I made this San Fran “plunge” note -‐-‐ with housing demand data out today -‐-‐ as a follow-‐up to my Miami condo crash note because it’s all the same trade. …excerpt from my 3-‐16 Miami note that applies to San Francisco as well. There is no doubt that “something happened” to momo market condo demand beginning in Q4’14. Demand in many of the hottest regions has literally fell of the proverbial “cliff” while supply under construction, pre-‐construction, and proposed is greater than in 2006. In fact, in Miami/Dade, in recent quarters, there has been a “plunge in demand” married with a ten-‐fold increase in current construction from the previous four-‐year period. Miami Beach demand has been hit especially violently. The “condo canary” was a key feature at the end of Bubble 1.0. How I see it… the 2003 to 2007 era was all about unorthodox demand (every mom & pa in America) with unorthodox capital (exotic loans) creating a wave of incremental, speculative liquidity that went away suddenly. The 2012 – 2014 era is no different, just different players; “unorthodox demand (insti’s and foreigners) with unorthodox capital (Fed, oil, and weak dollar) creating a wave of incremental, speculative liquidity” that is showing signs of going away as suddenly as it arrived due to the surging US dollar, oil market crash, and economic slowdown / corruption crackdown in China. As such, why should we expect a different outcome? In the Bay Area, it’s not just San Fran prop, but “tech heavy” Silicon Valley as well. Demand volatility is exactly what we saw at peak-‐bubble 2007 as well and demand always precedes price.
Data from DataQuick
Please see below…”3-‐16 Hanson...Miami Condo Demand Crash Update”. Thank you, Mark Hanson
[email protected]
DISCLAIMER: This message and attachments are for the sole use of the addressee and are privileged, confidential and exempt from disclosure. If you are not the addressee, copying, dissemination, or distribution of this communication is strictly prohibited. You must delete the e mail and destroy any copies. In publishing research, Hanson Advisors, MHJCL, and MAHA, Inc (the Company) is not soliciting any action based upon it. The Company's publications contain material based upon publicly available information, obtained from sources that we consider reliable. However, the Company does not represent that it is accurate and it should not be relied on as such. Opinions expressed are current opinions as of the date appearing in the Company's publications only. All forecasts and statements about the future, even if presented as fact, should be treated as
judgments, and neither the Company nor its partners can be held responsible for any failure of those judgments to prove accurate. It should be assumed that, from time to time, the Company and its partners will hold investments in securities and other positions, in equity, bond, currency and commodities markets, from which they will benefit if the forecasts and judgments about the future presented in this document do prove to be accurate. The Company is not liable for any loss or damage resulting from the use of its product. The Company is CA Corp registered in the state of CA.
Subject: 3-‐16 Hanson...Miami Condo Demand Crash Update
I am still trying to get a handle how hard the oil and currency volatility will hit “national” housing, especially considering the “Southern” region comprises 60% of all permits, starts and new home sales. It takes a while for macro events to feed into housing. But, over the past couple of months data are coming in and at early blush, it looks like about as hard as the loss of unorthodox credit hit housing demand in 2007/8.
February Miami Beach sales down 29% YoY with supply up 11% -‐-‐ 17.8 MONTHS SUPPLY! -‐-‐ can qualify as a “sudden demand collapse”. The big problem here is the same as in 2007…unorthodox demand/capital drives the market through the roof; 10s of thousands of units are under construction, about ready to break ground, or approved; and demand evaporates as quickly as it came. Of note, Vegas is having the same problem -‐-‐ supply surging/demand plunging -‐-‐ which is not surprising, as the same “currency traders” are involved with both cities and in 2007 both crashed at the same time. Condo Canary Update
There is no doubt that “something happened” to momo market condo demand beginning in Q4’14. Demand in many of the hottest regions has literally fell of the proverbial “cliff” while supply under construction, pre-‐construction, and proposed is greater than in 2006. In fact, in Miami/Dade, in recent quarters, there has been a “plunge in demand” married with a ten-‐fold increase in current construction from the previous four-‐ year period. Miami Beach demand has been hit especially violently. The “condo canary” was a key feature at the end of Bubble 1.0. How I see it… the 2003 to 2007 era was all about unorthodox demand (every mom & pa in America) with unorthodox capital (exotic loans) creating a wave of incremental, speculative liquidity that went away suddenly. The 2012 – 2014 era is no different, just different players; “unorthodox demand (insti’s and foreigners) with unorthodox capital (Fed, oil, and weak dollar) creating a wave of incremental, speculative liquidity” that is showing signs of going away as suddenly as it arrived due to the surging US dollar, oil market crash, and economic slowdown / corruption crackdown in China. As such, why should we expect a different outcome? Miami Condo Demand Collapse 1) In Miami/Dade area there are over 40k units underway or planned, greater than in 2006. This represents “years” of supply at present demand levels. 325 new condo towers proposed, with just more than 41k units. Of that, roughly
13,000 are in the planning stages, 15,000 are planned and approved, and more than 13,000 are under construction. “The vast majority of condominium demand comes from foreign buyers. Some of them, especially Russians, are seeing the value of their money drop precipitously against the U.S. dollar. South Americans are still very strong in the Miami market, but Europeans aren't far behind, and as the dollar gains strength, they too, lose purchasing power.” http://www.cnbc.com/id/102416571 At the height of the housing bubble in 2006, there were nearly 32,000 condo units underway in Miami-‐Dade County and Palm Beach County alone, per CBRE. In the past couple of years Miami/Dade absorption has been running around 20k-‐ 22k condo units per year. But, now has down-‐ticked to