The Wireless Backhaul Market Market Dynamics & The Continuing Opportunity
New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc. 30 S. Michigan, Suite 700 Chicago, IL 60603 (312) 980-7848 © New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc. www.nprg.com
November 10, 2009
Today’s Webinar
Objective: Provide summary insights into the U U.S. S backhaul market and the opportunities it presents for properly positioned service providers. Based on: NPRG proprietary research & analysis of Backhaul: 9 9 9 9
Backhaul Market Analysis & Study Current Backhaul Research Company-level research & analysis Ongoing research across sectors
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
2
Wireless Backhaul 2009
1
Backhaul Market Overview
2
Key Backhaul Players
3
Strategies & Technologies
4
The Opportunity & Trends
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
3
Backhaul Market 2009
SECTION 1: THE BACKHAUL MARKET
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
5
Backhaul Architecture Generalized Mobile Backhaul Architecture
Internet
Mobile Switching Center
POP
PSTN
Source: New Paradigm Resources Group
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
6
Fundamental Growth Factors in the Backhaul Ecosystem y © Cellular subscriber growth
End U Users
Broadband Wireless SP
©© Mobile data usage, rich media apps
Cellular / Mobile Data SP
©© Wireless technology standards (HSPA+, LTE, 4G…) t oduct o of o femtocells e toce s ª Wi-Fi,, introduction
NET BACKHAUL GROWTH = ©©©
©© BBW subs growth
Site Owner © Incremental tower adds
Backhaul Transport p SP
Core Network SP
©© FTTH/N = fiber deep in networks © Evolution of core capacity & convergence
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
7
Driving Current Backhaul Growth Mobile Subscribers by Carrier
Prime Opportunity: Independent Carriers
Prime Opportunity: Out of Franchise Territory
Prime Opportunity: Out of Franchise Territory
Source: New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
8
User Behavior: Necessary Components of Backhaul Growth While mobile data has gained popularity in recent years… the g greatest impact p will come with further smartphone p adoption. p Share of Subscribers on U.S. Cellular Networks: Mobile Data and Smartphones Ubiquitous
Mobile Cloud Access Mainstreaming
Early Recreational iPhone
Business
iPhone 3GS, G1, Pre, BB Storm
Source: New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
9
Leading Backhaul Customers Cellular Subscriber Market Share (2005-2009)
CLWR Other BBW
Source: New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
10
Backhaul Market 2009
SECTION 2: KEY BACKHAUL PROVIDERS
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
11
Sector Schema & Backhaul Emerging Wireless
Seeing opportunity, providers in a range of sectors are targeting the backhaul bac au market a e aggressively agg ess e y
LTE / 4G Cellular / Broadband Wireless (incl. Wi‐Fi and WiMAX)
Access Solutions
Fixed Wireless
Paid Content
Fiber Network Operators
Tier 1 Telcos Metro Ethernet BPL
Video Services
Satellite
Facilities‐ Based CLECs
Cable MSOs FTTx
IPTV (Competitive Video) Cable Video
IOCs
ISPs Content Delivery Cloud Computing
CIOCs
Non‐Facilities CLECs
Virtualization Software as a Service
VoIP
Managed Services
Wireline Voice & Data
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
12
Key Players in the Backhaul Market Selected Prime Movers in the Backhaul Services Market Sector
ILEC
Cable MSO
CLEC
Fiber Network Rollups & Legacy Utility Fiber
Fixed Wireless & Hybrid (Wireless plus Fiber)
Key Backhaul Providers • • • • •
AT&T CenturyLink (Embarq) Qwest Verizon Windstream
• • • • • • • • • • •
Cox Communications Time Warner Cable Comcast Level 3 Optimum Lightpath (unit of Cablevision) tw telecom XO American Fiber Systems (AFS) FPL Fibernet (unit of Florida Power & Light) IP Networks Zayo Bandwidth
• • •
Conterra Ultra Broadband FiberTower Telecom Transport Management (TTM)
Source: New Paradigm g Resources Group, p, Inc.
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
13
Serving Cell Sites The majority of wireless sites are located in Tier 1 carriers’ franchise territories carriers
Source: New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
14
Cell Tower Ownership U.S. Cell Tower Ownership (2009) Rank
Tower Owner
1
Crown Castle
2
American Tower
3
Verizon *
4
AT&T
5
SBA Communications
Others
CenturyLink (CTL + EQ) Global Tower Partners Mobilitie Partners LLC T-Mobile USA TowerCo
* Includes unreduced Alltel assets
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
15
Backhaul Customers: Cell Sites Wireless Providers Rank By Number Cell Sites (2Q 2009) Rank Provider 1
Verizon Wireless *
2
AT&T Mobility
3
Sprint Nextel
4
T-Mobile
5
US Cellular
6
Leap Wireless
7
MetroPCS
8
Clearwire
* Includes unreduced Alltel network
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
16
Backhaul Market 2009
SECTION 3: STRATEGIES & TECHNOLOGIES
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
18
Backhaul Transport Media Share Predominant Physical Medium to Cell Site 2013
2007 Fiber Fixed Wireless
Fiber be
Copper
Fixed Wireless
Copper
Source: New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
19
Carrying the Traffic: Competing p g Physical y Media Legacy Copper Loops (T1s) Pros
• Facilities in place: BH providers’ capital costs sunk • Max distance = miles • Well-understood technology, OAM well-defined • Engineered E i d to carry voice i
Cons
• Finite capacity—relatively low • Stepwise bandwidth • Per P unit it capacity it costt = linear li • Service outages • Engineered to carry voice—not data • Lease from ILEC
Provided By
• Incumbent LECs: AT&T, Verizon, IOCs
S Source: New N P Paradigm di R Resources G Group, IInc.
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
20
Carrying the Traffic: Competing p g Physical y Media Fiber to the Site
Pros
• Highly scalable bandwidth • Capacity © = per unit cost ª • Future-proof technology • Adjunct to broad corporate NGN strategy (FTTx) • Map smoothly into core networks (fiber)
Cons
• High buildout costs • Long construction intervals
Provided By
• Cable MSOs • Fiber Network Operators • CLECs • Incumbent LECs: Verizon, AT&T, major ILECs
Source: New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
21
Backhaul Alternatives Fixed Wireless and Ethernet over Copper in Backhaul Architectures Average Cell Towers
Copper Only: EoC Opportunity
Carrier Aggregation Ring g
PSTN POP
Mobile Switching Center
High-Load Site: Near Network, Fiber Served
Fixed Wireless Link to Remote Tower Copper Only: EoC E CO Opportunity t it
Source: New Paradigm Resources Group
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
22
Carrying the Traffic: Competing p g Physical y Media Fixed Wireless (Microwave)
Pros
• No trenching costs • Lower OPEX, invariable with mileage • Scalable bandwidth • Max distance = miles, miles not limited by physical facilities • Rapid deploy & turn-up • Reuse old gear at other sites
Cons
• Spectrum costs • Capacity constraints (~1 Gbps) • Require clear line of sight • Carriers’ skill set may be low for self-provisioning • CAPEX: install antennae at cell site, aggregation
Provided By
• Fixed Wireless / Hybrid providers • Self-provisioned by wireless carriers
Source: New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
23
Carrying the Traffic: Competing p g Physical y Media Ethernet over Copper
Pros
• Underlying facilities in place: No physical buildout • Max distance = miles • Greater capacity than legacy T1s • Ethernet Eth t interface: i t f facilitates f ilit t migration i ti tto all-Ethernet ll Eth t
C Cons
• CAPEX: deploy gear at MTSO/CO and cell site • Relies R li on availability, il bilit quality lit off copper ffacilities iliti tto sites it • Smaller capacity bump than FW or fiber
Provided By
• IOCs • CLECs • Supporting role for Tier 1 carrier
Source: New Paradigm Resources Group Group, Inc Inc.
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
24
Wireless Carrier Backhaul Strategies
Providers address the flood of data demand using one of three strategies: t t i
Data Offload
• Maintain legacy T1 access for voice • Alternate access sourced for data • Maintain parallel networks initially, converge over time
Hybrid
• Maintain legacy T1 gear in place at site • T1 over Ethernet using circuit emulation for all traffic • Migrate to all-Ethernet over time
Flash Cut
• Replace legacy T1 gear at site • Flash cut to Ethernet access for all backhaul traffic
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
25
Backhaul Market 2009
SECTION 4: THE OPPORTUNITY & TRENDS
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
27
Sizing the Market U.S. Cell Backhaul Market Size (2003-2013)
Source: New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
28
Who’s Serving the Cell Sites Backhaul Provider Market Share (% of Cell Sites)
Source: New Paradigm Resources Group
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
29
Backhaul Provider Strategies Sector Tier 1 Telcos, IOC
Cable
CLEC, Fiber Network
FW Carrier
Backhaul Positioning & Strategy • Dominant legacy BH providers • Access to most sites; accumulated expertise • Leveraging fiber builds, Ethernet for new business • Targeted and Strategic Focus • Leveraging fiber plant: near neighborhoods, etc. • Competing on price, opportunistic • Lead with Ethernet Ethernet, T1 circuit emulation • Network flexibility to carry TDM, Ethernet, both • Routes concentrated in and around urban areas • Regional or National presence: one partner partner, many markets • Exploit gaps in other BH provider architectures • Ideal are neutral sites with multiple carrier collocation • Emphasize time to turn-up, turn up, scalable bandwidth
Source: New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
30
Backhaul Market Trends • Data traffic growth (= backhaul demand) keeping pace with projections • BH providers all see increases, but ILECs cede some share • Mix of copper, fiber, wireless transport used as needed and available • Long-term pressure & movement to Ethernet continues— but faces capex p tradeoffs,, carrier decision-making g • SLAs, install intervals, carrier customer service important differentiators Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
31
Additional Information & Resources
• Telecom Industry Index & Catalog • NPRG’s GsO Online e Resource esou ce Ce Center te http://reports.nprg.com • Podcasts • Webinar slides •
• Upcoming Webinars • The Ethernet Market & Providers • Cable MSOs & Business Services
• NPRG NPRG’s s Research Agenda - 2010 Informed Direction Within a Changing Landscape
© New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.
32
New Paradigm Resources Group Group, Inc Inc.. Informed direction …within a changing landscape
Thank You! New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc. 30 S. Michigan, Suite 700 Chicago, IL 60603 (312) 980-7848 www.nprg.com © New Paradigm Resources Group, Inc.