Plantar “Fasciitis” or “Fasciosis” Edward P. Mulligan, MS, PT, SCS, ATC
Definition Repetitive microtrauma resulting in collagen degeneration at the origin of the plantar fascia on the medial calcaneal tubercle Histological evaluation of 50 surgical cases support the contention that this is a degenerative, not an inflammatory condition
National Director of Clinical Education - Grapevine, TX Faculty Instructor University of Texas Southwestern School of Allied Health Department of Physical Therapy Dallas, TX
Lemont H, et al. 2003, J Am Podiatr Med Assoc
www.continuing-ed.cc
Prevalence - Incidence
www.continuing-ed.cc
Plantar Fascia Anatomy
Most common foot condition treated by healthcare providers according to a survey of APTA Orthopedic Sections Foot-Ankle SIG group members
PF
10% incidence over course of lifetime Estimated to affect 2 million Americans so prevalence is around 1%
www.continuing-ed.cc
ADM
FDB AH
FP
dense multilayered fibrous connective tissue; bands 2-4 mm thick Originates at the medial calcaneal tuberosity and inserts into the plantar plates of the MTP joints and bases of the proximal phalanges Medial band is twice as thick as the lateral and central bands and most commonly involved in plantar fasciitis www.continuing-ed.cc
Proximate Neurological Structures
Proximate Neurological Structures
Medial Calcaneal Nerve
Medial and Lateral Plantar Nerves
arises from the posterior tibial nerve at level of the malleolus and supplies sensation to the plantar medial aspect of the foot
www.continuing-ed.cc
located between the FDB and QP and provides sensation to the medial and lateral plantar aspect the foot Compression can be a cause of the heel pain complaint
www.continuing-ed.cc
Plantar Fascia Function
Windlass Mechanism The windlass mechanism, secondary to toe extension during propulsion, puts tension on the plantar fascia and passively raises the arch
passive truss support of the longitudinal arch absorbs forces in early stance stabilizes the foot during propulsion
www.continuing-ed.cc
Truss Support Function When a superior load is applied on the arch – the plantar fascia (truss) prevents migration of the two ends away from one another, thus supporting the imposed load
Heel Spur
Body Weight
GRF
www.continuing-ed.cc
plantar fascia truss
GRF
Interpretation Tensile strain is increased as a patient’s body weight increases
The heel spur isn’t the problem - it’s the reaction to the problem 50% of patients with plantar fasciitis have heel spurs 50% of patients with bilateral heel spurs only had unilateral symptoms 15-20% of patients without plantar fasciitis have heel spurs Tauz, et al, 1963, Clin Orthop Lapidus, et al, 1965, Clin Orthop Young ,et al, 2001, Am Fam Phys Cornwall, et al, 2003, J Orthop Sports Phys Ther
www.continuing-ed.cc
Etiological Considerations
www.continuing-ed.cc
Etiological Considerations Primary cause is
“time wounds all heels”
obesity and/or prolonged standing cause and/or promote the problem in the non-athletic population
Groucho Marx
65-70% of adults patients with plantar fasciitis are overweight
www.continuing-ed.cc
www.continuing-ed.cc
Foot Type Predisposing Factor
Obesity Risk Factor Patients with higher BMI at higher risk Recommended < 25 Rano JA, 2001, J Foot Ankle Surg 5-6 times higher risk than those Riddle DL, et al, 2003, J Bone Joint Surg
Pes Planus
Pes Cavus
increased tensile tension on the plantar fascia
inherently tight, shortened fascia increases bowstring like load
under BMI of 25
www.continuing-ed.cc
www.continuing-ed.cc
Musculoskeletal Risk Factor
Musculoskeletal Risk Factor
GastrocGastroc-Soleus Tightness
1st MTP Hypomobility
78% had at least 5º limitations in df ROM Amis J, et al, Foot Ankle, 1988
23 times higher risk if >0º df ROM Riddle DL, et al J Bone Joint Surg, 2003
hold the calcaneus in varus and limits pronation causes compensatory substitution at the MTJ to increase sagittal plane dorsiflexion
patients with plantar fasciitis often present with a loss of passive and active 1st MTP extension ROM this finding could adversely affect the windlass mechanism function Unclear if this is a cause or result of plantar fasciitis Creighton, et al, 1987, J Orthop Sports Phys Ther
www.continuing-ed.cc
Musculoskeletal Risk Factor Additional findings positively correlated to plantar fasciitis
Decreased plantar flexion strength
www.continuing-ed.cc
Extrinsic Risk Factor Training/Activity errors magnified by presence of previous risk factors
BW, foot type, MS deficits
Kibler WB, et al, 1991, Amer J Sports Med
Violate Rule of “2s”
Decreased plantarflexion ROM
too much … too long … too often ….
Warren, 1984, Med Sci Sports Exer
3½ times more likely to have plantar fasciitis if the majority of the workday is spent on feet
Decreased toe flexor strength
But not 1st MTP hypomobility
Allen, et al, 2003, J Orthop Sports Phys Ther
Riddle, et al, 2003, J Bone Joint Surg www.continuing-ed.cc
www.continuing-ed.cc
Training Activity Modifications
COMMON SUBJECTIVE HISTORY
Reduce volume of prolonged weight-bearing Avoid sprinting and uphill running
Clinical Presentation X “worst steps are first steps” Y gradual, insidious onset Z sharp localized pain at plantar fascial origin
Increases TCJ dorisflexion and MTP extension ROM requirements
[ pain worse in AM, eases with gentle activity, increases again as day progresses
Avoid hard training surfaces
\ aggravated by stairs, hills, running, jumping, or “barefoot” activities www.continuing-ed.cc
Common Objective Findings STRUCTURE
Look for varus deformities or malalignment
PALPATION
Assess tenderness at medial calcaneal tuberosity and/or medial arch tenderness with palpable nodules
MOBILITY
Screen for decreased gastroc/soleus flexibility; limited 1st MTP ROM
FUNCTION
Often has pain or difficulty in performing unilateral heel raise
GAIT
May have supinated gait to avoid stress on plantar fascia
PROVOCATION
Simultaneous 1st MTP and ankle dorsiflexion with subtalar joint eversion
www.continuing-ed.cc
Windlass Provocation Test Forceful great-toe extension in a standing position causing pain at the medial calcaneal tubercle
100% specificity 31% sensitivity just
13% sensitivity if performed in NWB
DeGarceau D, et al. Foot-Ankle Int, 2003
www.continuing-ed.cc
Heel Pain Differential Diagnosis Neurologic
Soft Tissue
Skeletal
Systemic
Medial Calcaneal Nerve Entrapment
Subcalcaneal Bursitis
Calcaneal Stress Fracture
Reiter’s Syndrome
Plantar Nerve Entrapment
Achilles Tendinopathy
Calcaneal Apophysitis
Ankylosing Spondylitits
S1 Radiculopathy
Fat Pad Atrophy
Haglund Deformity
Rheumatoid Arthritis
Bone Bruise
Psoriasis
Tarsal Tunnel Syndrome
www.continuing-ed.cc
www.continuing-ed.cc
Differential Diagnosis Tarsal Tunnel Syndrome posterior tibial nerve entrapment burning or throbbing pain paraesthias on the plantar foot, toes, or lower leg tenderness distal and posterior to medial malleolus + Tinel’s weakness of IP flexors sensory deficits to medial arch and toes 1-3 www.continuing-ed.cc
General Treatment Approaches 1. 2. 3. 4.
Conservative (non-operative) Interventions ESWT Injections and Medications Surgical Interventions
Available Evidence There is limited evidence at this time on which to base clinical practice Common treatments used to reduce heel pain offer marginal gains over no treatment or control groups Crawford F, et al, 2007, Cochrane Review
I’m going to limit presentation to information within my scope of care
Consequently, we’ll review the quality of the evidence to support or refute individual interventions www.continuing-ed.cc
www.continuing-ed.cc
Quality of Evidence
Recovery Expectations
Level of Evidence
80-90% of patients respond to conservative treatment
Description Evidence supported by high quality randomized controlled trials Evidenced supported by lower quality randomized controlled trials or prospective comparative studies Evidence supported by retrospective comparative or case-controlled designed studies Evidence obtained from case studies Consensus - Agreement by an expert panel, in the absence of scientific evidence in the literature, based on experience and/or assumptions in the literature www.continuing-ed.cc
Treatment Considerations
www.continuing-ed.cc
Baxter, et al, 1984, Foot-Ankle Int 90% recovered with conservative care in average of 11 months Wolgin, Cook, Mauldin, 1994, Foot Ankle Int good results (resolution of symptoms) took an average of 6 months stretching, cushioned inserts, and NSAIDs most helpful according to patients poor results were in patients who were overweight, had bilateral symptoms, or longer duration of symptoms prior to medical management www.continuing-ed.cc
Basic Intervention Goals
www.continuing-ed.cc
Initial Treatment
Initial Treatment EDUCATION
REST avoidance of any activity that aggravates symptoms by decreasing its IDF As an example change the manner of the activity walk instead of run swim instead of walk bicycle in lower gear reduce plyometric movements
Quality of Internet-Derived Information 152 web sites evaluated and assigned a 0-10 rating based on the information it provided Definition, causes, risk factors, symptoms, diagnostic tests, conservative and surgical treatment options, and complications Mean score was 3.8 36% of sites had obvious conflict of interest or financial bias and these sites had significantly lower ratings Sites authored by orthopedic surgeons had the highest mean ratings (7.1) – followed by DPMs (5.2) and PTs (4.8) Moshirfar A, et al. 2004, Clin Orthop Relat Res
www.continuing-ed.cc
Symptomatic Care •
www.continuing-ed.cc
Iontophoresis
ice massage for its anesthetic value
dexamethasone iontophoresis provided more immediate reduction in acute symptoms, but does not alter the long outcome Gudeman, et al, 1997, Am J Sports Med
acetic acid iontophoresis provided a complete or substantial relief of heel pain over 6 treatments in 3 weeks Japour, et al, 1999, J Am Pod Med Assoc
Acetic acid/taping superior to dexamethasone/taping Osborne, et al. 2006, Br J Sports Med
www.continuing-ed.cc
No evidence for the effectiveness of:
www.continuing-ed.cc
Magnetic Therapy RCT showed that magnetic-embedded insoles NO more effective than placebo insoles in alleviating pain
Therapeutic ultrasound Crawford F, et al, 1996, Ann Rheum Dis
Low-intensity laser therapy
Winemiller MH, et al, 2003, JAMA
Basford JR, et al, 1998, Arch Phys Med Rehabil
www.continuing-ed.cc
www.continuing-ed.cc
Symptomatic Care
Therapeutic Exercise –
STRETCHING EMPHASIS
Anecdotally Critical
Rolling pin, Coke bottle, ball, or frozen juice can at bedside for arch roll stretching prior to weight bearing
Commercial
CAVUS Foot
Gastroc-Soleus Stretching
83% of successful patients said this was the most important treatment
Both sustained and intermittent stretching are effective in the management for painful heel syndrome
No statistically significant short term improvements in “ first-step” pain or foot function as compared to a control group
Wolgin, Mauldin, et al Foot Ankle J, 1994
products
Porter D, et al, 2002, J Rheumatol
“That Foot Thing” Foot Rubz
Radford JA, et al, 2007 BMC Musculoskeletal
www.continuing-ed.cc
Therapeutic Exercise –
CAVUS Foot
www.continuing-ed.cc
Intrinsic Plantar Fascia Stretch Greater improvement of pain and function, as well as greater patient satisfaction than traditional standing Achilles stretch
1st MTP stretching/mobilization Sesamoid mobilization Shamus J, et al, 2004 J Orthop Sports Phys Ther
Most effective when performed before initial few steps in AM
Soft Tissue Mobilization and Cross Fiber Massage to fascial tolerance
10 x 10 sec/TID and after prolonged NWB prescription
Intrinsic Plantar Fascia Stretch!!
DiGiovanni, et al. 2003, JBJS DiGiovanni, et al. 2006, JBJS
www.continuing-ed.cc
Therapeutic Exercise – PLANUS
www.continuing-ed.cc
Foot
STRENGTHENING EMPHASIS strengthen the muscles that control and reverse pronation posterior tibialis anterior tibialis peroneals www.continuing-ed.cc
Posterior Tib Training
www.continuing-ed.cc
Therapeutic Exercise – PLANUS Foot
STRENGTHENING EMPHASIS Intrinsic strengthening sweeps,
curls, and pick ups
Most helpful treatment by patient report (35% of subjects) as compared with night splints, orthotics, heel cups, NSAIDs, and corticosteroid injections
Manual Therapy Intervention Evaluate and treat all arthokinematic impairments and restrictions at TCJ, STJ, MTJ, TMTJ, and 1st MTPJ Case series – Young B, et al, 2004, J Orthop Sports Phys Ther
Martin RL, et al, 1998. Foot Ankle Int
www.continuing-ed.cc
www.continuing-ed.cc
Shoe Recommendations
External Support
to Control Symptoms
Shoes Tape Orthotics
stiff, firm heel counter with straight last well molded Achilles collar beveled and flared heel for stability midsole cushioning elevated heel good midfoot/forefoot flexibility 14% of patients with chronic heel pain found a change in shoes the most effective treatment Wolgin M, et al. 1994 , Foot Ankl Int
“Tape it up real tight, Floyd … and the other ankle, too.”
Low-Dye Taping
www.continuing-ed.cc
Calcaneal Taping
Significant short-term reduction in pain Landorff et al. 2005, J Am Podatr Med Assoc
Calcaneal taping was shown to be be more effective than stretching sham taping, or no treatment Hyland, et al, 2006, J Orthop Sports Phys Ther
temporary or trial technique to reduce pronation and stabilize 1st ray www.continuing-ed.cc
www.continuing-ed.cc
Taping and Orthotic Mechanical Support Randomized, prospective study to compare mechanical support (taping for first month and custom orthotic for next two months) with accommodative heel cups or corticosteroid injections Significantly better outcomes in mechanical group (70% satisfaction) as compared to 30-33% with antiinflammatory or accommodative modalities. Lynch DM, et al, 1998, J Am Podiatr Med Assoc
Orthotic Intervention Pain and function improved with the use of foot orthotics Roos E, et al, 2006, Foot Ankle Int
Soft Accommodative Orthotic provides total contact to the medial longitudinal arch customized heel pad/soft orthotic offered significant pain relief in a small sample of elderly patients Siligman DA, et al, 2003, Arch Phys Med Rehabil
Biomechanical Orthotic provide semi-rigid support to hyperpronation 66% decrease in pain and 75% reduction in disability Gross MT, et al, 2002, J Ortho Sports Phys Ther
www.continuing-ed.cc
No-Need for Long Term Use or Customization? Pre-fabricated orthotic insert more likely to provide symptom improvement that customized rigid device Pfeffer G, et al, 1999, Foot Ankle Int
www.continuing-ed.cc
Night Splints Maintains position of ankle and toe in dorsiflexion during the night
Did not account for foot types in randomization Both customized and pre-fabricated orthoses provided short-term improvements (3 months) in pain and function as compared to a sham group but no difference at 12 months
allows the plantar fascia to heal at a functional length and prevent physiological creep
Most effective in chronic conditions
symptoms present for > 6 months
Landorf KB, et al, 2006; Arch Intern Med
Could it be that condition has largely resolved by this point in time? Simple off-the-shelf orthoses have significant effect on fascitiis symptoms Tinley P, et al. Biomechanics, 2007
www.continuing-ed.cc
Night Splint Research ☺ Relief provided in 83% of patients with recalcitrant plantar fasciitis - Wapner, et al Foot-Ankle, 1991
☺ Ankle DynaSplint beneficial in patients with recalcitrant plantar fasciitis – Berlet GC, et al; Orthopedics, 2002
☺ Dorsiflexion splints provide symptomatic relief of recalcitrant plantar fasciitis in the majority of patients – Powell, M, et al, 1998, Foot Ankle Int
☺ Tension night splint improved the efficiency of a standard treatment protocol
www.continuing-ed.cc
Outcome Assessment Lower Extremity Functional Scale (LEFS) Foot Health Status Questionnaire (FHSQ) Foot and Ankle Ability Measure (FAAM) Foot Function Index (FFI) Martin RL, 2007, J Ortho Sports Phys Ther
– Batt ME, et al; Clin J Sports Med, 1996
No added benefit with addition of night splint to a standard treatment protocol – Probe RA, et al; Clin Orthoped Relat Res, 1999
Inconclusive on best type of splint to affect outcome, however, Strassburg sock shown to speed recovery. - Barry LD, et al; J Foot Ankle Surg 2002 www.continuing-ed.cc
All have been shown to reliable, valid (content and construct), and responsive www.continuing-ed.cc
www.continuing-ed.cc