

3,992. Alita Greeff

Sharm el Sheikh, Egypt

3,993. Wendy Gehrig

Surat Thani, Thailand

3,994. Margit Burk

Frankenhardt, Germany

3,995. Alyona Roudakova

Hurghada, Egypt

3,996. jade owen

Widnes, United Kingdom

3,997. Pauline de Jong

Leusden, Netherlands Please remember that a dolphin in captivity can't give you as much as when they live in freedom, like everybody. We can receive much more joy and unconditional love from the dolphins when they live in freedom. Go to swim with them, connect to them (you can use a picture for it) to feel what they give us. Please let everybody live free, so we can receive more of who they are.(not olny the dolphins)

3,998. kerry west

west sussex, United Kingdom

3,999. Rainer Grzeca

Hannover, Germany

4,000. Tanja Edert

Westerland / Sylt, Germany

4,001. leeg ox

pen an bed, France

4,002. Lawrence Cummingsw

School Aycliffe, United Kingdom

4,003. André Danioff

Wuppertal, Germany

4,004. Ingrid El-Kabbani

Dahab, Egypt

4,005. Tamas Szamos

Budapest, Hungary

4,006. Ameli Geisser

Bamberg, Germany

4,008. steve mills

Dahab, Egypt

4,009. Sara Strebel

Niederlenz, Switzerland

4,010. heidi quéro

Clairefontaine, France Page 162

These very highly intelligent, sensitive, active, life loving,communicative, gregarious creatures entertain on average more "human" characteristics than many so called civilised human beings..........give them the FREEDOM and PEACE they require and deserve.

We don't need this cruelty - we have the most beautiful sea here in Egypt.

Insupportable!!! -

Signatures 3,989 - 4,010

Name

From

Comments

4,011. Dick van Zomeren Heerlen, Netherlands 4,012. Rana Mahmoud

Cairo, Egypt

4,013. Willi Wagner

Troisdorf, Germany

4,014. Larry Newcomb

Jacksonville, FL

4,015. chris armstrong

sharm el sheikh, Egypt

4,016. agnes malcsiner

budapest, Hungary

4,017. Helene Skovbjerg Jakobsen

Aarhus N, Denmark

4,018. Morin Mickael

Angers, France

4,019. Inger Kohn

Dublin, Ireland

4,020. Deniz Ertin

Köln, Germany

4,021. Hannelore Haßfurter

München, Germany

4,022. Shamel Sheta

Alexandria, Egypt

4,023. Claudia Breitenbach

Wuppertal, Germany

4,024. Gaby Zwimpfer

Sursee, Switzerland

4,025. April McCormack

Dahab, Egypt

4,026. Martina Quix

Duesseldorf, Germany

4,027. Mayada sayed

new york, NY

4,028. Dirk Oberhaus

Leverkusen, Germany

4,029. Yuri Demidanov

Nizhny Novgorod, Russian Federation

4,030. Andrey Tashirev

Syktyvkar, Russian Federation

4,031. Katharina Eichelbaum

Neunkirchen, Germany

4,032. Peggy Schramm

Waukegan, IL

4,033. Elina Velichko

Kiev, Ukraine

4,034. K Said

borehamwood, United Kingdom

4,035. Stacy Stehle

Thornton, CO

4,036. Hellen Lopulua

mierlo, Netherlands

4,037. Johanna Miettunen

Helsinki, Finland

Page 163

Dolphins are to important for dolphins and humanity to accept this!!!

Please stop this stupid idea! There is no need for a dolphinarium....

-

Signatures 4,011 - 4,037

Name

From

Comments

4,038. Yulia Antonova

Moscow, Russian Federation

Stop it!!!! let dolphins live in nature!

4,039. Irina Karpovich

Minsk, Belarus

4,040. Jens Neuhäuser

Magdeburg, Germany

4,041. Vadim Kudryavtsev

Moscow, Russian Federation

4,042. Hamdy Samy's iMac

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

4,043. Beth Doherty

Lisburn, United Kingdom

4,044. Polina Ponomarenko

Montreal, Canada

4,045. liz sinnecker

stuttgart, Germany

4,046. Anton Zabaronok

Saint-Petersburg, Russian Federation

4,047. Ella Chugunova

Moskov, Russian Federation

4,048. Anett Püski

Debrecen, Hungary

Save dolphins!

4,049. Marlon Meierhöfer Heidelberg, Germany

Dolphins belong in the sea!

4,050. Mennette Holwerda

Rozendaal, Netherlands

let the dolphins free in nature where they belong!

4,051. virginie charbonnier

Nice, France

4,052. stephane gragnic

Epinay Sur Seine, France

4,053. Dmitry Osipov

Moscow, Russian Federation

4,054. Graziana Barsocchi

Milano, Italy

If you love something, set it free..... If you don't, let it go...

4,055. Mokrov Alexander Moscow, Russian Federation 4,056. Rainer Pitschel

Stuttgart, Germany

4,057. krisztina m

budapest, Hungary

4,058. Karin Meinecke

freiburg, Germany

4,059. Seaforce Nexusdiving

cairo, Egypt

4,060. barbara bordiehn

hurghada, Egypt

4,061. Bernardo Kramb

Leverkusen, Germany

Unbelievable. Stop it immediately!!!

4,062. Irmgard Neubauer Erkelenz, Germany 4,063. aya alaa

Cairo, Egypt Page 164

-

Signatures 4,038 - 4,063

Name 4,064. Elsafy Ibrahim

From

Comments

Red Sea, Egypt

this is very unfair,

4,065. PAUL Vierendeels Hurghada, Egypt 4,066. Ronald Veider

Axams, Austria

4,067. monica farrell

Vienna, VA

4,068. Youssef Faltas

Cairo, Egypt

4,069. Geoffrey Graham

Market Rasen, United Please stop the capture of Dolphins from the wild for Kingdom imprisonment in cruel, unhealthy condistions.

4,070. donna partridge

wolverhampton, United Kingdom

4,071. Cath Inanir

Fethiye, Turkey

4,072. EVE VAN HAVERMAET

HAACHT, Belgium

4,073. Markus Nußbaumer

84524, Germany

Stop dolphin captivity in Egypt!

4,074. michelle strudwick Portland, United Kingdom 4,075. Christina Kennedy Sheffield, United Kingdom 4,076. VERONICA ZARATE

THE WOODLANDS, TX

4,077. Virginie Rimbert

hamata, Egypt

4,078. Maxim Kazant

SPB, Russian Federation

4,079. susi aasal

hurghada, Egypt

4,080. shaun fox

hurghada, Egypt

4,081. Dieter Franz

Breitengüßbach, Germany

4,082. Larisa Kuzora

Odessa, Ukraine

4,083. Julie Butche

Newfoundland, PA

4,084. Esther Vogel

Wilen bei Wil, Switzerland

4,085. Victoria Hope

Swansea, United Kingdom

4,086. Tarik A.Fatah

Dahab, Egypt

4,087. Helge Lydorf

Grossrosseln, Germany

4,088. Myriam Benzing

Safaga, Egypt Page 165

Mr The Governor of the Red Sea, please, these dolphins need your help !! This is unbearable. The Red Sea is so rich with wild animals that the behaviour of this Hurgahda owner is an insult to your country. Virginie Rimbert

Dolphins belong in the wild and it's just sickening to see them in such confined conditions and even worse are the methods used to catch them. Along with the numbers who are slaughtered in the process! STOP STOP STOP!!!!!!

-

Signatures 4,064 - 4,088

Name

From

Comments

4,089. Jochen Philipp

München, Germany

4,090. Kathy Zeller

Candler, NC

4,091. Judith Gromes

Berlin, Germany

4,092. Dianne Lynn Elko

New Brighton, PA

4,093. Claudia FELLRATH

Oberhausbergen, France

4,094. Corinne Lavis

Almunecar, Spain

4,095. Alexandra Mironova

P-Kamchatskiy, Russian Federation

4,096. Tamara Bakhlycheva

Irvine, CA

4,097. henry Dobler

Eppenberg, Switzerland

4,098. Khaled elshawarby

maadi, Egypt

4,099. Radwa Ismail

Cairo, Egypt

4,100. Markus Fritsche

Hurghada, Egypt

4,101. Laszlo Nagy

Budapest, Hungary

4,102. Laura Santoni

Marbella, Spain

4,103. helican ingrid

Le Teil, France

4,104. Ruth Roellin

zug, Switzerland

4,105. Susanne Stinner

Duisburg, Germany

4,106. Karina gillado

Makati, Philippines

4,107. Karina Paller

Ljubljana, Slovenia

4,108. Dominic Giles

Weston-super-Mare, United Kingdom

4,109. L Wharton

Runcorn, United Kingdom

4,110. Claudia Reif

Rödermark, Germany

4,111. Eugen Kraus

Muenchen, Germany

4,112. Marguerite Pelt

Lelystad, Netherlands I firmly object to dolphin captivity.

4,113. lia Friedrich

Waiblingen, Germany

4,114. Slava Vlasov

*, Russian Federation

4,115. Bianca Richter

Friedberg, Germany

4,116. Zsanett Nagy

BERETTYOUJFALU, Hungary Page 166

An ocean without dolphins is like a garden without flowers...Please stop captiviting the dolphins. Their place is not in a delfinarium...never.

Please, do something about this situation. I'm sure it does no good to the image of Egypt in the eye of European and American tourists.

-

Signatures 4,089 - 4,116

Name

From

Comments

4,117. Diana Boesenberg

Essen, Germany

4,118. daniela bellapianta

montesilvano, Italy

4,119. may samy

sharm el sheikh, Egypt

4,120. Ehab El Meligy

oslo, Norway

4,121. Beatrix Pelzer

Hamburg, Germany

4,122. Sandra Altherr

Munich, Germany

4,123. Leslie Aros

Toronto, Canada

4,124. Dina Mehrez

Giza, Egypt

Save the dolphins!

4,125. gary durrell

felixstowe, United Kingdom

poor creatures they don`t deserve that

4,126. Pauline Cousins

Gwent., United Kingdom

I am in total support of this petition. This is so totally cruel, these four beautiful and intelligent bottlenose dolphins should be incarserated in such heinous conditions. These creatures should be free where they belong, in their oceans.

4,127. Rana Osman

Cairo, Egypt

4,128. Rosita Khalifa

Hurghada, Egypt

4,129. RAF WISSA

sharm, Egypt

4,130. Anna Kosali

Istanbul, Turkey

4,131. Christian Heylen

Liège, Belgium

4,132. Sabine Weber

Traunstein, Germany

PLEASE STOP IMMEDIATELY!

4,133. Juergen Fahl

Groß Boden, Germany

Free the dolphins!

4,134. Amr Aboulfath

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

4,135. annmarie mendoza

Portage, IN

4,136. Vlad Zelikov

Moscow, Russian Federation

4,137. Becky Davis

Gloucester, United Kingdom

4,138. Mahmoud Maklad

rehab, Egypt

4,139. BOURDIER MARYLENE

Pessac, France

4,140. Veronique Jirgal

Hurghada, Egypt

4,141. Marta Lesinska

Lomianki, Poland Page 167

The situation of these four poor creatures is totally unacceptable! And it is only the tip of the iceberg of a dirty industry - the dolphinaria.

plz stop this now befor they die becuz what happining is unfair for the dolphins

Please help these beautiful animals. Show the rest of the world that Egypt does care and respect animals.

-

Signatures 4,117 - 4,141

Name

From

Comments

4,142. Luna Boldischar

Augsburg, Germany

4,143. Maria Caterina Venturini

San Marino, San Marino

4,144. Mennatallah Nada Cairo, Egypt 4,145. francesco Poddighe

Turin, Italy

4,146. Danica Rushing

Destin, FL

4,147. Omar Ezzat

Cairo, Egypt

4,148. Carine Sabbagh

Cairo, Egypt

4,149. Kerstin Klimt

Vienna, Austria

4,150. Karim Moussa

cairo, Egypt

4,151. Theresa Nasralla

Cairo, Egypt

4,152. wendy lopez

MIAMI, FL

4,153. stephanie espino

Miami, FL

4,154. Pavel Pokrovskiy

Koh Tao, Thailand

4,155. Hind Al Ghalayini

Cairo, Egypt

4,156. Jessie McInroy

Waukee, IA

4,157. ezequiel grillo

miami, FL

4,158. Doris rberger

altmünster, Austria

4,159. Audrey Watson

Sorrento, Australia

4,160. Casey Johnson

Mooroopna, Australia

4,161. Mikhail Moiseev

Moscow, Russian Federation

4,162. OGIER andré

Rochefort, France

4,163. giorgio pini

sharm el sheikh, Egypt

4,164. Michael Mattiszik

St.Augustin, Germany

4,165. Stefan Schwenke

Waldbronn, Germany

4,166. Reetta Hänninen

Niemisjärvi, Finland

4,167. Salah Elmenshawi

Sharm El Shiekh, Egypt

4,168. Vitaly Shurupov

Murmansk, Russian Federation

4,169. Linzey Miceli

Grande Prairie, Canada

4,170. Bianca Leister

Hurghada, Egypt

4,171. martin müller

Frankfurt, Germany

Page 168

They were born free .... Let them free again .... This is not their right place .... Please return them to the sea ....

SSTTTTTTTTTTTTOOOOOOOOOOPPPPPPPPPPPPP

save the whales

strong urgent reaction should be done aginst those peapole other waise they learn the peapole to couch dolphins

-

Signatures 4,142 - 4,171

Name

From

Comments

4,172. Egor Shh

Cher, Russian Federation

4,173. Julia Litvyakova

S-Petersburg, Russian Federation

4,174. Justine Hollyer

London, United Kingdom

4,175. Martin Martson

New York, NY

4,176. Cutino Anne-Marie

France, France

4,177. Peter Hauser

Moorenweis, Germany

These cruel conditions must be stopped and the people responsible punished

I spend my holiday for more than 15 years now in Egypt. If I will hear more of these cruel I will stop visiting Egypt for holiday. Same with sharks. Both, dolphins and sharks are mostly important for benefit in the (red) see. Believe me, diving tourists will coming to see free dolphins and sharks. They won't see them in a aquarium.

4,178. Mahmoud Ibrahim hurghada-red sea, Egypt 4,179. girault jenny

lisieux, France

4,180. Yvonne Abdel-Al

Wedel, Germany

4,181. Elfriede Bradley

Duesseldorf, Germany

4,182. heba el begawi

cairo, Egypt

4,183. amber newman

walsham le willows, United Kingdom

4,184. Sabine Weigert

Regensburg, Germany

4,185. Val McDonagh

Coleraine, United Kingdom

4,186. Anna Zhelnina

perm, Russian Federation

4,187. Sara Othman

Cairo, Egypt

4,188. Martin Abza

Braunschweig, Germany Page 169

stop doing stupid things for money!!! our childrens children want to see nature not zoos!!! Man made pools are no place for one of the Greatest creations on this planet. It is an insult to God that man should be so greedy and selfish as to want to prosper from taking away the very reason for these animals to live. Dolphins were created to wander the oceans in family groups free from fear or predation from Humans. Egypt is a wonderful country with compassionate and intelligent country men and women, please do not allow anyone to build dolphinarium. Your coast is wonderful and the magic is that dolphins are all around the Red Sea coast, if you protect them and their food source then you will attract intelligent sensible visitors who will spend money with local boat owners to see the real lives of Dolphins - free in the seas expressing joy for life.

Appalling!

-

Signatures 4,172 - 4,188

Name

From

Comments

4,189. Christine Weiel

Schwarzach, Germany

4,190. b donoghue

waltham, United Kingdom

4,191. CLAUDE MARECHAL

RIBERAC, France

4,192. Helen Sayde

Nelson, United Kingdom

4,193. Stefanie Schmitz

Oberhausen, Germany

Les dauphins en liberté attirent beaucoup de plongeurs en Egypte. Si les dauphins sont prisonniers nous plongerons dans un autre pays

it is already not natural

4,194. François Lusignan Libreville, Gabon

The most stupid human act of the year !! I hope that Egyptian authorities will stop this soon ...

4,195. Stephanie Kadel

Weinheim, Germany

4,196. augusto alexis

st amans valtoret, France

4,197. Gilan Kamal

Cairo, Egypt

4,198. Sameh Halawa

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

4,199. Ananda Rousseau

St Helier, Jersey, United Kingdom

4,200. Noah Heinz

Eppelborn, Germany

4,201. Tunde Veres

Berettyóújfalu, Hungary

4,202. mowa awosika

sharm el sheikh, Egypt

4,203. Cordelia Longworth

Cullompton, United Kingdom

4,204. Ute Bohnenschäfer

hamburg, Germany

4,205. Holly Griffiths

Aberdyfi, United Kingdom

4,206. Helen Leahey

little, Germany

4,207. Natalia Evstratenko

Moscow, Russian Federation

4,208. Tobias Lege

Buchholz, Germany

4,209. RUSSELL GREEN

SHEFFIELD, United Kingdom

4,210. clare hutchinson

newcastle-upon-tyne, United Kingdom Page 170

This has to be stopped!!! Please post on your walls in facebook, lets make a big deal out of this because its a HUGE deal. Egypt relies on tourism, Divers will stop coming if this continues!

mir fehlen die Worte...

Let the nature live as it wish!

-

DOLPHINS ARE SOCIAL FAMILY MAMMALS, AND SHOULD NEVER BE CAGED IN ANY WAY

Signatures 4,189 - 4,210

Name

From

Comments

4,211. benoit chandans

paris, France

STOP !!!

4,212. Roman Pellegrini

Jenbach, Austria

4,213. Thomas Voshage

Hannover, Germany

4,214. Shady Ehab

cairo, Egypt

i can't believe that such beautiful creatures deserves that some assholes capture them and keep them in captivity, so lame really

4,215. CANDACE LUFFMAN

Ocala, FL

I WOULD LIKE TO SEE ALL DOLPHINS BE RELEAST FROM CAPTIVITY IN JAPAN & IN EGYPT.all whales & DOLPHINS are suspose to be all free.not in captivity.this is also to sat all DOLPHINS & WHALES FREE.

4,216. Arndt Bohne

Neuenkirchen, Germany

4,217. Adeline Boncompain

Pezens, France

4,218. emad edward

Cairo, Egypt

4,219. antonella verrigni

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

4,220. laura bourgain

mont saint aignan, France

4,221. Evgenyi Bulatov

Miass, Russian Federation

4,222. risa crabtree

Albuquerque, NM

4,223. Acsai Marianna

Budapest, Hungary

4,224. Hans Dilthey

Maadi, Cairo, Egypt

4,225. Sabine Braun

Hurghada, Egypt

4,226. veronique gaillot

tocane st apre, France

4,227. jeanette Hanna

Folkestone, United Kingdom

4,228. Rebecca Cullern

london, United Kingdom

4,229. roberta malavenda

reggio calabria, Italy

4,230. yasmine nagui

cairo, Egypt

4,231. Omar Haridy

Cairo, Egypt

its not fun to watch caged animals, i would never take my kids to such kind of amusement shows

4,232. Aguilar Liberto

AUSSILLON, France

Les sejours plongees se feront plus rares en mer rouge !!!!

4,233. Katalin Seregi

Hurghada, Egypt

4,234. chris cureton

wallasey, United Kingdom

4,235. Ibolya Baczkó

Budapest, Hungary Page 171

Please STOP it

these animals should be observed in their natural habitat and not kept in such poor conditions

-

Signatures 4,211 - 4,235

Name

From

Comments

4,236. Maria Laura Rodriguez

New York, NY

4,237. L Tyler

London, United Kingdom

STOP ALL CRUELTY TO NATURE NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! JUST BECAUSE THEY CAN'T TALK, DOESN'T MAKE THEM LESS REAL

4,238. Terry Nichols

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

F!*@king disgraceful!!

4,239. M Thomason

Houston, TX

You disgrace yourselves and your country by allowing this.

4,240. leah hazlehurst

stockport, United Kingdom

4,241. FREDERIC LOMBARD

SAFAGA, Egypt

4,242. Claire Barker

Ipswich, United Kingdom

4,243. Ernő Kiss

Budapest, Hungary

4,244. Godfried Kleinsmann

Lelystad, Netherlands Back to the sea with the Dolphins, now

4,245. milenko atanackovic

New York, NY

4,246. Bertus Vlietstra

Amsterdam Z.O., Netherlands

4,247. peter benei

budapest, Hungary

4,248. Nevine Salvade

Scottsdale, AZ

4,249. Derya Beyatli

Nicosia, Cyprus

4,250. Phala Bowles

Staunton, VA

4,251. kathy Cunningham

Killybegs, Ireland

4,252. Ivan Ulrich

Rothenthurm, Switzerland

CRAZY !!!!!!! EST L'EGYPTE EST L'INVITE D'HONNEUR AU SALON DE LA PLONGEE DE PARIS EN JANVIER 2011......IL FAUT EN CHANGER !!!

There are enough wild dolphins in the redsea, if people want to see them, Hire a boat, this will support also the community of Hurghada

All dolphinariums should be stopped. For god's sake animals are not our slaves!

4,253. Alexandra Melmer Oetztal Bahnhof, Austria 4,254. Denis Durrant

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

4,255. saLMA ESSAM

CAIRO, Egypt

4,256. bernadette bouckaert

Waterloo, Belgium

4,257. bruyere anne

Bruxelles, Belgium

4,258. Hugues Delaisse

Tubize, Belgium

Page 172

Let us hope that anyone involved with this outrage dies screaming!!! would you like to be in a cell ? no. those animals re as intelligents as humans!!

-

Signatures 4,236 - 4,258

Name

From

Comments

4,259. marie kapp

Oberschaeffolsheim, France

4,260. Anna Schmauser

Ellingen, Germany

4,261. Alwin Günster

Öpfingen, Germany

4,262. Dalila Keller

Augsburg, Germany

4,263. isabelle girault

sikasso, Mali

4,264. monica saarisalo

hurghada, Egypt

4,265. Pierre Defoy

Brussels, Belgium

4,266. danijel zambo

augsburg, Germany

4,267. jessica de vecchi

sharm el sheikh, Egypt

4,268. Nesrin Amin

Exeter, United Kingdom

4,269. Noha Marei

cairo, Egypt

4,270. yulia shiryaeva

simferopol, Ukraine

4,271. Miriam Salah

Cairo, Egypt

4,272. sanna ristimäki

vaasa, Finland

4,273. hatem d.ali

hurghada, Egypt

4,274. Omar El Adl

Cairo, Egypt

4,275. Knut Kroessner

Puebla, Mexico

4,276. Tatiana Yashina

Samara, Russian Federation

4,277. Laila Kheireldin

Hurghada, Egypt

4,278. Menna Elhefawy

Hurghada, Egypt

4,279. Ross van Zanten

Alberton, South Africa

4,280. Seif Shawky

Hurghada, Egypt

4,281. Helen Ellis

Hurghada, Egypt

4,282. Mazen Kandil

Cairo, Egypt

4,283. Toby Prosser

Melbourne, Australia

4,284. Laila Sedky

Cairo, Egypt

4,285. Nicole Schulz

Heilbad Heiligenstadt, Germany

4,286. shelley hunter

belleville, Canada

4,287. Storae Hassas

Hayward, CA Page 173

Please save our global environment, as well those dolphins which have got a much higher IO than some human persons without any respect to the nature

Can't believe that in this century people are still doing stupid things like building a dolphinarium in the middle of the desert next to the sea where u can enjoy them in their natural environment!!!!

dolphin is angle of the sea save them please

-

Signatures 4,259 - 4,287

Name

From

Comments

4,288. Mary Lyn Villaume

Portland, OR

Importing foreign dolphins is crazy. Keeping them in dreadfully inappropriate conditions is unforgiveable. The Egyptian Red Sea is blessed with lovely friendly dolphins. Anyone who wants to see them can go out on a boat and be escorted back in by a local pod. This is a serious ethical and environmental issue. These poor Japanese dolphins should be immediately shipped back to Japan and released in their native environment. The importation of dolphins, and the capture of local ones, should be immediately forbidden by law.

4,289. Vladislav Patsevich

Moscow, Russian Federation

4,290. Doris O'Toole

Freedom, ME

4,291. karim khamis

cairo, Egypt

4,292. Sabine Schreiber

xx, Switzerland

4,293. Rick Smallman

Port Macquarie, Australia

4,294. Reyzvig Olga

Krasnojarsk, Russian Federation

4,295. Samantha Coetzee

Port Elizabeth, South Africa

Just not right!!!!!!

As an ex marine mammal trainer I can tell you now that pool is way too small.

4,296. Yevgen Bessonov Kharkiv, Ukraine

Dolphinarium is simply a prison!

4,297. Simone Baumann

Romanel, Switzerland

4,298. Don Moffat

Bristol, United Kingdom

4,299. Róbert Ormándi

Szeged, Hungary

4,300. Guy LeNoir

Sawyers Valley, Australia

4,301. Malin Ivarsson

Hurghada, Egypt

4,302. Monika Golembiewski

Reinbek, Germany

4,303. Andreas Ketzel

St.augustin, Germany

4,304. luisa casali

rome, Italy

4,305. Mary ivanova

moscow, Russian Federation

4,306. Evdokija Danajloska

Gagny, France

4,307. Lorraine Marsden

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

4,308. Yvonne Eggenberger

Binningen, Switzerland

4,309. Diana Hansch

Bochum, Germany Page 174

Boycott Hurghada until these dolphins are released.

-

Signatures 4,288 - 4,309

Name

From

Comments

4,310. Kristel Aszody

Marsa Alam, Egypt

4,311. Laurice Dee, Ph.D.

Mesa, AZ

4,312. rosaria cescon

palestrina RM, Italy

4,313. Jan Müller

Langenhagen, Germany

I AM TRULY APPALLED, QUITE SHOCKED, AND VERY ANGRY TO HEAR ABOUT THIS! THESE BEAUTIFUL DOLPHINS ARE MEANT TO LIVE IN THEIR NATURAL HOME ENVIRONMENT - THE OPEN SEA - NOT IN A TINY, UNFILTERED SWIMMING POOL LIKE THIS ONE! HEY, THIS POOL IS MUCH SMALLER THAN THE SWIMMING POOL WHERE I DO MY LAPS IN EVERY DAY! I AM NOT SURPRISED TO HEAR THAT THESE DOLPHINS HAVE ALREADY SUFFERED NEEDLESSLY FROM SERIOUS EYE INFECTIONS AND OTHER PROBLEMS SINCE THEY'RE SWIMMING IN THEIR OWN EXCREMENT AND THE CARE IS SO DOWNRIGHT SUBSTANDARD! YOU TRULY NEED TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT THIS RIGHT AWAY AND STOP DOLPHIN CAPTIVITY IN EGYPT ALTOGETHER! (to be continued)

4,314. C.C. van der Meer Abcoude, Netherlands

Please free these dolphins...

4,315. Marion Ulrich-Schuler

Rothenthurm, Switzerland

4,316. bruno Brechler

carnoules, France

4,317. Nicole Graebner

Creussen, Germany

4,318. Jenni Klomberg

Mülheim, Germany

Stop it now!!!! This is not Life.

4,319. debbie mohamed

leeds, United Kingdom

this needs to be stopped, looking at the picture of where they are living disgusts me

4,320. Nermine Dumitrescu

Buhcarest, Romania

4,321. ramona joachim

potsdam, Germany

4,322. Serge Ego

Sleidige, Belgium

4,323. casper Douma

Lelystad, Netherlands Let the dolphins swim in their own habitat. They should export Japanese people to another planet. That's also better for the whales.

just disgusting ...

4,324. Frederic Francken Brussels, Belgium 4,325. mandy schouren

Venlo, Netherlands

4,326. hanady mahmoud cairo, Egypt 4,327. Uwe Dölling

Berlin, Germany

4,328. Cathrin Drewer

Berlin, Germany

4,329. ruggero stagni

segrate, Italy

4,330. Ariane Ammel

München, Germany Page 175

-

Signatures 4,310 - 4,330

Name

From

Comments

4,331. Denise Kooi

Rotterdam, Netherlands

4,332. jean-piere bousse

oostende, Belgium

4,333. cindy eisenhuth

Mitcham, United Kingdom

4,334. Svetlana Umarova

Moscow, Russian Federation

4,335. andree wedehase

Trier, Germany

4,336. nina ellawendy

sharm el sheikh, Egypt

4,337. odile ALIU

douvaine, France

4,338. p sastrowijoto

the hague, Netherlands

4,339. Evgeniya Gromova

Moscow, Russian Federation

4,340. Asli Gedik

A, Germany

4,341. Nadine Girstenbrey

8, Germany

4,342. Franco Cottini

Vercelli, Italy

4,343. stagni claudia

Segrate, Italy

4,344. Steve Weinman

Teddington, United Kingdom

4,345. Lorenzo Michelini

TARCENTO, Italy

4,346. Alla Savina

Moscow, Russian Federation

4,347. Claudia Busch

Augsburg, Germany

4,348. Martina Zambon

Arluno (MI), Italy

4,349. S. Verkennis

Kelpen-Oler, Netherlands

4,350. Luc Michiels

Brecht, Belgium

4,351. Michael Green

Hurghada, Egypt

4,352. Stefanie Kulick

Hurghada, Egypt

4,353. Jamie Honick

snow hill, MD

4,354. Cristian Carbone

Milan, Italy

4,355. Magdi Aziz

Hurghada, Egypt

4,356. grandi lucilla

savona, Italy

4,357. valerie attia

Cairo, Egypt

4,359. Jochen Pohlke

Berlin, Germany

4,360. albert Insomby

Seynod, France Page 176

je suis scandalisé et outré par cet acte cruel et stupide envers ces animaux -

Signatures 4,331 - 4,360

Name

From

Comments

4,361. Daniel Ostermeier Augsburg, Germany 4,362. Fiona Segeren

Breda, Netherlands

4,363. Konstantin Samoilov

Ms, Russian Federation

4,364. Firuzan Ertürk

Köln, Germany

4,365. Julia Colling

Remscheid, Germany

4,366. Rebeka Maticevic

Brusnice, Slovenia

4,367. Julia Volkmer

Bielefeld, Germany

4,368. Kerstin Rupp

Thalmassing, Germany

4,369. Jamie Spartz

West Bend, WI

how can people be so cruel? it's a disgrace for egypt

4,370. Ane Helen Hamza Larvik, Norway

That this happends in Egypt is horrible! Muslims should know better as keeping animals(ALL KINDS) in captivity is strictly forbidden in Islam! so in theory it should be easy to end it!

4,371. reem mokhtar

maadi, Egypt

4,372. clifford pisano

revere, MA

4,373. Andrea Schaul

Brisbane, Australia

4,374. anne hudson

cardiff, United Kingdom

4,375. Jane Sheridan

London, United Kingdom

4,376. Krsitin Jensen

Oslo, Norway

4,377. Amy Emam

cairo, Egypt

4,378. Katarína Linczényiová

Bratislava, Slovakia

4,379. Olga Larina

Novokuznetsk, Russian Federation

4,380. shady hamad

westwood, MA

4,381. Lucy James

Santa Rosa, CA

4,382. Carmen Herrmann

Hurghada, Egypt

4,383. Mustafa Khodary

Hurghada, Egypt

4,384. Jessica Gherardi

Nyon, Switzerland

4,385. Eberhard Hamborg

Hamburg, Germany

4,386. Marice Bastiaensen

Breda, Netherlands

4,387. Valérie Burgun

Rehling, Germany

Page 177

Respect the dolphins as they are also creatures of this planet. Respect their freedom!

-

Signatures 4,361 - 4,387

Name

From

Comments

4,388. Sebastian Bachmann

Frankfurt, Germany

4,389. Pascale LUEDI

Bienne, Switzerland

4,390. Grappa Gemma

Rome, Italy

4,391. Peter Ingham

Chudleigh, United Kingdom

4,392. Parvis Hanson

Geneva, Switzerland

4,393. marie kohler

grazac, France

4,394. Junes Denkler

Hurghada, Egypt

4,395. Mona Refaat

Hurghada, Egypt

4,396. Simona Guarnieri

Milan, Italy

4,397. Björn Alex

Lüneburg, Germany

4,398. Georgio zeilaa

egypt, Egypt

4,399. Nader Enany

Jamesville, NY

4,400. John Beck

Boulder, CO

4,401. Karin Rettig

Stanton, CA

4,402. Reem Khalil

münster, Germany

4,403. Pertot Paolo

Trieste, Italy

4,404. Olga Tsypkina

Moscow, Russian Federation

4,405. Rafel Aziz

Hurghada, Egypt

4,406. mohsen taweel

London, United Kingdom

4,407. Shadi MOkhtar

Hurghada, Egypt

4,408. Karim H. Attia

Hamburg, Germany

4,409. marta williuams

middletown, CA

4,410. Birgit van Besel

Faru, Maldives

4,411. juanito vicidomini

milano, Italy

4,412. Amr Moussa

Alexandria, Egypt

4,413. Lefevre Yvonne

Aulnay, France

4,414. Karin Jaumann

Augsburg, Germany

4,415. Jan Hoier

Lueneburg, Germany

4,416. Joanna Szafarczyk

London, United Kingdom

4,417. Naglaa Nagy

cairo, Egypt Page 178

Wild animals should be left in the wild

Dolphins belong to the OPEN SEAS

Killing the dolphins will lead to the destruction of the Eco system which will eventually kill us!

Egypt is an extremely cruel country. I am boycotting it for tourism.

From what I have seen last night in the movie by Ric O'Barry and what is happining in Japan .This is outrages and can not be tolerated

-

STOP IT!

Signatures 4,388 - 4,417

Name

From

Comments

4,418. fanta keyta

hurghada, Egypt

4,419. Susie Nassar

Giza, Egypt

4,420. Sarah Brugger

Buchloe, Germany

4,421. Matthew Barraki

Richmond, United Kingdom

4,422. jacob brakels

sneek, Netherlands

4,423. SEBASTIEN COUFFON

Saint Maur, France

4,424. Michael Hellwig

münchen, Germany

4,425. Cristina Riguzzi

Rome, Italy

4,426. Juliette El Fouly

Belfast, United Kingdom

4,427. alexandre remy

champagne, France

4,428. Noura Menesy

Hurghada, Egypt

4,429. Temmer Amin

Hurghada, Egypt

Let us stop being known for a country that 'is cruel to its animals' even if you don't love animals, respect their rights, so many tourists stop coming to Egypt because of the plight of the animals that they have seen on previous visits

I just can,t believe this!!!!!!

It is cruel. Plain and simple.

Absolutely disguisted in the way that Human Beings treat Dolphins. In the world and especially in the Red Sea.

4,430. Hausherr Caroline Wildhaus, Switzerland 4,431. b t

Sharm, Egypt

4,432. Sebastiaan Bals

Alkmaar, Netherlands

4,433. Silvan Ottiger

Thalheim an der Thur, Switzerland

4,434. Peggy Levesque

Saint-maur-des-fossã©s, France

4,436. Olena Byelovyentseva

Cairo, Egypt

4,437. peter mulder

hardenberg, Netherlands

4,438. Ирина Малыхина Dahab, Egypt 4,439. Susi Gisler

luzern, Switzerland

dear humans become finally awake

4,440. Piotr Piórewicz

Gdynia, Poland

There is many other places to stop this proces

4,441. Rita Schröter

Aachen, Germany

4,442. René Näf (fotodiver.ch)

Remetschwil, Switzerland

4,443. Dean Beekman

Monnickendam, Netherlands

Page 179

It's hard to believe that "animal friends" are still buying dolphins from Japan while everybody know the cruelty of the japanese "hunters"...sorry butchers.

-

Signatures 4,418 - 4,443

Name

From

Comments

4,444. Véronique Lajoinie

Saint-maur-des-fossã©s, France

4,445. Stefanie Batke

Munich, Germany

4,446. Katarzyna Stuczynska

warszawa, Poland

4,447. Heike Dixon

Köln, Germany

4,448. Diane Gan

Welling, United Kingdom

We have to protect these wonderful animals from greedy ruthless humans.

4,449. Doris Andreoli

Biezwil, Switzerland

I'm shocked about this. What's the mind of this gays? liberate and freedom for this dolphins!! I would like observe this rare creatures in natur and NOT in a pool or behind windows! When my childrens are older, i would like show with her in nature and not in books ore naturalmuseums!!

4,450. Elodie Maral

Marseille, France

4,451. Florian Schönenberger

Grenchen, Switzerland

4,452. Thomas Ney

Lueneburg, Germany

4,453. Micha Haven

eindhoven, Netherlands

4,454. Tina Smith

caldwell, ID

Money is and always will be the root of ALL evil !!!!

4,455. Nada Sherif

dubai, United Arab Emirates

i always wanted all animals to be treated with respect and care, its a shame that some countries just dont care anymore

4,456. Kinda almukaddem

Porter Ranch, CA

4,457. paul hardy

london, United Kingdom

4,458. Luciano Rambelli

Cinisello Balsamo, Italy

4,459. leticia Renard

Austin, TX

4,460. carla bos

raamsdonksveer, Netherlands

4,462. Lorna Allies

Norwich, United Kingdom

4,463. Anna Martens

Krefeld, Germany

4,464. Deanna Wilbur

Bangor, ME

4,465. Agnieszka Siudy

Brooklyn, NY

4,466. Timm Rosenplaenter

Oerlinghausen, Germany

4,467. daniela pavesi

cernusco s/n-mi-, Italy

4,468. Cecilia Chan

Nottingham, United Kingdom Page 180

I simply beleave that any living beeinf is supposed to live in its natural environment, and for sure not in captivity !

im a scuba diver prefere to see them in natural surroudings & swimming free

It is an absolutely nasty thing, that is happening to this clever and peaceful animal! Stop this horro right now!!

-

Signatures 4,444 - 4,468

Name

From

Comments

4,469. Annet van Aarsen

Leiden, Netherlands

4,470. Hamza Ali

Hurghada, Egypt

4,471. Agnieszka Saska

Warsaw, Poland

4,472. Fifi Lotfi

New Cairo, Egypt

4,473. Joanna Peczek

Skala, Poland

4,474. Mariam El Ezaby

New Cairo, Egypt

4,475. Delphine Gloux

Paris, France

4,476. alfredo venditti

rome, Italy

4,477. Yehia M.El-Sioufy

Hurghada, Egypt

4,478. Rita Tetkov

Raubach, Germany

Lets stop this evil... :( Poor Dolphins

Disgusting !!!

4,479. sylvia el mistikawy cairo, Egypt

they deserve to be in their natural habitat ,its cruel , no man would like to be in imprisoned in a 1*1 m cell for the rest of his life, so why do it to the dolphins, free them

4,480. Mahmoud Badawy

Hurghada, Egypt

thanks every member in hepca .u r doing a great job and a masseive help not just for red sea but also for us as a humen and behavior .i lost the feeling that there's a real non profit institutions but since i watch the movie listen to the speach and see what Hepca movement reacted against that issue i realized that that there's still people ready to believe in good.thanks a lot for ur interest in red sea in that good way deep respect and wish u all the .and always with u and support u with anyway .

4,481. Carole Newsome

Hurghada, Egypt

No country should want to be involved in this archaic trade

4,482. Anne Lorraine Vigouroux

Paris, France

4,483. Faithann Ortlieb

Murfreesboro, TN

4,484. Angie Picchi

Gig Harbor, WA

4,485. Evelyn Milburn

Houston, TX

4,486. carrie gaudette

Maple Ridge, Canada

4,487. Mary Alexander

Glen Allen, VA

4,488. Peter Karel

Maastricht, Netherlands

The wild sealife in the red sea should be preserved. If not It will start looking like the mediterraneum sea.

4,489. ahmed saber

alexandria, Egypt

let them please :(

4,490. Vaerten Sofie

Gierle, Belgium

STOP!

4,491. Susan Suni Ibarra Rohnert Park, CA 4,492. Alexandra Fechtig Höchst, Austria 4,493. FREIBURGHAUS PATRICK

bienne, Switzerland

4,494. Tom Kuerten

Boostedt, Germany

4,495. Sandra Refaat

Hurghada, Egypt Page 181

STOP FOR US AND OUR CHILDRENS

-

Signatures 4,469 - 4,495

Name

From

Comments

4,496. Bastian Obermeier

6, Germany

4,497. Norbert Scadock

Schwabenheim, Germany

what a pity that a petition is necessary for such things that should be self-evident

4,498. Marcus Leinkauf

Stelle, Germany

Stop it!

4,499. fabienne mourlon

st genis pouilly, France

Let dolphins in the sea, they have nothing to do in a swimming pool...

4,500. Svenja Dalmann

Ludwigshafen, Germany

4,501. Yasmin Müller

Basel, Switzerland

4,502. Kerstin Weiner

Burbach, Germany

4,503. Sylvie Schneidewind

Stuttgart, Germany

4,504. Malin Frey

Zürich, Switzerland

4,505. Erika Heinz

Burbach, Germany

4,506. Vivian Sapatoru

Pottendorf, Austria

4,507. Cathleen Vukusic

Vienne, Austria

4,508. Łukasz Piórewicz

Gdynia, Poland

4,509. Stephanie Schützinger

Hamburg, Germany

4,510. Sheila Jeitler

Traiskirchen, Austria

4,511. Monika Warzecha 56, Poland 4,512. Brigitte Zlomek

Vienna, Austria

4,513. Kasia Rusek

Warsaw, Poland

4,514. Aleksnadra Dmowska

Warszawa, Poland

4,515. Andrea Donkó

Budapest, Hungary

4,516. nadine Bahajjaj

hurgada, Egypt

4,517. Sabine Kallfels

Chemnitz, Germany

4,518. E Rubin

Wagenhausen, Switzerland

4,519. Klaus Ruppert

Freiburg, Germany

4,520. Antje Baer

Basle, Switzerland

4,521. Daniela Baer

Freiburg, Germany

4,522. Jessica Bellworthy

Hurghada, Egypt

4,523. Antje Sopora

Stralsund, Germany

4,524. rebout sandrine

St Pierre La Garenne, France Page 182

stop this now. this is so cruel, imagine yourself like them kept in a small room with no light and no space to move.

-

Signatures 4,496 - 4,524

Name

From

Comments

4,525. Barry Whitfield

Cirencester, United Kingdom

4,526. Maria Müller

Strobl, Austria

4,527. Manal Khayat

Cairo, Egypt

4,528. Agnieszka Kiela

Warsaw, Poland

4,529. LAURENCE FORET

HURGHADA, Egypt

4,530. samantha stacey

dubai, United Arab Emirates

4,531. Antje Köstner

Dresden, Germany

4,532. Elsa PERROUD

Marseille, France

4,533. halszka przychodzeń

Warsaw, Poland

We have to do something! It's revolting!!!

4,534. Małgorzata Łysiak Warsaw, Poland 4,535. Tanja Kraus

Hamburg, Germany

4,536. Mistrz Anatol

Anatol, AK

4,537. Andreas Weber

Gelsenkirchen, Germany

4,538. Edyta Owen

Otwock, Poland

4,539. Sandra Gerschler

Tiszakürt, Hungary

4,540. Sakura Jendro

Hamburg, Germany

4,542. Astrid BeckSommer

Offenbach, Germany

4,543. Wanda Rozentryt

Kościerzyna, Poland

Give them freedom again, stop this cruel procedure!

4,544. Tiziana Gentili

Moos, Germany

please stop dolphin captivity

4,545. Francine Vollenweider

Le Muids, Switzerland This is a prison....... Free the Dolphins ! Let them play and continue to smile in the open !

4,546. Richard Karels

oosterhout, Netherlands

safe our oceans

4,547. LOUSTALOT JOELLE

CHAMPDEUIL, France

Une situation scandaleuse alors même que l'Egypte se permet de faire payer une taxe pour le respect de l'environnement aux plongeurs qui viennent errer dans les eaux egyptiennes !!!

4,548. Dennis Gryncewicz

Lummen, Belgium

4,549. Angelique Mandervelt

Luxembourg, Luxembourg

4,550. Georgette Stevens

Geraardsbergen, Belgium

4,551. Stefanie Meier

Bielefeld, Germany Page 183

-

Signatures 4,525 - 4,551

Name

From

Comments

4,552. Ina Kandlbinder

Unbekannt, Germany

4,553. Alfred Pfau

Gernsbach, Germany

4,554. christian renner

attnang, Austria

4,555. Stephan Müller

Hannover, Germany

4,556. Aleksandra R

Podgorica, Serbia And Montenegro

4,557. Barbara Ott

Wavre, Switzerland

4,558. Torsten Feldbinder

Flechtorf, Germany

4,559. Denis Willoughby

London, United Kingdom

Lets see them swimming free as we do when we dive.

4,560. John Hanson

Welling, United Kingdom

These conditions are appalling and also self-defeating as the dolphins are wanted to put on show in a dolphinarium. If they survive they will be in poor condition. I also object strongly to keeping sea mammals even in good conditions.

4,561. bodoiu georgiana

Analhpsi, Greece

4,562. Tetyana Babych

Lviv, Ukraine

4,563. Ulrich v. Beck

Hamburg, Germany

4,564. Peca Radifkovic

Belgrade, Serbia And Montenegro

4,565. Andrea Heffe

Ebeleben, Germany

4,566. Simon Latulippe

Quebec, Canada

4,567. Katharina Wittig

Olpe, Germany

4,568. robin christophe

BRON, France

4,569. laura geron

pregnana milanese, Italy

4,570. Karim Radwan

Cairo, Egypt

4,571. Stefanie Sprung

München, Germany

4,572. Herbert Gfroerer

Murnau, Germany

4,573. Eva Trauzettel

Freiburg, Germany

4,574. wolfgang klamer

friedrichshafen, Germany

4,575. Ulla Haider

nepi, Italy

4,576. Heidi Hoser

Gundelfingen, Germany Page 184

let all creatures be free

It is sad to se that in 21 century people still have the urge to hold animals in captivity. Especialy the ones that require open spaces, open seas and that are so tender and inteligent as dolphins. Egypt is the country that has been blessed with the Red Sea and should be the first to lead the way to stop this cruel behavior. They dont know what they are doing to those beautifull animals

Pls stop the dolphin captivity and furthermore any plans for dolphin shows in Egypt!

Stop it now! -

Signatures 4,552 - 4,576

Name

From

Comments

4,577. mandy bragg

hitchin, United Kingdom

4,578. Carsten Beiter

Vettweiß, Germany

4,579. julien jonas

montauroux, France

4,580. Monika Żychlińska

Warszawa, Poland

4,581. Ekaterina Kirilenko

schiltigheim, France

4,582. elham sewielam

london, United Kingdom

4,583. Rawda Tomoum

Cairo, Egypt

4,584. ingrid mundt

lintorf, Germany

4,585. edyta petkov

cracow, Poland

4,586. Philippe Ducreux

Loyettes, France

4,587. Edith Vogler

Reichenburg, Switzerland

4,588. Kristin Farrag

Dundee, IL

4,589. Markus Kohler

Uhldingen, Germany

4,590. Jürg Isler

Thun, Switzerland

4,591. Marwa saleh

cairo, Egypt

4,592. Carine Detry

Gentbrugge, Belgium

4,593. serge kalamian

hurghada, Egypt

4,594. Alex Pitt

Choppington, United Kingdom

4,595. Christiane Brockhau

Düsseldorf, Germany

4,596. Ian Watkins

Lymington, United Kingdom

4,597. DIVER HOUSE

safaga, Egypt

4,598. mohamed zohdy ahmed

brunn am gp., Austria

dahh haram walahy ):

4,599. pietrasik sonia

dampmart, France

Want to see dolphin in the sea, not in a pool !!!

4,600. Harley Caulfield

Bradford, United Kingdom

4,601. roberto lo presti

cameri, Italy

4,602. Oliver Hess

Cologne, Germany Page 185

Stop this

let them free. they look happy even when they are not coz of the structure of their mouth. so dont think that they are enjoying being imprisoned in a pool, entertaining some fools. let them free as god created them

P-L-E-A-S-E!!!!!!FREE THE DOLPHINS!!!!

it is haram..if you can't provide adequate place and food...leave them to get their rizk from allah STOP dolphin captivity in Egyp

The Egyptians are a well-meaning and kind people, but I think that they will not have the training and expertise to look after these creatures correctly. Also, the Japs should not be allowed to export these animals

-

Signatures 4,577 - 4,602

Name

From

Comments

4,603. Marcia McDuffie

Rodeo, CA

4,604. Joelle Vallieres

quebec, Canada

4,605. Perrine Deramond Vitré, France 4,606. Monica Scandella

Cugnasco, Switzerland

4,607. sandra zuberbuehler

el gouna, Egypt

4,608. colleen yee

london, United Kingdom

4,609. Fatma Marei

Helsinki, Finland

4,610. Steffen Dorn

Wuppertal, Germany

4,611. Ralph Charlwood

London, United Kingdom

4,612. claire oleszko

essex, United Kingdom

4,613. A Ford

Hurghada, United Kingdom

4,614. Anke Fabian

Heidelberg, Germany

4,615. Ninetr El Gazawy

Heliopolis, Egypt

4,616. lee ann mcvay

austin, TX

4,617. Stefanie Karbe

Molfsee, Germany

4,618. Thorsten Chilla

Dortmund, Germany

4,619. L Usta

Istanbul, Turkey

4,620. Brigitte MOLA

Safaga, Egypt

Let them free !!!!

4,621. Aaron Schanz

Wietzendorf, Germany

es ist unglaublich das es so etwas schreckliches in so einer wunder schönen gegend wie dem Rotem Meer gibt wer nur ein einziges mal in seinem leben getaucht ist weiß wie wunderschön frei lebende Fische/Tiere sind STOPT Delphinarien

4,622. Joy Van der Beek

Eindhoven, Netherlands

Let them live in free nature like the satah reef!!

4,623. robert lorkiewicz

Virginia Beach, VA

Please help stop the slaughter by rejecting this plan for another dolphinarium. Thank you...

4,624. Veronica LACH

Oradea, Romania

4,625. justin caudill

austin, TX

4,626. Philippe CLEMENT

Asnières sur Seine, France

4,627. Engy Moussa

cairo, Egypt

4,628. Ponce Monique

Aulnay, France

4,629. Bruno Schutyser

b, Belgium Page 186

If the Egytpian tourist authoririties are serious, this should not be allowed.

next we need to save the donkeys, horses and crocodiles in Egypt too!!!!!

-

Signatures 4,603 - 4,629

Name

From

Comments

4,630. May Jakobsen

Sharm, Egypt

4,631. tony hesselink

zevenbergen, Netherlands

4,632. Jeannine Tricot

Bochum, Germany

4,633. dc ahe

Calgary, Canada

4,634. Katja Zimmer

Hoym, Germany

4,635. Kerryn Hewitt

Brighton, United Kingdom

4,636. Ewelina Sanchez

Bydgoszcz, Poland

4,637. Yvonne Spanke

Düsseldorf, Germany

4,638. Carmen Desouki

Deutsch Evern, Germany

4,639. christina hawari

el gouna, Egypt

4,640. Aggoun Myriam

rouen, France

4,641. Pascal GILBERT

Saint Germain Du Corbeis, France

4,642. Annette Rejek-Amer

Langenfeld, Germany

4,643. Robby Schropp

Kammlach, Germany

4,644. Hans Roodbol

waddinxveen, Netherlands

4,645. Roy Grimsley

London, United Kingdom

4,646. Astrid Fischer

Vienna, Austria

4,647. Anna Imm

Mainhausen, Germany

4,648. Philip Liehr

lederhose, Germany

4,649. Melissa Rodriguez

El Paso, TX

4,650. marina rebuffa

Ponderano BI, Italy

4,651. Rohr Brigitte

Nürnberg, Germany

4,652. Aleksandra Zyjewska

Bydgoszcz, Poland

4,653. Katja Kieslich

Düsseldorf, Germany

4,654. mel gassmann

speyer, Germany

4,655. Alexandre RIBEIRO

Courthezon, France

4,656. Manuel Wilflingseder

asd, Austria

Page 187

Stop with animal torturing please.

Other species are not ours to exploit and intelligent minds are capable of seeing this fact.

it's really crazy that this happend in Hurghada

-

This is bad animal cruelty

set the Dolphins free

Signatures 4,630 - 4,656

Name

From

Comments

4,657. Roland patzolt

parndorf, Austria

4,658. Barbara Corsi

verona, Italy

4,659. marianne kocher

Quincy, MA

4,660. caroline bruttin

margencel, France

4,661. accardo lorena

napoli, Italy

4,662. Alessandra Corsi

Verona, Italy

4,663. katia maria forte

verona, Italy

4,664. Nika Zbasnik

London, United Kingdom

4,665. Aleksandra Hajinovic

Hurghada, Egypt

4,666. cindy burlingame

Pompano Beach, FL

4,667. Ashley Arthur

Navan, Canada

4,668. Maria Muggia

Torino, Italy

4,669. Noha Eldeeb

cairo, Egypt

4,670. Marilyn Pullen

Auckland, New Zealand

This treatment of dolphins is utterly atrocious, it must be stopped!

4,671. Hans Greife

ÜBach-palenberg, Germany

Let them free!!

4,672. Billie Menier

Mamou, LA

I'm ashamed and very very sad...!

4,673. katja bergamaschi bironico, Switzerland

assolotamente bisogna liberare i delfini devono nuotare liberi nel loro ambiente!

4,674. Carmen Stickel

Vettweiß, Germany

Hi, I signed the petition "STOP dolphin captivity in Egypt". I'm asking you to sign this petition to help us reach our goal of 10,000 signatures. I care deeply about this cause, and I hope you will support our efforts.

4,675. Thomas Wagner

Wuppertal, Germany

4,676. Sabine Dorn

Wuppertal, Germany

4,677. Simone Hammerl

Unterwaltersdorf, Austria

4,678. BARBARA DEVIZZI

so, Italy

4,679. Kristina Snajder

Nikinci, Serbia And Montenegro

4,680. teresa bozano

genova, Italy

4,681. Ingolf Schriek

Olsberg, Germany

4,682. iman fahmy

Cairo, Egypt

4,683. Markus Klune

Stockerau, Austria

4,684. Jacks Genever

Rushden, United Kingdom Page 188

IGNOMINOUS!

-

Signatures 4,657 - 4,684

Name

From

Comments

4,685. Julie BARBIER

ROUEN, France

STOP THIS !!! SHAMEFULL

4,686. liz martinez

Las Vegas, NV

watch "The Cove" you'll never be able to go to a dolphin show again!

4,687. Ruth Jackson

Dublin, Ireland

4,688. Nina Anigbogu

Moscow, Russian Federation

4,689. Eric DAON

LE HAVRE, France

4,690. Anne Schwarz

Hurghada, Egypt

4,691. Eveline Taudor

Rendsburg, Germany

Es ist unglaublich, was in Ägypten mit den Delfinen passiert ist. Wie kann man nur 4 ausgewachsene Delfine in einem viel zu kleinen Pool halten. Ich bin absolut gegen Delfin-Parks. Ich möchte Delfine in ihrer natürlichen Umgebung, dem Meer, sehen und nicht eingesperrt in Pools. Ich bin oft in Ägypten und habe auch schon häufig Delfine gesehen. Es ist unbeschreiblich schön diese tollen Tiere zu beobachten. Stoppt das Delfinarium in Makadi Bay!!! Danke lieben Gruß Eveline

4,692. Lee Cooper

Hurghada, Egypt

I saw a pod of 14 dolphins in the wild only yesterday, there's no need whatsoever for this cruelty

4,693. Nina Karatsaneva

Sofia, Bulgaria

4,694. Ioanna Athanasiou

Ptolemaida, Greece

4,695. George Hägi

meinisberg, Switzerland

4,696. Bianca Kuester

Leopoldshöhe, Germany

4,697. andreas holler

röttingen, Germany

4,698. Ulrich Rieth

24, Germany

4,699. Kathrin Doute

Berlin, Germany

Leave animals alone, they are no toys.

4,700. Claudia Higgs

Seillans, France

Please do stop this cruelty!

4,701. Tracy Schafer

Willowbrook, IL

4,702. Sabine Breidenbach

Leverkusen, Germany

4,703. Gerhard Koehler

Ulm, Germany

Please stop this cruel bullshit, let them free!

4,704. Volker Ketels

Witzwort, Germany

STOP THIS CRUELTY ON OUR AND GODS PETS !!!

4,705. Astrid Moeller

Uplengen, Germany

4,706. Karine marie Shhadi

larvik, Norway

4,707. John Zysset

Basel, Switzerland

4,708. Jakob Olszewski

München, Germany Page 189

No creature should be made to live in captivity to satisfy human curiosity...we have no right to do that!!!

-

Free dolphins!!!!!!!!!!!!

let them free - immediately! Signatures 4,685 - 4,708

Name

From

Comments

4,709. Lynn Clijmans

Berchem, Belgium

4,710. Juliane Pohl

Neuried, Germany

4,711. Holger Korn

Böblingen, Germany

4,712. Tony Backhurst

Cranleigh, United Kingdom

4,713. Diana Huber

St. Gallen, Switzerland

4,714. Colin Scowcroft

Preston, United Kingdom

4,715. Marcelle Pallier

Nogent sur Marne, France

4,716. Julie Owen

Ft. Worth, TX

4,717. Sven Kahlbrock

hurghada, Egypt

4,718. Nicole Meyer

Hurghada, Egypt

4,719. Jasmin Böttger

Augsburg, Germany

4,720. Stephjan Kerssens

Assendelft, Netherlands

4,721. Monika Koch

Leinburg, Germany

4,722. luke king

Harare, Zimbabwe

4,723. Vladimir Psunenko

Zheleznodorozhny, Russian Federation

4,725. Monika Seidl

Hohenwarth, Austria

4,726. Michael Breitschwerdt

Nürnberg, Germany

4,727. Helmut Fox

Minden, Germany

4,728. Richard Sargeant

Altendorf, Switzerland

4,729. Philippe MARATUECH

COMBS LA VILLE, France

4,730. Olli Kahlbrock

Norheim, Germany

4,731. Walter Elefant

Wien, Austria

4,732. Andrew Pogrebnyak

Lugansk, Ukraine

4,733. Sonja Summ

Loerrach, Germany

4,734. Anna Greife

Übach-Palenberg, Germany

4,735. nik weber

Km2, Egypt

4,736. Frank Rottmann

Frankfurt, Germany

4,737. Neena Hwaidak

Cairo, Egypt Page 190

Shocking! We have to stop it!! As the premier diving tour operator sending divers from the UK to Egypt I am convinced that allowing Dolphinariums in Egypt will damage the Egyptian Diving Industry

Diese Leute sind Verbrecher.Ich fordere die ägiptischen Behörden auf ,diese Verbrecher sofort zu verhaften.

Stop it now!

-

Signatures 4,709 - 4,737

Name

From

Comments

4,738. Helmut Pankratz

Roth, Germany

4,739. Aber Allam

alexandria, Egypt

4,740. Claire G.

Lititz, IL

I Like dolphins!!!!!!!!!!!!! They should NOT be kept like this!!!!!!!!!

4,741. Steve Raith

Munich, Germany

I was 10 times to Hurghada. Stop this or I will do my diving holiday anywhere else!

4,742. Lee Parks

Barnsley, United Kingdom

These mammals are far smarter than mankind. They deserve freedom just as much as we would!!!

4,743. Ari Spenhoff

Hamburg, Germany

Appalling to see how some people try to make a living by destroying the live of others!

4,744. h. wulff

homberg, Germany

4,745. Armin Horn

Bochum, Germany

STOP dolphin captivity in Egypt

4,746. Thomas Griesch

Weissenborn, Germany

Wenn ich so etwas sehe schäme ich mich zu der Gattung Mensch zu gehören.

4,747. Jürgen Sielski

Naila, Germany

4,748. Lauren Williams

Springfield, IL

Stop the Abuse!

4,749. Rene Tarko

Zwolle, Netherlands

This is cruel!!! Simply unbelievable!!!

4,750. stephanie Falco

Irvine, CA

4,751. phil cotton

hurghada, Egypt

4,752. alexander koch

wannweil, Germany

4,753. Thomas Simon

Vienna, Austria

4,754. Szopori Anikó

Kecskemét, Hungary

4,755. Zachary Shahan

Sarasota, FL

4,756. chavee sophie

5300, Belgium

4,757. Odilia Wegener

Berlin, Germany

4,758. Satu Kauppinen

Iisalmi, Finland

4,759. Jens-Uwe Henze

Auenwald, Germany

4,760. Stefan Beck

Echterdingen, Germany

4,761. I Lawley

southampton, United Kingdom

4,762. Hartmut Ehret

Herxheim, Germany

4,763. Inas Lotfi

Cairo, Egypt

4,764. joanne firth

burnley, United Kingdom

4,765. Verena Vaid

Rorschacherberg, Switzerland

4,766. Hussein Marei

Montreal, Canada Page 191

Save the Dolphins

I hope these dolphins would survive in the Red Sea if they are released immediately, given the different environment from Japan, but it is better than being kept in a small pool.

-

Signatures 4,738 - 4,766

Name

From

Comments

4,767. Kristi Permin

Monmouth, OR

4,768. cynthia villaume

Liverdun, France

4,769. Wolfgang Hellmann

Berlin, Germany

4,770. Susanne Koch

Wannweil, Germany

4,771. Bea Joeck

Freiburg, Germany

4,772. Eleonor Magnusson

Östersund, Sweden

4,773. Claudine Strazza

New York, NY

4,774. Linda Halvorsen

Oslo, Norway

4,775. Danielle Wylie

Whitby, Canada

Free the dophins!!!!

4,776. Abraham Ortiz

Guaynabo, PR

Stop the captivity practice...you think that the dolphins have a smily face,,,wrong they are just stress out for been in jail!!!

4,777. Marixa Alvarez

San Juan, Puerto Rico

4,778. denis tapparel

playa del carmen, Mexico

4,779. Thilo Klecker

Offenbach, Germany

4,780. Alfred Brinker

Markelo, Netherlands

4,781. Colleen Wolters

Pennington, NJ

4,782. Karl Moser

St.Gallen, Switzerland

4,783. Ute Hofmann

Seeheim, Germany

4,784. Bernhard Frauneder

Vienna, Austria

This must stop!

Don't understand why you need dolphinariums in a country where you just have to go out with a boat to see dolphins. It's cruel and totally unacceptable.

4,785. Alfred Petermandl Grieskirchen, Austria 4,786. Patricia Stutzer

Durban, South Africa

Set them free!!!!

4,787. suzie elt

mojacar, Spain

Save the dolphins

4,788. joerg schimmel

Kaiserslautern, Germany

Freedom for the Dolphins !

4,789. Bev Brewis

Victoria, Canada

4,790. reem beydoun

beirut, Lebanon

4,791. Maik Schuerer

Erdmannhausen, Germany

4,792. Serge Parel

Pratteln, Switzerland

4,793. Wolfgang Höfer

Emden, Germany

4,794. Christiane Schäfer

Blieskastel, Germany

Page 192

-

Immediately stop the insanity .... We never take a day longer in Egypt, if not stop! Signatures 4,767 - 4,794

Name

From

Comments

4,795. marco caimi

milan, Italy

4,796. Jeannine Fischer

Wellington, New Zealand

4,797. Mohammed El-Zawahry

Cairo, Egypt

4,798. Peter Weel

Tilburg, Netherlands

4,799. Frank Hanselka

Stuttgart, Germany

4,800. Susanne Nardi

Stockholm, Sweden

4,801. Klaus-Dieter Schlüter

Lohne, Germany

4,802. peter loibl

Germering, Germany

4,803. dennis van der wal

6, Netherlands

4,804. Arnd-Peter Mauruschat

199, Netherlands

4,805. Andreas Forchhammer

Wackerstein, Germany

4,806. Emily Povey

Fife, United Kingdom

4,807. Katie Seely

Warkworth, New Zealand

4,808. Armin Brielmann

Moessingen, Germany

4,809. Sascha Gottlieb

Basel, Switzerland

4,810. Peter Schust

Berlin, Germany

4,811. Lilith Diamond

Bertinoro, Italy

4,812. Marion Preuss

Duesseldorf, Germany

4,813. Christina Holler

Lauda-kã¶nigshofen, Germany

Stop this madness please , this is not the middle ages people.........

The responsible person for this should to be arrested for the rest of his life in a coffin!

4,814. SOPHIE MILLION St Pierre D'allevard, France 4,815. Iris Hellmann

Dormund, Germany

4,816. Jochen Adam

Nürnberg, Germany

4,817. Stefania Erba

milan, Italy

4,818. Rob Coulon

LaPlace, LA

4,819. Marlene Bacher

Innsbruck, Austria

4,820. Nicole Schlueter

Hurghada, Egypt

4,821. Sandra Bischofberger

Friedrichshafen, Germany Page 193

-

Free this poor dolphins. That´s not human, that´s making money with animals. STOP IT NOW !!!

Signatures 4,795 - 4,821

Name

From

Comments

4,822. Michael Toellner

Wuppertal, Germany

4,823. silvia grassini

milano, Italy

IS UNHUMAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

4,824. DANY Prescillia

Varangã©ville, France

Il faut les sauver svp !

4,825. Steve Ware

Gloucestershire, United Kingdom

It is about time that these places of so called entertainment are boycotted around the world

4,826. Andreas Schmieder

Leibertingen, Germany

4,827. Michaela Fioratto

Weinfelden, Switzerland

4,828. Peter Ambagtsheer

Apeldoorn, Netherlands

4,829. Evert Doornebal

Leidschendam, Netherlands

4,830. lucy f

hurghada, Egypt

4,831. lynne lowes

manchester, United Kingdom

Enjoying the sea is not just seeing it, but knowing you are respecting it. Where many animals can safely be kept in captivity, the circumstances should be a reflection of care for mother Nature's gift. Who does not respect nature, especially in the case of these dolphins, does not deserve a place or a role in tourism. I'm surprised they are not even warned or prosecuted for maltreatment of animals.

4,832. Johan van de Ven Willemstad, Netherlands Antilles 4,833. maik gisberts

weert, Netherlands

4,834. H. Koens

Kruisland, Netherlands

4,835. Tineke Swinkels

Tilburg, Netherlands

4,836. Maxime Bogaard van den

Den Bosch, Netherlands

4,837. Karin ten Kate

Bussum, Netherlands

4,838. Regine Baron

Kassel, Germany

4,839. Susan Rademaker

Loosdrecht, Netherlands

4,840. Hedwig Dieraert

gent, Belgium

4,841. Jasmin Jaerisch

Düsseldorf, Germany

4,842. Barbara Homburg

Löhne, Germany

4,843. Sonia Sadowska

Wermelskirchen, Germany Page 194

I was recently so lucky to encounter wild dolphins on a snorkel tour in the Atlantic Ocean. Wow, what a wonderful animals. How cruel to hav them enclosed in such a tiny little swimming pool, facing a life in a dolfinarium, IF they survive. Please STOP catching ALL wild animals and make sure those 4 dolphins are set free again!

-

Signatures 4,822 - 4,843

Name

From

Comments

4,844. Richard King

Oosterwolde, Netherlands

4,845. roger jenkins

sharm, Egypt

4,846. charly Drutti

Lanaken, Belgium

4,847. ed van Hunnik

Suameer, Netherlands

4,848. angela ruggles

Dagenham, United Kingdom

4,849. Sandra Busch

Bochum, Germany

4,850. nils wernicke

münster, Germany

4,851. Frauke Albers

Hannover, Germany

4,852. Anja Schreiner

Munich, Germany

4,853. Marc Gérard

Diest, Belgium

4,854. Jens Meier

Duisburg, Germany

4,855. Beate Tank

Chemnitz, Germany

roger jenkins

Stop this nonsense immediately free the dolphins!

4,856. Edyta Warsaw, Poland Orta-Korzeniewska 4,857. Ron Buser

dieren, Netherlands

4,858. Lotta Forsberg

ostersund, Sweden

4,859. Jürgen Schneider

Berlin, Germany

4,860. Ben van Gent

Zierikzee, Netherlands

4,861. Marcus Schneider Berlin, Germany 4,862. C. van de Bergh

Oirschot, Netherlands

4,863. Klaus Dycha

Stuttgart, Germany

4,864. andrew brans

Dodrecht, Netherlands

4,865. sabine kuijs

dordrecht, Netherlands

4,866. Aylin Dreier

Barsinghausen, Germany

4,867. Arjan Waterman

Groningen, Netherlands

4,868. Ralf Doering

Chemnitz, Germany

4,869. Simen Myrberget

Hovin i Gauldal, Norway

4,870. Els Verstraete

Elewijt, Belgium

4,871. Lilly Tank

Chemnitz, Germany

4,872. Heike Scheunemann

Berlin, Germany Page 195

Please stopp this abuse.

-

Signatures 4,844 - 4,872

Name

From

Comments

4,873. Jasmin Yillah

Berlin, Germany

4,874. Harald Gottschalk

Braunschweig, Germany

4,875. Frank Engel

Frankfurt am Main, Germany

4,876. Arne Zillmer

Hannover, Germany

and thank you for the fish ...

4,877. Everhard H.M. Lange

Delft, Netherlands

cruel business

4,878. Irina Stoehr

Knebworth, United Kingdom

4,879. Chloe D.

NDIP, Canada

4,880. Andrea Scherdel

Taunusstein, Germany

4,881. Marco Köhnen

Weener, Germany

4,882. Andreas Albrecht

Moosach, Germany

4,883. Miriam Wild

Wesseling, Germany

4,884. nayeli urquiza

canterbury, United Kingdom

4,885. Hendrik Bock

Weener, Germany

4,886. Peter Sinning

Weener, Germany

4,887. Jörn Vollborth

Weener, Germany

4,888. Erik Wauters

Zoersel, Belgium

4,889. Peter Horsmeijer

Amstelveen, Netherlands

4,890. Syl Cuijpers

echt, Netherlands

4,891. Karl Friedrich Merz

Obernhof, Germany

4,892. Lintermans Kathleen

rhode saint genese, Belgium

4,893. Ana Cetinic

Belgrade, Serbia And Montenegro

4,895. Michael Furchner

Groß Twülpstedt, Germany

4,896. Tony B. Tokutake

SAO PAULO, Brazil

4,897. Barbara Müller

Murrhardt, Germany

4,898. Eva Bode

Bingen, Germany

4,899. Julian Mason

Kempten, Germany

Only when we safe the nature we have a small chance to alive!

Learn to dive and dive with them in complete freedom!!!!

OMG... you guys are sick motherf*****s STOP THIS IMMEDIATELLY !!!! do you want to live in a 2m² box for one month??? i think (continues on next page)

Page 196

-

Signatures 4,873 - 4,899

Name

From

Comments

4,899. Julian Mason

Kempten, Germany

(continued from previous page)

4,900. Marija Cetinic

Belgrade, Serbia And Montenegro

4,901. Michael Scheuer

Vienna, Austria

4,902. Ramona Artz

Gießen, Germany

4,903. Cora van Vliet

Ridderkerk, Netherlands

Please let those animals free! We will respect the Egyptions more if they will see that protecting fish and mammals is better than to hunt them or let them live in terrible circumstances. You have a Red Sea full of animals! Let them live, so we divers and tourist will come back! Who is the animal? You as an Egyption agreeing with this business, or the dolphins?

4,904. Pepijn Ham

Sint-Pancras, Netherlands

Wij don't we put this guy's in a little room whit smoke in it!!

4,905. Carlo Cozzolino

Portici, Italy

4,906. Bob van Ooij

Doetinchem, Netherlands

4,907. Edwin Donders

Zevenaar, Netherlands

4,908. Jim McKenzie

Nassau, Bahamas

Shocking !

4,909. Wendy Starreveld

Hilversum, Netherlands

free the dolphins!

4,910. christina neuhaus

Bönen, Germany

4,911. Nea Akayla

Portland, OR

4,912. Kellner Schorsch

Waldkraiburg, Germany

4,913. Pieter de Groot

Tilburg, Netherlands

4,914. kassem marianne

hurghada, Egypt

you guys would hate it!!!! i hope you die Julez

Please respect these dolphins and our environment at large. Stop importing wild dolphins. Give these captive dolphins a better home and treatment. Thanks, Nea.

4,915. anneke weishaupt winschoten, Netherlands 4,916. Hannelore Kain

Waldkraiburg, Germany

4,917. ceri hone

Swansea, United Kingdom

4,918. Jenny Wahl

Flieden, Germany

4,919. Ivan Karatsanev

Sofia, Bulgaria

4,920. Hisham elkhoudary

hurghada, Egypt

Page 197

-

Signatures 4,899 - 4,920

Name

From

Comments

4,921. peter cook

london, United Kingdom

4,922. Riess Daniel

Bayreuth, Germany

4,923. Michel Verhiest

Brussels, Belgium

4,924. Steffi Lange

Leonberg, Germany

4,925. lee abbott

london, United Kingdom

4,926. Joanna Karatsaneva

Sofia, Bulgaria

4,927. Simona Re

Viguzzolo, Italy

4,928. Rayk Hofmeister

Greiz, Germany

4,929. Vicente Perez

Mexico City, Mexico

These dolphins must be in the ocean where they come from.

4,930. Robin Harting

., Netherlands

Don't waste more time; be adequate and release those animals to their natural habitat. Thanks!!

4,931. Katya Janho

Berlin, Germany

4,932. LANA RENZA

Turin, Italy

4,933. Helga Kelle

Niederkassel, Germany

4,934. Andreas Scheuermann

Mannheim, Germany

4,935. susanna duft

burlington, Canada

4,936. malke aronovich

Mexico, Mexico

4,937. caterina garau

Cagliari, Italy

4,938. gabriella laczi

Budapest, Hungary

4,939. Kate Duvall

Edwardsville, IL

4,940. Marilyn Schuller

Overland Park, KS

4,941. Marina Schaa[

San Diego, CA

4,942. Oxana Istratova

Moscow, Russian Federation

4,943. Thijs Smeets

nuth, Netherlands

4,944. Monika Schuettig

Waldems, Germany

4,945. Alex Pinon

Frankfurt am Main, Germany Page 198

More than a scandal

it's funny that the most stupid and clear mistakes of humans are usually the most difficult to solve

Please, STOP!

I was shocked and stunned to see the size of the pool to hold the dolphins. This is NOT LIVING. How could this be even allowed in the first place. I love Egypt and the beautiful people I've met while travelling through this wonderful country but this will keep me from returning unless I learn intelligent decisions are made for the fate of these dolphins - release them back to their ocean home!

FREE THE DOLPHINS NOW!!!!! How can anybody put marine mammals into a pool for humans. Outrageous, even dogs get a better treatment

-

Signatures 4,921 - 4,945

Name

From

Comments

4,946. Michael Späth

Muenchen, Germany

stop immediatly!

4,947. Kea Leens

Aartselaar, Belgium

4,948. Myreille van de Kamp

Hilversum, Netherlands

4,949. Jan-Paul Honders Loosdrecht, Netherlands 4,950. claudia beer

Düsseldorf, Germany

4,951. Michaela Media

Altdorf, Germany

4,952. Patrick van Gemert

Zutphen, Netherlands

4,953. Roland Lubas

8, Austria

4,954. Stefan Roscher

Stuttgart, Germany

4,955. chris van Den Ouweland

rijkevorsel, Belgium

4,956. Manuela Albrecht

Wutã¶schingen, Germany

4,957. Sabine Schumacher

Aachen, Germany

4,958. Ria Reinehr

Antwerpen, Belgium

4,959. Inga Lühring

Westerstede, Germany

4,960. Jürgen Rosenberg

Oedheim, Germany

4,961. Ann Boroday

Moscow, Russian Federation

4,962. Evelyn Tsesmetzis

Esslingen a.N., Germany

4,963. Sascha Valerius

Steffeln, Germany

4,964. Olesja Jarovenko

Moscow, Russian Federation

STOP dolphin captivity in Egypt

This animals are social. The are very clever. And they are very similar to us.

Stop it!!!!!!! It's ridiculous! dolphines the most clever animals in the world - they have to live! and ppl dont have rights to kill!

4,965. Lisa van den Berg Haarlem, Netherlands 4,966. sven peks

Unterspiesheim, Germany

4,967. JIM DIEDERICH

STRASSEN, Luxembourg

4,968. Angelique D'andrade

Cairo, Egypt

Page 199

what's happening in Taiji Japan, not just here in egypt needs to be stopped as soon as possible. what is happening to this world and who human beings are becoming is just disappointing and sad. Thankfully there are those who still possess a heart and soul to see this kind of cruelty for what it is! -

Signatures 4,946 - 4,968

Name

From

Comments

4,969. Kris Simpson

North Ferriby, United Kingdom

International Dolphin Watch urges the Ministry of State for Environmental Affairs to take immediate action to release these dolphins and to prevent any more dolphins being imported into Egypt.

4,970. Mat Walker

Long Beach, CA

4,971. Helene Beck

Abyhoj, Denmark

4,972. mike mckay

Stockholm, Sweden

4,973. Andreas Breuer

Niederkrüchten, Germany

4,974. Miriam Coccoris

nieuwkoop, Netherlands

4,975. Ines Dermul

Hurghada, Egypt

4,976. Kalle Schäfer

Grafschaft, Germany

4,977. Ekaterina Suntsova

Moscow, Russian Federation

4,978. Teresa Origlia

Paris, France

4,979. Isabella PARFENOFF

Geneva, Switzerland

Please do not keep dolphins in captivity, - they belong in the wild...

Not only this we need to stop, also the killing in Japan!

4,980. Ksenia Sakharova Kirov, Russian Federation 4,981. Kristin Hager

Greiz, Germany

4,982. Shalabh Gupta

Moradabad, India

4,983. Mark Schülke

Soest, Germany

There are a lot of other ways to increase the attractivity of the already very popular Egypt for tourists. This is not necessary.

4,984. Georg Naegle

Berlin, Germany

stop it please !

4,985. Betty vn Hunnik

Suameer, Netherlands

4,986. hilary wilson

wellesbourne, United Kingdom

4,987. Laurie Samaha

levallois perret, France

There is no justification in keeping any wild animal captive, especially as dolphins are social creatures and wide ranging.

4,988. Darina Menshawy Brno, Czech Republic 4,989. kristjan nielsen

Ronne, Denmark

4,990. Rolf Bietmann

Gronau, Germany

4,991. Monika Dudziak

Terrarosa, Italy

4,992. Werner Sieber

Zollikon, Switzerland

4,993. Luiza Geanoglu

Constanta, Romania

Page 200

-

Signatures 4,969 - 4,993

Name

From

Comments

4,994. Graeme Buchan

Fraserburgh, United Kingdom

4,995. Ralf Honnef

Duisburg, Germany

4,996. Marianne Lenner

Recklinghausen, Germany

4,997. Ombretta Marzi

Rome, Italy

4,998. Nino Faranda

Port Ghalib, Egypt

4,999. deadra ullman

Williamsburg, VA

5,000. STEPHANIE ROCASSEL

Las Terrenas, Dominican Republic

5,001. Beith Valentine

London, United Kingdom

5,002. Kevin Bouwens

Amersfoort, Netherlands

5,003. Aliaa Madkour

Giza, Egypt

5,004. asha livingston

Burnaby, Canada

5,005. Lex Wijker

The Hague, Netherlands

5,006. Christian Philipps

Hemer, Germany

5,007. Patrick Hafkamp

Twello, Netherlands

5,008. John Smithers

Amstelveen, Netherlands

5,009. Mathijs Jansen

Muenchen, Germany

5,010. Stephan Durst

Lauben, Germany

5,011. Robert Hughan

Den Haag, Netherlands

STOP STOP STOP....... this is horrible, how can people be so gruel.... its like killing your own children. Goofy Aqua Video is very said by seeing the videoreports

5,012. Annemieke van Ling

Kerk-Avezaath, Netherlands

Free the dolphins!!!

5,013. LauraJayne Hamlett

Winsford, United Kingdom

Why Would People Do This..??!!

5,014. Norbert Roth

Geithain, Germany

5,015. Aimee McDonald

Castro Valley, CA

Havent you learned that keeping wild Animals is cruel and will end in only bad circumstances for humans and animals.

5,016. Ian Paynter

Brixham, United Kingdom

Egypt will benefit more in the long-run from concientious tourists than from the tired, sad practice of cetacean captivity.

5,017. Jeanie Loona

New York, NY

5,018. Sabina Ulbrich

Nürnberg, Germany Page 201

Please help dolphins to come back to the wild Why do humans want to capture animals? Let the animals have a life in their natural environment. Humans are not the be all and end all. Please enforce the law.

disgusting, something must be done to stop this!!!!

-

Signatures 4,994 - 5,018

Name

From

Comments

5,019. Milly Geyskens

Tessenderlo, Belgium Go and dive and visit the dolphins in their own habitat instead of this massacre to be

5,020. Ricarda Wessel

Hamburg, Germany

As long as the Egyptian government has accepted this cruel animal housing and the dolphins are not free, we do not spend more holidays in Egypt and advise everyone we know to do the same !

5,021. Amir Tawfik

Cologne, Germany

It is a shame that things like this still can happen due to greed for profit and a lack of conscience. The world is watching Egypt, these people should know that they destroy the image of Egypt worldwide!

5,022. marcel klomp

boxtel, Netherlands

STOP THIS CRIME

5,023. Annette Schmaltz

Berlin, Germany

5,024. Claire Nixon

Carnforth, United Kingdom

5,025. Claudia Fleischmann

Schlatt, Switzerland

5,026. Saskia Knaps

Tessenderlo, Belgium

5,027. ARIETTA MARINITSI

Athens, Greece

5,028. Dirk Verreydt

Sint-Niklaas, Belgium

5,029. Svyatoslav S

Moscow, Russian Federation

5,030. Tanja van Dalen

Dronten, Netherlands

5,031. Timo Didier

Stuttgart, Germany

5,032. Gerhu Punte

Den Bosch, Netherlands

5,033. Hassan Gazarine

asdgh, Egypt

5,034. Andrea Stümpel

Borchen, Germany

5,035. Chris Herrmann

Reichenberg, Germany

Free Them!!!!

5,036. Henk Grinwis

Rockanje, Netherlands

STOP IT NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

5,037. cristina girotti

roma, Italy

stop to captivity....dolphins FREEEEE!!!

5,038. Sara Maes

Hasselt, Belgium

5,039. Helga Cookson

Brussels, Belgium

5,040. Joern Wichmann

Mettingen, Germany

5,041. Flavio Marini

Alessandria, Italy

5,042. jacqueline cornel

eck en wiel, Netherlands Page 202

There are no words to fully express the anger and horror that any decent human being would feel after hearing about this. I only hope that this makes a difference, as there is no reason for it to ever happen again.

This is not acceptable !!!

stop this cruelty immediately!!

working as a concierge if you need any help to send any message through me

-

Stop it now!!!!!!!!

Signatures 5,019 - 5,042

Name

From

Comments

5,043. Derek Lambert

Madison, WI

5,044. ivana grmoja

Rakitovica, Croatia

5,045. Natalie Van Leekwijck

Deurne, Belgium

5,046. david Gbra

Hurghada, Egypt

5,047. Filomena Lomba Viana

Melksham-wiltshire, United Kingdom

5,048. gaby hansen

eastbourne, United Kingdom

5,049. Quinton Hanyan

Dallas, TX

5,050. victoria marshall

Rutland, VT

when are we going to learn? when dolphins become extinct? they belong in the wild the deserve to live free. this is imprisonment and illegal!

5,051. Kahtia Bonasia

Perth WA, Australia

STOP DOLPHIN CAPTIVITY IN EGYPT>>>IN FACT>>>>ANYWHERE ON THE PLANET>

5,052. catina laporte

Laval, Canada

5,053. Jonine Lichtenwald

North Vancouver, Canada

5,054. Mary Vallese

Las vegas, NV

5,055. Michelle Dufoe

South Beloit, IL

Please stop this

its an outrageous crime against the free spirit of animals to imprison them..they deserve the right to the freedom they were naturally born into.

5,056. Gerard Bouuwens ********, Netherlands 5,057. pauline pauwels

Palavas Les Flots, France

its even shame to think that poor dolphins could survive in this way, i am shock.... we should juge this people and send them to prison if they do this...

5,058. Anita Sandor

Mernye, Hungary

Let's leave at least Egyptian dolphins in peace and freedom , the natural way they are !!!

5,059. Anja Blunert

Panketal, Germany

5,060. Miriam Ben Jilani

Chalette Sur Loing, France

5,061. BRIAN SORSBY

Fyffe, AL

5,062. Frank Karrenberg

Hamburg, Germany

5,063. Matthias Kröger

Griesheim, Germany

5,064. Heike Ruf

München, Germany

5,065. Hans Kortman

Wassenaar, Netherlands

5,066. Riya Tikku

Saarbrücken, Germany

5,067. Moustafa Menshawy

Hurghada, Egypt

Page 203

Laat Dit Stoppen NU NU NU NU

-

Signatures 5,043 - 5,067

Name

From

Comments

5,068. sina kreicker

neu-isenburg, Germany

5,069. Maisetti Danielle

Aulnay, France

5,070. marion uttenthaler Dreieich, Germany

terrilble!

5,071. Ritva Janhonen

Jyväskylä, Finland

5,072. Fabian Buchwitz

Bayreuth, Germany

5,073. frédéric diebold

Cernay, France

5,074. john foard

mariposa, CA

5,075. alessandro la leggia

rome, Italy

5,076. Rossi Mario

milano, Italy

5,077. Peter Germonpre

Zwijnaarde, Belgium

Civilisation also means caring for animals...

5,078. WALZER OTTMARSHEIM, MARIECHRISTINE France 5,079. Remy Jaeger

Eckbolsheim, France

5,080. Paula Dyer

Worthing, United Kingdom

5,081. Maria Cristina Mullins

Rio De Janeiro, Brazil

5,082. d s

ath, Greece

5,083. Heinze Stephan

Rastatt, Germany

5,084. a rennbaer

berlin, Germany

5,085. Ivana Soliman

u, Czech Republic

5,086. stijn celis

hurghada, Egypt

5,087. Dyanna Beckwith

Vancouver, Canada

5,088. Marlene Lucas

Auckland, New Zealand

5,089. lynn decleire

gent, Belgium

5,090. Wolfgang Bettinger

Vienna, Austria

5,091. sven croes

sCHULEN, Belgium

5,092. Shaun Tilke

marsa Alam, Egypt

5,093. Jimena Pohl

Hurghada, Egypt

5,094. Alessandra El-Wakil

Coburg, Germany

5,095. Diana Luna

Mexico City, Mexico

5,096. Franz Kristlbauer

Emmerting, Germany

5,097. P Cronly

Blackwall, Australia Page 204

-

I prefer to see them free during my scuba-diving in the Red Sea

Signatures 5,068 - 5,097

Name

From

Comments

5,098. Leonora Cohen

mexico, Mexico

Los animales no son recursos. Liberémoslos de esta esclavitud. ¡STOP NOW! before it´s too late...

5,099. Detlev Bresser

Wuppertal, Germany

5,100. m eltouny

cairo, Egypt

5,101. Bart Cornelissen

Venlo, Netherlands

5,102. rafik alkaeiy

cairo, Egypt

5,103. menna dakroury

cairo, Egypt

5,104. Florian Weidhase

Nürnberg, Germany

5,105. Patricia Cori

Rome, Italy

The world is watching, just like we are watching Japan. Return these dolphins to the open sea while you still CAN.

5,106. Trudy Shaw

Leamington Spa, United Kingdom

Learn to dive and see these beautiful creatures in their natural habitat...

5,107. Lysandre Tremoureux

Vincennes, France

5,108. Sergey Boykov

Nakhodka, Russian Federation

5,109. Chris Dodd

Perth, Australia

5,110. Stefany Garza Gonzalez

Monterrey, Mexico

5,111. Keirollos Elassiouty

cairo, Egypt

5,112. Jasmin Stamm

Köln, Germany

5,113. pjl van der lee

vlaardingen, Netherlands

5,114. Anita Forisek

Budapest, Hungary

5,115. Sasha Somova

Moscow, Russian Federation

5,116. Sascha Norris

Atlanta, GA

5,117. Wolfgang Bedlan

Vienna, Austria

5,118. Tado Lohmüller

Hannover, Germany

5,119. Tiny Geron

Hurghada, Egypt

5,120. Dirk Ellenbeck

Kempen, Germany

I'm really shocked and hope that this will be stopped.

5,121. Mai Bassioni

Cairo, Egypt

Please stop dolphin captivity. Rare dolphins are driven to extinction by human inhumane and selfish activities. That's not fair! Please release these dolphins!

5,122. tania barros

Imola, Italy

5,123. Achim Heidelauf

22303, Germany

5,124. Nouran Abdel Hamid

Cairo, Egypt

Page 205

This should be stopped immediately and the people who did this should be punished.

-

Signatures 5,098 - 5,124

Name

From

Comments

5,125. Dorothea Stephan Winzer, Germany 5,126. Sylvia Ostmann

Leverkusen, Germany

5,127. Daniel Helbig

Mannheim, Germany

5,128. Sabrina Nardelli

Hamburg, Germany

5,129. sherif ezz

cairo, Egypt

5,130. Werner Prechtl

Bayreuth, Germany

5,131. Stefan Velten

Kaiserslautern, Germany

5,132. leplay Andree

Aulnay, France

5,133. Iryna Kubitska

Cairo, Egypt

5,134. Brigitte Hiller

Pereia, Portugal

5,135. Gomez Mélanie

1800, Switzerland

5,136. Cs. Kovács Gabriella

Leányfalu, Hungary

5,137. Simone Weber

Horstedt, Germany

5,138. Regina Wendelgaß

Ludwigsburg, Germany

5,139. Marcus Weber

Horstedt, Germany

5,140. Andreas Wöllner

Quedlinburg, Germany

5,141. Véronique Maître

Tours, France

5,142. Brigitte Bartmann

Hamburg, Germany

5,143. Rebecca Watts

Sale, United Kingdom

5,144. JILL SHIELDS

STONY POINT, NY

5,145. Ihab Adly

Cairo, Egypt

5,146. agnieszka wantke

gdynia, Poland

5,147. Martin Marienhagen

Hannover, Germany

5,148. Doris Potter

Hamburg, Germany

5,149. Joan Hepden

Essex, United Kingdom

5,150. melanie kammerer

berlin, Germany

5,151. Sven Trochocki

Hemmingen, Germany Page 206

There enough dolphins in your sea, there´s no cause to capt them!

Freedom for the Dolphins!

Repatrier au Japon des pauvres dauphins immédiatement, sain et sauf, aux frais du "propriétaire". Puis le capturer LUI, et au prison le plus vite, dans les conditions les plus inhumains possible. NON des delphinariums! Wer kennt nicht die Freude, wenn man bei einer Bootsausfahrt auf dem Roten Meer Delphine sieht, alles rennt, holt die Kamera und freut sich. Lasst die Tiere wo sie hingehören. Freedom for all dolphins. Let them live in here natural conditions.

This is not the right way!

Please sign this petition and get these creatures out of a desperate situation

-

Signatures 5,125 - 5,151

Name

From

Comments

5,152. Janine Krempl

Ergolding, Germany

5,153. Caroline Hazelgrave

London, United Kingdom

5,154. lara Iskander

cairo, Egypt

5,155. oddo Charly

Aulnay, France

5,156. Frank Sievers

Münster, Germany

5,157. Petra Smetazko

Vienna, Austria

5,158. Keleigh Dietsch

Cameron Park, CA

come on, halfway through!!

5,159. Pavlina Stefanova Pisek, Czech Republic 5,160. Markus Harant

Burg, Germany

5,161. Adam Hoffmann

Elsdorf, Germany

5,162. Stephan Galloy

Gründau, Germany

if not stopt will.no vacation in ägypten more !!!

5,163. Anne-Kathrin Peterseim

Hamburg, Germany

SAVE THE DOLPHINS!!!

5,164. caps georgia

Castelsarrasin, France

5,165. caps nadine

Castelsarrasin, France

5,166. Anna Milczarek

London, United Kingdom

5,167. Aref Hamoud

Hodeidah, Yemen

5,168. gaelle mULLER

Joue Les Tours, France

5,169. ivan dall

brescia, Italy

5,170. Karl Lloyd

Woodborough, United Kingdom

5,171. Karma Samten Lhamo

Liège, Belgium

5,172. Laetitia AMADEI

LYON, France

5,173. Delores Schnoor

Chester, MD

5,174. Ute Friedrich

Taipa, Macao

5,175. Karim Wahdan

atlanta, GA

5,176. mourad elfarnawany

atlanta, GA

5,177. Kendra Pringle

Carbondale, PA

5,178. Karen Tucker

Pensacola, FL

5,179. ivana sandri

trento, Italy

5,180. Ruth Rogers

Fort Collins, CO

5,181. vito rizzi

Bari, Italy Page 207

-

Signatures 5,152 - 5,181

Name

From

Comments

5,182. Sonia Pagni

Montignoso, Italy

Basta coi maltrattamenti e la prigionia di animali, costringendoli a vivere in un ambiente non adatto , lasciamoli liberi, è una vergogna.

5,183. daniela gazzini

campi bisenzio, Italy

5,184. eveline hall

carrickfergus, United Kingdom

5,185. Tino Rudolph

Oberlauterbach, Germany

5,186. Bianca Heidorn

Bremen, Germany

5,187. Barbara Gullo

torino, Italy

5,188. LIBERO EDOARDO

casalserugo (pd), Italy

5,189. Rodrigo Pacher Fernandes

Hamburg, Germany

5,190. Tiziana Silvestrin

San Giorgio - MN, Italy

5,191. Nathalie Berkes

Bad Breisig, Germany

5,192. ROSSANA ROAGNA

Turin, Italy

5,193. Luana Paino

turin, Italy

5,194. Mirella Spiga

Incisa S., Italy

5,195. Stefan Beck

Seitenstetten, Austria

5,196. Calantropio Morgana

torino, Italy

5,197. erika tracchi

111, Italy

5,198. dizy frederique

Aulnay, France

5,199. MARCO MAINELLA

rivoli, Italy

5,200. Alexia Diago

St Mandrier Sur Mer, France

5,201. Thierry Salicis

St Mandrier Sur Mer, France

5,202. Chilte Pascale

Aulnay, France

5,203. Flavie COURDESSE

Clermont-Ferrand, France

5,204. Barbara Jaeckli

Zurich, Switzerland

Egypt does not need inhumane dolphinariums; you can see wild & free dolphins from any boat all over the Red Sea & Gulf of Aqaba! Dolphinariums make for bad PR!

5,205. Markus Vielbier

Vilsbiburg, Germany

It is sad to have to keep talking about it again ...

5,206. aimee bird

whitby, United Kingdom

Dolphins are beautiful creatures that should not be kept in captivity, we are all creation from god/evolution and therefore are equal.

Page 208

-

It is wonderfull to see them swimming in the Ocean, they must not be held captive.

Signatures 5,182 - 5,206

Name

From

Comments

5,207. Nikki Scholefield

leeds, United Kingdom

5,208. Mohamed Lotfy

Hurghada, Egypt

5,209. comai marina

s'antonino, Italy

5,210. Eugenia Morzenti

Milan, Italy

5,211. marcus lewis

hurghada, Egypt

5,212. Sandy Pohlmann

Unterlauterbach, Germany

5,213. Nadine Querfurth

Bönningstedt, Germany

5,214. Sonia Custodero Rodriguez

Kreuzlingen, Switzerland

5,215. rosie manson

Messe, France

5,216. Stefan Maeurer

Erfurt, Germany

5,217. gerhard engelbrecht

gauteng, South Africa

5,218. Karen Vasily

Norristown, PA

5,219. giovanni lombardi

torino, Italy

5,220. Giorgia Cannavacciuolo

Monserrato, Italy

5,221. Sonia Fuentes

Glattbrugg, Switzerland

5,222. Joerg Kamchen

Rösrath, Germany

5,223. Lia Megges

Berlin, Germany

5,224. Sara-Dawn Howard

Horton,nr Wem, United Kingdom

5,225. Luca Lenzi

Turin, Italy

5,226. sal mollo

napoli, Italy

5,227. Aly Tarek

cairo, Egypt

5,228. Emanuele Berrè

Montecassiano, Italy

5,229. Wendelin Schleicher

Ingolstadt, Germany

5,230. anna daloia

ferrandina, Italy

stop please whit violence on the animals! stop!

5,231. Andrea Favilli

fano, Italy

Free Dolphin. Egypt is a wonderful country to visit. You don't need this kind of bad attraction

5,232. Alex Blin

Pereira, Portugal

5,233. Alia Tarek

Cairo, Egypt

5,234. Daniel Werner

Aalen, Germany

5,235. tim muehlberger

Huettlingen, Germany

5,236. jörg Quasthoff

Hamburg, Germany Page 209

-

Signatures 5,207 - 5,236

Name

From

Comments

5,237. guillot aurelie

Comines, France

5,238. Annie Anderson

Van Buren, AR

5,239. Ulrich Fricke

KARLSRUHE, Germany

5,240. Sabine Joos

xxx, Germany

5,241. Tamsir Triwati

Tangerang, Indonesia Some people are really fooled by money. My belief against violence to all kind of creatures and I myself feel very deeply sad. I only can sign in here to help, hope this will be useful.

5,242. paula Deeee

Johnstown, PA

5,243. Rick Carassai

Lima, Peru

5,244. maria teresa ravaioli

faenza, Italy

5,245. Peggy Kamchen

Roesrath, Germany

5,246. marilena ma

Attika, Greece

5,247. giovanni romagnoni

milan, Italy

5,248. Jochen Richter

Ober-Ramstadt, Germany

5,249. Frank Langenbruch

Bochum, Germany

5,250. iain bouskill

Sharm El Sheikh, Egypt

5,251. Holger Mletzko

Mühlhausen, Germany

5,252. doreen hackett

liverpool, United Kingdom

5,253. Petra Moeller

Gießen, Germany

5,254. Aurélie COUFFON

La Varenne, France

5,255. annette leifer

steinau, Germany

5,256. Danijela Dimitrakopoulos

Belgrade, Serbia And Montenegro

5,257. Jakub Banasiak

Warsaw, Poland

5,258. Kendall Mockridge

Center Moriches, NY

5,259. Claudia LiftonSchwerner

Nyack, NY

Page 210

This is cruel and barbaric. There are other ways to study these majestic creatures.

It´s a shame not only for egypt!

when you not ended this disaster i will never more visit your agypt

Animals are not art to put on display and attract attention. They are living, breathing, feeling creatures who should be able to enjoy their lives in their natural enviroments, not a poorly taken care of, inadequate pool.

-

Signatures 5,237 - 5,259

Name

From

Comments

5,260. AVANZI CLAUDIA

CREMONA, Italy

5,261. ELIZABETH MOODY

Apex, NC

5,262. paola carletti

ladispoli, Italy

5,263. Stephanie Kim

La Crescenta, CA

5,264. Anneke Payne

Salt Lake City, UT

5,265. George Chase

South Orange, NJ

5,266. Maggie Hughes

Nashville, IL

Dolphins are NOT fish. Dolphins are NOT sea pigs. Dolphins are NOT food. Dolphins are NOT entertainment. Dolphins are NOT and NEVER WILL BE human property.

5,267. Julianne Ferguson

nw, Canada

STOP THIS CRUEL INJUSTICE!!!

5,268. Ashley Fisher

Cordova, TN

5,269. Eric Welker

St. Louis, MO

5,270. Jennifer Ly

Prather, CA

5,271. Stacey Singer

Overland Park, KS

5,272. Heather Whitworth

Coopersburg, PA

5,273. B.J. Reynolds-Koonce

Livermore, CA

5,274. Aaron Marshall

Kenosha, WI

5,275. jamez blonde

Phoenix, AZ

5,276. Lindsey Lambert

Millville, MA

5,277. Hazel Bergtholdt

Springville, CA

5,278. Cherish Kelly

Apple Valley, CA

It's 2010 and we're still seeking pleasure out of a wild animal's suffering? It's time to get educated! How does seeing a dolphin in a pool in the middle of a desert further the education of anyone?

5,279. Karen Kirwin

Orlando, FL

Dolphins and most other creatures do not belong in the desert!Set them free!!!

5,280. Andrew Allred

West Valley City, UT

5,281. Manu Der

Brussels, Belgium

5,282. Debra Curby

Palm Springs, CA

5,283. johanne plourde

Sorel-tracy, Canada

5,284. fabrizio walder

kreuzlingen, Switzerland

5,285. Jonathan Sloan

De Queen, AR

Dolphin Captivity should be stopped worldwide!

Please stop! Dolphins do not belong in tanks.

5,286. myalinda martinez tyler, TX

Page 211

-

Signatures 5,260 - 5,286

Name

From

Comments

5,287. Raul Villanueva

Las Vegas, NV

This is a small step toward a large goal, we can live in a world where animals and humans are respected.

5,288. Jennie Cummins

Kapaa, HI

5,289. joy grey

lincoln city, OR

5,290. Melissa Cecil

Philpot, KY

5,291. Elizabeth Raymond

Waleska, GA

5,292. melinda shipp

charlotte, NC

killing dolphins is wrong. these stupid people that continue doing it should die too.

5,293. Sue Castle

Brentwood, CA

Please allow these dolphins to be set free.

5,294. Ria Brigmann

petaluma, CA

5,295. jenny rouh

Long Beach, CA

5,296. Amanda Powers

olympia, WA

5,297. Stefanie Bielekova

Seattle, WA

5,298. Mary Gomer

St.Paul, MN

5,299. Martin Kniss

Hong Kong, Hong Kong

5,300. Shannon Pesantes

Mentone, CA

5,301. Jrene Zuercher

Padang Bai, Bali, Indonesia

5,302. nataniel benares

manila, Philippines

5,303. Terry Coyne

Naperville, IL

5,304. Alexander Nolte

Paderborn, Germany

5,305. Asaf Regev

denver, CO

5,306. Darren Wicks

leeds, United Kingdom

We shouldn't kill animals just because it conveniences our race. It's not up to us to choose which species live or die

5,307. Carole McCartney Gold Coast, Australia 5,308. Nayera El Husseiny

Cairo, Egypt

5,309. Rachel Hardy-Holbrook

Spokane, WA

5,310. Kumiko Hayazaki

San Diego, CA

5,311. Karma Sangwan

East Amherst, NY

5,312. claude cote

Quebec, Canada

Stop exploiting dolphins in captivity : tha's a shame!!

5,313. Idelso Quintero

Miami, FL

It is a disgrace to see this happening. HEPCA thank you for your great work fighting for these dolphins. We all support your efforts and will not stop until the government (continues on next page)

Page 212

-

Signatures 5,287 - 5,313

Name

From

Comments

5,313. Idelso Quintero

Miami, FL

(continued from previous page)

5,314. Franziska Weber

Buchs, Switzerland

Dolphins don't belong in captivity, they belong to the ocean!

5,315. christelle vannier

pelousey, France

5,316. roberta tichenor

Maricopa, AZ

5,317. Brenda Marie

Burlington, Canada

5,318. Damian Guillen

Dillon, MT

5,319. Rosa Malagisi

Norfolk, VA

5,320. tina dotzauer

Male, Maldives

5,321. Rebecca Halbro

Copenhagen N, Denmark

5,322. Gildo Brav

Naq, Egypt

5,323. Mick Kanjanakaset

Orter Ranch, CA

5,324. Fabian Franzeck

Zürich, Switzerland

5,325. OLGA Iv

Kyiv, Ukraine

5,326. Kate Matthews

Woolpit, United Kingdom

I had the luck of feeding a wild dolphin in Australia - it just came up to me and took a fish out of my hand. They are magical creatures who have such inner beauty. PLEASE LEAVE THEM ALONE. They show us such resepct. Why can't we do the same. I am so angry to see what human beings are capable of. Sick!!!!

5,327. Richard Crawford

Bend, OR

These Dolphin must be set free from this life of slavery at all costs!!

5,328. Kyan Krumdieck

Christchurch, New Zealand

Absolutely Disgraceful.

5,329. marcos mitsas

Ferrara, Italy

5,330. Catherine Heitmeyer

Houston, TX

5,331. nathalie alduc

Bains Sus Oust, France

5,332. Dominique Howard

cape town, South Africa Page 213

forces these "business men" to reconsider for the sake of these animals health and well being or face the global outcry and economic impact that follows it.

Nobody wants to pay to see a trapped animal !!!Wake up and step into the present world and teh future, this is NOT entertainment !!!

Observe these beautiful animals in the wild - feel the pure bliss in seeing them play and enjoy their freedom. Why would anyone want to capture them and make their lives miserable?

Please ban dolphin captivity! It's not a human right to determine the fate of these beautiful creatures. They deserve to live in peace and happiness their natural environment. Please help.

-

Signatures 5,313 - 5,332

Name

From

Comments

5,333. Stefan Hollmann

Alpen, Germany

5,334. Marc van Bebber

Münster, Germany

5,335. Debra Bonnema

Springville, IA

Be more responsible, you are endangering their lives by not giving the right amount of space to live.. in. Not to mention taking free dolphins and making them captive. How does that benefit them?? It never will..people do not think what is best for the dolphins.. to stay free to stay happy with their families..

5,336. JB Monfort

Latour-bas-Elne, France

Let humans destroy humans, earth will survive, NOT animals

5,337. Krist Liew

Johor Bahru, Malaysia

5,338. Darren Beck

Vancouver, Canada

5,339. Monica Sanna

Canegrate, Italy

5,340. Eve Brinsley

Dubai, United Arab Emirates

5,341. Nadine Peter

Marburg, Germany

5,342. Christine Watson

Kettering, United Kingdom

5,343. Uschi Kainz

Würselen, Germany

5,344. Rebecca Green

DArsham, United Kingdom

5,345. Kristy Coates

Northants, United Kingdom

5,346. B Prins

Alphen aan den rijn, Netherlands

5,347. marcell kainz

würselen, Germany

5,348. zoe ng

tung chung lantau, Hong Kong

5,349. Nele Thijs

Retie, Belgium

5,350. Tosh Tachibana

Tokyo, Japan

5,351. Amy Taylor

Tauranga, New Zealand

5,352. ERICA SETTESOLDI

fucecchio, Italy

5,353. beverley thurtle

Norfolk, United Kingdom

5,354. Paola Lottini

Bologna, Italy

5,355. siberia4ever Rus

Novokuznetsk, Russian Federation Page 214

Please ban dolphin captivity! It's not a human right to determine the fate of these beautiful creatures. They deserve to live in peace and happiness and in their natural environment

rescue the dolphin

Please do the right thing and return these dolphins to the sea and ban captivity of dolphins in egypt

Tourist could see free dolphins in red sea.

-

Signatures 5,333 - 5,355

Name

From

Comments

5,356. Hetty Vink

Lower Hutt, New Zealand

5,357. Angelika Toth

london, United Kingdom

5,358. Cilente Bosman

Derby, United Kingdom

5,359. Aurore Heurard de Fontgalland

Paris, France

5,360. Michael Baureis

Herlev, Denmark

Dolphins are self-aware, highly intelligent creatures. Keeping them in captivity in such appalling conditions is totally inhumane and should not be allowed to continue.

5,361. Patrizia Romanelli Milano, Italy 5,362. John Quispel

Oud -beijerland, Netherlands

Dolfijnen horen in de zee niet een zwembad

5,363. Thomas Michaelis Bremen, Germany 5,364. Nan Faile

Leesville, SC

5,365. Alessandro Rizzo

Palermo, Italy

5,366. Paula Camps

Mahón (Minorca), Spain

5,367. Fay Howa

Cape Town, South Africa

5,368. Lindsey Selley

Warwick, United Kingdom

Please, no more dolphins to aquariums, we don't support them and won't visit them. Dolphins should be in the sea.

5,369. marcelo pisani

köln, Germany

just stop it....!!!

5,370. Shavonne McQuade

Pensacola, FL

5,371. Paul Chandler

Exeter, United Kingdom

5,372. Coryann Davis

salem, NH

5,373. Miriam Günther

Berlin, Germany

5,374. Jen Codair

malden, MA

5,375. Liz Wren

Borehamwood Herts, United Kingdom

5,376. Tracy Affannato

Danbury, CT

5,377. Stéphanie Brien

Orléans, France

5,378. Sonia Manning

Darwin, Australia

5,379. sue costello

Acton, Canada

5,380. LeAnn Little

Brighton, CO

5,381. Jennifer Ackim

Medina, OH Page 215

Please, freedom for the 4 dolphins that now are in captivity in Egypt in a ridicolous swimming pool in the middle of the desert. They must live in their natural habitat. As said Knopfler, "we haven't change since ancient times"...

This is discusting...please treat these animals kindly...

it is a terrible crime to all that is beautiful and free about the world to keep these amazing creatures in captivity.

-

Signatures 5,356 - 5,381

Name

From

Comments

5,382. Mayra Figueroa

Mexico, Mexico

5,383. Laura Bowman

Roanoke, VA

5,384. peter martin

ticehurst, United Kingdom

5,385. shawn dickerson

orange, TX

5,386. Janice Bauer

Hobe Sound, FL

5,387. Ivan Karatsanev

Sofia, Bulgaria

5,388. Cristina Waldis

Ponzone, Italy

5,389. maria rodriguez

otlando, FL

5,390. lorraine dupree

Morden, United Kingdom

5,391. matthias demacker

Munich, Germany

5,392. ilana Ellis

Stafford, VA

Save The Humans Of The SEA!

5,393. polly philipson

Bequia, Saint Vincent And The Grenadines

Absolutely disgusting practice and detrimental to a country which is famed for its amazing creatures in the ocean. I saw wild dolphins on a scuba dive in Sharm and it was magnificient.

Please help save the dolphins

5,394. Jennifer Semchuk Edmonton, Canada 5,395. Rainer Brutzer

Gaertringen, Germany

5,396. roberta furlan

paese, Italy

5,397. Karen Johnson

Cape Town, South Africa

5,398. Kelly Conner

Sunrise, FL

5,399. Mandy Lloyd-Jones

EL GOUNA, Egypt

5,400. Danielle Crockett

oakdale, CA

5,401. Lex Rigby

Sheffield, United Kingdom

5,402. Anne Vickman

Cambridge, MA

5,403. Christina Bailey

Hart, MI

5,404. Jessica Eiben

South Park, PA

Page 216

Dolphins are intelligent, living beings with the ability to feel pain and pleasure. They are not commodities or objects. They should be free to live their lives as they wish

Let's just pretend, for a minute, that you are a dolphin. Actually no, let's just pretend that you're you. Living freely at home, enjoying the life you've created for yourself. Then, suddenly, someone bigger and stronger than you removes you from your home, and sticks you in a small box far, far away from your family, friends, and loved ones. Guess what: you're a dolphin in Egypt. Try compassion on for size and set them free.

-

Signatures 5,382 - 5,404

Name

From

Comments

5,405. Julia Tuzhikova

Moscow, Russian Federation

5,406. Elizabeth Batt

Coram, MT

If dolphins were meant to be in the desert, God would have out them there!

5,407. Wanda Czubernat Stuttgart, Germany 5,408. David Whelan

Station Road, Hailsham, United Kingdom

5,409. marlyse baumann

dahab, Egypt

5,410. Charlene Atwater

Evergreen, CO

5,411. Michele Coppell, TX Cunningham-Scott

To whom it may concern, The ongoing trafficking, and unnecessary slaughter of dolphins, and all marine life, for sheer entertainment, has to stop! Animals are best viewed in the wild, in their natural habitat. Please help stop dolphin captivity!

5,412. Jennifer Beal

Plymouth, MA

Our survival as a human race relies on the health and well being of all creatures. Dolphins are intelligent and sensitive and need to be cherished as one of God's amazing creations. Please treat them as such. Leave them in the ocean where they belong to be free and happy!

5,413. Sandra Stricker

Merano, Italy

5,414. Annalisa Falzon

Tarxien, Malta

5,415. Michelle Sturgess

Jacksonville Beach, FL

5,416. Mara Silver

Shelburne Falls, MA

Captivity is cruelty. I have personally vowed never to go to a venue where dolphins or whales are held captive.

5,417. Brittany Turcotte

newmarket, Canada

Stop dolphin captivity!

5,418. Normajean Atkinson

Moultonborough, NH

5,419. Maria Trikilas

New Brunswick, NJ

5,420. Alicia Said

Mgarr, Malta

5,421. Alisa Jenkin

Ventura, CA

5,422. summer moore

austin, TX

5,423. Simon Goodchild

Ipswich, United Kingdom

5,424. daniel feret

bagnolet, France

5,425. Doranne Alden

Naxxar, Malta

5,426. Jasmin Ignatova

Moscow, Russian Federation

leave the dolphins in the sea

5,427. dennis richter

cape town, South Africa

kill the dolphin killers

Page 217

Simply cruel - please don't visit these places.

-

Signatures 5,405 - 5,427

Name

From

Comments

5,428. Judy Eeles

Aylesbury, United Kingdom

5,429. Heather Myers

Shelbyville, IN

5,430. Lizeth Escorza

South Gate, CA

5,431. Arshdeep Sekhon

New York, NY

5,432. ann vastmans-hibbett

Sneads Ferry, NC

5,433. gilbert scanfi

paris, France

5,434. Dave Wall

Wicklow, Ireland

5,435. Eline Ross

Ede, Netherlands

Save those magnificent creatures!!

5,436. Alice Diamond

Boulder, CO

Any captivity of wild animals should be banned. This is cruel and barbaric and shameful.

5,437. rebecca hinks

Bourne, United Kingdom

All dolphins should be in their natural environment. I am making a strong point to all my friends not to attend dolphin/whale shows, to prevent and stop the suffering of these beautiful creatures.

5,438. Collette Bourne

New West, Canada

5,439. Susan Michalec

Stafford Springs, CT

5,440. Heather Williams

Round Rock, TX

5,441. Carrie Adams

Ashland, OH

Let the dolphins swim free!!

5,442. David Turgeon

Saskatoon, Canada

Dolphins are an intelligent species and need to be treated accordingly.

5,443. Lidia Passiatore

Aarhus, Denmark

5,444. Alicia Annas

Edmonton, Canada

5,445. Stefania Florea

Bucharest, Romania

Prove that you`re worthy to live on this planet!

5,446. Alisa Cornell

Fairfax, VA

Keeping dolphins in captivity would be akin to keeping humans in a cage. how would you like to be in one room for your entire life with nothing else to look at but the four walls?!

5,447. Sophia Merritt

Victoria, Canada

The world is watching

5,448. Karina Ysabel Sanchez Puerta

Lima, Peru

5,449. yda bateman

dartford, United Kingdom

5,450. Karine Gouzet

Villié-Morgon, France

5,451. Lehua Malili

Las Vegas, NV Page 218

dolphins need to live in the ocean to be free. they do not belong in tanks or anywhere else besides the ocean! Show some respect for God's creatures and return these beautiful mammals to their natural habitat, which is definitely no where near the DESERT!!

Please Please let these wonderful creatures go. They should be in the wild. They are intelligent and feel as we do. They deserve their freedom. Let them enjoy their life as you have the choice to do so. Set them FREE ...........

-

Signatures 5,428 - 5,451

Name

From

Comments

5,452. Carla Oldenkamp

Austin, TX

For the sake of the world's future, please help send back the dolphins to a safe place. One where they can live free, the way nature intended.

5,453. Robin Shacklette

Louisville, KY

5,454. S. Prowse

Barrie, Canada

5,455. Günther Hellendahl

Neuss, Germany

do you want to do this with yourself ??? this person only think about money !!

5,456. katherine flanagan

Laguna Hills, CA

Please treat the Dolphins with respect.

5,457. Laura Harron

Valletta, Malta

5,458. Antonio Anastasi

Mgarr, Malta

5,459. M Kimmig

Karlsruhe, Germany

5,460. Louise Mauter

Meridian, ID

Anyone can see the suffering of these four, please free them. They need to be free not in pools in a desert!!!!

5,461. Serena Stean

Fleckney, United Kingdom

We'd rather see them in the sea and have a chance to dive with them in the wild than stare at them through a glass tank....

5,463. Kitty Quinn

Nanaimo, Canada

5,464. Marion Kaup

Hurghada, Egypt

5,465. Graham Love

Cobham, United Kingdom

5,466. Hartson Doak

Kapolei, HI

5,467. inka stafrace

st paul's bay, Malta

5,468. Christi Ferguson

Huntington Beach, CA

5,469. Cathy M

Chappaqua, NY

5,470. Christa Sciberras

Mqabba, Malta

5,471. Rachel Coursey

San Diego, CA

5,472. Heike Herzog

Solms, Germany

5,473. louise spiteri

mosta, Malta

Free the dolphins!

5,474. Kathy Cassidy

Houston, TX

please help protect the dolphons

5,475. Bente Jakobsen

Hjortshoej, Denmark

5,476. Nora Nefferdorf

Hilden, Germany

5,477. Daniel SOULAS

Bordeaux, France

5,478. Elizabeth Baires

Huntington Park, CA

5,479. Nichelle Nicholes

Pittsburgh, PA

5,480. Cindy Collier

Yorkshire, United Kingdom Page 219

There is no place in today's world for the cruel practice of holding dolphins in captivity.

This is disgusting We need to remember we "Share" this Planet...we do not own it! Please respect all life! Free the Dolphins.

-

Signatures 5,452 - 5,480

Name

From

Comments

5,481. Rhea Seren Phillips

Llanelli, United Kingdom

Who wouldn't want to see WILD dolphins in their natural environment. Captivity is just silly !!

5,482. elizabeth findlay

Tenbury Wells, United Kingdom

5,483. Reynard Loki

New York, NY

5,484. BJ Denenberg

Phila, PA

5,485. Jennette Smith

Marietta, GA

5,486. Leslie Roundy

Henderson, NV

5,487. Boza Majstorovic

Ljubljana, Slovenia

5,488. Rune Holm

Eidsberg, Norway

5,489. Marcia Bosley

Rogers City, MI

5,490. Claudia Maiwald

Berlin, Germany

5,491. Marvin Poole

essex, United Kingdom

5,492. Patsy Hatz

Itzig, Luxembourg

5,493. michael boulton

notts, United Kingdom

5,494. Rosemary Ginko

Rio Rancho, NM

5,495. Sally-Marie Rahn

Haltern, Germany

5,496. Melina Maritato

Buenos Aires, Argentina

5,497. Ludovic Boutet

levallois, France

5,498. Teresa Davis

Roseville, CA

5,499. Jill Thomas

Ogden, UT

5,500. Ninja Hamster

Dream, CA

5,501. Victor Vella

Zurrieq, Malta

5,502. Marisa Rodriguez

Brooklyn, NY

5,503. xiang(祥) zhang(张)

xi'an, China

5,504. Massiel Ortega

Philadelphia, PA

5,505. Heiko Schad

Rudersberg, Germany Page 220

This needs stopping NOW!

Please do not keep the dolphins in an aquarium. These are very high level mammals. They are not created for our entertainment. It is abuse of these beautiful and majestic creatures.

This situation is unacceptable. Stop playing like this with sealife and protect them. future generation needs our support and action.

I have always thought of Sharm El Sheik to be a diver's paradise, where one could swim, dive and enjoy free living sea creatures in their natural habitat. I'm disgusted to say the least, to read about these dolphins captives in dolphinaria in Sharm El Sheik! Divers should start boycotting and avoiding Sharm El Sheik if this happens. 我在15-109宿舍

-

Signatures 5,481 - 5,505

Name

From

Comments

5,506. Jennifer Hansbro

Fort Mill, SC

5,507. Cynthia Perez

Aurora, IL

5,508. Axel Kretschmer

Neu-Isenburg, Germany

5,509. deborah jackson

alicante, Spain

5,510. Suzanne Rogers

Carpinteria, CA

5,511. Adrianne Puza

New Cumberland, PA

5,512. Vanessa Collazo-Gutierrez

Fremont, CA

5,513. Julie Gabriel

Glendale, CA

5,514. Abigail Wolcott

Stanhope, NJ

5,515. Edie Dickenson

Spring Creek, NV

You need to do what is right and moral, and do it NOW!

5,516. margie grant-caplan

Havelock, New Zealand

Allowing events such as this to occur can only damage your name and credibility. Particularly in relation to tourism with the international traveller being much more savy and aware and making particular choices to boycott or not support areas where unsavoury practices such as this occur.

5,517. Martyn Wielemaker

Rotterdam, Netherlands

5,518. Margie Borchers

battle ground, WA

5,519. Marco Savarise

Seattle, WA

5,520. John Albrink

Las Vegas, NV

5,521. Julie Zakidalskaia

Foster City, CA

5,522. Loren Mohrman

Douglasville, GA

5,523. Sonia Zammit

Valletta, Malta

5,524. Terri Kokaly

Clifton Park, NY

5,525. Sigrid Leeb

St. Pölten, Austria

5,526. Rob Jansen

Alkmaar, Netherlands

5,527. Loranne Cachia

Zebbug, Malta

5,528. Keller Monica

Biasca, Switzerland

5,529. Rikke Pedersen

Hadsten, Denmark

5,530. W Tarr

Johannesburg, South Africa

5,531. sara hazzard

St Julians, Malta Page 221

Stop hurting Mother Nature!

PLEASE STOP THIS IN-HUMANE TREATMENT OF THESE DOLPHINS! IT IS CRUEL TO PUT THEM INTO LITTLE TANKS AFTER THEY WERE RAISED/LIVING IN THE OCEAN!!!!

Dolphins do not belong in captivity, and certainly not in an arid desert. The evil-ness of the human ego never ceases to disgust me.

Please help those that cant help themselves. Be the voice that says no more cruelty!!!

-

Signatures 5,506 - 5,531

Name

From

Comments

5,532. Nicole Binnicker

Leander, TX

5,533. Elena Niculescu

Bucharest, Romania

5,534. Daphna Feingold

new quay wales, United Kingdom

5,535. Valerie de Kergorlay

London, United Kingdom

5,536. Rainer Richter

Wolfenbuettel, Germany

5,537. Jane Savarise

Seattle, WA

5,538. Dawn Biro

Los Angeles, CA

5,539. Lana David

San Diego, CA

Let's leave at least Egyptian dolphins in peace and freedom , the natural way they are !!!

5,540. Tabetha Sturgeon Olathe, KS

The Dolphins are smart and deserve to stay in their natural environment...the wild!

5,541. Phil Mosher

Warrensburg, NY

Is it just part of mans inhumanity to all things or just stupidity that corrupts, maybe it is riches. To my way of thinking it is all of these things, riches which appears to corrupt and cause stupidity and ignorance. If only we could live life as the good Lord intended by loving all things.

5,542. khali Loinaz

San Juan, Puerto Rico

Keeping those dolphins in that small pool is inhumane and should not be allowed, they will not be able to roam free as they are supposed to be. The extreme heat of the desert as well as the dust it is very bad to the health of these creatures, why money must be the guiding force for everything putting the well being of many of the animals on earth, as Ghandi said " The grandeur of a nation is seen by the way they treat their animals" Please set them free.

5,543. sue onisko

Frankston, TX

THEY NEED TO STOP KILLING AND SELLING THESE BEAUTIFUL CREATURES IT NEEDS TO BE OUTLAWED ON THE SALE OF DOPHINS AND WHALES,AND OTHER SEA CREATURES. IM COMING TO JAPAN OR WHEREVER RIC NEEDS ME! LOVE YOU ALL!!.

5,544. Rachel Gugelberger

New York, NY

5,545. Jessica Valenzuela

Jacksonville, FL

5,546. Sean Collier

Columbia, MO

5,547. Helen Cullum

Dade City, FL

5,548. Mary Spartz

West Bend, WI

5,549. Valerie Card

Rancho Cucamonga, CA

5,550. joelle weber

cannes la bocca, France Page 222

-

People who keep dolphins in captivity must love them, to want them so close. But it's an uneducated love. We need government restrictions to control this all too human desire.

Signatures 5,532 - 5,550

Name

From

Comments

5,551. Violet Foster

Inglewood, New Zealand

5,552. Jennifer Trench

Valhalla, NY

5,553. Carla Solomon

Cheshire, United Kingdom

5,554. Kathy Bartholme

Tucson, AZ

5,555. Laura Gill

Sharm el Sheikh, Egypt

5,556. Diane Berg

Booneviille, AR

5,557. karen White

Liverpool, United Kingdom

5,558. V Jones

East Haddam, CT

5,559. sarah gilbert

Wichita, KS

Please take better care of these dolphins. Their home is the ocean. Please return them.

5,560. Julia Olsen

Toronto, Canada

Egypt has enough famous history, landmarks and beautiful nature to see on any visit. The last thing Egypt needs are dolphins. I was always planning to visit Egypt and looking forward to the visit. I will now be boycotting Egypt and will be sure not to visit until I am assured that these dolphins are freed and no further dolphins are imported for any reason.

5,561. ambra carraro

Resana, Italy

5,562. tammy guess

logan, OH

5,563. Cheri Baird

Bellingham, WA

5,564. Jen Moore

West Chester, PA

5,565. Joanne Coburn

Mississauga, Canada

That pool looks like a prison for the poor dolphins.

This is the year 2010!!!! Please - get educated! Leave these wild and beautiful creates where they belong - in the ocean. Please set free these beautiful creatures and stop the building of dolphinariums.

5,566. BARBARA ROSSI firenze, Italy 5,567. Tina Schmaltz

Cincinnati, OH

5,568. Natalie Nelli

channahon, IL

5,569. Neil Hutson

ammanford, United Kingdom

Wild animals need to stay where they are, in the ocean! put the people that do these things in jail and see how they like it!!

5,570. cathryn bales

New York, NY

This tyrannical practice of importing and basically enslaving dolphins must stop NOW all over the world!!!

5,571. Patricia Quinn

Palmdale, CA

5,572. Celeste Nash

Vista, CA

5,573. Bethany Cortale

Dublin, PA Page 223

Please release the 4 dolphins from this horrible small swimming pool. If you will only look at dolphins in the wild you will see who cruel this action is and what impact it's having on them and their health. Please release these poor animals.

-

Signatures 5,551 - 5,573

Name

From

Comments

5,574. Sandra Zaninovich

Los Angeles, CA

5,575. Ruth Navarro

Malta, Malta

5,576. Sandra Markert

23, Germany

5,577. donck Edit

Hoboken, Belgium

5,578. Angela Ackerley

Redcar, United Kingdom

5,579. S Bennington

W.Bloomfield, MI

5,580. Laura Grau

Zaragoza, Spain

5,581. Kirby Perryman

Kirkland, WA

5,582. Thorsten Pfisterer

Bruchsal76646, Germany

5,583. Karen Binette

Gardiner, ME

5,584. Veronica Torres

columbus, OH

5,585. BACHELLERIE Renée

St Selve, France

5,586. Wendy Drucker

Seattle, WA

5,587. Jessica Burkill

Kaiwaka, New Zealand

5,588. Alice Bourgineau

montréal, Canada

5,589. danna smith

pensacola, FL

5,590. Jackie Plourde

Hanmer, Canada

5,591. Jill Talbot

Rutland, VT

5,592. Rebecca Johnston

Adel, IA

5,593. David Hards

Upland, CA

5,594. Ismary Sosa

Tampa, FL

5,595. Christie Huck

Phoenix, AZ

5,596. Carla Hornback

Williamsport, PA

5,597. Meagan Nesbitt

saskatoon, Canada

5,598. berenice mathieu

le Pradet, France

5,599. Peter DE WILDE

Gent, Belgium

5,600. Romina Psaila

mtarfa, Malta Page 224

Gracias, Ric

Stop this now, it is encouraging the massacre in Taiji, I do not support or buy from the Japanese country and you are next...

Please release the four dolphins being held.

Suppose Hitler had been responsible for such practices, our planet would be to small..This kind of unethic, unscrupulous money making on the back of an audience of mostly childeren is really beyond recognition. There should come a worldwide moratorium on dolphinaria and an economic boycot of Japan.

-

Signatures 5,574 - 5,600

Name

From

Comments

5,601. Frances Scuteri-Moore

Satellite Beach, FL

5,602. Natascha Dubies

Hamburg, Germany

5,603. abigail blee

Plymouth, United Kingdom

5,604. Petra Bonello

St Paul's Bay, Malta

5,605. Andrea Cotton

Denton, United Kingdom

5,606. Kenneth New

Stockton, CA

Dolphins are one of the closest possible non human species on earth and I just do not understand how anyone would want to even take a chance at harming them, please listen to your hearts and put your self in their position

5,607. lee jacques

Mt. Brydges, Canada

we can only hope that the dolphins will be released but the people who are doing this are wealthy and money talks. we need an underground movement. sneak in and sneak out before anyone catches us. Wish I had a lot of money, I would start the movement, for now prayers and support for those already involved in The Quest for the dolphins release.

5,608. barbara rice

Bend, OR

Just terrible!!!!!

5,609. robinet delphine

roubaix, France

5,610. Anne-Marie Domeniconi

Gland, Switzerland

No captured animal is happy. Wood you, "human" be happy in a cage? Scientifically it is proved that dolphins are deeply depressed and often die soon after capturing.

5,611. Kriselle Seidel

Cleve Hts, OH

Please release the current captive dolphins who surely will not survive in this primitive, inadequate and inappropriate setting. Please do not import additional dolphins from Taji or anywhere for that matter and place them into captive settings that will surely kill them or at the very best, allow them to barely survive with major health issues and depression. Please free these beautiful creatures to their God given home in the sea.

5,612. Nicholas Timm

Worcester, United Kingdom

Come On! have a heart these creatures deserve more respect!

5,613. Roz Howes

Tyne and Wear, United Kingdom

Why why why do people insist on exploiting such beautiful dolphins and all living creatures for what to make a quick buck. Stop people are getting very wise and will eventually NOT come after they discover what actually goes on behind the scenes.

5,614. Charleen Murphy

newcastle, Australia

PLEASE PUT THE DOLPHINS IN A SAFE PLACE IN THE OCEAN WHERE THEY BELONG!! THEY ARE NOT TO BE IN A POOL!! THEY NEED THE FREEDOM TO SWIM AND BE WITH OTHER DOLPHINS!! THIS IS INHUMANE AND WRONG! THE DOLPHINS WILL BE DEPRESSED! (continues on next page)

Page 225

-

Signatures 5,601 - 5,614

Name

From

Comments

5,614. Charleen Murphy

newcastle, Australia

(continued from previous page)

5,615. lawrence walsh

Midland City, AL

5,616. Haley Maunder

Brigus, Canada

Be a leader, have the courage to stop the capture - we will applaud you all over the world. You know you have the power to change and we support you.

5,617. Dani Hale

London, United Kingdom

Please let these poor dolphins return to their natural habitat. It is inhumane to keep them in such appalling conditions and you're basically just shooting yourselves in the foot as the dolphins might not survive - and where will your precious investment be then? Please see sense and do the right thing.

5,618. William Spain

Boulder, CO

I wrote a letter to the Japanese in the early 70's, when they signed a ban on blue whale murder, then promptly set up slaughter armadas under the Clieanflag. My tactic was to shame them, on several levels; the deceit, lack of honor, etc

5,619. Mary Guirguis

Bolingbrook, IL

5,620. alldive scubaclub

notts, United Kingdom

5,621. Ginette Ricard

Montréal, Canada

5,622. Karen West

Santa Ana, CA

5,623. Kerry Korshoj

Baltimore, MD

5,624. Suzanne Whelan

Voluntown, CT

5,625. Niki Gianni

Chicago, IL

5,626. Sujatha Ramakrishna

Oak Park, IL

5,627. Loreley Hall

Fountain Hills, AZ

5,628. Igor Popovski

Skopje, Macedonia, The Former Yugoslav Republic Of

5,629. Tim Mehesy

Fords, NJ

5,630. Becki Bowdre

Ormond Beach, FL

5,631. Ceren Farr

Greenville, SC Page 226

THINK ABOUT SOMEONE OTHER THAN YOURSELVES PLEASE!! PLEASE LET THEM GO NOW!! ITS THE BEST THING TO DO!! THINK ABOUT WHAT THEY NEED!!

S.V.P relâchez-les pour qu'ils puisses vivre dans leur habitat naturel qui est la mer. en captivité, ils sont malheureux et à la longue ils deviennes malades et ils finisses par se laisser mourir. redonnez-leurs, leurs libertés si vous les aimés vraiment....merci !!!

These dolphins are in an incredibly tiny, barren, concrete tank with no enrichment. Their little cement pool is nothing like the ocean, which they were so brutally captured from! Free these individuals!

-

Signatures 5,614 - 5,631

Name

From

Comments

5,632. claudia quartarone

oshawa, Canada

5,633. Jessica Gandy

Seattle, WA

5,634. Amy Young

Saraland, AL

5,635. Linda Simm

Oak Ridge, NJ

5,636. Barbara McCabe

Toronto, Canada

5,637. Christine Cosby

Alpharetta, GA

5,638. Virginia Baylor

St. Pete., FL

5,639. Hannah White

Hammond, WI

5,640. Karen Nienkamp

Saint Louis, MO

Please stop this horrific plan and return the dolphis to the sea where they belong!

5,641. Steve English

Charlotte, NC

Dolphins are people (and more), too! This must be fixed asap!

5,642. Marie Feigl

Elphinstone, Australia I fully support every word of this partition, and request that you use your own personal conscience to guide your actions in the outlawing of all inhumane activities of others. The treatment of these dolphins would not be tolerated if the equivalent crimes of humanity were to be committed against humans, in fact, would be against the law. There should be no difference between the protection of humans and that of all animals, including dolphins.

5,643. Mary Truelove

Martinsville, IN

5,644. mary lou schmidt

Topeka, KS

5,645. Rob Ireland

Irby, United Kingdom

5,646. Olive Long

Belfast, United Kingdom

5,647. Deborah Low

Vancouver, Canada

5,648. Maria Ajac

Winter Haven, FL

5,649. Lucy Robinson

Bluffton, SC

5,650. Krista Watts

Encinitas, CA

5,651. susan krhounek

seattle, WA

5,652. Haans Siver

Melbourne, Australia

5,653. joanna zatorska

chicago, IL Page 227

When will people learn that these are mammals that need to skip through miles and miles of water to be healthy and happy?!

Please help free these baby dolphins, they should be with their mothers in the wild. born free Dolphins has been around longer than man has been walking upright. We should be studing them in the wild not in some tank or pool thats not natural. Who knows what we could learn!

Dr Nazif, WHAT'S GOOD ABOUT THIS ? Your name translates as "clean". Isn't it time to live up to it and wash your nations hands of this barbarism ?

Dolphins do not belong in captivity.

Please release these dolphins to their natural habitat. Honor the dolphins by doing the right thing.

Please stop importing dolphins. Let them live free in a wild -

Signatures 5,632 - 5,653

Name

From

Comments

5,654. Kimberly Martin-Mubasu

Chantilly, VA

5,655. Jane Wilson

West Salem, OH

5,656. Lisa Fryrear

Arlington, WA

5,657. Lindi Verster

Durbanville, South Africa

5,658. Lydia Keppler

Stuttgart, Germany

5,659. HOLLY EVANS

Studio City, CA

5,660. Jacqueline Leimgruber

NY, NY

5,661. kirstie dunne

Melbourne, Australia

5,662. Carmel Duke

Reservoir, Australia

These dolphins desperately need the help of humans. They are suffering and will continue to suffer in these appalling conditions. This is animal cruelty and must be stopped

5,663. amy telsey

brooklyn, NY

Please show your advancement as a civilization by not allowing intelligent creatures to be had in inhumane captivity. Thank you

5,664. Diane Bakan

Bradenton, FL

This cruelty MUST BE STOPPED!

5,665. Shari Hamed

Sharm el Sheikh, Egypt

5,666. James Howard

Rocklin, CA

5,667. alliot joelle

Uturoa Raiatea, French Polynesia

5,668. Papa Marius

Buzau, Romania

5,669. Ulf Hilzenbecher

Nuremberg, Germany

5,670. Zsofia Somlai

Godollo, Hungary

5,671. Veronica Boom

Somerset West, South Africa

5,672. Beth Ann Senderak

Castle Rock, CO

5,673. Pamela Harp Gentry

Agoura Hills, CA Page 228

Please Get those 4 dolphins out of the summing pool which is located in the backyard of a private citizen's back yark in Egypt and have the dolphins placed back into the ocean where they belong. The swimming pool and future dolphinarium that is being built are inadiquate for the dolphins and this should be stopped immediately. Also the high temperature in Egypt is definately not suitable for a dolphins to live in. Please being them back to their home in the ocean. Dolphins needs to be free

These highly intelligent creatures live in families and travel up to 40 miles a day, surfing waves and catching fish and communicating with one another. Imagine being stripped of every single one of your freedoms and you will know what their lives are like.

-

Signatures 5,654 - 5,673

Name

From

Comments

5,674. chiara benelli

Scandicci(fi), Italy

5,675. Daniela Gretz

Karlsruhe, Germany

5,676. fey anne marie

longwy haut, France

5,677. Jill Prosser

Bonne Terre, MO

5,678. Olivia Seynaeve

Oostende, Belgium

5,679. Ann Schrauwen

Hoegaarden, Belgium

5,680. Pascal Mehner

Fellbach, Germany

5,681. Carla Vergnano

Poirino, Italy

5,682. Luciana Ravenel

Blonay, Switzerland

5,683. Karmen Heiss

Caldaro, Italy

5,684. Pauline Cutajar

Burleigh Waters, Australia

5,685. Philip Kay

Rochdale, United Kingdom

When will man learn that we have no right to remove these wonderful creatures from thier own environment and hold them against their will for our alleged entertainment - that thinking is primeval!!!

5,686. Renee Chollett

Corpus Christi, TX

At this rate they'll be extinct. Just freaking gone in a matter of years. If that. Then what will the rest of us who cared and tried to prevent this do? We'll be left with a load of sorry-ass excuses.

5,687. lada knapkova

brno, Czech Republic

5,688. David Kinsella

Birgu, Malta

5,689. Ilaria Della Corte

Rome, Italy

5,690. cristina scandalli\

chiaravalle, Italy

5,691. stefania manoni

senigallia (AN), Italy

5,692. Katherine rawe

Oxford, United Kingdom

5,693. Simone Rogers

msida, Malta

5,694. Em Pomeroy

Bournemouth, United Kingdom

5,695. Steven Bennett

Daventry, United Kingdom

remettez ces dauphins à la mer !!laissez les tranquilles ,ce n'est pas digne de l'Egypte !! I will NOT visit Hurghada nor Egypt as long as they have dolphinaria, or support other animal cruelty!!!!

Help this dolphins please

This is simply unacceptable. How selfish of us humans. STOP dolphin captivity in Egypt PLEASE set them free, and encourage people to snk or dive to see them in their own home not a concrete cage Born free, let them live their lives in the wild, not in captivity for our entertainment. May God keep you all safe as you continue fighting the good fight.

5,696. Adriana Navarrete Madrid, Spain Aguinaga 5,697. Maree Robinson

Emu Park, Australia

GIVE THEM LIFE AGAIN- SET THEM FREE I PRAY THE RIGHT THING WILL BE DONE HERE FOR THESE DOLPHINS I PRAY A CHANGE WILL COME FOR THE WILD (continues on next page)

Page 229

-

Signatures 5,674 - 5,697

Name

From

Comments

5,697. Maree Robinson

Emu Park, Australia

(continued from previous page)

5,698. Jörg Riehmer

Dresden, Germany

5,699. paola magliola

ancona, Italy

5,700. marco pieranelli

milano, Italy

5,701. robert walsh

nürnberg, Germany

its an absolute disregard, and these people should be heavily prosecuted!!!

5,702. Heather Stip

Western Cap, South Africa

Come on, people, dolphins don't belong in the middle of the desert, in a swimming pool, for crying out loud! Put them back where they belong, in the sea.

5,703. Telma Alves

Lisboa, Portugal

5,704. Karin de Haas

Hurghada, Egypt

5,705. Michael Hobson

Faversham, United Kingdom

5,706. Daniela Marsigliani

ancona, Italy

5,707. Giulioni Luciano

Montemarciano, Italy

5,708. George Stadnik

Astora, NY

5,709. Simon Taylor

Southampton, United Kingdom

Allowing this spectacle, in breach of your own laws and common humanity, perpetuates the stupidity of people who capture dolphins and those who pay to see them. You should be proud of your heritage and educating people, not conspiring with their ignorance.

5,710. John Lobley

Nelson, United Kingdom

Incarcerating wild animals such as dolphins for mere entertainment, like bear baiting, panders to the least noble characteristics of human beings. What does it teach our children?

5,711. Mladenka Pavelic

Crikvenica, Croatia

STOP dolphin killing!

5,712. philiippe plantey

pembroke, Malta

5,713. Alessia Gallus

Oristano, Italy

5,714. Liezel Krieger

Bloemfontein, South Africa

5,715. stefan riedl

munich, Germany

5,716. conchon caroline

les ulis, France

5,717. Lorenzo Sulli

Scandicci, Italy

5,718. pedro morgado

Almada, Portugal Page 230

DOLPHINS BEING CAPTURED OR SLAUGHTERED ONE WORLD ONE CHANCE STOP dolphin captivity in Egypt

I just do not understand how or why these types of captures are necessary in any way. These are the most inteligent species on this planet next to us, just leave them be and stop these hunts/captures/tranportation/trade of the dolphins

Liberate i delfini! Incontrarli in mare aperto e nuotare con loro è certamente più emozionante che vederli rinchiusi all'interno di una piscina!!!!

Stop ! quel interet? GOD IS watching YOU -

Signatures 5,697 - 5,718

Name

From

Comments

5,719. peter fichtner

Vienna, Austria

5,720. CAMILLI LAURA

MONTELABBATE (PU), Italy

5,721. Mario Stefan

Hannover, Germany

we should do the same to this people who capt the Dolphins!!!!!!!!!

5,722. Daniela Günther

Hamburg, Germany

STOP this and set them free!!

5,723. Cara Mason

Chester, United Kingdom

5,724. Kerstin Hahn

Overath, Germany

5,725. Jumana Miqdadi

Edinburgh, United Kingdom

5,726. Edward zammit

Birkirkara, Malta

5,727. Alisha Salkeld

Carlisle, United Kingdom

5,728. Dave London, United Cornelius
CorneliusKingdom 5,729. Nicolette Patterson

Cape Town, South Africa

5,730. Mandy Noe

Calhoun, GA

5,731. Loreta Barbetti

Falconara M.ma (AN), Italy

5,732. Patricia Jones

Rhuddlan, United Kingdom

5,733. Andrea Marchionni

Pesaro, Italy

5,734. Gamze Oz

istanbul, Turkey

5,735. Hani Khalil

Cairo, Egypt

5,736. Jessica A

Greenville, SC

5,737. germana maiolatesi

monteporzio catone, Italy

5,738. Sonja Kirschnick

Cologne, Germany

5,739. pati nigro

Saugerties, NY

5,740. semira bener

istanbul, Turkey

5,741. Uwe Messerschmidt

Cologne, Germany

Page 231

Another useless shame against our world...

It's a shame poeple still do savage acts like these. They were not created to be in captivity.

Please make it illegal to kill dolphins and/or sell them to ANYONE especially to privTE INDIVIDUALS, INVESTORS, INDUSTRIES OF ANY KIND OR FOR ENTERTAINMENT. THEY SHOULD BE PROTECTED AS A SPECIES AND IT IS A CRIME THAT MANY OF US AND HOPEFULLY MANY MORE WILL BOYCOTT JAPAN AND JAPANESE PRODUCTS it´s a shame what people do for profit... poor animals or better poor people!! -

Signatures 5,719 - 5,741

Name

From

Comments

5,742. Gloria Binder

Etobicoke, Canada

5,743. Jennifer Supplee

Ocala, FL

5,744. Samantha Hunter

Errol, United Kingdom

5,745. Leticia Lovheim

Landskrona, Sweden

Leave the DOLPHINS ALONE!!!!!!!!!!!

5,746. Gabrielle Matern

Montreal, Canada

This animal abuse is no different than human slavery. The cruelest of animals is man and the root of its evil is money. I wonder which religion approves of this abuse?

5,747. Mary Brown

Pando, Uruguay

As president of ANIML HELP in Uruguay We support the cause firmly and will spead it

5,748. Ashly Covington

Mechanicsville, VA

Taking dolphins out of the wild is a terrible practice but what is going on in your country is HORRIBLE. How can you stand by and do nothing when there are four helpless animals being kept in a swimming pool in the middle of the desert? They will not survive long and if they die in captivity, your country helped to murder them. Please show the world your humanity and caring spirit and force the owner to release the dolphins into the wild.

5,749. gladys/alfred nemirow

montville, NJ

unthinkable, never repeat this atrocity!

5,750. Alison Jordan

Newbury, United Kingdom

5,751. Dennis Bensberg

Duisburg, Germany

5,752. Jerilyn Catareli

Huntingdon, PA

5,753. Elisa Gitto

Cesano Boscone, Italy

5,754. Frankie Denton

Hallandale, FL

5,755. Bea Jensen-Fangel

Kolding, Denmark

5,756. Erin Keffeler

Selden, NY

5,757. stefano marinelli

senigallia, Italy

5,758. Alicia Hattersley

Eastbourne, United Kingdom

Support HEPCA and the government in Egypt to stop the cruelty to dolphins in Egypt.

5,759. Jessica Rabah

Frisco, TX

This is disgusting. These beautiful animals need to be left in the wild. There is no way you couold ever recreate the home you STOLE them from. They will not survive in captivity , especially the conditions they are being subjected too. What did they do to deserve this?

5,760. Arnaud Dupont

Blacksburg, VA

5,761. marie elaina rago

Allentown, PA Page 232

A dolphin is a wild animal, they should be in the wild!!!! Dolphin's are not our pets, they are beautiful creatures and should be treated with respect.:)

It just breaks my heart that this is happening..please please please stop this insanity!!!

Stopt the pilgrimage of the Dolphins!

I will never go to a dolphin/whale park again, and fully support the efforts of HEPCA.

-

Signatures 5,742 - 5,761

Name

From

Comments

5,762. clare auchterlonie

Redondo Beach, CA

5,763. verbecque christine

Antwerp, Belgium

5,764. Diane Emira

Salt Lake City, UT

5,765. Glen Venezio

San Juan, PR

5,766. ADHAM ATTIA

safaga RED SEA, Egypt

ENOUGH IS ENOUGHSET THEM FREE

5,767. Carmen Demapan Hialeah, FL Fernandez 5,768. william willke

Houston, TX

Please help these beautiful creatures.

5,769. Michael Groh

Walsrode, Germany

5,770. Kathryn McCabe

Natchez, MS

Dolphins do not belong in the middle of the desert!

5,771. Valeria senigaglia

milano, Italy

Dolphinarium are a plain demonstration on how sustainable enjoy of marine mammals is failing to achieve it's goal.

5,772. Tina Kovac

London, United Kingdom

disgraceful!

5,773. Jacob Berelman

Hod Hasharon, Israel

Support HEPCA and the government in Egypt to stop the cruelty to dolphins in Egypt!

5,774. Kara Marshall

Vancouver, Canada

5,775. Nicky Day

New York, NY

I think these ppl are discusting...Cant or wont the UN do anything about it? making it a world wide law against any animal cruelty?

5,776. Sorrentino Teresa naples, Italy 5,777. Donnetta Thomas

Elbing, KS

5,778. Amanda Watson

Oxford, United Kingdom

5,779. Janice Mackenzie-Fast

Richmond, CA

5,780. rodha vencato

vicenza, Italy

5,781. sabrina perez

Molina De Segura, Spain

5,782. Thomas Schinagl

Freistadt, Austria

5,783. Marc Lamshöft

Engelskirchen, Germany

5,784. Dana Laclave

Melbourne, FL

5,785. Gerald Steinwand

Bergneustadt, Germany

5,786. Milos Sazel

PRAGUE 17, Czech Republic Page 233

I AM outraged with the cruel inhuman treament !!!!!

Stop this thing! It`s terrible!!! Egypt is such a nice country, but this cruel things will destroy the nice nacionality of egypt! STOP THIS EMEDIATELY!!!!

-

Signatures 5,762 - 5,786

Name

From

Comments

5,787. Martyn Jakeman

Scourie, United Kingdom

5,788. Chezzi Laetitia

Grône, Switzerland

5,789. Luis Francisco Reyes

Caracas, Venezuela

5,790. Joanne Dowling

SHARM, Egypt

5,791. Laura Domingo

Simi Valley, CA

5,792. leonella mengucci M.labbate (Pu), Italy 5,793. Reiner Lambert

Bensheim, Germany

5,794. Brittany Simpson

South Jordan, UT

5,795. Amr Hamada

Cairo, Egypt

5,796. Joyce Hallidy

Scarborough, ME

5,797. Synthia Gross

Potsdam, Germany

5,798. Peter Kraus

Hartenstein, Germany

5,799. Nicole Sturm

Taunusstein, Germany

5,800. Tess Pilipiszyn

loughborough, United Kingdom

5,801. Uwe Feuerherd

58802, Germany

5,802. carsten urbinat

waldbröl, Germany

5,803. Jennifer Okoluk

Arlington, TX

5,804. mostyn lovett

clevedon, United Kingdom

5,805. Daniel Pursche

Bonn, Germany

STOP! IT! NOW!

5,806. Jelena Zaric

Belgrade, Serbia And Montenegro

Doplhins are not meant to live in tanks- they belong to sea.

5,807. shirley sureck

St Petersburg, FL

5,808. Willi Schröttle

34, Germany

5,809. Sherry Gerszberg

Kendall Park, NJ

5,810. Kai-Sven Vogel

Lucerne, Switzerland

5,811. Ludger Krane

Los Angeles, CA

5,812. kai lovett

clevedon, United Kingdom

5,813. Delma S. Fleming, Ph.D.

Ponce,, Puerto Rico

5,814. Dolores Gallo

El Gouna, Egypt

5,815. Marjolein Groenewegen

The Hague, Netherlands

5,816. Mirette Bakir

Cairo, Egypt Page 234

this is so very cruel......

In this day and age there should not be news of animal cruelty like this, from any country. Humanity it seems is not going froward.

Bring them back to their family in the sea, where they belong. -

Signatures 5,787 - 5,816

Name

From

Comments

5,817. Diana Petrova

Sofia, Bulgaria

5,818. Frederic Luc

Courdimanche, France

5,819. Rossana Pastrana

Barcelona, Spain

5,820. Gernot Bsteh

Stockerau, Austria

5,821. hilary meyer

earlysville, VA

5,822. solange scherer

st pete, FL

5,823. Tim Weyers

Brüggenn, Germany

5,824. suzanne weaver

Panama City Beach, FL

5,825. Tracy Dorrance

Sebastopol, CA

5,826. Monika Daller

Köln, Germany

5,827. Tracy Fay

Erith, United Kingdom

5,828. Ksenia Watts

London, United Kingdom

5,829. Amy Hynd

Stafford, United Kingdom

5,830. Donatella Tizi

Fermo, Italy

5,831. Elizabeth Matteini

canton, MI

5,832. Enas El-Saddik

6 October, Egypt

5,833. Andy England

Bristol, United Kingdom

5,834. Ursula Aragunde Kohl

Guaynabo, Puerto Rico

5,835. Alejandra V

Buenos Aires, Argentina

5,836. Behrang Bina

Melbourne, Australia

5,837. Justine Garcia

North Hollywood, CA

5,838. Natalie Baus

Helotes, TX Page 235

Dolphins do not belong in captivity. They will commit suicide when held captive. They live with their families in the wild and they hear with sonar. Their sonar makes it impossible to hear in a concrete tank. It is inhumane to make them live like this. They are suffering and won't survive. Grausam!

It is absolutely cruel to take an animal that requires a great body of water to live in humane conditions and stick it in a swimming pool for profit. It's also cruel to support this kind of industry. It will be extinct soon as people learn about this cruelty and stop it by NOT supporting it any longer. I'm one of them.

Stop doing horrible things as they'll hit back at you at some stage of your life. Animals are defenceless, loving creatures, and it's our responsibility to take care of them. If we don't, it's a crime, and we'll be punished.Karma.

Please stop facilitating the removal of dolphins from their natural habitats! Get those dolphins back to the ocean. They deserve a good life.

-

Signatures 5,817 - 5,838

Name

From

Comments

5,839. Nicole Hauer

Hamburg, Germany

5,840. Li Wun Loo

kepong, Malaysia

5,841. Veronica Torres

Los Angeles, CA

5,842. Ivan Lin

Singapore, Singapore

5,843. paola paccassoni

fano, Italy

for free dolphin in the sea

5,844. Michael Modro

Winsen, Germany

STOP dolphin captivity in Egypt and all over the world!

5,845. Hester Low

-, Singapore

5,846. dorottya luntz

budaörs, Hungary

5,847. Kerstin Arff

Kiel, Germany

5,848. Freja Lovett

Clevedon, United Kingdom

5,849. Maren Kukuk

Berlin, Germany

5,850. Michaela Göhr

Halver, Germany

5,851. annarita sensini

falconara marittima, Italy

5,852. Francesca Mannucci

arezzo, Italy

5,853. Elisa Brongers

Schiedam, Netherlands

5,854. Layne Russell

Redding, CA

5,855. Manuela Haug

Leinzell, Germany

5,856. magda maamoun

giza, Egypt

5,857. sebastian grob

Dormagen, Germany

5,858. Janina Halbauer

Wülfrath, Germany

5,859. Alexey Terskiy

Moscow, Russian Federation

5,860. mark willoughby

loughborough, United Kingdom

5,861. Юлия Микульская

Рыбинск, Russian Federation

5,862. Bianca Gottwald

Castrop-rauxel, Germany

5,863. tiziana piccinini

falconara m.ma, Italy

5,864. Birgit Grahl

Berlin, Germany

sham on you egypt for fueling the slaughter of dolphins in taiji

5,865. Katie Cape Town, South Peacock-Edwards Africa 5,866. Ana Collazo

those poor dolphins need to be set free

SHOCKING !!!! The creatures of the planet have a right to live in FREEDOM, just as much as us humans do ( we are creatures too, no more advanced, but VERY selfish ! ) RELEASE all Dolphins in captivity !!!!

Ponce, Puerto Rico Page 236

-

Signatures 5,839 - 5,866

Name

From

Comments

5,867. Thomas Gebert

Stein, Germany

5,868. Cigdem Cooper

Sharm el Sheikh, Egypt

5,869. Ian hook

somerset, United Kingdom

5,870. Georges Pharaon

leb, Lebanon

5,871. brooke waites

essex, United Kingdom

5,872. Beatrice Nippe

Berlin, Germany

5,873. paola sturba

Ancona, Italy

5,874. Bassem Wahba

---------------, Egypt

5,875. Melissa Menotti

Chiaravalle, Italy

5,876. Annalena Hagenah

Berlin, Germany

5,877. Paul Gose

Pfullingen, Germany

5,878. Klaus Remmele

Munic, Germany

5,879. Laura Zaky

glastonbury, United Kingdom

Just awful, how can we really let this go on????

5,880. Gerhard Felsche

53842, Germany

STOP dolphin captivity in Egypt

5,881. Christian Lanner

Birgitz, Austria

5,882. nikole L

new york, NY

5,883. ale mari

hann münden, AE

5,884. Naomi Bergau

Bury St. Edmunds, United Kingdom

5,885. Bertela Pascale

13100, France

5,886. Antonella Cabrelli

London, United Kingdom

5,887. Zuzanna Rote

Poznan, Poland

5,888. Justyna Wrzesinska

Torun, Poland

5,889. David Mannheim

Krefeld, Germany

5,890. Thomas Siebenson

Kairo, Egypt

5,891. Johann Berger

Stockerau, Austria

5,892. Philipp Schwingel

safaga, Egypt

5,893. Alexandra Klein

Eppelheim, Germany

5,894. Mark Attard

East Northport, NY

this is disgusting, wake up, who wants to openly view cruelty???

Stop!!!!!!!! Lives them alone!

The belief that you can take what you desire without giving God's creatures respect for living the life they were born into disgusts me. Man's potential for arrogance, greed, and (continues on next page)

Page 237

-

Signatures 5,867 - 5,894

Name

From

Comments

5,894. Mark Attard

East Northport, NY

(continued from previous page)

5,895. Simone Gaeckle

Schwäbisch Hall, Germany

5,896. Jeannette Stadler-Remmele

München, Germany

5,897. patricia van asbroeck

Birgitz, Austria

5,898. Jürgen Kellner

Heroldsberg, Germany

5,899. David Lowndes

M, Malta

5,900. Samantha Esra

Johannesburg, South Africa

5,901. letizia balsamo

Perinaldo, Italy

5,902. A. Searle

Edinburgh, United Kingdom

5,903. Evelyn König

Köln, Germany

5,904. annette merl

hurghada, Egypt

5,905. Nihan Burkay

Bursa, Turkey

lack of empathy is displayed in those seeking to capitalize on dolphins and cetaceans of all sizes.

Please stop the import of dolphins in the Middle East.

dophins should never be in capture,its well known that dolphin suffer a hell in captivity & can die after a while.dolphins care the most intelligent animals on this earth & extremly sensibel ! its elementary for dolphins to be happy & free in nature.

5,906. denise Verhaegen Grand Quevilly, France 5,907. Thomas Wisst

Stuttgart, Germany

5,908. Joachim Tröster

Gochsheim, Germany

5,909. Agnieszka Kubicz

Chrzanow, Poland

5,910. Dorothea Reitz

Winhöring, Germany

5,911. Hazel Seymour

Saskatoon, Canada

5,912. Tammy Marino

Phillipsburg, NJ

5,913. Erika Armoa Martinez

Asuncion, Paraguay

5,914. Mona Daoud

Cairo, Egypt

5,915. Vitaly Bellkin

Tomsk, Russian Federation

5,916. Megan McKenna

Chandler, AZ

5,917. Kathy Schemers

Waterford, MI

5,918. Rita Thompson

newcastle upon tyne, United Kingdom Page 238

-

nature is cruel enough, without man adding to it.

Signatures 5,894 - 5,918

Name

From

Comments

5,919. Marion Bardenbacher

Nürnberg, Germany

5,920. Jennifer Keeton

Salyersville, KY

5,921. Hans Klapka

Steinheim, Germany

5,922. Birgitta Oberting

Ainring, Germany

Stop this unbelievable Act!

5,923. Martina Friedrichs Moelln, Germany 5,924. Knut Reuss

Nuertingen, Germany

Stop this unbelievable Act!

5,925. Patricia Zerta

Herten, Germany

Dolphins are very intelligent animals, they can`t live in captivity!!! That`s why dolphinarium be closed in Germany. How would you feel if your life locked in a room???

5,926. douglas coats

angaston, Australia

capturing wild creatures of any kind is a disgrace unless it is of benefit to the species

5,927. anke strothteicher

Berlin, Germany

5,928. pille francois

Aulnay, France

5,929. Gudrun Wiesflecker

Absam, Austria

5,930. Georg Hauch

Eschbronn, Germany

5,931. Mike Freel

New Orleans, LA

5,932. Thorsten Z

Hannover, Germany

5,933. Kim Smith

Auckland, New Zealand

5,934. Tiffany Theden

Brooklyn, NY

5,935. robert markee

joshua Tree, CA

5,936. Asmaa El-Degwi

Giza, Egypt

thank you for taking this message. please consider releasing these beautiful mammals back into the wild where they belong, not caged in a chemical filled watery prison. thank you

5,937. Sascha Kovacevic nürnberg, Germany 5,938. Maren Heinig

Sydney, Australia

5,939. SY Leung

Tai Po, Hong Kong

5,940. Val Munchow

Johannesburg, South Africa

5,941. Detlef Möller

Lippstadt, Germany

5,942. susanne schmitz

Düren, Germany

5,943. Jan Bochinski

Warszawa, Poland

5,944. Natalia Dziedzianowicz

Warsaw, Poland

5,945. Martina Schwarz

Reutlingen, Germany

Einfach nur grausam diese Quälerei. STOP IT NOW !

5,946. Jonathan Young

Honiton, United Kingdom

Lock their kids in a small dirty room, then ask them how they feel !!!!!!!

Page 239

Please stop hurting the dolphines

-

Signatures 5,919 - 5,946

Name

From

Comments

5,947. Amy Kingston

hockley, United Kingdom

Please implore these poor dolphins and return them back to the wild where they belong not stressed in a captive unsuitable prison!

5,948. Giulia D'Antuono

Pesaro, Italy

5,949. Carola Eschborn

Aschaffenburg, Germany

5,950. ADELINE ROUMAILHAC

villefranche de conflent, France

5,951. Judy Mayor

Murillo, Canada

5,952. Juergen Thuerk

St. Gallen, Switzerland

Dolphins are born to live in freedom

5,953. nicolas focquet

hurghada, Egypt

together change is possible

5,954. Suzi Livesay

Peoria, AZ

What you are doing is contributing to the dolphin hunt & slaaughter such as those that take place in Taiji, Japan. Please, have a heart, stop now.

5,955. Bianca Camilotti

Mannheim, Germany

5,956. Till Holzheuer

Sandweier, Germany

5,957. Emil Walters

Salzburg, Austria

5,958. Angie Bahris

Abbotsford, Canada

5,959. susanna wolf

sinsheim, Germany

5,960. René Rösler

Rangsdorf, Germany

5,961. linda brockett

Calderbank, United Kingdom

5,962. Klaus Nöbauer

Linz, Austria

5,963. Tamer El-Helw

Orlando, FL

5,964. anuschka tournoy

Oostkamp, Belgium

Free the dolpins - now !!!

stop wale captivity anywhere an stop dolphin slaughtering in japan!!

5,965. Emily McSpadden Tulsa, OK 5,966. Sarah Tomlinson

Sale, Cheshire, United Kingdom

5,967. Helmut Schuster

Vienna, Austria

5,968. Lucia S.

Charlottesville, VA

5,969. Fiona Morrison

Dahab, Egypt

5,970. laila karim

cairo, Egypt Page 240

These dolphins need to be released immediately. They're going to die if they stay in that pool much longer. Please let them go home.

Please show respect for these beautiful creatures, who love living freely as we humans do. Tourists in general, and especially divers are very opposed to dolphin shows and dolphinariums. Setting these up in Egypt will be a serious blow to Egypt's popularity as a tourism destination. Please set these creatures free!

-

Signatures 5,947 - 5,970

Name

From

Comments

5,971. Rani Codron

Herzele, Belgium

Stop it !!

5,972. Tanya Riley

Withernsea, United Kingdom

This is disgraceful for 4 dolphins to be kept in such a small pool with no faiclities

5,973. charmaine whalley

nottingham, United Kingdom

5,974. Joachim Wischerhoff

Muelheim an der Ruhr, Germany

5,975. COSSON VALERIE

LE MANS, France

5,976. Antonio Orsini

Unterensingen, Germany

5,977. jean pierre richy

le mans, France

5,978. Diana Hermes

Gimbsheim, Germany A real scandal!!!!

5,979. Keith Peake

Reading, United Kingdom

5,980. Paul Kemp

Rijswijk, Netherlands

5,981. Sieber Pirmin

Wattwil, Switzerland

5,982. Astrid Maxelon

Overath, Germany

5,983. Holly Franklin

south sinai, Egypt

5,984. stasi alessandra

TAVIANO, Italy

5,985. Frank Berg

Bönen, Germany

5,986. Dawn Goodall

irvine, United Kingdom

5,987. Simon Wenk

Basel, Switzerland

5,988. Heike Wildt

Garbsen, Germany

5,989. Nadine Bühre

Kiel, Germany

5,990. Andrea Wittenburg

Tor., Canada

5,991. Hannelore Mattausch

Bad Haering, Austria

5,992. Mike Roberts

Fort Mill, SC

5,993. miriam krenzke

offenbach, AE

5,994. Dion Borg

Mellieha, Malta Page 241

I am a diver and regularly consider coming to Egypt. There is no excuse for keeping these magnificent animals in captivity. As long as this happens in Egypt i will dive elsewhere in the World and will not give any of my tourist money to your country

The Egyptian gov should recognise that this is not where the dolphins belong, they should be consistent with there views & ensure these dolphins are freed.

Capturing wild intelligent animals to be used purely for human entertainment is the highest form of self-centered arrogance! Further injustice is to constrain an animal that regularly travels 60-70 kilometers a day in the vast open oceans to a pool in the desert! Please, you must not allow this to continue.

-

Signatures 5,971 - 5,994

Name

From

Comments

5,995. sandra milton

rabat, Malta

5,996. Soha Eshraghi

Fresno, CA

5,997. Erin Mellett

Ballwin, MO

5,998. Daniela Weber

Leithen, Austria

5,999. Karl Drost

Emmerich am Rhein, Germany

6,000. Rainer Stump

Mühlheim, Germany

6,001. Julia Brugger

Innsbruck, Austria

6,002. Maxine Lee

Caringbah, Australia

Stop it

6,003. wolfgang scheiber adnet, Austria 6,004. Natalia Vinogradova

Moscow, Russian Federation

6,005. Marie Maurer

Montréal, Canada

6,006. Claudio Calamari

Piacenza, Italy

6,007. leyna stemle

Chesterfield, MO

6,008. Denise Hansen

Waterford, WI

6,009. Jennifer Rowley

Scarborough, United Kingdom

6,010. Tim Green

sharm, Egypt

6,011. Ayman Afifi

Giza, Egypt

6,012. Angeles Madrazo

Cd. Del Carmen, Campeche, Mexico

6,013. Jens Kopper

El Gouna, Egypt

6,014. Felix Wesel

Munihch, Germany

6,015. Keryn Bowden

Shellharbour, Australia

6,016. Ludovic MAC LEOD

BORDEAUX, France

6,017. Juliane Vietze

Vechta, Germany

6,018. René Rieger

Salzburg, Austria

6,019. eduard werner

vienna, Austria

6,020. Kristin Weber

Mainz, Germany

6,021. Susanne Lachnit

Vienna, Austria

6,022. Ahmed El Menoufy

Cairo, Egypt

6,023. Sarah Brulhart

Bulle, Switzerland

6,024. Andreas Wörther

Salzburg, Austria Page 242

HORRIBLE! Stop this insane madness!

I think more seriously is to stop trade in Endagered species particularly marine mammals.

STOP THIS !!!!!!!!!!!

Let them live in their natural environment. Would we put human beings in cages??????

-

Signatures 5,995 - 6,024

Name

From

Comments

6,025. Fatma Wafaai

Cairo, Egypt

6,026. trivelli daniele

roma, Italy

6,027. Danielle Pomfret

Glossop, United Kingdom

6,028. Kate Van den Neucker

hasselt, Belgium

6,029. Mary Greenwood

Lancashire, United Kingdom

6,030. gill ashton

Wallasey, United Kingdom

6,031. Estelle Denamur

Rixensart, Belgium

6,032. Lisa Wilson

Abingdon, United Kingdom

6,033. Susan Bergman

Göteborg, Sweden

6,034. Alison Pong

Hong Kong, Hong Kong

6,035. steen ludovic

la chapelle st aubin, France

6,037. Chris Moynihan

Albany, NY

6,038. Joan Smolar

Manalapan, NJ

These smart beautiful creatures should not be kept in captivity.

6,039. Tamer Edward

Hurghada, Egypt

STOPIT

6,040. Claudia Kalies

Berlin, Germany

6,041. Norbert Meyer

Chemnitz, Germany

6,042. Anna Kim

Augusta, GA

6,043. cousin elodie

ferriere la grande, France

6,044. Lorraine Pitt

shrewsbury, United Kingdom

6,045. Peter Detmold

Detmold, Germany

6,046. gabrielle onorato

rimouski, Canada

6,047. Asim Sheikh

Dublin, Ireland

6,049. elodie genga

Lure, France

6,050. Erin Riedemann

Crosby, MN

6,051. Françoise Bonté

Evry, France

6,052. Jenny Schrecklinger

Wallerfangen, Germany

6,053. Erik Garbe

Hammarã¶, Sweden Page 243

I OBJECT TO DOLPHIN CAPTIVITY. These dolphins need to be taken back to their home IMMEDIATELY. ALIVE.

If people want to see dolphins it should be in the ocean where they can be free to come and go as they wish.

these beutiful dolphins should never be put into captivity it is soul destroying to see this cruelty happen in this day and age shame on you !!!

stop this madness!

-

Signatures 6,025 - 6,053

Name

From

Comments

6,054. Michelle du Preez

Auckland, New Zealand

6,055. Devaney Roberts

Springfield, OH

6,056. Maike Pohl

Celle, Germany

6,057. Kevin Smith

Dublin, CA

6,058. Barbara Wertz

Williamsport, PA

6,059. Karen Johnson

Castle Hill, Australia

6,060. Corey W

Indio, CA

6,061. martin sachs

dortmund, Germany

6,062. Julien Blanchard

Chartres, France

6,063. rob green

london, United Kingdom

6,064. Alex McKnight

Reading, United Kingdom

6,065. Michael Fischer

Berlon, Germany

6,066. Valentina Kiessling

Tashkent, Uzbekistan

6,067. FRYDLENDER Michel

LOMBRON, France

6,068. Francis GRUAU

Brains sur Gée, France

6,069. Poppy Wilson

Glasgow, United Kingdom

6,070. JAMIN Aurélien

Montbizot, France

6,071. piron christophe

le mans, France

6,072. gordon GREENWOOD

Port st Mary, United Kingdom

6,073. Karen De Man

Overijse, Belgium

6,074. Gaia Cairati

Cassano d'Adda, Italy It's cruel.Leave the Dolphins in their natural environment

6,075. Igor Pylypan

Donetsk, Ukraine

6,076. Cordova Valentina

Pontenure, Italy

6,077. bourdeau sylvie

le mans, France

6,078. Pascale GUILLOMET

YVRE L'EVEQUE, France

Set them free!

6,079. Paul Dixon

Falkirk, United Kingdom

No animal should be kept in captivity, what right do we have to essentially jail for life an innocent being?

6,080. Taburet damien

le Mans, France

6,081. VALENTIN Stéphane

LE MANS, France

Page 244

Stop this! We don't need a dolphinarium!

these creatures should be in the ocean, not being petted by ignorant tourists 10 hours a day.

-

Signatures 6,054 - 6,081

Name

From

Comments

6,082. katja popowicz

Stuttgart, Germany

6,083. w Prieur

72650, France

6,084. jacques DUPREY

XXX, France

6,085. Lisa Moloney

Harrogate, United Kingdom

Totally shocked - I did not realise Egypt were allowing this misery to take place. My heart goes out to these intelligent beautiful creature kept in a FISH TANK!!! Will never recommend Egypt as a "holiday" destination and make sure I tell everyone why

6,086. ;ark Titz

Lorch, Germany

Stopp !!!!!

6,087. Vanessa Hass

Laatzen, Germany

Me, my familiy and our friends will never visit Egypt again when things like this will happen!!! Set all dolphins free !!!

6,088. Gilles COINCON

ST SATURNIN, France

Barbares!!!

6,089. karen wilkinson

clitheroe, United Kingdom

i wonder if these people would like to be put in a cage that is to small for them and not cared for properly so that they get ill! i'm dam sure they would not not so why do it to wild animals like these. Why don't they set up tour boats to see these creatures in the wild and swim with them in there enviroment where they would be free to interact with the public if they wanted to,isn't that what freedom is all about? would these people like to be slaves all over again?

6,090. Richard Nash

LLANGOLLEN, United Kingdom

Visitors to Egypt now have evry chance to swim with wild dolphins in the Red Sea. Thsi should be regulated and encouraged rather than keep these mammals in inhumane condition in pools. Such abuse does your image no good.

6,091. Madison Martinez

Annandale, VA

6,092. Erika Vervliet

Mortsel, Belgium

6,093. Chloe Smith

Wolverhampton, United Kingdom

6,094. Andrea Decker

Pentling, Germany

6,095. Patrick Cleary

Wolverhampton, United Kingdom

6,096. Frank Aurich

Berlin, Germany

6,097. DORE benoit

savigné l'evêque, France

6,098. Doreen Kruscha

Berlin, Germany

6,099. Serena Wittkopp

Hollywood, CA

6,100. Alexis Trevino

Hurst, TX

6,101. Viola Kienast

Cairo, Egypt

6,102. Stefanie Schmitt

Hanau, Germany

6,103. Max Schluckebier

Gießen, Germany Page 245

We have recently had a wonderful diving club holiday to Egypt though i was completely unaware this cruelty was taking place. I will certainly not visit again as long as this continues!

Please do continue speaking for the Japan Dolphins!

-

Signatures 6,082 - 6,103

Name

From

Comments

6,104. Mari Carmen Moral

Payson, IL

6,105. Cayce Smith

Austin, TX

6,106. Cynthia Lopez

Vancouver, WA

Shame on you for killing there beautiful mammals

6,107. Carola Dams-Ostendorp

Weener, Germany

Me and my family will never visit Egypt again, as long as such a cruelty of animals will happen!

6,108. laura morrison

Calgary, Canada

6,109. Brooke Comer

cairo, Egypt

6,110. Jens Maertens

Seesen, Germany

6,111. PELLIER JEAN PIERRE

AMNE, France

6,112. Jackie Shannon

Warrington, United Kingdom

6,113. Enrico Toso

phuket, Thailand

6,114. Martein Meier

München, Germany

6,115. Lauren Plummer

Kent, United Kingdom

6,116. Chris Plummer

Kent, United Kingdom Disgraceful

6,117. Chloe Hunt

Minehead, United Kingdom

6,118. Petra Holzmann

Schriesheim, Germany

6,119. Karin Messelink

Leeuwarden, Netherlands

6,120. Hala El asmar

Cairo, Egypt

6,121. Jocelyn Newman

Canberra, Australia

6,122. Jo Mattock

London, United Kingdom

6,123. Elizabeth Saunders

Hurghada, Egypt

6,124. Sandra Beck

Seitenstetten, Austria

shocking

Well, it's sad but true ...

A distressing sign of human greed gone too far - in an attempt to pull in more tourist dollars these companies are handing out life sentences of imprisonment to these innocent creatures. If these were Pandas or Polar Bears I'm pretty sure this would never have been allowed. We must begin to respect our marine life, before it is too late.

6,125. Stephanie Mueller heidelberg, Germany

It is a shame, whow is it possible to buy the Dolphins so easiely- do they have a permittion to import them to Egypt.? Dolphins have to live in the nature - not in Pools!!

6,126. Emily Pompei

VB, VA

Hunting them & enslaving them is no different than kidnapping children from their families & selling them into the underground world of human trafficking. End it NOW!!!

6,127. Richard Norbury

London, United Kingdom

Is this really neccesary? I think not!!!

Page 246

-

Signatures 6,104 - 6,127

Name

From

Comments

6,128. Manfred Lackner

Riegersburg, Austria

6,129. Martina Gruber

Ramsau, Austria

6,130. Justina van Bakel

2, Netherlands

6,131. lara gerdes

sharm, Egypt

6,132. veronica magni

Milano, Italy

6,133. Amir Sarhan

Cairo, Egypt

6,134. paul davis

Plymouth, United Kingdom

6,135. Nadine Trenz

Aurich, Germany

6,136. miranda rais

cadiz, Spain

6,137. paula lampard

weymouth, United Kingdom

Disgusting! End this now!!!!

6,138. Andrea Cosentino Malaga, Spain

Captivity is a torture that we can not afford

6,139. Jane Sanderson

Newquay, United Kingdom

PLEASE ADDRESS THIS SITUATION I WAS GOING TO COME OUT TO YOUR COUNTRY ON HOLIDAY, BUT I AM NOW THINKING TWICE BECAUSE OF THIS!

6,140. wendy clack

Edinburgh, United Kingdom

6,141. vanessa eldridge

PADSTOW, United Kingdom

6,142. Lucinda Cowing

ku, Japan

6,143. Christina Girotto

Florianopolis SC, Brazil

6,144. Regina Widd

Coventry, United Kingdom

I have recently bought an apartment in Makadi Bay - but was unaware of this !I am absolutely appalled and disgusted that this is going on in a country I love so much !!! Please put a stop to this cruelty and the planned dolphinarium in Makadi !!!! Leave your dolphins where they belong - in your oceans !!!and don't give in to greed !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Thank you x

6,145. Marion Brooksby

Falkirk, United Kingdom

Please please put a stop to this,dolphins should be in their natural free environment

6,146. Kasia Nowacka

Kornik, Poland

6,147. Tom King

ware, United Kingdom

Dolphins are beautiful creatuures to be seen in the wild only! down with dolphinarium!!!!

6,148. Patty Tse

Hong Kong, Hong Kong

Keeping the dolphins in such a small pool is extremely cruel. I won't visit Egypt unless the dolphins are freed!!!!!!

6,149. Jenny Hung

Hong Kong, Hong Kong

6,150. Vaidas Gasickas

Vejle, Denmark

LET dolphins GO, bastards!

6,151. skott daltonic

Boston, MA

PLEASE set these animals free!

Page 247

These are wild animals not goldfish. They have every right to live a proper life in the sea, until us humans come along and capture and kill every thing that moves!!

-

Signatures 6,128 - 6,151

Name

From

Comments

6,152. Eric Scibor-Rylski

México City, Mexico

6,153. angie chapman

loughborough, United Kingdom

6,154. Emma Gee

Manchester, United Kingdom

6,155. Julie Oldham

Bridlington, United Kingdom

6,156. Jessica Jones

hacketstown, Ireland

6,157. Gen MacCallum

Easington, United Kingdom

6,158. Robin Vigfusson

Nutley, NJ

6,159. Marie Aston

Sandend, United Kingdom

6,160. Wayne Hanley

St Georges Basin, Australia

6,161. ian grieves

Perth, United Kingdom

6,162. jyl forsyth

Birmingham, MI

6,163. carly slight

Horley, United Kingdom

6,164. Bruno Fouque

LE MANS, France

6,165. Paula Coelho

Santo António Cavaleiros, Portugal

6,166. Justine Curgenven

Mynydd Llandegai, United Kingdom

6,167. veronica stancorelli

mallorca, Spain

6,168. Jacquie W

Singapore, Singapore

6,169. Hope Turner

Leicester, United Kingdom

Please, please release these dolpins back into the wild while it still fresh to them. They are not supposed to be in captivity. How can they live in this small shallow pool for the rest of their lives, being fed alsorts of drugs to keep them mellow. How would we like it if we were locked in a small room for the rest of our lives. Its not right, Egypt, stand out from the other countries and stop it now...

I can't believe anyone would do this to sentient beings. But then I know how humans treat each other - is there any hope for non-human animals?

Shameful, this should never be allowed.

just stop this...it is obscene.

6,170. rebecca mckenzie sheffield, United Kingdom

Dolphins belong in the wild not fishtanks!

6,171. Jessie Taylor

Why do these beautiful creatures have to keep suffering in such vile conditions for OUR entertainment? Dolphins were born in the ocean, not pools - with reason! Put them back where they belong, where they'll be happy.

Prescott, AZ

Page 248

-

Signatures 6,152 - 6,171

Name

From

Comments

6,172. Brenden Gebhart

Prescott, AZ

6,173. Pauline booth

Stonehaven, United Kingdom

6,174. Morgan Weber

Wattrelos, France

6,175. PAULA MAHER

south yorkshrie, United Kingdom

6,176. Kath K

London, United Kingdom

6,177. Geneva Sawick

Union City, PA

"One day the absurdity of the almost universal human belief in the slavery of other animals will be palpable. We shall then have discovered our souls and become worthier of sharing this planet with them." -- Martin Luther King, Jr

6,178. Vanessa Roden

Goettingen, Germany

I love the Red Sea. There is enough to see there; aquariums and such are needless.

6,179. Stephanie Langner

Hamburg, Germany

6,180. michael klimt

salzburg, Austria

6,181. kree eyre

Broome, Australia

6,182. Christopher Wallace

Binfield, United Kingdom

6,183. Karen Connellan

Hobart, Australia

Please. please stop this cruel torturous existence!! :( This is completely inhumane!! :( I think it is disgusting keeping these highley intellegent animals in captivity when they have a right to be free to have there families and to be free from harm and to be kept safe.I am strongley against this treatment of dolphins and it should be stopped FULL STOP!.

Shame on Hurghada for this cruel captivity of these gentle creatures and shame on Japan for hunting them.

6,184. Courtney Brennan Henley on Thames, United Kingdom 6,185. Clara Stella

Milano, Italy

6,186. Liz McKay

BATHGATE, United Kingdom

PLEASE LEAVE THE DOLPHINS ALONE, SO THEY CAN LIVE IN PEACE IN THERE OWN HABITAT. HOW WOULD YOU LIKE TO BE HELD IN CAPTIVITY???

6,187. Juanita Toth

Pleasanton, CA

This is horrifying and so terrible.

6,188. Ingo Ludwig

Schwerin, Germany

6,190. ezio cavazzini

segrate, Italy

pratica crudele ed inutile dato che basta una barca x vederli liberi in mezzo al mare!

6,191. Georg Körner

Düsseldorf, Germany

Stop it!

6,192. Holise Cleveland

Fall River, MA

6,193. mostafa abdelhaleem

Hurghada, Egypt

6,194. Jeremy Ferro

07100, France

6,195. massimo gifoli

new york, NY

Page 249

Bring them back to the sea, you are doing the wrong thing

-

Signatures 6,172 - 6,195

Name

From

Comments

6,197. Tess Stevenson

Houghton Regis, United Kingdom

6,198. Nico Lothring

Heusenstamm, Germany

6,199. Lynn Gladhill

Portsmouth, NH

6,200. Beatriz Tur

São Paulo, Brazil

6,201. lynn malcolm

merseyside, United Kingdom

6,202. WONG SZE

HONG KONG, Hong Kong

6,203. Wendy Pool

Coral Springs, FL

6,204. Yat Ming Lee

Hong Kong, Hong Kong

6,205. Kara Mathiesen

Loveland, CO

6,206. Christian Burgess

Bridgetown, Australia

6,207. Ashley senior

Bronx, NY

6,208. Annastacia Fulcher

Nj, NJ

There is far more enjoyment to be had watching these beautiful mammals in the wild instead of being badly treated into doing stupid tricks. These animals are being stolen from the wild, how frightened they must be. We need to stop this NOW.

6,209. Clara Soon

Petaling Jaya, Malaysia

Dolphins do belong in the oceans and we have no right to imprison them. Stop torturing those dolphins... =(

6,210. Claudia Roos

Ingelheim, Germany

Let them free !!!!

6,211. Janice Kendall

Rotherham, United Kingdom

This is not entertainment it's sadistic and cruel. This is extremely cruel to these dolphins in their efforts to entertain you. Next time you enjoy a day at Sea World consider what these whales and dolphins are put through. This is not a way for sentient brings to live and.be treated ~ What a sick and disgusting world we live in when animals are treated in such cruel ways for our entertainment. :o( Lynn

STOP dolphin captivity!

6,212. Sandie Kristensen Cph, Denmark 6,213. Conrad de Jesus

Brentwood, CA

6,214. Mark Hansen

San Diego, CA

6,215. Nika Palušová

Bratislava, Slovakia

6,216. Edeltraud Wiemers

Blankenfelde, Germany

6,217. Emma Bird

Edinburgh, United Kingdom

6,218. Ulf Heckmann

Kasendorf, Germany Page 250

This has to stop.

-

Signatures 6,197 - 6,218

Name

From

Comments

6,219. Robert Mairesse

Escondido, CA

6,220. ELTIBY JOELLE

ESCHAU, France

6,221. laurence socquet-juglard

Quimper, France

6,222. Ingeborg Pannekoek

Papendrecht, Netherlands

6,223. charrier nicolas

saint gelais, France

6,224. M DoroffWilkie

Burnsville, MN

Let them free!

6,225. Raymonde Steurs Bruxelles, Belgium 6,226. Nick Davies

Porthcawl, United Kingdom

6,227. Robert Rutkowski

Dortmund, Germany

6,228. Andrea Angel

Sunrise, FL

6,229. Karma Thomas

Boise, ID

6,230. Alex Sluder

Rock Hill, SC

6,231. Christian Hartmann

Stuttgart, Germany

6,232. Rosemary Sutcliffe

Goulburn, Australia

6,233. elca maranzana

South Hadley, MA

6,234. shirley mcburney

Co. Antrim, United Kingdom

6,235. Nadine Seidel

Eppendorf, Germany

6,236. eve green

roanoke, VA

6,237. Günter Reichardt

Neudenau, Germany

Dolfins in prisson - no living conditions for this living beings

6,238. kerry firkin

Newcastle, Australia

We must protect these beautiful Koala Bears they are our treausers we must do all we can to protect them

6,239. Sona Cermakova

Bratislava, Slovakia

6,240. Dawn Woody

Middletown, NY

6,241. Ischel Bianco

Houston, TX

6,242. chelsea andrews

London, United Kingdom

6,243. Sazz j

Newcastle, United Kingdom

6,244. Jane Keating

Brighton, United Kingdom

Get these poor dolphins back to their natural habitat in the ocean now...this is totally disgusting...how dare you, who do you think you are keeping these beautiful animals in a pool??? Release them now and show SOME compassion

6,245. Jamie-lee Shimizu Elk Grove, CA 6,246. Danielle Fender

Fort Myers, FL Page 251

-

Signatures 6,219 - 6,246

Name

From

Comments

6,247. Rachel Larivee

London, Canada

I won't stop, until people realize the consequences!

6,248. Ina Hilmer

Schieder, Germany

I have been at the awareness night. I will tell all people I know about this stupid plans. All my colleagues will get a example of the Cove from me with christmas. It starts with the little things...Please keep go ahad with what you are doing and let me know if can support you on other ways. Thanks a lot for what you are doing. Your have all my respect. Love, Ina

6,249. Keli Tobias

Aurora, Canada

6,250. Stefan Leenborg Jensen

Odense C, Denmark

6,251. Marina Mikkelsen

San Luis Obispo, CA

6,252. faye b

-, Ireland

6,253. Gavin Swan

Sanga Pt, Australia

6,254. El Simpson

Philadelphia, PA

6,255. lauren jerrey

crawley, United Kingdom

These animals are living in a bathtub! They should be free and no captive situation can ever mimic that..

6,256. Diederik Jeangout Belsele, Belgium 6,257. Cailan O'Connell

Dublin 3, Ireland

6,258. Charity Colvin

Belton, TX

6,259. Bernadette Manzano

Hayward, CA

6,260. Peter King

Crewe, United Kingdom

6,261. Neil Staveley

Norwich, United Kingdom

6,262. Elaine Edwards

St. Catharines, Canada

6,263. postic patrice

morlaix, France

6,264. Maria Atwood

carmichael, CA

6,265. Julie Sickles

Clyde, OH

6,266. Patricia Medvescek

Brownsburg, IN

6,267. Lindsey Porter

Columbus, GA

STOP THE MADNESS!

6,268. Melissa Hunsicker Lehighton, PA 6,269. Karen Koenig

Los Angeles, CA

6,270. Denise Nutt

Reynoldsburg, OH

6,271. Rachel Holzer

windermere, FL

6,272. Lara Celikel

krefeld, Germany

6,273. Tami Goodall

Snohomish, WA Page 252

-

Signatures 6,247 - 6,273

Name

From

Comments

6,274. Helene Jakobsen

Oslo, Norway

6,275. Lindsey Cherry

Colorado Springs, CO

6,276. John Neal

Charlotte, NC

6,277. Muhanad Youssef fort lee, NJ 6,278. Geisla Lemos

Belo Horizonte, Brazil

6,279. lisa rowntree

uk, United Kingdom

6,280. Lauren Coe

Framingham, MA

6,281. Elizabeth Robles

San Jose, CA

SET THEM FREE!! What is wrong with you

6,282. Lawrence Morgan Berkhamsted, United Kingdom 6,283. Roland Carbia

Canovanas, Puerto Rico

6,284. Barbara Clarke

Luxor, Egypt

6,285. Caitlin McCusker

Brooklyn, NY

6,286. Courtney Cunningham

Middletown, RI

6,287. Christina Trunzo

Clinton, CT

6,288. zoe redgrift

wootton, ulceby, United Kingdom

6,289. Rachel Porter

Manchester, United Kingdom

6,290. Katherine Lanfranco

New York, NY

6,291. jessica ratajczak

magdeburg, Germany

6,292. Fabian Günther

Hambrg, Germany

6,293. Diana Garcia

Guayaquil, Ecuador

6,294. Hannah Thornton

Leeds, United Kingdom

They deserve so much better

Their lives are worth more than that.

This cause is so incredible worth it! I hope that the slaughter of dolphins ends in our lifetime.

6,295. Ashley Henderson Strafford, NH 6,296. Lucas Neves

Santos, Brazil

6,297. Mhairi Jack

Glasgow, United Kingdom

6,298. Holly Teed

Seattle, WA

6,299. Fiona VanSise

Akron, OH

6,300. Bethany Weitz

West Seneca, NY

6,301. Nick Hernandez

Savage, MN

6,302. andrea lujan

Buenos Aires, Argentina

6,303. Helena Soh

Monterey, CA Page 253

STOP dolphin! Just live your life, and save the world.

Slavery is not right, anywhere for any creature.

-

Signatures 6,274 - 6,303

Name

From

Comments

6,304. Maria Cardoso

Hialeah, FL

6,305. Joanne Ryan

Delray Beach, FL

6,306. Karen Recabarren Santiago, Chile 6,307. Elle Osborne

St Austell, United Kingdom

6,308. Sabine Talberga

Talsi, Latvia

Set them free!

6,309. Janine Griffith

Wierda Park, South Africa

Enough is enough ! Set them free, it is the only right thing to do !

6,310. Jennifer Sears

Sacramento, CA

6,311. Ecaterina Mucomilov

cluj, Romania

6,312. Lawrence Curtis

Naples, FL

6,313. luisa cruz

monterrey, Mexico

6,314. Heather Nolta

Fredericksburg, VA

6,315. Stephanie von Deesten

Harrislee, Germany

6,316. Kim Alexandra Moser

Arni, Switzerland

6,317. Tanchira Arjinkit

London, United Kingdom

poor dolphins........

6,318. Todd Montgomery Chesterfield, VA

More examples of cruelty to animals.. this sort of thing is normally prosecuted... please do so, to encourage others against turning this discovery into a habit and from turning into common practice...

6,319. Catrin Güdter

Helmstedt, Germany

6,320. Mary S

seattle, WA

6,321. Sophie Kingsnorth London, United Kingdom 6,322. Ellen Burke

San Diego, CA

6,323. Tiffany Precissi

Stockton, CA

6,324. Bobby Allen

Annapolis, MD

6,325. amanda Perry

Punta Gorda, FL

6,326. Justin Hughes

Smithville, MO

6,327. Caterina Azzara

Palermo, Italy

6,328. Fabien Genin

La Grande Motte, France

SAVE THE DOLPHINS!

6,329. Chelsea Crawford Morrow, GA 6,330. Megan Terry

Walled Lake, MI

Page 254

DOLPHINS BELONG IN THE OCEAN, NOT AN INADEQUATE POOL.If these were humans there would be hell to pay! Well, animals have the right to live too!!!! Let them go! -

Signatures 6,304 - 6,330

Name

From

Comments

6,331. Thomas Baird

Ross Shire, United Kingdom

Stop this right now.

6,332. Tanya Hadden

Desert Hot Springs, CA

This is the 21st century and wealth is no longer measured by those beings under our control.

6,333. Caroline Fauvet

Château-Thierry, France

6,334. Diana Mora

Bogotá, Colombia

6,335. Jolyon Head

Red Lodge, United Kingdom

6,336. Kathy Watkins

Key West, FL

6,337. Natasha Birch

London, United Kingdom

6,338. Royale Ziegler

Los Angeles, CA

6,339. shantell sabbar

birmingham, United Kingdom

6,340. Elena Arrisico

Palermo, Italy

6,341. Anna Arrisico

Palermo, Italy

6,342. Latoya Jackson

orlando, FL

6,343. Lesley White

Savannah, GA

6,344. Amanda Hudson

Hawthorne, CA

6,345. T Benjamin

London, United Kingdom

6,346. amanda sudell

jupiter, FM

6,347. Lina Dimopoulos

Windsor, Canada

6,348. frederic BESSONE

X, France

6,349. Arne Goyvaerts

Antwerp, Belgium

6,350. jennifer oliver

Delray Beach, FL

6,351. William Greenhalgh

Hunt Valley, MD

Please end this cruelty

6,352. BELINDA HAYNES

Keller, TX

Please stop the importation of cetaceans into Egypt. My husband and I were considering a diving trip to Egypt. One of the reasons was the likelihood of being able to see dolphins in the WILD. But we will not patronize or support businesses in a country that allows this importation and exploitation of cetacean's to occur.

6,353. candice noname

calgary, Canada

STOP THE CRUELTY!!

6,354. Alida Bennett

Wellington, New Zealand

Please set these intelligent and special animals FREE...would you want to be held in a small space like that with others?? I think not!!!

Page 255

This is beyond cruel!

This is DISGUSTING! Poor treatment of animals in general is nothing but inhumane.

We just sank to a new low, didn't we?

-

Signatures 6,331 - 6,354

Name

From

Comments

6,355. niki ross

Ashford, United Kingdom

6,356. ashley strain

woodbridge, NJ

6,357. Ula Vovk

Naklo, Slovenia

6,358. Tom Chiodo

Celebration, FL

6,359. Barbara Mlynarczyk

Rochester, NY

6,360. KIMBERLY MARKSBERRY

santee, CA

6,361. Karen Esterhuizen

ohope, New Zealand

6,362. Kayla Humphrey

Tewksbury, MA

STOP dolphin captivity in Egypt!!!

6,363. Steven McCulloch Bellshill, United Kingdom 6,364. Hannah Brooks

Montgomery, AL

6,365. D O

Burtonsville, MD

6,366. Camilla Rosenquist

København, Denmark

6,367. Ryan Nelson

Manassas, VA

6,368. Olga Hoffman

Dublin, Ireland

6,369. Alysha Hartman

Bixby, OK

6,370. Theresa Clarke

Luxor, Egypt

6,371. Lisa Noseworthy

Fredericton, Canada

6,372. Todd Crowe

London, Canada

6,373. Renya Sabosch

Schleswig, Germany

6,374. Bregje Felder

Amsterdam, Netherlands

6,375. Amir Kitmitto

Santa Barbara, CA

6,376. Danielle Fleenor

Murrieta, CA

Save The Dolphins!!!!!!!

6,377. Amy Walls

Washington, OK

Dolphins are fun, energy filled aquatic animals. They need to be able to roam! SET THEM FREE!

6,378. Scott Ross

Ofallon, MO

Stop killing the dolphins and whales and using science as an excuse..

6,379. Joanna Acosta

bronxville, Dominican Republic Page 256

Please stop hurting the defenseless dolphins! They deserve life too

Those poor dolphins probably won't survive the quarantine period in the conditions they're in. How well monitored is the Dolphina Park, are the dolphins kept in better conditions there? Living in Egypt myself I am well aware of the Egyptian attitude towards ALL animals so I worry very much about these poor creatures.

Stop this terrible act....

-

Signatures 6,355 - 6,379

Name

From

Comments

6,380. Olivia Wellock

Bournemouth, United Kingdom

6,381. Emma Davis

Toronto, Canada

6,382. Cindy Carroll

Killeen, TX

6,383. Tiffany Love

Lakeside, CA

6,384. Jeremy King

Garden City, MO

6,385. Agata Centkowska

Gdynia, Poland

6,386. Ashley Bourgeois

Winnipeg, Canada

6,387. Charlene Reagan

Canyon Country, CA

6,388. Giselle Hidalgo

Buenos Aires, Argentina

These dolphins do not belong in a swimming pool in the heat of the sun. They are going to die if they are not release. Please help the dolphins and release them so that they can swim freely. Thank you for your time. Cindy Carroll

6,389. Stephanie Russell Kilmarnock, United Kingdom 6,390. RENAULT Laurent

LE MANS, France

6,391. Samantha Deming

Bethlehem, PA

I LOVE DOLPHINS

6,392. Amanda Kaminski Oak Park, IL 6,393. taylor gonzalez

indianapolis, IN

6,394. Amy Cheetham

Liverpool, United Kingdom

6,395. pamela geisinger

Barto, PA

6,396. pantufa marcus

setubal, Portugal

6,397. Solveig Esteva

West Haven, CT

6,398. Elizabeth Lafferty

Waterbury, CT

6,399. Joanne Bilby

Brighton, United Kingdom

6,400. Vera Lausberg

Herz., Germany

6,401. Valerie Payet

Ste Anne, Reunion

6,402. Irene Schinagl

Graz, Austria

these animals deserve to be in the wild, where they were born and meant to be. not in a pool that doesn't fit their needs at ALL.

Please, please, release these dolphins. To keep them in these conditions will most surely kill them. Free them now before it is too late

STOP THE SLAUGHTERING !!!

6,403. Juliana Norenberg Pelotas, Brazil 6,404. Joline Squires

Waterloo, Canada Page 257

-

Signatures 6,380 - 6,404

Name

From

Comments

6,405. Killi Chastain

Tomball, TX

6,406. cassandra carreiro

Brampton, Canada

6,407. Jessica Moore

Wood Ridge, NJ

6,408. Jaclyn Polizzi

Arlington, TX

6,409. Lucy D.

No Mind, Bulgaria

6,410. Kathi Thomas

Weston, FL

6,411. Meredith Bond

Phoenix, AZ

6,412. laura skelly

phila, PA

6,413. Megan Adams

Henderson, NV

6,414. Heather McCarron

London, Canada

6,415. Natasha Wicks

Las Vegas, NV

6,416. Francine Sapiencia

mirassol, Brazil

6,417. Alyssa Bradley

Benson, AZ

6,418. Ravi Madapati

Mountain View, CA

6,419. Christiane Rohde

Köln, Germany

6,420. Nadine Prechtel

Schwabach, Germany

6,421. Stacey Mohr

Stevens Point, WI

6,422. Aline Bieites

Rio de Janeiro, Brazil

6,423. Lorie Hattam

Newcastle, United Kingdom

6,424. alejandra uilar

bogota, Colombia

6,425. Sadaf Hussain

Seattle, WA

6,426. Jenna Rehberg

North vancouver, Canada

6,427. Eliza Duschkin

Livonia, MI

6,428. Carolyn Fish

Lagrangeville, NY

6,429. Molly Laufman

Charleston, SC

6,430. Amber Whatman

Pitt meadows, Canada

6,431. Angela Salewsky

Toronto, Canada

6,432. Eva Erika

New York, NY

6,433. Christina Sousa

winnipeg, Canada

6,434. Aymeric BLANC

VALBONNE, France

6,435. Asma'a F

Ypsi, MI

6,436. Donel Martinez

Plantation, FL Page 258

Stop the cruelity of dolphans now!

Put an end to this now!!!

-

Signatures 6,405 - 6,436

Name

From

Comments

6,437. Traci Mondragon

Austin, TX

6,438. Kelly Richardson

Newcastle, United Kingdom

6,439. Nicole Gagnon

North Bay, Canada

6,440. Fernanda Mello

São Paulo, Brazil

6,441. laura sanchez

downey, CA

6,442. Brittany Bates

Osmond, NE

6,443. Amber Hopkins

Grand Bend, Canada

6,444. Lisa Moore

London, United Kingdom

6,446. mary marshall

hanford, CA

6,447. gunes ilicak

mugla, Turkey

its the same thing with putting an innocent child in jail..

6,448. Amanda Formisano Paccagnella

Ribeirao Preto, Brazil

Why do people do this kind of thing? Something's seriously wrong with this world.

6,449. Joanna Ivanova

sofia, Bulgaria

6,450. emma stewart

stockport, United Kingdom

6,451. Brenda Limon

Mexico, Mexico

6,452. Kirsty Macdonald

aberdeen, United Kingdom

6,453. Michelle Wright

Brixham, United Kingdom

6,454. Leslie Holding

Cicero, IN

6,455. Vero Riva

Mexico City, Mexico

6,456. Wendy Freeman-Knight

Calgary, Canada

6,457. Josh Schmidt

Holladay, UT

6,458. kelly hatzaki

athens, Greece

6,459. Gustavo Pereira

Rio De Janeiro, Brazil Let them be free!

6,460. Maddy Tash

London, United Kingdom

6,461. Morgan Addams

Belém, Brazil

6,462. cari stuart

turlock, CA

6,463. Jennifer Espada

Lehigh Acres, FL

6,464. Danny Gutierrez

Los Angeles, CA

6,465. kayla prather

Myrtle Beach, SC

Page 259

Lets give voice to those who can not speak. Lets do something for these animals. They deserve a dignified life as everybody else =)

Please STOP doing this to the dolphins. STOP dolphin captivity

-

Signatures 6,437 - 6,465

Name

From

Comments

6,466. Marta Povoas

Guildford, United Kingdom

6,467. Evette Nixon

Middletown, OH

6,468. Jacklyn Cardenas

South Gate, CA

6,469. Laura Miller

Nashville, TN

6,470. Pamela Wilson

Santa Monica, CA

6,471. Julie Jantzen

Armstrong, Canada

6,472. Monica Hochstim

The Woodlands, TX

STOP THE DOLPHIN SLAUGHTER AND END CAPTIVITY! NOW!

6,473. Megan Mannahan Port Huron, MI 6,474. kate fairbourn

leeds, United Kingdom

6,475. Lucy Fraser

Canberra, Australia

6,476. Victoria Costa

Rio de Janeiro, Brazil

6,477. Evangelina Lopez

SS, El Salvador

6,478. carrie ciotti

yuma, AZ

6,479. Eleazar Lapuz

Placentia, CA

6,480. Amanda Meyer

Carmel, IN

I'm from El Salvador, and I want world dolphins to be FREE!

6,481. Renee Verhoeven Geelong, Australia 6,482. Samantha Tress

Brooklyn, NY

6,483. Cheryl Anderson

Regina, Canada

6,484. Tabitha Lorentz

Johannesurg, South Africa

6,485. Taylor Miller

Naples, FL

6,486. joshua smilak

orlando, FL

6,487. Gaelle DENIS

Rouen, France

6,488. Krista H.

London, Canada

6,489. Marlene Ozuna

Tulare, CA

6,490. Natividad Sosa

New York, NY

6,491. Alicia Mendoza

Kenosha, WI

6,492. miranda thurston

scottsdale, AZ

6,493. Amber Chambers

Shaw A F B, SC

6,494. Michele Lazarow

Hallandale, FL

6,495. Annie Yocum

Waynesboro, PA

6,496. ruth chavez

Albuquerque, NM

6,497. Lauren Ravenelle

Santa Rosa, CA Page 260

We need to take moral responsability as the dominant species. We cannot behave in such a barbaric manner and believe that the violence is not affecting anyone, because that assumption would be wrong. Save the dolphins!

Please free these Dolphins!! They do not deserve this!!! -

Signatures 6,466 - 6,497

Name

From

Comments

6,498. Lisa Sculnick

Sunrise, FL

Please get those dolphins to a safer location!

6,499. Carina Vonk

Calne, United Kingdom

6,500. Marc Clish

sunderland, United Kingdom

There are powerful people that could stop this cruelty... STOP BEING SPINELESS AND MAKE IT HAPPEN!!!

6,501. Laura Hamilton

Pompano beach, FL

We need to have this horrible crime stopped

6,502. Rachel OK

Limerick, Ireland

6,503. juli perry

lake ozark, MO

6,504. Dava Smith

York, SC

6,505. Ignacio Tripodi

The Colony, TX

6,506. tammy flowers

Winston-salem, NC

6,507. Jenifer Wallis

Birmingham, AL

6,508. Lucy Travell

Sussex, United Kingdom

6,509. Ashley Horwath

Saint Paul, MN

6,510. Carissa Rumble

mississauga, Canada

6,511. Jackie Cottrell

sutton weaver, United Kingdom

6,512. S Turner

Streamwood, IL

6,513. Mark White

London, United Kingdom

6,514. Ross McNae

Glasgow, United Kingdom

6,515. Jesse Pickott

Pasadena, CA

6,516. M Cox

Belconnen, Australia

6,517. Heather Lee

Port Huron, MI

6,518. Simona Kalachov

Tartu, Estonia

6,519. kathleen drozd

Lockport, IL

6,520. Jade Suey

Vancouver, Canada

6,521. Estefania Garcia Sedano

D.f, Mexico

because we're not alone in this world, we have to take care of those who can't defended themself... PRO ANIMAL!!! =)

6,522. John Foley

Riverview, FL

Wild animals should Not be caged or tanked...

6,523. Alisa Nichols

Auckland, New Zealand

6,524. Anette Nedreli

Bergen, Norway

6,525. Eva Rijsdijk

Ridderkerk, Netherlands

6,526. Victoria Myers

Hampton, VA Page 261

stop all of this inhumane treatment. it isn't necessary for your livlihood.

and close the ones in Turkey while you are at it!! especially Sealanya. So many deaths......

-

Signatures 6,498 - 6,526

Name

From

Comments

6,527. thomas yarborough

catonsville, MD

6,528. J Fedele

Smyrnq, DE

6,529. Melissa Wisch

Chardon, OH

6,530. Cate Gordon

Auburn, GA

6,531. Chante AuBuchon Kamloops, Canada 6,532. Jamie Lyn Parungao

Chicago, IL

6,533. Stuart Ralph

Renfrew, United Kingdom

6,534. Sharra Platt

Malibu, CA

6,535. Christian Proepper

Duesseldorf, Germany

6,536. Joanna Swan

Edinburgh, United Kingdom

6,537. Mike Vass

Lancashire, United Kingdom

6,538. Angela salcido

Corona, CA

6,539. Kimberley Gray

Danville, VA

6,540. Stephanie PEters

maasmechelen, Belgium

6,541. adriana dellecase

laugharne, United Kingdom

6,542. Didem Gürer

İStanbul, Turkey

6,543. Annette Tucci

Haverhill, FL

6,544. Rita van Nek

3, Germany

6,545. Thi Quach

Wall, NJ

6,546. Elena Levina

Lincoln, United Kingdom

6,547. Louise Clifford

sunderland, United Kingdom

6,548. Harriet Kirby

Manchester, United Kingdom

6,549. Lorraine Soden

barry, United Kingdom

6,550. Maddie Panebianco

Burlington, Canada

6,551. Robin Merritt

Edwardsville, IL

Page 262

Save the dolphins!!!!!!

Stop this now! We need !to respect life and let these creatures live free. How dare you hold them hostage! Help stop dolphin captivity!!

any animal should not be kept captive in such tiny enclosures, its ridiculous that people are still this idiotic in 2010.

Captivity Kills!

-

Signatures 6,527 - 6,551

Name

From

Comments

6,552. Adrian Jolley

Telford, United Kingdom

Please release my friends with the utmost of speed ....... I beg you!!

6,553. Corey Staley

Chester, VA

This is apalling and disgraceful and cruel. I have lost a tremendous amount of respect for the Red Sea Governorate.

6,554. Nicolle Vassallo

Chula Vista, CA

6,555. Gail Tingle

Denison, TX

6,556. Joanna Hardeman

London, United Kingdom

6,557. ashley wetherell

cary, NC

6,558. Karen Y

San Francisco, CA

6,559. Jessica Elsing

Baraboo, WI

6,560. Joann Salvati

Dallas, TX

6,561. Kelly Maguire

wellington, New Zealand

6,562. Pamela Newlove

St Eugene, Canada

6,563. Rosie Peach

Gibraltar, Gibraltar

6,564. Enoé Parada

Caracas, Venezuela

6,565. Suzanne Perkins

Everett, WA

6,566. lynne zonies

Ventnor, NJ

6,567. kevin van der beeuren

Antwerp, Belgium

6,568. Karen Hannigan

Westbrook, ME

6,569. Anna Taylor

Cambridge, United Kingdom

6,570. Desiree Zavaleta

Kearny, NJ

6,571. Troy Oliver

Olathe, KS

6,572. Alison Banks

Poway, CA

6,573. Annette Cancel

Orlando, FL

6,574. Resul YILMAZ

Istanbul, Turkey

6,575. djani fuchidjieva

varna, Bulgaria

6,576. deborah threlkel

san francisco, CA

6,577. David Sugier

Rivière St. Louis, Reunion

6,578. Megan Sutton

Oakville, Canada

Page 263

Please stop the captivity trade.

Stop this cruel and disgusting treatment now

Return them to their natural habitat NOW!!!

Please acknowledge this petition - that it stands for the citizens of the world that are standing up for the preservation, conservation, welfare and rights of all dolphins.

-

Signatures 6,552 - 6,578

Name

From

Comments

6,579. Bobbi Claywell

Phoenix, AZ

There is no excuse for the filth these beautiful creatures are tolerating. They will not make it if their environment is not changed, and changed soon. Please - release them to an organization that will rehabitate them into the wild...let them live the lives they were given. Let them be free.

6,580. Vicky N.

S.P.S, Honduras

Animals, just like humans are alive and even if they don't have as full comprehension as we do, they do feel and they do get hurt. And like you guys wouldn't like been in a cage, they don't like feeling trap! LET THEM GO!! THEY DESERVE TO BE FREE!!

6,581. Rebecca Rennison

Bradford, United Kingdom

6,582. luciana amado

Ica, Peru

6,583. Crystal Rumery

Bowling Green, KY

STOP DOLPHIN CAPTIVITY. These are beautiful, living creatures that deserve to be free, just as humans.

6,584. Feusi Krisztina

Budapest, Hungary

Please live them live

6,585. Shannon Hurley

Barrington, RI

6,586. Erin Burns

Madison, WI

6,587. jacky Tash

London, United Kingdom

6,588. tosha weeks

Ft.wayne, IN

6,589. Liz Mikre

Bloomfield, NJ

6,590. Yee Ping Voon

Kuala Perlis, Malaysia

6,591. Jamaka Petzak

Glendale, CA

6,592. Lilia Angelo

queen creez, AZ

6,593. lena müller hofmann

stockholm, Sweden

6,594. Lisanna Lira

Eagle Pass, TX

6,595. nicole dunbar

Thomasville, NC

6,596. Tricia Krasovetz

Danbury, CT

6,597. Jacqueline Aitken

Glasgow, United Kingdom

This senseless exploitation and suffering must be stopped. ENOUGH. Wont go to Egypt until the dolphins are free! Bad, bad badwill for Egypt!!!!! Stop Captivity of Dolphins!

6,598. Veith Puchheim, Germany Schoergenhummer 6,599. Lisa Barr

charlottesville, VA

6,600. Sejal Dalsania

Boston, MA

6,601. Hetu Amy

Montreal, Canada

6,602. Sheena Helm

Lacombe, Canada

6,603. Coral Alvarado

Menifee, CA Page 264

-

Signatures 6,579 - 6,603

Name

From

Comments

6,604. Liza Ceinos

Lacey, WA

This are unacceptable conditions for any dolphin. Please help us stop the cruelty of such kind and noble creatures. They belong free from captivity!!!!

6,605. Oralagh Hughes

Belfast, United Kingdom

Stop the cruelty that these Dolphins are suffering! lets lock the people doing it up!!

6,606. james long

lake worth, FL

6,607. Stephanie Houston

East Moline, IL

6,608. John Moeller

Nyborg, Denmark

6,609. Mindy Nemetz

jacksonville, FL

6,610. Elizabeth Somer

Toronto, Canada

6,611. SOPHIE CURE

Madrid, Spain

Tourists will not go to egypt nor to countries who let this happen. we have canceled all our offers for trips to egypt in various of our travel agencies.

6,612. rebekah hemworth

belfast, United Kingdom

This Needs To Be Stopped. These animals are smart cratures and should be in the wild..!

6,613. Kathy Stenger

seattle, WA

6,614. Nicole Miller

Oakdale, CA

6,615. Abigail Bridges

Lithia, FL

What has been done to these poor creatures is absolutely horrible! Please find it in your heart to save these beautiful animals.

6,616. catherine myles

carnoustie, United Kingdom

Simply appalling.

6,617. Bree Crow

Kenner, LA

6,618. Logan Cadwallader

Victoria, Canada

6,619. Carmelle James

Isle of Wight, United Kingdom

This cruelty has to be stopped now and forever...

6,620. Deryck Greer

Johannesburg, South Africa

Leave wild animals in the wild!

6,621. Alexandria Maillot

Maple Ridge, Canada

6,622. Charlie Childs

Godalming, United Kingdom

6,623. Ahmad Alsalem

Surra, Kuwait

6,624. jacqueline geurts

auckland, New Zealand

6,625. Whitney Strong

Elkhart, IN

6,626. Aleksandra Szol-Koniuszy

Cracow, Poland

Page 265

Lets stop this nonsense....think about yourself living in these conditions...dolphins are loving compassionate animals and they dont deserve this...lets stop this now...show you care, come on now!!!

How would you like to be taken out of your home & placed in captivity in a small room for the rest of your life?

-

Signatures 6,604 - 6,626

Name

From

Comments

6,627. poulet frederic

champigny, France

stop le massacre.

6,628. Develyn Barker

Victoria, Canada

6,629. Cynthia Rosales

Red Deer, Canada

6,630. lynsey harding

Liverpool, United Kingdom

This is soooo HORRIBLE and NEEDS TO STOP!!!! The dolphins are helpless once they are caught it's now up to us to stop this and HELP THEM!! I hope by signing this petition it helps!!

6,631. Katherine Yacelga Bronx, NY 6,632. Valerie Stein

fort lauderdale, FL

6,633. Stephen Jacura

Burnaby, Canada

6,634. lauren watson

Cleveleys, United Kingdom

6,635. Kathryn Killion

East Moline, IL

6,636. Alisha Becker

Nazareth, PA

6,637. michele quintas

Batavia, IL

6,638. Chelsi Archibald

Ogden, UT

Save the dolphins!

6,639. Chantal vanderlinden

whakatane, New Zealand

Disgusting!

6,640. edwin salvador

los angeles, CA

6,641. Anissa Meyers

West Unity, OH

6,642. Hanna Tiensuu

Stockholm, Sweden

6,643. Katrina Smale

wickford, United Kingdom

6,644. Rachel Fausak

Brooklyn, NY

6,645. konnar wilson

basildon, United Kingdom

6,646. Tegan Selby

NSW, Australia

6,647. beverly hughett

knoxville, TN

6,648. david mattinson

Coburg, Australia

6,649. Candace Eastwood

Listowel, Canada

6,651. Nicole Mack

Mögglingen, Germany

6,652. Alyssa Koske

Berlin, Germany

6,653. Mellissa Potrikhalin

everett, WA

6,654. patricia mayes

Russellville, KY Page 266

THIS IS DISCUSTING return them to the sea where they BELONG! its just wrong, you couldnt let anyone do it to yourself, why let them do it to other INTELIGANT beings

Its time we ended this kind of captivity because it shows no real environment for dolphins and supports a brutal practise in attaining these wonderful creatures. They belong in the sea!

-

Signatures 6,627 - 6,654

Name

From

Comments

6,655. Alexandria Stegall Burton, MI 6,656. Katie Attwood

Calgary, Canada

6,657. Kath Johnston

Fethiye, Turkey

6,658. wim wille

Gentbrugge, Belgium

6,659. kristin zielinski

altamont, NY

Truly shocking. Get these poor dolphins out of there! what a shame that these precious animals have to suffer a life of entrapment and abuse. Stop the capture now!

6,660. Marika Kurashima San Diego, CA 6,661. Jonas Sugarman

Coral Gables, FL

6,662. Geoff Chapman

Kapunda, Australia

6,663. Melin Staggs

Warrenton, MO

6,664. suzanne wiseman St Albans, United Kingdom 6,665. Melissa Kelbus

Lemont, IL

6,666. Werner Juelicher

Cologne, Germany

6,667. karl osharkey

santa monica, CA

6,668. Bev Zia

Alameda, CA

6,669. Eli Hernandez

Monterrey, Mexico

6,670. Nancy Manso

las Vegas, NV

6,671. C.C. Wellman

Buellton, CA

6,672. Heather Thompson

Janesville, WI

6,673. Samantha Whitcraft

Miami, FL

6,674. Pat Sullivan

Toronto, Canada

6,675. Helen Atkins

Shinfield, United Kingdom

My father had a Marine Biological Research Foundation and these dimentions for this pool and the water conditions are unacceptable! They must comply with the standards and the Dolphins must be under the care of a veterinarian who specializes in marine mammals.

I think it's absolutely disgusting the way these friendly mammals are treated, put yourself in their position and see how you like it. Leave Gods animals alone and poach for killers of people instead.

6,676. jonathan gonzalez santa barbara, CA 6,677. Linda Byway

Minster, United Kingdom

6,678. Huerta Claudia

Mexico, Mexico

6,679. gwen miller

tyrone, PA

6,680. julia cranmer

Southampton, NJ

6,681. Kelley McAdon

Folsom, CA Page 267

-

Signatures 6,655 - 6,681

Name

From

Comments

6,682. Joelle Dunn

Erie, PA

6,683. Jeff Friedman

Cleveland Hts, OH

6,684. Franziska Feist

Berlin, Germany

6,685. amy camptell

Snowflake, AZ

6,686. Dustin Marlor

Clayton, NC

6,687. Debra Castellana

Berkeley, CA

6,688. Stephanie Conacher

brantford, Canada

6,689. Linda Ojanen

Turku, Finland

6,690. Elizabeth Pruitt

Conley, GA

6,691. Lm Thompson

La Jolla, CA

6,692. uta koebrich-sullivan

Eberfing, Germany

Please leave them free back into the ocean - please.

6,693. allison saupe

el paso, TX

Please allow for the humane rescue of these highly intelligent and beautiful creatures, now. Thank-you for your saving action.

6,694. ginette casswell

Cambridge, United Kingdom

6,695. Jane Shirochenkova

Cherkassy, Ukraine

6,696. Luca Di Battista

Rome, Italy

6,697. colleen celban

Levittown, NY

6,698. KAROLINA Korybut

Szczecin, Poland

6,700. Jacky Carty

Surrey, United Kingdom

6,701. Gina Pietrafeso

Littleton, CO

6,702. Kathrin Neumann

Kruså, Denmark

6,703. Jennifer Thompson

Seaside, OR

6,704. Karin Keeling

Charlotte, NC

6,705. Jan Rider

Bethlehem, PA

6,706. rodrigo morales

los angeles, CA

6,707. Mel Alexea

Aghia Paraskevi, Greece

6,708. Laurie Goodale

Muskogee, OK Page 268

Stop captivity and free the dolphins!!!!

Lets put people in a cage, make them do tricks for our entertainment then see how we feel... Dolphins are beings, they deserve to be treated as such not kept in prison.

I had a fantastic holiday in Taba this year and was particularly impressed with how important the sea life seemed to be to you, but I'm afraid articles like this dolphin captivity make me not want to return to Egypt.

Stop this cruelty on innocent animal please.

Please leave ric take the dolphins and rehabilate them... So they can be let go back to where they belong the ocean not someones pool.. They deserve better!

-

Signatures 6,682 - 6,708

Name

From

Comments

6,709. Cheryl Cunningham

St. Augustine, FL

6,710. CLAUDIA CORYELL

Sun City, CA

6,711. Lara Young

Taunton, United Kingdom

6,712. Christine Yancer Voshel

Shelby, OH

6,713. Betina Loudermilk sun valley, CA 6,714. Danielle Capello

Novi, MI

6,715. Rose Bulaong

San Francisco, CA

6,716. P Turick

Adamsville, RI

6,717. Laura White

Moscow, ID

6,718. Andy Kho

Houston, TX

6,719. Sabrina Magrane

Feldkirch, Austria

6,720. Sarah Duong

Toronto, Canada

6,721. ANNE CULLEN

GLASGOW, United Kingdom

6,722. Moya Ruocco

Capri, Italy

Please support Richard O'Barry

6,723. Susan Ottevanger Port Hueneme, CA 6,724. Ilse Kerkes

Duisburg, Germany

Save the Dolphins

6,725. Jeri Miller

Aventura, FL

Please stop holding dolphins in captivity. They are the most majestic and intelligent creatures on the planet and belong in the ocean.

6,726. Daragh Redmond

Dublin, Ireland

6,727. Melissa D'Amore

Harker Heights, TX

They are meant to be free! Too many animals have died in captivity. It's unbelievably wrong.

6,728. Theresa Drake

Mesa, AZ

Stop this NOW!!

6,729. Marianne Stoveland

Oslo, Norway

Animals are not here to entertain our own species. Release these precious dolphins and don't hold them captive!

6,730. Robin Winters

Saint Cloud, FL

You need to let them go. If they die, that will forever be their death on your hands.

6,731. Clementine mccutchen

Bordeaux, France

dolphins in captivity.... what a crime. I would never pay to see these sad animals in trapped in a tank.

6,732. Sarah Barry

Marske, United Kingdom

If they say it is illegal then this certainly is a sloppy state of affairs on the givernments part. This is totally unacceptable to keep intelligent sentient beings in this manner and is absolutely animal cruelty.

6,733. Debbie Sayer

Mugla, Turkey

The only word to describe this is SİCK SİCK SİCK

6,734. Joshua Stevens

Elizabeth, NJ Page 269

-

Signatures 6,709 - 6,734

Name

From

Comments

6,735. Bibiana Oliveira

porto alegre, Brazil

6,736. Tiziano Bachis

Nijlen, Belgium

6,737. Kristan Torres

Houston, TX

6,738. Paul Vest

Anchorage, AK

6,739. Kerry Tucker

Simi Valley, CA

6,740. Ginny McIntosh

Laguna Hills, CA

6,741. anita owens

menomonee falls, WI

6,742. Julia Hobbs

Waterford, Ireland

6,743. Courtney Murr

Hoover, AL

6,744. Julie Gray

Portsmouth, United Kingdom

6,745. Alexander Stern

Trencin, Slovakia

6,746. Lauri Griffiths

Greenwood Lake, NY

6,747. deborah bachler

Littleton, CO

6,748. Lori Anderson

canmore, Canada

6,749. amelia magby

bauxite, AR

6,750. Melissa Bacon

Snow Hill, MD

6,751. Michael Lemus

Whittier, CA

save the creators of sonor!

6,752. Damion Santoro

Buena Park, CA

Animals can feel pain.

let nature live

these conditions are making the dolphins sick! would you put yur kids goldfish in a dixie cup? no...probably the toilet first!!!!! wake up folks...

They are wild creatures and they should live freely!

6,753. Tina Konstantinou Brampton, Canada 6,754. Holly Hanna

Middleburg, FL

6,755. Jessica Pullin

Ruston, LA

6,756. Lori Gold

Huntington, NY

6,757. Alexandro Ledee

Deltona, FL

Save the dolphins!!!

6,758. Marisa Ohanian

La Habra, CA

Enough is enough! Leave these beautiful creatures where they belong! IN THE WILD!!!

6,759. Victoria Lepore

Yonkers, NY

6,760. Michelle Pimental

Plymouth, MA

6,761. Glenn Sergent

Culloden, WV

6,762. Heather Stone

Victoria, Canada

Any animal in captivity is wrong, but animals that are sentient to the extent that dolphins are might be the worst possible victims of selfish humans. Think outside the box and your own personal bubble. Compassion is human, economics is not.

6,763. Marla Torres

Houston, TX

Dophins have been nothing but friends to humans. They should NOT be kept captive. Just as humans should NO either.

6,764. Jenny Hensley

Maineville, OH Page 270

-

Signatures 6,735 - 6,764

Name

From

Comments

6,765. Estel Moore Forn

arenys de munt, Spain

6,766. Judith Montgomery

London, United Kingdom

6,767. gülhan özdemir

Adana, Turkey

6,768. Paulina Santis

Santiago, Chile

6,769. bethany jacobs

trussville, AL

6,770. Jenny Rowley

Norwich, United Kingdom

6,771. Christopher Mankarious

Cairo, Egypt

6,772. Judith Basora

Terrassa (Barcelona), Spain

6,773. Corin Bishop

Ventura, CA

6,774. Luwidka Amador

Miami, FL

6,775. austin templer

san antonio, TX

6,776. James Watts

Newcastle-Upon_Tyne, United Kingdom

6,777. Zoë Wightman

Sydney, Australia

6,778. Tamara Abashian

Durham, NC

6,779. Lydia Lacey

Rochford, United Kingdom

6,780. don cramer

Surprise, AZ

6,781. Sarah Gilmour

Sydney, Australia

6,782. Rodrigo Echeverria

Barcelona, Spain

6,783. kirsty jones

cheshire, United Kingdom

6,785. wes stone

Austin, TX

HE YOUU!! STOP TO KEEP DOLPHINS!! AND STOP TO BE A MONSTER!! DOLPHINS ARE ALIVE LIKE YOU!! THEN THEY NEED THIR FREEDOM TO SURVIVE!! I WISH YOU GOT WHAT YOU DO FOR ALL ANIMALS!! SO IF YOU'RE GOOD TO THEM, HOPE YOU GET ALL THE GOODS, IF NOT I HOPE OULL GET THE WORST IN YOUR LIFE!!!

There is only one place that dolphins should be , swimming free in the wild ...

free the dolphins

Please make the decision to protect the wellbeing of these beautiful, sensitive creatures. They are not to be kept as pets.....they must be free!!

6,786. Tracy Von Richter Brampton, Canada 6,787. L Bentley

London, United Kingdom

6,788. Ciara Bamsch

Jarrell, TX

6,789. Kelli Rutherford

San Diego, CA Page 271

-

Signatures 6,765 - 6,789

Name

From

Comments

6,790. Gina Lucero

San Diego, CA

6,791. Brandi S

sadg, AL

6,792. Brandon Mundell

Austin, TX

6,793. Mallory MacTaggart

Honolulu, HI

I think anyone who treats animals this way needs to be kept in a cage themselves... See how long they last.

6,794. Camil Danielewicz Stockholm, Sweden 6,795. Kimberly Horsley

Martinez, CA

6,796. Caitlin Palmer

Chandler, AZ

6,797. Caren Bainbridge

Penrith, United Kingdom

6,798. Karren Leon

Glendale, MS

Stop Animal Abuse!

6,799. Bahir Hakeem

Tucson, AZ

Please don't do this!!

6,800. Rachel Narasimhan

Birmingham, MI

6,801. Jessyca Horsst

kingston, PA

6,802. Julia Kwong

Huntington Beach, CA

6,803. O. Alvarado

Dallas, TX

6,804. Hester Bartels

Malden, Netherlands

6,805. Kristy Gertz

Mesa, AZ

6,806. Alice Wallner

Ajax, Canada

6,807. Justin fox

needles, CA

6,808. Kristine Lewis

Carbondale, PA

6,809. shelley arsenault

burnaby, Canada

6,810. mark swales

billingham, United Kingdom

6,811. Nikki Gallant

surrey, Canada

6,812. Chad Thomson

Red Deer, Canada

6,813. Treshan O'shaughnessy

Spring hill, FL

6,814. Veronica Maldonado

New York, NY

6,815. Alyssa Sinclair

Herstmonceux, Hailsham, United Kingdom

6,816. alex brooks

Hull, United Kingdom

6,817. Valerie Jones

Houston, TX Page 272

The world is watching, Egypt will sertainly not make itself popular with this tragic dolphin captivity. It is not of this time, it will suit Egypt to ban captivity of these animals.

we need to save our whales

This must stop please,it is cruel and unecessary.

Stop this!

This is simply appalling.

-

Signatures 6,790 - 6,817

Name

From

Comments

6,818. David Hogan

Newport, United Kingdom

6,819. Gabriela Enciso

Rowland Heights, CA

6,820. Vijaya Ramcharitar

Piarco, Trinidad And Tobago

6,821. Lauren Martinson

Long beach, CA

6,822. Sarah McNabb

Melbourne, Australia

6,823. Stephanie Kandris Vaughn, WA 6,824. Jackie Luna

los angeles, CA

6,825. carla baltazar

Sabugal, Portugal

6,826. Mariana Magalhães

5, Brazil

6,827. Jennifer Ganstine

Englewood, CO

6,828. Peter Adler

Zurich, Switzerland

6,829. Danielle Buckles

Manassas, VA

6,830. Olga Krywyj

winnipeg, Canada

These "children of the sea" do not belong in captivity in a chlorinated pool in the middle of a desert! Release them immediately.

6,831. karyn labovitz

Coffs Harbour, Australia

Please stop this cruel treatment of these beautiful animals now. I will be boycotting Egypt, and otherwise desirable place to visit and encouraging my fellow travelers to do the same.

6,832. Alejandro Riva Palacio

Chihuahua, Mexico

6,833. Beatriz de la garza

Saltillo, Mexico

6,834. Tina Elleman

Leland, NC

6,835. Kennedy Hauder

Sparks, NV

6,836. Jessica Miller

Meadville, PA

6,837. karin yates

Snow Camp, NC

6,838. Heather Romano

Fullerton, CA

6,839. carolyn videc

newmarket, TN

6,840. Krystilyn Atkinson

Eden, VT

6,841. Géssica Dapik

Salvador - BA, Brazil

6,842. FALLON MORALES

TORRANCE, CA

6,843. Ken Roell

West Chester, OH

Page 273

STOP dolphin captivity in Egypt! You hunt,the world cries.

What you do to animals, you do to your fellows. Stop treating them like material goods. Animals are beings with a conciousness we might not understand yet.

This is your idea of quarantine, Egypt? What is wrong with you? -

Signatures 6,818 - 6,843

Name

From

Comments

6,844. Jem Ramsay-Dunn

Andover, United Kingdom

F*CKING DISGUSTING!

6,845. C Darden

Marietta, GA

6,846. nisa az

Batu Caves, Malaysia

6,847. Colleen Goodreau Windsor, Canada 6,848. Louisa Aubé

Trois-Pistoles, Canada

6,850. Erika Forde

Medfield, MA

6,851. alejandro ruiz marin

Playa Del Carmen, Mexico

6,852. Lulu Pembers

London, United Kingdom

let them be free!

I want them to be free it's like throwing a cat in a bin peace xx

6,853. Joanne Akiskalian Encinitas, CA 6,854. C Black

Costa Mesa, CA

Dolphins do NOT belong in Egypt. They belong in the ocean. This is cruel and serves no GOOD purpose. This greedy self indulgent act of capturing exotic marine mammals for ones amusement has to stop. Please.

6,855. Caterina Ienco

Mississauga, Canada

6,856. Betheny Zeledon

Red Deer, Canada

6,857. Emma Reeve

cambridge, United Kingdom

6,858. David Blanchard

Kent, WA

6,859. Samantha morris

Randwick, Australia

6,860. Charles Church

Fort Worth, TX

6,861. Joann Proveto

Goldens Bridge, NY

6,862. David Hollier

Crestline, CA

This is important. please stop this!!!

6,863. Amanda Galbraith Sioux Falls, SD 6,864. Maria Furtado

Ponta Delgada, Portugal

6,865. Rose Carreiro

providence, RI

6,866. Zackran Griffith

clinton, MS

6,867. Naz Barragan

La Crescenta, CA

6,868. Brian Hickey

North Battleford, Canada

6,869. Antoinette McGroty

College Station, TX

6,870. ohad aviv

Tel Aviv, Israel

6,871. melanie fitzgerald

torrington, CT Page 274

Disgusting! you hold them in captivity against their will at least give them adequate humane space to live! this is torture! Disgraceful Please let them be free!

Don't be cruel to these intelligent animals. They are apart of life, they are daughters, sons, fathers, and mothers too.

-

Signatures 6,844 - 6,871

Name

From

Comments

6,872. Kathryn Gorton

tiverton, RI

Please, search your heart. Dolphins are wild and they belong in the wild.

6,873. Thomas Bedard

Greenfield park, Canada

6,874. Brittany Justice

Ashland, KY

6,875. Megan Nold

alhambra, CA

6,876. Michael Maharry

Fairfield, CA

6,877. kimberly cannon

lancaster, TX

6,878. Lisa Cunningham

Saint Augustine, FL

6,879. Monica Kuhn

Aliso Viejo, CO

6,880. Ariel Castro

Phoenix, AZ

6,881. amber graves

Tomball, TX

6,882. Gina Milinovich

Clearwater, FL

6,883. S R

Block, MD

Make it stop!!

6,884. Beatriz Nunes

São Paulo, Brazil

THIS IS TOTALLY CRAZY.

6,885. Joseph Goodman

Gainesville, FL

6,886. David Campbell

Liverpool, United Kingdom

6,887. Sara Dantas

Rio de Janeiro, Brazil

6,888. carissa Cimochowski

Holden, MA

6,889. melissa ginette

Port Orange, FL

6,890. Valentina Mazloumian

Cairo, Egypt

6,891. Hatice Kondoz

Cherry Hill, NJ

6,892. Ruby Eaches

Newport, RI

6,893. Madeleine M

luskville, Canada

6,894. Vinessa Lanfranco

Farmingdale, NY

This has to end!! These dolphins are not ours to keep, they belong in the wild not in captivity!!! LET THEM GO!!!

6,895. Lillian Reitz

Springfield, NJ

Please release these dolphins and allow them to swim free in the ocean as nature intended. Thank you.

6,896. Kelly Whalley

Leitrim, Ireland

STOP dolphin captivity in Egypt, AND all over the world!!!!

6,897. ghada daoud

pearl river, NY

6,898. MALLORIE MARSHALL

miramar, FL

6,899. Steven Schermer

Peoria, IL

6,900. Genevieve DeMars

Woodland Hills, CA

Page 275

We gotta put a end to this guys ..pass it on the more people that know the more people can help

Animals are not here for your amusement quit being so primitive

END IT NOW

STOP ILLEGAL and CRUEL treatment, sale and containment of dolphins in Egypt and around the world. It is SICK! -

Signatures 6,872 - 6,900

Name

From

Comments

6,901. Andrea Swindle

Fresno, CA

6,902. Lonnie Rejda

Denver, CO

6,903. sarah Lash

tucson, AZ

6,904. clarissa passarinho

new york, NY

6,905. Bridget Paling

Marlboro, NJ

6,906. Sonya S

Porter Ranch, CA

The dolphins are meant to be free. ENOUGH with animal cruelty already!!!!!!

6,907. Bonnie Carpenter

Ballston Spa, NY

They need to leave the dolphins in the ocean. Sure they are beautiful, but are not mean't for captivity!!!

6,908. Diana Grozdeva

Sofia, Bulgaria

6,909. parker Rabon

Raleigh, NC

6,910. Christine salcido

corona, CA

6,911. GERI CLOUSTON

Plymouth, WI

6,912. katherine desmond

brighton, MA

6,913. Rachelle Dunbar

Markham, Canada

6,914. Samantha De Loza

Miami, FL

Dolphins are meant to be free!!! Keeping them capitve is cruel and unfair. Please allow these animals to enjoy the ocean as they are meant to freely. Stop animal cruelty!!!!!!!

6,915. Christal Summer VanEtten

Bellingham, WA

4m deep? You've got to be kidding me. This is horrible and needs to end now.

6,916. bernice ponca

pierre, SD

i love dolphins, i am very aware of the captivity of these glorious animals. its sad to me.

6,917. Thanh Tran

Hoboken, NJ

6,918. Fredy Cantoran

lancaster, CA

6,919. kendra garvin

Charleston, SC

6,920. Julia Machado

Chicago, IL

6,921. Angela Berenger

Canberra, Australia

This needs to stop today~ Enough is enough~ Dolphins are free and should be treated as such!

6,922. Ralph Cruz

Whittier, CA

Please stop :)

6,923. NATAJSHA ANGULO

SEVILLA, Spain

6,924. rachael sadler

nottingham, United Kingdom

6,925. Mariah Jarvis

Wilmington, NC

6,926. Danielle Dunican

ROI, Ireland

This is an outrage. Dolphins belong in the freedom of the ocean! This is completely against their nature..

6,927. Andrew Mara

sydney, Australia

Disgusting!

Page 276

SAVE THE DOLPHINS!

Suggest Documents