Licensing Sub Committee of Corporate Services Committee 27 January 2003 IRVINE, 27 January 2003 - At a Meeting of the Licensing Sub Committee of the Corporate Services Committee of North Ayrshire Council at 2.00 p.m. Present David Munn, Robert Reilly, Jack Carson, Elizabeth McLardy, John Moffat, and David O'Neill. In Attendance I. T. Mackay, Assistant Chief Executive, A. Fraser, Manager Legal Services, J. Kerr, Chief Legal Officer (Licensing & District Court), F. Murray, Solicitor (Licensing) and M. McCann, Administrative Assistant (Legal and Protective); and M. McKeown, Corporate and Democratic Support Officer (Chief Executive's). Also In Attendance Superintendent B. Kennedy (Strathclyde Police). Chair Councillor Munn in the Chair. Apologies for Absence Ian Clarkson, Samuel Gooding and John Reid. 1.
Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982: Taxi Numbers Limitation
Submitted report by the Assistant Chief Executive (Legal and Protective) on applications for taxi licences in respect of Zone 2 (Ardrossan/Saltcoats/Stevenston) where all licences are currently allocated. In terms of Section 10 of the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982 the licensing authority may refuse to grant applications for taxi licences in order to limit the number of taxis "if but only if, they are satisfied that there is no significant demand for the services of taxis in the area which is unmet". North Ayrshire Council, as Licensing Authority, has agreed limitations on the number of taxi vehicle licences it is prepared to grant and the Council area is divided into Zones for the purposes of these limitations. Zone 2 is the Ardrossan/Saltcoats/Stevenston area and the numbers limitation for that Zone is 83. All taxi licences within the Zone have been allocated. In September 2002 the Council received two applications for taxi vehicle licences (TL/500 & TL/501) in Zone 2. Both applications relate to taxi vehicles which are wheelchair accessible. These applications were considered by Sub Committee at the meetings held on 21st October and 11th November 2002 respectively. In both cases the Sub Committee agreed to proceed to a Hearing and to advertise the application in terms of Paragraph 2 (7) (c) of the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982.
Page 1
The applicant who had submitted both applications was present at the meeting and was represented. The Chief Legal Officer (District Court and Licensing) set out the background to the Hearing as previously intimated to the applicant. The applicant and his representative then addressed the Sub Committee in support of the applications and in terms of unmet demand for wheelchair accessible taxi vehicles in Zone 2. The Sub Committee agreed to (a) increase the taxi numbers limitation for Zone 2 Ardrossan/Saltcoats/Stevenston from 83 to 85 licences; and (b) grant applications TL/500 and TL/501. 2.
Gaming Act 1968
Submitted report by the Assistant Chief Executive (Legal and Protective) on applications received under Section 34 of the Gaming Act 1968 for permits for gaming machines. The Sub Committee agreed to grant permits in respect of the following applicants:Applicant
Machines
Brunton Miller agents for Pubmaster Ltd & Susan McNeil The Cavern Club 10a Rivergate Centre Irvine
2 machines (New)
D H Biesterfield, Solicitor for The Noble Organisation Ltd Nobles Amusements Unit 6a Rivergate Irvine
(Renewal)
3.
Exclusion of Public
The Sub Committee resolved in terms of Section 50(4) of the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973, to exclude from the Meeting the press and the public for the following items of business on the grounds indicated in terms of Paragraphs 6, 13 and 14 of Part I of Schedule 7A of the Act. 4.
Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982: Taxi Driver Licences
Submitted report by the Assistant Chief Executive (Legal and Protective) on proposed variations of licensing conditions attached to taxi driver licences presently in force.
Page 2
In terms of the procedure to deal with variations to licences, the Council as Licensing Authority is required to grant a Hearing to each licence-holder to consider any representations they may have in respect of any proposed variation to the conditions attached to their licence. 261 licence-holders, as set out in attached Appendix LS1, were cited to attend the meeting. The holder of licence TDL/685 was present at the meeting and sought clarification in respect of the application of new condition 3 prohibiting smoking in taxi vehicles. The Assistant Chief Executive was heard in explanation that this condition applied only to the times when the vehicle is being used as a taxi, and not to times when it is being used privately. The Sub Committee agreed to vary the conditions attached to taxi driver licences presently in force, as set out in the attached Appendix LS1, in accordance with Paragraph 10 of Schedule 1 of the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982. 5.
Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982: Applications for Licences
Submitted report by the Assistant Chief Executive (Legal and Protective) on (a) applications for the grant or renewal of licences; (b) issues in respect of existing licence-holders which may require a Hearing; and (c) Hearings which require to be determined by the Sub Committee. The Sub Committee agreed to dispose of these matters as indicated in the attached Appendix LS2. The meeting ended at 3.30 p.m.
Page 3
Licensing Sub Committee 27/01/2003 Appendix No LS1
Taxi Driver Licenceholders cited to attend variation of Licensing Condition Hearings Number
Reference Number
Applicant
001
TDL/348
Mr Peter Craddock 53 Eastern Avenue Largs
002
TDL/349
Mr William Hepburn 36 Mull Terrace Bourtreehill Irvine
003
TDL/350
Mr Jozef Bulik 34 Kincaidston Drive Kincaidston Ayr
004
TDL/351
Mr Thomas Thomson c/o 3 St Andrews Road Ardrossan
005
TDL/352
Mr Michael Cassidy 53 Montgomerie Street Ardrossan
006
TDL/353
Ms Lorna McCallum 20 Middlepart Crescent Saltcoats
007
TDL/354
Mr James Kelly 71 Gateside Street West Kilbride
008
TDL/355
Mr John Watt 46 Elm Park Ardrossan
009
TDL/357
Mr Patrick Dalzell 158 Clark Drive Irvine
010
TDL/359
Mr George Crichton 18 Livingstone Terrace Irvine
Page 1
011
TDL/360
Ms Barbara Richards 5 St Johns Place Stevenston
012
TDL/362
John McGaw 3 Stronsay Court Broomlands Irvine
013
TDL/364
Mr Andrew Todman 61 St Kilda Bank Broomlands Irvine
014
TDL/365
Mr Robert Thallon 20 Mansfield Way Girdle Toll Irvine
015
TDL/366
Mr John Vogwell 17 Greenhead Avenue Stevenston
016
TDL/367
Mr Lesby Lees 22 Barra Lane Broomlands Irvine
017
TDL/368
Mr John Monaghan 64 Mill Road Irvine
018
TDL/369
Mr William Russell c/o John Russell 20 Auchanshangan Drive Saltcoats
019
TDL/370
Mr Joseph Boyle 37 Parkside Bourtreehill South Irvine
020
TDL/372
Mr Patrick Cawley 7 Glebe Street Saltcoats
021
TDL/373
Mr Danny Mathieson 56 Chapelhill Mount Ardrossan
022
TDL/377
Mr William Neave 26 Camphill Drive Kilbirnie
Page 2
023
TDL/380
Mr David MacLeod 15d Warner Street Stevenston
024
TDL/382
Ms Margaret McGuire 34 Broughton Green Irvine
025
TDL/383
Mr Robert Gillespie 29E Holehouse Road Largs
026
TDL/384
Mr Terry Mulhearn 12 Moorpark Road West Stevenston
027
TDL/385
Mr James Train 52 Churchill Drive Ardrossan
028
TDL/386
Mr Stephen Clark 6 Pottery Place Kilmarnock
029
TDL/387
Mr Peter Kelly 13 Greenbank Road Irvine
030
TDL/388
Mr Douglas McGregor 17 Fintry Place Bourtreehill Irvine
031
TDL/389
Mr Robert Donnachy Top Flat, 36 Cochrane Street Kilbirnie
032
TDL/391
Mr John Dallas 6 Pladda Road Saltcoats
033
TDL/392
Mr James Norwood 2A Greenhead Avenue Stevenston
034
TDL/393
Mr David Flannigan 86 Blacklands Crescent Kilwinning
035
TDL/394
Mr Crawford Little 62 Haco Street Largs
Page 3
036
TDL/395
Mr James McGilvray 85 Glen Avenue Largs
037
TDL/397
Mr John Convery 28 Nethermiln Road West Kilbride
038
TDL/398
Mr James Dean 11 Holms Avenue Dreghorn Irvine
039
TDL/399
Ms Ann Blacklock 77 Eastern Crescent Largs
040
TDL/401
Mr Peter Mathieson 62 Jermond Drive Irvine
041
TDL/402
Mr William Logan 3 Rowan Place Beith
042
TDL/403
Mr Steven Mason 3 Montgomerieston Place Kilbirnie
043
TDL/404
Mr George Barrowman 10 Castlepark Drive Fairlie
044
TDL/406
Mr William Birrell 47 Maree Place Castlepark Irvine
045
TDL/407
Mr David Herron 37 Afton Court Irvine
046
TDL/408
Mr David McLelland 1A Weirston Road Kilwinning
047
TDL/410
Mr John Blair 22 Mount View Dreghorn Irvine
Page 4
048
TDL/411
Mr Thomas Grier 24 Woodwynd Kilwinning
049
TDL/413
Mrs Angela McKerrell 119 Greenacres Ardrossan
050
TDL/415
Mr Stephen McCreadie 13 Parkend Terrace Saltcoats
051
TDL/416
Mrs Heather McKernon 58 Wheatley Road Saltcoats
052
TDL/417
Mr Campbell Taylor 57 Bank Street Irvine
053
TDL/418
Mr Downie Livingstone 35 Alexander Avenue Stevenston
054
TDL/419
Mr Robert Black 12 Morrison Court Stevenston
055
TDL/422
Mr James Cunninghame 4 Boyd Orr Road Saltcoats
056
TDL/424
Mr Stewart McCulloch 5 Dippin Place Saltcoats
057
TDL/425
Mr Gordon Findlay 1 Highet Gardens Irvine
058
TDL/426
Mr James Morrison 13 Mull Place Broomlands Irvine
059
TDL/427
Mr Brian Mustoo 19 Holehouse Court Largs
060
TDL/428
Mr Robert Frew 1 Campsie Way Bourtreehill Irvine
Page 5
061
TDL/431
Mr Gordon Williamson 127 Glen Avenue Largs
062
TDL/432
Mrs Angela Murray 9 Laverock Drive Largs
063
TDL/435
Ms Fiona Wagstaff 19 Stair Drive Drongan
064
TDL/437
Mr James O'Halloran 2 Broomfield Largs
065
TDL/438
Mr Thomas Anderson 35 Rowanside Terrace Ardrossan
066
TDL/440
Mr Ronald Ballantyne c/o 43 Adams Avenue Saltcoats
067
TDL/441
Mr Gary Paterson 3 Ardneil Court Ardrossan
068
TDL/443
Mr William Russell 5 Pladda Crescent Broomlands Irvine
069
TDL/446
Mr John Andrew 9 Royal Avenue Largs
070
TDL/448
Mr Christopher Anderson 17 Limekiln Road Stevenston
071
TDL/449
Mr Gordon Merrilees 65 Keppenburn Avenue Fairlie
072
TDL/450
Mr David Aitken 29 The Roundel Largs
073
TDL/451
Mr Ronald Tudhope 5 Love Street Kilwinning
Page 6
074
TDL/452
Mr Ivan Gourley 39 Fleming Crescent Saltcoats
075
TDL/453
Ms Daniella McLardy 19 Coldgreen Avenue Kilbirnie
076
TDL/454
Mr William Thomson 6 Girdle Gate Girdle Toll Irvine
077
TDL/455
Mr Garry Walker 10A Titchfield Road Troon
078
TDL/456
Mr Gordon McGregor 120 Argyle Road Saltcoats
079
TDL/457
Mr Kevin Findlay 37 Oak Road Ardrossan
080
TDL/458
Ms Patricia Ross 62 Park View Ardrossan
081
TDL/461
Mr Stephen Wolohan 23A Wellpark Road Saltcoats
082
TDL/462
Mr Matthew Imrie 4 Sommerville Drive Stevenston
083
TDL/464
Mr Ian King 8e Caledonia Road Ardrossan
084
TDL/466
Mr Paul Miller 23 Bradshaw Street Saltcoats
085
TDL/467
Mr David McPherson 11 Castlepark Gardens Fairlie
086
TDL/469
Mr Stephen Noble 8 Kilmory Road Saltcoats
Page 7
087
TDL/470
Mr Glyn Morris 63 Beech Avenue Beith
088
TDL/474
Ms Barbara McKillop 31 Keppenburn Avenue Fairlie
089
TDL/476
Mr Anthony Gallagher 4 Kildonan Place Saltcoats
090
TDL/478
Ms Deborah Bell 76 Chapelhill Mount Ardrossan
091
TDL/480
Mr Alan Simpson 15 Inverclyde View Largs
092
TDL/481
Mr George Davidson 5 Ellisland Place Saltcoats
093
TDL/482
Mr Ronald Rowe 11 Glenacre Drive Largs
094
TDL/485
Mr James Blackley 1 Anderson Drive Irvine
095
TDL/487
Mr Joseph Hill 29 Holehouse Road Largs
096
TDL/488
Mr Stuart Galloway 31 Dykesmains Road Saltcoats
097
TDL/489
Mr Malcolm Shepherd 45 Lomond Crescent Beith
098
TDL/490
Mr Archibald McSwegan 77 Chapelhill Mount Ardrossan
099
TDL/492
Mrs Sandra Donald 29 Parkhouse Road Ardrossan
Page 8
100
TDL/496
Mr Colin Black 118 Chapelhill Mount Ardrossan
101
TDL/498
Mr John Sands 1 Weir Road Ardrossan
102
TDL/501
Mr Steven Glen 45 Sannox Drive Saltcoats
103
TDL/503
Mr Gordon Boyd 22 Winton Avenue Kilwinning
104
TDL/504
Mrs Marguerite Beattie 22 Churchill Drive Ardrossan
105
TDL/505
Mr Robert McDerment 74 Corrie Crescent Saltcoats
106
TDL/506
Mr Robert McMahon 43 Links Road Saltcoats
107
TDL/508
Mr John Lochhead 4 Winton Place Ardrossan
108
TDL/510
Mr Ian Harrison 1 Queens Avenue Largs
109
TDL/511
Mr Derek MacLean 60d Waterside Street Largs
110
TDL/513
Mr John McCubbin 19 Donaldson Avenue Stevenston
111
TDL/514
Mr Graeme Stewart 95 Argyle Road Saltcoats
112
TDL/518
Mr Robert Kirk 14 Linkwood Place Girdle Toll Irvine
Page 9
113
TDL/520
Mr John Hughes 44 Dalry Road Ardrossan
114
TDL/522
Mrs Christine Boyd Beulah 69 Brisbane Road Largs
115
TDL/523
Mr Alan Farrelly 55 Corrie Crescent Saltcoats
116
TDL/524
Mr Michael Crawley 14G Park Street Kilmarnock
117
TDL/525
Mrs Patricia Kennedy 20 Barrington Avenue Beith
118
TDL/526
Mr Roger Donaldson 32 Sersley Drive Kilbirnie
119
TDL/527
Mr James Monaghan 135 Sundrum Place Kilwinning
120
TDL/528
Mr Peter Danskin-Smith 33 Douglas Street Largs
121
TDL/529
Ms Carol Teevan 40 St Andrews Road Ardrossan
122
TDL/530
Ms Phyllis Gaw 12 Merryvale Road Irvine
123
TDL/531
Mr David Mill 88 Overtoun Road Springside Irvine
124
TDL/532
Mr William Bruce 72A Parkend Road Saltcoats
125
TDL/533
Mr Martin Morrison 112 Leven Place Irvine
126
TDL/534
Mr Henry Coleman
Page 10
19 Lynn Drive Kilbirnie 127
TDL/535
Mr Peter Hackett 21 Linkwood Place Lawthorn Irvine
128
TDL/536
Mr Andrew Spence The Bungalow Croftdean Farm Knockentiber Kilmarnock
129
TDL/537
Mr Robert Smith 42 Morris Moodie Avenue Stevenston
130
TDL/538
Mr Daniel Cairns 24 Central Avenue Kilbirnie
131
TDL/539
Mr George Dickson 34 Burns Street Irvine
132
TDL/540
Mr Steven Harvey 100 Chapelhill Mount Ardrossan
133
TDL/541
Mr Thomas Borland 40 Miller Road Saltcoats
134
TDL/542
Mr Michael Watson 29 Knockrivoch Place Ardrossan
135
TDL/544
Mr Roderick Carson 23a Caldon Road Irvine
136
TDL/545
Mr Terence Milligan 35 Hazlegrove Kilwinning
137
TDL/551
Mr Stanley Clugston 74 Hillside Street Stevenston
138
TDL/552
Mr Robert Gaw 4 Springside Terrace Springside Irvine
Page 11
139
TDL/553
Mr Robert Hamilton 43 Milton Road Kilbirnie
140
TDL/554
Mr Stephen Hewitt 74 Glen Avenue Largs
141
TDL/555
Mr Joseph McGuire 36 Rowanside Terrace Ardrossan
142
TDL/556
Mr William Burley 4 Station Road Springside Irvine
143
TDL/557
Mrs Judith Marshall 60 Burnside Road Largs
144
TDL/558
Mr Alexander Livingstone 2 Killoch Place Girdle Toll Irvine
145
TDL/561
Mr Rodney Speirs 30 Newhouse Way Girdle Toll Irvine
146
TDL/563
Mr John Laverty 42 Whitecraig Road Ardrossan
147
TDL/564
Mrs Margaret Imrie 48 Wallace Avenue Stevenston
148
TDL/566
Ms Andrea Adair 29 Calderpark Street Lochwinnoch
149
TDL/567
Mr Stuart Kean 25 Gateside Street West Kilbride
150
TDL/569
Mr David Tudhope 10 Keir Hardie Crescent Kilwinning
Page 12
151
TDL/571
Mr Thomas Caddis 72 Springhill Avenue Crosshouse Kilmarnock
152
TDL/572
Mr John Brown 47 Chestnut Avenue Beith
153
TDL/573
Mr James McGrath 44 Corrie Crescent Saltcoats
154
TDL/575
Mr Max Eade 12 Holehouse Road Largs
155
TDL/576
Mr William Murray 3 Lochlea Road Saltcoats
156
TDL/577
Mr Gordon Smith 43 Hamilton Crescent Stevenston
157
TDL/579
Mr Kevin McGoogan 133 Greenacres Ardrossan
158
TDL/580
Mr William Grant 3 Thistle Terrace Stevenston
159
TDL/581
Mr Alexander Lammie 16 Murray Crescent Lamlash Isle of Arran
160
TDL/583
Mr Frank McLaughlan 31 Park View Ardrossan
161
TDL/585
Mr Geoffrey Hepburn 5f Harbour Street Saltcoats
162
TDL/587
Mrs Patricia Ross 62 Dick Terrace Irvine
163
TDL/590
Mr Alexander Reid 85 Sharphill Road Saltcoats
Page 13
164
TDL/591
Mr Alexander Chalmers 42 Rowanside Terrace Ardrossan
165
TDL/592
Mr William McGinn 83 Campbell Avenue Stevenston
166
TDL/594
Ms Annette Raeburn 3 St James Place Stevenston
167
TDL/595
Ms Kirsteen McPhail 35 Glen Avenue Largs
168
TDL/596
Mr Robert McMath 99 Keppenburn Avenue Fairlie
169
TDL/598
Mr Gordon Dorrans 45 Ford Avenue Dreghorn Irvine
170
TDL/599
Mr Alexander Elliott 45 Main Road Fairlie
171
TDL/600
Mr McKenzie Davidson 15 Druid Drive Kilwinning
172
TDL/603
Mr Stewart Marston 10 Brisbane Road Largs
173
TDL/604
Mr Samuel Charles 22 Mulgrew Avenue Saltcoats
174
TDL/605
Mr James Hannah 8 Station Road Springside Irvine
175
TDL/608
Mr Colin Sturgeon 6 Knockrivoch Wynd Ardrossan
176
TDL/609
Mr Mark Henry 7 Bellard Road West Kilbride
Page 14
177
TDL/610
Mrs Maureen Denver 27 Kennedy Road Saltcoats
178
TDL/612
Mr Matthew Dobbie 10 Enterkine Square Pennyburn Kilwinning
179
TDL/613
Mr David Kirk 55 Shore Road Stevenston
180
TDL/614
Mr Andrew Wallace 24 Keir Hardie Road Stevenston
181
TDL/616
Mr Paul Payne 3 Dornoch Court Whitehurst Park Kilwinning
182
TDL/617
Mr David Irvine 1 Wheatley Place Stevenston
183
TDL/618
Mr Michael Kennedy 14 Cunninghame Road Ardrossan
184
TDL/619
Mr Laurence Sweeney 56 Cramond Way Broomlands Irvine
185
TDL/620
Mr Allan Coll 5 Annandale View Crosshouse By Kilmarnock
186
TDL/621
Mr Patrick Docherty 133 Paterson Avenue Irvine
187
TDL/622
Mr Allan McInnes 56 Blair Road Dalry
188
TDL/623
Mr Stewart Thompson 51B New Street Stevenston
Page 15
189
TDL/624
Mr John O'Donnell 44 Kinnier Road Saltcoats
190
TDL/625
Mr Anthony Needles 32 Castlepark Gardens Fairlie
191
TDL/626
Mrs Annie Lawless 10 Mansfield Way Girdle Toll Irvine
192
TDL/627
Mrs Margaret MacLeod 52 Kelvin Street Largs
193
TDL/629
Mr David Fyfe 32 Bankhouse Avenue Largs
194
TDL/630
Mr Thomas Anderson 139 Main Street Kilwinning
195
TDL/631
Mr James McLennan 8 Nelson Road Saltcoats
196
TDL/633
Ms Carol McGregor 3 Causeyway Court Fairlie
197
TDL/634
Mr Andrew Mullin 69 Seaton Terrace Irvine
198
TDL/635
Mr Alan McDowell 44 Lawson Drive Ardrossan
199
TDL/636
Mr Peter Hornell 47 Cairnsmore Way Bourtreehill Irvine
200
TDL/637
Mr Gordon Phillips 22 Churchill Drive Ardrossan
201
TDL/638
Mr John Bruce 30 Churchill Avenue Kilwinning
Page 16
202
TDL/639
Mrs Phyllis Rodden 47 St Brennans Court Kilbirnie
203
TDL/640
Mr Robert Clark 107 Montfode Drive Ardrossan
204
TDL/641
Mr John Jamieson 28 Sharp Avenue Dreghorn Irvine
205
TDL/642
Mr Thomas Burns 1 Springvale Street Saltcoats
206
TDL/643
Mr David Cameron 2 Gilfillan Avenue Saltcoats
207
TDL/644
Mrs Deborah Russell 32 McKillop Place Saltcoats
208
TDL/645
Mr Robert Milliken 47 Station Drive Springside Irvine
209
TDL/646
Mr Stephen Wright Flat 1/R, 148 Main Street Largs
210
TDL/648
Mrs Jacqueline Myers 8 Knockrivoch Gardens Ardrossan
211
TDL/649
Mr Hugh McFedries 39 Rubie Crescent Irvine
212
TDL/650
Mrs Margaret Shaw 142 St Margarets Avenue Dalry
213
TDL/651
Mr James Garven 22 Greenside Avenue Springside Irvine
Page 17
214
TDL/652
Mr Stuart Robertson 167 Glen Avenue Largs
215
TDL/653
Mr George Winters 43 Claremont Crescent Kilwinning
216
TDL/657
Mr Ronald McCulloch 22 Caldon Road Irvine
217
TDL/658
Mr John McBroom 73 Peden Avenue Dalry
218
TDL/659
Mr Steven Townsley 35 St Andrews Road Ardrossan
219
TDL/660
Mr Gordon McKellar 27 Duffield Drive Largs
220
TDL/661
Mr Steven Conway 6 Cramond Way Broomlands Irvine
221
TDL/662
Mr Robert Brown 45 Lomond Place Castlepark Irvine
222
TDL/663
Mr Brian Robinson 24 Sannox Drive Saltcoats
223
TDL/665
Mr Ronald Forbes 76 Eglinton Road Ardrossan
224
TDL/666
Mr Maxwell Russell 13 Afton Court Irvine
225
TDL/667
Mr Stephen McNamee c/o 3 Arran Place Saltcoats
226
TDL/668
Mr Robert Cambridge 17 Darg Road Stevenston
Page 18
227
TDL/669
Mr John Stevely 70 Hyslop Road Stevenston
228
TDL/670
Mr William Gamble 89 Sillars Meadow Irvine
229
TDL/671
Mr Jamie Kerr 3 Burnbrae Crescent Perceton Irvine
230
TDL/672
Mr David Wilson 33 Blackthorn Avenue Beith
231
TDL/673
Mrs Rebecca Walker 10 Park Avenue Beith
232
TDL/674
Mr Arthur McIver 62 Seamore Street Largs
233
TDL/675
Mr William Hamilton 1 Mossgiel Road Ardrossan
234
TDL/676
Mr Vincent Maxwell 35 Braeside Avenue Largs
235
TDL/678
236
TDL/680
Mr Ian Adams 69 Oaklands Avenue Irvine Mr David Simpson 15 Inverclyde View Largs
237
TDL/681
Mr Patrick Docherty 2 Moorfoot Way Bourtreehill Irvine
238
TDL/682
Mr Jeffrey Love 19 Lochcraig Court Bourtreehill Irvine
239
TDL/683
Mr Thomas McQuillan 25 Fencedyke Way North Bourtreehill Irvine
Page 19
240
TDL/684
Mr Scott McGlinchey 36 Dirrans Terrace Kilwinning
241
TDL/685
Mr James Costine 33 Ash Drive Beith
242
TDL/686
Mr Kevin Webb 38 Ardrossan Road Saltcoats
243
TDL/687
Mr Ernest Baker 31 Lamont Drive Irvine
244
TDL/688
Mr John Reid 143 Trelawney Terrace Stevenston
245
TDL/689
Mr Mark Watt 18 Castle Road Ardrossan
246
TDL/690
Mr Graham Brown 17 Argyle Road Saltcoats
247
TDL/691
Ms Elizabeth Quirk 65 Redstone Avenue Kilwinning
248
TDL/692
Mr Alexander Irvine 85 Overtoun Road Springside Irvine
249
TDL/694
Mr Harry Packham 51 Woodcroft Avenue Largs
250
TDL/695
Mr Andrew Johnston 131 Barrie Terrace Ardrossan
251
TDL/696
Mr David Tudhope 10 Keir Hardie Crescent Kilwinning
252
TDL/698
Mr Michael Thompstone 17 Kilpatrick Place Bourtreehill South Irvine
Page 20
253
TDL/699
Mr Robert Hendry 132 Chapelhill Mount Ardrossan
254
TDL/700
Mr Ian MacDonald 39 Dick Crescent Irvine
255
TDL/701
Ms Audrey O'Donnell 178 New Street Stevenston
256
TDL/703
Mr Peter Shanks 4 Huttonpark Crescent Largs
257
TDL/704
Mr Callan McKee 2 Boyd Orr Road Saltcoats
258
TDL/705
Mr William Alexander 82 Sunnyside Road Shortlees Kilmarnock
259
TDL/707
Mr George Thomson 20 Greenside Avenue Springside Irvine Irvine
260
TDL/708
Mr James Park 34 Bankhouse Avenue Largs
261
TDL/709
Mr Craig Riley The Old Byre No 6 Yonderfield Portencross West Kilbride
Page 21
Licensing Sub Committee 27/01/2003 Appendix No LS2
Part A - Applications for Licences/Renewals of Licences/Permits Type of Licence/ Applicant Ref. No
Decision
Taxi Driver TDL/924 (N)
Brian Thompson
Agreed to grant.
TDL/821 (R)
On the basis of the information before it the Sub Committee agreed to hold a Hearing in terms of Paragraph 4 of Schedule 1 of the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982.
TDL/918 (N)
On the basis of the information before it the Sub Committee agreed to hold a Hearing in terms of Paragraph 4 of Schedule 1 of the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982.
Street Trader Operator STL/O/189 (N)
On the basis of the information before it the Sub Committee agreed to hold a Hearing in terms of Paragraph 4 of Schedule 1 of the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982.
Late Hours Catering LHCL/078 (N)
On the basis of the information before it the Sub Committee agreed to hold a Hearing in terms of Paragraph 4 of Schedule 1 of the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982.
Page 1
Second Hand Motor Vehicle Dealer SHDL/089 (N)
Agreed to continue to the next meeting for further information from the applicant.
Public Charitable Collections PCC/2003
Mary B Madden for International Child Care
Agreed to grant.
PART B - Reports in respect of Licenceholders where the issues raised may require a formal Hearing Type of Licence/Ref. No
Licenceholder
Decision
TL/400
On the basis of the information before it the Sub Committee agreed to hold a Hearing in terms of Paragraph 11 of Schedule 1 of the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982.
PHCL/038
On the basis of the information before it the Sub Committee agreed to hold a Hearing in terms of Paragraph 11 of Schedule 1 of the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982.
TDL/310
To take no action.
PART C: Individual Licences where Hearings have been convened. Type of Licence/Ref No: TDL/255 The applicant having been duly cited was present at the Hearing. The Solicitor (Licensing) set out the background to the Hearing as previously intimated to the applicant. The representative of the Chief Constable of Strathclyde Police addressed the Sub Committee in respect of an objection by the Chief Constable, which was considered competent in terms of Paragraph 3 of Schedule I of the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982. The applicant then addressed the Hearing before withdrawing together with the Solicitor (Licensing) and the representative of the Chief Constable, to allow the Sub Committee to deliberate. Page 2
All parties thereafter returned to hear the Sub Committee's decision. Decision Agreed unanimously to refuse the application in terms of Paragraph 5 (3) (a) (ii) of Schedule I of the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982 on the grounds that the applicant is not a fit and proper person to be the holder of a taxi drivers licence by virtue of the convictions recorded against her. Type of Licence/Ref No: TDL/913 The applicant having been duly cited was present at the Hearing. The Solicitor (Licensing) set out the background to the Hearing as previously intimated to the applicant. The applicant then addressed the Hearing before withdrawing together with the Solicitor (Licensing) to allow the Sub Committee to deliberate. All parties thereafter returned to hear the Sub Committee's decision. Decision Agreed unanimously to grant the application for a restricted period of 1 year in terms of Paragraph 5 (1) (b) of Schedule I of the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982.
Page 3