Downtown Vancouver Local Bus Service Review
Final Summary Report | August 2015
Contents Executive Summary.............................................................................................................3 Study Process
........................................................................................................................... 3
Network Vision.......................................................................................................................... 4 Immediate............................................................................................................................ 5 Near-term
............................................................................................................................ 6
Background and Purpose...................................................................................................8 Study Process...................................................................................................................... 10 Phase 1: Issues and Opportunities........................................................................................ 10 Key Themes....................................................................................................................... 12 Phase 2: Alternative Network Designs and Evaluation....................................................... 13 Special Topic Workshops.................................................................................................. 13 Geographic-Based Workshops
......................................................................................... 14
Preliminary Evaluation of the Network Design Concepts
............................................ 16
Phase 2 Consultation........................................................................................................ 17 Phase 3: Network Vision and Recommended Actions........................................................ 21 Concept Refinement......................................................................................................... 21 Cambie Bridge Route (17)................................................................................................ 24 Eastern Corridor Routes (3, 4, 7, 8, 19, 200’s)............................................................... 24
Recommended Actions.................................................................................................... 25 City of Vancouver
.................................................................................................................. 25
TransLink................................................................................................................................. 25 TransLink and the City
.......................................................................................................... 26
Next Steps............................................................................................................................ 28
Page
|
2
Executive Summary The purpose of the Downtown Vancouver Local Bus Service Review (DBSR) is to develop a shared, one-to-five year vision for the downtown bus network. The vision will guide decision making at TransLink and the City of Vancouver (the City) to ensure efforts are coordinated toward achieving our common goals. The DBSR incorporates the goals and policies of the City’s recently adopted Transportation 2040 Plan, and builds on TransLink’s Vancouver/UBC Area Transit Plan, focusing on downtown areas that have experienced substantial change in recent years. WE ARE HERE
Summer 2013
2014
Summer 2015
1
2
3
Issues and opportunities
Alternative network designs and evaluation
Recommended network vision
• Understand current issues and gaps in the downtown bus network.
• Present alternative network design concepts of the downtown local bus network for public discussion.
Phase
• Identify opportunities to inform the development of alternative network designs.
• Use feedback to evaluate alternatives.
• Recommend actions to achieve this vision. • Identify a common near-term vision for the downtown local bus network.
STUDY PROCESS The DBSR followed a three-phase study process to better understand the current and anticipated transit service issues in the downtown core to: 1. Develop alternative scenarios for changes to the downtown transit network to be implemented over the next one-to-five years; 2. Evaluate these alternatives to establish a network vision; and 3. Provide recommendations on preferred actions with respect to infrastructure investment and transit service planning.
Page
|
3
These recommendations will help guide decision making at TransLink and the City of Vancouver through their respective planning and implementation processes.
NETWORK VISION
The downtown bus network effectively and reliably connects downtown neighbourhoods and enables convenient transit connections to the broader city and region. The downtown transit network is consistent and easy to understand, with clear communication of temporary detours associated with road closures and special events.
The following list of priorities provides a road map to achieving the network vision for the local bus network in downtown Vancouver. These priorities are financially viable options that meet the objectives of the DBSR and result in improved transit connections, better reliability, and an aligned local downtown network that works with current land use patterns. Priorities for the next one-to-five years have been separated into two focus areas: 1) Immediate: targeted for implementation over the next one-to-two years; and 2) Near-term: for subsequent completion and in some cases require further analysis.
Page
|
4
BA YSH
ER
OR
NI
E
CH ILC O
BA R
E LL BID W
GEO
RG
CA RD ER O
UR
E
MO HO ME R
RN BY HO
DA VIE
RIC HA RD S
N
ITH
EL
AD CIT
BSO
KEEFER
EXPO
UNION
MAIN
RO
SM
SEY
CH BEA GE
BRID
extension (dotted)
VIL
LE
IC PACIF DR AK
CAMBIE
E
BR IDG E
GR AN
POWELL
E
AB Y
D
CA MB IE
BU
BU RR AR D
TE
RN
RW OO
B
• Extend trolley service along Pacific Boulevard and Cambie Street towards Waterfront Station.
RONT
VIL L
BU HA
ARD URR
WAT ERF WATER
HO WE
OX
GR AN
NIC OLA BR OU JER GH TON VIS
CO M
6
HA
N
UIR
N LSO NE
• Extend 6 Davie/Downtown trolley service eastward along Davie Street to the YaletownRoundhouse Canada Line Station.
DU NS M
LSO
VA DO COR TINGS R S DE PEN
RO
NE
C O A L H A R B O U R
IA
HA
BRIDGE
LL RE
CLA Y
BEA TTY
D PEN
Extend the 6 Davie/Downtown to connect the West End, Yaletown and Gastown.
ALB
DE NM AN
G IL
FOR D
LAGOON
TH UR LOW
IMMEDIATE
FALSE CREEK
Figure 1: Immediate Priority – Route 6
• Finalize layover or last stop accommodation plans; options include: Cambie at Pender, or adjust existing location at Davie at Denman. OR
NI
E
NM DE
ILC O CH
TON
PEN
GH
CO M
IE
HA RIC
UNION
C
IC PACIF DR AK
IDG BR
BRIDGE
E CAMBIE
LE
EXPO
21
N
VIL
KEEFER MAIN
MB
UR MO ME HO RD S
DA VIE
E
LSO
E
N
NE
GE
BRID
EL
AD CIT
BSO
ITH
R
BY RN HO
B
CA
RO
SM
SEY
CH BEA
D
GR AN
POWELL
LE
D RR AR
AB Y
RW OO
BU
TE
RN
BU
RONT
VIL
BU HA
GR AN
JER VIS
WAT ERF WATER
HO WE
OU
OX
BR
UIR
BEA TTY
LL
UR
DU NS M
N
ARD URR
C O A L H A R B O U R
IA HA
CA RD ER NIC O OLA
RG
VA DO COR TINGS R S DE
BID WE
GEO
TH
ELL
Explore C21 terminus HARO changes NELSO
LOW
CLA Y
DR
• Combine the C23 Davie/Main and C21 Yaletown/Beach into a new C21 service connecting English Bay to Yaletown-Roundhouse, Stadium-Chinatown and Main Street stations via Beach Avenue, Pacific and Expo Boulevards.
BA YSH
ER
BA R
PEN
Consolidate the C23 Davie/Main and C21 Yaletown/Beach services.
ALB
AN
GIL
FOR
D
LAGOON
• Remove the layover or last Figure 2: Immediate Priority – Route C21 stop, from Morton Avenue by implementing necessary parking, traffic engineering and bus stop changes along Bidwell Street and Station Street. FALSE CREEK
• Engage community members to ensure public support for this new routing on Bidwell Street.
Page
|
5
Determine route for the 5 Robson/Downtown to improve consistency and reliability, based on an expected City of Vancouver decision regarding frequency and duration of road closures of the 800-block of Robson Street. • If road closures and required transit detours are frequent or prolonged, reroute 5 Robson/Downtown via Burrard Street to provide a more consistent service for customers year-round. • If road closures and required transit detours are infrequent and not prolonged, re-route 5 Robson/Downtown via Seymour and Richards streets to provide access to high-demand destinations year-round, with occasional detours. • In either case, the 5 Robson/Downtown and 6 Davie/Downtown routes will be coordinated so they can share layover space for vehicle downtime. NOTE: definition of “frequency” and “duration” will be determined by TransLink with input from the City of Vancouver.
NEAR-TERM Simplify city-wide/regional transit services (3, 4, 7, 8, 200s) on eastern corridors. • Pursue opportunities to realign bus service in a more predictable and easy to understand way.
Review design of 17 Oak/Downtown following implementation of immediate priorities. • Reevaluate alternative network designs for the 17 Oak/Downtown based on emerging ridership patterns following the implementation of service changes to the 5 Robson/Downtown and 6 Davie/Downtown.
Improve service reliability and customer experience. • Increase communications between TransLink and the City so that transit customers can be better informed in advance of temporary detours to accommodate road closures.
Page
|
6
• Explore opportunities to assess and improve travel times and reliability in areas where changes could have a significant impact. Priority corridors for this study area include: –– –– –– –– ––
Burrard Street Georgia Street West End Corridors (Robson, Denman and Davie streets) Granville Corridor (Seymour, Granville and Howe streets) Eastern Corridors (Hastings and Pender streets)
• Projects may include: –– Review of stop spacing and amenities. –– Implement transit priority measures.
Page
|
7
Background and Purpose Local bus services in Vancouver’s downtown core are some of the most productive and in-demand services in the region. However, their current design pre-dates much of the growth and investment within downtown that has occurred over the past decade. The current Vancouver/UBC Area Transit Plan (ATP) was completed in 2005. Since this time, the downtown core has experienced significant change including high growth in areas east of Granville, such as Yaletown and Downtown South, as well as the introduction of new rapid transit infrastructure (Canada Line).
Stanley Park
West End Community Centre
Coal Harbour Community Centre Canada Place TO
Sinclair Centre
SFU BCIT
Woodward's
St Paul's Hospital Library Queen Elizabeth Theatre
Rogers Arena BC Place Stadium Edgewater Casino
Granville Island
Study Boundary Area
While TransLink continues to update Figure 3: DBSR Study Boundary Area Area Transit Plans (now expanded to more comprehensive Area Transport Plans) on an ongoing basis, an update to the Vancouver/UBC ATP will not be prepared for several years. TransLink conducts local corridor/area reviews on an as-needed basis, supplemental to this planning process as part of ongoing management of the transit network. The Downtown Vancouver Local Bus Service Review (DBSR) is one such review. The City and TransLink have identified the need for a detailed review of local bus services in the downtown core. This will help develop a unified vision for the transit network for the next one-to-five years. Recent land use and street geometry changes within the downtown (particularly east of Granville Street) have implications for the downtown transit network which need to be identified and addressed with solutions. The most notable changes are proposed under the City’s Transportation 2040 plan, and include: (1) the potential removal of the Georgia and Dunsmuir Viaducts and replacement with a reconfigured at-grade road network; (2) consideration of a permanent pedestrian plaza on the 800-block of Robson Street; and (3)
Page
|
8
Dr Sun Yat-Sen Classical Chinese Garden
S W
focus on multi-modal planning, including the expansion of cycling and pedestrian infrastructure. There is also a proposal to relocate the Vancouver Art Gallery to the northeast corner of Georgia and Cambie Streets. As part of this proposal, there is potential that the 600-block of Cambie Street would be closed to vehicles to allow for a new public plaza.
The council-approved West End Community Plan (November 2013) and the Downtown East Side Local Area Plan (March 2014), as well as the Eastern Core Strategy and planning for the Northeast False Creek, which are both still ongoing, are other relevant City planning processes that were active during the DBSR to better coordinate land use and local transit planning. The purpose of the DBSR is to develop a shared, one-to-five year vision for the downtown bus network. The vision will guide decision making at TransLink and the City to ensure efforts are coordinated toward achieving our common goals.
Page
|
9
Study Process The following phases and sub-tasks provided the framework to achieve the study objectives. These tasks were compiled into three distinct phases, as shown below. Consultation with the public, including key stakeholders, was undertaken during Phase 1 and 2 of the project to help guide the work outlined below. The public consultation summaries can be found in the Appendices. This final report provides the summary of Phase 3 and final recommendations of the DBSR. WE ARE HERE
Summer 2013
2014
Summer 2015
1
2
3
Issues and opportunities
Alternative network designs and evaluation
Recommended network vision
• Understand current issues and gaps in the downtown bus network.
• Present alternative network design concepts of the downtown local bus network for public discussion.
Phase
• Identify opportunities to inform the development of alternative network designs.
• Use feedback to evaluate alternatives.
• Recommend preferred alternatives. • Articulate a common near-term vision for the downtown local bus network.
PHASE 1: ISSUES AND OPPORTUNITIES The first phase of the DBSR focused on understanding previous work, existing conditions, issues and opportunities related to local bus service downtown. Activities comprised of a broad public and stakeholder consultation process, including stakeholder meetings, public open houses and online questionnaire. Key components of this phase of the study included a review of: • Transit-related public feedback reported in land use and transportation plans previously conducted by either the City or TransLink. • Existing downtown local bus network, including ridership patterns. • Existing trolley infrastructure to better understand plans and priorities for the trolley network, as well as implications of potential road network changes, Page
|
10
existing infrastructure investments, and considerations for expansion, such as electrical requirements like a rectifier station. • Transit priority measures that could be implemented along main travel streets, including, but not limited to: rush-hour parking restrictions, bus only lanes, bus stop upgrades or traffic calming measures. • Roadway and infrastructure changes under consideration by the City, including VIVA Vancouver initiated seasonal closures of Granville Street and 800-block Robson Street, viaduct changes, and potential closure of 600-block Cambie Street as part of the new Vancouver Art Gallery proposal. Phase 1 also included a TransLink and City workshop with transit consultant Jarrett Walker to explore the issues, opportunities and considerations presented by the current downtown bus network. Items identified include, but are not limited to, the need for: • Better bus connections between the West End, Yaletown and Gastown. • Fewer travel patterns disruptions resulting from Granville Street closures. • An easier to understand bus network in CBD/Gastown/Chinatown area. • More transit service options in Coal Harbour and the south side of Stanley Park. • Connections between regional and downtown services. • A complete grid of bus services across the peninsula east-west and north-south. • Simplified services running on adjacent corridors where feasible.
Page
|
11
KEY THEMES Key themes raised in Phase 1 were consistent with feedback received through previous transportation and community plan processes conducted by both the City or TransLink. Top 10 key themes from Phase 1 public consultation • Update the downtown network to reflect changing development patterns. • Increase service frequency, particularly during peak hours, evenings and weekends. • Design routes to be simple, direct, and easy to understand. • Design routes to be consistent and dependable, avoiding temporary re-routes as much as possible. • Improve communication of closures/re-routes to customers. • Improve reliability of services (reduce bunching). • Improve connections between downtown neighbourhoods. • Integrate bus services with rapid transit. • Improve bus stop amenities and accessibility. • Consider introducing a downtown “circulator,” potentially with free service.
Technical Analysis
Phase 1
Public Input
Identify Issues and Opportunities
Phase
2
ALTERNATIVE NETWORK DESIGNS & EVALUATION
Page
|
12
PHASE 2: ALTERNATIVE NETWORK DESIGNS AND EVALUATION During Phase 2, a series of six joint internal workshops between TransLink and the City were held to address themes identified in Phase 1 and identify alternative network design concepts and improvements for the downtown bus network. Three of the workshops focused on special topics related to the downtown bus network while the other three were organized around a geographical area of downtown.
SPECIAL TOPIC WORKSHOPS These workshops were used to: 1. Help inform the development of network design concepts; and 2. Identify improvements that will be explored and implemented through other processes. For example, station upgrade processes can help to integrate active modes of transportation into stations, communication processes can help to achieve better information sharing related to special events, and street furniture contract processes can improve bus stop amenities. Intermodal connections: Topics discussed included a review of all current and planned station upgrades; transit station amenities (including secured bike parking); plans for future cycling infrastructure; pedestrian wayfinding; bus stops and real time information; and integration of transit with car share services. Special events: Topics discussed included a review of special events ranging from single day events such as the Sun Run, Marathon or Car Free Day, to scheduled closures such as the Vancouver Police Department’s Granville Entertainment District weekend closures and VIVA Vancouver’s Robson Square installations, and spontaneous or unplanned events such as protests and rallies. Finally, construction related impacts were also reviewed. Traffic management plans were discussed for each special event type. Communications opportunities for special event transit disruptions were also discussed and focused on methods used to communicate internally within the City and TransLink, between agencies (City/TransLink and/or Coast Mountain Bus Company) and with the public. Accessibility and the public realm: Discussion included a review of the accessibility of stops and transit vehicles, bus stop amenities and a review of the street furniture contract. Pedestrian and transit signage, including schedule information at bus stops were also important topics covered in the workshop.
Page
|
13
GEOGRAPHIC-BASED WORKSHOPS Using geographic-based workshops the staff team was able to group all of the concepts into six focus areas, to better generate technically feasible alternatives to the existing transit network. A comprehensive list of 31 network design concepts was developed. This included variations on concepts that would be affected by the potential closures of the 800-block of Robson Street or the 600-block of Cambie Street. Downtown-only routes: This involves the four bus routes (5, 6, C21, and C23) that provide service exclusively within the established downtown boundary. Cambie Bridge route: A review of the 17 route, currently the only bus route that travels into and out of the downtown via the Cambie Bridge. Presently, the 17 completes a one-way loop downtown which serves primarily as a turnaround of the Oak Street bus, and is the only bus route that provides service through the southeastern portion of downtown. Eastern Corridor route: An exploration of the numerous bus services that enter and exit the downtown through the eastern corridor (i.e. Pender, Hastings, Cordova, and Powell Streets). This corridor includes both local and regional services from the North Shore, via Second Narrows Bridge. New routes that would use the street network resulting from the potential removal of the Georgia/Dunsmuir Viaducts were discussed in Phase 1. However, these design concepts were not carried forward as it is unlikely that the work required to remove the viaducts and build the new road network will be complete within the five year time frame of this review. Granville Bridge routes: The Granville Corridor includes seven different services (4, 6, 7, 10, 14, 16, and 50), carrying passengers into and out of the downtown via the Granville Bridge, providing key connections to major destinations and rapid transit services. Bus services are periodically relocated to Seymour Street (northbound) and Howe Street (southbound) throughout the year to accommodate different activities that take place on Granville Street. This relocation of service can result in confusion for customers and reliability issues for bus travel time. Lions Gate Bridge routes: Georgia Street hosts several services from the North Shore via Lions Gate Bridge. These are largely regionally focused services aimed at commuters and also provide a local service along this corridor to residents of Coal Harbour and the West End. Burrard Corridor: The 2 and 22 bus routes provide transit service along the stretch of Burrard from Pender to Burrard Street Bridge. Also, the 44 provides an express service
Page
|
14
from Waterfront Station to UBC via Burrard Street. Both these services are very popular and suffer from unreliability due in part to “bus bunching.” On weekdays, there are currently northbound bus lanes during the AM peak period (7 to 9:30 a.m.) and southbound bus lanes during the PM peak period (3 to 6 p.m.).
Workshop Key Takeaways 1. It is important to look at specifics of operation such as transit priority measures and bus stop locations, in addition to the bus routes. 2. Although many of the existing bus routes in the downtown are on appropriate corridors, some of the more recently developed neighbourhoods in the area were not as well served as the older, more established neighbourhoods. 3. Reliability and predictability were key concerns on streets that had frequent and well-used transit.
Page
|
15
PRELIMINARY EVALUATION OF THE NETWORK DESIGN CONCEPTS Each of the 31 alternative design concepts was assessed using the Multiple Account Evaluation (MAE) separately by the City and TransLink staff. To assist with the assessment, TransLink worked with a consultant to develop capital and operating cost estimates for each of the concepts. This list of alternatives was reviewed and cut to a shortlist of the most promising network design concepts to be shared for public input. After staff evaluation, three focus areas contained concepts that were not moved forward: 1. Granville Corridor – While permanently removing transit service from Granville Street was considered, the most promising concept for this corridor was to retain services along Granville Street whenever possible and reroute via Seymour and Howe as it operates today. 2. Lions Gate Services – The greatest improvements to services coming across the Lions Gate Bridge along Georgia Street were shown to be related to transit priority measures rather than new service designs. 3. Burrard Corridor – Similar to the Lions Gate Services, the Burrard Corridor improvements related to transit priority measures rather than new service designs.
Develop Alternatives A) Downtown-only Routes
B) Cambie Bridge Route
Phase 2
D) Granville Bridge Routes
C) Eastern Corridor Routes
E) Lions Gate Bridge Routes
F) Burrard Bridge Routes
Multiple Account Evaluation
Deliverability
Economy
Financial
Environment
Land Use
Transportation
Social & Community
Consult on Promising Network Design Concepts A) Downtown-only Routes
Page
|
16
B) Cambie Bridge Route
C) Eastern Corridor Routes
PHASE 2 CONSULTATION Feedback received through Phase 2 of consultation was used to inform and evaluate the final set of alternatives. During this second phase of consultation, City and TransLink staff presented: • An overview of the DBSR • A summary of what we heard in Phase 1 • The approach taken to develop and evaluate revised network design concepts • Details of promising network design concepts in three areas, including the redesign of: –– Downtown-only routes –– Cambie Bridge route –– Eastern Corridor routes • Next steps Feedback was gathered through: • Meetings with key stakeholders –– DBSR Stakeholder Working Group and Transportation 2040 Advisory Committee, March 20, 2014 –– West End Seniors Community Planning Table, March 28, 2014 • Open houses –– –– –– ––
West End Community Centre, April 5, 2014 Yaletown Roundhouse Community Centre, April 9, 2014 Woodward’s Atrium, April 10, 2014 Vancouver Public Library, April 12, 2014
• Online questionnaire (April 2 to 21, 2014)
Phase 2 Consultation Results Outreach to downtown residents, organizations, businesses and stakeholders was achieved through several channels. Over 300 people attended the four public open houses, and approximately 990 people completed the questionnaire, either online or in writing, during the public consultation period from April 2 to 21, 2014. Input was gathered to gain a better understanding of how the network design concepts would
Page
|
17
work for them as compared to the services in place today. Respondents were also asked if they agreed or disagreed that TransLink and the City had identified the main benefits and trade-offs associated with each concept, or if there were additional benefits and trade-offs they felt the DBSR should consider. Details of the outcomes of this phase of consultation including the questionnaire can be found in the Phase 2 Consultation Summary document. The results of this consultation were used to complete the MAE for the Deliverability account.
General Themes There was broad support for the design concepts presented during Phase 2. Members of the public were generally in agreement that TransLink and City staff had identified the main benefits and trade-offs for each concept. In addition to network changes, there was a strong desire for increased frequency and improved reliability among all transit services in the downtown area. Although it is outside the framework of the DBSR, there was also an interest in improving transit priority measures along main travel streets including Burrard, Georgia, Granville, Hastings and Pender; bus stop upgrades; integration of services with the cycling network; and changes to bus routes in or near the downtown.
Downtown-only Routes (5, 6, C21, C23) Key themes for the two network design alternatives presented for the downtown-only routes were: • Support for standard-sized buses along the full length of Davie Street. • Connecting to Yaletown Station on the Canada Line. • Desire to maintain year-round transit service along Robson Street at least as far east as Granville Street. In general, there was more widespread support for Concept A1 than Concept A2 (see Figure 4) due to the improved connections between the West End, Yaletown and Gastown and the connection to the SkyTrain.
Page
|
18
FOR D GIL
NM AN DE
CH ILC O
FRON
T
POWELL
TH U
EXPO
UNION
MAIN
MB IE
KEEFER
E
1
BRIDGE
BR
CAMBIE
E
FALSE CREEK
CA
C2
N
ITH
IC PACIF DR AK
VIL LE GR AN
CAMBIE
AD CIT
BEA TTY
RIC HA RD S
GE
EL
BSO
SM
DA VIE
BRID
BRIDGE
BR
WAT ER
WATER
HO WE SEY MO U
D
ARD BURR
RO
R
RW OO
HO ME R
C2
RA RD
HA
BU R
AB Y
HO RN BY
UNION
OX
UIR
LE
JER VIS TE
EXPO
DU NS M
N
RN
BU
KEEFER MAIN
CA
EL
1
BEA TTY
HO ME R
E
FALSE CREEK
BU
C O A L H A R B O U R
IA
CO M
6
BR
MB IE
R SEY MO U
HO RN BY
N
E
RG
LSO
OU G
POWELL
GEO
GR AN VIL
RLO W TH U
LL BID WE
RO
CA RD ER NIC O OLA
WATER
5
HA NE
RLO W
CLA Y
IC PACIF DR AK
VIL LE GR AN
CAMBIE
BA R
N LSO NE
GE
E
T
AD CIT
BSO
ITH
DA VIE
BRID
BRIDGE
RO
SM
N LSO NE
BR
FRON
HO WE RA RD
BU R
D
ARD BURR
E
IDG E
RW OO
RIC HA RD S
CA
BEA TTY
3
C2
IC PACIF DR AK
VIL LE
AB Y
HA
BU
UNION
MAIN
EXPO
OX
RN
TE
MB IE
SEY MO U
HO ME R
KEEFER
N
UIR
WAT ER
LE
JER VIS
BR
HO WE
LE RA RD
HO RN BY
EL
E
N LSO NE
RIC HA RD S
N
ITH
DU NS M
CO M
6 BU
OR
NI
C O A L H A R B O U R
IA
LSO
OU G
POWELL
RG
BA YSH
ER
CH BEA
1 GE
NE
GEO
GR AN VIL
RLO W TH U
LL BID WE
RO
T
WATER
AD CIT
BSO
SM
DA VIE
BRID
GR AN
FRON
5
HA
CH BEA
C2
CH BEA
D
ARD BURR
RO
R
RW OO
BU R
TE
AB Y
HA
GR AN VIL
HTO N JER VIS
BR
OU G
6
OX
UIR
WAT ER
CA RD ER NIC O OLA
LL
N
CO M
RN
BU
DE
CH ILC O
CH ILC O
DE
DU NS M
LSO
BU
CLA Y
C O A L H A R B O U R
IA
ALB
VA DO COR TINGS R E S HA PEND
BID WE
RG
E
VA DO COR TINGS R E S HA PEND
NE
GEO
VA DO COR TINGS R E S HA PEND
RO
OR
NI
EL L DR PEN
5
HA
LAGOON
BA YSH
ER
BA R
EL L DR PEN
EL L DR PEN
CLA Y
ALB
NM AN
E
Concept A2
HTO N
GIL
OR
NI
BA R
CA RD ER NIC O OLA
FOR D
LAGOON
BA YSH
ER
IDG E
ALB
NM AN
GIL
FOR D
LAGOON
Concept A1
IDG E
Business as Usual
HTO N
FALSE CREEK
Figure 4: Downtown-only Routes
Cambie Bridge Route (17) Comments related to the Cambie Bridge Route (Figure 2) options revealed: • The current route generally works well for users; • Several concerns raised with the concepts including that B1 may reduce direct access to the Central Business District and the Granville and Georgia area; • Modest support for Concept B2; and • Operational and reliability concerns associated with the left turn at Granville and Robson in B2 were raised. Suggestions included extending the 17 west to Burrard Street to provide access further across the downtown peninsula, or ending the service south of False Creek as it duplicates the Canada Line from Broadway into downtown. Business as Usual
OR
E
|
19
MA
LOW UR TH
E
FRON
T
POWELL
BIE
N
BEA TTY
E
IC PACIF DR AK
FALSE CREEK
WAT ER
WATER
KEEFER EXPO
UNION
MAIN
MO
R ME HO DS
LE E
CA M
HO WE
LE VIL GR AN
D
RN HO
DA VIE
EL
AD CIT
BSO
ITH
IDG
CAMBIE
BRIDGE
FALSE CREEK
RO
SM
AR
GE BRID
IC PACIF DR AK
E
RR AR
D
ARD BURR
17
UR
RW OO
SEY
UNION
BY
EXPO
BU
BU T
KEEFER
AB Y
UIR
CAMBIE
TON GH
OU JER VIS
RN
RIC H
DS AR
BU E
BIE CA M
17
EL
AD CIT
BEA TTY
R ME HO
E
N OX
MAIN
MO SEY BY RN
HO
DA VIE RIC H
E
N
ITH
BR IDG
GR AN VIL LE
BSO
SM
DU NS M
CO M
HA
C O A L H A R B O U R
IA
LSO
BRIDGE
BID WE LL
LOW UR TH HO WE
LE VIL GR AN
D RR AR
D
GE BRID
BRIDGE
RO
UR
RW OO
BU
BU T
AB Y
Figure 5: Cambie Bridge Route
Page
DE N
CH
TON GH
OU BR JER VIS
RN
E
MB IE
CA
17 BEA TTY CAMBIE
MAIN
MO SEY
R ME HO RD S
POWELL
RG
RO
NE
BR
BID WE LL
UR LOW TH HO WE
LE VIL D
BY HO RN
RIC HA IDG E
BU HA
GEO HA
T
WATER
N LSO
LE
OX
FRON
NE
BR
UNION
N
CO M
UIR
WAT ER
N LSO
FALSE CREEK
EXPO
DU NS M
LSO
ARD BURR
IC PACIF DR AK
E
EL
AD CIT
E
CLA Y
C O A L H A R B O U R
IA
NE
DA VIE
E
N LSO
VIL
N
ITH
KEEFER
OR
NI
CH BEA
BSO
SM
NE
GR AN
POWELL
NE
CH BEA
CH BEA
D
GE BRID
RO
UR
RW OO
RA R
AB Y
BU R
TE
RN
GR AN
BU HA
ARD BURR
T
WATER
RG
RO
CA RD ER NIC O OLA
CH
TON GH
JER VIS
BR
OU
OX
GEO HA
CA RD ER NIC O OLA
LL BID WE
N
CO M
UIR
FRON
BA YSH
ER
VA DO COR TINGS R E S HA PEND
LSO
WAT ER
VA DO COR TINGS R E S HA PEND
DU NS M
VA DO COR TINGS R E S HA PEND
NE
C O A L H A R B O U R
IA
ELL
RG
RO
DR
ELL
GEO
HA
ALB
BA R
PEN
CLA Y
DR
ELL
DR
CLA Y
BU
ILC O
MA
N
NI
DE N
ILC O
NM DE
ILC O CH
LAGOON
BA YSH
ER
BA R
PEN
PEN
BA R
CA RD ER NIC O OLA
ALB
BR
E
N
OR
NI
GIL FOR D
LAGOON
BA YSH
ER
Concept B2
GR AN VIL
ALB
AN
GIL FOR
D
LAGOON
Concept B1 GIL FOR D
Eastern Corridor Routes (3, 4, 7, 8, 19, 200’s) Key themes regarding Concept C1 centered on support for simplifying routes on the eastern corridors. However, some concern was heard in relation to walking distances for transfers between Main Street and eastbound services on Hastings Street, as well as perceptions of personal safety at this location.
Business as Usual
Concept C1
19 WAT ERF
UR
HO WE
LE VIL
MB CA
BEA TTY
R ME HO HA
RD S
E
IC PACIF DR AK
E
L
CI
N
ITH
DA VIE
4, 7, 200s
IE
GR AN
UR
MO
D BU
MAIN
SM
CAMBIE
BRIDGE
CAMBIE
RR AR
IE MB CA
BEA TTY
R ME HO HA
FALSE CREEK
4
HASTINGS PENDER
E TAD
BSO
N
N
E
UNION
RO
LSO
LSO
IC PACIF DR AK
EXPO
CORDOVA
KEEFER EXPO
UNION
3, 8 19
E
KEEFER
,7
POWELL
DU NS MU IR
NE
DA VIE
EL
4, 7, 200s
RIC
HO WE
LE VIL
GR AN
UR
MO SEY
D RR AR BU
TH
TH
N
ITH
NE
RD S
HASTINGS PENDER
3, 8 19
SM
RONT
CORDOVA
AD CIT
BSO
WAT ERF WATER
POWELL
DU NS MU IR
RO
IA
LOW
UR
LOW
RONT
,7
C O A L H A R B O U R
RG
WATER
4
RIC
GEO
MAIN
IA
BRIDGE
RG
SEY
GEO
19 C O A L H A R B O U R
FALSE CREEK
Figure 6: Eastern Corridor Routes
Suggestions for a more comprehensive transit priority corridor on Hastings Street were also received. Given the study boundary area for this review, it was determined that this work was out of scope, and should be investigated as part of a Hastings B-Line implementation project.
Page
|
20
PHASE 3: NETWORK VISION AND RECOMMENDED ACTIONS CONCEPT REFINEMENT Results from Phase 2 public consultation, along with additional technical work, were used to refine concepts and to develop the Network Vision and associated recommended actions.
Downtown-only Routes (5, 6, C21, C23) Following the pubic consultation, further technical analysis was conducted on the Downtown-Only Route concepts. Further refinement of the C21 Yaletown/ Beach showed that removing the layover from Morton Avenue enables a new route through Bidwell Street. This reduces travel time by avoiding intersections on Morton Avenue, and provides access to the same origins and destinations, as well as better connections to the 6 Davie/Downtown service. ALB
FOR
D
LAGOON
BA YSH
OR
NI
E
CH
DE
ILC O
NM
AN
GIL
ER
BA R
LL BID WE
LOW
DU NS M
HO RD S HA
IE
EXPO
UNION
MAIN
KEEFER
1
C2
N
RIC
CA
MB
UR MO
ME
R
BY RN HO
DA VIE
E
LSO
ILL E
N
ITH
EL
AD CIT
BSO
NE
E
G BRID
RO
SM
SEY
CH BEA BUR
IC PACIF DR AK
BRIDGE
IDG
E
CAMBIE
E
BR
GR AN V
POWELL
LE D BU
RR AR
AB Y
D
D RAR
RONT
HO WE
OX
WAT ERF
WATER
VIL
JER VIS TE BU
RN
RW OO
CO M
GR AN
TON GH
OU BR
BU HA
N
UIR
PEN
CA
LSO
6
C O A L H A R B O U R
IA HA
RD ER NIC O OLA
RG
VA DO COR TINGS R S DE
RO
NE
GEO
UR
5
HA
TH
ELL
DR
CLA Y
BEA TTY
PEN
Further analysis of options for routes 5 Robson/Downtown and 6 Davie/Downtown determined that for Concept A1 (Figure 4), the right turn from southbound Granville Street to westbound Robson Street was not operationally feasible due to significant delays to other bus services on Granville Street. A route for the 5 Robson/Downtown using Seymour and Richards was chosen as the most promising alternative to Granville Street.
FALSE CREEK
Although Concept A2 did not Figure 7: Concept A2(b) evaluate as well as Concept A1 during the public consultation, the team saw merit in a bus route that extended the majority of Robson Street. For this reason, an alternative concept was developed to extend service of the 5 Robson/ Downtown and 6 Davie/Downtown. This alternative (Figure 7) allowed for better access to Gastown and Stadium-Chinatown Station on both routes.
Page
|
21
TransLink and the City found that closures of Robson Square (800-block Robson Street) to vehicular traffic to create public space does not preclude transit service from safely operating in a space shared with pedestrians. It was also confirmed that Robson closures to all vehicles including buses are expected periodically (e.g. Jazz Fest, protests, etc.), although it has not been defined how frequent and prolonged these closures will be in the future. Until there is further clarity, all service concepts require a Robson closure detour, at least for special events. In light of the above findings, detours for the potential 800-block Robson Street closures were further refined. Through this process, it was determined that the West Georgia and Hamilton street detour for Concept A2 and A2(b) was not an appropriate alternative as the infrastructure investment required was significant and did not provide benefits to transit customers. After taking these findings into consideration along with feedback from public consultation, the evaluation found that three packages of alternatives are operationally feasible and are presented in Table 1. Package 1: Seymour-Richards Base Service
Package 2: Burrard Base Service
Package 3: Robson Base Service
via Hastings Street D FOR GIL
D
NM DE
ILC O
FRON
T
POWELL
LOW UR TH LE VIL
IE
BEA TTY
C2
UR
AD CIT
MO
N
SEY
R ME HO RD S HA RIC
KEEFER
EXPO
E
UNION
MAIN
MB CA
D RR AR BU
BY RN HO
EL
BSO
ITH
1
LE
IC PACIF DR AK
E BRIDGE
BR
IDG
E
CAMBIE
VIL GR AN
CAMBIE
WAT ER
WATER
FALSE CREEK
FALSE CREEK
FALSE CREEK
RO
SM
DA VIE
BR
BRIDGE
E IDG
D
IDGE
E
VIL
RW OO
ARD BURR
UIR
HO WE
TON GH
JER VIS
1
C2
IC PACIF DR AK
BR
AB Y
HA
BU
MAIN
UNION
OX
RN
TE
IE MB CA
BEA TTY
R ME HO
KEEFER
EXPO
DU NS M
CO M
6 BU
C O A L H A R B O U R
IA
LSO N
BR
HO WE
N
E
RG
NE
OU
POWELL
GEO
GR AN
LOW UR TH
LL BID WE
RO
LE UR MO
RD S HA LE
EL
AD CIT
BSO
ITH
DA VIE
RIC
BR
RO
SM
SEY
BY RN
IDGE
GR AN
WATER
5
HA
T
VIL D RR AR BU
TE BU
D
HO
BEA TTY CAMBIE
E IDG
GR AN
TON GH
OU BR JER VIS
UR
R ME HO
RW OO
FRON
N LSO
RD S
AB Y
HA
OX
WAT ER
NE
LE
RN
ARD BURR
E
VIL
6 BU
CO M
UIR
N LSO
C2
IC PACIF DR AK
BR
DU NS M
NE
HA
UNION
CLA Y
C O A L H A R B O U R
IA
LSO N
MAIN
EXPO
1
N LSO
RIC
KEEFER
RG
CA RD ER NIC O OLA
LL BID WE
IE MB CA
D
MO SEY
BY RN HO
N
E
NE
GE
EL
AD CIT
BSO
ITH
DA VIE
BRID
GR AN
CH
DE
ILC O CH
LOW UR TH HO WE
LE VIL
RO
SM
GEO
NE
CH BEA
CH BEA
D
RO
CH BEA
RW OO
ARD BURR
POWELL
BRIDGE
BU
HA
RR AR
AB Y
BU
TE
RN
GR AN
TON JER VIS
BR
OU
GH
6
OX
WATER
5
HA
T CA RD ER NIC O OLA
LL BID WE
CO M
UIR
FRON
E
VA DO COR TINGS R E S HA PEND
LSO N
WAT ER
VA DO COR TINGS R E S HA PEND
DU NS M
NE
BU
C O A L H A R B O U R
IA
ELL
RG
OR
NI
BA R
DR
ELL
GEO
VA DO COR TINGS R E S HA PEND
RO
BA YSH
ER
PEN
CLA Y
DR
5
HA
ALB
AN
E
NM
AN NM DE
ILC O CH
OR
NI
BA R
PEN
ELL
DR
CLA Y
CA RD ER NIC O OLA
LAGOON
BA YSH
ER
AN
E
BA R
PEN
Regular Routing
ALB
FOR
FOR
OR
NI
GIL
LAGOON
BA YSH
ER
GIL
ALB
D
LAGOON
E
LL
TH UR LOW
DU NS M
CO M
FRON
T
POWELL
LE VIL
MB IE
N
BEA TTY
ME R HO
E
HA RD S
1 C2
IC PACIF DR AK
CAMBIE
BR
BRIDGE
E
VIL
E
FALSE CREEK
EL
AD CIT
BSO
ITH
DA VIE RIC
LE
RO
SM
KEEFER
EXPO
UNION
MAIN
MO UR SEY
BY RN HO
GE BRID
CA
D RR AR
D
ARD BURR
WAT ER
WATER
HO WE
OX
UIR
BU
RW OO
GR AN
CAMBIE
E
AB Y
HA
C O A L H A R B O U R
IA
GR AN
BR
JER VIS
1 C2
E
IDG
RN
BU
UNION
IC PACIF DR AK
BR
BU
MAIN
EXPO
FALSE CREEK
22
6
TE
IE MB CA
KEEFER
RG
IDG
ME R HO HA RD S RIC
N
E
GEO
LSO N
OU G
POWELL
VIL HOW E LE MO U SEY
RN BY HO
EL
AD CIT
BSO
ITH
DA VIE
RO
N LSO
VIL LE
WATER
5
HA NE
NE
GR AN
RO
SM
N LSO NE
GE BRID
T
CH BEA
CH BEA
D
BEA TTY
RW OO
FRON
BRIDGE
BU
HA
GR AN
AB Y
R
TE
RN
D
BU
OX
RR AR
JER VIS
BR
OU
6
CO M
BU
GH TO
N
LSO N
UIR
WAT ER
HTO N
NE
ARD BURR
|
NM AN
CH
DU NS M
BID WE
UR IA
CA RD ER NIC O OLA
LOW
C O A L H A R B O U R
TH
RG
Table 1: Downtown Only Routes
Page
DE
ILC O
NM DE
CH ILC O
LL BID WE CA RD ER NIC O OLA
GEO
VA DO COR TINGS R E S HA PEND
RO
E
CLA Y
ELL
5
HA
OR
NI
BA R
DR
ELL
DR
CLA Y
BA YSH
ER
PEN
PEN
BA R
ALB
D
FOR
OR
NI
AN
GIL
LAGOON
BA YSH
ER
GIL FOR
ALB
D
LAGOON
VA DO COR TINGS R E S HA PEND
800 Robson Transit Closure
via Pender Street
The technical analysis found that their associated infrastructure and service costs are very similar. However, these service concepts provide different benefits. Package 1: The Seymour-Richards streets base service reaches important destinations, but is more difficult to understand during Robson closures. Package 2: The Burrard Street base service is easy to understand at all times, but is further from some important destinations. Package 3: The Robson Street base service reaches important destinations, but the route is not easy to understand during Robson closures. The selection of a final alternative shall be based on evaluating access to important origins and destinations and assessing how understandable the service design is for customers. The technical recommendation also depends on the likely frequency of Robson Square closures: • Package 2, if road closures and required transit detours are frequent or prolonged, then re-route 5 Robson/Downtown via Burrard Street to provide a more consistent service for customers year-round; • Package 1, if road closures and required transit detours are infrequent and not prolonged, then re-route 5 Robson/Downtown via Seymour and Richards streets to provide access to high-demand bus stops year-round, with occasional detours. • In either case, the 5 Robson/Downtown and 6 Davie/Downtown routes will be coordinated so they can share layover space for vehicle downtime. NOTE: definition of “frequency” and “duration” will be determined by TransLink with input from the City of Vancouver.
Once the City of Vancouver confirms the expected future programming of Robson Square closures for the next five years as well as longer term, a final alignment will be confirmed for the 5 Robson/Downtown, and the process for funding acquisition and service change delivery can continue. As the decision for final alignment for the 6 Davie/Downtown has been confirmed, the process for trolley infrastructure changes can proceed as an immediate network priority.
Page
|
23
CAMBIE BRIDGE ROUTE (17) Draft concepts of the Cambie Bridge service were not further refined. Feedback from the public received through Phase 2 consultation revealed that the current route generally works well for users. Technical analysis also revealed operational concerns regarding reliability of particular turning movements in draft concepts, and it is expected that ridership patterns would change after implementation of the above mentioned changes to the 5 Robson/Downtown and 6 Davie/Downtown. In light of the above findings, reassessment of draft concepts for the 17 Oak/ Downtown is recommended after the implementation of changes to the 6 Davie/ Downtown and 5 Robson/Downtown.
EASTERN CORRIDOR ROUTES (3, 4, 7, 8, 19, 200’s) Previous tasks identified opportunities to realign bus services in the eastern corridor. The Downtown Eastside Local Area Plan has identified Gastown and Water Street as areas where relevant improvements to the pedestrian realm and road network will occur, and could impact transit operations. These changes could impact bus services not included in the existing corridor concept (Figure 6), such as the 50 Waterfront Station/False Creek South. Further assessment of eastern core network changes and consultation are recommended upon the confirmation of road network changes.
Page
|
24
Recommended Actions CITY OF VANCOUVER 1. Confirmation of expected programming of Robson Square closures for the near and long-term, to determine year-round route of the 5 Robson/Downtown. 2. Ensure technical design work completed by TransLink and the City in support of maintaining transit service is taken into consideration as part of public space design and decision-making, including: • 800-block of Robson Street for Robson Square • 600-block of Cambie Street for Vancouver Art Gallery and associated public space
TRANSLINK 1. Based on City of Vancouver expected programming of Robson Square closures for the near and long-term: –– If road closures and required transit detours are infrequent and not prolonged, re-route 5 Robson/Downtown via Seymour and Richards streets to provide access to high-demand bus stops year-round, with occasional detours. –– If road closures and required transit detours are frequent or prolonged, reroute 5 Robson/Downtown via Burrard Street to provide a more consistent service for customers year-round. 2. Implement identified routing changes through TransLink’s established planning and implementation processes: • Extend 6 Davie/Downtown service east via Davie, Pacific, Cambie and Hastings streets. • Implement 5 Robson/Downtown to coordinate operations with the new 6 Davie/Downtown and provide through-service from Robson/Denman streets to Davie/Yaletown. • Merge the C23 Yaletown/Davie/Main St Station and C21 Yaletown/Beach by removing the Davie Street segment, which becomes redundant with the extension of the 6 Davie/Downtown. Page
|
25
3. Invest in trolley overhead improvements to enable service changes above, including: • Davie Street east of Richards Street; • Pacific Boulevard between Davie and Cambie streets; • Cambie Street between Pacific Boulevard and Hastings Street; and • Turning and passing wires/switches at or near several intersections.
TRANSLINK AND THE CITY 1. Pursue reviews of travel times and reliability, with consideration of stop spacing, transit priority, and amenities, including: • West End Corridors (Robson, Denman and Davie Streets) • Burrard Street • Georgia Street • Granville Corridor (Seymour, Granville and Howe Streets) • Eastern Corridors (Hastings and Pender Streets) 2. Implement parking, road and intersection improvements, traffic engineering and bus stop changes to accommodate associated service changes, including: • Extend the 6 Davie/Downtown east of Granville, and along Pacific and Cambie. • Remove the C21 Yaletown/Beach layover from Morton Avenue. • Finalize proposal for layover accommodation for the 5 Robson/Downtown and 6 Davie/Downtown at Cambie at Pender (preferred location), or adjust existing layover location at Davie Street at Denman Street if preferred option is not feasible. Implement parking, road geometry and bus stop changes accordingly. • Investigate additional bus layover facilities as part of the City’s Central Waterfront Hub redevelopment to strengthen this multi-modal hub. • Investigate additional bus layover facilities at Station Street as preferred layover location for the C21 Yaletown/Beach route. 3. Consider further routing proposals consistent with the vision through TransLink’s ongoing management of the transit network, including: • Eastern corridor proposals to lines 3, 4, 7, 8, 19 and 200’s, as included in ‘Concept 1’ presented in Figure 6. Page
|
26
• Change services that provide basic coverage in the Gastown area (e.g. 50 Waterfront Station/False Creek South). • Engage additional stakeholder and public consultation as appropriate, once the road network in the area has been defined. 4. Improve communication of road closures and associated transit detours in partnership with City of Vancouver Special Events, Vancouver Police Department and Coast Mountain Bus Company.
Page
|
27
Next Steps The DBSR developed a shared, one-to-five year vision for the downtown bus network and identified and evaluated immediate and near-term priorities. The resulting vision will guide decision making at TransLink and the City to ensure efforts are coordinated toward achieving our common goals. TransLink will undertake detailed planning and design work for the identified routing changes. Through its established planning, consultation and implementation processes, the immediate and near-term priorities will be considered for implementation based on regional priorities. The City of Vancouver will confirm expected programming of Robson Square closures for the near and long-term, and ensure technical design work completed by TransLink and the City is taken into consideration as part of its decision-making.
Page
|
28