PowerGen Asia Bangkok
October 2013
Gas Turbine multi-fuel capability for Power Generation and Cogeneration Per Johansson / Mike Welch / Brian Igoe: Siemens Industrial Turbomachinery Siemens AG 2013 All rights reserved.
siemens.com/answers
Keeping the Wheels of Industry turning Contents
Restricted © Siemens AG 20XX All rights reserved. Page 2
2013-10
• Natural Gas: the Fuel of Choice
3
• Refined Liquid Fuels
6
• Volatile Liquid Fuels
9
• Alternative Gas Fuels
12
• Mixed Fuel Operation
18
• Summary
19
Natural Gas: the Fuel of Choice Widely available, clean burning fuel
%
Forecast share of future energy market by fuel type
• Low cost • Forecasts indicate growing role of natural gas in energy generation • LNG and pipelines allow global trading
io m
as s)
oo d (n on -B
Li gn ite
oa l C
ie se l D
W W
2013-10
S
Page 3
M
Restricted © Siemens AG 20XX All rights reserved.
0.45 0.4 0.35 0.3 0.25 0.2 0.15 0.1 0.05 0
at ur al G as
• Low air pollutant emissions • Excellent fuel for Dry Low Emissions (DLE) combustors
CO2 emissions by fuel type (tonnes CO2 per MWh )
N
• Low CO2 emissions • High efficiency power generation • High efficiency Cogeneration
• Gas-rich areas are not necessarily those with high gas demands • Spot market may see gas shipments diverted to highest price markets
USD/million BTU
Growing demand, rising costs
• Countries relying on imports may see rising prices or gas shortages • Policy may decide which consumer group gets preference in times of supply shortage • Domestic consumers • Industry Variation in gas prices at major trading hubs Restricted © Siemens AG 20XX All rights reserved. Page 4
2013-10
What can be done if natural gas is not available ?
• Temporary interruption •
Liquid fuel as back-up
• Long-term interruption or non-availability of gas • Look for alternative fuels • Refined Liquid Fuels • Volatile liquid fuels • Alternative gas fuels • All these alternatives are potential fuels for Gas Turbines •
Project economics may be affected but may be preferable to complete loss of production
Restricted © Siemens AG 20XX All rights reserved. Page 5
2013-10
Gas Turbine fuel test facilities
Refined Liquid Fuels Wide range of fuels that allow continuous energy production • Dual fuel gas turbines • Natural Gas as primary fuel • Liquid fuel as back-up • Liquid fuel back-up • Typically premium refined fuel such as #2 diesel or kerosene • Automatic changeover on gas turbines between fuels • Gas to liquid on falling gas pressure • Premium refined fuels are suitable for Dry Low Emissions combustors • But premium liquid fuels are expensive • Prolonged operation will impact on operating costs Restricted © Siemens AG 20XX All rights reserved. Page 6
2013-10
Dry Low Emissions burners for the Siemens Light Industrial Gas Turbine range
Refined Liquid Fuels
Cheaper refined fuels are available • Intermediate (IF) and Heavy Fuel Oils (HFO) can be used in some gas turbines • High viscosity • High contaminants • Unsuitable fuels for most gas turbines • Suitable for Siemens SGT-500
Size comparison SGT-500 burner to aero derivative gas turbine burner
• Residual fuels 40 – 50% cheaper than diesel and kerosene • Reduced operational costs for long periods without natural gas • Also possible to use treated crude oil or refinery residual oils
Restricted © Siemens AG 20XX All rights reserved. Page 7
2013-10
SGT-500 Combustion Can
Tri-fuel capability compelling feature for order placement
EDO Cement, Nigeria • Siemens to supply 3 x SGT-500 generator sets for island mode operation in a new cement factory • Natural gas as primary fuel • But pipeline gas supplies not secure • Potential outages could last months • Tri-fuel gas turbine configuration was essential • Capability of SGT-500 to operate on cheaper HFO was key factor in order award SGT-500 Gas Turbine
Restricted © Siemens AG 20XX All rights reserved. Page 8
2013-10
Volatile Liquid Fuels
By-products from processing or refining processes that may offer a lower cost alternative to premium refined fuels • Require changes to the liquid fuel system of Gas Turbines • Need to ensure fuel stays as a liquid
Gas flaring in the Oil industry: a potential source of NGLs and LPG
• Low viscosity and lubricity require special fuel pumps • Ethanol has only 60% energy content of diesel • Greater volumes required so larger pipework, burner galleries etc
Siemens SGT-100 Low pressure LPG / naphtha burner Restricted © Siemens AG 20XX All rights reserved. Page 9
2013-10
Example installation - Volatile Liquid Fuels Naphtha-fuelled installation, Turkey • Industrial customer suffering from frequent power outages and natural gas pipeline not yet constructed • Selected naphtha as fuel for initial years of operation until natural gas became available • Chose Siemens to supply a gas turbine for a Cogeneration plant • Improved production volumes and quality due to reliable supplies of electricity and process heat Siemens SGT-100 naphtha-fuelled gas turbine
Restricted © Siemens AG 20XX All rights reserved. Page 11
2013-10
Alternative Gas Fuels
Alternative gas fuels can act as a substitute natural gas • By-products from industry • Coke Oven Gas; Blast Furnace Gas; Refinery Gas • Hydrogen-rich gases with carbon monoxide and low heating value • Naturally-occurring methane-rich gases • Landfill gas, digester (sewage) gas, biogas • Weak natural gases (methane + carbon dioxide) • Is handled with changes to DLE systems or utilizing conventional combustion systems Cogeneration plant in a Refinery
Restricted © Siemens AG 20XX All rights reserved. Page 12
2013-10
Alternative Gas Fuels Coke Oven Gas Installation, China • Coke Oven Gas (COG) mainly composed H2 and CO is a waste gas from the steel industry • Often just flared off as a waste product • Siemens SGT-200 high hydrogen fuel capability expanded to cover COG • Gas cleaning prior to turbine to remove or reduce levels of contaminants • 2 units installed with > 25000 operating hours Siemens SGT-200 configured for operation on Coke Oven Gas (COG), China
Restricted © Siemens AG 20XX All rights reserved. Page 13
2013-10
Alternative Gas Fuels Ethanol Processing Plant, China • Process produced waste biogas • 60% methane (CH4) • 36% carbon dioxide (CO2) • Wobbe Index of 21MJ/Nm3 • Biogas fuel only configuration • Siemens SGT-400 Dry Low Emissions combustor tested to prove satisfactory operation and start capability
• Cogeneration plant entered service May 2013
Restricted © Siemens AG 20XX All rights reserved. Page 14
2013-10
Siemens SGT-400 in operation on a weak gas fuel, China
Alternative Gas Fuels
University of New Hampshire (UNH), USA • Tri-generation plant with 15ppm Nox requirement • Originally envisaged to operate on natural gas with diesel fuel as back-up • Landfill gas from nearby source emerged as low cost fuel • Technical challenge is low and varying WI
Siemens SGT-300 tri-fuel DLE gas turbine
Restricted © Siemens AG 20XX All rights reserved. Page 15
2013-10
Mixed Fuel Operation
Sometimes there just isn’t enough gas…
Mixed Fuel Operation: 'Topping Up' with Liquid Fuel
• Common on Heavy Oil developments in the Oil & Gas industry
90.00%
• Siemens gas turbines have the ability to operate on two fuels simultaneously
60.00%
70.00%
Liquid Fuel %
• Use a suitable liquid fuel to compensate for a shortage of gas
80.00%
50.00% 40.00% 30.00% 20.00% 10.00% 0.00% 1%
10%
25%
50%
75%
100%
GT Load
Permissible operating envelop for an SGT-500 on mixed fuel operation where gas is the primary fuel with liquid fuel top-up Restricted © Siemens AG 20XX All rights reserved. Page 17
2013-10
Summary • Natural Gas is expected to be the fuel of choice for many years to come. • The volatility of the NG market is expected to increase, making alternatives for back-up or substitution fuels more interesting • Secure supply of energy • Optimisation of economics • Locally available ‘waste’ fuels can displace natural gas • Potentially ‘free’ or lower cost fuels • Avoid import of natural gas by using local resources to best ability • Reducing environmental impact Siemens gas turbines have the capability to meet the new requirements on dual/tri fuel operation on most kinds of gaseous and liquid fuels. Restricted © Siemens AG 20XX All rights reserved. Page 18
2013-10
Thank you for your attention Per Johansson Product Manager – SGT-500 Siemens Industrial Turbomachinery AB Slottsvägen Finspång Sweden Phone: +46 (122) 82037 Mobile: +46 (70) 203 01 71 E-mail:
[email protected]
siemens.com/answers Restricted © Siemens AG 20XX All rights reserved. Page 19
2013-10