E M E A H OT E L S M O N I TO R AU G U S T 2 0 1 0 ISSUE 6
EMEA HOTELS MONITOR AUGUST 2010 Introduction In Issue 5, we speculated that the volume of distressed sales in 2009 could have been the beginning of something big, but this initial ripple has not resulted in a tsunami of transactions. If anything the system has become even more blocked as banks adopt the “rolling loan gathers no loss” approach. Hotel markets across the region are continuing to perform well and construction costs are falling in most countries. In this issue we also present the first in a series of tabulations - average room sizes by category as stipulated by the big brands.
Cushman & Wakefield Hospitality employs a team of dedicated professionals globally, covering all disciplines. From the world’s largest wholly-owned offices platform, the team can serve you and your business wherever you are based and wherever you want to go.
EC Harris is a leading international Built Asset Consultancy generating positive outcomes for its clients from their investment and expenditure in built assets. EC Harris has an international team of Hotel experts who act as trusted advisors to its clients in planning and executing strategies that optimise the construction, operation, use and ownership of built assets.
STR Global provides clients with access to hotel research with regular and custom reports covering over 40,000 hotels globally. They provide a single source of global hotel performance data, offering concise, accurate and thorough industry research worldwide and they track a variety of Profitability, Pipeline and Census data covering all aspects of the industry.
1
Performance Trends 2010 City
Amsterdam
2009
ADR
Occ
RevPAR
ADR
Occ
RevPAR
Growth
€
%
€
€
%
€
ADR Abs (€)
Occ
RevPAR
%
Abs %
%
Abs (€)
%
123.34
70.6
87.11
123.32
65.9
81.23
0.01
0.0
4.8
7.2
5.88
7.2
Berlin
88.30
65.4
57.75
81.79
62.9
51.43
6.51
8.0
2.5
4.0
6.32
12.3
Budapest
62.60
52.6
32.92
70.53
48.2
34.02
-7.92
-11.2
4.3
9.0
-1.10
-3.2
Cairo Cape Town Copenhagen
98.39
65.4
64.32
93.97
65.4
61.47
4.42
4.7
0.0
0.0
2.85
4.6
125.44
57.6
72.23
86.63
60.2
52.12
38.81
44.8
-2.6
-4.3
20.11
38.6
95.77
57.8
55.35
112.06
56.1
62.88
-16.30
-14.5
1.7
3.0
-7.53
-12.0
Dubai
172.20
73.1
125.91
188.63
69.0
130.07
-16.43
-8.7
4.1
5.9
-4.16
-3.2
Dublin
79.01
62.5
49.36
87.37
59.5
52.01
-8.36
-9.6
2.9
4.9
-2.65
-5.1
Edinburgh
86.21
72.7
62.67
83.37
71.3
59.45
2.83
3.4
1.4
2.0
3.23
5.4
Helsinki
96.32
63.0
60.65
104.77
57.6
60.31
-8.46
-8.1
5.4
9.4
0.34
0.6
London
139.12
79.2
110.15
126.61
77.1
97.63
12.51
9.9
2.1
2.7
12.53
12.8
Madrid
92.67
64.8
60.02
95.30
57.1
54.42
-2.63
-2.8
7.7
13.4
5.60
10.3
Milan
136.62
61.3
83.72
146.98
57.2
84.05
-10.36
-7.0
4.1
7.2
-0.33
-0.4
Moscow
147.28
59.2
87.14
154.05
53.2
82.01
-6.77
-4.4
5.9
11.1
5.13
6.3 -17.2
Muscat
176.82
57.8
102.20
214.65
57.5
123.41
-37.83
-17.6
0.3
0.5
-21.21
Oslo
122.19
59.0
72.13
110.42
60.7
67.05
11.77
10.7
-1.7
-2.8
5.08
7.6
Paris
171.57
74.5
127.77
165.51
71.9
118.98
6.06
3.7
2.6
3.6
8.79
7.4
Prague
73.94
55.4
40.99
83.33
51.1
42.58
-9.39
-11.3
4.3
8.5
-1.59
-3.7
Riyadh
199.29
66.6
132.73
194.11
66.6
129.25
5.18
2.7
0.0
0.0
3.48
2.7
Rome
138.54
64.5
89.40
144.27
57.6
83.09
-5.72
-4.0
6.9
12.0
6.31
7.6
Stockholm
112.76
64.3
72.46
100.70
62.7
63.12
12.06
12.0
1.6
2.5
9.34
14.8
Vienna
90.98
67.3
61.27
94.15
59.2
55.76
-3.17
-3.4
8.1
13.7
5.51
9.9
Zurich
148.31
70.4
104.34
145.09
64.4
93.48
3.22
2.2
5.9
9.2
10.86
11.6
Source: STR Global
After a turbulent 2009, the first half of 2010 saw a recovery for most hotel markets. Occupancy levels improved on weak performances last year, whilst ADR remained under pressure. Middle Eastern markets lagged behind their European and African counterparts as the region went later into the downturn in early 2009.
2
Cape Town was the star performer in ADR terms. The FIFA World Cup, which took place 11 June to 11 July 2010, boosted the YTD rates. In June 2010, Cape Town’s ADR grew 117% compared to June 2009 and 18% YTD in local currency. Interestingly, occupancy levels for the month of June remained subdued at 58%, just 7.9 percentage points higher than last year.
Oslo’s room supply increased (+9%) in the first half of this year, which slowed down the occupancy recovery. ADR in local currency just finished the YTD on a virtual par with the first six months of 2009 (-0.7%) London achieved the highest YTD occupancy of the markets reviewed here. The combination of strong demand (being influenced by the favourable Euro/USD to Pound exchange rates) and its continued appeal as a leisure and business destination enabled hoteliers to start rebuilding their ADR (YTD +6.4% in local currency). 3
Hotel Construction Costs Budget hotels € per sqm
€ per sqm
€ per sqm
€ per sqm
UK
1,350 - 1,750
1,700 - 2,210
2,180 - 2,730
2,710 - 3,460
Austria
1,120 - 1,520
1,540 - 1,880
1,790 - 2,800
1,950 - 3,380
Belgium
1,040 - 1,660
1,960 - 2,530
1,810 - 2,730
2,280 - 3,350
Bulgaria
500 - 970
820 - 1,260
970 - 1,500
1,030 - 1,680
Croatia
1,010 - 1,520
1,160 - 1,920
1,320 - 2,100
1,630 - 2,630
890 - 1,260
1,070 - 1,440
1,340 - 1,860
1,780 - 2,270
Denmark
1,410 - 1,890
1,560 - 2,230
2,280 - 3,080
2,390 - 4,140
France
1,490 - 2,110
2,210 - 2,720
2,030 - 2,740
2,720 - 3,800
Germany
1,690 - 2,620
2,230 - 3,470
2,040 - 3,140
2,490 - 3,790
900 - 1,240
1,330 - 1,810
1,360 - 2,000
1,880 - 2,500
600 - 800
960 - 1,210
1,310 - 2,220
1,580 - 2,650
Ireland
1,750 - 2,110
2,530 - 3,030
2,700 - 3,220
3,190 - 3,600
Italy
1,170 - 1,800
1,290 - 2,050
1,990 - 3,010
2,100 - 3,090
960 - 1,210
1,140 - 1,580
1,350 - 1,880
1,550 - 2,300
Netherlands
1,380 - 1,750
1,500 - 1,790
1,640 - 2,070
1,950 - 2,340
Poland
1,030 - 1,810
1,510 - 2,510
1,750 - 2,920
2,190 - 3,950
Portugal
990 - 1,350
1,310 - 1,640
1,510 - 1,810
1,780 - 2,340
Romania
1,010 - 1,320
1,140 - 1,350
1,330 - 1,540
1,570 - 1,740
Russia
1,130 - 1,380
1,730 - 2,080
1,900 - 2,370
2,180 - 3,190
Serbia
850 - 1,210
1,160 - 1,730
1,260 - 1,990
1,630 - 2,280
Slovakia
680 - 1,040
930 - 1,430
1,010 - 1,540
1,190 - 1,720
Spain
1,300 - 1,720
2,300 - 2,760
1,970 - 2,400
2,280 - 3,330
Sweden
1,660 - 2,110
2,090 - 2,740
2,440 - 2,860
2,840 - 3,940
Turkey
1,100 - 1,600
1,200 - 1,880
1,200 - 1,970
1,460 - 2,620 2,310 - 3,520
Czech Republic
Greece Hungary
Latvia
Abu Dhabi
- -
Mid market - low
Mid market - high
1,580 - 2,060
1,780 - 2,620
Egypt
1,880 - 2,170
2,200 - 2,590
2,350 - 2,810
Ghana
1,110 - 1,800
1,520 - 2,380
1,690 - 2,420
Luxury
2,570 - 3,090 - -
Oman
- -
1,560 - 2,020
1,760 - 2,580
2,270 - 3,470
Qatar
- -
1,600 - 2,080
1,810 - 2,640
2,340 - 3,570
Saudi Arabia
- -
1,520 - 1,980
1,700 - 2,500
2,220 - 3,360
Costs may include dry leisure facilities but not swimming pools. Note that figures now include cost estimates for FF&E. Costs include contractor’s preliminaries and overheads and profits, but no allowance for land costs, land procurement fees, or consultants’ fees. Costs are based on a conversion ratio of £1 = €1.11.
Country
Source: EC Harris
The figures above have been calculated from a survey which EC Harris has carried out of construction costs in 50 different countries. Costs are now given per sqm of gross internal floor area (thus multiplying the above by the gross area per key tabulated on the last page of this issue should provide you with a guide cost per key) and include FF&E. 4
Construction costs in many parts of the world have continued to fall over the past year as the global
downturn continues to affect construction workload, reducing contractors’ profits and bringing down tender prices. Western Europe as a whole remains the most expensive region. The fall in tender prices in the UK, down by almost 10% since this time last year, means that the UK only comes in 8th in the European league. 5
Transaction Tracker Region
Hotel
Portfolio Transactions 3x Accor hotels 3x various hotels 5x Premier Inns
Location
No. of Keys
Total Price (€)
Price per Key (€)
Europe UK UK
553 274 400
57,000,000 15,700,000 40,200,000
103,000 57,000 100,000
Single Asset Transactions CEE
Mercure Zabatova Sheremetievo 2 Hotel
Bratislava, Slovakia Moscow, Russia
175 247
17,000,000 49,800,000
97,000 201,000
France
Renaissance Le Parc Trocadero Pullman Paris La Defense Bailli de Suffren Hotel
Paris Paris Paris
116 384 25
35,500,000 77,200,000 5,100,000
306,000 201,000 203,500
Italy
Grand Hotel Timeo + Villa Saint'Andrea Novotel + Ibis hotels
Sicily
161
81,000,000
503,000
Nr Florence airport
400
34,000,000
85,000
Spain
Hotel Husa Paseo del Arte NH Maquinista Hotel
Madrid Barcelona
260 92
50,000,000 8,000,000
192,000 87,000
Turkey
Munamar Hotel Sungate Port Royal Hotel
Iclemar, Marmaris Beldibi, Antalya
180 989
15,000,000 190,000,000
83,000 192,000
UK
Park Central Hotel Travelodge Bournemouth Seafront abba Queen's Gate Hotel St Ermins Cumberland * Coronation Hotel Marriott Marble Arch Doxford Hall Hotel New Northumbria Hotel * * Charlton House Hotel & Spa * *
Bournemouth
60
4,400,000
74,000
Bournemouth
110
8,200,000
75,000
90 285 1,019 23 240 25 57 26
40,000,000 75,000,000 264,500,000 3,000,000 61,500,000 10,400,000 6,700,000 3,400,000
444,000 263,000 260,000 131,000 256,000 414,000 118,000 129,000
Other Europe
Holiday Inn Amsterdam Schipol Chief O'Neill's Hotel Motel One Leipzig Nikolaikirche Marriott Courtyard
Amsterdam, Netherlands Dublin, Ireland Leipzig, Germany Stockholm, Sweden
342 73 194 278
30,000,000 8,500,000 15,000,000 66,000,000
88,000 116,000 77,000 237,000
Middle East
Four Seasons Cairo at The First Residence Jerusalem Regency Hotel
Cairo, Egypt
269
250,000,000
929,000
Jerusalem, Israel
505
47,000,000
93,000
London London London London London Northumberland Newcastle Shepton Mallet
* Price for the head lease only ** Sold out of receivership. Source: Cushman & Wakefield Hospitality
Other deals of interest but not listed include the sale of the Columbus Hotel in Monaco (to be rebranded a Swissôtel) and a few corporate transactions where ownership has changed materially, including: Hoseasons (UK), Fairmont~Raffles Hotels International, Regent Hotels, Tryp Hotels and Interstate Hotels & Resorts. 6
It is worth noting that although there have been few deals in the UK, there are many examples where banks
have been extending and amending loans. Examples include: the owners of 47 Marriotts in the UK, De Vere Hotels, Ramada Jarvis Hotels, Alternative Hotel Group and The Rocco Forte Collection. Prices have been rounded where appropriate. We do not warrant the accuracy of this data which was obtained from publicly available sources and reported in industry journals. Conversions to euros were made according to the exchange rate at the time of the announcement.
7
Hotel Development Parameters Europe
MEA
Urban
Resort
Urban
Resort
sqm
sqm
sqm
sqm
Luxury Net area per key Gross area per key
38 - 60 90 -120
38 - 70 90 -145
40 - 60 90 -130
45 - 70 95 -145
Upper Upscale Net area per key Gross area per key
28 - 40 60 -100
30 - 50 70 -110
28 - 50 70 -140
35 - 55 85 -165
Upscale Net area per key Gross area per key
20 - 35 40 - 80
20 - 40 40 - 90
30 - 36 65 -100
30 - 40 70 -120
Mid-market Net area per key Gross area per key
22 - 28 40 - 67
25 - 30 50 - 67
22 - 30 45 - 80
26 - 33 70 - 95
Limited Service Net area per key Gross area per key
13 - 23 20 - 40
21 - 23 33 - 60
Cabin Net area per key Gross area per key
6 -15 12 - 30
10 25
Ratio of gross to net Luxury Upper Upscale Upscale Mid-market Limited Service Cabin
1.8 - 2.5 1.8 - 2.5 2.0 - 2.3 1.7 - 2.7 1.3 - 2.0 1.5 - 2.0
1.6 - 2.4 2.0 - 2.5 2.0 - 2.3 1.7 - 2.7 - - -
1.8 - 2.2 1.9 - 2.8 1.9 - 2.8 1.9 - 2.8 1.4 - 2.6 2.5
1.6 - 2.5 2.0 - 3.0 1.9 - 3.1 2.5 - 2.9 - - -
Net area per key = size of standard room bay Gross area per key = total built area of the hotel (including public areas and back of house) divided by number of keys Source: Cushman & Wakefield Hospitality
Unsurprisingly, resort hotels tend to have larger room bays and more space for amenities compared to urban hotels, with the gross area per key being significantly larger in resorts. Hotels in Middle East and Africa (MEA) tend to offer larger rooms and more amenities compared to developments in Europe, in both urban and resort markets.
8
The “ratio of gross to net” varies enormously depending on the quality of hotel, location and region; whereby the net room area per key can be multiplied by a factor of 1.3 to 3.1 in order to derive an indicative gross area per key.
Telephone: +44 (0)20 7935 5000
[email protected] www.cushmanwakefieldhospitality.com
Contact: Allan Sugg Telephone: +44 (0)20 7812 2398
[email protected] www.echarris.com/hotels
© 2010 Cushman & Wakefield All rights reserved
Telephone: +44 (0)20 7922 1930
[email protected] www.strglobal.com