Introduction to Swiss Tax Law

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut Introduction to Swiss Tax Law Fall Semester 2014 René Matteotti Professor of Law, Chair of Swiss, European and Inte...
Author: Edwin Thornton
0 downloads 0 Views 327KB Size
Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Introduction to Swiss Tax Law Fall Semester 2014 René Matteotti Professor of Law, Chair of Swiss, European and International Tax Law at the University Zurich and Attorney-at-Law Madeleine Simonek Professor of Law, Chair of Swiss and International Tax Law at the University of Zurich

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Fiscal Sovereignty: 3 Levels of Taxation •

Confederation: Authority in all areas in which it is empowered by the Federal Constitution  the Confederation must only levy taxes to which it is authorised by the Federal Constitution.



Cantons (26 Cantons) Authority in all areas that are not reserved to the Confederation  the cantons are authorised to levy any type of tax as long as they do not infringe upon the exclusive authority of the Confederation or upon the Federal Constitution and Federal Law.



Municipalities (approx. 2600 Communes): Authority in all areas that are entrusted to them by the Canton  the municipalities must only levy taxes within the bounds of the authority delegated to them by the respective cantonal law.

24.9.14

Seite 2

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Principal Taxes on the Federal Level Taxes on income

Taxes on goods and services

• Income tax (individuals)



Value Added Tax

• Tax on net profit (legal entities)



Stamp duties

• Withholding (Anticipatory) tax



Tobacco tax



Alcohol tax



Beer tax



Mineral oil tax



Customs duties

24.9.14

Seite 3

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Principal Taxes on the Cantonal and Communal Level Taxes on income and on net wealth • Income and net wealth tax (individuals)

Taxes on goods and services •

Tax on the transfer of immovable property (in certain cantons)



Motor vehicle tax

• Withholding tax on certain income of residents and nonresidents



Stamp duties



Dog tax

• Real estate capital gains tax



Entertainment tax

• Tax on net profit and on capital (legal entities)

• Inheritance and gift tax (in certain cantons)

24.9.14

Seite 4

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Federal Revenue

Quelle: Eidg. Finanzverwaltung, Bundesfinanzen in Kürze – Rechnung 2011, S. 7

24.9.14

Seite 5

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Principal International Agreements •

Double Taxation Treaties Wide net of double taxation treaties concluded by Switzerland (as per 1 January 2013: approx. 95 treaties on income taxes)



Bilateral Agreements with the European Union, from a tax perspective in particular of relevance

 Agreement on free movement of persons  Agreement on taxation of savings income in form of interest payments  Agreement on fight against fraud and all other illegal activities to the detriment of financial interests  Agreement on the elimination of double taxation on pensions

24.9.14

Seite 6

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Constitutional Principles of Taxation (I) Art. 127 Federal Constitution 1

The general principles of taxation, particularly the circle of taxpayers, and the object of the tax and its calculation, shall be established by statute

2

To the extent that the nature of the tax allows it, the principles of universality and equality of tax treatment and of taxation according to economic capacity shall be followed

3

Intercantonal double taxation is prohibited. The Confederation shall take the necessary measures

24.9.14

Seite 7

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Constitutional Principles of Taxation (II) • Principle of universality  Prohibition of a privileged treatment of certain taxpayers or group of taxpayers  Prohibition of discrimination and of more burdensome taxation of certain taxpayers or group of taxpayers



Principle of equality and ability-to-pay principle  Each taxpayer must contribute to the fiscal revenue of the state according to his/her economic and personal resources  Horizontal equality: taxpayers who are in the same economic and personal situations and derive the same amount of taxable income must be taxed identically  Vertical equality: taxpayers who are in different economic and personal situations and derive a different amount of taxable income must be taxed differently

24.9.14

Seite 8

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Prohibition of Intercantonal Double Taxation •

Prohibition of intercantonal double taxation: actual and potential double taxation



Principle of non-discrimination:  a taxpayer who is only taxable in a canton with a part of his income shall not be treated differently from a taxpayer who is taxable with all of his income in that canton  Applicable for both the canton of residence and the canton of source

24.9.14

Seite 9

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Harmonisation of Direct Taxes (I) Art. 129 Federal Constitution 1

The Confederation shall set out principles on the harmonisation of the direct taxes imposed by the Confederation, the Cantons and the communes; it shall take account of the efforts towards harmonisation made by the Cantons.

2

Harmonisation shall extend to tax liability, the object of the tax and the tax period, procedural law and law relating to tax. Matters excluded from harmonisation shall include in particular tax scales, tax rates and tax allowances.

3

The Confederation may issue regulations to prevent unjustified tax benefits.

24.9.14

Seite 10

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Federal Direct Tax Act Federal Law on the Federal Direct Tax of 14 December 1990 (FDTL) (Bundesgesetz über die direkte Bundessteuer [DBG], SR 642.11), regulating: •

Federal Income Tax levied on the income of individuals;



Federal Corporate Tax levied on the net profit of legal entities;



Source Tax levied on the income of certain individuals and legal entities.

24.9.14

Seite 11

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Federal Individual Income Tax (I) Subjects to the Federal Individual Income Tax – Two categories of taxpayers (I) •

Taxpayers with personal attachment  Swiss residents  unlimited tax liability (“world-wide income tax principle”) - Swiss residence (Art. 3 (1) FDTL) - Abode of at least 30 days (with gainful activity) or 90 days (without gainful activity) (Art. 3 (3) FDTL)



Exception of the world-wide income tax principle: enterprises, permanent establishments and real estate situated abroad are unilaterally exempt from income taxes (Article 6 (1) FDTL)  Unilateral exemption method with progression (Article 7 (1) FDTL)

24.9.14

Seite 12

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Federal Individual Income Tax (II) Subjects to the Federal Individual Income Tax – Two categories of taxpayers (II) •

Taxpayers with economic attachment  non-residents  limited tax liability (“source principle”) (Art. 4 and 5 FDTL)  real estate in Switzerland  permanent establishment in Switzerland  gainful activity without temporary abode  board members or directors of Swiss corporations  pensions and similar remunerations paid by Swiss institutions/insurance



Taxation of the Swiss source income



Ordinary tax assessment or withholding tax

24.9.14

Seite 13

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Federal Individual Income Tax (III) Taxable Income •



Principle of taxation of the overall net income, including: 

income from dependent and independent services (incl. compensatory income)



income from movable and immovable property



income from insurances and seniority allowances

Tax exempted are inter alia: 

capital gains on movable and immovable assets if not realised on business assets, e.g. realised on private assets (Article 16 (3) FDTL)



Inheritance and gifts; some kind of insurance payments; financial aids for low-income people (Article 24 FDTL)

24.9.14

Seite 14

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Income Tax Rates for Individuals Assumption: single person, without children, taxable income CHF 100‘000 or CHF 200‘000; tax year 2012: Taxable Income Federal income tax:

100’000

200’000

2.9 %

6.8 %

Cantonal income tax (incl. municipal income, without parish tax) • Berne 20.9 % 24.0 % • Zurich 13.8 % 18.6 % • Zug 9.8 % 11.4 % • Wollerau (Canton of Schwyz) 6.5 % 7.0 %

24.9.14

Seite 15

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Federal Corporate Income Tax (I) Subjects to the Federal Corporate Tax – Two categories of taxpayers • Taxpayer with personal attachment  Swiss residents  unlimited tax liability (Art. 50 FDTL); except of enterprises, permanent establishment and real estate abroad (Art. 52 (I) FDTL)  Registered office (statutory seat)  Effective place of management • Taxpayer with economic attachment  non-residents  limited tax liability (Art. 51 FDTL)  real estate in Switzerland  permanent establishment and enterprises (carried out by sole proprietor or partnership) in Switzerland 24.9.14

Seite 16

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Federal Corporate Income Tax (II) Determination of the taxable profit • In principle, the financial statement is authoritative for corporate tax purposes provided that the financial statement corresponds with the Swiss accounting rules • Tax adjustments to the financial statement are only allowed if expressly stated in the tax law, e.g. 

constructive dividends to a shareholder or an affiliated person



commercially unjustified expenses or depreciations



earnings not entered into the financial statement

24.9.14

Seite 17

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Corporate Tax Rates Assumption: share corporation, taxable profit CHF 100‘000 or CHF 1‘000‘000; tax year 2012; rates after tax: Taxable Profit Federal corporate tax:

100’000

1’000’000

8.5 %

8.5 %

Cantonal corporate tax (incl. municipal income and parish tax) • Zurich 18.4 % 18.4 % • Berne 15.5 % 18.7 % • Zug 4.5 % 8.8 % • Sarnen (Canton of Obwalden) 5.24 % 5.24 %

24.9.14

Seite 18

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Cantonal Corporate Income Tax – Special tax regimes (I) Holding Tax Regime - Requirements •

Corporation (share corporation, limited liability company)



Main purpose: permanent holdings in other companies



No business activities in Switzerland



Two thirds of the assets consist of participations or two thirds of the profit consist of profit derived from participations (dividends or capital gains)

Taxation



Exempt from cantonal corporate income tax, except of corporate tax on real estate



Considerably reduced capital tax rate

24.9.14

Seite 19

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Cantonal Corporate Income Tax – Special tax regimes (II) Domiciliary and Mixed Company Regime - Requirements •

Corporation (share corporation, limited liability company)



The company’s business activity must mainly be performed abroad, i.e. no or only secondary business activities in Switzerland



In principle, at least 80% of both profit and expenses must be generated abroad

Taxation •

Reduction of the tax basis: income from Swiss sources is fully taxed; income from foreign sources is only taxed at a quota of 5 - 25 % depending on the individual case



Considerably reduced capital tax rate

24.9.14

Seite 20

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Ongoing discussions with the EU European Union’s Point of View: • The privileged Swiss tax regimes are to be considered as state aid or/and harmful tax competition • Therefore, they violate the provisions of the Free Trade Agreement (FTA) from 1972, in particular Article 23 FTA • Further, the European Union demands from Switzerland to take over the Code of Conduct on business taxation  In order to settle the (political) dispute, Switzerland plans modifications of the controversial cantonal tax regimes as a part of the corporate tax reform III (“UStR III”)

24.9.14

Seite 21

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Memorandum of Understanding with EU Press release of Federal Department of Finance on 20 June 2014 “New tax measures should be in line with international standards. In return, the EU member states confirm their intention to lift corresponding countermeasures as soon as the regimes in question have been abolished. “

 Which international standards? Prohibition of state aid?  When will «the regimes in question» be regarded as abolished?

24.9.14

Seite 22

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Consultation on Corporate Tax Reform III On 22 September 2014, Federal Council started consultation on CTR III and published legislative draft. Key points: • Abolishment of cantonal tax regimes, federal tax practice re principal companies and Swiss finance branches • New regimes to be implemented • •

IP-Box (based on British model) Interest-adjusted corporate tax (notional interest deduction on safetyequity)

• Reduction of corporate income tax rates on cantonal level (falls into cantonal autonomy) • Selection of further measures to improve the tax legislation system • • • • • 24.9.14

Comprehensive rules for the disclosure of hidden reserves (step-up) Abolition of issuance tax on equity capital Adjustments to participation exemption Unlimited loss carry-forward etc. Seite 23

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

EU Code of Conduct Criteria 1. Benefits are only granted to foreigners or for transactions with foreigners 2. Benefits are completely isolated from the domestic economy so that they have no impact on domestic tax basis

Ringfencing

3. Benefits are granted regardless of actual business activity and business substance in the member country granting the tax benefits 4. Deviation from internationally accepted principles, in particular from the tax principles set by the OECD 5. Lack of transparency 24.9.14

Seite 24

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

European State Aid Prohibition Legal Basis Art. 107 Treaty on the functioning of the European Union (TFEU, ex-Art. 87 TFEC) (1) Save as otherwise provided in the Treaties, any aid granted by a Member State or through State resources in any form whatsoever which distorts or threatens to distort competition by favouring certain undertakings or the production of certain goods shall, in so far as it affects trade between Member States, be incompatible with the internal market. Art. 23 Free Trade Agreement between Switzerland and the EU (1) The following are incompatible with the proper functioning of the Agreement in so far as they may affect trade between the Community and Switzerland,(…)

iii) any public aid which distorts or threatens to distort competition by favouring certain undertakings or the production of certain goods. 24.9.14

Seite 25

Rechtswissenschaftliches Institut

Legal uncertainty regarding the European state aid rules and Code of Conduct 1. Decision of the Commission regarding the Spanish R&D regime 2008  Broad definition of royalty payments, less selective

2. EFTA-decision regarding the Liechtenstein R&D regime 2011  No selective differentiation since all companies may benefit

3. Decision of the Commission regarding Gibraltar 2013  Is already the differentiation between types of income selective?

4. Press release of the Commission regarding Luxembourg R&D 2014  Mobile companies as particular type of company?

5. Preliminary examination of the EU Code of Conduct Group regarding the UK patent box 2013  Substance requirements regarding R&D activities? 24.9.14

Seite 26