Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited
Annual report and accounts 2013
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Contents 3 7
Chairman’s Statement
23
Consolidated Balance Sheet
Chief Executive’s Review
24
Consolidated Cash Flow Statement
12 15
Financial Overview
25
Directors, Committees and Other Information
Consolidated Statement of Total Recognised Gains and Losses
25
20 21
Statement of Board Responsibilities
Reconciliation of Movement in Shareholders’ Funds
26
Statement of Accounting Policies
22
Consolidated Profit and Loss Account
29 48
Notes to Financial Statements
Independent Auditor’s Report
Five Year Historical Information
1
2
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
‘‘ Dairygold Co-Operative Society remains firmly on course with its plans for sustainable profitable expansion‘‘
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Chairman’s Statement 2013 was both a busy and successful year for Dairygold Co-Operative Society and its farming Members on a number of fronts.
In the early months of 2013 the Society continued its post quota preparation with one-to-one meetings with Milk Suppliers. These were very well attended and confirmed a milk growth rate of 55% to 60% by 2020, over the 2011 base year. At the Special General Meeting (SGM) in Mallow in April, the Society’s Members overwhelmingly endorsed the Society’s Post Quota Plan giving the Society a clear mandate to proceed. The fodder crisis in the early part of the year was a significant challenge for Members, and the Society took the lead role in responding to it. The weather significantly improved from June onwards resulting in Members producing a record volume of milk and delivering an excellent grain tonnage. Buoyant dairy market returns resulted in the payment of a high milk price during 2013 and provided much needed cash flow to cover the high costs incurred in a difficult first half of the year. In November, the High Court action brought by the Society’s former CEO against Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited was satisfactorily concluded. In recognition of the very successful year the Society paid year end bonuses to suppliers and customers of €7.5 million. The bonuses comprised a 0.5 cent per litre on all contracted 2013 milk supply, a €7 per tonne rebate on all compound feed purchased during 2013 and a €5 per tonne rebate on all fertiliser purchased during 2013.
Milk Supply Agreements and Post Quota Planning A key focus for the Society during 2013 was the continued planning for post quota expansion. The ending of the quota regime in 2015 offers Irish dairy farmers the first opportunity in thirty years to increase milk production without external restrictions. In January, the Society launched a three month programme of one-to-one meetings with Milk Suppliers who were encouraged to participate fully in the consultation process, to use the meetings to evaluate their post quota plans and to understand the Milk Supply Agreement (“MSA”) fully in light of their own particular farming circumstances. Almost all Milk Suppliers participated in the one-to-one consultations and over 97% of all Milk Suppliers have signed up to an MSA with the Society. Members’ commitment to milk forecasting, as part of the MSA, will ensure the right capacity is in place to process post quota milk in a highly efficient manner. The fundamental elements of the plan are well advanced including milk forecasting, enhancing the cheese, ingredients and IMF centric product portfolio, developing routes to market and investing in processing capability. The plan also ensures the appropriate funding is available to fund the development and to allow the Society to maintain effective control over milk price.
3
4
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Special General Meeting At the SGM, in Mallow on 11 April 2013, the Society’s Members voted by an over 4:1 majority to endorse its Post Quota Plan. The Society’s Plan, combined with its financial strength, is designed to maintain a leading milk price, reflecting maximum reward for milk quality and milk solids, produced in a sustainable way. The Society’s pioneering Post Quota Plan broke new ground, in addressing issues that the whole industry is now facing, as all seek to find new ways of managing operations and the supplier/processor relationship without the certainty of milk quotas. I am confident that the plan which is both robust and flexible, will meet the challenges which will undoubtedly exist in future years, whilst also ensuring that the Society and its Members will be able to take advantage of the opportunities that the post quota era will offer.
Sustainable Dairy Assurance Scheme The Society will only be able to avail of the opportunities expansion can bring if we produce quality milk in a sustainable manner. To support this, the Society is an active participant in Bord Bia’s national Sustainable Dairy Assurance Scheme which is now being rolled out nationwide. The Scheme is a hugely positive development for the Irish dairy industry and will offer significant benefits to the Society and its Members. To demonstrate this, the Board has approved a 0.1 cent per litre bonus for all Dairygold Suppliers who sign up as participants in 2014 and successfully complete the related audit. It will be especially important in the context of meeting customers’ expectations and securing new customers and markets for the Society’s expanded dairy output post 2015. Almost all of the international food companies who are the major buyers of dairy produce have set out long term targets to enhance the sustainability of their supply chains. It will mean that the Society will have accreditation from an independent international body that demonstrates the quality and sustainability of its dairy produce right back to the farm where the milk is produced. This will complement the factory accreditations such as ISO and BRC, and CLAS accreditation for the laboratories, that the Society has already achieved.
At the announcement of Dairygold’s €33 million investment in Castlefarm were (l ro r) Bertie O’Leary, Dairygold Chairman, Jim Woulfe, Dairygold Chief Executive, Richard Bruton TD, Minister for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation, Sean Sherlock TD, Minister of State for Research and Innovation and Michael Cantwell, Head of Food at Enterprise Ireland.
Supplier Information The Society continues to support its Suppliers through the provision of advisory and other services. The latest of these supports is the Society’s new smartphone App which is available to all of the Society’s Milk Suppliers. The pioneering ‘MyMilk App’ allows the Society’s Milk Suppliers, on a timely basis, to view their milk supply volumes, composition and quality results and their Balanced Scorecard points. It also provides a secure link to their monthly milk statement and other important time sensitive information to help them effectively monitor performance.
Awards Congratulations to Milk Suppliers, Richard and Nora Fitzgerald from Mitchelstown who won the 2013 Dairygold Milk Quality Awards. The judges described Richard and Nora’s achievement as an excellent example of what good management and high standards of production can deliver. Dairygold Milk Suppliers, Richard and Nora Fitzgerald of Gortnahoun, Mitchelstown who were declared the overall winner of the 2013 Dairygold Milk Quality Awards are pictured on their farm with Dairygold Milk Advisor Frank O’Flynn.
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Dairygold Chief Executive, Jim Woulfe and Chairman, Bertie O’Leary pictured at the Port of Cork where the Society imported and distributed hay to relieve the Fodder Crisis.
Lorries coming from Rosslare Port, distributing fodder to Dairygold’s catchment area.
Dairygold Teagasc Joint Programme
Rules Review
Dairygold and Teagasc have initiated a new joint programme, which will proactively and effectively engage with all of the Society’s Milk Suppliers to help them deliver sustainable on-farm profitability aligned to market requirements. I would encourage all Milk Suppliers to participate in this programme.
The Board, the Rules Committee and the General Committee, reviewed the rules of the Society primarily in relation to categorisation of Members who trade with the Society through companies and partnerships, permitted consecutive service period and eligibility for service on the Representative Structure and related procedural issues.
Fodder Crisis The unique benefits of the Co-Operative model and ethos were clearly highlighted in late spring when fodder supplies ran short in the absence of grass growth due to the prolonged and exceptionally cold winter. The Society quickly rose to the challenge that the fodder crisis presented to its Members and led the initiative to import fodder, from the UK, Netherlands and France, which was provided to Members at cost. In excess of 700 loads, carrying over 10,000 tonnes of fodder, were shipped and distributed throughout the Society’s catchment area helping to bring much needed fodder relief to farmers in difficultly. Arranging the sourcing, transport and distribution of this quantity of fodder in such a short time period was a logistical challenge, but well executed. In addition to this, the Society also offered interest free credit on ruminant compound feed for March and April to all customers.
Open Days 2013 also saw the opening of a new chapter in the Society’s Member communications activity. At the SGM, the Board and management gave a commitment to Members to make arrangements for them to see at firsthand how the Society invests in the business.
I believe that the motions to be put before the SGM, proposing the rule changes relating to the above are equitable and necessary to ensure the ongoing development and good governance of the Society.
Board and Management I would like to thank all my fellow Board colleagues for their significant contribution, support and commitment over what has been a very busy year for the Society. I also thank the Members of the General and Regional Committees for their input and contribution to the progress we have made over the last year. I thank outgoing Board Member Liam Foley for his valued contribution to the Board over the last three years while I welcome John O’Sullivan to the Board and I look forward to his positive contribution during his tenure. I would also like to express the Board’s appreciation to Chief Executive, Jim Woulfe, for his leadership and commitment and also to his management team and all employees for their work and dedication during 2013. Finally, I thank all Members and customers whose continued loyalty is the foundation of the Society’s ongoing success.
Conclusion
As a result, the Society organised six separate Dairygold Open Days which attracted over 1,000 Members to guided tours of the Clonmel Road and Castlefarm facilities. This was a significant undertaking on the part of all involved and very positive feedback was received from Members.
As a business, Dairygold Co-Operative Society remains firmly on course with its plans for sustainable profitable expansion and I would like to thank you all for your efforts in making this possible. This is an exciting time for the Society and I ask for your continued support and commitment to ensure that we continue to deliver our goals in the years ahead.
Those who attended the Open Days had an opportunity to see the €33 million redevelopment programme underway at Castlefarm which is now being commissioned in time for peak production in 2014. This represents the successful completion of the first phase of the Society’s post quota processing expansion plan.
Bertie O’Leary Chairman
5
6
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
‘‘ 2013 milk supply was 4% ahead of 2012 and the Society received its highest ever annual volume from it Members‘‘
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Chief Executive’s Review 2013 was an excellent year for Dairygold. The year saw a record milk price paid to Members and record operating profit, continuing the strong performance of recent years.
Turnover rose to €847 million in 2013, from €731 million in the previous year, with a substantial rise in operating profit to €27.9 million from €20.9 million in 2012. The operating profit represents a 33% increase on the previous financial year. This was achieved after paying a leading milk price and €7.5 million in year end bonuses to both Members and other customers. 2013 saw the Society record its highest ever annual milk volume of 959 million litres from its Suppliers. The Society’s strong financial performance was delivered by optimising its product and customer mix and by the processing and operating efficiencies achieved following the investment in capital expenditure and continuous improvement over the last number of years. In addition, the unprecedented strong returns from international dairy markets helped the Society achieve its strong financial performance and deliver a leading milk price to Members. The 2013 financial results build on the five year trend which has seen our operating profit on core activities grow from €11.8 million in 2009 to €27.3 million in 2013. In addition, from 2008, the Society has invested approximately €140 million in the business, while reducing its net debt over this period.
€30.0
Dairygold’s 2013 Product Portfolio (milk utilisation)
Whey 71%
Casein/ Butter 33%
Cheese 38%
Whole Milk Powder 12%
€27.3
€25.0
€22.6 €18.9
€20.0
5% of the milk processed above is through collaborative arrangements
€20.6
€11.8
The projected growth is based on detailed surveys of our Members’ future milk growth intentions which indicate a desire to increase milk volume output by approximately 55% to 60% by 2020.
2009
Dairygold has led the way in terms of developing a strategy which is based, not just on anticipated global demand for output, but on the capability and the appetite of its Members to expand.
€10.0 €5.0 €0.0
The vision sees Dairygold building its business on a core cheese and IMF ingredients product portfolio, growing incrementally through an appropriately financed modular investment plan which will support both volume and margin growth.
IMF Skim/Butter 17%
Operating Profit 1m
€15.0
The Society can look forward to continued growth in turnover and profit together with a leading milk price reflecting maximum reward for milk solids produced by Dairygold’s farmers in a sustainable and quality assured manner.
2010
2011
2012
2013
Post Quota Strategy 2013 represented a key milestone for Dairygold’s Post Quota Strategy. At the SGM in April, the Strategy was endorsed by the Members who voted overwhelmingly in favour of the Society’s Post Quota Plan with its central objectives to maximise Members’ returns, minimise risk and ensure sustainable business growth. The conclusive endorsement gave the Society the backing to move forward and continue to build on the achievements of recent years.
7
8
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
The Society’s Milk Supply Agreement (“MSA”), with forecasting at its core, is a key element of the Post Quota Strategy to ensure returns are maximised and risk is minimised. A key focus of the Plan in 2013 and 2014 is the continued development of the enhanced routes to market, including building strategic customer relationships, both independently and in conjunction with the Irish Dairy Board, for the additional dairy products that the incremental milk volumes will produce. Our objective, at all times, is to maximise the commercial equation, in a sustainable way. A key enabler to increasing our routes to market is the national Sustainable Dairy Assurance Scheme, which will assure customers of the advantages of our product offering as they seek independent verification that we offer high quality, sustainably produced dairy products.
Dairy Markets Global milk supplies in 2013 did not grow in line with forecast, primarily due to adverse weather events in many of the major dairy production and exporting regions. The knock on consequence saw sharp price increases, which coincided with our milk production season. This is further proof that dairy market returns are cyclical in nature and will continue to experience price volatility which farmers and processors need to be aware of. Dairygold Market Returns/Milk Price Tracker 2008 to 2013 40
Dairygold Quoted Milk Price incl VAT @ 3.3% Protein and 3.6% Butterfat
38
38.1
36 34
33.6
33.4
CPL
32 7 Year Average Price 31.5 CPL
30 28 26 24 22 20
21.8 2008
2009
2010
Year
2011
2012
Food Ingredients Ireland The Irish Dairy Business had a very successful year and was a key contributor to the Society’s overall improved financial performance. On this basis, the Society declared a year end milk bonus of 0.5 cent per litre on all contracted 2013 milk supply. Milk supply was 4% ahead of 2012 and the Society received its highest ever annual volume of 959 million litres from its Members. While good weather from mid-year onwards was a contributing factor, the growth pattern also offers a good indication of our Milk Suppliers’ desire for expansion. January 2013 saw work begin on the €33 million investment to develop and expand our Castlefarm facilities. New milk intake bays and a new pasteurisation and separation plant have been completed and internal work is nearing completion on the new evaporator, dryer and an automated centralised bag off. The support we received from Enterprise Ireland for this development has enabled us to improve the energy efficiency and environmental performance of the site. The second phase involving the development of our existing site in Mallow is underway. This will see the development of new state-of-the-art milk drying facilities capable of producing the full range of milk powders, up to and including, infant milk formula. The Mallow development continues the Society’s modular approach which aligns expansion with forecasted milk volume growth and separates the proposed investment into a number of stages. The initial installation of a 7½ tonne per hour dryer and associated infrastructure in 2015 will be fully operational in 2016.
30.9
29.4
Notwithstanding this, the long-term outlook for dairy products globally is positive, driven by population growth, higher incomes and increased urbanisation, combined with changes in eating habits. The developing regions of the world are in milk deficit. For example, China is only 80% self-sufficient in milk and its whole milk powder imports increased from 50,000 tonnes to over 600,000 tonnes in the five years from 2008 to 2013. The Society is targeting emerging markets, such as Asia, Middle East and Africa, for its additional product, post quota.
2013
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
During the spring, with limited grass growth, Dairygold’s mill in Lombardstown produced a record weekly average of 8,800 tonnes in the March/April period. In addition, fertiliser sales were also significantly up. Those early months were a very expensive period for milk and beef production. In recognition of this, the Board declared a feed rebate to its Members of €7 per tonne on all compound feed purchased in 2013 plus a fertiliser rebate of €5 per tonne on all fertiliser purchased in 2013.
Agri Retail
Sarah Moore, Raheen Co-Op Superstore.
Member milk forecasting will continue to determine the timing and extent of the investment required in the business. Milk Suppliers’ volume forecasting will ensure the Society operates at optimum efficiency from a processing capacity and marketing perspective.
Food Ingredients Overseas Our overseas dairy businesses performed well and in line with expectations, despite being challenged by higher raw material costs as a result of increased dairy commodity prices. The main challenge for the businesses was to recover these higher raw material costs from the competitive food manufacturing and food service sectors in the main markets of the United Kingdom and Mainland Europe. The UK business, based in Crewe and Leeds performed well, despite the increased raw material price challenges and difficult market environment. The business continues to be a leading supplier of a range of formatted and soft cheeses to the UK’s ready meals and food manufacturing sectors. In a competitive business environment, innovation is critical and the UK business continues to develop technical solutions in order to provide its customers with value offerings. The French business, following its restructuring in late 2012, delivered an improved performance in 2013. The business, which now focuses on cheese powders, is projected to continue to grow and contribute to the overall financial performance of the Society. Dairygold Germany provides a key sales distribution network for the Society’s Irish dairy ingredients sales to Central and Eastern Europe. In addition, its cheese sales to the industrial, food service and retail sectors continue to grow and deliver in line with expectations. Dairygold‘s sales office in Spain continues to develop market opportunities in Southern Europe, the Middle East and North Africa for the Society’s Irish dairy ingredients.
Agri Operations 2013 was a very successful year for Agri Operations. Difficult farming conditions created unprecedented demand for feed, with ruminant feed sales, which reached record levels, up significantly on 2012.
Dairygold’s Agri Retail Business performed well in 2013, with turnover ahead of expectations. Despite continued weak consumer confidence in the general economy, higher demand for agri inputs from our traditional Co-Operative customer base resulted in a positive year for the business. We are currently investing in the development of a new e-commerce sales and distribution channel for Agri Retail which will provide our customer base with an alternative way to do business with the Society. The business still has challenges and with the advancement of IT technology and distribution systems, it is imperative that we examine and evaluate alternative options that fulfil our customer needs.
Subsidiaries, Joint Ventures and Associates Munster Cattle Breeding Group Limited had another successful year, despite the weather related challenges in the early part of 2013. The key highlight for the year was the opening of the new Bull Stud facility at its headquarters in Ballyvorisheen, Mallow, which is being operated by the National Cattle Breeding Centre.
9
10
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
This is a positive development for the animal breeding industry and particularly important from a biosecurity and animal welfare perspective. In 2013, Dairygold and Glanbia acquired the IAWS shareholding in the Malting Company of Ireland Limited. This resulted in the Malting Company of Ireland Limited becoming a 50:50 joint venture owned by Dairygold and Glanbia. This protects Dairygold’s grain suppliers’ interests in an added value route to market for premium Irish barley.
Reox In November 2013, the Board of Dairygold and the independent Directors of Reox Holdings plc (“Reox”) reached an agreement which sees Dairygold acquiring Reox’s property assets in a “Debt for Asset” transaction which was completed on 31 March 2014. The Reox property assets, having a net book value of €24 million as at 30 June 2013, were acquired in return for the release of the €16 million loan note and certain legacy property related liabilities owed by Reox to Dairygold, plus a cash payment of €0.5 million from Dairygold to Reox. This transaction is in the best interests of Dairygold as it further strengthens the Dairygold organisation, finally removing the financial exposure to Reox and allowing it to focus on dairy and agri business growth and Post Quota Strategy.
Continuous Improvement and People Development Our post quota expansion plans are critically dependent on our ability to maintain the competitive position which our current cost structure has given us. Competitiveness will be the key to Dairygold’s success in achieving profitable growth and our focus in that regard is unwavering. In relation to this, our Continuous Improvement Programme (Advance 2020) is a priority in giving our organisation the competitive edge it needs, to take full advantage of the opportunities that the post quota era offers. In 2013, sixteen Dairygold managers completed an intensive one year diploma programme in High Performance Leadership, delivered by the Irish Management Institute in conjunction with University College Cork. These graduates are the first group of Dairygold employees to have completed this one year programme tailored for business development and growth. A further sixteen managers are participating in this year’s programme. The business recognises that people development is a key requirement to deliver on the future strategy of the Society and these programmes are one of many key initiatives, which will help in delivering this.
Member Relations 2013 was a year of intensive interaction between the Society and its Members, which commenced with the one-to-one discussions with Milk Suppliers on their future milk supply intentions, which provided both parties the opportunity to discuss the post quota era. This was followed by the SGM, where more than 2,000 Members attended and engaged in debate on the expansion strategy. In the days following the SGM, the Society became acutely aware of the fodder crisis which was looming and led the initiative on importing fodder to meet our Members’ needs at a time of great challenge on farms. We committed to establishing ever closer links with our Members and a series of open days in September were arranged for Members to visit the new and expanding dairy facilities in Mitchelstown. This widespread engagement is an essential aspect of the core ethos of the Society with Members, Suppliers and management engaged with each other on an ongoing basis.
A Word of Thanks 2013 represented a year of intensive work for all involved in the Dairygold business. The progress we have made across strategic, operational and financial fronts was achieved through the committed effort of a lot of people. On a personal level, I wish to thank the Membership of the Regional and General Committees, the Chairman and the Board for their support during the year. I want to thank Government Agencies including Enterprise Ireland and the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine and our Banking Syndicate, whose support is vital for our business growth plan. Finally, I wish to thank our customers, suppliers and shareholders for their contribution to our 2013 success. I also wish to express special thanks to my management colleagues and all employees, for their full commitment to the Society in 2013.
Summary In summary, the Dairygold business is in good shape and primed for growth ready to meet our Member Suppliers’ expectations. A thought out strategy combined with our strong financial position will enable us to deliver on our goal, which is to maximise our Member Suppliers’ income from farming, by maximising the value we add to current and future milk and grain supply and by minimising the cost of farm inputs, while growing the Net Asset Value of the Society.
Jim Woulfe Chief Executive
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Dairy Expansion Phase 1 - Castlefarm Development 2013/2014
11
12
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Financial Overview 2013 has been a very successful year for Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited, continuing the financial and operational progress made over the last number of years. The Society generated a record Operating Profit of €27.3 million (after paying a leading milk price and declaring year-end bonuses of €7.5 million) from its core activities in 2013.
2013 Key Financials
Dairygold generated an Operating Profit for the year from its core dairy and agri business activities of €27.3 million after declaring year-end bonuses of €7.5 million.
Dairygold’s net asset value increased by €22.6 million to €273.8 million.
Dairygold invested a total of €32.1 million of cash in capital expenditure in 2013.
The Society’s bank debt position increased by €4.1 million, to €60.9 million, at the end of 2013, with Member funding contributing €5.2 million.
Dairygold secured its investment in Reox Holdings plc, through the completion of a “Debt for Asset” transaction on 31 March 2014.
Profit and Loss Account The overall Operating Profit of €27.9 million (2012: €20.9 million) increased by €7.0 million, including the share trading performance of €0.6 million (2012: €0.3 million). The increase in the Operating Profit on core activities of €6.7 million was principally due to continued: – product and customer mix optimisation. – processing and operating efficiencies following the investment in capital and continuous improvement over the last number of years. Turnover in 2013 increased by €116.2 million compared with 2012, from €731.2 million to €847.4 million. The increase was driven across the Society, with: – Dairygold Food Ingredients’ sales volumes increasing together with the benefit of a significant increase in dairy market returns; – Dairygold Agri Business achieving increased revenue, primarily through higher ruminant feed and fertiliser volumes and retail store sales.
The share of joint ventures’ and associates’ performance was an operating loss of €64,000 in 2013 (2012: loss of €12,000). In order to reflect the increase in the share price of One51 plc, a reversal of the 2012 financial asset impairment of €1.8 million occurred. Net interest payable was €2.0 million (2012: €2.2 million). Bank interest payable of €4.5 million (2012: €4.7 million) was partially offset by a finance credit of €2.5 million (2012: €2.5 million). The taxation charge for the year of €2.1 million (2012: €2.5 million) relates primarily to corporation tax on profits, partially offset by a deferred tax credit. Profit after taxation for the financial year was €25.6 million (2012: €14.4 million) and the retained profit was €24.0 million (2012: €12.6 million) after paying share interest of €1.2 million (2012: €1.2 million) to Members. The increase in retained profit primarily reflects the higher operating profit and the reversal of the financial asset impairment.
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Balance Sheet In 2013, the net asset value of the Society’s Consolidated Balance Sheet increased by €22.6 million to €273.8 million. The increase primarily reflected the retained profit for the year of €24.0 million, an increase in minority interest of €0.4 million and net shares issued of €0.3 million. These were partially offset by the negative impact of currency movements on net investments of €1.3 million, a decrease in the pension asset accounted for through reserves of €0.8 million and decreases in the share of joint ventures’ and associates’ reserve movements of €0.1 million. Fixed assets of €239.5 million comprising tangible assets, intangible assets and financial assets, increased by €18.9 million, from €220.6 million primarily as a result of: – capital expenditure investment of €40.4 million; – an increase in the value of quoted investments of €2.0 million; – an increase in the share of joint ventures’ and associates’ net assets of €0.2 million.
These increases were partially offset by: – depreciation and amortisation charges of €19.5 million, – impairment of tangible assets and disposals of €0.2 million, – a transfer in the loan note of €3.0 million to current assets, – a net reduction in loan stock of €0.7 million, and – the impact of negative currency movements of €0.3 million. Net current assets less creditors falling due after more than one year of €39.5 million (2012: €39.9 million) were down €0.4 million, primarily as a result of: – an increase in stocks of €20.9 million to €109.5 million, – an increase in debtors of €19.8 million to €120.4 million, – an increase in creditors (excluding bank debt) of €37.1 million to €129.5 million, and – an increase in bank debt of €4.1 million to €60.9 million. The net pension asset increased by €1.8 million driven by an improvement in the asset returns, reductions in the assumptions surrounding inflation, payroll and pension payment increases, partially offset by a reduction in the discount rate of 0.2%. The capital grants’ liability of €8.3 million decreased by €1.4 million as a result of the amortisation credit for the year. The deferred tax liability of €0.1 million decreased by €1.0 million from 2012. The share capital increased by €0.3 million to €93.4 million, reflecting shares issued of €1.8 million less shares redeemed of €1.5 million.
The revenue reserves increased by €21.8 million to €169.7 million, resulting from the retained profit for the year of €24.0 million, partially offset by the negative impact of currency movements on net investments of €1.3 million, the actuarial loss on the pension asset of €0.8 million and a reduction in the share of associates’ reserves of €0.1 million.
Cash Flow The net cash outflow of €3.1 million during 2013 and a negative non cash movement of €1.0 million are the drivers of the increase in bank debt of €4.1 million to €60.9 million at 31 December 2013. The net cash outflow of €3.1 million results from: the investment in the business of €32.1 million primarily relating to investment in capital expenditure. increased working capital requirements of €12.1 million, resulting primarily from increased debtors balances and stock reflecting the increased dairy market prices, partially offset by an increase in creditors. payments of €10.0 million to cover net finance costs, taxation, pension contributions, share redemption and share interest. EBITDA of €46.0 million, which was generated from the business (incorporating a profit of €0.6 million from share trading). Member funding receipts in relation to revolving fund and loan notes of €5.2 million, inclusive of interest.
Pension An actuarial valuation of the pension scheme was undertaken in 2013. This confirmed that the pension scheme met the Minimum Funding Standard as at the valuation date, 01 January 2013. However, given the current challenges around financial markets and pension schemes in general, the Society will keep the scheme under review on an on-going basis. The net pension asset, based on the FRS 17 valuation as at 31 December 2013, was €3.2 million, compared to an asset of €1.4 million in 2012. The increase was driven predominantly by an improvement in the asset returns, reductions in the assumptions surrounding inflation, payroll and pension payment increases, partially offset by a reduction in the discount rate of 0.2%.
13
14
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Dairygold Headquarters, Clonmel Road, Mitchelstown, Co. Cork
Based on FRS 17 the pension scheme continues to have sufficient assets to meet future liabilities and continues to be adequately funded.
Financial Assets The Society’s investment portfolio, managed in conjunction with a third party investment manager, had a market value of €34.7 million including ARYZTA AG at €23.5 million (€56.38 per share), FBD at €0.9 million (€17.39 per share) and One51 plc at €2.5 million (€0.65 per share) as at 31 December 2013. The investment portfolio was carried on the Society’s Balance Sheet at cost, less any impairment provision, at €8.9 million (2012: €7.0 million) as at 31 December 2013.
Member Funding In addition to the €1.8 million shares issued, in 2013, through the minimum shareholding mechanism, the Society received €1.6 million of loan notes and €3.6 million in revolving fund contributions, both inclusive of interest. This member funding compliments the Society’s bank funding in delivering the Society’s business growth and development strategy.
Post Balance Sheet Events On 31 March 2014, the Society completed a “Debt for Asset” transaction with Reox Holdings plc. Dairygold acquired the Reox property assets with a net book value of €24 million in return for releasing both a €16 million loan note and the indemnity associated with certain legacy property related liabilities, plus a cash payment of €0.5 million from Dairygold to Reox. This transaction eliminates the Society’s financial exposure to Reox, as the Society has received assets in exchange for an unsecured loan note, thereby strengthening the Society’s Balance Sheet.
Conclusion and Outlook The Society has delivered a very positive financial performance in 2013, with all businesses contributing to this improved performance. The Society is in a strong financial position as it prepares to take advantage of the opportunities that the post quota era will provide and to grow and develop the business in a sustainable manner.
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Directors, Committees and other information
The Dairygold Board of Directors and Officers Back row, l to r: John O’Sullivan, Thomas Feeney, John Malone, Richard Hinchion, Patrick O’Keeffe, John F. O’Gorman and Donal Buckley. Front row, l to r: Edmund C. Lynch, Dan Flinter, Jim Woulfe (Chief Executive), Bertie O’Leary (Chairman), James Lynch (Vice Chairman), Eamonn Looney (Secretary) and John McKeogh.
Board of Directors Bertie O’Leary (Chairman) James Lynch (Vice Chairman) Donal Buckley Thomas Feeney Dan Flinter Richard Hinchion Edmund C. Lynch John Malone John McKeogh John F. O’Gorman Patrick O’Keeffe John O’Sullivan
15
16
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Senior Management Team
Jim Woulfe
Michael Harte
Tim Healy
Chief Executive
Chief Financial Officer
Head of Dairygold Food Ingredients, Ireland
Chris Edge
Sean O’Sullivan
John O’Carroll
Head of Dairygold Food Ingredients, UK and Europe
General Manager Agri Operations
General Manager Agri Retail
Eamonn Looney
Adrian Beatty
Secretary
Head of Human Resources
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Other information Chief Executive
Secretary
Auditor
Jim Woulfe
Eamonn Looney
Deloitte & Touche, No. 6 Lapp’s Quay, Cork.
Registered Office
Principal Bankers
Clonmel Road, Mitchelstown, Co. Cork.
Allied Irish Banks plc Bank of Ireland HSBC Bank plc Rabobank Ireland plc Ulster Bank Ireland Limited
Board Committees The Board has established a committee structure to assist it in the discharge of its responsibilities in compliance with the highest standards of corporate governance. The committees and their membership are detailed below. All committees of the Board have written terms of reference dealing with their role and authority delegated by the Board. The Secretary of the Society acts as secretary to each of these committees.
Audit Committee
›
monitoring the integrity of the financial statements of the Society and reviewing significant financial reporting judgements contained in them;
›
reviewing the annual financial statements before submission to the Board;
›
monitoring and reviewing the operation and effectiveness of the internal audit function;
›
considering and making recommendations to the Board in relation to the appointment, reappointment and removal of the external auditors and terms of engagement of the external auditors;
›
approving the remuneration of the external auditors for statutory audit work and ensuring that the level of fees is appropriate to enable an adequate audit to be conducted. Reviewing the extent of any non-audit services and related fees;
Arthur Cox McCann Fitzgerald
›
assessing annually the independence and objectivity of the external auditors and the effectiveness of the audit process, taking into consideration relevant professional and regulatory requirements and the relationship with the auditors as a whole, including the provision of any non audit services;
›
reporting to the Board on the operation of the Society’s system of internal control and risk management, making any recommendations to the Board thereon;
›
reviewing the arrangements by which employees of the Society may, in confidence, raise concerns about possible improprieties in matters of financial reporting or other matters and ensuring that these arrangements allow proportionate and independent investigation of such matters and appropriate follow up action;
›
reviewing its own effectiveness as a committee and making any necessary recommendations for change to the Board.
The Audit Committee comprises Messrs Dan Flinter (Chairman), Edmund Lynch, John McKeogh and Patrick O’Keeffe. The Chief Executive, Chief Financial Officer, Head of Internal Audit, other Directors, Senior Management and representatives of the external auditors may be invited to attend all or part of any meeting. The role and responsibilities of the Audit Committee are set out in its written terms of reference and include:
Solicitors
The key activities undertaken by the Committee during 2013 under its Charter were as follows:
Financial Reporting The Audit Committee reviewed the statutory accounts of the Society and following the appropriate engagement with the external auditors, recommended their adoption by the Board. Risk Management and Control The Audit Committee continued to review the risk registers for the Society on a rolling basis during 2013. It considered the reports of the internal audit department which formed part of the annual work plan of that function and which had been approved by the Audit Committee. The focus of the work of the internal audit department was reviewed by reference to best practice externally.
17
18
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
External Audit The Audit Committee reviewed the report of external audit on the processes they have in place to ensure their independence and objectivity. The remuneration of external audit was approved by the Audit Committee. The Audit Committee reviewed the external audit plan and subsequent findings from the annual audit. The Audit Committee reviewed external audit’s management letter and management’s response.
General Committee
A policy is in place governing the use of external audit for non-audit services. The policy of the Society is that the services of the external auditor may be used for non-audit services provided that those services are not in conflict with auditor independence and where there are sound commercial reasons to so use them.
Remuneration Committee The Remuneration Committee comprises Messrs John Malone (Chairman), James Lynch, John F. O’Gorman and Bertie O’Leary. The role and responsibilities of the Remuneration Committee are set out in its written terms of reference. The principal responsibilities of the committee are to: ›
›
›
determine the policy for the remuneration of the Chief Executive, Secretary and Direct Reports to the Chief Executive as well as the Society’s policy on remuneration and or expenses payable to members of the Board, members of the Regional Committees, General Committee and members of any sub committee established from time to time; review and sanction new or amended salaries, incentive bonus, retirement benefit and or other benefits for Senior Executives of the Society whose remuneration is to be determined by the committee; agree the policy and or procedures for authorisation of claims for expenses of Senior Executives, the Board, and members of the Regional Committees, General Committee and any other sub committee established from time to time.
MALLOW
TIPPERARY
Mr. Donal Buckley
Mr. Ciaran McGrath
Mr. Vincent Buckley
Mr. Eamonn Morrissey
Mr. Michael Duane
Mr. John F. O’Gorman
Mr. John Fitzgerald
Mr. Michael Tobin
Mr. John Hedigan
Mr. Michael Tuohy
Mr. John Kenny Mr. Finian Magner Mr. Timothy McSweeney Mr. Michael O’Hanlon
Mr. Liam Lane
Mr. Andrew O’Keeffe
Mr. Patrick D. Lehane
Ms. Elizabeth Sheehan
Mr. Edmund C. Lynch
Mr. Donal Shinnick
Mr. Patrick Millerick
Mr. Peter Twomey
Mr. Sean O’Brien Mr. Barry O’Connor
MITCHELSTOWN
The Rules Committee comprises Messrs Bertie O’Leary (Chairman), James Lynch, John F. O’Gorman and Patrick O’Keeffe. The principal responsibilities of the committee are to: ›
›
›
18
review the rules of the Society on a periodic basis to ensure they are consistent in their application and aligned to the Society’s strategic objectives. advise and make recommendations in conjunction with the General Committee, as necessary, to the Board of the Society with regard to any alterations or amendments required to the rules. make recommendations on policy matters, to the Board of the Society, in relation to the implementation of the rules.
Mr. Timothy O’Leary Mr. John O’Sullivan
Mr. Patrick Clancy Mr. John W. Coughlan Mr. Robert Drake
LIMERICK
Mr. Thomas Feeney
Mr. Maurice Curtin
Mr. John A. Fox
Mr. William Hickey
Mr. Michael Gowen
Mr. Daniel Hogan
Mr. Philip Leahy
Mr. John Hough
Mr. Martin O’Doherty
Mr. Roger Keogh
Mr. Patrick O’Keeffe
Mr. James Lynch
Ms. Mary Twomey-Casey
Mr. John McKeogh Mr. Gerard O’Dwyer
MID-CORK Mr. Patrick Ahern Mr. John Bernard Mr. Donal Creedon Mr. Jerome Desmond
Rules Committee
CORK/EAST CORK
Mr. Brendan Hinchion Mr. Richard Hinchion Mr. Donal F. Hurley Mr. John Joe Kelleher Mr. Sean MacSweeney Mr. Don McSweeney Mr. Michael Murphy Mr. Gerard O’Connell Mr. Daniel P. O’Donovan Mr. Bertie O’Leary Mr. Cornelius O’Riordan
Mr. David Woulfe
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Regional Committees AGHABULLOGUE/ RYLANE Mr. Patrick Ahern Mr. Edward Twomey AHADILLANE Mr. Donal Barrett Mr. Patrick Sexton ALLENSBRIDGE Mr. Cornelius Murphy ANGLESBORO Mr. William Bourke ANNACOTTY/ BIRDHILL/KILLALOE Mr. Michael Caplis Mr. John McKeogh Mr. Laurence McNamara ARAGLEN Mr. Thomas Feeney Mr. Patrick O’Donoghue ARDAGH/OLDMILL Mr. Denis Hayes Mr. John Hough Mr. David Woulfe ARDFINNAN Mr. Shane Mason BALLINAMONA Vacancy BALLINDANGAN Mr. Martin O’Doherty Mr. Patrick O’Keeffe BALLINGEARY Mr. Sean O’Sullivan BALLINHASSIG Mr. James Crowley Mr. Michael Murphy BALLYCLOUGH Mr. Donal Buckley Mr. Martin O’Brien Mr. Andrew O’Keeffe BALLYHOOLY Mr. Philip Leahy Mr. Jeremiah Lenihan
BAWNMORE Mr. Cornelius O’Riordan BENGOUR Mr. Patrick O’Driscoll BERRINGS/DRIPSEY Mr. Denis B. O’Mahony Mr. John Walsh BLACK ABBEY/ KILDIMO Mr. Patrick O’Brien Mr. Seamus O’Riordan Mr. Michael Reidy BOHERLAHAN Mr. Joseph Tobin Mr. Michael Tuohy BUNRATTY Mr. James Lynch Mr. Kevin McInerney BUTTEVANT/ TEMPLEMARY Mr. Denis O’Connell Mr. Donal Shinnick Mr. Ian Wharton CAHIR Mr. Thomas Marnane Mr. Michael Tobin CAPPAMORE Mr. Sean Meehan CARRIGALINE Mr. John Bernard Mr. Patrick Foott Mr. Jeremiah McCarthy Mr. Gerard O’Connell CARRIGNAVAR Vacancy CASTLETOWNROCHE/ KILLAVULLEN Mr. Henry Fitzgerald Mr. Finian Magner Vacancy CAUM/MACROOM Mr. Michael Murphy
BALLYLOOBY Mr. Stephen Keating Mr. Eamonn Morrissey
CHURCHTOWN / LISCARROLL Mr. John Hedigan Mr. Michael Mangan
BALLYMAKEERA Mr. Daniel Hallissey Mr. Bertie O’Leary
CLOGHEEN Mr. John Flynn Mr. John F. O’Gorman
BALLYPOREEN Mr. Patrick M. Clancy Mr. Michael Sweeney
CLONDROHID Mr. Finbarr O’Connell Mr. Stephen Roche
BALLYRICHARD/ COBH Mr. Anthony Barry Mr. Andrew Bird Mr. Patrick O’Donovan Ms. Martina O’Neill Mr. Thomas Russell Vacancy
CLOVERFIELD/ CORELISH Mr. Sean O’Brien COACHFORD/ KILCOLMAN Mr. Denis Finnegan Vacancy
C.M.P. Mr. Timothy Cashman Mr. Patrick D. Lehane Mr. James Murphy Mr. Donal O’Brien Mr. Timothy O’Leary Mr. John O’Sullivan Mr. Flor Riordan CORROGHURM/ MITCHELSTOWN Mr. Patrick Condon Mr. Martin Fox Mr. David Kent Jnr Mr. Eamonn O’Brien Mr. Don Whelan
KILBEHENNY Mr. William O’Doherty Mr. Martin Russell
NEWMARKET-ONFERGUS Mr. Kieran Woods
KILCORNEY Mr. John Browne Mr. Tim Leader
OOLA Mr. Gerard O’Dwyer
KILDORRERY Mr. Robert Drake Mr. John Walsh KILLOWEN/ MOSSGROVE Mr. John Canty Mr. Don McSweeney
OUTRATH Mr. Matthew McEniry Mr. Ciaran McGrath Mr. Martin Moloney Mr. John O’Donnell Mr. Thomas Prendergast Mr. Thomas Ryan
COURTBRACK Mr. Vincent Buckley Mr. Timothy McSweeney
KILLUMNEY Mr. Jerome Desmond Mr. Thomas M. Griffin
PARK Mr. Kevin Galvin Mr. Matthew Hurley Mr. Barry O’Connor Mr. Michael J. Riordan
DARRAGH Mr. James Condon Mr. Thomas Hyland
KILNAMARTYRA Mr. Brendan Hinchion Vacancy
RATHDUFF Mr. John Aherne Mr. Teddy Buckley
DONERAILE Mr. Michael Duane Mrs. Elizabeth Sheehan
KILROSS Mr. Daniel Hogan Mr. John O’Neill
RUSHEEN Mr. Sean Corkery
DONOUGHMORE Mr. Liam Foley Mr. Fintan McSweeney
KILWORTH Mr. John Clancy Mr. Michael Gowen
DROMBANNA Mr. William Hickey Mr. John O’Brien Mr. William Walsh
KNOCKADEA Mr. John W. Coughlan Mr. John A. Fox
DROMTARIFFE Mr. Peter Duggan Mr. Eamonn Tarrant GALBALLY Mr. Timothy Blackburn Mr. Michael Donovan
KNOCKLONG/ GORMANSTOWN Mr. Geoffrey Walsh LISSARDA Mr. Richard Hinchion Mr. Sean MacSweeney
GARRYSPILLANE Mr. Morgan Murphy Mr. John P. Tobin
LOMBARDSTOWN Mr. Frank O’Connor Mr. Michael O’Hanlon Mr. Peter Twomey
GLANWORTH Mr. Denis Joyce Ms. Mary Twomey-Casey
MALLOW Mr. Coleman Cronin Mr. John Kenny
GLOSHA/ REARCROSS Mr. Roger Keogh Mr. Eamonn O’Toole
MILLSTREET/ BALLYDALY Mr. Diarmuid Corkery Vacancy
GRANAGH/MILTOWN Mr. Vincent Griffin Mr. Gerard Kennedy
MOGEELY Mr. John Dunne Mr. Liam Lane Mr. Edmund C. Lynch Mr. Patrick Millerick Mr. Denis O’Brien Mr. Sean O’Brien Mr. Maurice Smiddy
HOLLYFORD Mr. Martin O’Connell HOSPITAL/KILTEELY/ SARSFIELD Mr. Patrick Hanley Mr. Liam O’Carroll INCHIGEELA/ TEERGAY Mr. Donal Creedon
MOURNEABBEY Mr. Derry Cronin Mr. John Fitzgerald MUSKERRY Mr. Daniel P. O’Donovan
SHINAUGH Vacancy SHOUNLARAGH/ TOGHER Mr. Donal F. Hurley TEMPLEMARTIN Mr. Michael P. Murphy TERELTON/TOAMES Mr. John Joe Kelleher Mr. Liam O’Riordan TOURNAFULLA/ MEENAHELA Mr. Denis Aherne Mr. Maurice Curtin Mr. Donal Fitzgerald
19
20
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Statement of Board Responsibilities The Industrial and Provident Societies Acts, 1893 to 1978 require the Board to provide for the preparation of financial statements, in accordance with accounting standards generally accepted in Ireland, for each financial year which gives a true and fair view of the state of affairs of the Society and of the result of the Society for that period. In preparing those financial statements, the Board shall cause: ›
suitable accounting policies to be selected and applied consistently;
›
reasonable and prudent judgements and estimates to be made;
›
the financial statements to be prepared on a going concern basis.
In accordance with Rule 63 of the Society’s rules, the Board shall cause proper books of account and records to be kept as are necessary to give a true and fair view of the Society’s business and affairs. The Board is also responsible for safeguarding the assets of the Society and shall cause reasonable steps to be taken to provide adequate protection in this regard.
On behalf of the Board:
Bertie O’Leary James Lynch Chairman Vice Chairman 31 March 2014
31 March 2014
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Independent Auditor’s Report to the Members of Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited We have audited the financial statements of Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited for the year ended 31 December 2013 which comprise the Consolidated Profit and Loss Account, the Consolidated Balance Sheet, the Consolidated Cash Flow Statement and Consolidated Statement of Total Recognised Gains and Losses and the related notes 1 to 36. The financial reporting framework that has been applied in their preparation is Irish law and accounting standards issued by the Financial Reporting Council and promulgated by the Institute of Chartered Accountants in Ireland (Generally Accepted Accounting Practice in Ireland). This report is made solely to the Society’s Members, as a body, in accordance with Section 13 of the Industrial and Provident Societies Act, 1893. Our audit work has been undertaken so that we might state to the society’s members those matters we are required to state to them in an auditors’ report and for no other purpose. To the fullest extent permitted by law, we do not accept or assume responsibility to anyone other than the society and the society’s members as a body, for our audit work, for this report, or for the opinions we have formed.
Respective Responsibilities of Directors and Auditors As explained more fully in the Statement of Board Responsibilities, the Board are responsible for the preparation of the financial statements giving a true and fair view. Our responsibility is to audit and express an opinion on the financial statements in accordance with Irish law and International Standards on Auditing (UK and Ireland). Those standards require us to comply with the Auditing Practices Board’s Ethical Standards for Auditors.
Scope of the audit of the financial statements An audit involves obtaining evidence about the amounts and disclosures in the financial statements sufficient to give reasonable assurance that the financial statements are free from material misstatement, whether caused by fraud or error. This includes an assessment of: whether the accounting policies are appropriate to the group and the parent company’s circumstances and have been consistently applied and adequately disclosed; the reasonableness of significant accounting estimates made by the directors; and the overall presentation of the financial statements. In addition, we read all the financial and non-financial information in the Annual Report to identify material inconsistencies with the audited financial statements and to identify any information that is apparently materially incorrect based on, or materially inconsistent with, the knowledge acquired by us in the course of performing the audit. If we become aware of any apparent material misstatements or inconsistencies we consider the implications for our report.
Opinion on financial statements In our opinion the financial statements ›
give a true and fair view of the state of the affairs of the Group as at 31 December 2013 and of the profit of the Group for the year then ended; and
›
have been prepared in accordance with Generally Accepted Accounting Practice in Ireland.
As required by section 13(2) of the Industrial and Provident Societies Acts, 1893 we examined the balance sheets showing the receipts and expenditure, funds and effects of the society, and verified the same with the books, deeds, documents, accounts and vouchers relating thereto, and found them to be correct, duly vouched, and in accordance with law.
Chartered Accountants and Statutory Audit Firm Cork 31 March 2014
21
22
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Consolidated profit and loss account for the year ended 31 December 2013 2013 Notes E’000
TURNOVER 1
2012 E’000
847,407 731,233
OPERATING PROFIT before amortisation
2
29,301 22,235
Goodwill and other intangible asset amortisation
9
(1,359) (1,381)
OPERATING PROFIT 27,942 20,854 Share of losses of joint ventures
(118) -
Share of gains/(losses) of associates
54 (12)
Financial asset impairment credit/(charge)
3
1,841 (1,841)
Interest payable and similar charges
4
(4,461) (4,657)
Interest receivable and similar income
4
2,509 2,506
PROFIT on ordinary activities before taxation 27,767 16,850 Taxation charge on profit on ordinary activities
6
(2,145) (2,494)
PROFIT after taxation 25,622 14,356 Minority interest
22
(424) (602)
PROFIT for the financial year 25,198 13,754 Share interest RETAINED PROFIT for the year
The above results are derived from continuing operations.
On behalf of the Board:
Bertie O’Leary James Lynch Chairman Vice Chairman 31 March 2014
31 March 2014
7
(1,163) (1,179)
20
24,035 12,575
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
23
Consolidated balance sheet as at 31 December 2013
2013 2012
Notes
E’000
E’000
FIXED ASSETS Tangible assets
8
194,215 172,199
Intangible assets
9
10,499 12,076
Financial assets
10
34,770 36,347
239,484 220,622 CURRENT ASSETS Stocks
11
109,515 88,570
Debtors
12
120,386 100,633
Bank and cash
1,466 8,973
231,367 198,176 CREDITORS falling due within one year
13
(125,058) (108,440)
NET CURRENT ASSETS 106,309 89,736 TOTAL ASSETS LESS CURRENT LIABILITIES
345,793 310,358 14
(66,794) (49,784)
Capital grants
16
(8,257) (9,618)
Deferred taxation
17
(128) (1,117)
CREDITORS falling due after more than one year PROVISION FOR LIABILITIES AND CHARGES
270,614 249,839 PENSION ASSET
18
NET ASSETS
3,230 1,427 273,844
251,266
CAPITAL AND RESERVES Share capital
19
93,430 93,079
Capital reserves
20
1,007 1,007
Revaluation reserve
20
6,946 6,946
Bonus reserve
20
138 138
Profit and loss account
20
169,733 147,930
SHAREHOLDERS’ FUNDS Minority interest 22
271,254 2,590
249,100 2,166
CAPITAL EMPLOYED
273,844
251,266
On behalf of the Board:
Bertie O’Leary James Lynch Chairman Vice Chairman 31 March 2014
31 March 2014
24
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Consolidated cash flow statement for the year ended 31 December 2013 2013 Notes E’000
2012 E’000
Net cash inflow from operating activities
24
33,188 32,715
Returns on investments and servicing of finance
25
(4,342) (4,747) (4,684) (244)
Taxation paid 26
(31,516) (15,756)
Equity share interest paid
(1,126) (1,154)
Management of liquid resources
4,621 (295)
Capital expenditure and financial investment
27
738 (853)
Financing 28
(3,121) 9,666
(Decrease)/increase in cash in the year
Reconciliation of net cash flow to movement in net debt for the year ended 31 December 2013 2013
2012
E’000 E’000
(Decrease)/increase in cash in the year
(3,121) 9,666
Non cash movements
(961) 744
(4,082) 10,410
Movement in net debt Net debt at 1 January
(56,832) (67,242)
Net debt at 31 December
(60,914) (56,832)
Analysis of net debt At Non
1 January. 2013
Cash
cash
flow movement
E’000 E’000
E’000
At
31 December 2013 E’000
Cash and bank balances
8,973
(6,546)
(961)
1,466
Invoice discounting and overdrafts
(17,586)
16,210
-
(1,376)
Finance leases
(225)
-
-
(225)
(8,838) 9,664 (961) (135) Debt due after one year
(47,000)
(13,000)
-
(60,000)
Finance leases
(994)
215
-
(779)
(47,994) (12,785)
- (60,779)
(56,832) (3,121) (961) (60,914)
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
25
Consolidated statement of total recognised gains and losses for the year ended 31 December 2013
2013
2012
E’000
E’000
Profit for the financial year 25,198 13,754 Share of joint ventures’ reserves movements
(57) -
Share of associates’ reserves movements
(49) (75)
Currency translation difference on net investment
(1,297) 1,142
Difference between actual and expected return on pension scheme assets
(2,575) 17,581 (629) 4,471
Experience (losses)/gains arising on pension scheme liabilities Effects of changes in assumptions underlying the present value of pension scheme liabilities
2,632 (28,536) (257) 417
Deferred tax associated with movement on pension scheme Total recognised gains relating to the year
22,966
8,754
Reconciliation of movement in shareholders’ funds for the year ended 31 December 2013
2013 2012
Notes
E’000
E’000
Total recognised gains relating to the year
22,966 8,754
Share interest
7
(1,163) (1,179)
Issue of ordinary shares including conversions
19
1,817 34
Shares redeemed
19
(1,466) (1,245)
Net change in shareholders’ funds
22,154 6,364
Opening shareholders’ funds
249,100 242,736
Closing shareholders’ funds
271,254
249,100
26
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Statement of Accounting Policies The significant accounting policies adopted by the Society are: Basis of Preparation: The financial statements have been prepared in accordance with accounting standards issued by the Financial Reporting Council and the Irish Industrial and Provident Societies Acts, 1893 to 1978.
Accounting Convention: The financial statements, which are denominated in euros, are prepared under the historical cost convention as modified by the revaluation of certain fixed assets.
Basis of Consolidation: The consolidated financial statements incorporate: a) the accounts of Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited (“the Society”) and its subsidiaries for the year ended 31 December 2013. b) the Society’s share of the results and post acquisition reserves of joint ventures and associates as reported in the latest audited financial statements. This is to 30 June 2013 for Reox Holdings plc and 31 December 2012 for the other joint ventures and associates. c) any material adjustments for joint ventures and associates (arising between the date of their latest financial statements as above and the year end of the Society) and consequently Reox Holdings plc, Co-Operative Animal Health Limited and Malting Company of Ireland Limited results are incorporated to 31 December 2013. d) any material differences between the Society’s accounting policies and that of its joint ventures and associates where required. The results of subsidiaries, joint ventures and associates acquired or disposed of are included in or excluded from the financial statements from the effective date of acquisition or disposal. The interests of minority shareholders in subsidiary companies reflect the minority’s proportion of the net assets of the relevant subsidiaries. The results of overseas subsidiary companies are translated into euros at the average rate for the year.
The assets and liabilities of overseas subsidiary companies have been consolidated at the rate of exchange ruling on the balance sheet date. Exchange differences arising on the retranslation of the opening balance sheets of overseas subsidiary companies together with differences in exchange rates on the translation of the profit and loss account are included in reserves.
Turnover: Turnover represents the invoiced value of goods and services to third parties, including EU export refunds and excluding value added tax. Turnover is recognised when the Society receives the right to consideration as ownership and risk passes to third parties. Rebates are recognised by the Society on a receipts basis.
Share Trading: Accounting for Transactions Investment transactions are accounted for on the trade date. All investments are stated at cost and are not subsequently revalued. Realised gains and losses on investment disposals are calculated using the first in first out method based on the difference between the original cost and the disposal amount. A provision is made for impairment in value, particularly in the case where impairment is permanent, as evidenced by losses crystallised post year end. This is reassessed on a yearly basis, based on current market prices and valued at the lower of cost and market value.
Investment Income and Expenses Dividends are recognised as income on the dates that securities are first quoted “ex-dividend” to the extent information thereon is reasonably available to the Society. Interest income is recognised by the Society on an accruals basis. Income from quoted companies is stated net of withholding tax.
Tangible Fixed Assets and Depreciation: Tangible fixed assets are stated at cost or valuation less accumulated depreciation. Depreciation is calculated to write off the cost or valuation of tangible fixed assets other than freehold land over their estimated useful lives by equal annual instalments at the following annual rates:
Buildings:
2.0% - 10.0%
Plant and machinery: 7.5% - 33.3% Motor vehicles:
12.5% - 25.0%
Tangible fixed assets in the course of construction are carried at cost less any recognised impairment loss. Depreciation of these assets commences when they are commissioned and ready for their intended use. The carrying value of tangible assets is reviewed for impairment if events or changes in circumstances indicate the carrying value may not be recoverable. Impairment is assessed by comparing the carrying value of an asset with its recoverable amount (being the higher of net realisable value and value in use). Net realisable value is defined as the amount at which an asset could be disposed of net of any direct selling costs. Value in use is defined as the present value of the future cash flows obtainable through continued use of an asset including those to be realised on its eventual disposal.
Leased Assets: Assets held under leasing arrangements that transfer substantially all the risks and rewards of ownership are capitalised. The capital element of the related rental obligations is included in creditors. The interest element of the rental obligations is charged to the profit and loss account so as to produce a constant periodic rate of charge. Rentals in respect of all other leases are charged to the profit and loss account as incurred.
Goodwill: Goodwill arising on acquisitions representing the excess of the total cost of the Society’s investment over the fair value of the separable net assets acquired is amortised over its expected useful economic life of a maximum of twenty years, on a straight line basis. The carrying value of goodwill is reviewed annually and provision is made for any impairment. Impairment losses are recognised in the profit and loss account.
Intangible Assets: Purchased intangible assets are included at cost and amortised over a maximum of ten years, depending on their estimated useful economic life, in equal annual instalments. A provision is made for any impairment in value.
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Statement of Accounting Policies (continued) Financial Fixed Assets:
Taxation:
Provisions:
Associated and Joint Venture undertakings Associated undertakings are those undertakings in which the Society has a significant interest in the equity capital and over which it is able to exercise significant influence. Joint Venture undertakings are those undertakings in which the Society has a joint interest in the equity capital and over which it jointly exercises control. The Society’s interests are stated at cost, plus its share of post acquisition reserves, less provision for permanent diminution in value.
Corporation tax is calculated on the result for the year after taking account of capital allowances and any relevant reliefs.
Provisions are charged against the profits of the Society where there may exist a liability arising from present obligations. Provisions are reviewed at each balance sheet date and adjusted to reflect current best estimate. Where material, some provisions are discounted.
Joint ventures and associates are accounted for using the gross equity method and equity method respectively. The group’s share of the profits less losses of joint ventures and associates are included in the consolidated profit and loss account. The group’s interests in their net assets or liabilities are included as fixed asset investments in the consolidated balance sheet at an amount representing the group’s share of the fair values of the net assets at acquisition plus the group’s share of post acquisition retained profits or losses. Goodwill arising on acquisition of joint ventures and associates is dealt with as stated above.
Other investments Trade investments are those undertakings in which the Society does not exercise a significant or participating interest. The Society’s interest in these undertakings is stated at cost, less provision for permanent diminution in value.
Stocks: Stocks are valued at the lower of cost and net realisable value. Cost in the case of raw materials, goods for resale and expense stocks comprise the purchase price including transport and other directly attributable costs. Cost in the case of work-in-progress and finished goods comprises direct material and labour costs and an appropriate proportion of manufacturing overhead based on normal production levels. Net realisable value represents the estimated sales price less costs to completion and all appropriate holding, selling and distribution expenses.
Deferred Taxation: Deferred taxation is provided in respect of all timing differences that have originated but not reversed at the balance sheet date where transactions or events have occurred at that date that will result in an obligation to pay more, or right to pay less or to receive more tax, with the following exceptions: i) vision is not made for tax on gains arising from the revaluation of fixed assets unless there is a binding agreement for the disposal of assets.
Research and Development: Expenditure on research and development is written off to the profit and loss account in the year in which it is incurred.
Foreign Currencies: Foreign currency transactions entered in to by entities during the year have been translated at the rates ruling at the time of these transactions.
ii) deferred tax assets are recognised only to the extent that the Board of Directors consider that it is more likely than not that there will be suitable future taxable profits from which the underlying timing differences can be deducted.
Monetary assets and liabilities arising in foreign currencies have been retranslated at rates ruling at the balance sheet date. Exchange differences have been included in the profit and loss account for the year.
Deferred tax is measured on an undiscounted basis at the tax rates that are expected to apply in the periods in which the timing differences reverse based on existing tax rates and law.
Revolving Fund: The revolving fund is a compulsory mechanism by which milk suppliers contribute to the funding of the Society with monies contributed repaid in full, together with accumulated interest when the period expires. Contributions will be made over seven years from 2013 to 2019, with a maximum of sixty monthly deductions over the seven year period. The first 75,000 litres of milk supplied by each member in any year will be exempt from the deduction. No contribution will be made when the Dairygold quoted milk price is below 27 cent per litre including VAT. When the milk price is 27 cent per litre or above a 0.5 cent per litre deduction will be made. Contributions will be repaid in the eighth year after receipt i.e. contributions made during 2013 will be repaid with interest in 2020 and so on. The interest rate applying to contributions is 3 month EURIBOR (Euro Interbank Offered Rate) plus 2.5%. Interest is accrued on a yearly basis.
Capital Grants: Grants receivable in respect of tangible fixed assets are included in the financial statements when the amounts have been ascertained and are released to the profit and loss account in equal annual instalments over the expected useful lives of the relevant assets.
Revenue Grants: Revenue based grants are accounted for in the year in which the related expenditure is incurred and are dealt with directly through the profit and loss account.
Debtors: Known bad debts are written off and specific provision is made for any amount the collection of which is considered doubtful. A further general provision is also maintained.
Member Funding:
27
28
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Loan Notes Members are offered the opportunity to invest on a voluntary basis in a loan note. The scheme commenced in 2013 and will run for three years. Members who subscribe to the loan note will be repaid their investment in full plus accumulated interest on the fifth anniversary of their investment. A total of €15 million will be offered and the offer will close once the voluntary €15 million target has been subscribed to. The interest rate applying to the loan note is 3 month EURIBOR plus 4%. Interest is accrued on a yearly basis.
The full service cost of the pension provision is charged to operating profit. The net impact of the unwinding of the discount rate on scheme liabilities and the expected return of the scheme assets is charged and credited to finance costs.
Minimum Shareholding Each milk supplier is required to achieve and maintain a shareholding in the Society equivalent to 4.0 cent per litre of milk supplied. Where a milk supplier’s shareholding is less than 4.0 cent per litre at the end of any year, a contribution of 0.5 cent per litre will be deducted from his or her monthly milk payment in the following year until the supplier achieves the required threshold of 4.0 cent per litre of milk supplied. This commenced in 2013. Deductions are converted in to shares in the Society.
Defined Contribution: Retirement benefits to employees are funded by contributions from the company and employees. Payments are made to pension trusts which are financially separate from the Society.
Pensions: Defined Benefit: Under Financial Reporting Standard 17 Retirement Benefits, pension scheme assets are measured using fair values. Pension scheme liabilities are measured using a projected unit method and discounted at the current rate of return on a high quality corporate bond of equivalent term to the liability, which is estimated by reference to appropriate yield curves. The pension scheme surplus (to the extent that it is recoverable) or deficit is recognised in full, net of deferred tax and presented on the face of the balance sheet. The movement in the scheme surplus/deficit is split between operating and financing items in the profit and loss account and the statement of total recognised gains and losses.
Any difference between the expected return on assets and that actually achieved is charged through the statement of total recognised gains and losses. Similarly, any differences that arise from experience or assumption changes are charged through the statement of total recognised gains and losses.
Where the Society is a participating employer in a multi-employer defined benefit pension scheme and its share of the underlying assets and liabilities cannot be identified on a consistent and reasonable basis, the scheme is accounted for as a defined contribution scheme.
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Notes to financial statements 1 Turnover 2013
2012
E’000
E’000
Turnover: group and share of joint ventures’
866,316 731,233
Less: Share of joint ventures’ turnover
(18,909) -
Group turnover 847,407 731,233 Geographical analysis by destination: 2013
2012
E’000
E’000
Ireland 378,370 322,805 United Kingdom
152,106 133,801
Rest of Europe
195,864 162,827
Rest of World
121,067 111,800
847,407 731,233 Principal activities by class of business: Food Ingredients 593,153 500,803 Agri Business 250,012 225,932 Dairygold Finance 4,242 4,498 847,407
731,233
Segmental information, by market, has not been given because, in the opinion of the Board of Directors, to do so would be prejudicial to the interests of the Society.
2 Operating profit 2013
2012
E’000
E’000
Turnover - Note 1 847,407 731,233 Less: Raw materials and consumables
661,813 575,430
Payroll costs - Note 5
55,965 52,492
Operating costs
63,682 65,330
Depreciation - Note 8
18,091 17,211
Grant amortisation - Note 16
(1,361) (1,067)
Change in stock of finished goods and goods for resale
19,916 (398)
Operating profit before amortisation
29,301 22,235
29
30
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Notes to financial statements 3 Financial asset impairment credit/(charge)
2013
2012
E’000
E’000
Financial asset impairment credit/(charge)
1,841 (1,841)
The financial asset impairment reversal for 2013 reflects the Society’s interest in its long term shareholding in One51 plc.
4 Net interest (payable)/receivable and similar (charges)/income
2013
2012
2013
2012
E’000
E’000
Interest payable and similar charges Bank interest payable and similar charges Share of joint ventures’ net interest payable
(4,399) (4,657) (62) (4,461) (4,657)
Interest receivable and similar income Bank interest receivable
57 48
Net interest receivable and similar income relating to pensions
2,452 2,458
2,509 2,506
(1,952) (2,151)
5 Payroll costs The weekly average number of employees:
2013
2012
Number
Number
Dairygold Food Ingredients
586 566
Dairygold Agri Business
531 533
1,117 1,099
Payroll costs comprise:
E’000
E’000
Wages and salaries
48,025 45,199
Social welfare costs
5,044 4,896
Pension costs
2,896 2,397
55,965 52,492
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Notes to financial statements 6 Taxation charge on profit on ordinary activities
2013 E’000
2012 E’000
Corporation tax Irish tax Foreign tax
(2,713) (1,815) (489) (224) (3,202) (2,039)
Prior year provision movement Irish tax
6 (44)
Foreign tax
- (29)
6 (73)
Tax charge Share of associates’ tax Share of joint ventures’ tax Total corporation tax Deferred tax credit/(charge) - Note 17 Total tax
(3,196) (2,112) 83 (44) (21) (3,134) (2,156) 989 (338) (2,145) (2,494)
The tax assessed for the year is different from the standard rates of corporation tax, as follows:
Profit before tax
27,767
Corporation tax at standard rate
(3,471) (2,106)
16,850
Effects of: Expenses allowable for tax purposes
618 353
Research and development tax credits
100
101
Excess depreciation over capital allowances
(424) (253)
Higher tax rates (non-trading income)
(101) (49)
Non taxable income Losses brought forward Current year losses Higher tax rates (overseas)
25
26
360
469
-
(536)
(309) (44) (3,202) (2,039)
7 Share interest
2013
2012
E’000
E’000
Share interest paid @ 1.25% (2012: 1.25%) Ordinary share capital
(1,163) (1,179)
(1,163) (1,179)
The Board has recommended that share interest of 1.25% be paid on the share capital in issue at 31 December 2013. This will amount to €1,168,000 and is subject to approval at the Annual General Meeting.
31
32
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Notes to financial statements 8 Tangible assets
Land &
Plant &
Motor
Construction
buildings
machinery
vehicles
In Progress
Total
E’000
E’000
E’000
E’000
E’000
4,553
7,271 286,770
COST OR VALUATION At 1 January 2013 Cost Valuation Additions
88,409
186,537
35,749 124,158
55,872 242,409
4,020
-
3,253
Impairment
-
Disposals
-
7,271 378,391
664 32,475 40,412
(159) (1,229)
- 91,621
4,553
- (131)
- (159) - (1,360)
Transferred from CIP
50
7,221
-
(7,271)
-
Translation adjustments
(85)
(203)
(1)
-
(289)
At 31 December 2013 Cost
92,394
Valuation
35,749
128,143
195,420 55,872
5,085 32,475 325,374 -
- 91,621
251,292
5,085 32,475 416,995
34,378
168,867
2,947
Charged during year
3,328
14,387
Relating to disposals
-
(1,202)
(24)
(146)
37,682
181,906
DEPRECIATION At 1 January 2013
Translation adjustments At 31 December 2013
-
206,192
376
-
18,091
(130)
-
(1,332)
(1)
-
(171)
3,192
-
222,780
NET BOOK VALUE At 31 December 2013
90,461
69,386
1,893 32,475 194,215
At 31 December 2012
89,780
73,542
1,606
7,271
172,199
A professional valuation of substantially all the Society’s land, buildings and plant and machinery was undertaken by Lisney during 1996. The basis of valuation was depreciated replacement cost or, where appropriate, open market value. The valuation was incorporated into the financial statements and the surplus arising taken to the revaluation reserve. The valuers also estimated the remaining useful lives of the assets. The Society has not adopted a policy of annual revaluations as permitted by Financial Reporting Standard 15. The Board of Directors has taken the view that a reasonable valuation of the cost of tangible fixed assets under a historical cost basis would be €285 million.
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
33
Notes to financial statements 9 Intangible assets
2013 2012
GOODWILL
E’000
E’000
COST At 1 January Translation adjustments At 31 December
22,016 21,553 (426) 463 21,590
22,016
AMORTISATION At 1 January Charged during year Translation adjustments At 31 December
10,522 9,054 1,242 1,265 (208) 203 11,556
10,522
NET BOOK VALUE At 31 December
10,034
11,494
844
844
OTHER INTANGIBLE ASSETS COST At 1 January and 31 December AMORTISATION At 1 January
262 146
Charged during year
117 116
At 31 December
379
262
NET BOOK VALUE At 31 December NET BOOK VALUE TOTAL
465
582
10,499
12,076
The carrying value of goodwill relates to a number of UK and Irish businesses acquired in previous years. The other intangible assets relate to customer lists acquired. All intangible assets are amortised over a maximum of 20 years. In 2012, the Society reviewed the amortisation rates of its intangible assets and decided to increase the amortisation rate to 10 years, to reflect estimated useful life, in relation to the customer lists acquired.
34
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Notes to financial statements 10 Financial assets
2013 2012
E’000
E’000
JOINT VENTURES Share of net assets - 1 January Tranferred from Associates Share of net results Share of associates reserve movements
6,189 (201) (57) -
Share of net assets - 31 December Loans to joint ventures - Note 30
5,931 435 -
Balance
6,366 -
ASSOCIATES Share of net assets - 1 January Net assets other than goodwill Transferred to joint ventures Share of net results Share of associates reserve movements
7,984 8,115 (6,189) 137 (56) (49) (75)
Share of net assets - 31 December Loans to associates - Note 30 Loan notes - Note 30
1,883 7,984 - 85 10,000 13,000
Balance
11,883 21,069
UNQUOTED Shares at cost - 1 January and 31 December
444 444
QUOTED Shares at cost - 1 January Additions Disposals Impairment credit/(charge)
6,972 8,391 3,008 4,478 (2,874) (4,056) 1,841 (1,841)
Shares at cost - 31 December
8,947 6,972
LOAN STOCK At - 1 January Additions Redemptions
7,862 8,901 877 569 (1,609) (1,608)
7,862 At - 31 December 7,130 TOTAL
34,770 36,347
a)
The joint ventures and associates are included in the financial statements at the cost of the investment plus the Society’s share of post acquisition reserves.
b)
In the opinion of the Board of Directors, the value of the unquoted investments is not less than that shown above.
c)
The market value of the quoted investments excluding Reox Holdings plc at 31 December 2013 was €34,696,000 (2012: €24,661,000).
d)
The loan stock refers to unconverted loan stock received from the Irish Dairy Board based on the Society’s trading activity with it.
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
35
Notes to financial statements 10 Financial assets (continued) Details of principal subsidiaries, joint ventures and associates are included in Note 35 to these financial statements. In 2011, Reox Holdings plc issued subordinated unsecured loan notes of €19 million to the Society. These loan notes were repayable over six years (commencing in 2012) in annual instalments of €3 million each year for five years and €4 million to be repaid in December 2017. Interest does not accrue on these loan notes, unless the repayments are not received by the Society on the due dates. See note 34 (Post Balance Sheet Events) regarding the redemption of these loan notes as part of a “Debt for Asset” transaction. The following additional disclosures are required by Financial Reporting Standard 9, Associates and Joint Ventures, as the Co-Operative’s share of the results of its associate entities and joint ventures exceed certain thresholds specified in the standard. Disclosure in aggregate of the Co-Operative’s share of results of all associates and joint ventures:
2013 2012
E’000
E’000
Turnover
21,869 26,100
Fixed assets
12,621
Current assets
10,172 11,232
Liabilities due within one year
(9,563) (9,762)
Liabilities due after one year
(3,585)
11,420
(4,019)
The results detailed below for Reox Holdings plc are disclosed separately based on criterion specified in Financial Reporting Standard 9, Associates and Joint Ventures, as follows: Name:
Reox Holdings plc
2013
E’000
The Co-Operative’s share of: Turnover 308 Loss before exceptional items Exceptional items Loss before taxation
(115) (115)
Taxation
83
Loss after taxation
(32)
Fixed assets
6,338
Current assets
1,808
Liabilities due within one year
(3,914)
Liabilities due after one year
(2,612)
The results detailed below for joint ventures, in aggregate, are disclosed separately based on criterion specified in Financial Reporting Standard 9, Associates and Joint Ventures, as follows:
2013
E’000
Joint ventures analysed as follows: Fixed assets Current assets
6,080 8,066
Share of gross assets
14,146
Liabilities due within one year
(5,459)
Liabilities due after more than one year
(963)
Share of gross liabilities
(6,422)
Share of net assets
7,724
36
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Notes to financial statements 11 Stocks
2013
2012
E’000
E’000
Raw materials
15,156 15,353
Finished goods
74,581 53,635
Goods for resale
14,525 15,555
Expense stocks
5,253 4,027
109,515
88,570
There is no material difference between the above amounts and the replacement cost of stocks.
12 Debtors falling due within one year
2013 2012
E’000
Trade debtors
E’000
105,414 85,915
Prepayments and accrued income
5,505 10,015
Amounts due from related parties - Note 30
6,440 3,123
Corporation tax VAT
87 2,940 1,580 120,386
100,633
13 Creditors falling due within one year
2013 2012
E’000
Bank loans, invoice discounting and overdrafts Obligations under finance leases
E’000
1,376 17,586 225 225
Trade creditors
33,716 18,742
Provisions, accruals and deferred income
86,008 67,702
Amounts due to related parties - Note 30
1,073 491
Corporation tax
- 1,401
PAYE and PRSI
1,996 1,757
Loan stock - Note 23
664 536 125,058
108,440
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
37
Notes to financial statements 14 Creditors falling due after more than one year
2013 2012
E’000
Bank loans falling due between two and five years Obligations under finance leases - Note 15 Other loans Advances received for members’ loan notes
E’000
60,000 47,000 779 994 - 340 25 315
Loan notes (including interest accrued)
1,544 -
Revolving Fund (including interest accrued)
3,586 -
Convertible stock - Note 21 Loan stock - Note 23
226 228 634 907 66,794
49,784
15 Obligations under finance leases
2013 2012
E’000
Falling due within one year Falling due after more than one year
E’000
225 225 779 994 1,004 1,219
16 Capital grants
2013 2012
E’000
At 1 January Receivable during year
E’000
9,618 4,652 - 6,033
Credited to profit and loss account
(1,361) (1,067)
At 31 December
8,257 9,618
17 Deferred taxation
2013 2012
E’000
At 1 January
E’000
1,117 779
(Credited)/charged to profit and loss account
(989) 338
At 31 December
128 1,117
The deferred tax arose due to timing differences, relating to the manner in which items are treated in the profit and loss account from an accounting perspective as opposed to from a taxation perspective, in addition to the existence of losses forward. The Society had unrecognised deferred tax assets of €1,341,193 (2012: €1,546,842) at the end of the year. This asset has not been recognised due to uncertainty surrounding the timing of future profits. Deferred tax in relation to the pension schemes is dealt with under the pension’s note 18 in accordance with the provisions of Financial Reporting Standard 17, Retirement Benefits.
38
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Notes to financial statements 18 Pension asset
Dairygold Pension Schemes
The Society operates and contributes to a number of externally funded defined benefit and defined contribution pension schemes in Ireland.
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Pension Plan 2010
This is a defined benefit pension plan which was established as a result of the merger of four defined benefit pension plans sponsored by the Society. The accounting calculations reported herein relate to this plan and are based on accounting policies, actuarial methods and assumptions which are consistent with the requirements of FRS 17 and were selected by the Society having taken advice from Mercer who are the company’s professional pension service providers.
The cash contributions payable to the plan are determined from a full actuarial valuation undertaken by the Scheme Actuary at intervals not exceeding three years. The last such valuation of the plan was undertaken as at 1 January 2013 in accordance with generally accepted actuarial principles and assumptions. The principal assumptions used in the valuation of accrued liabilities were that investment return would exceed future general salary inflation by 3.25% per annum and pension increases by 0.75% per annum in respect of existing pensioners and 1.5% per annum in respect of future pensioners. At the effective date of that valuation, the value of the assets was €232 million which was sufficient to cover approximately 98% of the benefits that had accrued to members, after allowing for future expected increases in pensionable remuneration. The valuation report is not available for public inspection. The main financial assumptions employed in the accounting valuation as at 31 December 2013 are:
2013
2012
2011
% % %
Inflation rate increase
1.80 2.00 2.00
General payroll rate increase
2.30 2.50 3.00
Pension payment increase
1.60 1.80 2.00
Discount rate
3.90 4.10 5.10
The expected long-term rates of return for: Equities
7.00 8.00 8.00
Bonds
3.10 2.70 4.40
Property
6.50 7.00 7.00
Cash
0.30
0.75 1.40
Expected return on assets: In developing the expected long-term rate of return on asset assumptions, consideration was given to the prevailing yield on low risk investments (government bonds), the historical level of risk premium associated with the other classes in which the portfolio is invested (equities) and the expectations for future returns of each asset class. The expected return for each asset class was then weighted based on the actual asset allocation to develop the expected long term rate of return on asset assumptions for the portfolio.
Discount rate assumption: In setting the discount rate, as with all other assumptions, the Society obtained independent actuarial advice from Mercer. The discount rate is set by reference to the yield on high (AA rated) quality bonds denominated in euro with duration equivalent to the duration of the liabilities.
Mercer has advised that the discount rate selected of 3.9% (2012: 4.1%) reflects the market yield on high quality corporate bonds at 31 December 2013. They have confirmed that they are satisfied that the approach taken is in accordance with the requirements of FRS 17.
Pension levy: The Irish Finance (No. 2) Act 2011 introduced a stamp duty levy of 0.6% on the market value of assets under management in Irish pension funds, for the years 2011 to 2014 (inclusive). The levy is based on scheme assets as at 30 June in each year, or as at the end of the preceding scheme financial year. A further levy of 0.15% was introduced in the 2014 Finance Act for 2014 and 2015, bringing the total levy due in 2014 to 0.75%.
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Notes to financial statements
18 Pension asset (continued)
During 2012, the Society informed the Trustees of the plan that the cost of the pension levy would have to be borne by the members of the plan, primarily in the form of adjustments to their benefits. Therefore the Society has, in its consolidated profit and loss account for 2013, recognised the cost of the levy in the form of an addition of €1.4 million to its service cost but this was counterbalanced by a negative past service cost of €1.4 million to reflect the benefit adjustments that will be made to fund the levy.
Mortality assumptions: Membership of the Society’s pension plan is too small to allow a statistical analysis of mortality experience suitable for facilitating a scheme specific projection of future experience. In the circumstances standard mortality tables have been employed. These tables include allowance for future improvements in mortality rates.
Following the completion by the Scheme Actuary of the full valuation mentioned above, there is now one standard consolidated mortality table applied to all members of the merged plan whereas in the past plan specific assumptions had been applied to the members of the four original plans. The assumption adopted in the accounting calculations is consistent with that which the Scheme Actuary adopted in the full funding valuation and also with statistics published by the Society of Actuaries in Ireland. They incorporate an allowance for expected future mortality improvements in line with Central Statistics Office projections. These assumptions would be regarded by Mercer to be a “best estimate” and they are in line with those adopted by most Irish plcs.
The assumed life expectations on retirement at age 65 are noted below.
Weighted average life expectancy:
As at 31 December 2013
Members age 65 (current life expectancy)
22.6 23.9 22.4 24.9
Members age 45 (current life expectancy)
25.0 26.0 23.8 25.9
The sensitivities regarding the principal assumptions used to measure the scheme liabilities are set out below:
Assumption
Discount rate Rate of inflation Rate of salary growth Rate of mortality
As at 31 December 2012
Male Female Male Female
Change in assumption
Increase by 0.25% Increase by 0.50% Increase by 0.50% Increase by 1 year
% Impact on scheme liabilities
Decrease by 4.6% Increase by 6.5% Increase by 2.0% Increase by 2.3%
Plan assets The weighted average asset allocation at the year end was as follows: 2013 2012 % %
Equities 43.4% 47.6% Bonds 51.7% 47.7% Properties 4.5% 4.3% Cash 0.4% 0.4% 100% 100%
39
40
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Notes to financial statements 18 Pension asset (continued) The overall surplus in the scheme at 31 December is:
2013 2012 2011
E’000
E’000
E’000
Fair value of assets: Equities 102,464 110,287 98,207 Bonds Property
122,003
110,408 97,794
10,636
9,939 9,903
871
1,057 413
235,974
231,691 206,317
Present value of scheme liabilities
(232,283) (230,060) (201,350)
Cash
Surplus in scheme Related deferred tax
3,691
1,631 4,967
(461)
(204) (621)
Closing pension asset 3,230 1,427 4,346 The amounts included within operating profit for the year under FRS 17 are as follows:
2013 2012
E’000
E’000
Current service cost
3,784
3,375
Past service credit
(1,402) (1,700)
Total charged within operating profit
2,382
1,675
The amounts included within finance charges for the year under FRS 17 are as follows:
2013
2012
E’000
E’000
Expected return on the pension scheme assets
11,881 12,701
Interest on past service scheme liabilities
(9,429) (10,243)
Net finance credit within interest receivable and similar income
2,452 2,458
The analysis of amounts recognised in the statement of total recognised gains and losses are as follows:
Actual return less expected return on the pension scheme assets Experience (losses)/gains arising on the scheme liabilities Changes in assumptions underlying the present value of the scheme liabilities Actuarial loss recognised in the statement of total recognised gains and losses
2013
2012
E’000
E’000
(2,575) 17,581 (629) 4,471 2,632 (28,536) (572)
(6,484)
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
41
Notes to financial statements 18 Pension asset (continued) Movement in pension scheme assets:
2013
2012
E’000
E’000
231,691 206,317
Value at 1 January Expected return on assets
11,881 12,701
Actual return less expected return on pension scheme assets
(2,575) 17,581
Employer contributions
2,562 2,365
Plan participants’ contributions
1,345 1,338
Benefit payments and expenses
(8,930) (8,611) 235,974 231,691
Value at 31 December Movement in pension scheme liabilities:
(230,060) (201,350)
Value at 1 January Current service cost
(3,784) (3,375)
Past service credit
1,402 1,700
Interest cost
(9,429) (10,243)
Gains/(losses) on liabilities
2,003 (24,065)
Plan participants’ contributions
(1,345) (1,338)
Benefit payments and expenses
8,930 8,611 (232,283) (230,060)
Value at 31 December
The history of experience gains and losses has been:
2013
E’000
Difference between the expected and actual return on scheme assets Percentage of scheme assets Experience gains and losses arising on the scheme liabilities Percentage of past service scheme liabilities Amount that has been recognised in statement of total recognised gains and losses Percentage of past service scheme liabilities
(2,575)
2012 2011 2010 2009 E’000
E’000
17,581 (20,853)
E’000
E’000
(88) 9,974
(1.09%)
7.59% (10.11%) (0.04%) 4.80%
(629)
4,471 1,424 (3,036) 2,624
(0.27%)
1.94% 0.71% (1.50%) 1.38%
(572) (0.25%)
(6,484) (18,603) 4,496
2,537
(2.82%) (9.24%) 2.28% 1.33%
Irish Co-Operative Societies Pension Scheme
The Society also participates in an industry wide Irish Co-Operative Societies Pension Scheme. This is a multi-employer defined benefit scheme. However, as the underlying assets and liabilities attributable to individual employers cannot be identified on a consistent and reasonable basis, the Society is accounting for the pension scheme as if it were a defined contribution scheme in accordance with FRS 17. The charge in the profit and loss account in respect of this plan was €204,000 (2012: €204,000).
The most recent actuarial valuation of the scheme was carried out as at 1 July 2011. At this date the actuarial value of the assets of the scheme was insufficient to cover 100% of the benefits that had accrued to members. The funding level was 79% at 1 July 2011. The valuation also confirmed that the scheme did not satisfy the statutory minimum funding standard at that date. The actuarial report for this scheme is available for inspection by members of the scheme but not for public inspection.
42
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Notes to financial statements 18 Pension asset (continued)
Pension Cost
The total pension cost charged to the operating profit was €2,896,000 (2012: €2,397,000). Valuations have been performed in accordance with the requirements of Financial Reporting Standard 17, Retirement Benefits, as at 31 December 2013. Scheme liabilities have been calculated using a consistent projected unit valuation method and compared to the scheme’s assets at the valuation date.
19 Share capital
Issued ordinary shares of E1 each
2013
2012
E’000
E’000
At 1 January Shares issued Conversion of convertible stock - Note 21
93,079 94,290 1,817 33 - 1
Shares redeemed
(1,466) (1,245)
At 31 December
93,430
93,079
In 2010, the Society introduced a revised share redemption process, whereby the value of shares redeemed up to €5,000 or 30% of such value, if greater, is paid in cash in that year. The balance is transferred to a loan stock account, which is being paid in equal instalments over the following four years.
2013 2012
E’000
Cash paid Arising as loan stock - Note 23 Shares redeemed
E’000
(1,077) (884) (389) (361) (1,466)
(1,245)
From 2012 onwards, the Society has accelerated the payment of the value of shares redeemed, whereby the value of shares redeemed up to €5,000 or 40% of such value, if greater, is paid in cash in that year. The balance is transferred to a loan stock account, which is being paid in equal instalments over the following three years. In common with other Societies incorporated under the Industrial and Provident Societies Acts, 1893 to 1978, the Society does not have an authorised share capital. The rules make provision for the issue of shares at the discretion of the Board and for the issue of convertible stock and loan capital. Any issues have taken place at par.
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
43
Notes to financial statements 20 Reserves
Capital
Revaluation
reserves
Bonus
reserve
Profit & Loss
reserve account
E’000
E’000
E’000
E’000
At 1 January 2013
1,007
6,946
138
147,930
Arising on currency translation
-
-
-
(1,297)
Actuarial loss recognised in the statement of total recognised gains and losses (net of deferred tax)
-
-
-
(829)
Share of joint ventures’ reserves movements
-
-
-
(57)
Share of associates’ reserves movements
-
-
-
(49)
Profit for year
-
-
-
24,035
At 31 December 2013
1,007
6,946
138
169,733
Society and subsidiaries
1,007
6,946
138
169,276
-
-
-
457
1,007
6,946
138
169,733
Joint ventures and associates At 31 December 2013
21 Convertible stock
2013 2012
E’000
At 1 January Conversion to share capital - Note 19
E’000
228 231 - (1)
Stock redeemed
(2) (2)
At 31 December
226 228
‘A’ convertible stock can be converted into ordinary shares based on conditions set out in the rules of the Society and subject to agreements at the time of the stock issue.
22 Minority interest
2013
2012
E’000
E’000
At 1 January Profit on ordinary activities after tax At 31 December
2,166 1,564 424 602 2,590
2,166
44
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Notes to financial statements 23 Loan stock
2013 2012
E’000
At 1 January
E’000
1,443 1,692
Arising on share redemption - Note 19
389 361
Loan Stock repayment
(534) (610)
At 31 December Falling due within one year Falling due after more than one year
1,298 1,443 664 536 634 907
24 Reconciliation of operating profit to net cash inflow from operating activities
2013
2012
E’000
E’000
Operating profit
27,942 20,854
Depreciation
18,091 17,211
Difference between current service pension cost and payments made
(180) (690)
Capital grants credit
(1,361) (1,067)
Goodwill and other intangible asset amortisation
1,359 1,381
Cash related to business terminations and restructuring
(602) (1,294)
Increase in stocks
(20,945) (3,274)
Increase in debtors
(16,666) (1,693)
Increase in creditors
25,550 1,287
Net cash inflow from operating activities
33,188 32,715
25 Returns on investments and servicing of finance
2013
2012
E’000
E’000
Interest received
57 48
Interest paid
(4,399) (4,795)
(4,342)
(4,747)
26 Capital expenditure and financial investment
2013
2012
E’000
E’000
Payments to acquire tangible fixed assets
(32,142)
(22,518)
Payments to acquire financial fixed assets
(3,885)
(5,047)
Receipts on disposal of fixed assets Receipts on disposals of financial fixed assets Capital grants
28
112
4,483
5,664
-
6,033
(31,516)
(15,756)
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Notes to financial statements 27 Management of liquid resources
2013
2012
E’000
E’000
Redemption of loan stock - Note 23
(534)
(610)
25
315
Loan notes
1,544
-
Revolving fund
3,586 -
4,621 (295)
Advances received for members’ loan notes
28 Financing
2013
2012
E’000
E’000
Issue of share capital
1,817 33
Redemption of shares
(1,077) (884)
Redemption of convertible stock
(2) (2) 738
(853)
29 Financial commitments Future investments and capital expenditure approved by the Board and not provided for in these financial statements amounted to €10,631,000 (2012: €7,620,000). At 31 December 2013, there were forward open foreign exchange contracts of approximately €2.5 million (2012: €3.1 million), on which there was an unrealised foreign exchange loss of €nil based on sales made in 2013 (2012: gain of €26,000 relating to 2012 sales) and a loss of €21,000 on 2014 related sales (2012: gain of €93,000 relating to 2013 sales).
30 Related party transactions The Group’s related parties, as defined by Financial Reporting Standard No. 8, Related Party Disclosures, the nature of the relationships and the extent of transactions with them are summarised below. The Group views key management personnel, directors and companies controlled by them, associate undertakings and non-wholly owned subsidiaries as related parties under the standard. The Society purchases goods and services from its joint ventures and associates and sells goods and services to its joint ventures and associates on standard commercial terms. The purchases from and sales to the joint ventures and associates during 2013 amounted to €10,223,000 (2012: €9,381,000) and €3,909,000 (2012: €5,043,000) respectively. The trading balances outstanding by and to the Society amounted to €661,000 (2012: €213,000) and €440,000 (2012: €123,000) respectively at the year end. The Society has provided a loan of €435,000 (2012: €85,000) to its joint venture, The Malting Company of Ireland. The Society purchases and sells goods and services from and to a non-wholly owned subsidiary, Munster Cattle Breeding Group Limited and its subsidiaries, on standard commercial terms. During 2013 the purchases from and sales to Munster Cattle Breeding Group Limited amounted to €7,000 (2012: €12,000) and €486,000 (2012: €475,000) respectively. The trading balance outstanding to the Society amounted to €41,000 (2012: €14,000) at the year end. On the establishment of this venture, the Society provided a loan of €1,320,000 to its non-wholly owned subsidiary, of which €660,000 was repaid in 2012, with the balance of €660,000 paid in 2013. In the ordinary course of business, some key management and directors, in their capacity as farmers and/or directors of trading companies are involved in trade with the Society on standard commercial terms. The aggregate level of purchases from and sales to these related parties during the year amounted to €1,852,000 (2012: €1,313,000) and €3,452,000 (2012: €3,470,000) respectively. The trading balances outstanding to the Society at the year end were €411,000 (2012: €278,000). No specific reserve has been required in 2013 (2012: nil) for bad or doubtful debts in respect of amounts owed by key management or directors and companies controlled by them.
45
46
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Notes to financial statements 30 Related party transactions (continued) Directors of the Society, in aggregate, contributed €108,000 (2012: nil) to loan notes and had deductions of €20,000 (2012: nil) made in respect of the revolving fund, both inclusive of accrued interest.
Reox Holdings plc During the year the Society and Reox Holdings plc (Reox) had a number of commercial arrangements. These are summarised below: i)
The Society has guaranteed lease obligations in respect of certain former subsidiaries of Reox. Reox has indemnified the Society for any costs that might arise in respect of those obligations.
ii) The Society supplies electricity to certain properties owned by Reox. All charges for supply of such electricity are based on arm’s length commercial terms. Reox owed the Society €16 million as at 31 December 2013 (2012: €16 million) in unsecured loan notes. The details of the terms and conditions and the repayment timeline of these loan notes are set out in Note 10. These loan notes were redeemed as part of a “Debt for Asset” transaction which was completed post year end on 31 March 2014 (See Note 34 – Post Balance Sheet Events).
31 Contingent liabilities Sales to the Irish Dairy Board are based on “on account” prices and are subject to adjustment when the prices are finally agreed. Provision is made as and when required for future deficits in the product categories. The Society has guaranteed the liabilities (as defined in Section 5 (c) (iii) of the Companies (Amendment) Act, 1986) for the financial year ended 31 December 2013 of its Irish subsidiaries and as a result they are exempted from filing their individual accounts under the provisions of Section 17 of the Companies (Amendment) Act, 1986. Grants of €13,645,000 (2012: €13,919,000) which have been received under agreements between the Society, its subsidiaries, Enterprise Ireland and the European Agricultural Guidance and Guarantee Fund may become repayable should certain circumstances set out in the agreements occur.
32 Securities and guarantees The Society has entered into bank guarantees on behalf of its subsidiaries. The amounts guaranteed at the balance sheet date were €61,376,000 (2012: €64,586,000) and they are secured by fixed and floating charges on the assets of the Society and its subsidiaries. The following liabilities disclosed under creditors falling due within one year are secured by the Society:
2013
2012
E’000
E’000
1,376
17,586
Invoice discounting
The invoice discounting facility of €60 million is secured on certain trade debtors. All debtor values are shown in the balance sheet at their gross value.
33 Restatement of comparatives Certain prior year figures included within the balance sheet account and related notes have been reclassified to ensure comparability with the current year presentation.
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Notes to financial statements 34 Post balance sheet events
Reox Holdings plc On 31 March 2014, the Society completed an “Debt for Asset” transaction with Reox Holdings plc. Dairygold acquired the Reox property assets with a net book value of €23.9 million in return for, releasing both a €16.0 million loan note and the indemnity associated with certain legacy property related liabilities, plus a cash payment of €0.5 million from Dairygold to Reox.
35 Principal operating subsidiaries, joint ventures and associates Subsidiaries Country of Incorporation
% Holding
Activity
Agricola Properties Limited
100.0%
Property
Ireland
Dairygold Agri Business Limited Ireland 100.0%
Procuring, distribution and retailing of agri and non agri supplies and farm inputs
Dairygold Deutschland Handlesgesellschaft mbH
Germany
100.0%
Sales & distribution
Dairygold Finance Limited
Ireland
100.0%
Finance company
Dairygold Food Ingredients Limited
Ireland
100.0%
Dairy ingredients
Dairygold Food Ingredients (U.K.) Limited
U.K.
100.0%
Dairy ingredients
Dairygold Food Ingredients (France) SAS
France
100.0%
Dairy ingredients
Munster Cattle Breeding Group Limited
Ireland
66.0%
AI and Farm services
Watfore Limited
Ireland
100.0%
Property
Joint Ventures Country of Incorporation
% Holding
Activity
Co-Operative Animal Health Limited
50.0%
Farm services
Ireland
The Malting Company of Ireland Limited Ireland 50.0% Malting Associates Country of Incorporation % Holding Activity National Cattle Breeding Centre Limited
Ireland
20.0%
AI services
Reox Holdings plc
Ireland
26.1%
Holding company
The Companies and Societies operate principally in the countries of incorporation. Only the principal operating subsidiaries are listed above. The names and addresses of the registered offices of all the subsidiaries and associates are available from the Secretary of Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited.
36 Approval of financial statements The financial statements were approved by the Board of Directors on 31 March 2014.
47
48
Dairygold Co-Operative Society Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2013
Five year historical information Five year profit and loss account
2013
2012
2011
E’000
E’000
E’000
TURNOVER Core activities Share trading OPERATING PROFIT Share of joint ventures Share of associates
847,407
27,322 20,559 22,579 18,926 11,772 620 295 (415) 7,310 1,687 27,942 20,854 22,164 26,236 13,459 (118) - - - 54
(12) 999 (7,514) (1,044)
Exceptional items
1,841 (1,841)
(1,952) (2,151) (841)
PROFIT before taxation
27,767
Taxation
(2,145)
PROFIT after taxation
25,622
PROFIT for the financial year
E’000
731,233 757,833 693,559 555,175
Net interest payable
Minority interest
2010 2009 E’000
(424) 25,198
-
(18) (1,019) (419)
(950)
16,850 22,322 18,285 10,446 (2,494) (577) (1,177) (875) 14,356 21,745 17,108 9,571 (602) (578) (352) (258) 13,754 21,167 16,756 9,313
Share interest (1,163) (1,179) (1,205) (1,233) (1,238) RETAINED PROFIT
24,035
12,575 19,962 15,523 8,075
Five year balance sheet
2013
2012
2011
E’000
E’000
E’000
2010 2009 E’000
E’000
Net Assets Employed: Fixed assets
239,484 220,622 224,551 192,718 209,039
Stocks
109,515 88,570 85,296 86,853 73,086
Debtors
120,386 100,633 96,407 105,801 98,963
Creditors
(129,472) (92,419) (93,627) (92,808) (85,826)
Net Debt
(60,914) (56,832) (67,242) (62,332) (77,886)
Capital grants Deferred taxation liability Pension asset
(8,257) (9,618) (4,652) (5,492) (6,311) (128) (1,117) (779)
(364)
(441)
3,230 1,427 4,346 16,913 10,100 273,844 251,266 244,300 241,289 220,724
Financed by: Shareholders’ funds Minority interest CAPITAL EMPLOYED
271,254 249,100 242,736 240,303 220,090 2,590 2,166 1,564
986
634
273,844 251,266 244,300 241,289 220,724
www.dairygold.ie