How Agriculture Can Provide Food Security Without Destroy

How Agriculture Can Provide Food Security Without Destroy... http://independentsciencenews.org/news/agriculture-can-prov... Health Environment (Un)S...
5 downloads 2 Views 426KB Size
How Agriculture Can Provide Food Security Without Destroy...

http://independentsciencenews.org/news/agriculture-can-prov...

Health Environment (Un)Sustainable Farming Biotechnology Science Media

Home » (Un)Sustainable Farming »Environment »News » Currently Reading:

Home About Independent Science News Contact us

How Agriculture Can Provide Food Security Without Destroying Biodiversity May 23, 2011 (Un)Sustainable Farming, Environment, News 1 Comment Jonathan Latham and Allison Wilson According to conventional wisdom, the Brazilian city of Belo Horizonte (pop. 2.5 million) has achieved something impossible. So, too, has the island of Cuba. They are feeding their hungry populations largely with local, low-input farming methods that enhance the environment rather than degrade it. They have achieved this, moreover, at a time of rising food prices when others have mostly retreated from their own food security goals. The conventional wisdom contradicted by these examples is that high yielding agricultural systems necessarily reduce biodiversity. Sometimes this assumption is extended to become the ‘Borlaug hypothesis’ after Norman Borlaug, the architect of the green revolution. The Borlaug hypothesis states that the preservation of rainforests, an example of biodiversity, depends on intensive industrial production of sufficient food to allow for the luxury of unfarmed areas (e.g. Trewavas, 1999). So, since Belo Horizonte and Cuba appear to have defied this logic, what is their secret? Are they succeeding in spite of their commitment to sustainability, or because of it? Or is conventional wisdom simply wrong? These pressing questions are explored in a new review, Food security and biodiversity: can we have both? by Michael Jahi Chappell and Liliana Lavalle, and published in the journal Agriculture and Human Values. A pathbreaking new approach Whether agricultural productivity and biodiversity are mutually exclusive has only recently emerged as a central question in agriculture. It follows increasing awareness, both that global biodiversity is in rapid decline, and that much of the decline is a result of industrialised agriculture . This is evident from data as diverse as increases in the number and size of ocean dead zones to declines in pollinators (Cameron et al 2011). However, as the number of those who go hungry swells, countries and development advocates see themselves as faced with seemingly impossible choices between food security and environmental degradation. Such pressures, together with the acknowledgment that the productivity of industrialised agriculture can be short-lived, have stimulated academics and others to reexamine their thinking (e.g. Tscharntke et al 2011). Perhaps the best-known attempt to rigorously evaluate the biodiversity versus food question was the International Assessment of Agricultural Knowledge, Science Technology and Development (IAASTD) . This United Nationssponsored commission was set up to resolve the competing ways forward being offered for agriculture. Reporting in 2007, the IAASTD commission left its mark mainly by pointing out that it is a mistake to think of agriculture as simply about productivity. Agriculture provides employment and livelihoods, it underpins food quality, food safety and nutrition,

1 of 7

08/12/2012 07:23

How Agriculture Can Provide Food Security Without Destroy...

http://independentsciencenews.org/news/agriculture-can-prov...

and it allows food choices and cultural diversity. It is also necessary for water quality, broader ecosystem health, and even carbon sequestration. Agriculture, concluded the IAASTD, should never be reduced merely to a question of production. It must necessarily be integrated with the many needs of humans and ecosystems. According to John Vandermeer of the University of Michigan, the IAASTD report “did conclude that food security and biodiversity could be reconciled”. Amidst discussion of many other issues that conclusion, however, was largely lost. What Chappell and LaValle have contributed, he says, is to focus specifically on the question of whether biodiversity and food security can co-exist in the same place. “They have brought together the data that can resolve the contradictions contained in both sides of the biodiversity versus food argument”, he says. Helda Morales, Professor of Agroecology at El Colegio de la Frontera Sur, Mexico, agrees. “This is a careful review of the relevant information available on biodiversity and food security.” Sustainable agriculture and productivity Yields are the first issue Chappell and LaValle considered. Surveying the scientific evidence, they find it supports the idea that a ‘hypothetical world alternative agriculture system’ could adequately provide for present or even predicted future populations. This is primarily because present and future populations do not need more food than we currently produce. But it is also because agroecological methods involve only a minor yield loss compared with the best that industrial agriculture has to offer. Indeed small farms, which they believe will have to be the basis of any future sustainable agriculture, typically yield more than larger ones. Both conclusions are accepted by Teja Tscharntke, Professor of Agroecology at Georg-August University in Goettingen, Germany. “Hunger in the developing countries can only be reduced by helping smallholders,” he says, and even in Germany, “organic farming would easily feed the population if nutritional recommendations were followed”. Sustainable agriculture and biodiversity On the question of whether agroecological methods also enhance biodiversity, the answers appear even more clear cut. While industrialised agriculture is often considered the biggest single global contributor to extinction, biodiversity of every kind is enhanced on farms that avoid industrial methods compared with farms that do not. A recent meta-analysis cited by the review put this figure at “30% more species and 50% more individuals” on agroecological farms. Chappell and LaValle found that smaller farms using agroecological methods are more biodiverse and less harmful to the environment generally. This finding was consistent over a wide range of localities, crops and production systems. Probably that is because multiple aspects of industrialised agriculture, from large field sizes to the use of nitrogenous fertilisers and pesticides, are each associated with biodiversity losses. Embedded agriculture Agriculture is a system that functions within bigger ecological, political and economic systems. Success, therefore, must ultimately be judged at that level. Chappell and LaValle consider that the two examples they studied—Belo Horizonte and Cuba—offer tentative evidence of success at a regional level. Of these two, Cuba’s commitment (and also success) appears to have been the greater. It is claimed, for example that the “capital city of Havana is now almost entirely supplied by alternative agriculture, in or on the periphery of, the city itself”. They acknowledge, however, that two examples do not prove anything except a principle. As Teja Scharntke puts it “such examples may be models for some but not all countries.” Future directions Nevertheless, say Chappell and LaValle, this all points to the conclusion that “the best solution to both food security and biodiversity problems would be widespread conversion to alternative practices.” Instead of supporting a competitive relationship “the evidence emphasizes the interdependence of biodiversity and agriculture.” Helda Morales goes even further “I would go beyond this statement and say that we cannot have food security if we do not have biodiversity”. For John Vandermeer, the uniquely holistic approach of Chappell and LaValle is the key to a consensus. “When people dispute these conclusions, it is almost invariably because they are using too narrow a frame of reference.” And it is a consensus that appears to be gaining wider attention. In December of 2010 The United Nations special rapporteur on the right to food published a document asserting that agroecology had demonstrated “proven results” and that “the scaling up of these experiences is the main challenge today.” The immediate practical obstacle, however, to choosing a food system that supports both food security and the environment is public policy. Citing Per Pinstrup-Andersen, the former Director General of the International Food Policy Research Institute, Chappell and LaValle state: “It is a myth that the eradication of food insecurity is truly treated as a high priority.” The real obstacles to ecological high-yield farming, Vandermeer believes, are research priorities and

2 of 7

08/12/2012 07:23

How Agriculture Can Provide Food Security Without Destroy...

http://independentsciencenews.org/news/agriculture-can-prov...

economics. “Industrial farming only appears to be more viable because it is subsidised.” Even though there are at present some uncertainties, “If we applied the same research efforts to agroecological approaches that we currently do to support industrialised farming, even more could be achieved.” References Cameron SA, Lozier JD, Strange JP, Koch JB, Cordes N, Solter LF, Griswold TL (2011) Patterns of widespread decline in North American bumble bees. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 108: 662-667. Chappell MJ and LaValle LA (2011) Food security and biodiversity: can we have both? Agriculture and Human Values 28: 3-26. Author Copy Pinstrup-Andersen P (2003) Global Food Security: Facts, Myths and Policy Needs. IFA-FAO Agriculture Conference. Trewavas A (1999) Much food, many problems. Nature 402: 231-2 Tscharntke T et al. (2011) Multifunctional shade-tree management in tropical agroforestry landscapes – a review. J. Applied Ecology. in press. Like

35

Tweet

Print This Post

11

0

1

Email This Post

Currently there is "1 comment" on this Article: 1.

George Naylor says: November 13, 2012 at 11:06 pm This is all true, but the authors slight the policy questions: What would the policy be? and How do we get truly democratic governments with the understanding that Food Sovereignty is the foundation of food security and democracy? I recommend the book Food Movements Unite! , Eric Holt-Gimenez, editor, which can be ordered from the Food First website. Check out my chapter 3. Thanks. Reply

Comment on this Article: Name (required) Email (required) Website

Submit Comment

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

Search

3 of 7

08/12/2012 07:23

How Agriculture Can Provide Food Security Without Destroy...

http://independentsciencenews.org/news/agriculture-can-prov...

Follow Us

Science News on the Web India, World’s Largest Livestock Owner, Balks at Farming Gas Curbs in Doha Gorham institute: Mercury in seafood more harmful than believed Palm Oil officially labelled 'sustainable' Biofuel by EU Neurobehavioral problems following low-level exposure to organophosphate pesticides Cornstalks Everywhere But Nothing Else, Not Even A Bee Organic: Food Justice for the 99% AAP Statement: Pesticide Exposure in Children Fracking Our Food Supply Fears weed killer decision a death knell for reef Science under pressure as pesticide makers face MPs over bee threat GM 2,4-D-Tolerant Crops set to Accelerate Pesticide Use From California to India the GM Battle Rolls On Answers to critics: Why there is long term toxicity due to NK603 Roundup-tolerant genetically modified maize…. Climate Change Drought Predictions Have Relied on a Simplistic (and wrong) Model Bt failure to hit cotton yield by 40%: Govt of India African Civil Society calls on the African Union to ban genetically modified crops Bottled water on Thanksgiving menu in tainted region Common nanomaterial interferes with soil fertility and is taken up by plants Organic farmers condemn U.S. report, claim it favors GMO MEPs demand better evaluation of GMOs Academics question pesticide approval US Closes Antitrust Investigation Into Seed Industry, Monsanto DuPont-Dow Corn Defeated by Armyworms in Florida Lead, poor food pose health risks for Karachi's kids Science et conscience (in French) After Halt to Planting, Court Orders Eradication of Unlawful GE Plants on Southeastern Wildlife Refuges Statement: call to action vs the planting of GMO corn in open field situations in Mexico EPA may take over enforcing water act in Iowa Scientists and farmers groups write to Supreme Court on TEC report on GM crops How Big Pork Screws Small Towns Teratogenic Effects of Glyphosate-Based Herbicides: Divergence of Regulatory Decisions from Scientific Evidence Subtle but potentially serious: health effects of low-level pesticide exposure Regulatory decisions on releasing genetically modified (GM) insects biased by corporate interests Prop. 37: Genetic food labels loses Scientists Fight Over GE Moratorium in India CRG Statement RE: AAAS Board Statement Against Labeling of Genetically Engineered Foods Big Sugar's Sweet Little Lies Why I’m Voting Yes on Prop 37: Label Genetically Modified Foods Yes: Food labels would let consumers make informed choices (Response to the AAAS from 20 Scientists) Agribusiness as Usual: The Death of Peasant Farming

Tag Cloud

agriculture agroecology biology biotechnology Bt crop crops development disease DNA ecology environment farming FDA food genetically modified genetics GM GMO maize meat medical China corn

diet

nano

nanotechnology

nutrition plant

plants pollen predisposition public

interest rice risks safety science soy study technology

transgene transgenic US USDA virus

4 of 7

08/12/2012 07:23

How Agriculture Can Provide Food Security Without Destroy...

http://independentsciencenews.org/news/agriculture-can-prov...

Switch site Switch to our mobile site

Why Independent Science News? Scientific inventions and ideas shape the future. As science becomes ever more beset by commercial and ideological pressures, there is now an urgent need for scientific reporting and analysis from an independent, expert, public interest perspective. With this as its standard, Independent Science News works to shape a future that is biodiverse, just, and healthy for everyone. More about us...

Related News Articles Synthetic Biology and Stem Cells Combined to Make the World’s First “BioTractor” New Report Links Food, Climate and Agricultural Policies Psychiatrists plead to continue funding of genetic approaches to disease 23andMe disproves its own business model Strangely like Fiction: Sponsored Academics Admit Falsely Claiming Dairy Hormone Safety Endorsements Transgenic High-Lysine Corn LY038 Withdrawn After EU Raises Safety Questions Welsh Farmer’s Defiance of GMO ‘Ban’ Not So Defiant After All US Crop Yield Increases Owe Little to Biotechnology

Commentaries How Millions of Farmers are Advancing Agriculture For Themselves

by Jonathan Latham The world record yield for paddy rice production is not held by an agricultural research station or by a large-scale farmer from the United States, but by Sumant Kumar who has a farm of just two hectares in Darveshpura village in the state of Bihar in Northern … Like

738

Tweet

147

7

59

Risk and Responsibility: Farming, Food, and Unconventional Gas Drilling

Michelle Bamberger and Robert E. Oswald (Photo credit: Marcellus Protest) Extraction of hydrocarbon gas from tight shale formations using horizontal drilling and hydraulic fracturing has been advertised as a path toward energy independence for the United States and is being promoted worldwide. This is tempered by environmental and societal

5 of 7

08/12/2012 07:23

How Agriculture Can Provide Food Security Without Destroy...

http://independentsciencenews.org/news/agriculture-can-prov...

concerns … Like

248

Tweet

60

1

36

Seralini and Science: an Open Letter

(Authors listed below) (Traduction Francaise) A new paper by the French group of Gilles-Eric Seralini describes harmful effects on rats fed diets containing genetically modified maize (variety NK603), with and without the herbicide Roundup, as well as Roundup alone. This peer-reviewed study (Seralini et al., 2012), has been criticized by … Like

1.2k

Tweet

217

20

95

Vitamin A Wars: the Downsides of Donor-driven Aid

Ted Greiner, Professor of Nutrition, Hanyang University, Korea (Photo Credit: Jon Orlando) Surely one of the most precious of human dreams is to become rich and famous by doing good for others. And what could do more good than eradicating global malnutrition? Subtle variations on that theme have muddled the … Like

80

Tweet

20

0

10

More Commentaries...

Reviews The China Study: The Most Comprehensive Study of Nutrition Ever Conducted and the Startling Implications for Diet, Weight Loss and Long-Term Health

Author: T. Colin Campbell, PhD and Thomas M. Campbell II ISBN: 1932100660, 978-1932100662 Publisher: Benbella Books (2004) What will it take for veggie stir-fry on rice to replace a beef burger on a bun as the all-American meal? A switch to a more plant-based diet has been standard dietary advice … Like

16

Tweet

0

0

1

The Unhealthy Truth: How our Food is Making us Sick and What We Can Do About It

6 of 7

08/12/2012 07:23

How Agriculture Can Provide Food Security Without Destroy...

http://independentsciencenews.org/news/agriculture-can-prov...

Author: Robyn O’Brien (with Rachel Kranz) ISBN: 978-0-7679-3071-0 Publisher: Broadway books (2009) Allergies and food intolerances are serious medical conditions. They are the cause of many deaths and hospitalizations annually and they predispose to other illnesses. They can also exact a high toll in other ways since worry, inconvenience and … Like

19

Tweet

0

1

5

More Reviews... 2012 Independent Science News - Good with Science. Subscribe (RSS) Part of the Bioscience Resource Project Except where otherwise noted, content on this site is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License. Website by WordPress

7 of 7

and Digital Marketing and Design

08/12/2012 07:23

Suggest Documents