Comparison guide for R 134a compressors 220V – 240V, 50 Hz Replaces CN.40.E1.02 A comparison and replacement guide between Danfoss R134a compressors and others The object of this Hermetic Note is to give a survey of competitive R134a compressors for 220V, their model designation, application, displacement, capacities, cooling, starting conditions, and finally to give information about which Danfoss compressor to chose when replacing a model of a different make. Please note that all comparisons in this guide are only based on capacities. This means that power consumption has not been taken into consideration. Accordingly, no Danfoss energy optimized compressors have been selected. If a greater number of compressors has to be replaced, please consult the manufacturers catalogues to confirm that design and performance characteristics meet the system requirements. The capacities are given in Watts at CECOMAF- or ASHRAE testing conditions. CECOMAF – conditions: without subcooling of liquid. ASHRAE – conditions: with subcooling of liquid. All recommendations in this comparison guide are based on published information from the following companies: Aspera (leaflet 2/93) Danfoss DKK Scharfenstein (leaflet 1/91) Embraco (leaflet 9/93) L’Unite Hermetique (leaflet 9/93) Matsushita (leaflet 1/92) Necchi (leaflet 10/93) Türk Elektrik (leaflet 9/92) Unidad Hermetica (leaflet 1/93) VOE = Verdichter Oe.GmbH (leaflet 1/93) ZEM = Zanussi Electromeccanica (leaflet 1/93)

4 2.3 4 5 5 6 6 6 6 6 7

ZEM LBP

Displacement cm3

Capacity Watt (-25o C)

Cooling

Danfoss compressor

Capacity Watt (-25o C)

Starting torque

GL35AA GL40AA GL45AA GL50AA GL60AA GL70AA GL80AA GL90AA GL99AA

3.4 4.0 4.6 5.1 6.0 6.6 8.1 9.1 9.9

58 66 78 90 108 121 145 165 176

S S S S S S S S S

TL4F TL4F TL5F TLS5F TLS6F TLS7F NL9F NL9F NL11F

61 61 82 91 105 118 157 157 200

LST LST LST LST LST LST LST LST LST

ZEM LBP

Displacement cm3

Capacity Watt (-25o C)

Cooling

Danfoss compressor

Capacity Watt (-25o C)

Starting torque

GL35AB GL40AB GL45AB GL50AB GL60AB GL70AB GL80AB GL90AB GL99AB

3.4 4.0 4.6 5.1 6.0 6.6 8.1 9.1 9.9

52 61 70 80 96 108 131 147 160

S S S S S S S S S

TL4F TL4F TL5F TL5F TLS5F TLS6F NL7F NL9F NL9F

61 61 82 82 93 105 134 157 157

LST LST LST LST LST LST LST LST LST

Energy optimized models ZEM LBP

Displacement cm3

Capacity Watt (-25o C)

Cooling

Danfoss compressor

Capacity Watt (-25o C)

Starting torque

GL35AH GL40AH GL45AH GL50AH GL60AH GL70AH GL80AH GL90AH GL99AH

3.4 4.0 4.6 5.1 6.0 6.6 8.1 9.1 9.9

60 67 79 92 109 121 147 164 174

S S S S S S S S S

TL4F TL4F TL5F TLS5F TLS6F TLS7F NL9F NL9F NL11F

61 61 82 91 105 118 157 157 200

LST LST LST LST LST LST LST LST LST

Application

L/MBP

LBP

HBP/LBP

Compressor

Displacement

TL2.5F TL3F TLES3F TL4F TLES4F TL5F TLS5F TLES5F TLS6F TLES6F TLS7F TLES7F NL6F NLE6F NL7F NLE7F NL9F NLE9F NL11F FR7.5F FR8.5F FR10F SC 15F SC 18F SC 21F TL3G TL4G TL5G FR6G FR7.5G FR8.5G FR10G FR11G SC10G SC12G SC15G SC18G SC21G SC12/12G SC15/15G SC18/18G SC21/21G

cm3 2.61 3.13 3.13 3.86 3.86 5.08 5.08 5.08 5.70 5.70 6.49 6.49 6.1 6.1 7.3 7.3 8.35 8.35 11.15 6.93 7.95 9.05 15.3 17.7 20.95 3.13 3.86 5.08 6.24 6.93 7.95 9.05 11.15 10.3 12.9 15.3 17.7 20.95 2 х 12.9 2 х 15.3 2 х 17.7 2 х 20.95

Testing conditions: Condensing temperature Ambient temperature Suction gas temperature Liquid temperature

CECOMAF 55o C 32 o C 32 o C 55 o C

Capacity Watt Cecomaf -25o C +5o C 32 42 44 61 65 82 93 93 105 105 118 122 109 110 134 135 157 160 200 103 126 138 230 280 335 42 222 61 276 82 340 83 450 103 500 126 580 138 630 170 775 115 760 183 960 230 1120 280 1320 335 1570 366 1920 460 2240 560 2640 670 3140

Cooling

S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S S/O S O/F S S S O/F O/F F S S S F F F F F F O/F O/F F F F F F F

Starting torque

LST L/HST LST L/HST LST L/HST L/HST LST L/HST LST L/HST LST L/HST LST L/HST LST L/HST LST L/HST L/HST L/HST L/HST HST HST HST L/ HST L/ HST L/ HST L/ HST L/ HST L/ HST L/ HST L/ HST L/ HST L/ HST HST HST HST HST HST HST HST

Cooling: S = Static cooling O = Oil cooling F = Fan cooling

Code number CompresCompressor sor with oil-cooler 102G4200 102G4300 102G4310 102G4400 102G4410 102G4501 102G4520 102G4510 102G4620 102G4610 102G4720 102G4710 103G6606 103G6607 103G6706 103G6702 103G6802 103G6812 103G6803 103G6900 103G6910 103G6740 103G6840 103G6940 104G8500 104G8510 104G8800 104G8810 104G8100 102G4350 102G4452 102G4550 103G6660 103G6680 103G6780 103G6880 103G6980 104G8000 104G8240 104G8250 104G8520 104G8330 104G8820 104G8140 104G8280 104G8580 104G8880 104G8180

Aspera Displacement LBP cm3 BP1046Z 2.85 BP1058Z 3.44 BP1072Z 4.15 BP1084Z 4.60 BP1111Z 5.93 B1112Z 6.27 B2112Z 6.27 B1116Z 8.38 B2116Z 8.38 B1118Z 8.07 B2118Z 8.07 E1121Z 13.6 Energy optimized models BK1086Z 5.40 BK1112Z 6.27 BK1114Z 7.40 BK1116Z 8.38

Capacity Watt (-25o C) 46 52 66 77 94 102 102 136 136 152 152 192

Cooling S S S S S S S S S S S F

Danfoss compressor TL3F TL4F TL4F TL5F TLS5F TLS6F TLS6FX NL7F NL7FX NL9F NL9FX NL11F

Capacity Watt (-25o C) 42 61 61 82 93 105 105 134 134 157 157 200

Starting torque LST LST LST LST LST LST HST LST HST LST HST LST

105 112 129 154

S S S S

NL6F NL6F NL7F NL9F

109 109 134 157

LST LST LST LST

Danfoss compressor TL3G TL4G TL5G TL3G TL4G TL5G FR6G FR6GX FR10G FR10GX FR10G FR10GX SC 2G SC 2GX SC12G SC12GX SC18G SC18GX SC21GX SC12/12G SC18/18G

Capacity Watt (+5o C) 222 276 340 222 276 340 450 450 630 630 630 630 960 960 960 960 1320 1320 1570 1920 2640

Starting torque LST LST LST LST LST LST LST HST LST HST LST HST LST HST LST HST LST HST HST LST HST

Danfoss compressor TL3F TL4F TL5F

Capacity Watt (-25o C) 42 61 82

Starting torque LST LST LST

Aspera HBP BP5125Z BP5128Z BP5132Z B5125Z B5128Z B5132Z B5144Z B6144Z B5160Z B6160Z B5170Z B6170Z E5187Z E6187Z T5185Z T6185Z T5213Z T6213Z T6215Z J6220Z J6226Z

Displacement cm3 3.15 3.80 4.30 3.65 4.38 4.85 5.90 5.90 8.00 8.00 8.85 8.85 12.0 12.0 12.58 12.58 17.4 17.4 20.40 25.80 34.37

Capacity Watt (+5o C) 231 275 296 237 280 325 431 431 622 622 673 673 915 915 885 885 1235 1235 1510 2050 2770

Cooling

DKK LBP

Displacement cm3 3.05 3.82 4.32

Capacity Watt (-25o C) 40 58 68

Cooling

KVO,52 NO5-6U KVO,63 NO6-6U KVO,75 NO7-6U

S S S S S S F F F F F F F F F F F F F F F

S S S

Embraco LBP EM20HNP EM30HNP EM40HNP EM50HNP EM60HNP FG65HAK FG75HAK FG85HAK FG95HAK FFI12HBK

Displacement cm3 2.27 3.01 3.77 4.99 5.54 6.76 7.95 9.05 10.61 11.15

Capacity Watt (-23.3o C)* 31 62 86 120 139 164 193 227 262 308

Cooling

Embraco HBP PW3.5HK9 PW4.5HK11 PW5.5HK14 FG65HAK FG75HAK FG85HAK FG95HAK FFI12HBK

Displacement cm3 3.46 4.33 5.54 6.76 7.95 9.05 10.61 11.15

Capacity Watt (7.2o C)* 337 414 527 671 785 900 1055 1260

Cooling

L’Unite LBP AZ1320Y AZ1330Y AZ1335Y AZ1339Y AZ1348Y AEZ1358Y AEZ1365Y AEZ1380Y AEZ2380Y

Displacement cm3 2.95 3.6 4.0 5.0 5.6 6.9 8.1 9.4 9.4

Capacity Watt (-25o C) 37 56 63 68 88 103 127 163 163

Cooling

L’Unite HBP AZ4410Y AZ4412Y AZ4414Y AZ3419Y AZ4419Y AEZ3425Y AEZ4425Y AEZ3430Y AEZ4430Y AE3440Y CAE4440Y CAJ4452Y CAJ4461Y CAJ4492Y CAJ4511Y

Displacement cm3 2.95 3.6 4.0 5.6 5.6 7.55 7.55 8.85 8.85 12.05 12.05 15.2 18.3 29 32.7

Capacity Watt (+5o C) 197 252 290 398 398 539 539 654 654 859 859 1131 1310 1900 2523

Cooling

S S S S S S S S S F

S S S S S S S F

S S S S S S S F F

S S S F F F F F F F F F F F F

Danfoss compressor TL2.5F TL3F TL4F TLS5F TLS6F TLS7F NL7F NL9F NL11F SC15F

Capacity Watt (-23.3o C)* 45 58 84 127 144 162 183 215 274 324

Starting torque LST LST LST LST LST LST LST LST LST LST

Danfoss compressor TL4G TL5G FR6G FR7.5G FR8.5G FR10G SC10G SC12G

Capacity Watt (7.2o C)* 364 680 785 850 1025 1290

Starting torque LST LST LST LST LST LST LST LST

Danfoss compressor TL3F TL4F TL4F TL5F TLS5F NL6F NL7F NL9F NL9FX

Capacity Watt (-25o C) 42 61 61 82 93 109 134 157 157

Starting torque LST LST LST LST LST LST LST LST HTS

Danfoss compressor TL3GX TL4GX TL4GX FR6G FR6GX FR7.5G FR7.5GX FR10G FR10GX SC12G SC12GX SC15G SC18G SC12/12G SC18/18G

Capacity Watt (+5o C) 222 276 276 450 450 500 500 630 630 960 960 1120 1320 1920 2640

Starting torque HTS HTS HTS LST HTS LST HTS LST HTS LST HTS HTS HTS HTS HTS

Matsushita LB P S43C80KA S48C95KA D66C13RA D77C15RA D91C18RA

Displacement cm3 4.33 4.85 6.58 7.69 9.07

Capacity Watt (-23.3 o C)* 95 110 151 186 215

Cooling

Necchi LB P ETR3 ETR3.5 ETR4 ETR5 ETR5.5 ESC5 ESC7 ESC8 ESC8.5 ESC9 ESC11

Displacement cm3

Capacity Watt (-23.3 o C)* 60 75 87 117 130 107 147 172 186 205 246

Türk LB P AZ47Y AZ82Y AZ107Y AE120Y AE146Y AE175Y

Displacement cm3 2.86 4.00 5.59 6.64 7.94 8.99

Unidad LB P GL35AH GL40AH GL45AH GL50AH GL60AH GL70AH GL80AH GL90AH GL99AH

Danfoss compressor TL5F TL5F NL6F NL7F NL11F

Capacity Watt (-23.3 o C)* 113 113 152 186 256

Starting torque LST LST LST LST LST

Cooling

Danfoss compressor TL3F TL4F TL4F TL5F TLS5F TL5F TLS6F NL7F NL7F NL9F NL11F

Capacity Watt (-23.3 o C)* 58 84 84 113 127 113 144 183 183 215 274

Starting torque LST LST LST LST LST LST LST LST LST LST LST

Capacity kcal/h (-23.3 o C)* 47 82 107 120 146 175

Cooling

Danfoss compressor TL3F TL5F TLS5F NL6F NL7F NL9F

Capacity kcal/h (-23.3 o C)* 50 97 106 130 157 185

Starting torque LST LST LST LST LST LST

Displacement cm3 3.4 4.0 4.6 5.1 6.0 6.6 8.1 9.1 9.9

Capacity Watt (-25 o C) 60 67 79 92 109 121 147 164 174

Cooling

Danfoss compressor TL4F TL4F TL5F TLS5F TLS6F TLS7F NL9F NL9F NL11F

Capacity Watt (-25 o C) 61 61 82 93 105 118 157 157 200

Starting torque LST LST LST LST LST LST LST LST LST

Unidad HB P GP12P B GP12P T GP14P B GP14P T

Displacement cm3 12 12 14.2 14.2

Capacity Watt (+5 o C) 985 985 1092 1092

Cooling

Danfoss compressor SC12G SC12GX SC15G SC15G

Capacity Watt (+5 o C) 960 960 1120 1120

Starting torque LST HST LST HST

VOE LB P OF605 OF789 OF1033A OF1350A

Displacement cm3 3.4 4.4 5.7 7.5

Capacity Watt (-25 o C) 50 70 96 130

Cooling

Danfoss compressor TL4F TL5F TLS5F NL7F

Capacity Watt (-25 o C) 61 82 93 134

Starting torque LST LST LST LST

S S S/O/F S/O/F S/O/F

S S S S O O

S S S S S S S S S

F F F F

S S S S

Compressor

Heigth Suction Discharge Oil-cooler Process

TL

A B C D E

NL

FR

SC

SC-Twin

TL2.5F TL3F TL4F TL3G

TLES3F TLES4F TL5F TLS5F TLES5F TLS6F TLES6F TLS7F TLES7F TL4G TL5G

NL6F

NL7F

NLE6F NLE7F

NL9F NLE9F NL11F

FR7.5F FR8.5F FR10F FR6G FR7.5G FR8.5G FR10G FR11G

SC10G

SC12G SC15F

SC15G SC18F

SC18G SC21G SC21F

SC12/12G SC15/15G

SC18/18G SC21/21G

156 6.2 5.0

166 6.2 5.0

175 6.2 5.0

178 6.2 5.0

185 6.2 5.0

254 16 6.2

6.2

6.2

203 10.2 6.2 6.2 6.2

244 12 6.2

6.2

203 8.2 6.2 6.2 6.2

213 10.2 6.2

6.2

191 8.2 6.2 6.2 6.2

193 8.2 6.2

6.2

185 8.2 6.2 6.2 6.2

6.2

6.2

6.2

6.2

Перепечатку выполнила М. Беджанян