Anxiety Disorders Association of Canada
Social Anxiety Disorder Guidelines Stéphane Bouchard, Ph.D. John Walker, Ph.D. Pierre Bleau, M.D, FRCP
Overview of the symposium 1. Brief review of basic concepts in social anxiety disorder. 2. Epidemiology of social anxiety disorder. 3. Neurobiology of social anxiety disorder. 4. Psychology of social anxiety disorder. 5. Pharmacological treatment of social anxiety disorder. 6. Psychotherapeutic treatment of social anxiety disorder. 7. ADAC/ACTA Guidelines.
1. Brief review of basic concepts
Social Phobia / Social Anxiety Disorder Fear of scrutiny, negative evaluation by others or fear of humiliation and embarrassment
Social Anxiety Disorder (Social Phobia) • Marked fear of performance or social interaction situations. • Excessive fear of scrutiny or negative evaluation. • Fear of acting in a way (or showing anxiety symptoms) that will be humiliating or embarrassing. • Results in avoidance or endurance with distress. DSM-IV summarized
Social Phobia “Subtypes” Generalized
Nongeneralized (discrete, specific)
O O
O O
“Most” social situations (DSM IV) - performance - interactional
O O O O
Overlaps with avoidant personality disorder - 80-90 %
Most Most probably probably more more on on aa continuum continuum of of severity severity (quantitative) (quantitative) rather rather than different entities (qualitative). Stein et al., 2000. than different entities (qualitative). Stein et al., 2000.
1 or 2 social situations Usually performance writing in front of others eating in front of others telephone public speaking
Signs and Symptoms: Cognitive Symptoms • Fear of negative evaluation or disapproval • Negative evaluation of one’s own performance • Perfectionist standards • Expectations that others will be critical • Expectations that social situations will go badly (trigger bad habit or poor social skills) • Post-mortem thoughts
Signs and Symptoms: Physical Symptoms • • • • • • • • •
Blushing Stuttering or stammering Sweating Gastrointestinal symptoms (embarrassing) Dry mouth Palpitations Trembling Urgency of micturition Panic attacks
Signs and Symptoms: Behavioral Symptoms • Avoidance of difficult social situations • Being in situations but not participating (speaking) • Use of alcohol in social situations • Non-verbal behaviour – eye contact, shaking hands, interpersonal distance • Relying on family and friends • Leave the situation
Examples of feared social situations Social Interaction
Performance
• Going to a party
• Public speaking
• Lunch with peers
• Meeting new people
• Dating
• Fear of eating, drinking or writing in public
• Asking a teacher for help • Speaking to a boss at work • Asking a salesclerck for help • Asking for directions
• Fear of using a public washroom • Fear of using a telephone in public • Playing an instrument, sports • Entering a room
Differential Diagnosis Vs Other Anxiety Disorders Characteristics of social anxiety disorder are: • Childhood or adolescent onset • Impairment restricted to social situations • Blushing (Not present in Panic Attacks) • Unique cognitions (such as fear of scrutiny by others) (Different from fear to become fool) • No improvement with TCA
Rating Scales for Social Anxiety Disorder Clinician-Administered Scales Evaluation Rating Scale Clinical Severity
Clinical Global Impression (CGI) for Severity of Illness Liebowitz Social Anxiety Scale Clinical Global Improvement Hamilton Rating Scale for Anxiety Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression Social Anxiety and Distress Scale
Functional Disability
Sheehan Disability Scale Mini International Neuropsychiatric Interview (MINI) Duke Brief Social Phobia Scale Global Assessment of Functioning
Specificity Non-specific Specific Non-specific Non-specific Non-specific Specific Non-specific Non-specific Specific Non-specific
Rating Scales for Social Anxiety Disorder (Cont’d) Patient Self-Administered Scales Evaluation Rating Scale
Specificity
Clinical Severity
Social Phobia Inventory (SPIN)
Specific
Fear Questionnaire
Specific
Functional Disability
Liebowitz Disability Self-Rating Scale
Specific
Quality of Life
WHO Quality of Life - 100
2. Epidemiology of social anxiety disorder
Presentation lead by: John R. Walker, Ph.D. University of Manitoba
THE EPIDEMIOLOGY OF SOCIAL PHOBIA John R. Walker, Ph.D. University of Manitoba
Why is epidemiology important?
Why is epidemiology important? Informs us about the impact of a problem on the problem on the population as a whole. Knowledge of prevalence helps in planning service, education, and research. Research on risk factors helps in our understanding of etiology. Basis for developing and evaluating preventative procedures and public health practices
Lifetime Social Fears In Young People (EDSP, Munich – Ages 14-24) Situation
Lifetime Rate
Eating or drinking in public
4.4%
Writing while someone watches
2.2%
Participating in social events
4.6%
Performance/test situations
18.2%
Public speaking
13.2%
Talking with/to others Any social fear (from these questions)
6.4% 27.3%
Lifetime Rates of Social Phobia Location
Rate
Age, Study
Winnipeg
7.1%
18+, Stein et al, 1994
USA (NCS)
13.3%
15-54, Kessler et al, 1994
Ontario (OHS)
6.7%
15-64, Boyle et al, 1996
EDSP, Munich
7.3%
14-24, Wittchen et al, 1999
Alberta/Winnipeg
7.2%
16+, Stein et al, 2000
Paris
7.3%
18+, Pelissolo et al, 2000
Canadian Community Health Survey (2003) Females, 12 Month Prevalence Disorder
Age 15-24
Age 25-64
Overall
Social Phobia
6.2%
3.4%
3.4%
Panic Disorder
3.3%
2.2%
2.1%
Agoraphobia
1.2%
1.2%
1.1%
Maj. Depression
8.2%
5.8%
5.5%
Canadian Commun. Health Survey (2003) Males, 12 Month Prevalence Disorder
Age 15-24 Age 25-64
Overall
Social Phobia
3.3%
2.7%
2.5%
Panic Disorder
1.2%
1.2%
1.1%
Agoraphobia Maj. Depression
0.4% 4.3%
3.5%
3.4%
What are the causes of anxiety and depressive disorders? • • •
Biological / genetic factors? Conditioning or learning? Adverse experiences during childhood? • Life stress close to the time of onset?
Genetics of Social Anxiety Disorder Kendler’s study of female twin pairs Concordance rates of: - 15.3% for dizygotic pairs - 24.4% for monozygotic pairs - Heritability index of 30%
Childhood Adversity and SAD Ontario Health Survey (Chartier, Walker, Stein, 2001) Adverse Experience Juvenile Justice Involvement Child-welfare involvement Running away from home Lack of close adult relationship Marital conflict – parents Parental history of mental disorder Severe physical abuse Severe sexual abuse
O.R. 1.82 2.70 3.40 2.63 1.82 2.13 2.54 1.72
Childhood Adversity and SAD - 2 Ontario Health Survey (Chartier, Walker, Stein, 2001)
Adverse Experience - School
O.R.
Special education before grade 9
2.97
Special education after grade 9
2.71
Failing a grade before grade 9
1.99
Dropping out of high school
2.08
Social phobia is often the first disorder in the history for individuals with comorbid disorders Magee et al (1996)
What about childhood?
Concept of Behavioral Inhibition Jerome Kagan (1984, 1988) • Generally shy demeanour • Tendency to approach new situations with restraint, avoidance, and distress • Measured in different ways from infancy to early school years • Moderate levels of stability • Consistent Inhibition related to later anxiety
Early Developmental Stages of Psychopathology Study • • • • •
Munich Germany Ages 14 – 24 Baseline interview and follow up 20 or 40 months afterward Parents also provided some information First interview covered 12 month and lifetime, follow up interviews covered intervening time
Early Developmental Stages of Psychopathology Study • Longitudinal design allows an evaluation of risk of future disorders among individuals who have one disorder at the start of the follow up period • Previously most of the data available have been from cross sectional studies where researchers must rely on the accuracy of retrospective reports. • Are retrospective reports influenced by today’s mood? OR, is there under reporting of past experiences?
Social Anxiety Disorder and Risk of Major Depression (Stein et al., 2001) Baseline Diagnosis
Depressive Disorder Over Follow-up
No Mental Disorder
8%
Odds Ratio
SAD – No Depression
24%
3.5
Depression – No SAD
25%
3.8
Depression + SAD
44%
8.7
Social Anxiety Disorder and Risk of Major Depression (Stein et al., 2001) • Presence of both social anxiety disorder and depression was also related to increased severity of depression (number of symptoms, presence of suicide attempts, duration) • Other anxiety disorders likely follow a similar pattern • May not be a causal relationship, third factor may be involved
Selected Risk Factors For Anxiety and Depressive Disorders (Wittchen et al., 2000) Risk Factor
Depression
SAD
GAD Panic Agora
Edu. Probs.
1.7
2.7
Early Sep.
2.0
2.4
Parent Alc.
1.4
Parent Dep. Behav. Inhib.
2.1
3.6 2.3
2.7
2.4
Parent Anx. 1.9
2.2
10.0
6.4
Specific Phobia
1.4 2.3
2.4
1.6
10.0
18
4.2
Important Research Questions • Can we intervene early to reduce the impact? • Will prevention or early intervention applied to anxiety problems reduce other disorders? • What prevention approaches could be considered? • How cost effective would various intervention programs be?
Desirable Characteristics for Prevention Approaches • Community and school based rather than clinic based • Reaching out to families rather than waiting for referrals • Non stigmatizing – of children and of parents • Support parents in their role rather than blaming • Use change agents who will be available at the community level • Highly structured program to facilitate dissemination • Based on sound knowledge of child development
Social Phobia Why the Strong Interest? • Most common anxiety Disorder • Early age of onset • High rates of comorbidity • Significant personal morbidity • High financial burdon • Treatable although underrecognized
3. Neurobiology of social anxiety disorder
Presentation lead by: Pierre Bleau, M.D. McGill University
Psychobiology of FEAR Amygdala Central Nucleus
Central Central Gray Gray
Lateral Lateral Hypothalamus Hypothalamus
Paraventricular Paraventricular Nucleus Nucleus
Reticulo Reticulo pontis pontis
Freezing Freezing Blood Blood Pressure Pressure
Adapted Adapted from from LeDoux LeDoux .. The The Emotional Emotional Brain. Brain. 1996. 1996.
Stress Stress Hormones Hormones
Startle Startle Reflex Reflex
Conditioning of the Anxiety/Fear Response Fear conditioning – Coincidences between stimuli that trigger the fear response and the activation of the amygdala are connected together through hardening of synapses in the basolateral nucleus of the amygdala. These are arguably the formation of ‘emotional memories’
LeDoux J. Biol Psychiatry 1998; McKernan & Shinnick-Gallagher Nature 1997; Davis M Biol Psychiatry 1998
Sensory Sensory Cortex Cortex
Rhinal Rhinal (transitional) (transitional) Cortex Cortex (memories) (memories)
(memories (memories and and contexts) contexts)
(objects) (objects)
Sensory Sensory Thalamus Thalamus
Hippocampus Hippocampus
AMYGDALA
(stimulus (stimulus features) features)
Medial Medial Prefrontal Prefrontal (extinction) (extinction)
FEAR (responses (responses and and experiences) experiences) Adapted from LeDoux. The Emotional Brain. 1996.
Conditioning of the Anxiety/Fear Response Avoidance conditioning – Dysphoric experiences associated with the activation of the fear/anxiety responses are avoided. This involves prefrontal cortical and limbic interconnections
LeDoux J. Biol Psychiatry 1998; McKernan & Shinnick-Gallagher Nature 1997; Davis M Biol Psychiatry 1998
Sensory Sensory Cortex Cortex
Rhinal Rhinal (transitional) (transitional) Cortex Cortex (memories) (memories)
Hippocampus Hippocampus (memories (memories and and contexts) contexts)
Sensory Sensory Thalamus Thalamus
AMYGDALA
(stimulus (stimulus features) features)
FEAR (responses (responses and and experiences) experiences)
Adapted from LeDoux. The Emotional Brain. 1996.
Medial Medial Prefrontal Prefrontal (extinction) (extinction)
Conditioning of the Anxiety/Fear Response Contextual conditioning – Stimuli associated with cues that trigger the fear anxiety response result in increased vigilance. This involves declarative memory circuits mediated through the hippocampus
LeDoux J. Biol Psychiatry 1998; McKernan & Shinnick-Gallagher Nature 1997; Davis M Biol Psychiatry 1998
Sensory Sensory Cortex Cortex (objects) (objects)
Sensory Sensory Thalamus Thalamus (stimulus (stimulus features) features)
Rhinal Rhinal (transitional) (transitional) Cortex Cortex (memories) (memories)
Hippocampus Hippocampus (memories (memories and and contexts) contexts)
AMYGDALA
Medial Medial Prefrontal Prefrontal (extinction) (extinction)
FEAR (responses (responses and and experiences) experiences)
Adapted from LeDoux. The Emotional Brain. 1996.
Increased Amygdala Response to Angry/Fearful Faces in Normals: Impact of Short vs. Long Allele of the Serotonin Transporter Gene (SERT) Amygdala Responses: Group > 1 Group
Short Allele SERT Hariri et al. Science 2002:297:400-403
Long Allele SERT
Non -Stressed Non-Stressed
Stressed
Stress results in decreased dendritic branching of neurons in the CA3 region of the hippocampus Woolley CS, Gould E, Frankfurt M, McEwen BS. J Neurosci. 1990(Dec);10(12):4035-4039
Normal
Normal Survival and Growth
Stress
Antidepressants
↑ Glucocorticoids ↓ BDNF
↑ Serotonin and NE ↑ BDNF ↓ Glucocorticoids
Atrophy/Death of Neurons
↑ Survival and Growth
Other Neuronal Insults: Genetic Factors
Hypoxia-Ischemia Hypoxia-Ischemia Hypoglycemia Hypoglycemia Neurotoxins Neurotoxins Viruses Viruses
BDNF = brain-derived neurotrophic factor; NE = norepinephrine. Duman RS, et al. Arch Gen Psychiatry. 1997;54:597-606.
Neurobiology of Anxiety Cognitive Conspiracies Afférent pathways
Efferents pathways
PROCESSING
Adapted from Charney and Deutsch 1996
Neurobiology of Anxiety Cognitive Functions
Cognitive conspiracies
Cingulate g. _
Afférent pathways
Amygdala __ Hippocampus
PROCESSING Adapted from Charney and Deutsch 1996 And from Gray’s theory 1982, 2000
Neurobiology of Anxiety Cognitive Functions
Cognitive conspiracies
Cingulate g.
_
Afférent pathways
Amygdala __ Hippocampus
PROCESSING Adapted from Charney and Deutsch 1996 And from Gray’s theory 1982, 2000
Neurobiology of Anxiety Cognitive Functions
Cognitive conspiracies
Cingulate g.
_
Afférent pathways
Amygdala __ Hippocampus
PROCESSING Adapted from Charney and Deutsch 1996 And from Gray’s theory 1982, 2000
Neurobiology of Anxiety Cognitive Functions
Cognitive conspiracies
Cingulate g.
_
Afférent pathways
Amygdala __ Hippocampus
PROCESSING Adapted from Charney and Deutsch 1996
Neurobiology of Anxiety Lateral Lateral Hypothalamus Hypothalamus
Cognitive Functions
Cognitives conspiracy
Dors.Motor Dors.Motor N. N. Vagus Vagus Nucleus Nucleus Ambiguus Ambiguus
Cingulate g.
Parabrachial Parabrachial Nucleus Nucleus
Ventral Ventral Tegmental Tegmental Area Area
_
Locus Locus Ceruleus Ceruleus
Afférent pathways
Amygdala __
Dorso-lateral Dorso-lateral Tegmental Tegmental N N
N. N. Reticularis Reticularis Pontis Pontis Caudalis Caudalis
Hippocampus
Central Central Grey Grey or or Striatum Striatum Trigiminal, Trigiminal, Facial Facial N N
PROCESSING Paraventricular Paraventricular N N (Hypothal.) (Hypothal.) Adapted Adapted from from Charney Charney and and Deutsch Deutsch 1996 1996
Neurobiology of Anxiety Lateral Hypothalamus
Cognitive Functions
Cognitives conspiracy
Dors.Motor N. Vagus Nucleus Ambiguus
Parabrachial Nucleus
Cingulate g.
Ventral Tegmental Area
_
Afférent pathways
Locus Ceruleus
Amygdala
Dorso-lateral Tegmental N
__ N. Reticularis Pontis Caudalis
Hippocampus
Central Grey or Striatum Trigiminal, Facial N
PROCESSING Adapted from Charney and Deutsch 1996
Paraventricular N (Hypothal.)
Neurobiology of Anxiety Lateral Lateral Hypothalamus Hypothalamus
Sympathetic Sympathetic Activation Activation
Dors.Motor Dors.Motor N. N. Vagus Vagus Nucleus Nucleus Ambiguus Ambiguus
Parasympathetic Parasympathetic Activation Activation
Parabrachial Parabrachial Nucleus Nucleus
Increased Increased Respiration Respiration
Ventral Ventral Tegmental Tegmental Area Area Locus Locus Ceruleus Ceruleus
Activation Activation of of Dopamine Dopamine Noradrenaline Noradrenaline
Dorso-lateral Dorso-lateral Tegmental Tegmental N N
Acetylcholine Acetylcholine
N. N. Reticularis Reticularis Pontis Pontis Caudalis Caudalis
Increased Increased Reflexes Reflexes
Central Central Grey Grey or or Striatum Striatum
Cessation Cessation of of Behavior Behavior or or Flight Flight
Trigiminal, Trigiminal, Facial Facial N N
Mouth Mouth open, open, jaw jaw movements movements
Paraventricular Paraventricular N N (Hypothal.) (Hypothal.)
ACTH ACTH Release Release
Adapted from Charney and Deutsch 1996
Neurobiology of Anxiety Lateral Hypothalamus
Sympathetic Activation
Dors.Motor N. Vagus
Parasympathetic
Nucleus Ambiguus
Activation
Parabrachial Nucleus
Increased Respiration
Ventral Tegmental Area
Activation of Dopamine
Locus Ceruleus
Noradrenaline
Dorso-lateral Tegmental N
Acetylcholine
N. Reticularis Pontis Caudalis
Increased Reflexes
Central Grey or Striatum
Cessation of Behavior or Flight
Trigiminal, Facial N
Mouth open, jaw movements
Paraventricular N (Hypothal.)
ACTH Release
Adapted from Charney and Deutsch 1996
Neurobiology of Anxiety Lateral Lateral Hypothalamus Hypothalamus
Sympathetic Sympathetic Activation Activation
Dors.Motor Dors.Motor N. N. Vagus Vagus Nucleus Nucleus Ambiguus Ambiguus
Parasympathetic Parasympathetic Activation Activation
Parabrachial Parabrachial Nucleus Nucleus
Increased Increased Respiration Respiration
Ventral Ventral Tegmental Tegmental Area Area Locus Locus Ceruleus Ceruleus
Activation Activation of of Dopamine Dopamine Noradrenaline Noradrenaline
Dorso-lateral Dorso-lateral Tegmental Tegmental N N
Acetylcholine Acetylcholine
N. N. Reticularis Reticularis Pontis Pontis Caudalis Caudalis
Increased Increased Reflexes Reflexes
Central Central Grey Grey or or Striatum Striatum
Cessation Cessation of of Behavior Behavior or or Flight Flight
Trigiminal, Trigiminal, Facial Facial N N
Mouth Mouth open, open, jaw jaw movements movements
Paraventricular Paraventricular N N (Hypothal.) (Hypothal.)
ACTH ACTH Release Release
Adapted from Charney and Deutsch 1996
Neurobiology of Anxiety Lateral Lateral Hypothalamus Hypothalamus
Sympathetic Sympathetic Activation Activation
Tachycardia,BP Tachycardia,BP elevation elevation
Dors.Motor Dors.Motor N. N. Vagus Vagus
Parasympathetic Parasympathetic
Urination, Urination, defecation, defecation, Bradych. Bradych.
Nucleus Nucleus Ambiguus Ambiguus
Activation Activation
Ulcers Ulcers
Parabrachial Parabrachial Nucleus Nucleus
Increased Increased Respiration Respiration
Respiratory Respiratory Distress Distress
Ventral Ventral Tegmental Tegmental Area Area
Activation Activation of of Dopamine Dopamine
Behavioral Behavioral && EEG EEG
Locus Locus Ceruleus Ceruleus
Noradrenaline Noradrenaline
Arousal Arousal
Dorso-lateral Dorso-lateral Tegmental Tegmental N N
Acetylcholine Acetylcholine
Increased Increased vigilance vigilance
N. N. Reticularis Reticularis Pontis Pontis Caudalis Caudalis
Increased Increased Reflexes Reflexes
Startle Startle response response
Central Central Grey Grey or or Striatum Striatum
Cessation Cessation of of Behavior Behavior or or Flight Flight
Freeze Freeze or or Flight Flight
Trigiminal, Trigiminal, Facial Facial N N
Mouth Mouth open, open, jaw jaw movements movements
Facial Facial expression expression of of Fear Fear
Paraventricular Paraventricular N N (Hypothal.) (Hypothal.)
ACTH ACTH Release Release
Cortisol Cortisol (Stress (Stress response) response)
Adapted Adapted from from Charney Charney and and Deutsch Deutsch 1996 1996
Neurobiology of Anxiety Lateral Lateral Hypothalamus Hypothalamus
Sympathetic Sympathetic Activation Activation
Tachycardia,BP Tachycardia,BP elevation elevation
Dors.Motor Dors.Motor N. N. Vagus Vagus
Parasympathetic Parasympathetic
Urination, Urination, defecation, defecation, Bradych. Bradych.
Nucleus Nucleus Ambiguus Ambiguus
Activation Activation
Ulcers Ulcers
Parabrachial Parabrachial Nucleus Nucleus
Increased Increased Respiration Respiration
Respiratory Respiratory Distress Distress
Ventral Ventral Tegmental Tegmental Area Area
Activation Activation of of Dopamine Dopamine
Behavioral Behavioral & & EEG EEG
Locus Locus Ceruleus Ceruleus
Noradrenaline Noradrenaline
Arousal Arousal
Dorso-lateral Dorso-lateral Tegmental Tegmental N N
Acetylcholine Acetylcholine
Increased Increased vigilance vigilance
N. N. Reticularis Reticularis Pontis Pontis Caudalis Caudalis
Increased Increased Reflexes Reflexes
Startle Startle response response
Central Central Grey Grey or or Striatum Striatum
Cessation Cessation of of Behavior Behavior or or Flight Flight
Freeze Freeze or or Flight Flight
Trigiminal, Trigiminal, Facial Facial N N
Mouth Mouth open, open, jaw jaw movements movements
Facial Facial expression expression of of Fear Fear
Paraventricular Paraventricular N N (Hypothal.) (Hypothal.)
ACTH ACTH Release Release
Cortisol Cortisol (Stress (Stress response) response)
Adapted Adapted from from Charney Charney and and Deutsch Deutsch 1996 1996
P P H H E E N N O O T T Y Y P P E E O O F F A A N N X X II E E T T Y Y
Neurobiology of Anxiety Lateral Lateral Hypothalamus Hypothalamus
Sympathetic Sympathetic Activation Activation
Tachycardia,BP Tachycardia,BP elevation elevation
Dors.Motor Dors.Motor N. N. Vagus Vagus
Parasympathetic Parasympathetic
Urination, Urination, defecation, defecation, Bradych. Bradych.
Nucleus Nucleus Ambiguus Ambiguus
Activation Activation
Ulcers Ulcers
Parabrachial Parabrachial Nucleus Nucleus
Increased Increased Respiration Respiration
Respiratory Respiratory Distress Distress
Ventral Ventral Tegmental Tegmental Area Area
Activation Activation of of Dopamine Dopamine
Behavioral Behavioral & & EEG EEG
Locus Locus Ceruleus Ceruleus
Noradrenaline Noradrenaline
Arousal Arousal
Dorso-lateral Dorso-lateral Tegmental Tegmental N N
Acetylcholine Acetylcholine
Increased Increased vigilance vigilance
N. N. Reticularis Reticularis Pontis Pontis Caudalis Caudalis
Increased Increased Reflexes Reflexes
Startle Startle response response
Central Central Grey Grey or or Striatum Striatum
Cessation Cessation of of Behavior Behavior or or Flight Flight
Freeze Freeze or or Flight Flight
Trigiminal, Trigiminal, Facial Facial N N
Mouth Mouth open, open, jaw jaw movements movements
Facial Facial expression expression of of Fear Fear
Paraventricular Paraventricular N N (Hypothal.) (Hypothal.)
ACTH ACTH Release Release
Cortisol Cortisol (Stress (Stress response) response)
Adapted Adapted from from Charney Charney and and Deutsch Deutsch 1996 1996
P P H H E E N N O O T T Y Y P P E E O O F F A A N N X X II E E T T Y Y
Functional Neuroanatomy of Fear and Anxiety Fear Fear and and Anxiety Anxiety Response Patterns Response Patterns
(( Charney Charney & & Deutsch Deutsch 1996 1996 )) Cingulate Cingulate gyrus gyrus
Primary Primary sensory sensory and and Association Association Cortices Cortices Striatum Striatum Periaqueductal Periaqueductal gray gray
Orbitofrontal Orbitofrontal cortex cortex Peripheral Peripheral receptor receptor cells cells of of exteroceptive exteroceptive auditory,visual auditory,visual somesthetic somesthetic sensory sensory systems systems
Multisynaptic Multisynaptic pathways pathways
Thalamus Thalamus
uss aam mppu c o c p o H Hiippp inaall EEnnttirirhhin ccooeerrtteexx
Olfactory Olfactory sensory sensory stimuli stimuli
Afferent Afferent system system
Visceral Visceral afferent afferent pathways pathways
Fight Fight or or flight flight response response
Trigeminal Trigeminal nucleus nucleus Facial Facial motor motor nucleus nucleus
Single Single or or
Fear-induced Fear-induced skeletal skeletal motor motor activation activation
Facial Facial expression expression of of fear fear
Amygdala Amygdala
Locus Locus ceruleus ceruleus
Nucleus Nucleus Paragigantocellularis Paragigantocellularis
Stimulus Stimulus processing processing
Parabrachial Parabrachial nucleus nucleus
Fear-induced Fear-induced hyperventilation hyperventilation
Dorsal Dorsal motor motor nucleus nucleus of of the the Vagus Vagus
Fear-induced Fear-induced parasympathetic parasympathetic
Lateral Lateral hypothalamus hypothalamus
Paraventricular Paraventricular nucleus nucleus of of the the hypothalamus hypothalamus
nervous nervous system system activation activation Fear-induced Fear-induced sympathetic sympathetic nervous nervous system system activation activation
Neuroendocrine Neuroendocrine and and neuropeptide neuropeptide release release Efferent Efferent system system
Increase Increase urination urination defecation defecation ulcers ulcers bradycardia bradycardia Tachycardia Tachycardia increase increase BP BP sweating sweating piloerction piloerction pupil pupil dilat dilat Hormonal Hormonal stress stress response response
Neurobiology of Social Anxiety Disorder
Biology of Social Phobia Generalized
• Central dopaminergic involvement ? • Central serotonergic dysregulation?
Nongeneralized
• Peripheral autonomic mediation
Social Anxiety Disorder Spectrum-Continuum “Normal” Shy Performance - Social Anxiety Disorder Generalized - Social Anxiety Disorder Avoidant Personality Disorder
Age At Onset of Social Anxiety Disorder In Subjects Without Agoraphobia or Simple Phobia 30
(N=106)
Number of Subjects
25 20 15 10 5 0 0-5 6-10 11-15 16-20 21-25 26-30 31-35 36-40 41-45 46-50 51-55 56-60 61-65 66-70 71-75
Age (years) Schneier 1992
Serotonergic Function in SAD Knutson, Knutson, 1998 1998
SSRI SSRI treatment treatment
Increased Increased sociability sociability in in healthy healthy controls controls
Various Various studies studies
SSRI SSRI treatment treatment
Beneficial Beneficial effect effect in in Patients with SAD Patients with SAD
Hollander, Hollander, et et al. al. 1998 1998
m -CPP challenge m-CPP challenge (partial -HT agonist) (partial 55-HT agonist)
Significantly Significantly greater greater cortisol cortisol response response vs. vs. controls controls
Tancer Tancer,, 1993 1993
Fenfluramine Fenfluramine challenge challenge
Increase Increase in in cortisol cortisol Response Response
Moskowitz Moskowitz et et al. al. 2001 2001
Tryptophan Tryptophan Challenge Challenge
Increased Increased sociability sociability in in healthy healthy controls controls
Arbell Arbell et et al, al, 2003 2003
55-HTTPRL -HTTPRL polymorphism polymorphism
Association Association between between shyness shyness and and ll allele allele
Kang Kang Seob Seob Oh, Oh, 2003 2003
55-HTTPRL -HTTPRL polymorphism polymorphism
higher higher proportion proportion of of the the ll allele allele in in SAD SAD patients patients
Stevens Stevens et et al, al, 2004 2004
55-HTT -HTT binding binding
greater greater binding binding potential potential in patients with SAD in patients with SAD
Nutt Nutt et et al, al, 2004 2004
TRP TRP depletion depletion
Reverse Reverse SSRI SSRI treatment treatment
Neurobiology of SAD Serotonergic systems – Increased 5HT associated with dominant social status associated with affiliative behavior – Decreased 5HT associated with subordinant status
Moskowitz, et al 2001
Moskowitz DS, Pinard G, Zuroff DC, Annable L, Young SN The effect of tryptophan on social interaction in everyday life: a placebo-controlled study.Neuropsychopharmacology 2001 Aug;25(2):277-89
Neurobiology of SAD Dopaminergic systems – Modulates approach behavior – Reduces dopaminergic function in patients with SAD • Reduced striatal dopamine reuptake binding • Reduced D2 receptor binding density Tiihonen J, Kuikka J, Bergstrom K, Lepola U, Koponen H, Leinonen E. Dopamine reuptake site densities in patients with social phobia. Am J Psychiatry 1997 Feb;154(2):239-42
Tiihonen, et al 1997. Schneier FR, et al. Am J Psychiatry. 2000;157:457-459.
Evidence for dopaminergic dysfunction • Atypical antipsychotic olanzapine is effective in social anxiety disorder monotherapy (Barnett et al, 2003) • High rates of social anxiety disorder in patients with Parkinson’s Disease (Stein et al, 1990) • Healthy subjects with a detached personality show lower density of the dopamine D22 receptors (Laakso et al, 2000; Farde et al, 1997)
D2 Density and Personal Detachment in Normal Subjects 70
Detachment
60 50 40 30 20 15
25 35 D2-receptor density (pmol ml-1)
45
Individual values (n = 24) for D2-dopamine-receptor density plotted against KSP detachment scores. To adjust for the effect of gender, the scores were transformed to T scores using normative data. The T scores have a mean (± s.e.m.) of 50 (±10) in the normal population. Farde L, et al. Synapse. 1997;25:321-325.
Dopamine Transporter
4 hr after 185 MBq 123I-ß-CIT.
24 hrs after 185 MBq 123I-ß-CIT
and 20 mg paroxetine
Dopamine transporter binding in the basal ganglia of SAD patients and controls
β− CIT binding ratio
10
8
* 6
4
2 Stevens et al, 2004
Controls
Patients
D2 Receptor Binding Potential [1231] IBZMbinding potential ml/gr
200
P