Towards BIM Guide 2.0 The current status of BIM Guides Development in South Korea 2014. 10. 27. bSI + ISO meetings in Toronto, Canada

Ghang Lee, Ph.D. Associate Professor, Architectural Engineering Yonsei University [email protected]

Hierarchical Structure of National BIM Guides Project based Guide

Architectural Works

… Works

Civil Works Applying

Project-specific BIM Guides Common BIM Guide

Public Organizations

Arch. BIM Guide

Public Organization 1

MEP BIM Guide

Public Organization 2

BIM Modeling Guide

Public Organization 3

PPS, GSA, S.P. St.

Organization-specific BIM Guides Common BIM Guide

BIM Guide

Struc. BIM Guide

Arch. BIM Guide

Struc. BIM Guide

Owners/Clients

BIM Modeling Guide

Governments

Domain-specific Architectural BIM Guide

National level 00 Civil BIM Guide BIM Guide BIM Guides

International Standard

Generic BIM Guide

National Built Environment BIM Guide

International/national level International Standards (ISO) BIM Guide Framework BIM Framework (domain-independent)

National Standards

Standards

Reference Standards

Applying Core Tech. Building permission System

Administration System

Fire/Disaster System

Civil System

Ubiquitous System

3 D GIS

Modified from (Inhan Kim, 2011)

2

National BIM Guides in South Korea Type National

domain-specific

Organization MLTM

(Ministry of Land, Transport and Maritime Affairs)

PPS

(Public Procurement Service)

Guides - 2010: National BIM Roadmap National Architectural BIM Guide - 2010-2012: PPS BIM roadmap PPS BIM Guide ver. 1.0-1.2 - 2014: PPS BIM Guide ver. 2.0 (Under development) - 2010: National BIM Guide for Overall Built

KICT Public Environment organization (Korea Institute of Construction Technology) - 2012: BIM Guide for Modeling FM Information ver. 1.0 LH

(Land and Housing)

MND

(Ministry of National Defenses)

KICTEP

R&D

Project

- 2012: BIM Design Guide - 2014: MND BIM Guideline ver. 1.0 (Under development)

(Korea Institute of Construction and Transportation Technology Evaluation and Planning)

- 2009-2015 (Super Tall Building Project) Open BIM standard and application for super tall buildings

KICTEP

- 2006-2011: Virtual Construction Project: BIM Guide

KPX

(Korea Power eXchange)

- 2010: Design Competition Guideline for New Head office Building

Digital Broadcasting Contents Center

- 2010: First PPS Open BIM based Turnkey (Design Build) project

KEPCO

- 2011: BIM Design Competition Guideline

(Korea Electric Power Corporation) …

3 …

National

National Architectural BIM Guide (MLTM, 2010)

domain-specific

Public organizationbased

 General guidelines for "How to adopt BIM" by public organizations

Project-based

 Serves as a foundation for other BIM guides  Composed of BIM process guide, technical guide,

Table of Contents

and management guide

1.1 Purpose of the guide

 Distributed to 26 government bodies and

1.2 How to use the guide

1.3 Contents of the guide

organizations

1. Overview

 Developed by MLTM with buildingSMART Korea

1.5 Order of priorities 1.6 Terminology 1.7 Acronym

and Kyunghee Univ.

1.8 Revision of the guide 2. BIM Process Guide

Process Guide

BIM Guide

1.4 Reference standards

2.1 BIM use planning 2.2 BIM process planning 2.3 BIM execution planning 2.4 BIM execution 3.1 BIM data format

3. BIM Technical Guide

Process Guide

3.2 BIM software 3.3 BIM data file

3.4 BIM information classification 3.5 BIM contents

4.1 BIM project management 4. BIM 4.2 BIM quality assurance Management 4.3 BIM deliverables Guide 4.4 Responsibility and right

Management Guide

4.5 BIM service fee structure

4

Public Procurement Service (PPS) BIM Guides

National domain-specific

Public

organization Guidelines for public facility projects based  Version 1.0 was developed by PPS with buildingSMART Korea, Kyunghee Univ., and Project-based

Heerim Architecture.  Release dates:  Version 1.0: 2010. 10. 21. – basic modeling guidelines  Version 1.1: 2012. 4. 19. – guidelines for design-compliance checking

 Version 1.2: 2013. 3. 14. – enhanced modeling guidelines, property information guidelines, standard BIM report format, BIM-based construction estimation, etc.  Version 2.0: Under development

5

Public Procurement Service (PPS) BIM Adoption Roadmap

National domain-specific

Public organizationbased

Matured application of BIM to the “total service” turn-key ( joint-venture) projects over US$ 50M

Project-based

2016 2013~2015 Application of BIM to at least 3 or 4 projects with a broad perspective

2012 2011

2010

Application of BIM to all “total service*” turn-key ( joint-venture) projects over US$ 50M

BIM adoption to all “total service” public facility projects

*total service project: a project whose entire procurement and construction process is planned and managed by PPS (a.k.a. customizable procurement system)

Application of BIM to at least 2 large design & construction projects

PPS BIM Adoption Roadmap (2010) 6

The number of PPS BIM project (2010-2013)

# of PPS BIM projects (A total of 18 projects) 9 8

8 7 6 5

5

4

4 3 2 1

1

0 2010

2011

2012

7

2013

What are new in PPS BIM Guide ver. 2.0? PPS BIM Guide ver. 1.2

PPS BIM Guide ver. 2.0  Reflection of the current BIM status in South Korea

Table of Contents 1. General Information 1.1 목적 및 원칙 1.2 지침의 구성 1.3 관련 기준 및 규격 1.4 용어의 정의 1.5 약어정의 1.6 지침의 개정 2. PPS BIM Management 2.1 BIM 적용 대상 2.2 수행조직 및 역할 2.3 발주전 단계의 관리 2.4 공고단계의 관리 2.5 사업수행의 BIM 관리 3. Schematic Design Submission 3.1 개요 3.2 BIM 데이터 작성 기준 3.3 BIM 활용 기준 : 디자인 검토 및 계획 품질 확보 3.4 BIM 활용 기준 : BIM 설계도서 산출 3.5 BIM 활용 기준 : 개략 에너지효율 검토 3.6 BIM 보고서 작성기준 3.7 BIM 성과품 제출기준 3.8 책임과 권리 4. Design Development Submission 4.1 개요 4.2 BIM 데이터 작성 기준

 Improved guidelines for maximizing the reuse of design BIM models/data throughout the construction phase  Additional guidelines for the construction phase • Key: Reasonable work scopes of architects and contractors

 Consistency with the national BIM policy and standards • Application of standards, guidelines and library contents being developed by the national open BIM R&D project (2013-2015)

……..

8

BIM Guide for the “Korea Power eXchange” Project  One of the first design competition guides for a BIM-based project  Released in March, 2010

National domain-specific

Public organizationbased Project-based

Design Competition Guide Contents 1. Aim 2. Summary 3. Model and drawing submission guide 4. Evaluation and winner selection procedure

5. Copyright issues 6. Post-selection procedure 7. General design guide 8. Detailed design guide 9. Others 10. Appendix and Templates

9

BIM guide for the “Digital Broadcasting Contents Center” Project  Open BIM-based project  Project period: 2010-2014 (including construction)

National domain-specific

 BIM scope: design-compliance checking, energy analysis, 4D simulation, basic and advanced geometry modeling, quantity take-off, facility

Public organizationbased Project-based

management 4D simulation

Integration

Digital Project MS Excel

Basic Modeling

Advanced Modeling

Revit

Digital Project

IFC 2X3 Energy Anal`ysis

Spatial / Q.C

Riuska

Solibri Model Checker

10

BIM guide for the “KEPCO headquarters office building” Project  Project period: 2011-2014 (including construction)  The BIM scope has been reduced to design review, quality assurance of construction documents, basic quantity take-off, construction document generation, energy efficiency analysis, etc.

11

National domain-specific

Public organizationbased Project-based

Modularization of the Korea BIM Standard (KBIMS) Framework Korea BIM Standard (KBIMS) Framework module 2. Process

2.1

New BIM Guide 2. Process

2.2

… 3. Guides

3. Guides

3.1 3.2 … 4. Classification

4. Classification

4.1 4.2 …

12

Korea BIM Standard (KBIMS) Framework  Proposed and being developed by buildingSMART Korea (2013-2015)  An R&D project funded by Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport (MOLIT)  Composed of 9 groups and 43 modules  Based on ISO 12006-2 and Open BIM standards  Supports legacy BIM guides

13

9 Groups and 43 Modules of KBIMS Framework

1. BIM General

2. Process

3. Guides

4. Classification

11. Terms 12. Interpretation for Terms 13. Abbreviations 14. BIM Functionalties 15. BIM Information Level 16. Maturity Model 21. Standard Process 22. Use Scenarios 23. Guide for Quality Assurance 31. Guide for BIM Libraries 32. Guide for Modeling 33. Guide for 2D Drawings 34. Guide for Documents 411. Facilities by Form 412. Facilities by Function 421. Spaces by Function 43. Elements 44. Work Results 45. Resources 46. Phases 471. Disciplines 472. Roles 481. Information 482. Standard Details

5. Information Specification

6. BIM Elements

Open BIM Standards

8. Softwares and Contents

9. BIM Management

14

51. Project Information 52. Electronic Catalogue 53. Analysis Input Data 54. Analysis Output Data 61. BIM Objects 62. BIM Properties 63. Dictionary for Properties 71. Information Delivery Manual 72. Model View Definition 73. Industry Foundation Classes 74. International Framework for Dictionaries 75. IFC for GIS 79. Other International BIM Standards 81. Functional Spec for Software 82. Spec for Contents 91. Organization 92. Management Process 93. Copyrights and Obligations 94. Return of Investment and Fees

Q&A

15