Stratified/Personalised/Precision Medicine J Stuart Elborn Queen’s University Belfast and BHSCT.
The Cystic Fibrosis (CFTR) Gene
Identified 1989 Chromosome 7 27 exons Encodes for CFTR Protein
>1800 mutations described
F508del/F508del
G551D/F508del
CF Airway Disease: Pathophysiology Normal
CF
Classes of CFTR mutations (>2000 in total)
Boyle MP, De Boeck K. The Lancet Respiratory medicine. 2013
Improved Survival with Treatment Innovation Incremental Modest Benefits
Stratified/Precision Medicine for CF
Advances in therapy have been incremental • Individual benefit is modest but cumulative • Life expectancy greatly increased
RCTs
Centre care
Age (years)
Mist tents
40 35 30 25 20 15 10 5 0
Neonatal screening
1st pathologic description
NPD and Cl transport
CF gene identified
Ivacaftor Colobreathe Bronchitol TIP AZLI
HTS Azithromycin Inhaled Tobramycin
1st successful pregnancy Sweat chloride rhDNase test developed Inhaled colistin Discovery antipseudomonal antibiotics of high salt antistaphylococcal antibiotics in sweat
Correctors: Increase number and function of CFTR channels at the cell surface
Cl-
VX-770
Cl-
Cl-
ClCl-
ClCl-
Cl-
ClCl-
G551D
Cl-
Cl-
VX-809 Cl-
F508del
Cl- Cl-
ClCl-
Class III CFTR Mutations
CFTR protein
X ClCl-
Molecular Defect
Amino acid substitution or missense mutations causing defective CFTR protein regulation
Functional Consequence
Decreased CFTR protein channel opening (gating defect)
Examples of Mutations
G551D, G551S, G1349D
Golgi
mRNA
CFTR Gene
Phase 3 Results (G551D) FEV1
PEx
CFQ-R
wt
Ramsey, B…Elborn JS et al. New Engl J Med (2011), 365: 1663-1672
2012 - FDA Approves Ivacaftor
Mucociliary Clearance: The Movie Baseline
Ivacaftor - 3 months Trachea
Courtesy of Dr. Tim Corcoran, U. Pittsburgh
Ivacaftor Lung Function Benefit Persists
See: McKone et al. NACFC 2013
Ivacaftor Expansion Timeline % Population
2012- G551D 2013 – other gating mutants Predicted: 2014- R117H 2015-2016 – residual function
4% (6%) 5% (1%)
8% (16%) 15% (20%)
What About the Most Common Mutation - F508del? 50% of patients have F508del mutations on both alleles 80% of patients have at least one F508del mutation
F508del results in little to no CFTR protein at the cell surface Cl–
CFTR Cl–
Normal quantity of CFTR channels at the cell surface
Golgi
Proteasome
Few F508del-CFTR channels at the cell surface ER
Nucleus 16
Vertex Pharmaceuticals Incorporated VX809 NDA ISE: ISE for Lumacaftor in Combination with Ivacaftor
Key secondary endpoints & additional analyses, TRAFFIC/TRANSPORT Pooled Figure 3.2.1.1 Absolute Change from Baseline in Percent Predicted FEV1 (Percentage Points) at Each Visit Full Analysis Set
Proportion of Event-free Subjects Absolute Change in ppFEV1, LSMeans (+/- 95% CI)
6
Lung function TTF Pulmonary exacerbation
5
4
Exacerbations Events requiring hospitalization
1.0
Events requiring IV antibiotics
39 to 61% reduction for patients in combination groups
3
0.9
45 to 56% reduction for patients in combination groups –45% –56% P5,000 Gating/ R117H/ Residual CFTR
>2,000 G551D
KALYDECO
ivacaftor monotherapy
ivacaftor + corrector
Next gen correctors triple combinatons
Complex regimens
4
Challenges For Stratified Medicine in CF • Range in disease severity among people with the same CFTR mutations ⁻ Modifier genes ⁻ Environment • Stage of disease at time of treatment • Cost/access of therapies • Adherence to therapies
Translational Research in CF Thanks to • All the people with CF and parents who participated in clinical trials • PIs (TDN & ECFS-CTN) • study teams who participated in clinical trials to improve treatment for CF • Industry/academic partnerships