Large Energy Superpositions via Rydberg Dressing Mohammadsadegh Khazali, Hon Wai Lau, Adam Humeniuk and Christoph Simon Institute for Quantum Science and Technology and Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Calgary, Calgary T2N 1N4, Alberta, Canada (Dated: September 7, 2015)

arXiv:1509.01303v1 [quant-ph] 3 Sep 2015

We propose to create superposition states of over 100 Strontium atoms being in a ground state or metastable clock state, using the Kerr-type interaction due to Rydberg state dressing in an optical lattice. The two components of the superposition can differ by of order 250 eV in energy, allowing highly sensitive tests of energy decoherence models. We take into account the effects of higherorder nonlinearities, spatial inhomogeneity of the interaction, decay from the Rydberg state, and diminishing Rydberg level separation for increasing principal number.

There are currently many efforts towards demonstrating fundamental quantum effects such as superposition and entanglement in more and more macroscopic systems [1–13]. One class of quantum states that is attracting a lot of attention are so-called cat states, i.e. superposition states involving two components that are very different in some relevant physical observable, such as position, phase or spin. Here we propose a method for creating such large superpositions in energy. This is relevant in the context of testing proposed energy decoherence models due to quantum gravity effects [14–16]. Our proposed method relies on the uniform Kerr-type interaction that can be generated between atoms by weak dressing with a Rydberg state [17–19]. This can be used to generate cat states in the spirit of the well-known optical proposal by Yurke and Stoler [20]. Using an optical clock state in Strontium as one of the two atomic basis states makes it possible to create large and long-lived energy superposition states. The superposition can be verified by observing a characteristic revival. We analyze the effects of relevant imperfections including higher-order nonlinearities, spatial inhomogeneity of the interaction, decay from the Rydberg state, and diminishing Rydberg level separation for increasing principal number. Previous related, but distinct, work includes Ref. [21], which briefly discussed the creation of energy superposition states in Strontium Bose-Einstein condensates based on collisional (rather than Rydberg) interactions. Refs. [22, 23] performed detailed studies of the creation of moderate-size cat states using two different schemes based on Rydberg blockade. The number of atoms is limited to of order ten in these schemes due to competing requirements for the presence and absence of blockade between different Rydberg transitions in the same ensemble. They also don’t use metastable states, resulting in only small differences in energy between the two components. Ref. [24] briefly discussed the creation of moderate-size (15 atoms) Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger type states in Strontium atom chains, albeit without mentioning the energy superposition aspect. This paper uses attractive Rydberg interactions, but not the uniform Kerr-type interaction used in the present work. The number of atoms in Ref. [24] is limited by unwanted tran-

!

!

(a)

∆!

5!"! !!! !

(b)

Ωr   317nm

5!5! !!! !

!

!

698nm Ωe  

!

!

(c)

5! ! !!! !

!

(d)

!

⊗!

⊗!

!

!

FIG. 1. (Color online) Proposed scheme for creation of large energy superposition. (a) Level scheme in Strontium. The pseudo-spin states are the singlet ground state |gi and a long lived excited triplet state |ei. An off-resonant laser field (Ωr ) dresses the excited state with the Rydberg level |ri. This creates a Kerr-type interaction between the atoms in the excited state. The resonant laser field (Ωe ) is applied for population rotation. (b-d) The evolution of the Husimi distribution of the collective spin state on the Bloch sphere. Application of the Kerr-type interaction splits the initial coherent spin state (CSS) (b) into a superposition of two CSS at opposite poles of the Bloch sphere (c). Applying a π/2 rotation along the x axis following the cat creation process results in a superposition of all atoms being in the ground or excited state.

sitions to other nearby many-body states [25]. Ref. [26] proposed to use the Yurke-Stoler approach to create spin cat states in Bose-Einstein condensates, but using collisional interactions and without metastable states. Ref. [27] proposed the creation of energy superposition states of light, but these states are comparatively short-lived and thus less directly suitable for testing energy decoherence. We now describe our proposal in more detail. In an ensemble of N Strontium atoms trapped in a 3D opti-

(a) 0.1

Fc = 70 Fc = 80 Fc = 90

0.2

Fr = 70 Fr = 80 Fr = 90

w

(b)

2

Dressing  strength  (w)  

w

w

cal lattice [28], one can consider a two-level0.05system con- 0.1 0.2 0.2   π (a)   (b)   sisting of the singlet ground state |gi and a long-lived !! !! excited triplet state |ei, which are separated in energy -1 0.01   10 0.05 ! ! ! ! -­‐π   π -­‐π   π0 by 1.8 eV. An interaction between the atoms can be 0.2 induced by dressing the clock state 1000 with a strongly inFr = 70 10 induces a light (b) shift 0.05 0.05   teracting Rydberg level [17]. This Fr = 80 Fc=70%   100 0.1 Fr  = 90 (LS) on the atoms which depends on the Rydberg blockFc=80% 20 40 60 80 100 120 Fc=90%   ade. When the whole ensemble is inside the blockade N -1 state with no Ry0.02   radius, the dressing laser couples 0.02 10the 120   60   0.05 100   120 40   80   100 20   -1 20 40 60 80 dberg excitation ⊗i |φi i (where10 φ-1∈ {e, g}) to a state Cat  Size  (N)   10 |ei level gets excited where only one of theP atoms in the to the Rydberg√ level i |φ1 ...ri ...φN i with an enhanced FIG. 2. (Color online) Effect of higher than second order -2the number Rabi frequency Ne Ωr , where N10 e is (from 20 of atoms 40nonlinearities 60 80 100the 120expansion of Eq. (1) in terms of Ne ) 40 60 100120 in the excited state. The effective interaction between on N the80fidelity of the cat state. The weak dressing parameter 10-220 -220 40 60 Ωr 100120 ) has to be reduced for larger atom numbers N in (w = 80 10of the excited atoms in the presence dressing laser is the 2∆ 100120 20 40 60 80 order to keep a fixed fidelity Fc (Fc = 0.7, 0.8, 0.9 from top difference between the light shift of the blockaded and to bottom). The inset shows the Husimi Q function for an non-interacting atoms [18, 19] (N ) ELSe

(1) Ne ELS

J= − (1)     p p Ne 1 ∆ − ∆2 + Ne Ω2r − ∆ − ∆2 + Ω2r , = 2 2 where ∆ is the detuning and Ωr is the Rabi frequency of √ Ne Ωr the dressing laser. In the weak dressing regime ( ∆  1) one can expand Eq. (1) to obtain a Kerr-type interΩ4 action J = (Ne2 − Ne )χ0 , where χ0 = 16∆r 3 . The two levels |gi i and |ei i for each atom are equiv(i) alent to a spin 1/2 system with Pauli matrices σx = (i) (|gi ihei | + |ei ihgi |)/2, σy = i(|gi ihei | − |ei ihgi |)/2 and (i) σz = (|ei ihei | − |gi ihgi |)/2 acting on the atom at site i. To study the entire ensemble we use the collective PN (i) spin operators Sl = i=1 σl . A coherent spin state (CSS) is defined as a direct product of single spin states iφ |θ, φi = ⊗N i=1 [cos θ|gii + sin θe |eii ] [29], where all the spins are pointing in the same direction, and φ and θ are the azimuthal and polar angles on the (collective) Bloch sphere. The CSS can also represented as |ηi = |θ, φi = sbe   P N N (1 + |η|2 )−N Ne =0 η Ne |Ne i [29] where |Ne i = Ne PN √1 i1